Microsoft is Ruining Minecraft (but not really)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 14 чер 2024
- In today's video we're taking a look at what Microsoft has been doing to not just Minecraft, but Java, Bedrock, and Mojang. Everyone is talking about 1.19.1 but we'll be going over pretty much everything. From the Microsoft Account Migration to the Marketplace and Minecoins, I hope you enjoyed the video!
I don't think this is the best video I've ever uploaded, but I wanted to experiment with getting a video out in a timely manner, as well as practice on my editing skills and trying out a lot of different things, my main issues with it is I don't think I discussed my opinions properly on the matter, and may come off as dismissive of Java player's concerns.
=CHAPTERS=
0:00 - Introduction
1:40 - The Purchase
3:38 - Adminium
5:40 - Possible Warning Signs
8:13 - MC Community Anytime [X] Happens
10:20 - Why Microsoft is Doing This
=SOCIALS=
Discord Server: / discord
Patreon: / randomsageless
Twitter: / randomsageless
Reddit: / randomsageless
=CREDITS=
Minecraft is developed by Mojang Studios, and owned by the Microsoft Corporation.
In-Game Acting: [Preferred Name]
Anonymus001
BarnacleBoy
Lazzick
Lucasia
Praxibetl
R00kieMaster
Ravennn
RoboticAuthor
Whitebeartigtig
Video & Image: [Owner, "Title" - Link]
u/OmarBs, "Bountiful Update Logo" - / this_title_i_made_for_...
u/HenryFrenchFries, "Version Timeline" - / seeing_as_a_lot_of_red...
u/Julian-Wolfskin-, "Simplified Mojang Logo" - / i_tried_to_create_a_ne...
Music & Sound: [Artist, "Title," Album - Link]
C418, "Surface Pension," One - c418.bandcamp.com/track/surfa...
C418, "The First Million," One - c418.bandcamp.com/track/the-f...
C418, "Certitudes," One - c418.bandcamp.com/track/certi...
C418, "Preliminary Art form," One - c418.bandcamp.com/track/preli...
C418, "Lawyer Cage Fight," One - c418.bandcamp.com/track/lawye...
C418, "Total Drag," One - c418.bandcamp.com/track/total...
If you own anything used in this video, and have issues with it's usage, please contact me through the email found in my channel's "About" page. - Ігри
Hey guys, I know I say this literally every time but I'm not super proud of the script for this video, I think I could have explained some of my points later on a bit better and ended it a bit more properly, but the main purpose behind getting this video was editing experience and practicing with getting videos out in a timely matter. I'm super excited for next episode!
Remember to like and subscribe and all that stuff, also join my Discord: discord.gg/EtvkZwVJ8U
If you'd like to support me on Patreon and get cool perks, you can check it out here: www.patreon.com/randomsageless
Bro your script was perfect don’t be hard on your self we aren’t perfect and neither are you.
Your script was fantastic Sageless!
While it's good to look towards improving your future scripts, it's important to not be self deprecating, stay positive
You video sounds pretty well just uss those what-ifs on the next one, I've watched a video of yours regarding 1.19.1 and like how you make your videos
@@Appitea thank you
unfortunately as much as i won't to say mojang isn't at fault, they still have control over their game and they aren't being forced to do this and they also want to do it themselfs
As a parent I find these changes awful.
me too (note: i'm a bedrock minecrafter here, and i seriously hated this chat reporting system so much)
"Think about the children" harms the adults instead
They’ll find that out when their kids are banned.
I’m sure the children hate the changes too, even though it’s supposed to be “helping them”
i just laughed as hard as i have this week
"Instead of bringing your outrage to the artist, bring it to the businessman."
Holy heck, what a line.
True but lets be real I feel like 9 times out of 10 that an artist says that they have just done a crappy piece of work and are trying to deflect blame
Except the artists agree with all of it
@@flysoup3607 The artists are contractually obligated to agree with it. Do you not understand how businesses work? If you don't agree you get fired, and that means they would be stripped of their ability to work on their own creation.
death to microsoft
@lightswitch1483 Exactly. How fucking dare they prioritize their and their family's financial safety in a rough industry in a fucked up economy. Absolutely despicable.
Honestly I fell really bad for Agnes she seems like a really nice and happy person that’s been withered down to sadness from all of the stress
@@andreseduardoclavasquinreg1199 she honestly looks like she hasnt slept for countless nights, i feel bad for her
death to microsoft
Like she's about to cry. It's fucked up
U ain't wrong tbh. Compared to how she seemed in minecon 2019, it seems working at Mojang is very deppressing
Princess Agnes
Minecraft has been making series’s on their UA-cam channel, and recently the last episode of their “Secrets of Minecraft” series, however there’s some stuff in the video that people have pointed out to be a bit suspicious. At the beginning of the video, a character named Jonathan is shown showing a feature that will “change Minecraft forever”. Afterwards, one of the two hosts of the show, who in the previous episode was shown the “future of Minecraft”, is trying to say what the feature is, and eventually reveals that they’re adding “Mobbo” to the game, who was a character that was originally shown in the “How we Make Minecraft” series, who’s whole point was that he defyed all of Mojang’s rules when adding a mob to the game. He says that it was a desperate attempt to boost sales, and that it will ruin the game forever. After the two hosts see Jonathan adding Mobbo to the game, the same host from before mentions that he “warned everyone about this two years ago.”
Many people in the comments see this video as a “cry of help” from Mojang, and that Jonathan represents Microsoft and Mobbo represents the chat reporting feature. This is further solidified by the fact that “two years ago” was also when the account migration was announced. I don’t have a specific view on this, nor do I think it's 100% true, it's just something I wanted to point out.
Sounds "Likely" but you think a worker could use a friend laptop, make a "Not calling fooking stupid for not knowing insider baseball" post on Reddit or 4chin.
Is it really that hard?
@@Subject_Keter I don’t think I understand what you’re saying.
@Subject Keter Could you elaborate? This reads like you just hit random buttons in your phone’s autocomplete section.
