MUST WATCH! When Did ‘White Resentment’ Become a Political Strategy?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 вер 2024
  • When Did ‘White Resentment’ Become a Political Strategy? Karen Hunter, Don Calloway and Rachel Bitecofer have an interesting convo. MUST WATCH!
    This is a clip from the Karen Hunter Show, which airs Monday-Friday 3-6 p.m. ET on SiriusXM. For more, go to player.siriusx..., sign up and search Karen Hunter Show.
    MUST WATCH! When Did ‘White Resentment’ Become a Political Strategy?
    We are not minorities. We are the Global Majority!
    Summertime…and the living is easy.
    The cotton blend drop is here!
    Love what Karen is wearing? Check out www.theglobalmajority.com to shop The Global Majority, our newest, exclusive assortment is here!
    Get 3 months of SiriusXM for Free! Go to...
    siriusxm.us/KarenHunterShow
    Like, Share & Subscribe! New content and interviews every day of the week. We love our community, and we want to hear from you!
    Want to know more about Karen Hunter? Check out... karenhuntersho... for the latest news and updates.
    To listen to the full three-hour radio show, get the @siriusxm app and search “Karen Hunter Show.” Free Trial:
    care.siriusxm....
    Follow Karen on Twitter at / karenhunter
    #trump #thebreakfastshow #charlamagnethagod #msnbc #foxnews #gutfeld #donaldtrumpnews #trumpguilty #hushmoneycase #jamesobrien #trump #rolandmartin

КОМЕНТАРІ • 214

  • @whooley8782
    @whooley8782 3 місяці тому +14

    When you're used to privilege, equality feels like oppression.

    • @ronny-lb1cr
      @ronny-lb1cr 3 місяці тому

      Yeah Trump's election defeat 2020 actually felt like opression to MAGA. Today some of them say we blacks can relate to Trump's suffering. We are living in a crazy world

  • @williamcarter9066
    @williamcarter9066 3 місяці тому +76

    The oppressor can’t pretend to be the oppressed!!

    • @KriticalThinker137
      @KriticalThinker137 3 місяці тому

      Have you forgotten the definition of a so-called "Karen"? Pretense is the foundation of oppression.

    • @badlt5897
      @badlt5897 3 місяці тому +7

      Yes it can. It is.

    • @SassyTarheel
      @SassyTarheel 3 місяці тому +13

      And yet they do all day everyday.

    • @SassyTarheel
      @SassyTarheel 3 місяці тому

      @user-pq4jj5sx7p Said black people aren't the oppressors. They are the oppressed whether they know it or not. I'm guessing they have Stockholm syndrome.

    • @Todd-o9d
      @Todd-o9d 3 місяці тому

      Exactly

  • @donesecarr3570
    @donesecarr3570 3 місяці тому +35

    When that bad check of wytness bounces...

    • @ricks6927
      @ricks6927 3 місяці тому

      *​@capoislamort100 *
      *There is always that first time, then it all comes to fruition!*
      *Donald Trump 1st=34 Counts!*
      *Hunter Biden 2nd= 3 Counts!*
      *Let the floodgates open for their crimes.*

    • @p.w.7493
      @p.w.7493 3 місяці тому +5

      ​@@capoislamort100
      Not yet. But it will...soon.

    • @derrynelson4637
      @derrynelson4637 3 місяці тому

      It’s Been Bouncing For Years and Decades with insufficient Funds. But they Been Using our Tax Dollars and Not putting it back into Our Communities. But you see they’re Losing the Battle in Diversity and Inclusion. They Have Low Birth Rates and High Abortion Rates. And we are Winning This Battle day by day. Week by Week,month by month , Year By Year, Decade by Decade.

  • @margaretmcglynn5077
    @margaretmcglynn5077 3 місяці тому +16

    Diversity (everyone gets a fair shake and we all get to work side by side and learn from each other), Equity (fairness to all, not only to traditionally powerful groups), and Inclusion (making sure everyone experiences belonging and fairness, despite "traditional" biases).
    Or, as someone once said, "Do unto others as you would have them do unto you."
    DEI is the Golden Rule. You can't be Christian and be against it.

  • @mgardner70
    @mgardner70 3 місяці тому +10

    Sounds like he is afraid to compete. When you have had everything in your favor, fairness seems like you've been discriminated against.

