A city ordinance has been in effect since 1971 designating Royal St. as a pedestrian mall closed to traffic during certain hours. Bands have traditionally used this time for busking. After the Hard Rock Hotel collapse in 2019 traffic was rerouted to Royal Street 24 hours a day. The hotel has been demolished yet for some reason the city did not return Royal St. to a pedestrian mall per the 1971 ordinance (Sec. 154-608, Vieux Carre' Malls). Several bands decided to play on Royal this day in protest. Tuba Skinny was set up in a no parking space and traffic continued interrupted while they played (Royal is a 1 way street). You will see this in my other videos and at the end of this video when traffic passes after the policeman drives off. A month after this video was released the city relented and allowed the bands to return.
@@lioneldarde1851I don't know if the FQF has any stages set up on Royal, so it wouldn't surprise me if they keep traffic on Royal. They are ignoring their own city ordinance.
It's a shame they are harassing the bands like that. My 5 years there in the late 70's early 80's were the best. Bands on Royal and other streets were the heart and soul of that city. They have been playing there even before they paved some of the streets. Hope my two cents worth burned a few ears at city hall.
I'm in Australia and have been following Tuba Skinny for quite some time. Much of this time they have been on Royal Street without any problems arising from that. Leave well enough alone as they are an integral part of the New Orleans tourism industry. Their music brings joy to many far and wide. God Bless Tuba Skinny.
When I was a tourist in New Orleans I saw all sorts of poor behaviour in the streets, mainly due to alcohol abuse. I'm sure the police would be better dealing with this than hassling harmless musicians. Without its unique style of music New Orleans would be unknown to tourists. Regards from Australia.
@@michaelhalsall5684 speaking from Melbourne Australia. Here here Just get the road closed. ( for everyone’s safety. ). I just read the full 154 Code. Keep going Tuba Skinny. I’d love to see the Video the washboard player did on his phone. ( just sayin ! )
The elephant in the room is race. Whites are being attacked and marginalized across America. This officer has no logical reason to be doing this. Chilling.
I'm watching this from Ireland and say well done Tuba Skinny for standing up for your rights to play, message to the mayor, the world is watching you, get your act together and make this pedestrian again
From Canada: Firstly I am shocked by the rudeness and arrogance of the police. Siren blazing, no tact, no willingness to listen or resolve the issue. Bad publicity for visiting the U.S ..and there's Tuba Skinny, ambassadors for a trip to the States. Like many people overseas, my dream is to visit N.O just to experience them playing on the street . A daily dose of Tuba Skinny got me through out long cold lock- downs in Canada. ( Had me dancing in the kitchen) The city needs needs a golden plaque in recognition of their extraordinary musicianship. The city should PAY them for the tourist publicity it gives to New Orleans not limit them. THANK YOU ❤️❤️❤️ Tuba Skinny. You are fantastic!
Listen for real , stay the fuck out of America , take it from someone stuck inside , this is a very dangerous place , and a very bad place , it is ruled by wicked elite rich ancient creatures . No one should come here especially right now , things are getting worse by the day here , mass shootings everywhere , good people getting put into cages for defending themselves . Stay where you are you are much safer there . Nothing to see here !
@@LibbyRal Até eu Edmilson Donizete Botéquio, aqui no Brasil sempre assisto as apresentações do Tuba e programo com a família uma viagem para New Orleans, muito motivado a conhecer o pessoal do magnifico Tuba Skiny
At LEAST they should be encouraging artists. Maybe even making public spaces available for them to perform in that are desIgnated as appropriate and legal spaces. The police harassment looks really bad.
Thankfully, we are coming out of the pandemic. Between booster vaccines and better therapies death rates are dropping. The issue WAS a valid issue in that you don't want to encourage crowds of people to congregate.
Tourists and locals alike love New Orleans because of the vibrant music scene out in the streets. Nobody goes to the City to see more CARS! Tuba Skinny is an INSTITUTION, man.
You've already demonstrated your courage and dedication. Nothing that ensues from this will diminish that in any way. I have written to the Mayor; you are the best thing that has happened to New Orleans since Louis Armstrong.
I'm going to have to slightly modify that post, written in the heat of passion. Let's not forget the Nevilles, Fats, Allen Toussaint, and a myriad of others. No disrespect to them.😊
@@stepaushi Royal in the central quarter is supposed to be closed to vehicular traffic M-F between 11 a.m. and 4 p.m., and on Saturdays and Sundays between 11 a.m. and 7 p.m. This has been the case since the early 1970s. You're right that they don't enforce it.
@@StephenLipps It's weird that the police would not know that, though. Either it's legally closed to vehicles or it's not. Do you think this is legally documented somewhere? I def think Royal should be free of cars, but I also think police should not be denigrated for doing their job it it is indeed not declared vehicle-free.
Well yeah they joined the force so they could wear a gun and bully people who don't wear one, not protect or serve...going after murderers is scary, and "not what they signed up for"
Tuba Skinny: a City’s treasure, a State treasure, a National treasure. To be treated like this by city police is disgraceful. Officer couldn’t wait until they finished the tune before engaging the siren !? I sincerely hope some retraining is in order. I don’t know the local laws but I do know the local police made fools of themselves on this occasion. Truly incredible.
@@UserGuy-g4l I say let's change something. There's no reason why a maleficent force such as the police should go on unchecked for so long in the land of democracy. We the people who do nothing to stop it are to blame
The Mayor would do well to treasure the musicians who continue to export their talent to the whole world. In addition to e mailing the Mayor, supporting the correct application of the law, the freedom of expression to perform like this is a matter to be closely guarded. Greetings from Derby, England.
I am sorry to tell you that there is not much 'freedom of expression' in Derby. Prospective buskers have to pass an audition by the Council to get a licence.
Well that’s a clever move by the Mayor……destroy the very thing that visitors and tourists visit New Orleans for in the first place. Live Jazz! I bet the local traders, shop keepers, food vendors and small businesses appreciate her shortsightedness! Keep playing TS. Love from U.K.!
I never wanted to go to New Orleans until I discovered Tuba Skinny, and it is on the street where I would love to see them perform, preferably outside a pub.
I would suggest everyone inundate city hall with e-mails, letters, phone calls, etc. Never put dumbasses (the administration in this case?) in the seat of power. They don't follow their own rules and regulations. I hope people like Tuba Skinny and others continue to exercise their freedom and hold them to their own rules. I don't blame this officer, he seemed to handle this situation the best he could. God bless.👍👊🏼🇺🇸
It is hard to believe that the Mayor would hassle the very band that puts New Orleans back on the map again. Tuba Skinny needs to be encouraged. They are incredible musicians with the most endearing music style and rhythm. TS got it all. Much love from Ireland.
I am French and I live near Paris. I discovered the video with the French Quarter police (!) and it's incredible. I've been following you from France on UA-cam for a long time (I'm a trombone player) and you are partly the soul of this city. April 26th is a good day, it's my birthday ! Keep playing in the street, it's a pleasure to listen to you. Don't give up!
