Stop comparing and saying ones better than the other, each of them have pure talent and its absolutely amazing. I cry every time listening to this song, especially since reminds me of when they used to be 12
Baekhyun's voice is one of the million special inspirations that brings me interest in K-pop's bands. His voice is warm, sweet, light and flowing, a little bit hilarious, and of course mischievous, but carry a lot of emotions, just as his funny personality. " Beautiful" - Baekhyun is an proof. Wow, so cool, Baek, I'm sorry that I'm not an Exo's fan, but i'm your voice's fan. Just good singers can bring these emotions to the audience. Sing more and more, ok
Chen at 3:27-3:42 and 3:56-4:07 takes my breath away. His passion, emotion, expression, powerful voice. He moves me beyond words. Also, he looks amazing with his hair styled this way. Handsome yet pretty and delicate at the same time, just wow. And of course, all three performed beautifully. Baekhyun improves in each performance during his part in the climax, I'm so proud. He's absolutely remarkable here. And when D.O closes the song, his emotions are so on point, I just want to hug him forever. And do I even have to mention their harmony? Like a choir of angels. Magic. Lastly. THANK YOU MUCORE. THANK YOU THANK YOU for this BEAUTIFUL stage and live orchestra. They truly looked like three angels up there because of this stage.
Baekhyun is my bias but I do admit that his voice was shaky during the first stage. But he improved in the second one and this third time was indeed a charm! I liked this stage best so far because of the camera direction. I guess MBC had time to study the song and the other stages to decide which scenes to capture etc. The result shows that the production team was paying attention to every detail of the song so that it did not miss any crucial points such as at 2:05. I never got to see DO sing this part until now. Great job indeed :)
i feel more emotion from baekhyun's voice. Chen and D.O have amazing voices but sometimes i feel like its too...perfect? idk how to describe it but its just that baek's voice is so different... (in a good way of course~)
i think almost everyone feels the same. their voices are all good but there's something in his singing that makes him more attention grabbing. right right???
Umm everyone has their own opinions lol. I feel like Baekhyun's voice has lots of emotions in it. As for chen we never said anything bad about him lol we didn't offend any members we just said baekhyuns voice has lots of emotions and chen, d.o have amazing voices as well
I think that starting with the sweet and sour song is a good mood. It calms down the fan and forces them to stay quite. No fanchants, no cheerings (only in the end). This way Kyungsoo, Baek and Chen can concentrate and relax a bit.
Chen dont hear what people about you. For me bcs of your voice my tears down. Your voice make me feeling deep. Baekhyun and D.O you guys so cool and calm. Love all. To exotic pls stop compare their voice. 3 of them hve a beautiful voice. Mybe baekhyun is your bias but pls dont critics chen..
Theyre getting better and better omg omg chen finally can control his emotion and he looks calm so do his voice and its beautiful :') my babie saranghae
Everyone is talking about vibratos and stuff about their voices but I don't really understand because I don't what those words means. So I'll make my own comparison without the technicalities. Here is what I think and you don't have to agree with it. Chen has the best range because he can hit the the lowest note and highest note amongst the 3 of them (Xiumin doesn't count because he isn't as stable and consistent in his high note). Chen reminds me of Ryeowook (high voice), Yesung (low notes), Kyuhyun (stability and range). Baekhyun's voice is amazing. He reminds me of Kyuhyun somehow (stability, technique or whatever it is, he just remind me of him). My favorite part of the song is the peak at 3:16 which he sung. I just love it. D.O reminds me too much of Yesung's deep, emotional voice. His range isn't like Chen but he makes up for it with his voice alone. I think if he practice more and keep doing what he does, he will be as recognize as Yesung. Because Yesung is mainly recognize as SJ's very main vocal because his voice is amazing. Kyuhyun is more stable but Yesung and his voice are just amazing. So I think D.O can be that too. By the way, this is again what I think. No one needs to agree. FYI, my biases are Yesung and Chen.
you said all what i want to say ~_^ , same thoughts as me for all , chen always ake me remmeber ryeowook voice , my 2 fav vocalist in 2 bands & my biases
My favorite part is also the peak ;-) but I also think there voices were a bit unstable because of the type of song they are singing. You can tell whenwhen they start tobsing out instead clamly, if I ya know what I mean about that:-D , it becomes very clear and stable. I don't think the ballad type song suits their voice ranges.