  • @TheJo201
    @TheJo201 3 місяці тому +18

    Guys While there is an understanding that this is what this man Believes just he had been misinformed, please Remember that misinformed people can sometimes act on what they believe with the potential to cause Great Harm.

  • @cvc1814
    @cvc1814 3 місяці тому +11

    Ms Hunter once again great panel informative conversation ❤

  • @MrMetro-mt5qv
    @MrMetro-mt5qv 3 місяці тому +54

    The WS don’t want anyone playing the victim… because he wants to be the victim.

  • @gregorypeterson9
    @gregorypeterson9 3 місяці тому +45

    When you tell a lie over and over again, and its not consistently challenged it will become the truth. 😢

    • @robertamccartney5500
      @robertamccartney5500 3 місяці тому +4

      Indeed. 💎

    • @derrynelson4637
      @derrynelson4637 3 місяці тому

      Always Remember Misinformation Got a lot of Black Lives Murder. Way Back in the Day with Those Big Lies from White Supremacy.

    • @sceptre3524
      @sceptre3524 3 місяці тому +1

      No it won’t …. It’s just a lie that’s agreed upon…

  • @soysauce6550
    @soysauce6550 3 місяці тому +27

    I'll say Ronald Reagan started it.

    • @taynaburton5828
      @taynaburton5828 3 місяці тому

      I would have to agree with Don about Richard Nixon ushered in this White Resentment that Ronald pick up that torch that helped him get elected also, now it's Trump.

    • @andreabrown4541
      @andreabrown4541 3 місяці тому

      Nixon started the "war on us" before Reagan became president and codified the war on drugs.

  • @p.w.7493
    @p.w.7493 3 місяці тому +6

    Love this 🔥 🔥 🔥 conversation, Prof. Hunter.
    Y'all covered the bases and then some. In the process, you've reignited some things that we seem to have forgotten. Thanks for the enlightenment!!
    How can we continue being uninformed after all that you’ve shared?
    Thank you so very much for this convo.
    🙏🏾🖤💯

  • @k.bllard6329
    @k.bllard6329 3 місяці тому +1

    That was a really good question from Mr. Calloway. I plan to ask some of my older relatives where they think it started too.

  • @donaldcole8030
    @donaldcole8030 3 місяці тому +29

    Karen, you are the real deal. Thank for the knowledge. Love your channel. One of the best on the tube. ❤alone.

  • @ebsmith29
    @ebsmith29 3 місяці тому +9

    I would say that it was first a political strategy during the Civil War and Reconstruction, the 1860s and '70s. If it was not at that time, I would then say the 1950s, '60s and '70s. I saw video clips of when segregationists from around the early 1950s asked something like "why are things only being done for them" (African-Americans). Or one would say something similar like "Black people have as much rights as everyone else." After LBJ signed the civil rights bills, the Southern Strategy comes with Nixon, Reagan, and the older Bush with the help of political operatives like Lee Atwater.
    Conservatives and republicans use emotion and grievance to make their points and use them much better than liberals and democrats during campaigns.

  • @melshome6745
    @melshome6745 3 місяці тому +8

    It started during reconstruction

  • @dennisharry8408
    @dennisharry8408 3 місяці тому +5

    Resentment against the "other" has been a tactic since humans split into tribes. These crap ideas need to be combatted with better ideas.

  • @TirraOmilade
    @TirraOmilade 3 місяці тому +6

    Karen! I love that you are highlighting The Black Menaces. Sebastian and that group have an amazing come up story!

  • @williwombat1066
    @williwombat1066 3 місяці тому +10

    YT resentment has always been a political strategy from the Southern Strategy onward. Trump gave merely gave legitimacy to come out from its dark corners. I concur wholeheartedly with Don Calloway. I’ll add that we should never underestimate white rage. Jan. 6 is proof of that.

  • @LifeIsWhatUMakeOfIt-B100
    @LifeIsWhatUMakeOfIt-B100 3 місяці тому +1

    What the guy in the green shirt initially says about the white fella being "genuinely misinformed" shows how misinformed he is to think that they don't know or understand what they are saying or doing. 👁👁

  • @StoneageT
    @StoneageT 3 місяці тому

    🙏

  • @user-f15d9
    @user-f15d9 3 місяці тому +1

    The bad guys think they're the good guys. Yep. But, some know better, for sure.