I love to watch the band play in the street and to see all the happy people taking in the atmosphere created by the talent in the band i hope this gets resolved positively quickly the city of New Orleans cannot lose such a beautiful thing best wishes from Australia
What makes New Orleans different than other cities? Bands like Tuba Skinny playing on the street. It's what makes New Orleans special and memorable and cool. Hope the band and other bands get to play where they'd like to play rather than being told by the powers that be that it's not acceptable.
Dear Mayor Cantrell, I was very disappointed to see James Sterling’s recent video of Tuba Skinny being told they could not play in their usual place on Royal Street. It is no exaggeration to say that the beautiful atmosphere which comes through in the videos of them playing in this location have persuaded my wife and me to visit the city (from England) next year. New Orleans has something extremely precious in these performances, something which other cities would dearly love to have, and which deserves to be protected and nurtured. It would be truly tragic if an overly strict (and, it is said, incorrect) interpretation of the law were allowed to stifle such a unique and beautiful thing. With Best Regards, Derek Ryden, Stroud England.
I've always loved you British for your wit, charm and keen intelligence. Wish I could've said what you did. I just said, "I'm not visiting NO if you shut down the mall to pedestrians." Tuba Skinny is New Orleans Heritage Jazz.
I was in New Orleans in May of 2019. We were there a week and traveled around the area to see sights. This is a unique place such as I have never seen. I never felt really safe while there, although nothing bad ever happened. Heard lots of good music and ate lots of good food, but never saw Tuba Skinny because I had not heard of them at the time. I will go out of my way to see them in person if I am ever in the area again.Good luck guys and gals. You are the best !
Dear Mayor Cantrell: International fans of Tuba Skinny as well as the many worthy buskers that make New Orleans such a special city to visit (and watch on You-tube) plead with you to do the right thing for your city - bring busking back to Royal Street. Remember also that New Orleans is the jazz capital of the world: are you not dishonouring its well-earned heritage?
@@RM-je5qw the city passed an ordinance in the last century to close down parts of Royal Street and allow pedestrian traffic. What the musicians are asking is for that to be enforced. When musicians busk on the sidewalk, then pedestrians are forced into the street. No one wins.
@@RM-je5qw Stand corrected. The city has an ordinance allowing for parts of that street to be a pedestrian mall at certain times. This is what the musicians are requesting. When it was enforced, emergency vehicles knew to reroute accordingly. Bourbon Street becomes a pedestrian walk every night and they all manage just fine
Brisbane Australia here. Have loved Tuba Skinny for many years. Saw them live when they were here, some years back. Wouldlove to see them continue in their home country. Pretty horrible to see the Police behave like that.
I love how the Trombone player pulls out the ORDINANCE CODE from his pocket!!👍 And the COP plain out ignores what was said!!. And while there was plenty of room for them to drive by.... haha soo sad...
What a bummer. We would love to have Y'all come back to Abita Springs! Thank you so much for your fantastic set at the Abita Busker Festival. Big love from across the lake!
I for one would love to see busking on Royal St. again as well as folks dancing. I first got to know and love Tuba Skinny through the videos James and others shot of them playing on Royal. Most of the other bands I like from New Orleans I first saw in UA-cam videos playing on Royal St.
I'm watching this from germany and say well done Tuba Skinny for standing up for your rights to play, message to the mayor, the world is watching you!!!!!! Al the Best for u, I listen your musik so gladly.
Dear Mayor Cantrell: A few says ago, a disgrace to New Orleans played out on Royal Street. The Big Easy's own Tuba Skinny had returned to their roots busking on Royal. How lucky you are. I wish I could afford the trip from California to hear them in person and join the fun. People were dancing to the music and having a congenial good time, when a police car blared right into the middle with screaming siren. A cop raged up to the band, being unbearably aggressive and rude. Any attempt to engage in polite conversation with him he countered by shouting it down. See for yourself. Tuba Skinny confronted by N.O. Police while busking He is not a good ambassador. Why would a tourist want all that negatively? Please keep automobiles away from Royal, and keep that cop away from people. Best regards, David B. Jones
Hello Friends! Tuba Skinny is like a breath of "fresh air!" They play the BEST jazz, out there!! I don't live in N.O., but I really enjoy the music coming out of there! The police were doing there job, and what need's to change is the ordinance!! I WILL SEND AN E-MAIL TO THE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL ASKING FOR REVIEW OF THE ORDINANCE!! PLEASE EVERYONE!! SEND AN E-MAIL TO N.O. MAYOR! THANK YOU T.B.S. for such GREAT MUSIC! Gary
The ordinance states that during certain hours no traffic is allowed, only pedestrians. The ordinance is fine. It is not being enforced. That is the problem.
It's a great shame that the NO police is not aware that Tuba Skinny has given name to Royal Street and is a point of attraction of tourism that in turn pays to the city for its public service. Shame on them.
In some cities cops would have arrested people during this short encounter if they spoke back. Tuba Skinny is world famous but here in NO get damned by the po'lice forperforming a few feet off the sidewalk. I wonder if these same cops stop cars driving with loud in yo'face hip hop music blasting and shaking your windows.?
New Zealand fan of Tuba Skinny here - you folks ROCK! I mean - as if New Orleans doesn't already have enough streets for cars! Message to New Orleans authorities - people come to your city for the MUSIC, not the cars!
Dear Mayor Cantrell: From all over the world we look at you and all think "how is it that TS which is one of America's finest showcases, as well as other jazz bands are treated this way?". Please, to you who are the first guardian of your city's traditions, we ask you to implement the arrangements so that the city's musicians can continue to play on Royal Street. With all due respect.
You guys handled yourselves with both Respect "and" Backbone. Well done. We come down from Birmingham once every 2 months, and it's always ah Honor if we are able to see ya'll play 👍👍
My name is Mike Brooks and my grandpa was Anthony “Tuba Fats)Lacen. I’m just here to say that arguing with the cops isn’t gonna get you anywhere. My family has been busking in the quarter for 3 generations and I was taught by the older guys that the cops are just relaying a message. If you have an issue then you need too figure out a way to get your message straight to the city officials. Maybe it’s time for us musicians to second line to City Hall again
True Mike. The police officer is just doing the bidding of the politicians who sign his paycheck. He was firm but professional. However, he was wrong about the band obstructing traffic. You can see him and the other cars drive by unobstructed. You will see later in other videos that I will post that even large delivery trucks pass by. By the way, did you know that your grandpa is the reason the band is called Tuba Skinny?
@@tubafats100 The story is that Todd, the tuba player, was riding his bike through the Quarter with his tuba and someone yelled at him "You must be Tuba Skinny!" So this is how the band was named. This was when your grandpa was till alive.
Take the time to get everyone and do it BIG. Second line for the death of N.O. tourism. There are only two reasons for anyone to visit New Orleans. Dead history and live music.
I don't believe that even the cop thought he was doing the right thing. These musicians are doing nothing but bringing joy and happiness to it's of people. What a disgrace!
Police are only following orders of their understanding of the law. Police don't have to agree with it, they (just like the citizens) have to follow it. You're complaining to the wrong people.