everyone has their opinion, as for me yes im a baekstan ^^ but IN THIS SONG I JUST LOVE CHEN VOICE BECAUSE IT GIVES ME GOOSEBUMPS. but actually their vocals are equal, fair & square. Baekhyun - Powerful voice Chen - Soulful voice D.O - Sweet voice Luhan - Kind of unique voice (maybe because he's chinese) ^^
omg i've watched pretty much all the live performances of this and D.O. looks like he's going to cry at the end of every one :'O he is actually the cutest member in EXO in my opinion. All three have amazing voices...Chen just blew me away :)
Finally I'm here again just after listening its cover by MJ, Seungwoo, Hongseok and Hyojin on Mcountdown. And it feels like there is no other one who sing EXO songs better than EXO.
I think that all vocal line (Baekhyun / D.O /Chen until Luhan) have heaven voice and they have perfect show on stage for me, but Baekhyun's voice is the best emotional in many songs. # I love his voice.
Their voice is heaven :) DBaekChen Awesome ! I love Kyungsoo's voice more because he's my bias and he has a sweetest tone. Jongdae can reach highnote easier than what i thought and Baekkie's voice is great. I love his voice when he performing MAMA. Ahh, I miss MAMA ERA :D
This is my favorite ballad from Exo, all 3 of them has are angel like vocals , I dont know why some say Chen lacks emotions longing,sadness,regret its all over his vocals .When all of them singing together its so perfect .
Wow, they are getting better and better with each live show! The first performance was a little shaky but they kept on improving. The stage concept is also getting more and more interesting too! It's as if each TV station is competing to outdo the previous one :) Kudos to MBC's production team for truly understanding the camera direction needed for this song. For example, this is the first time I get to see DO sing this part (at 2:05-2:06) and the camera effect quickly faded to show a zoomed-out shot of the entire stage so people can see that Chen is singing next. Very clever! I like it, +MBCkpop !!
i love everyone in exo literally. They all have unique talent and they are all what brings exo together. Without all 12 members there is no exo. so I think everyone in exo is the best. No matter how good their vocals or dancing skills are.
until now (it's 2018) people still argue who's the best between the vocal line. even EXO-L can't stop comparing (in a bad way) these 3 vocalist. saying baekhyun the best or d.o. the best or jongdae the best. I just don't understand. lol why you guys keep arguing like that, can we just appreciate them equally? jongdae is my ultimate bias. of course I love his voice. but I love baekhyun and kyungsoo too. I love when jongdae sings. I love when baekhyun sings. I love when kyungsoo sings. and when they're singing together in one song, can you even imagine how happy I am? T.T their voice so blessing.
Honestly to Sing this song , You need to "Feel" it . You can hear how well the Members sing this , They have this Feel That fits this song . They have Voice, expression, and Heart for this song
I loooove Baekhyun's talent very much. Just a small note: It's the first time I see a professional singer moving, shaking the microphone this way. I'm surprised it doesn't cause problems for his performance.
It makes me angry how nobody appreciates Baekhyun's talent. People is always praising Jongdae and Kyungsoo but what about Baekhyun? A good singer is not someone who sings only high notes, I hope people can understand that...
I'm a DO fan, i think do has great tone, but i always felt baekhyun has a stronger voice and i felt the power of his range when pulling intense parts are spot on (ie wolf and baby, dont cry just to list a few)! and i know alot of people that likes baek's voice the best so yup xD
If you look into lyrics you ll understand this song is a mixture of emotions , mainly D.O and Baekhyun's parts are about sweetness of love ,sweet memories they had,thankfulness towards her wanting to be with her again but Chen's part mainly is regret , blaming himself for selfishness , and longing with regret . Comparing emotional delivery here is bit unfair since the parts they have has different meanings . Even you did with delivery its not just Chen's strong powerful vocals , more line distribution shine here , but also strong emotional delivery , the heartbroken ness,regret ,self blame , too much negative things,his facial expressions shows it very much . As a young singer hats off to him to build such emotional delivery . I cant believe specially in early EXO days how toxic people were to specially chen . Like getting mad at people even mentioning him.
The 3 of them make me cry like a baby, their voice are not just good, and their tecnique is perfect, but the 3 of them convey the feeling of the song really well. Baek got the most touching part of the song IMO, specially with the orchestra there, but the despair in Jongdaes voice in the high notes, and the sadness at the very end with KyungSoo, it's so well done that makes me cry. EXO is blessed with very talented people.