@@Subject_Keter poor fella had a stroke
@@watersnortmoment3734 He's trying to say that one of the Mojang employees could leak everything going on anonymously. Yeah this reads poorly but it's still comprehensible
I've seen a lot of people call 1.19.1 a "controversial" update, when it is NOT. a controversy is something with 2 sides. Nearly NO ONE is in favor of getting banned by a power hungry corporation
Mojang is still one side of the argument
1.19.84*.
@@brainbomb. literally 1.19.84. Now seriously, 1.19.1 is the version on Java
@@TheyCallMeIce Both Bedrock and Java are affected by it.
@@brainbomb. I know. For once bedrock and java players have stopped arguing which is the superior version
My main fear for java is that they will implement the marketplace feature, and remove regular moding capabilities.
For the sake of 'compatability'
I just hope free mods stay alive :(
@@sphereyahya If they add the marketplace to Java edition it's almost certain that the free mods will be banned and any easy way to mod will be removed.
@@ArturoPladeado if that ever happens then lets just say the game is dead :(
They can't remove modding from Java, it is too late. Do know that they could deny modding in their TOS that i would still use and create mods either way.
@@ArturoPladeado as someone who worked for mojang we're planning on puting marketplace on java so java mod creator can get alot of support and feature directly from mojang. I know the community might be mad but it is a good way to support mod dev
“Maybe instead of directing your outrage to the artist, consider the business man”
The most mature thing I’ve heard anybody say from our generations. It is about time horrible corporate shitters pay for what they all suck at.
death to microsoft
We need to boycott Microsoft, but any time anyone mentions that everyone’s like “how they’re too big?” Well not they are not, look at Budweiser and target, they lost billions due to the boycotts which are still continuing mind you, if Microsoft were to lose a few million or even a billion they wouldn’t care they’d keep doing what they’re doing, but if we kept up a boycott for long enough we could severely damage their income and they’d have to make a change, or Minecraft would simply be a massive hole in their pocket, I believe a profitable Minecraft is a dying Minecraft, so let’s make it not so profitable for them anymore, delete Minecraft make videos comment as much as possible and stop buying marketplace items and any new releases of any games or products related to Minecraft, we all love Minecraft but like a drug addicted family member, it needs some tough love before it falls deeper into its hole.
Hell I might go as far as to invest in Linux and get rid of windows.
My biggest fear with the updates they seem to be peddling is that they’re going to try and phase out the ability to access older versions in Java. I’m a modded player and almost only play modded Minecraft. So with the marketplace in bedrock I’m really worried they’re gonna phase out the older versions so they can introduce a marketplace system and destroy the modding community. I could see them arguing something like “we’re phasing out the old versions so because of the moderation and player reporting system” just to introduce the marketplace to Java the next update.
I don't think they are so stupid because' let's face it, the second Mojang removes mod support, Minecraft is officially dead.
@@f1reflam3 Imo the worst thing would be make the Mods like "DLC" but it will be buggy, annoying and say you dont like Thermal Expansion, you are forced to buy iy to see if you like it or not
@@Subject_Keter * coff coff * minecraft bedrock
There is zero chance of that happening even if Mojang wanted to, most of the version JARs have been extensively archived and can continue to be archived even without Mojang's consent.
@@f1reflam3 The game has no mod support, it's all community made. The most mojang has done is provide obfuscation maps and un-hardcode some stuff and replace it with datapack based data.
I think it's likely that this is a combination of microsoft and mojang's fault, although one thing is certain: this is not the fault of the developers, and whoever made this decision has set the devs up to take the blame. As if they didn't have enough to deal with already.
@@mellohi6175 you know what's painful? From the first moment i heard about this shit, i could already clearly invision the person who came up with the idea, and your comment just makes me even more sure in what i think.
I mean everyone who has an history in seeing censoreship online knows that those people are always the same
You're right, it's BlackRock and it's social score
Sounds about right.
actually its just one person at microsoft who doesn't listen to the community.
"vertical slabs remove creativity!!!" - 🤓
"Trust me, this is a positive change. Nothing is going to change about the game"
*Funny how it's coming from a 'right-side up' Dinnerbone*
XD
Never trust a right-side up dinnerbone
Imposter
@@_amya__ its a warning
Cough cough *roses* cough cough *zombie pigmen* cough cough
Just to clarify, the "pointless warning popups" are actually about the serious log4j exploit that happened a while ago. Since the older versions of minecraft don't have a fix for the log4j exploit, the only way to stop the log4j exploit on older versions is for the owners of the server you are on to launch the server using a line of code that looks something like this: "NoFormatMsgLookups=true" I'm pretty sure this is the only time people really used this for fixing that exploit. This applies to not only minecraft, but things like large social companies like discord. I'm reasonable sure that most of the companies fixed this by now, but since mojang doesn't want to go through each and every version of minecraft available to players and adding a fix to the apache log4j issue, they just made that warning. I think that this is kinda lazy of mojang to basically give away thousands of accounts to malicious coders because they couldn't just put that code into each and every version of minecraft.
That last part about mojang being lazy is not fully backed up, but I have my sources on the rest of those things
The Minecraft I love will never die no matter what. It will forever inside my heart.
the MC I love is 1.8.9 and backwards
what microsoft is doing with minecraft is to make the game as globalized as possible, stupid packages in the marketplace, new pre-established systems for the chat filter, lack of support and almost total absence of dialogue with the community.
This is not minecraft and is not coming back to us like the gold days.
This is worth a try. #SaveMinecraft
globalized?
@@rickyrackey7930 Literally won't do anything whatsoever. Seen this story multiple times with games. Better to give up and not waste energy on it.
@@NazzyDragon It worked for Tf2. They can’t stop us United.
Please tell me hytale doesn't have Player "Safety" Features or chat moderation so anarchy servers are safe...
The reason the outrage is directed towards mojang is because we know microsoft won't listen. Its not just outrage for the sake of outrage. Its outrage to prevent the neutering of Java, the last bastion of truly free Minecraft.
This is where money piling comes in and becomes a political problem when it comes to courts if you guys fight it you’ll lose.
@@freedomdude5420 we don’t care we will still fight it
@@just-a-fnf-fan it’s not that you can’t fight the problem is your strategy is a problem.