Именно такая музыка, которую исполняет Tuba Skinny на пешеходной улице города, является душой Нового Орлеана, чем этот город прославился на весь мир и стал родиной джаза. Неужели власти города в лице своей полиции не способны понять это? Власти должны поддерживать и стимулировать подобное музицирование, создавать для этого лучшие условия, а не мешать инициативе музыкантов.
Hurricanes, cops. NO has become a killjoy place. Used to jive once. Just cancelled our plane tickets and hotel booking. Yeah, it was only a week, but I can tell you our little vacation was NOT to look at cars. The next thing that needs to happen is that ordinary citizens boycott the business on Royal Street until the band is asked back again.
Dear Senator Kennedy, You are the best thing to hit the government since canned beer. There is a music group that has helped to keep a New Orleans tradition alive named "Tuba Skinny". To say the least, they are exceptional musicians and represent what is best about your fine State. One specific tradition that had existed for years was that Royal Street was a pedestrian thruway but in recent years, it has been opened up to traffic. This greatly hinders the opportunity for your State's finest musicians to display their talents and make a few dollars at the same time. Would you please consider advising Mayor Cantrell to close Royal Street to vehicular traffic which would help to re-establish one of New Orleans' sacred traditions? I thank you for your time and anticipated courtesies in this matter.
I've been to New Orleans and love the music. We hardly have this kind of music in Michigan can I buy your music. Love u guys. Keep playing Rona in Michigan
Thanks for posting this, James. I have sent an email to the mayor, though what influence I, as a foreigner, may have is doubtful. I hope this gets sorted out as soon as possible, for the sake of all musicians and all music lovers.
@@stewartfenton7660 I did mention that in my email, and also how it gives free advertising for NOLA as a vacation spot, yadda, yadda, resulting in more money in the local economy.
What a day that was, so glad we got it back open. But there are efforts to stop the pedestrian mall by an angry few, thank you Councilman Freddie King for hearing us at the council meeting
Never been to NOLA. But the only reason I would go, would be to see the players on Royal Street. It's like the Cable Cars in San Francisco. Part of the city and a big attraction.
I am not familiar with the city of New Orleans; Unfortunately. So I can't have an opinion on how City Hall manages traffic. However, I am familiar with the fine street musicians of New Orleans through the Internet and Tuba Skinny is the crown jewel of them all. Therefore, I have a very strong opinion on their talent, virtuosity and the unique experience of watching them living the music and taking me on their wings with every note and every syncopation. Every single one of them. I hope the Mayor understands that these musicians serve, preserve and spread a very important, fundamental I would dare say, part of the American musical tradition. I hope that she realizes that New Orleans jazz is part of world music. It touches everybody around the globe. More inportantly, I hope that she can feel the music and appreciate the art like the rest of us around the world which apparently is not the case. What's the problem? Bar owners on Royal Street? Some other kind of pressure on the Mayor? Last but not least, if the Mayor knew how many times doctors like myself tuned in to the street musicians of New Orlens during the COVID 19 epidemic to listen to the uplifting music to have some strength restored to our souls to keep going, maybe, just maybe she might change her mind. If you ever find yourselves in Greece people, you're welcome to block my street all you want. Just keep playing. I'll pick up the tickets for obstructing traffic.
Shame on the Ingnorance of the City Administration. Neither do they value the beauty of Street Music over traffic of cars thru the streets, nor do they seem to understand what treasure they have in the city with THIS band - Tuba Skinny for ever ! We love you all over the world !
Thanks for filming here. It is very sad, that Tuba Skinny and others can't play at Royal Street anymore. I saw a plenty of videos I saw them playing there. And they sounded so great and fresh playing before the officer stopped them. But he did only his job. In my opinion a bit unfriendly in this situation. Best wishes from Germany. 👋
Big Tuba Skinny fan from Cape Town, Africa. Have written to your mayor asking that the music be allowed to prevail. Tuba Skinny - the Royals of Royal Street.
@@errolfellows409 HI my Durban brother. I stumbled upon them on UA-cam and became a big fan. I'm sure there are many more Tuba Skinny fans in South Africa.
The officer was wrong and I love how when confronted with the written law he ignores the person and just keeps repeating himself like a child that doesn’t get their way, hilarious. And beings they are public servants “they Are Supposed to enforce” such written laws not interpret them (thats the judicial systems job). And I also love how police today demand respect but give None and I noticed the other officer was just stared at them (almost like he was hoping and waiting for someone to do something “they consider” a threat. My wife’s grandfather & father were career police officers and retired with honors and was not only respected in the community but (her grandfather) was awarded for never having to resort to violence or having to pull his service revolver. He remarked that 95 outta 100 situation situation can be talked down without escalating it further. It’s a shame that today’s officers seem to almost look for situations & for them to escalate, rather than being neutral and understanding. Like they have something to prove(mind you not All of them are like that but I’ll say 3/4’s are). That’s not how you get respect. All I saw in this video was a bullies picking on every day people trying to spread a little joy in what would be a otherwise depressing and dark city scape (without them). They may have to have someone for security & or a law expert with them wen they play. Because their now marked and will probably be singled out everytime they play. A shame we have to have security to protect us from our own so called public security. Good luck tuba skinny and keep playing no matter what the bullies (political & in uniform) say. 👍👍😎
Dear Mike Smith, You couldn't have said it more succinctly, congratulations. This is a person who is used to addressing everyone all day long about anything and everything, if they are then addressed on their behavior then they have a very hard time digesting it. This behavior may have been possible 50 years ago, but it is quickly forgotten that the citizen has not stood still in his or her knowledge, and also that of the legislation. I'm surprised that they both don't get more intrusive and come so close to you that you automatically start making a defensive gesture, this intimidation technique is very well known to me. Here in Rotterdam I have seen them apply the technique from very close by, in one they had made a mistake because he was aware of the trick and stood still with his hands in his pockets. I then asked a police officer standing outside the circle, aren't your colleagues trying to provoke something? He didn't react to that, but when they left he spoke briefly with the highest in rank, who then looked in my direction, thought for a few seconds and then decided to leave. Many here are falling over the attitude of the law enforcement officer, and I think quite rightly that he doesn't care about what's written in the rules but isn't implemented, tells a lot about those at the top who are thus making the failing to comply with rules agreed upon by democracies. It is very similar to what could be heard after 1945 during the Nuremberg trial,, order is order or rather Befehl ist Befehl.
@@hirondelle8734 No, that is certainly not the case, you speak with a gut feeling, sorry. Your statement, however brief, tells more about your attitude.
And I'm just betting that your wife's Father and Grandfather didn't have to deal with people who thought they had the right to set up a band on the roadway of a city. Times change, there is far less respect for law and order now than anytime in the near past. Music is great, playing it in a proper place would be more respectful of and for everyone! I am sure the Coppers have better things to do than to tell people to move back off the road, sheech! I especially like the trombone player with an attitude deserving of a 3 year old.