  • @Starchild011067
    @Starchild011067 3 місяці тому +1

    Where have you been? White Resentment as a political strategy was enacted when the Southern Strategy was first proposed by Barry Goldwater and defined by Lee Atwater...it was used to elect Nixon and has fed the conservative evangelical agenda ever since.

  • @laroysterjr
    @laroysterjr 3 місяці тому

    "Nothing is more dangerous than sincere ignorance and conscientious stupidity." - Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. I have far greater appreciation and understanding of these words today. 😞
    Professor Hunter has provided practical examples of "I don't always have conversations with the willfully ignorant but when I do they're just as non-reality-based and non-productive as they've always been". 🙂 Unfortunately, I've reached the point where I have zero empathy for willful ignorance that doubles down on conscientious stupidity. It's far too dangerous!
    The caller's perspective is "I don't always say that I'm a full supporter of the ideology of "Inherent Merit-based Whiteness" but when I do I frame it as "anti-DEI". 🙂

  • @Handle2point0
    @Handle2point0 3 місяці тому

    Which episode is this? I wanna hear the full call

  • @BPIII71
    @BPIII71 3 місяці тому +2

    After the Civil War

  • @p.s.perkins5896
    @p.s.perkins5896 3 місяці тому

    When have those predisposed to such values, not been a part of the political energy for some throughout history?

  • @you21MS
    @you21MS 3 місяці тому

    My friened rentment is not the right word!

  • @frankwhite3659
    @frankwhite3659 3 місяці тому +1

    Sebastian Gorka,not Gorsuch.

  • @makeitmakesense2616
    @makeitmakesense2616 3 місяці тому

    8:39 nah i think it's Teddy Roosevelt. Just read a biography on his daughter, Alice Roosevelt, and learned me some thangs

  • @professeurolive
    @professeurolive 3 місяці тому

    It's always been a political strategy, come on now. This must be a rhetorical question.

  • @ronaldshiffman9171
    @ronaldshiffman9171 3 місяці тому

    In 1972 when affirmative action was institutionalized in the US, 57% of college graduates were men. 50 years later, 2022, 40% of college graduates are men. 8 million working age men are living in their parents' home, probably playing video games most of the day. The US definitely has a big problem and we definitely have no idea about how to fix it. The reason why the Supreme Court ruled against affirmative action is straight forward. Affirmative action is unconstitutional. It gives preferences for gender and race. White men were the losers during the affirmative action period. Oh well. But the playing field has been leveled, so the hope is that the next 50 years will result in a better society.

    • @MrStCyrX
      @MrStCyrX 3 місяці тому

      The playing field will never be level, but being white shouldn’t give you a leg up. Earn it like everyone else.

    • @berthabanks5223
      @berthabanks5223 3 місяці тому +2

      @ronaldshiffman9171
      The Supreme Court didn't strike down
      Affirmative Action because of any change in the law but because racist Conservatives organized

    • @mspixie1100
      @mspixie1100 3 місяці тому +1

      We won't have a better society because there is too much hate unfortunately.

    • @ronaldshiffman9171
      @ronaldshiffman9171 3 місяці тому

      @@berthabanks5223 It is important in life, regardless of your feelings, to recognize the facts. Feeling about the law don't change the law. 'The Court held that race-conscious admissions programs violate the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.'

    • @Faks-Now
      @Faks-Now 3 місяці тому

      The playing field has been leveled? With whom?
      The federal government had laws in place against Black Americans for 400 years. Affirmative Action helped mostly with women.
      Now, wyt men are scared?😠🤔

  • @herbalrootwoman
    @herbalrootwoman 3 місяці тому +48

    I feel some type of way about him adopting black babies and having this type of mindset 😳

    • @anthonymeans7439
      @anthonymeans7439 3 місяці тому +8

      Exactly!

    • @nandib570
      @nandib570 3 місяці тому +10

      It is terrifying that this person is supposed to nurture, grow, care for, and love two beautiful precious black babies, in the world. This is hurtful. It isn't shocking.

    • @damonpatterson8293
      @damonpatterson8293 3 місяці тому +10

      I hope he treats them as full human beings and not "pets" that he flaunts to prove he's not racist.