I keep saying this and I'll say it again...I'm a new 8 month baby EXO-L thanks to Kai's Rover song but it was EXO's live, power, soulful, vocal line that made me pay attention! Chen, Baekhyun and D.O.'s vocals are thee best I've ever heard in the industry! As a lover of old RnB soul music and singers, EXO's vocal line and music is exactly what I've been looking for in K-pop! I may be late to the party but I'm so glad I found the group that's right for me. It's unhealthy the amount of EXO's 11+ years of content I've been consuming these past several months! It is well worth the time and I have been constantly blessed with EXO's talent! EXO's music and vocals make me feel at home. Thank you for existing EXO! New EXO-L loving and supporting from Canada!!!
I think Chen's voice is more to high vocals.. Do's voice sound really good in low note.. Baekhyun is just a perfect blend of that high and low... Also his powerful voice..
Dance music to K-Pop for them or any other group on live requires practice even more to have that voice but when emotional music like this comes to it.. you'll realise what pure talent is on this song from EXO
of all Kpop song outhere, This was the one that got me into exo and then into kpop, i s till remember how Chen`s voice gave me chills and it still do, so proud of where they r now, i love u my boys :D
I'm not an expert in terms of vocals but ill go ahead and say why they're a perfect combo and are good in their own way. Baekhyun 's voice PROJECTION is amazing. Its at a consistent tone and volume. For chen, he can hit the high notes EFFORTLESSLY. And lastly, kyungsoo's voice is very VERSATILE. Man man man, If you mix all of these vocal strengths in together, then you would have a power singer tbh, which is why the three of them mix well. Therefore, we need to stop comparing and appreciate each one of them.
I flailed all over the place and i might have even shed a few tears at some point omg i wasn't aware i was capable of so much fangirling afsghgjdfkhdsıdjhymh CHEN
Seungsik & Seungwoo of Victon brought me here.... the song is nice, its melody & tone are remarkably good & touching & 2Seungs have covered the song with perfection.: all 3 Exo singers are good, Chen & Baekhyun gave me chills & Do made me warm..
Tricia Agpoon Liking is not what makes you a fan :P It's really supporting them by purchasing their songs and albums, going to their concerts, buying merchandise, promoting them,spazzing etc, I buy some of their songs but that's just because I think they are "good."
Ephraim Gonzales No, supporting them through purchases isn't the definition of "being a fan." What makes you a fan is shown through your dedication and love towards them. If you want the best for them and support them then, you're a fan. It really doesn't matter whether you have 10 posters or 1, it's based on how much you love and want them to succeed.
Their vocal line is no joke. Damn boys
Yea best vocal line in k- pop
Stop comparing and saying ones better than the other, each of them have pure talent and its absolutely amazing. I cry every time listening to this song, especially since reminds me of when they used to be 12
Really miss ot12😭
개소름인것
이때태어난애들지금초딩임..
이때초딩인애들지금중고딩임..
이때대딩인애들지금직딩..
이때대뷔한그룹들지금제개약하거나해채함..
I really miss exo ot12😭
Baekhyun eats CD's. it's official
Wow. Chen's amazing voice gives me chills!
GablesHorse of course, he is main vocal and highnotes of EXO
Jelly bean Yup :D
GablesHorse ofc hes chenny chen
+GablesHorse his voice makes me get teary eyes. no joke
beaglechen you know shat the left hes suho or do .becaude the face memberexo same face
Baekhyun's voice is one of the million special inspirations that brings me interest in K-pop's bands. His voice is warm, sweet, light and flowing, a little bit hilarious, and of course mischievous, but carry a lot of emotions, just as his funny personality. " Beautiful" - Baekhyun is an proof. Wow, so cool, Baek, I'm sorry that I'm not an Exo's fan, but i'm your voice's fan. Just good singers can bring these emotions to the audience. Sing more and more, ok
Everytime Baek sings this part at 3:16 i always get goosebumps
OMG SAMMMMMEEEEEEEEEE
SAME NO ONE EVER MENTIONS THAT ITS SO BEAUTIFUL
same same EVERY SINGLE TIME
Traitor
Me tooo 😭
Chen at 3:27-3:42 and 3:56-4:07 takes my breath away. His passion, emotion, expression, powerful voice. He moves me beyond words. Also, he looks amazing with his hair styled this way. Handsome yet pretty and delicate at the same time, just wow. And of course, all three performed beautifully. Baekhyun improves in each performance during his part in the climax, I'm so proud. He's absolutely remarkable here. And when D.O closes the song, his emotions are so on point, I just want to hug him forever. And do I even have to mention their harmony? Like a choir of angels. Magic. Lastly. THANK YOU MUCORE. THANK YOU THANK YOU for this BEAUTIFUL stage and live orchestra. They truly looked like three angels up there because of this stage.