@@davidnapemaskwa7251 You are ignoring a very important subject, there is no follow-up to a democratic decision, which means that the executive authority disregards democracy, which tends to move in the direction of communism, if not a dictatorship. I was of the opinion that America wants to stay far away from that. If you feel addressed, it is also your job to address everyone at all times, but prefer not to be addressed yourself. Certainly there is less and I may say much less awe and respect for the police, but you have to earn awe and respect, which you do not get when handing over your certificate. In addition, the citizen is no more the citizen of about 75 years ago, as in this example, the musician is better aware of the state of affairs than he who should know and list it, even if you just wake him or her from the deepest sleep . In that respect, both enforcers still piss and shit in a diaper and are still very far away from being 3 years old, despite or thanks to the impressive car they drive and have to use the siren at all times if necessary, what kind of adolescent behaviour. They not only disgrace themselves, but take the entire enforcement corps with them in their wake, fine colleagues, that will get you far and you can be proud of it. Now I have to mention that in my opinion some of them deserve it, we have vacationed in Florida quite often, usually in the same hotel. During breakfast and sometimes during dinner, enforcers regularly came to eat there. There is nothing wrong with that, they have every right to do so, but most of them radiated such arrogance and they looked at you as if you had just made them an indecent offer when you said good morning or evening to them at the counter. Very unfortunate if you feel so far above the common citizen. Sorry if you feel addressed, but you must have noticed that we live in a completely different time. Have a very nice day
INTERESTING A HUNDRED YEARS AGO , people complained in every city in the USA that automobiles had no right to the streets , and there was 1000's of deaths a week nation wide caused by what we call traffic accidents today
The once beautiful and creative city that was New Orleans is being destroyed by politicians that literally hate it for its unique contribution to our country . Let the musicians play!!! That's what makes it so unique!! The street performers!!!
Maybe your letters to the mayor of New Orleans helped. According to an online post by WDSU-TV the police department has announced street closures to re-create the pedestrian mall. Royal Street will be closed to automobile traffic between Bienville Street and Orleans Street 11am-4pm weekdays and 11am-7pm weekends. Businesses are being notified. Is that the area in question? I've only been to New Orleans once.
If this is permanent and not just for French Quarter Festival next week, then yes it is a victory. I read the article and there is no mention of it being temporary.
I know how you guys feel ... Here in Australia if I ever get lost in the desert I will just start busking and I can assure you someone will come along in no time telling me I can't do that there.
I was a Mayor for a long time (not in New Orleans though I knew a Mayor there). When police do something like that it is almost always because of a complaint. They don't care about the issue one way or another, it's just get the complaint settled and move to the next one. The siren leading up to the video a firms it was responding to a complaint. Probably a merchant along the street thinks his/her business is hurt. I used to have businesses complaining when there was a street fair or festival. It will needs lots of discussion with in City Hall but can be corrected.
Sadly the Police are in the middle of this and were trying to do the right thing. It should be the elected officials out there explaining their policy.
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
A city ordinance has been in effect since 1971 designating Royal St. as a pedestrian mall closed to traffic during certain hours. Bands have traditionally used this time for busking. After the Hard Rock Hotel collapse in 2019 traffic was rerouted to Royal Street 24 hours a day. The hotel has been demolished yet for some reason the city did not return Royal St. to a pedestrian mall per the 1971 ordinance (Sec. 154-608, Vieux Carre' Malls). Several bands decided to play on Royal this day in protest.
Tuba Skinny was set up in a no parking space and traffic continued interrupted while they played (Royal is a 1 way street). You will see this in my other videos and at the end of this video when traffic passes after the policeman drives off.
A month after this video was released the city relented and allowed the bands to return.
Bien triste 😥 😥
And What about FQF ??
@@lioneldarde1851I don't know if the FQF has any stages set up on Royal, so it wouldn't surprise me if they keep traffic on Royal. They are ignoring their own city ordinance.
It's a shame they are harassing the bands like that.
My 5 years there in the late 70's early 80's were the best.
Bands on Royal and other streets were the heart and soul of that city.
They have been playing there even before they paved some of the streets.
Hope my two cents worth burned a few ears at city hall.
Thank you, James.
理由なく制限されることに抗議する勇気に賛同します。ハードロックホテルの記事を読みました。同じく建設業にたずさわる者として残念です。ニューオーリンズらしい街へ復活して欲しい。警察官だって本当は取り締まるより、音楽を楽しみたいだろうに。
No one comes to New Orleans to see the traffic. They come for the music.
🎯
I'm in Australia and have been following Tuba Skinny for quite some time. Much of this time they have been on Royal Street without any problems arising from that. Leave well enough alone as they are an integral part of the New Orleans tourism industry.
Their music brings joy to many far and wide. God Bless Tuba Skinny.
When I was a tourist in New Orleans I saw all sorts of poor behaviour in the streets, mainly due to alcohol abuse. I'm sure the police would be better dealing with this than hassling harmless musicians. Without its unique style of music New Orleans would be unknown to tourists. Regards from Australia.
@@michaelhalsall5684 Well said Michael.
@@michaelhalsall5684 speaking from Melbourne Australia. Here here Just get the road closed. ( for everyone’s safety. ). I just read the full 154 Code. Keep going Tuba Skinny. I’d love to see the Video the washboard player did on his phone. ( just sayin ! )
The elephant in the room is race. Whites are being attacked and marginalized across America. This officer has no logical reason to be doing this. Chilling.
Music givesblife to the city. Let the mayor put down his feet on these arrogant police. Put out a resolution first. Then the city DIES. REGRETS LATER.
I'm watching this from Ireland and say well done Tuba Skinny for standing up for your rights to play, message to the mayor, the world is watching you, get your act together and make this pedestrian again
Love the buskers in Dublin such as alli Sherlock .
also Rosey Byrne and Emmeline Gracie
@@mmg9675 love Rosie and Cuan and Sabah and many more.wish I could go to Grafton Street 🙂
It's not the officer's fault.
@@stepaushiCouldn't the police fail to notice by taking a different route.? Looking for a fight methinks, or bored.
From Canada: Firstly I am shocked by the rudeness and arrogance of the police. Siren blazing, no tact, no willingness to listen or resolve the issue. Bad publicity for visiting the U.S ..and there's Tuba Skinny, ambassadors for a trip to the States. Like many people overseas, my dream is to visit N.O just to experience them playing on the street . A daily dose of Tuba Skinny got me through out long cold lock- downs in Canada. ( Had me dancing in the kitchen)
The city needs needs a golden plaque in recognition of their extraordinary musicianship. The city should PAY them for the tourist publicity it gives to New Orleans not limit them.
THANK YOU ❤️❤️❤️ Tuba Skinny. You are fantastic!
Listen for real , stay the fuck out of America , take it from someone stuck inside , this is a very dangerous place , and a very bad place , it is ruled by wicked elite rich ancient creatures . No one should come here especially right now , things are getting worse by the day here , mass shootings everywhere , good people getting put into cages for defending themselves . Stay where you are you are much safer there . Nothing to see here !
I thought he was pretty polite, considering the impossible job he’d been given. Who were the brain dead who elected the mayor?
B.C. Here. 👍👍
Germany agrees 👍👍👍
Less cars, more music. Hooray for these talented musicians
A friend that plays music.... is a friend INDEED.... KEEP THE CARS OUT ..... KEEP THE JOY OF MUSIC.... ESPECIALLY IN THESE DIFFICULT MOMENTS.....
The next NO Mayor prospect who runs on the above comment as their primary campaign slogan will get elected in a landslide.