@@freedomdude5420 makes sense
@@just-a-fnf-fan if only you could guys could go on go fund me but after that little whoops a daisy with the Canadian truckers, these guys are so biased it’s not even funny. I guarantee you if somebody went on the website like go fund me and they fund against Company that’s doing illegal actions, for court purposes, I bet you they’ll go right to that other company that involves funding and cut it. It would be a good way to sue companies like go fund me because it would go so how dangerous these entities are and show their true colors.
This game made a lot of my life
and now they're ruining it.
so many fond memories playing this. actually pretty scary to think it'll be over soon.
‘do not go gentle into that good night’ death to microsoft
If notch never sold we would be a way better position
I agree, but a giant corporation ruining (trying) someone’s life with mammon is to blame(Notch’s QOL (family relations, friend relations, life purpose+satisfaction) drastically dropped with that amount of wealth)filthy lucre. interest based usury. vile vipers disgusting.
Notch is a good man (we all are imperfect: no man is without sin). It is evident if you have been paying attention and have played Minecraft for a long time.
death to microsoft
mojang employees have debunked the idea that this is microsoft's doing and instead this was mojang's decision with microsoft providing the resources to go through with it
I have no doubts that Microsoft has influenced this idea, though. Their ultimate goal is to sterilize and corporatize the game. Since day 1 of the Microsoft acquisition, they've been planning to completely strip Minecraft of its indie game vibe, because an indie game just isn't good for corporate business. Sure, Mojang is implementing everything, but without a doubt what we're seeing now is the result of Microsoft executing their master plan.
Just because Mojang responded and said the feature was their fault doesn't actually mean it's true. They were trying to protect any single person from being blamed and decided to take the hit because Microsoft certainly wasn't going to. It's also possible that Microsoft told them to address it. But I do agree that putting it all on Microsoft ignores that almost definitely Mojang DID have at least some part to play in this feature and probably a bigger part than most are willing to admit it seems...
Well if they provided the resources they are definitely the mastermind behind it
@@3v1l73ddy cope
@@innerecho9468 ultra cope
I remember playing Pocket Edition very soon after release, probably some time in 2011 or 2012. TNT didn't even work, survival wasn't in the game, and the creative inventory was like 1 page with barely any scroll. It was barebones, yet still enjoyable and incredibly nostalgic now. I haven't really touched it since Bedrock came out, things went downhill pretty fast even if the game got much more fleshed out. Likewise, I played Java since 2013, starting in 1.5. I've enjoyed the game off and on since then, but I stopped after the account migration and recent events only solidified this position. Its just not the same anymore, with a clear corporate vibe cropping up that just erodes what makes Minecraft so great.
Yeah your comment is so far off base.
It doesn’t matter what worked in 2011 or 2012 lol. It isn’t close to like that now.
@@MrExdous69 Okay but the game *remained* pretty damn good up until recently. Even 1.17 and 1.18, while underwhelming in scope, were still quite playable and had some decent new content that fit the Minecraft vibe. I wasn't terribly pleased with the new 1.18 music but a simple resource pack dealt with that. The more recent events are in a whole other category however. Minecraft has taken a serious and sudden change of course (well, mostly sudden, there were warning signs like the whole debacle about sharks and dolphins, mob votes, ditching C418 over licensing, and especially how they've treated Bugrock edition). You clearly didn't read or understand the whole comment - I have still enjoyed the game up until these problems started to crop up and mar the experience, and I may still occasionally hop on older versions in singleplayer until that gets boring.
@@StuffandThings_ everyone is just blowing this whole thing out of proportion. Java still exists even though it really should have been phased out since the programming language isn’t really used for games with the reach and player base Minecraft has. You still have your beloved Java edition. There isn’t anything legitimate things you can’t do that you could…
It sure seems like Java players want to bitch about every little thing. Oh no! A chat reporting system! What ever will I do?
Don’t be a prick and it won’t effect you in the slightest.
And I know all about bedrock since it’s the only version I play since I’m a console player
@@MrExdous69 It will affect _everyone,_ since now we have to constantly worry if someone might try to troll or take something woefully out of context, banning us from the entirety of multiplayer. Socialization, a core aspect of multiplayer, is now crippled. Java since the beginning was player-run, where Mojang put their trust in the players and the servers to moderate as they pleased. There were communities for everyone, some curated more than others, and it was up to players to chose and be mindful of their environment. The game has been fundamentally altered in a way that flies directly in the face of what it always stood for - a decentralized, player driven experience made up of various communities with various standards and various ways of experiencing the game. Mojang is now forcing their own moderation on everybody with little regard for nuance. Should there have been some sort of multiplayer moderation tool baked into the base game? Yes, of course. But it should have been server-side and optional, like most moderation tools already used, and not this monstrosity.
I take it you either don't care, or pretend that this will be a good system because it will ""protect"" people who were already protected by server moderation. Java players have generally been quite okay with most updates, this is by far the most riled up they have been and for good reason. Minecraft was great, but it seems that they now want to turn it into a heavily curated marketing tool.
@@StuffandThings_ I don’t care because I play console. That has already been a part of console edition. Guess what? I’ve played for YEARS without being banned. Like I said don’t be a prick and it won’t effect you.
Also the day Microsoft bought this IP you should of known this was coming. Microsoft will protect itself from Karen’s being pissed that little Bobby heard the N word playing a game with grown ass people. Nevermind it’s Karen’s job to protect and police what and who little Bobby is playing with. But she doesn’t and she holds Microsoft accountable.
Guess you bitch and think it’s the end of the world that McDonalds cups caution that coffee is hot.
Truth is, version parity is coming. This was just another brick in that wall.
the thing is microsoft doesnt have too much of a say in mojang java (mojang stockholm). while mojang bedrock (mojang us) is mained by Microsoft. I'm just hopefull that Microsoft doesn't go after mojang stockholm or if it does then mojang can remove themselves form Microsoft and be an independent dev with lady agnis (idk how to spell her name) at the head. what she has done for both the community and the devs is amazing and I feel her anxiety every time an update comes out because this is a game that I love and I know anxiety for a release can lead to full cancelation of any new updates.
What I am afraid of is that eventually they'll ban any mods that try to tamper with the "safety" features like the chat reporting and there would be no way around this nightmare.