Baekhyun is my bias but I do admit that his voice was shaky during the first stage. But he improved in the second one and this third time was indeed a charm! I liked this stage best so far because of the camera direction. I guess MBC had time to study the song and the other stages to decide which scenes to capture etc. The result shows that the production team was paying attention to every detail of the song so that it did not miss any crucial points such as at 2:05. I never got to see DO sing this part until now. Great job indeed :)
I'm a vocalist and Chen is the best vocalist in exo. He has lot of potential to become a great vocalist. Exo is lucky to have him
i feel more emotion from baekhyun's voice. Chen and D.O have amazing voices but sometimes i feel like its too...perfect? idk how to describe it but its just that baek's voice is so different... (in a good way of course~)
i think almost everyone feels the same. their voices are all good but there's something in his singing that makes him more attention grabbing. right right???
Disagree :/ i feel just as much emotion from Chen as Baekhyun
Umm everyone has their own opinions lol. I feel like Baekhyun's voice has lots of emotions in it. As for chen we never said anything bad about him lol we didn't offend any members we just said baekhyuns voice has lots of emotions and chen, d.o have amazing voices as well
I didn't say anything wrong either mate. Just expressing my opinion too.
Lol okay
I think that starting with the sweet and sour song is a good mood. It calms down the fan and forces them to stay quite. No fanchants, no cheerings (only in the end).
This way Kyungsoo, Baek and Chen can concentrate and relax a bit.
Every time Chen sings his part, I'd instantly feel goosebumps all over . They're all just sooooooo good
왜 12월도 아닌데 계속 듣고있는거냐고...
스엠이 진짜 엑소 보컬라인만큼은 잘뽑았어
Chens vocals are amazing!
Daebak!!! This performance is best!! I love Baekhyun's voice❤
Baekhyun has deadly stare ;;__;;
Baekhyuna, I love your voice so much
Chen dont hear what people about you. For me bcs of your voice my tears down. Your voice make me feeling deep. Baekhyun and D.O you guys so cool and calm. Love all. To exotic pls stop compare their voice. 3 of them hve a beautiful voice. Mybe baekhyun is your bias but pls dont critics chen..
Chen's voice was so so so so so amazinggggggggggggg
다시는 아이돌 엑소만큼 못 좋아할것같음
내 학창시절을 행복하게 보내게 해준 처음이자 마지막 아이돌...
순탄하게 잘 살았으면 좋겠음
Love Baekhyun voice. He has a unique voice.
Damn D.O needs more lines he's voice is too good
CHEN's voice is so amazing
Altho Chen has a higher range but I prefer D.O's voice...he has this sweet tone...
chen's voice is very unique and i really love it!
Theyre getting better and better omg omg chen finally can control his emotion and he looks calm so do his voice and its beautiful :') my babie saranghae
3:17-3:24 My favorite part! Baekhyun!!
Chen's voice is my favorite but they sound so beautiful when they sing together ;-;
Everyone is talking about vibratos and stuff about their voices but I don't really understand because I don't what those words means. So I'll make my own comparison without the technicalities. Here is what I think and you don't have to agree with it.
Chen has the best range because he can hit the the lowest note and highest note amongst the 3 of them (Xiumin doesn't count because he isn't as stable and consistent in his high note). Chen reminds me of Ryeowook (high voice), Yesung (low notes), Kyuhyun (stability and range).
Baekhyun's voice is amazing. He reminds me of Kyuhyun somehow (stability, technique or whatever it is, he just remind me of him). My favorite part of the song is the peak at 3:16 which he sung. I just love it.
D.O reminds me too much of Yesung's deep, emotional voice. His range isn't like Chen but he makes up for it with his voice alone. I think if he practice more and keep doing what he does, he will be as recognize as Yesung. Because Yesung is mainly recognize as SJ's very main vocal because his voice is amazing. Kyuhyun is more stable but Yesung and his voice are just amazing. So I think D.O can be that too.