There should be a law that there has to be a band like this in every street corner.
I bet we be a lot happier.
Loved you guys. Play on. 🏴👌
EVery time I see videos of music flash mobs, I think the same thing. How much happier the world would be if music randomly popped up everywhere.
Would that law compel musicians to play on the corners if there weren't enough volunteers?
I wish every city and town had music playing. It might soothe the souls of the savage beasts we put up with now.
There's the episode of South Park with the peruvian panflute bands though... do you really want that?
@@LibbyRal Até eu Edmilson Donizete Botéquio, aqui no Brasil sempre assisto as apresentações do Tuba e programo com a família uma viagem para New Orleans, muito motivado a conhecer o pessoal do magnifico Tuba Skiny
This is an issue that the city needs to address. This music is the heart of the city and these musicians need to be encouraged.
At LEAST they should be encouraging artists. Maybe even making public spaces available for them to perform in that are desIgnated as appropriate and legal spaces. The police harassment looks really bad.
Nashville ended their ban...they found out busking is a big tourist attraction.
Agree 100%. What is N.O. without this music?
Control of its people has become much more satisfying, to the "leaders," than culture in New Orleans & other great cities.
Thankfully, we are coming out of the pandemic. Between booster vaccines and better therapies death rates are dropping. The issue WAS a valid issue in that you don't want to encourage crowds of people to congregate.
Tourists and locals alike love New Orleans because of the vibrant music scene out in the streets. Nobody goes to the City to see more CARS!
Tuba Skinny is an INSTITUTION, man.
Very well said
So well-put and to paraphrase: `Nobody ever goes to New Orleans to see more CARS!'
You've already demonstrated your courage and dedication. Nothing that ensues from this will diminish that in any way. I have written to the Mayor; you are the best thing that has happened to New Orleans since Louis Armstrong.
Damn straight!
I'm going to have to slightly modify that post, written in the heat of passion. Let's not forget the Nevilles, Fats, Allen Toussaint, and a myriad of others. No disrespect to them.😊
Yeah! that's Right!
@@terrulian No, you were right the first time. Best thing since Louis Armstrong.
Don't think so.
Well done Tuba Skinny - from England!!
Such a beautiful performance. The city is absolutely crazy to prohibit busking on Royal street, it's what gives this city a reason to exist.
That it true. On the other hand, people should not be taking their anger out on the one who is tasked with enforcing the rules.
@@stepaushi what rule?
@@StephenLipps In this case, the people were blocking traffic. It's not the police officer's fault to be tasked with enforcing it.
@@stepaushi Royal in the central quarter is supposed to be closed to vehicular traffic M-F between 11 a.m. and 4 p.m., and on Saturdays and Sundays between 11 a.m. and 7 p.m. This has been the case since the early 1970s. You're right that they don't enforce it.
@@StephenLipps It's weird that the police would not know that, though. Either it's legally closed to vehicles or it's not. Do you think this is legally documented somewhere? I def think Royal should be free of cars, but I also think police should not be denigrated for doing their job it it is indeed not declared vehicle-free.
How lovely to live in a city with so little crime that the police have time to argue with street musicians...
Well yeah they joined the force so they could wear a gun and bully people who don't wear one, not protect or serve...going after murderers is scary, and "not what they signed up for"
Music like this is the lifeblood of New Orleans,a one way street only requires one lane for traffic.
Tuba Skinny: a City’s treasure, a State treasure, a National treasure. To be treated like this by city police is disgraceful.
Officer couldn’t wait until they finished the tune before engaging the siren !? I sincerely hope some retraining is in order.
I don’t know the local laws but I do know the local police made fools of themselves on this occasion. Truly incredible.
Making fools of themselves .. that's not new 😏.
But their to scared to go after a shooter shooting up elementary kids even when they out number him 100 plus to one.
Cops. What can you say?
@@UserGuy-g4l I say let's change something. There's no reason why a maleficent force such as the police should go on unchecked for so long in the land of democracy. We the people who do nothing to stop it are to blame
Right. Maleficient nails it!
The Mayor would do well to treasure the musicians who continue to export their talent to the whole world. In addition to e mailing the Mayor, supporting the correct application of the law, the freedom of expression to perform like this is a matter to be closely guarded. Greetings from Derby, England.
This mayor hates musicians
I am sorry to tell you that there is not much 'freedom of expression' in Derby. Prospective buskers have to pass an audition by the Council to get a licence.
He needs to stand down, be removed!
As a Tuba Skinny fan from New Zealand I wish you every good thing. I think you have become the victims of a local grinch.
One of my dreams is going to New Orleans to see Tuba Skinny. For sure they have cultural and economic value for the city! Respect from Japan!
Well that’s a clever move by the Mayor……destroy the very thing that visitors and tourists visit New Orleans for in the first place. Live Jazz! I bet the local traders, shop keepers, food vendors and small businesses appreciate her shortsightedness! Keep playing TS. Love from U.K.!
I never wanted to go to New Orleans until I discovered Tuba Skinny, and it is on the street where I would love to see them perform, preferably outside a pub.
Hey, the problem is that the Mayor isn't getting his cut. Corrupt bastards!
I would suggest everyone inundate city hall with e-mails, letters, phone calls, etc. Never put dumbasses (the administration in this case?) in the seat of power. They don't follow their own rules and regulations. I hope people like Tuba Skinny and others continue to exercise their freedom and hold them to their own rules. I don't blame this officer, he seemed to handle this situation the best he could. God bless.👍👊🏼🇺🇸
It is what the government wants to destroy what makes America great HOLD your ground change the mayor
There's nothing short-sighted about the World Economic Forum, which the mayor of New Orleans belongs to.
It is hard to believe that the Mayor would hassle the very band that puts New Orleans back on the map again. Tuba Skinny needs to be encouraged. They are incredible musicians with the most endearing music style and rhythm. TS got it all. Much love from Ireland.
Just wrote the Mayor on behalf of TS, common sense, and the American Way!
Thank you all for your beautiful music
From the UK , and I can say that I am a proud Tuba Skinnyhead! You give so much joy and pleasure. More power to your elbow.
I just sent my email to the mayor! Keep playing! Love that NOLA traditional jazz and especially Tuba Skinny!
Hi Jerry What's the Email Address ?
I am French and I live near Paris. I discovered the video with the French Quarter police (!) and it's incredible.
I've been following you from France on UA-cam for a long time (I'm a trombone player) and you are partly the soul of this city.
April 26th is a good day, it's my birthday !
Keep playing in the street, it's a pleasure to listen to you. Don't give up!
Thank you for this James. I've added my two penny worth from Spain to the mayor.
I love to watch the band play in the street and to see all the happy people taking in the atmosphere created by the talent in the band i hope this gets resolved positively quickly the city of New Orleans cannot lose such a beautiful thing best wishes from Australia
What makes New Orleans different than other cities? Bands like Tuba Skinny playing on the street. It's what makes New Orleans special and memorable and cool. Hope the band and other bands get to play where they'd like to play rather than being told by the powers that be that it's not acceptable.
the cops didn't chase them away. they just asked them to move to the sidewalk and that's it
6:29 "You're the one who's blocking traffic, sir." He does have a point there.