Them adding reporting system is like youtube removing dislikes
or any shitty change youtube has done for the past like 3 years idk.
atleast you can get dislike back through extensions
This is really a nice comparison.
You can get back dislikes with Return YouYube Dislikes, and you can get chat safety back with No Chat Reports. Both of those were terrible changes made by terrible companies.
@@hrudyplayz dont quote me on this but i've heard form other videos that they might find away to make those mods not work
@@phoenixthewolf6301 They can't. Java Edition is basically open-source at this point. It is a very open platform, as it can be perfectly decompiled easily. It means that if they ever wanted to stop mods, they would basically have to rewrite the whole game or kill Java entirely. Even then, it is still possible to decompile and mod Bedrock, although way harder due to DRM.
Even if they were to block modding somehow, people would just switch to older versions, even if they have to pirate it (i know i would). It's simply too late at this point in time to block modding.
Finally, nobody at Mojang seems against mod devs. I mean Kingbdogz is one of the aether devs after all, they added features like horses with the help of modders in the past, and they even release official deobfuscation maps to make projects like Forge and Fabric easier to update.
As a Beta 1.7.3 Player i can agree that the Marketplace is an ugly way for greedy creators to make Money and also that Stolen Content (Aether&Faithfull) exists is just disgusting! Kingbdogz an official Developer of Minecraft can't do ANYTHING about it.
Faithful is not in marketplace for months 😂
im pretty sure kingbdogz is the creator of the OG aether mod , so i think he can do something about it , idk
Bedrock player here,
This thing is just Absolutely useless..i guess the only good reason for it is for buying cosmic items in servers like the hive,other than that maybe for the more useless character creator which have probably 2 good things(capes and I guess emotes)
@@PhonyFox_A literally there are like 2 free capes, to get more you need to have like a million minecoins
@@PhonyFox_A yo but there are free items + no thing in java and u can download anything like in java.. wait what am i even talking about...
Microsoft started ruining Minecraft when they changed the display name of Pocket Edition to just Minecraft, and then changed real Minecraft to Minecraft: "Java Edition." And that will forever be the biggest insult to this game in my eyes, still hate that change.
Really the worst change to any game you could make is corporatization. I grew up with Minecraft, played it thousands of hours for 6+ years, it's been sad watching not only myself drift away from the game, but also the small indie-game freshness, air of mystery, and the old community surrounding all of it.
The chat filtering was already horrible for years now, I don’t touch chat anymore especially after the false ban I got Minecraft chat bans are the most dystopian shit
Genuinely, I think my biggest problem with the game as it stands now, is that it doesn't have the same atmosphere that it did before, sure some of this may be due to getting older, but I feel like a lot of the magic the game orignally had: "the fear of the night, the prolonged midgame, the fun playing basic but unique maps, has ben all but lost. And (like I said) some of this is definately me getting older, but at the same time it seems like microsoft wants to comlpetely burry that part of minecraft's history, they want to completely change the textures, add more endgame content to make people even more overpowered and less afraid of the night, etc. A large part of the fun that I had orignally with minecraft was the process of going from naked dude in the middle of the woods to owner of a castle, but it seems like that process has been completly overwritten in newer versions, now you can just walk into a village and get basic iron tools, then find a shipwreak and start getting diamonds. A lot of the progression and the work that you do while progessing was taken away, which is fun for some people but it basically leaves me trying to find "vanilla" modpacks that make the game harder and playing the older versions.
To me, Minecraft is more about collecting resources building things to your liking, than surviving any danger. I appreciate quality of life things in the late game, though it would be nice if there were more features for our early, game loving friends, like a revamp of difficulty.
@@miimiiandco.8721 yeah, I think that's the big thing about Minecraft, it caters in some way to everyone, or at least it's meant to. What I may not like about the game is exactly what someone else might love about it. But there is one design philosophy that I've noticed more recently Minecraft has drifted away from, that I believe will improve the fun on both sides of the coin. Balance, a lot of the game has more recently been focused on an almost power trip style gameplay loop where the options open to the player allow them to conquer the world and be safe from any reasonable danger in mere minutes. That's not to say that danger is the most important element of Minecraft, I still do believe that the most integral aspect is the building and the taming of the world, but when that task is so easy to complete that the main problem facing me every time I play is where I'm going to put ultra megabase 3006; I think there is a problem. The achievements made in Minecraft feel much more real (at least to me) when they were hard won achievements, I don't have fun playing a game where everything is handed to me I enjoy carving out my niche in a world through my own work. And maybe we differ in that thought process, but that's why there are multiple difficulty options. Essentially all this is to say, I agree with you, there needs to be some rework of difficulty, and It can't just be giving zombies some more health and power, it has to be a real tangible effect that forces you to change how you approach the game.
Just disable structures. Then you have the "old" minecraft with nothing in the world. Or just don't go to the village or shipwreck if you think that's cheating or to easy.
@@max5183 if I turn off structures I'm going to be missing out on quite a bit of the game, and "just don't go to shipwrecks" doesn't fix the fundemental problem with the current way the game is balanced. My argument was that the fall of Minecraft is the loss of "hard won" battles, essentially that the midgame and early game content is being ignored in favor of late game content. That favoritism (at least to me) makes the late game feel cheap and unsatisfying. And because of the small amount of content being added specifically for the midgame and early game, just not going to shipwrecks is like a band-aid on an amputation it doesnt fix the fundemental problem, that after a while going through the same motions over and over again starts to get boring.
death to microsoft
Minecraft was perfect before Microsoft showed up. Now it feels like a completely different game.
Microsoft buy things to ruin it, this is happened many times..
Great video.
Sorry for being off-topic, but what shader are you using in these videos?
May I point out microsoft ended legacy edition and now played minecraft on console is way worse, I tried playing bedrock console split screen yesterday and it was stupid how bad it was, on legacy it was very good, but then microsoft discontinued it.
And microsoft only discontinued it so they wouldn't have competition on Xbox with fuckrock edition
@@megaman37456 what
What is Bad in this context?
@@megaman37456 what do you mean? Even on xbox the game now is trash
@@matheuscabral9618 You do realize there was a version on Xbox long before Bedrock Edition right?