By the way, this is again what I think. No one needs to agree. FYI, my biases are Yesung and Chen.
you said all what i want to say ~_^ , same thoughts as me for all , chen always ake me remmeber ryeowook voice , my 2 fav vocalist in 2 bands & my biases
My favorite part is also the peak ;-) but I also think there voices were a bit unstable because of the type of song they are singing. You can tell whenwhen they start tobsing out instead clamly, if I ya know what I mean about that:-D , it becomes very clear and stable. I don't think the ballad type song suits their voice ranges.
Kayla Leigh they're still pretty new. Let's hope they get better every practice they do.
Well, I'm happy to agree with you.
and here we are and some people complaining about SM artist lipsyncing everytime, lol
like when they do live it's the best anyways....
Baekhyunah~
Your voice is amazing!
D.O. ♥
I cant believe how rookies be this talented ..Only exo.....I miss baek,chen,DO singing together...
겨울이 온다 이번년도도 책임져라..
올해도요~~
내년도요~
Beautiful Voices~ Beautiful stage~ DAEBAK!
EXO Fighting!
EXO♥️💖♥️❤💖💔💝♥️💕💚💜💖♥️💝📞🌷💚🌷
EXO🍱🖤💝💚💘💖❤🍔💖📞💜🌷🥰🍷☕
i love baekhyun's part at 3:15-3:25
baekhyun has the most emotional voice out of all 3 :))
idk why but this song makes me want to become a singer...
And i thought i was the only one...Phew~
Raychee Tang lol the lighting and the song makes me think. wow, it must be nice standing there
me too
SAAAME and it’s 2019
Chen looks like a child of an Angel here.
Baekhyun needs to show his charismatic forehead more often
Kyungsoo is a little ball of cuteness
Baekhyun,I love your voice
everyone has their opinion, as for me yes im a baekstan ^^ but IN THIS SONG I JUST LOVE CHEN VOICE BECAUSE IT GIVES ME GOOSEBUMPS. but actually their vocals are equal, fair & square.
Baekhyun - Powerful voice
Chen - Soulful voice
D.O - Sweet voice
Luhan - Kind of unique voice (maybe because he's chinese) ^^
I CANT EVEN EXPLAIN HOW GOOD JONGDAE LOOKS IN THIS PERFORMANCE
omg i've watched pretty much all the live performances of this and D.O. looks like he's going to cry at the end of every one :'O he is actually the cutest member in EXO in my opinion. All three have amazing voices...Chen just blew me away :)
I'm just in love with Baek's high note
Finally I'm here again just after listening its cover by MJ, Seungwoo, Hongseok and Hyojin on Mcountdown. And it feels like there is no other one who sing EXO songs better than EXO.
I think that all vocal line (Baekhyun / D.O /Chen until Luhan) have heaven voice and they have perfect show on stage for me, but Baekhyun's voice is the best emotional in many songs. # I love his voice.
Their voice is heaven :)
DBaekChen Awesome ! I love Kyungsoo's voice more because he's my bias and he has a sweetest tone. Jongdae can reach highnote easier than what i thought and Baekkie's voice is great. I love his voice when he performing MAMA. Ahh, I miss MAMA ERA :D
진짜 그냥 이때로 돌아가고 싶다
아무것도 모르던 때로
This is my favorite ballad from Exo, all 3 of them has are angel like vocals , I dont know why some say Chen lacks emotions longing,sadness,regret its all over his vocals .When all of them singing together its so perfect .
Wow, they are getting better and better with each live show! The first performance was a little shaky but they kept on improving. The stage concept is also getting more and more interesting too! It's as if each TV station is competing to outdo the previous one :)
Kudos to MBC's production team for truly understanding the camera direction needed for this song. For example, this is the first time I get to see DO sing this part (at 2:05-2:06) and the camera effect quickly faded to show a zoomed-out shot of the entire stage so people can see that Chen is singing next. Very clever! I like it, +MBCkpop !!
i love everyone in exo literally.
They all have unique talent and they are all what brings exo together.
Without all 12 members there is no exo.
so I think everyone in exo is the best.
No matter how good their vocals or dancing skills are.
Baek's voice literally gives me chills. What a talented singer!!