He was!
Dear Mayor Cantrell,
I was very disappointed to see James Sterling’s recent video of Tuba Skinny being told they could not play in their usual place on Royal Street. It is no exaggeration to say that the beautiful atmosphere which comes through in the videos of them playing in this location have persuaded my wife and me to visit the city (from England) next year. New Orleans has something extremely precious in these performances, something which other cities would dearly love to have, and which deserves to be protected and nurtured. It would be truly tragic if an overly strict (and, it is said, incorrect) interpretation of the law were allowed to stifle such a unique and beautiful thing.
With Best Regards, Derek Ryden, Stroud England.
I hope this is what you sent to the mayor. 🤔 Doubt she wathes youtube much less reads the comments. Kudos to you if you did.
@@joeheid4757 I did!
I've always loved you British for your wit, charm and keen intelligence. Wish I could've said what you did.
I just said, "I'm not visiting NO if you shut down the mall to pedestrians." Tuba Skinny is New Orleans Heritage Jazz.
Well said I couldn't have said it better myself
Great words
I was in New Orleans in May of 2019. We were there a week and traveled around the area to see sights. This is a unique place such as I have never seen. I never felt really safe while there, although nothing bad ever happened. Heard lots of good music and ate lots of good food, but never saw Tuba Skinny because I had not heard of them at the time. I will go out of my way to see them in person if I am ever in the area again.Good luck guys and gals. You are the best !
Dear Mayor Cantrell: International fans of Tuba Skinny as well as the many worthy buskers that make New Orleans such a special city to visit (and watch on You-tube) plead with you to do the right thing for your city - bring busking back to Royal Street. Remember also that New Orleans is the jazz capital of the world: are you not dishonouring its well-earned heritage?
Make it official letter to major office and I belive thousands of people would back it up
@@RM-je5qw But isn't that what busking is?
@@RM-je5qw the city passed an ordinance in the last century to close down parts of Royal Street and allow pedestrian traffic. What the musicians are asking is for that to be enforced. When musicians busk on the sidewalk, then pedestrians are forced into the street. No one wins.
@@RM-je5qw Stand corrected. The city has an ordinance allowing for parts of that street to be a pedestrian mall at certain times. This is what the musicians are requesting. When it was enforced, emergency vehicles knew to reroute accordingly. Bourbon Street becomes a pedestrian walk every night and they all manage just fine
@@RM-je5qw seria maravilhoso. Se criem mais calçadões e menos carros
Brisbane Australia here. Have loved Tuba Skinny for many years. Saw them live when they were here, some years back. Wouldlove to see them continue in their home country. Pretty horrible to see the Police behave like that.
I love how the Trombone player pulls out the ORDINANCE CODE from his pocket!!👍 And the COP plain out ignores what was said!!. And while there was plenty of room for them to drive by.... haha soo sad...
What a bummer. We would love to have Y'all come back to Abita Springs! Thank you so much for your fantastic set at the Abita Busker Festival. Big love from across the lake!
I for one would love to see busking on Royal St. again as well as folks dancing. I first got to know and love Tuba Skinny through the videos James and others shot of them playing on Royal. Most of the other bands I like from New Orleans I first saw in UA-cam videos playing on Royal St.
New Orleans is nothing without these street musicians, they are the essence of the culture of this great city! Guess it's time for a new mayor.
I'm watching this from germany and say well done Tuba Skinny for standing up for your rights to play, message to the mayor, the world is watching you!!!!!! Al the Best for u, I listen your musik so gladly.
Dear Mayor Cantrell:
A few says ago, a disgrace to New Orleans played out on Royal Street. The Big Easy's own Tuba Skinny had returned to their roots busking on Royal. How lucky you are. I wish I could afford the trip from California to hear them in person and join the fun.
People were dancing to the music and having a congenial good time, when a police car blared right into the middle with screaming siren. A cop raged up to the band, being unbearably aggressive and rude. Any attempt to engage in polite conversation with him he countered by shouting it down.
See for yourself. Tuba Skinny confronted by N.O. Police while busking
He is not a good ambassador. Why would a tourist want all that negatively?
Please keep automobiles away from Royal, and keep that cop away from people.
Best regards,
David B. Jones
Hello Friends!
Tuba Skinny is like a breath of "fresh air!" They play the BEST jazz, out there!!
I don't live in N.O., but I really enjoy the music coming out of there!
The police were doing there job, and what need's to change is the ordinance!!
I WILL SEND AN E-MAIL TO THE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL ASKING FOR REVIEW OF THE ORDINANCE!!
PLEASE EVERYONE!! SEND AN E-MAIL TO N.O. MAYOR!
THANK YOU T.B.S. for such GREAT MUSIC!
Gary
The ordinance states that during certain hours no traffic is allowed, only pedestrians. The ordinance is fine. It is not being enforced. That is the problem.
Brava & Bravo to the performers. Long live the spirit of NOLA!!!
It's a great shame that the NO police is not aware that Tuba Skinny has given name to Royal Street and is a point of attraction of tourism that in turn pays to the city for its public service. Shame on them.
This treatment of Tuba Skinny is like the NYPD telling Lady Liberty to get out of the harbor; she's blocking cargo ships.
That is a great analogy.
Brilliant...
"You're blocking the traffic" - What traffic? In all their videos, has anybody ever seen a vehicle obstructed by this band?
I am living in France. Last month there was a petition to close Roal Str. again for traffic. I hope it helps.
In some cities cops would have arrested people during this short encounter if they spoke back.
Tuba Skinny is world famous but here in NO get damned by the po'lice forperforming a few feet off the sidewalk.
I wonder if these same cops stop cars driving with loud in yo'face hip hop music blasting and shaking your windows.?
Most likely they do not.
Merci pour la qualité et la diversité du répertoire ainsi que la qualité des interprétations BRAVO !
Well done from Australia for standing your ground. It would be better for the police to focus on far more pressing issues in N.O. This is nonsense!
New Zealand fan of Tuba Skinny here - you folks ROCK!
I mean - as if New Orleans doesn't already have enough streets for cars!
Message to New Orleans authorities - people come to your city for the MUSIC, not the cars!
Dear Mayor Cantrell:
From all over the world we look at you and all think "how is it that TS which is one of America's finest showcases, as well as other jazz bands are treated this way?". Please, to you who are the first guardian of your city's traditions, we ask you to implement the arrangements so that the city's musicians can continue to play on Royal Street.
With all due respect.
You guys handled yourselves with both Respect "and" Backbone. Well done. We come down from Birmingham once every 2 months, and it's always ah Honor if we are able to see ya'll play 👍👍
My name is Mike Brooks and my grandpa was Anthony “Tuba Fats)Lacen. I’m just here to say that arguing with the cops isn’t gonna get you anywhere. My family has been busking in the quarter for 3 generations and I was taught by the older guys that the cops are just relaying a message. If you have an issue then you need too figure out a way to get your message straight to the city officials. Maybe it’s time for us musicians to second line to City Hall again
True Mike. The police officer is just doing the bidding of the politicians who sign his paycheck. He was firm but professional. However, he was wrong about the band obstructing traffic. You can see him and the other cars drive by unobstructed. You will see later in other videos that I will post that even large delivery trucks pass by. By the way, did you know that your grandpa is the reason the band is called Tuba Skinny?