They killed an entire version the legacy Console edition which are by far the best versions of Minecraft for console players far far better than the Bedrock editions on the various consoles. They made Bedrock unplayable for a long time on Xbox, they didn’t allow some versions of the legacy console editions to get the final update, they clearly exploit the employees and now they’ve added essentially the worst censorship that I’ve seen in a game for ages. Yes absolutely yes Microsoft are ruining it.
for xbox it's not the best update, but anyway if you just mean that nintendo crap I'm glad they don't like minecraft
I can still access to the Legacy edition.
@@SMAL731 I can too thankfully because I still have Xbox one edition
@@MCLegend13 I have the Minecraft legacy edition copy.
I play that version more often than bedrock because I can craft stuff,check out my inventory much faster.
@@SMAL731 I used to play it more often too but sadly my other friends no longer have that version and I am the only one that does and yeah it was a way better version
from a gameplay and feature perspective, no, i don’t think so. the whole chat restriction controversy has been concerning though, and makes the future look even more rough
Do you have a link for your playermodel?
it's not a "controversial" update, the correct word is "hated." "controversial" means there are people for and against the update. this time it is 100% against. everyone agrees it's bad, no controversy. i happened to notice this stupid euphemism in this video
“Controversial - adjective - causing a lot of angry public discussion and disagreement” -Oxford dictionary. Please actually look up what words mean before you say these things.
@@mrbister8714 google isnt a reliable source and remember the keyword 100% not a lot
@@Skateboardings Google ISN’T a reliable source, but when every source agrees on a general definition, that should show something, I didn’t just pull up the first source that came up. And that definition doesn’t say “unless it’s 100%, then it’s no longer controversial” ANYWHERE. Which is what op is saying, because everyone is against it, it doesn’t count as controversial anymore. And even if that were the case, chat reporting DOES have defenders. The defenders always come from stupid povs but they do exist, so it’s not even “100%”
By definition, the update is controversial, that’s what I’m getting at here
@@mrbister8714 🤓
Up until this Orwellian situation, I never really considered leaving, but I now find myself looking at Minetest and how to get it to the point that using it will suffice.
can you let me know what has caused you to leave the game? I don't understand the outrage to the 1.19.1 chat reporting
@@remy7005 Before this, minecraft servers were handling their moderation just fine. There are plenty of ways to moderate a server chat. This update takes the power out of the hands of people running their servers and puts it into the hands of potential griefers.
@@xRAINxOFxBLOODx Yeah that makes sense, I think the chat reporting should be an optional tool for server owners. And maybe I've got too much faith in Mojang but I don't see griefers really being able to abuse the system
"I can't say racial slurs to children in video game! this is just like brave new 1984: animal fahrenheit"
@@remy7005 My personal issue with it is they are trying to fix a problem that is not there when the Minecraft community at large would want almost anything other than this. Example fixing how well servers are able to run the newer versions of the game. Or trying to fix the divide on java edition as when 1.9 came out a lot of players did not like the combat changes and it really split the java community in half. Basically for there first major implementation to the game its not something we need or want at the time being.
"You can't sue me buttons" had me laughing harder than I should've
Also, where did the combat snapshots go? Those were looking like they could've fixed the 1.8-1.9 split in the player base.
I was playing pirate version the whole time, and i really wanted to buy it. But now it seems, it would be safer to not
I would still recommend buying it, just NEVER, FOR ANY REASON update past 1.19.0
@@notme8232 also applies to playing on servers with 1.19.1 players even if your are 1.18 for example
@@BobAndGlueSticks no it only applies to 1.19 players and above since thats when cryptographic chat signing was introduced
Buy it its very good
same here.
The main issue is that the report system is Microsoft's way to control servers. They don't pay for the private servers, so they should have no control over what they do on them.
death to microsoft
Those server do cost them money
@@marijnnn4992 no?? the servers pay the companies that own server networks not microcock
I feel like the migration has decreased the amount of players that used to play java, which is really sad. Not only that, but i heard that you can get banned for just saying, "You suck!" I also feel so bad for Agnus, I have noticed she has been actin like she was about to cry due to all the stress. Also some of my friends who used to play java quit; because they could never figure out how to migrate their account! Due to them either forgetting their password, or just not understanding the instructions. I hate the migration idea, I had to get one of my friends to help me because i forgot my minecraft password. Also it's not like you have a choice not to migrate, according to Microsoft you HAVE to migrate your account in order to keep playing minecraft. I think that's just stupid! I think if they wouldn't have added a migration requirement, there would be a lot more players playing java. I can see why a lot of people are switching to bedrock.
Going to the account migration thing, I remember opening the Java launcher being told my Mojang account had to be migrated to Microsoft. Okay, not that big of a deal, just migrate and get it over with. I tried, but it said that I need to get a code by email to be able to migrate. One problem, don't have access to that email anymore, I was stupid and thought I would have access to it for over 8 years, but I only had it for only a couple more years. I was hoping I could just get the code with a different email, I couldn't. Change the email? Send a verification code to that email. I feel dumb and thinking it's partially my fault for not verifying the account email, but I thought I had more time. I spent loads of money, made hundreds of friends, a whole bunch of progress on who knows how many servers, all that stuff, and now I can't get to it. I wish they could've at least let Mojang players still play, maybe with not as good account security, but still. I don't want my years of progress to go to waste.
It's intentional lol. They could help java users get their accounts back, but that doesn't make money. They want people to spend another 30$ for a new account on bugrock edition.
I’m fairly certain a Mojang Dev said it was their choice on a drama post made by one Minecrafter. It pretty much went under the radar. So much so I believe the tweet is gone now
The problem is it's just a tweet, not verifiable :(
@@RandomSageless My Drill Sergeant once said, "Perception is Everything."
I think we have the right to assume it's accurate if it's actually coming from a Dev.
@@3N1StaticGaming yeah
@@RandomSageless BillyK_ said it's Mojang as well, so did Docm77
@@RandomSageless
Ms are only listening to the community that makes them the most money, the parents of crusty 10 year old iPad kids
they’re not gonna listen to us unless we convinced the people they’re listening to
they don’t rely on us to make money, the rely on the
Remember the term “Online Interactions not rated” that you would find on the back of a game box? Yeah, screw that now I guess.