WOOAAAH. Chen completely blew me away. You go jongdae
until now (it's 2018) people still argue who's the best between the vocal line. even EXO-L can't stop comparing (in a bad way) these 3 vocalist. saying baekhyun the best or d.o. the best or jongdae the best. I just don't understand. lol
why you guys keep arguing like that, can we just appreciate them equally?
jongdae is my ultimate bias. of course I love his voice. but I love baekhyun and kyungsoo too.
I love when jongdae sings.
I love when baekhyun sings.
I love when kyungsoo sings.
and when they're singing together in one song, can you even imagine how happy I am? T.T their voice so blessing.
Honestly to Sing this song , You need to "Feel" it . You can hear how well the Members sing this , They have this Feel That fits this song . They have Voice, expression, and Heart for this song
I swear i tear up listen to this song almost every time.Everything about this performance is breathtaking.
I loooove Baekhyun's talent very much. Just a small note: It's the first time I see a professional singer moving, shaking the microphone this way. I'm surprised it doesn't cause problems for his performance.
It makes me angry how nobody appreciates Baekhyun's talent. People is always praising Jongdae and Kyungsoo but what about Baekhyun? A good singer is not someone who sings only high notes, I hope people can understand that...
Don't worry I love Baekhyun his voice is just so nice to listen to and it gives me chills everytime!! :)
not to mention his motorcycle sounds LMAO AHAHHA
he's imo the best voice in EXO and one of the best in the Kpop industry !
r u joking?
baekhyun's voice is damn powerful, can hit high notes!
chen and baekhyun owned this song
even though i like d.o. voice the best
I'm a DO fan, i think do has great tone, but i always felt baekhyun has a stronger voice and i felt the power of his range when pulling intense parts are spot on (ie wolf and baby, dont cry just to list a few)! and i know alot of people that likes baek's voice the best so yup xD
If you look into lyrics you ll understand this song is a mixture of emotions , mainly D.O and Baekhyun's parts are about sweetness of love ,sweet memories they had,thankfulness towards her wanting to be with her again
but Chen's part mainly is regret , blaming himself for selfishness , and longing with regret .
Comparing emotional delivery here is bit unfair since the parts they have has different meanings . Even you did with delivery its not just Chen's strong powerful vocals , more line distribution shine here , but also strong emotional delivery , the heartbroken ness,regret ,self blame , too much negative things,his facial expressions shows it very much . As a young singer hats off to him to build such emotional delivery .
I cant believe specially in early EXO days how toxic people were to specially chen . Like getting mad at people even mentioning him.
The 3 of them make me cry like a baby, their voice are not just good, and their tecnique is perfect, but the 3 of them convey the feeling of the song really well.
Baek got the most touching part of the song IMO, specially with the orchestra there, but the despair in Jongdaes voice in the high notes, and the sadness at the very end with KyungSoo, it's so well done that makes me cry.
EXO is blessed with very talented people.
Chen..chen daebakkk
i all the performances so far... chen has easily sung and sounded the best. well done chen. you deserve way more love and praise!
Chen always makes me happy when he sings!!,,
Their eyes are so teary...making me crying
I get so offended when people say exo can't sing, i'm jus like your bias is showing
I keep saying this and I'll say it again...I'm a new 8 month baby EXO-L thanks to Kai's Rover song but it was EXO's live, power, soulful, vocal line that made me pay attention! Chen, Baekhyun and D.O.'s vocals are thee best I've ever heard in the industry! As a lover of old RnB soul music and singers, EXO's vocal line and music is exactly what I've been looking for in K-pop! I may be late to the party but I'm so glad I found the group that's right for me. It's unhealthy the amount of EXO's 11+ years of content I've been consuming these past several months! It is well worth the time and I have been constantly blessed with EXO's talent! EXO's music and vocals make me feel at home. Thank you for existing EXO! New EXO-L loving and supporting from Canada!!!
Baekhyun's voice so dramatic
Chen has such a powerful voice. Gah I'm getting teary eyed when he sings. :) great job to all three though. Love this song.
baekhyun
I'm fall in love with beakhyun's voice. they all are amazing @@
Chen >< I love your voice.
Three of the most talented singers ever. This song is so incredibly beautiful and moving that I almost want to cry.