    • @damonpatterson8293
      @damonpatterson8293 3 місяці тому +8

      Cognitive dissonance is a thing.

    • @derrynelson4637
      @derrynelson4637 3 місяці тому +5

      Especially From 🇺🇬 Uganda.

  • @justmyopinion9883
    @justmyopinion9883 3 місяці тому +27

    Donald Trump knew the Republican base would respond to his dog whistles. He knew they were afraid after having a Black man in the White House for 8 years. So, he played into that fear.

    • @stephaniedonato6414
      @stephaniedonato6414 3 місяці тому

      He also says the things they don't have the balls to say out loud. He's a racist and has no problem with it.

    • @viviansmithbarnes
      @viviansmithbarnes 3 місяці тому

      And the political party deserves EVERYTHING they get for allowing this tRUMP BS!

    • @KentonJoseph
      @KentonJoseph 3 місяці тому

      Nixon campaign started the democrat = black mindset. Every election since the republicans insinuate it.

  • @amarbyrd2520
    @amarbyrd2520 3 місяці тому +58

    Both the Kennedy brothers, MLK, and Malcolm X all got assassinated around the same time -- and that "time" is when Black people started to make ECONOMIC PROGRESS in America. I can't believe we're still having to have this conversation because people either don't know to or refuse to connect the dots.

  • @sharongillesp
    @sharongillesp 3 місяці тому +9

    White grievance or white whining? Trump whines so well.

  • @donovanshannon1234
    @donovanshannon1234 3 місяці тому +19

    Nothing more that WHITE FEAR

  • @robertamccartney5500
    @robertamccartney5500 3 місяці тому +19

    😲 When "I'm NOT racist, I own Black people."--were a person. 😤

    • @vickiebonner4181
      @vickiebonner4181 3 місяці тому +1

      😂😂😂 Exactly

    • @Faks-Now
      @Faks-Now 3 місяці тому

      Yep. That's right!

    • @Faks-Now
      @Faks-Now 3 місяці тому +1

      Yep!

    • @ursamajor6347
      @ursamajor6347 3 місяці тому

      Well, you know who’s fault it is the people who let this disgusting person adopt these babies. It’s like they don’t understand there is something fundamentally wrong with these individuals

  • @1hotshon
    @1hotshon 3 місяці тому +5

    All of our social problems derive from greed (capitalism) and bias (racism). If we took care of the basic needs of everyone in society, everything else could be resolved.

  • @godfreychristophe1442
    @godfreychristophe1442 3 місяці тому +8

    Karen and Rachel awesome analysis

  • @tjmastermind
    @tjmastermind 3 місяці тому +5

    This was a great de-construction of how the state of race relations ended up where it is and how it’s used as political theory. Y’all stated something simple, yet profound; we’ve been having the same fight since the civil war and no time in history will be any different. Racism is woven into the fabric of America and it’s impossible to undue all of the fabric.

    • @WoolyTresses
      @WoolyTresses 3 місяці тому

      America was built on racism

  • @dwrighte1
    @dwrighte1 3 місяці тому +4

    Misinformed people are dangerous, my brother.

  • @joirichardson1479
    @joirichardson1479 3 місяці тому +23

    1 way to detect racism is when anyone says, "I don't care if you're white, black, purple, red? etc..."
    That is my pet peeve bc there are no purple people😒 Let's talk facts only‼️
    SN: I really need that artist and song title to the intro, it's so 🔥🔥🔥

    • @peaceangel4192
      @peaceangel4192 3 місяці тому +6

      Glad I'm not the only one. That mess makes me crazy, too! It feels like a halfway distraction or deflection, diminishing the actual people.

    • @SassyTarheel
      @SassyTarheel 3 місяці тому

      They think by saying this it makes them seem not racist. I say they are full of ish. Deep down they are prejudice at least and racist at most.

    • @blackant51
      @blackant51 3 місяці тому +4

      I love the "best person for the job" line 😅😅😅😅

    • @justmyopinion9883
      @justmyopinion9883 3 місяці тому +8

      My favorite is: “We all bleed red no matter what color we are”.
      That’s true. So why has skin color been so important historically?

    • @damonpatterson8293
      @damonpatterson8293 3 місяці тому +1

      That man suffers from cognitive dissonance. I hope he treats his sons like full human beings and not "pets" that he can flaunt to say he's not racist.