Huh? I don't understand, can you explain to me?
@@whosfredol5194 I don’t know if they still do it, but back then from what I remember they used to label “ONLINE INTERACTIONS NOT RATED BY THE ESRB” on the box of games, signaling that online play was unrated. Now games have tons of moderation systems to make online only E for everyone. There is no more freedom.
And when I open up Mario Kart Wii when WFC is long gone
@@GGamerLiam Wiimmfii exists.
Good video! Also what shader are you using?
I remember a year or two ago I was just scrolling through UA-cam when I saw this badboyhalo video where he basically just ranted about how Microsoft was ruining Minecraft little by little in order to appeal to children. At the time I was definitely doubting that Microsoft would ever go out of their way to ruin a game just for more money, but now I see he was absolutely right
death to microsoft
I think Microsoft implemented the chat filter as a precautionary measure due to COPPA.
If they lose COPPA protection Minecraft would be deemed unsafe for childern and that would cause a lot of problems.
UA-cam had this exact problem and Roblox gets mass sues bc of it, so i can see why they would think its a good idea to implement it.
very good analysis , i just wish they implemented it better
they could atleast made the feature on by default and add the option for people to turn it off, but what they did is just radio silence for days now.
COPPA? What do privacy laws have to do with this? What do you even mean with "COPPA protection"?
Also, deeming something unsafe for kids means it allows tracking and targeted advertising, which is more profitable. Although that's not relevant in this case, companies don't want their stuff to be considered for children as it will bring in way less ad money.
It's not relevant to minecraft at all, afaik it doesn't contain any advertising at all, unless they're fucking up bedrock really badly.
@@kyh148 as jan mention it will make any game that they deemed unsafe for children cause alot of problems such as suing , court and bunch of stuff. Microsoft and/or Mojang does not want this so they implement this chat report feature
@@kyh148 UA-cam got fined 170 million $ just for having large child audience and not enforcing COPPA rules.
As for what I meant by "COPPA protection", if Microsoft gets sued, they can always say: "We are enforcing COPPA rules, so we are not at fault."
I think a big part of the controversy, besides alarmism, is because Minecraft has exhibited classic corporate stubbornness and telling fans with suggestions to improve player protection systems that their ideas will never be implemented, and even small private servers with mods or plugins to disable chat report that their existence is considered illicit now. It’s perfectly possible to go have both child safety features and have players enjoy the game without fearing a wrongful banhammer, but for whatever reason the company just does not want to do that.
death to microsoft
Bit out of context, but what resource pack makes the cloud rounded?
its shaders lol
note on the spongebob thing being the "same day" as the news on technoblade, well... we learned of his death pretty late at night (if I recall correctly), and they likely scheduled the tweet or something (don't know if that is necessarily a feature on twitter or not but they could've still planned the best time to tweet it) to come out on that day with absolutely NO WAY to know. That really is not a good example you have no idea what was going on behind the scenes and a deal like that likely was planned out a while in advance with that date set for the tweet.
I've been playing bedrock for years now and I've always identified myself as a small redstone builder.
The biggest problem I've seen with bedrock so far is that redstone in a greater scale is almost impossible to make. It isn't as simplistic as in java because of the programming. Slime elevators, huge piston doors or complex circuits for chronometers, calculators and others are just unimaginable. It's also really difficult to make compact circuits.
I noticed this too, simple circuits are now messes of repeaters n torches and seemingly nobody wants to make tutos for circuits modified for bedrock
I remember when people were making a big Bedrock push, they never showed harder to make contraceptions.
I think the main issue with Bedrock is the randomness when it comes to certain circuits. I can see Bedrock Redstone being as good as Java Redstone if people actually tried to learn it.
Repeater ticks doesnt even make sense
Play Java, it's just much better
Good point don't blame the coders blame the suits
yupp
fun fact ... becouse of moving account to microsoft I couldn't manage to move mine becouse of some error so ... account gone forever.
same. It's so awesome and convenient I love it soooooooo much Microsoft thanks. I'll also be sure to purchase all your microtransactions and never say bad words while playing👍👍👍Infact I love you so much I'm just gonna give you 1000$ right now, isn't that what you want Microsoft??
Microsoft deleted my alt account connected to my same email when I migrated ):
anyone know if I can recover it? (forgot username)
I think Microsoft is ruining only the Java Edition so people are forced to migrate to the Bedrock Edition so we can be forced to perches monetized reskinned mods, skins, and textures and play on a extremely buggy and terrible connection set up version.
Things are going to have to get really bad for Java to be worst then Bugrock in it's current state.
Sadly bedrocks condition is arguably worse with a full censorship and being able to be banned from singleplayer, with even a tremendous amount of bugs that mojang just doesn't seem keen on fixing, which is disappointing as it has soo much potential if only it was more focused on, also as for the marketplace, yes its terrible but thats why u can get addons for free like java
Bedrock is puke.
despite this terrible update, Java is still preferable to the disgrace that bedrock is.
@@mrlaz9011 oh cmon bedrock isn't that bad! The hive is a good server and that server is really fun with custom models
It has been confirmed that the higher-ups at Mojang are responsible for this change, just a reminder
Source for this information? well also the idk wtf the ceo of mojang has been doing since the management team sucks ass currently
We can make a change. #SaveMinecraft
No shit
@GoTi4No actually Microsoft is causing the filtering issues. Microsoft kinda controls mojang you kniw
Sorry I meant know
is the first 15 seconds of the intro based off another game? for some reason it seems super familiar to me but i cant put my finger on it
Gosh, I've been waiting so long for someone to say this out loud. I just can't play new versions of the game: they feel soulless and more corporate, especially since the 1.14 retexture and replacement of C418 with new composers. To my mind the community created much better versions of the game with mods on such versions as 1.7.10, but when I'm trying to point this out, people are just yelling at me "ACCEPT THE CHANGES!" or "MODDED OLDER VERSIONS ARE RUINING MINECRAFT!"