I think Chen's voice is more to high vocals.. Do's voice sound really good in low note.. Baekhyun is just a perfect blend of that high and low... Also his powerful voice..
10년이 지나도❤
Dance music to K-Pop for them or any other group on live requires practice even more to have that voice but when emotional music like this comes to it.. you'll realise what pure talent is on this song from EXO
of all Kpop song outhere, This was the one that got me into exo and then into kpop, i s till remember how Chen`s voice gave me chills and it still do, so proud of where they r now, i love u my boys :D
엑소는 싫어했지만 이노래는 제일좋아했음 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 멜로디가 너무좋음
Man chen's amazing voice *always* blows me away >< ~
♥
They can melt my heart how is this possible 😭 I'm crying and I don't know if I'm happy or sad or overwhelmed or proud
I don 't know why people dislike this, Isn't it so amazing and they're jealous ?????
The best stage of Miracles in Dec up til now
Bekhyun's voice is full of emotions.
Chen your voice is the best
나를 엑소엘로 만들었던 노래. 시간이 흘렀음에도 여전히 좋다 듣고 있으면 그 시절의 기억들이 하나씩 떠오르는 신기한 경험을 하게 돼 다시는 돌아가지 못할 과거이기에 더욱 소중해 훗날 나이가 더 들어서도 살아가다 한 번씩 꺼내볼 거같다
wow chen's voice is awesome i love it how it sound here but also D.O and baek voices are awesome XD
Pause at 0:34 D.O.'s eyes are watery I've been noticing that every time they sing this beautiful song.
Pause at 0:57 also Baek's eyes are very watery too
Chen's eyes also! Pause at 1:12 Chen,Baek, and D.O. are thinking about the past when all the members were together makes me wanna cry
DANG!!!! D.O really knows how to put crystal clear emotions to any song!!!!
Chen's vocal
BAEKHYUN WONDERFUL VOICE ♥♥
Yes, it's 2020 and my heart still breaks every time I listen to this...
I'm not an expert in terms of vocals but ill go ahead and say why they're a perfect combo and are good in their own way. Baekhyun 's voice PROJECTION is amazing. Its at a consistent tone and volume. For chen, he can hit the high notes EFFORTLESSLY. And lastly, kyungsoo's voice is very VERSATILE. Man man man, If you mix all of these vocal strengths in together, then you would have a power singer tbh, which is why the three of them mix well. Therefore, we need to stop comparing and appreciate each one of them.
I flailed all over the place and i might have even shed a few tears at some point omg i wasn't aware i was capable of so much fangirling afsghgjdfkhdsıdjhymh
CHEN
3:15~3:27 킬포 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 너무 좋아
이게 어떻게 7년 전이야... 7일 전이라고 해주라 제발ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
Really happy that Chen took center stage (:
😢😭D.O 😍 his voice, his eyes
Seungsik & Seungwoo of Victon brought me here.... the song is nice, its melody & tone are remarkably good & touching & 2Seungs have covered the song with perfection.: all 3 Exo singers are good, Chen & Baekhyun gave me chills & Do made me warm..
Wow baeksoo chorus is amazing...... It helps to heal our ears....
Our Lagend our king.. let's keep support Exo
the most emoticional kpop song ever.
I dunno why I cant consider myself as an exo fan tho I buy most of their albums songs and this one is gloriously performed well.
lol if you like them then I think you are a fan xD
Tricia Agpoon Liking is not what makes you a fan :P It's really supporting them by purchasing their songs and albums, going to their concerts, buying merchandise, promoting them,spazzing etc, I buy some of their songs but that's just because I think they are "good."
Ephraim Gonzales No, supporting them through purchases isn't the definition of "being a fan." What makes you a fan is shown through your dedication and love towards them. If you want the best for them and support them then, you're a fan. It really doesn't matter whether you have 10 posters or 1, it's based on how much you love and want them to succeed.
Julie Li*applause* Well said.
Maybe you're a fan of the music they make. Not really exo members themselves.
2018년에도 아직 보시는 분!!? 12월의 기적 덕분에 엑소팬이 되었어요 ㅠㅠ 그래서 저에겐 아주 소중한 노래에요 ㅠㅠ 이젠 2019년은 얼마 안남았는데 2019년에도 행복한 일만 가득하길! 여러분들 행복하고 건강하세용!
SM should have just had Chen and Baekhyun sing this song and give D.O. an RnB song he can sing alone :P