  • @pw44salem
    @pw44salem 3 місяці тому +2

    There’s a great book that highlights all that has been spoken. Roland Martin recently wrote a book called White Fear and it pinpoints the facts.

  • @Faks-Now
    @Faks-Now 3 місяці тому +1

    They need to know that their pappy and grand pappies ( from Maverick show) and others lied to them. They need DEI!!! They need to be WOKE!!!

  • @WaleOOO
    @WaleOOO 3 місяці тому +13

    Help to revive our ancestor's reputation by imitating their commitment to Truth…Teach your children to do the same….SPEAK TRUTH ALWAYS

  • @Faks-Now
    @Faks-Now 3 місяці тому +1

    Nobody likes mediocrity. The complainers need to learn the real American history, Black history.

  • @MM-fl6vn
    @MM-fl6vn 3 місяці тому +1

    When hasn't it been political strategy?!??!🙄

  • @scroogemcduckrich9705
    @scroogemcduckrich9705 3 місяці тому +1

    4:43 i don’t feel bad for these folks. they are willfully ignorant

  • @dirtysouth2821
    @dirtysouth2821 3 місяці тому +1

    Obama

  • @WaleOOO
    @WaleOOO 3 місяці тому +2

    ….Truth breeds trust…Trust breeds unity…without Truth there can be no trust…without Trust there can be no unity…no one unifies with those they do not Trust…no one trust those that do not speak Truth

  • @Platypus-Dreams
    @Platypus-Dreams 3 місяці тому +2

    Misinformed? It's illogical to think these things

  • @nobullzone8394
    @nobullzone8394 3 місяці тому +2

    I call it reverse psychology!

  • @osirismoon
    @osirismoon 3 місяці тому +1

    In 1994, I was a freshman at Alabama State, an HBCU. I don't remember how I found it, but I just so happen to run across a radio station that I later learned was catered towards conservative listeners. They didn't talk about race all the time, but when they did, that is when I learned white resentment was a thing. Montgomery is the capital of Alabama and there is a major Air Force base and it seemed some of listeners had resentment towards "unqualified" blacks working in state and federal government. The callers just mostly vented. There was a running theme: hatred of the federal government, Al Sharpton and Jesse Jackson. 😆

    • @trisha1989
      @trisha1989 3 місяці тому +1

      exactly! I had a similar experience when I worked in a small federal government office in a hick town in Virginia. I was only the second Black person to work there in 2000 the first got there in 1998. I was shocked that rush Limbaugh and Fox news would be blaring from the tv and radios in the office. Complaining about the same two people Rev Jackson and Rev Al. I asked the other Black person how can they deal with this and she said she just blocked it out and just played Gospel music. I couldn’t during a staff meeting I addressed it and all radios had to be turned down and the tv was left on the weather channel. They actually felt oppressed but I truly learned a lot by going from a big city to a small town. We are truly outnumbered and it’s an uphill battle that I don’t believe we are truly preparing for!

  • @scroogemcduckrich9705
    @scroogemcduckrich9705 3 місяці тому

    2:01 well you’ve had 400 years of receiving preferential treatment treatment

  • @Setupshot8indaSide
    @Setupshot8indaSide 3 місяці тому

    Considering the Collective Actions Committed to Others Particularly Black People. They Should be Glad a Job Position is Something to Cry about. If God wasn't Merciful....

  • @gloriasmith7797
    @gloriasmith7797 3 місяці тому

    PREJUDICE IS A PERSONAL COMMITMENT TO IGNORANCE!!!.
    #BeKind

  • @whateverwhatever5715
    @whateverwhatever5715 3 місяці тому

    Anybody else start dancing when Karen's intro comes on ?? Love that song

  • @WoolyTresses
    @WoolyTresses 3 місяці тому

    Interesting. They have ALWAYS had the advantage but when they receive regardless of status we are somehow to blame???? It's so funny how they say we want to play victim 😅

  • @charlesbrown1365
    @charlesbrown1365 3 місяці тому

    “Kimmel examines what he describes as the "aggrieved entitlement" of white men in early 21st-century American society. According to Kimmel, many white men, as members of a historically dominant group in America, have reacted to increases in social equality and the loss of economic advantage with overt anger and rage. Written from a scholarly perspective, the book describes various manifestations of this anger, including domestic violence, shootings, involvement in white supremacist groups,[2] and the men's rights and fathers' rights movements.[3] Each chapter of the book discusses a different topic and population of men, including young men and violence, men's rights groups, men's violence toward women, the white working class, and white supremacist groups such as Neo-Nazis.[4]”