They are trying to sell the game to more parents with kids
They cant sell the game again if u bought it alrdy
And if u aint dumb u wont touch the marketplace (cuz u wud just play java edition, skins, maps, textures r free here after all)
So they ignore the community completely becuz they arent trying to appeal to u
They think they can continue to sell minecraft even if the player base is dead as long as they find a way to sell to parents
Exactly. I bought the game back before it blew up, when Notch still said he was planning to open source it. From my viewpoint I was giving money to a small indie dev for a passion project. At the time I was a poor student and I pirated most of my games, so me giving money was a huge deal. Now Notch has sold the game to Microsoft, and Microsoft has taken away my ability to play the game I paid for, unless I migrate my account. It's honestly a huge betrayal by Notch of all the people who made it possible for him to get where he is.
@@seeibe I feel u
Buying the game as a student with no actual income was a big deal and a statement
Though I wouldnt say Notch betrayed us
After all, it was an opportunity to earn an amount of money that would take many lifetimes to earn, it was the fruit of his success
I'd say it is Microsoft who betrayed him and us by taking the game to hell
I don't understand why when chat report was added on java the community reacted, but when render dragon was added on bedrock, the community did nothing .
Easy answer. Nobody cares about bedrock edition.
@@boomsharadeForget it , only concrete answers so I don't start with Minecraft lagva jalag edition or reply to your answer : nobody cares about bedrock, with the answer : I know someone who cares and that someone is ur mom. if you don't have serious answers without toxic stuff then stop commenting , I mean how would you feel if the shaders on optifine were banned. I don't care about bedrock especially, I support equality between the 5 versions of minecraft. i mean why don't the 5 versions support each other, the differences between java and bedrock only psychopaths notice, you support a group of psychopaths who started this trend ? But what can I expect from an Lame American , with stupid state rules, brain wash because of TikToks .
@@boomsharade java gets a taste of their own medicine
@@MeltedToast84 What medicine? You mean the poison microsoft are trying to feed us?
@@MeltedToast84 the irony is that there really is an achievement by that name
back then when a major update was announced, mojang really implemented a lot of new stuff. Now we wait a year for a cherry tree and lightning bugs
I have dropped anchor at 1.17.1 and will play that version in the single player world I have from now on, I see the current Mojang pumping out updates just for updates sake and many of the updates only slow the game down and make it way too complicated. I miss Notch so much
I think that they will hardly mess up and everyone will just move to older version like 1.18 or 1.12.2 (the best version of all times)
"MC Java. MCPE. MC Legacy Edition. MC Pi Edition. Long ago, the four games lived together in harmony. Then everything changed when the Microsoft nation attacked."
And also MC 3DS
mc pi edition is just an old version of mcpe.
Minecraft will truly be gone when a Minecraft store gets released on Java.
It's. Called marketplace
“Is Microsoft ruining Minecraft?”
Is that even a question?
Y E S. THEY ARE
I just play single player and I'm pissed that with the 1.19.2 Java update I've yet to find a single abandoned mine. I used to love exploring them and getting lost in endless tunnels, now all I ever find our large caverns and crevices with a normal amount of coal and a smattering of iron. This blows.
You put the timeline together pretty well and it makes a lot of sense I like the video.
Glad you enjoyed!
@@RandomSageless Thanks for the heart, I like series so far think you should know that
@@dstyKchp I'm so excited for y'all to see what's in store for the next 3 episodes :)
@@RandomSageless Thanks have fun working on them
what shaders are these
After a lot of negativity about these updates, it's great to hear the positive come out again. We as humans tend to forget that they are humans just like us.
corpo rats are not humans, they are rats
corporatists aren't humans, that's what they want you to think, they're just greedy pigs doing nothing but detrimental things
Corporate people have descended into hell, they don't know things like fun or empathy, only greed
Hmmm only a spy would say this
No human ever thought that this was a good idea lmao.
#saveminecraft dont ruin a game we all grew up on
#saveminecraft ig.
#saveminecraft
death to microsoft
What's the shader you're using? It looks nice
What shaderpack is that? I love it's subtle, yet very obvious aesthetic!
Great vid! The marketplace is good. As a concept. You will get some great additions to the game impossible otherwise. However, it was ruined by Minecoins. What even are they? Robux 2.0? They can’t be, since from what I’ve heard, people on Roblox may be impressed by your skin. If you pay using Microsoft bought currency, the creators of the content may get nothing! The game is so expensive, affordable, yes, but not if everything you have is reset and you have to buy it ALL again.
From what Microsoft has said is the creators do get the "majority" of the revenue, but I haven't verified that. There's a big problem with people stealing work from others and making money off the market place though, Aether for instance.
Yup I agree with this comment
I think in game purchases should be banned from payed games
@@RandomSageless A 70/30 cut is industrial standard. Marketplace so expensive for little actual value
@@RandomSageless Yeah. You get good ones cheap sometimes, but there are also very high chances of pure garbage that is abnormally expensive.
hopefully them putting a warning label for servers that have a plugin or mod that makes player reporting not possible is all that they do, cause that means it's not their fault you are playing a server you are "exposed" on. so they cant get sued. What I worry about is they start making mods bannable (somehow)
My main problem, my ps4 edition ran just fine; ever since bedrock I've had numerous issues.
The Microsoft account troubles in the beginning, the marketplace being added, texture packs needing to be re-downloaded everytime I play, and after a long break getting back into it; all of my saves get corrupted for some reason. All in all, I think I'm done with minecraft.
They make you pay for skins and multiplayer they even make you pay for the ability to cross your worlds over from one console or pc to another I hate over priced realms SO much
While it may appear we can't convince Microsoft to take back the chat report feature, there are still things we can do to circumvent it.
1. Don't use chat
2. Use the No Chat Reports mod and pray the server you try to connect to won't enforce secure chat (which servers have it default to true, but then again no one likes chat reporting in the first place)
3. Don't update to 1.19 or beyond.
4. Don't play multiplayer or Realms at all.
We can still fight back; we have some control.
1.19 is not safe due to chat signatures. players from 1.19.1 can report you
1.18.2 is safe
@@IgorMgtowandVideoGames Well I was unaware of that, thanks for the heads up.
this is a player who thinks positively like me, what's the big deal , the same thing with the marketplace if you look for positive stuff you will find, but still I want to see how smart you are, I haven't found a way to accept render dragon or to see any meaning in it, what should I do in such situations if I want to enjoy the old shaders. another thing I don't understand is why there are so many tributes for Technoblade but for Bashurverse there is almost none .