@@JamesSterling yea I kinda figured that their name was a play on Tuba Fats.
@@tubafats100 The story is that Todd, the tuba player, was riding his bike through the Quarter with his tuba and someone yelled at him "You must be Tuba Skinny!" So this is how the band was named. This was when your grandpa was till alive.
Take the time to get everyone and do it BIG. Second line for the death of N.O. tourism. There are only two reasons for anyone to visit New Orleans. Dead history and live music.
Vote her out.
I don't believe that even the cop thought he was doing the right thing. These musicians are doing nothing but bringing joy and happiness to it's of people. What a disgrace!
it's sad to see that the police of new orleans are wasting their precious time preventing the music of Tuba Skinny
Hey Yall leave Tuba Skinny alone 😔 🤪
Police are only following orders of their understanding of the law. Police don't have to agree with it, they (just like the citizens) have to follow it. You're complaining to the wrong people.
@@philcremer4709 Police should focus on the real issues!
@@philcremer4709 Exactly.
I'ts more safe than trying to catch a criminal?
Plod could at the very least have waited a moment to allow the number to be played out.
Именно такая музыка, которую исполняет Tuba Skinny на пешеходной улице города, является душой Нового Орлеана, чем этот город прославился на весь мир и стал родиной джаза. Неужели власти города в лице своей полиции не способны понять это? Власти должны поддерживать и стимулировать подобное музицирование, создавать для этого лучшие условия, а не мешать инициативе музыкантов.
Envolve política local amigo
Hurricanes, cops. NO has become a killjoy place. Used to jive once. Just cancelled our plane tickets and hotel booking. Yeah, it was only a week, but I can tell you our little vacation was NOT to look at cars. The next thing that needs to happen is that ordinary citizens boycott the business on Royal Street until the band is asked back again.
Dear Senator Kennedy, You are the best thing to hit the government since canned beer. There is a music group that has helped to keep a New Orleans tradition alive named "Tuba Skinny". To say the least, they are exceptional musicians and represent what is best about your fine State. One specific tradition that had existed for years was that Royal Street was a pedestrian thruway but in recent years, it has been opened up to traffic. This greatly hinders the opportunity for your State's finest musicians to display their talents and make a few dollars at the same time. Would you please consider advising Mayor Cantrell to close Royal Street to vehicular traffic which would help to re-establish one of New Orleans' sacred traditions? I thank you for your time and anticipated courtesies in this matter.
Must be a different Kennedy than I have heard of!!!!!!!!
That cop is missing out on busting a car-jacker....
Tuba skinny You are what New Orleans is all about . Good old jazz and God knows this day and age .We need something good . I love to listen to you ❤️
I've been to New Orleans and love the music. We hardly have this kind of music in Michigan can I buy your music. Love u guys. Keep playing Rona in Michigan
Thanks for posting this, James. I have sent an email to the mayor, though what influence I, as a foreigner, may have is doubtful. I hope this gets sorted out as soon as possible, for the sake of all musicians and all music lovers.
It matters that the mayor knows how much New Orleans means to the whole world for its music, and will do after she is gone.
@@stewartfenton7660 I did mention that in my email, and also how it gives free advertising for NOLA as a vacation spot, yadda, yadda, resulting in more money in the local economy.
Thank you 🙏 sir!
I’m in the UK and if I were to visit New Orleans it would be for the sole reason of hoping to catch you guys play excellent music in the street 👏👏👏👏
What a day that was, so glad we got it back open. But there are efforts to stop the pedestrian mall by an angry few, thank you Councilman Freddie King for hearing us at the council meeting
Never been to NOLA. But the only reason I would go, would be to see the players on Royal Street. It's like the Cable Cars in San Francisco. Part of the city and a big attraction.
Everyone knows their rights, no one knows their duty!
One the most enjoyable you tubers that I watch. Keep the music going
HOLD YOUR GROUND! We are with you.
The original traffic Jam Session!!!!! Keep on swinging!🥳🎶
I am not familiar with the city of New Orleans; Unfortunately. So I can't have an opinion on how City Hall manages traffic.
However, I am familiar with the fine street musicians of New Orleans through the Internet and Tuba Skinny is the crown jewel of them all.
Therefore, I have a very strong opinion on their talent, virtuosity and the unique experience of watching them living the music and taking me on their wings with every note and every syncopation. Every single one of them.
I hope the Mayor understands that these musicians serve, preserve and spread a very important, fundamental I would dare say, part of the American musical tradition. I hope that she realizes that New Orleans jazz is part of world music. It touches everybody around the globe.
More inportantly, I hope that she can feel the music and appreciate the art like the rest of us around the world which apparently is not the case.
What's the problem? Bar owners on Royal Street? Some other kind of pressure on the Mayor?
Last but not least, if the Mayor knew how many times doctors like myself tuned in to the street musicians of New Orlens during the COVID 19 epidemic to listen to the uplifting music to have some strength restored to our souls to keep going, maybe, just maybe she might change her mind.
If you ever find yourselves in Greece people, you're welcome to block my street all you want. Just keep playing. I'll pick up the tickets for obstructing traffic.
Not the first time I see this. Just watched the same scenario in Dortmund Germany. They are going to ban music!
Globalists trying to assert power for the sake of power.
Public pressure pretty much always works , properly applied. Seems like you have to embarrass the powers that be into doin the right thing.
I Love that Robin tried to pay the dude off 😂!
Shame on the Ingnorance of the City Administration. Neither do they value the beauty of Street Music over traffic of cars thru the streets, nor do they seem to understand what treasure they have in the city with THIS band - Tuba Skinny for ever ! We love you all over the world !
Omigosh, there's music in the French Quarter! I'm glad they nipped that in the bud, toot sweet!
Thanks for filming here. It is very sad, that Tuba Skinny and others can't play at Royal Street anymore. I saw a plenty of videos I saw them playing there.
And they sounded so great and fresh playing before the officer stopped them.
But he did only his job. In my opinion a bit unfriendly in this situation.
Best wishes from Germany. 👋
Locking the street with no traffic on it. SMH
Big Tuba Skinny fan from Cape Town, Africa. Have written to your mayor asking that the music be allowed to prevail. Tuba Skinny - the Royals of Royal Street.
Hellooo, Patrick! Glad to find another TUBA SKINNY fan from South Africa! I'm in Durban.
@@errolfellows409 HI my Durban brother. I stumbled upon them on UA-cam and became a big fan. I'm sure there are many more Tuba Skinny fans in South Africa.
@@patrickmanthey5864 Yep, ditto for the UA-cam discovery. There is some wonderful music on YT!
New Orleans needs a new Mayor !
Don't they realize New Orleans would be nothing without street music?
Tuba Skinny is the soundtrack of "Life" . This is no different then telling New Orleans that you can no longer drink Beer or listen to Music.
To hell with cars. They have ruled us for too long. The streets are for everyone including bands not just cars. Fight back.