  • @beaujac311
    @beaujac311 3 місяці тому

    Rachel Bitecofer is totally right about the University of Georgia. She went to school there around 2000 and she said that the black enrollment was around 8%. I bet it isn't much higher than that now. It may even be lower. Blacks make up 30% of the population in Georgia and that 30% should be represented at the University of Georgia which is the flagship university for the state of Georgia. Right now it is at a paltry 7.5%. Even Ole Miss has done a better job of enrolling its black students than UGA.

  • @jopinscott1777
    @jopinscott1777 3 місяці тому

    Certain individuals thrive on spreading fear, hatred, and distrust among the masses; it's how they keep the rubes in hysteria and how they can continually relieve them of their money... And America's jilted ex is at the forefront of that endeavor. "They're coming to take what's yours! They're coming to get you! They said Candyman three times!"

  • @timphillips1218
    @timphillips1218 3 місяці тому

    The Reagan administration was the foundation of this situation.

  • @censoredamerican3331
    @censoredamerican3331 3 місяці тому +1

    Black fragility...woke martial arts.

    • @KarenHunterShow
      @KarenHunterShow  3 місяці тому +2

      this sounds like gibberish. You're just throwing words together. can you express yourself? What issue do you have with this view and what's your counter, and please provide sources that helped form your opinion.

    • @censoredamerican3331
      @censoredamerican3331 3 місяці тому +2

      @@KarenHunterShow only fragile black people worry about the white people so much. Fragile people show their jealousy. No rich white person is resentful of black people. They fight other rich white people. Same with rich black people. They fight other rich black people. Confident black people succeed, just like the white people. We are all human and black kids are just as good as white kids. My advice is Instead idolizing race, worship God. Come to terms with the fact that there are more white Americans than black Americans. This is okay. Its just the way it is. Demographics vary all over the world. Globally, white people fought a whole war to free the slaves. No black army anywhere in the world has ever found a whole war to free all the slaves in Africa. Black Christians are still slaves to Brown Islamic reasons in Africa and we don't fret about that. Let go of the hate and jealousy. Focus on prosperity. Or help fee some real slaves.

  • @whateverwhatever5715
    @whateverwhatever5715 3 місяці тому

    Shared via threads

  • @batgirlp5561
    @batgirlp5561 3 місяці тому

    Rachel isn't going to tell you how to dismantle a system that benefits her

    • @KarenHunterShow
      @KarenHunterShow  3 місяці тому +1

      Have you read her book? Sounds as if you haven't...just here running your mouth with no knowledge or substance.

  • @sheresehinkle4889
    @sheresehinkle4889 3 місяці тому

    👍👍

  • @rebeccalara4982
    @rebeccalara4982 3 місяці тому

    🪶❤🌟🙏🏽

  • @tjinks7530
    @tjinks7530 3 місяці тому

    How is he assuming as u say if he literally said color shouldn't matter if one is qualified...Ion get it 🤷🏾‍♂️

  • @fred5399
    @fred5399 3 місяці тому

    " United Negro college fund" Where is the fund for white students? i

    • @peaceangel4192
      @peaceangel4192 3 місяці тому +1

      If you are not being disingenuous, here's how you can help yourself - look up college stats, include legacy admissions, all the various sports scholarships (include lacrosse, rowing, skiing, swimming, polo, etc), check where the most grant money goes. That's where you're going to find your precious white students.

    • @blackant51
      @blackant51 3 місяці тому +1

      Hush

    • @relaxlibrary4249
      @relaxlibrary4249 3 місяці тому +7

      Said like a misinformed person.

    • @mspixie1100
      @mspixie1100 3 місяці тому

      All of the money that is given to white colleges from white alumni !!

    • @kennethdorsey6511
      @kennethdorsey6511 3 місяці тому +1

      There is a whites only scholarship founded by Jason Mattera in 2004

  • @veronicajade20
    @veronicajade20 3 місяці тому +2

    "Whiteness is an identity without a soul and empty interior space created by negations and exclusion.”- Scott Malcomson