Him: is microsoft ruining minecraft?
Me instantly: YES
its not
Microsoft locked my account for no reason 😡😡😡
There’s a 4 GB storage limit on the Xbox OS, so eventually you’ll reach a limit with a single world if you’ve been playing for a while. An inevitable limit for crazy builds, and largely explored worlds because there’s some weird storage limit for Minecraft itself even if you have the space on your Xbox 😕
Ouch
I still have my old Modpacks from back to beta 1.5 on my PC. I play them from time to time and actually enjoy them more than more recent Minecraft Versions. The recent version where not bad, but they feeled out of touch for me, who played Minecraft since the alpha.
I joined Minecraft back in 2014 with pocket edition, which I still often play on to this day, although I do play on Xbox more. I don’t have a computer, so I’ve really not have been able to play Java that much. I mean, we got big salmon, right?
As a bedrock player I’m jelly from all what y’all have with Java, it’s like (in my opinion) they treat Java like royalty giving them options and freedom, but on bedrock we are limited to a crappy cash grab marketplace, I feel like they need to just let Java be the main game, or give bedrock some features like hardcore.
Even the combat didn't get updated on bedrock
Wait, Bedrock doesn't have HARDCORE MODE?! That's a feature people have been asking for since THE FREAKING LEGACY CONSOLE ERA!!
its not so much that MS "gave" java anything, more so that they took away the freedoms of scrubrock users
I play the mobile version of Minecraft and I checked the rating's and reviews and clicked the glitches section it's never ending and in Minecraft you can never find dungeons they removed it due to the cave generation along with the mineshafts
It’s fun that my Nintendo Switch version of Minecraft quite literally freezes at random intervals. Except it doesn’t. It just stops the screen and sounds and any inputs for up to a minute until it doesn’t and all of them happen at once, often killing me in the process.
higher ups at mojang did this. the "nice mojang" narrative is moot
all I want from them is to remove getting kicked from singleplayer and actually having a reason to be reported, also no perma bans or if u get perma banned u can pay 5 bucks and play again just with less warnings. like if 2 people report u banned again
and maybe just bans from public servers not private realms that u and ur friends made.
You can get kicked from singleplayer?!?!
@@sidr8920 Well, yeah. Singleplayer is running on an internal server, that is why there is actual lag in the gameplay sometimes.
@@sidr8920 if u spam in chat to much
@@ArtemSqueaky that's really stupid. You should be able to do whatever you like in singleplayer
@@sidr8920 yea
Hey! at 7:43 where tf is Linux on your Pie Chart
I can't even play multiplayer now and they say that I have to give access in my Microsoft account but I don't know where
Great video man, you explained things very well in this video. Hopefully the support will get it into the eyes of Mojang!
I'm sorry, but I'm gonna have to disagree with your point on directing the hate at Mojang. They are just as much as responsible for adding this change as Microsoft are, and from what I heard, they were totally okay with adding this feature, with no disputes whatsoever. If they really were innocent, they would've made at the very least a bit more of an uproar, and they wouldn't have outright ignored us for the past week or so. On top of that, there has been a definitive whistleblow that someone within the minecraft community has been in kahoots with Mojang and has used their position of power to force this change. Unfortunately, the person that pointed this out has aided them in their escape by not telling us who they are. If it is a single person behind this change, then this is one of the few times a witch-hunt would be an appropiate reaction.
idk if this is true (saw it in another video) it was about that the chat report system is going to be in all versions, not only 1.19 and mods will not work at all, if thats the case then there isn't an escape?
I missed the old times when in June Mojang cared only about game updates and not rainbow shit
exactly what I was thinking. Microsoft may have added some stupid stuff, but they are not trying to kill Minecraft. And the game isn't going to die because of reporting. We have plugins and mods to help with the reporting system already, and if worse comes to worse; Don't chat. Its not that the problem isn't bad, its that the community is blowing up the problem beyond what it should be.
the issue is that, many people DO chat, and chat is a very useful tool. being banned from the entirety of multiplayer permenantly for saying smth stupid is rediculous, and better yet, server moderation EXISTS ALREADY. this is completely unnecessary and will harm the game moving forward, even if it does get removed as mojang has lost a lot of their reputation, moreso than when they announced 1.19 to be a much, much smaller update than promised
no, the problem is people are becoming way too used to restricted freedom of speech and other stuff, it's genuinely alarming how bad it's getting
you bought a game, you should be able to talk shit with your friends in a server
I think the idea of security in minecraft chats is a good thing, I just think it was implemented very intrusively
Minecraft: Becoming too child friendly
Roblox: Becoming too adult
6:57 A banner ad showed up at this part for me lol
I absolutely hated the migration thing cuz I literally could not play minecraft and was a struggle for most ppl who either had a very old account for example RekRap2 or forgot they're login credentials like me, they even stopped it from other clients as well. I overall thought it was for no reason and hated it so much
it sucked :(
@@RandomSageless The migrationg thing was annoying my microsoft account i've used for +10 ten years has a xbox live perma ban, when i went to link, it barred me from playing minecraft on my minecraft account. I owned that minecraft account before microsoft even bought minecraft and now i'm pretty much banned from playing minecraft for something unrelated to minecraft its bs.I got around it but still it pissed me off.
i do believe they are trying to kill off java. think about it, people can make custom skins, maps, and mods, all for free. having everything on bedrock means complete control over the in game market
People can do that on bedrock for free too. Having a world download or add on cost minecoins is completely upto the creator, they choose to do it. You can make custom maps and skins or bedrock too
Ik that i’m way out of subject but can anyone please tell me what’s the name of the shader he’s using??🙏🏻
They really messing up minecraft. My minecraft accounts was gone after the migration. I tried contacting microsoft and mojang but both kept redirecting my to the other. This situation is so bad that the microsoft support guy didnt even know what mojang was. And didn't even know anything about minecraft. So ye there goes 25 EUR
I’m glad Techno is not alive to see this. Although he would crusade against it. RIP Techno.
Good point,