This vid hurts my soul, greetings from the netherlands.
The World is watching you Mayor.
This is the dumbest thing I've ever heard. My next visit to NO was to see TS. I can see a street full of traffic anywhere.
In Portland Oregon the restaurants have seating for customers out in the street where cars would usually park. So far, no diners have been run over.
The officer was wrong and I love how when confronted with the written law he ignores the person and just keeps repeating himself like a child that doesn’t get their way, hilarious. And beings they are public servants “they Are Supposed to enforce” such written laws not interpret them (thats the judicial systems job). And I also love how police today demand respect but give None and I noticed the other officer was just stared at them (almost like he was hoping and waiting for someone to do something “they consider” a threat. My wife’s grandfather & father were career police officers and retired with honors and was not only respected in the community but (her grandfather) was awarded for never having to resort to violence or having to pull his service revolver. He remarked that 95 outta 100 situation situation can be talked down without escalating it further. It’s a shame that today’s officers seem to almost look for situations & for them to escalate, rather than being neutral and understanding. Like they have something to prove(mind you not All of them are like that but I’ll say 3/4’s are). That’s not how you get respect. All I saw in this video was a bullies picking on every day people trying to spread a little joy in what would be a otherwise depressing and dark city scape (without them). They may have to have someone for security & or a law expert with them wen they play. Because their now marked and will probably be singled out everytime they play. A shame we have to have security to protect us from our own so called public security. Good luck tuba skinny and keep playing no matter what the bullies (political & in uniform) say. 👍👍😎
Dear Mike Smith,
You couldn't have said it more succinctly, congratulations.
This is a person who is used to addressing everyone all day long about anything and everything, if they are then addressed on their behavior then they have a very hard time digesting it.
This behavior may have been possible 50 years ago, but it is quickly forgotten that the citizen has not stood still in his or her knowledge, and also that of the legislation.
I'm surprised that they both don't get more intrusive and come so close to you that you automatically start making a defensive gesture, this intimidation technique is very well known to me.
Here in Rotterdam I have seen them apply the technique from very close by, in one they had made a mistake because he was aware of the trick and stood still with his hands in his pockets.
I then asked a police officer standing outside the circle, aren't your colleagues trying to provoke something?
He didn't react to that, but when they left he spoke briefly with the highest in rank, who then looked in my direction, thought for a few seconds and then decided to leave.
Many here are falling over the attitude of the law enforcement officer, and I think quite rightly that he doesn't care about what's written in the rules but isn't implemented, tells a lot about those at the top who are thus making the failing to comply with rules agreed upon by democracies.
It is very similar to what could be heard after 1945 during the Nuremberg trial,, order is order or rather Befehl ist Befehl.
@@hirondelle8734 No, that is certainly not the case, you speak with a gut feeling, sorry.
Your statement, however brief, tells more about your attitude.
And I'm just betting that your wife's Father and Grandfather didn't have to deal with people who thought they had the right to set up a band on the roadway of a city. Times change, there is far less respect for law and order now than anytime in the near past. Music is great, playing it in a proper place would be more respectful of and for everyone! I am sure the Coppers have better things to do than to tell people to move back off the road, sheech! I especially like the trombone player with an attitude deserving of a 3 year old.
@@davidnapemaskwa7251 You are ignoring a very important subject, there is no follow-up to a democratic decision, which means that the executive authority disregards democracy, which tends to move in the direction of communism, if not a dictatorship.
I was of the opinion that America wants to stay far away from that.
If you feel addressed, it is also your job to address everyone at all times, but prefer not to be addressed yourself.
Certainly there is less and I may say much less awe and respect for the police, but you have to earn awe and respect, which you do not get when handing over your certificate.
In addition, the citizen is no more the citizen of about 75 years ago, as in this example, the musician is better aware of the state of affairs than he who should know and list it, even if you just wake him or her from the deepest sleep .
In that respect, both enforcers still piss and shit in a diaper and are still very far away from being 3 years old, despite or thanks to the impressive car they drive and have to use the siren at all times if necessary, what kind of adolescent behaviour.
They not only disgrace themselves, but take the entire enforcement corps with them in their wake, fine colleagues, that will get you far and you can be proud of it.
Now I have to mention that in my opinion some of them deserve it, we have vacationed in Florida quite often, usually in the same hotel. During breakfast and sometimes during dinner, enforcers regularly came to eat there. There is nothing wrong with that, they have every right to do so, but most of them radiated such arrogance and they looked at you as if you had just made them an indecent offer when you said good morning or evening to them at the counter.
Very unfortunate if you feel so far above the common citizen.
Sorry if you feel addressed, but you must have noticed that we live in a completely different time.
Have a very nice day
@@davidnapemaskwa7251 cops should be defunded, completely...and nimbly laws are for controlling little loosers.
INTERESTING A HUNDRED YEARS AGO , people complained in every city in the USA that automobiles had no right to the streets , and there was 1000's of deaths a week nation wide caused by what we call traffic accidents today
The once beautiful and creative city that was New Orleans is being destroyed by politicians that literally hate it for its unique contribution to our country . Let the musicians play!!! That's what makes it so unique!! The street performers!!!
Maybe your letters to the mayor of New Orleans helped. According to an online post by WDSU-TV the police department has announced street closures to re-create the pedestrian mall. Royal Street will be closed to automobile traffic between Bienville Street and Orleans Street 11am-4pm weekdays and 11am-7pm weekends. Businesses are being notified. Is that the area in question? I've only been to New Orleans once.
If this is permanent and not just for French Quarter Festival next week, then yes it is a victory. I read the article and there is no mention of it being temporary.
I know how you guys feel ... Here in Australia if I ever get lost in the desert I will just start busking and I can assure you someone will come along in no time telling me I can't do that there.
MarksMusic : CHUCKLES! CHORTLES! GUFFUCKINGFAWS!!
When the police car turned up, the siren was actually in time, and tune with the band
I was a Mayor for a long time (not in New Orleans though I knew a Mayor there). When police do something like that it is almost always because of a complaint. They don't care about the issue one way or another, it's just get the complaint settled and move to the next one. The siren leading up to the video a firms it was responding to a complaint. Probably a merchant along the street thinks his/her business is hurt. I used to have businesses complaining when there was a street fair or festival. It will needs lots of discussion with in City Hall but can be corrected.
Ah. No need to plan a trip to New Orleans now. Thanks for posting.
Normalement la musique adoucit les mœurs, mais pour la police . La musique qu'il préfère c'est celle de leur sirène. Que c'est triste.
Such a beautiful spring garland of flowers; and of course the music: tight, the word that comes to mind.
...this too will pass; keep playing.
Cheers!
Btw you guys are awesome love your music very inspirational sooths the soul , thank you much for that . ❤️🤘
Amazing artists doing that very thing that made this city famous
This type of behavior must be protected. Leave these good folks alone..
It never really has been a free country. That's just something we try to pretend when condemning other countries.
Sadly the Police are in the middle of this and were trying to do the right thing. It should be the elected officials out there explaining their policy.
When that siren fired up I thought that Tuba Skinny was doing an homage to Fats Waller's "The joint is jumpin'!"