Why can’t Bayern Munich find a manager?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 чер 2024
- Bayern Munich announced back in February that this season would be Thomas Tuchel’s last as their manager. Fast forward three months and Bayern are yet to find a replacement.
Xabi Alonso, Julian Nagelsmann, Unai Emery and now Ralf Rangnick have opted to stay at their current jobs rather than join the German club. The question is why are Bayern struggling to fill their managerial vacancy.
Ayo Akinwolere is joined by The Athletic's Seb Staffored-Bloor & ex-Bundesliga striker Jan Aage Fjortofb to discuss who Bayern could possibly turn to next and how soon they can make it a reality.
00:00 Intro
00:21 The managerial search
02:56 Who could take the job?
05:52 Bayern Munich’s rebuild
11:36 Bayern Munich’s performance during the season
13:07 Could there be a Tuchel stay at Bayern?
16:28 Is there a shortage of top managers?
24:27 UCL semi-final
27:55 Outro
The Athletic Football Podcast is your essential guide to football's biggest stories, five times a week this season...
Listen on Apple and Spotify: theathletic.lnk.to/tafcpodYT
Subscribe to The Athletic Football Podcast channel 👉 bit.ly/athleticuk | 🔔Make sure to enable all push notifications!🔔
The Athletic is currently offering a special price subscription of £2/$2 a month for the first 12 months. To redeem that limited-time-only offer go to 👉 theathletic.com/footballpod
Follow The Athletic FC:
Website 👉 theathletic.com
Twitter 👉 / theathleticfc
Instagram 👉 / theathleticfc
Facebook 👉 / theathleticfc
Follow Tifo Football:
Website 👉 tifofootball.com
Twitter 👉 / tifofootball_
Facebook 👉 / tifofootball
Instagram 👉 / tifofootball_
Subscribe to Tifo Football 👉 bit.ly/TifoFootball
Thumbnail: Kevin Voigt / Contributor / Getty Images Europe via Getty Images
#bayernmunich #bundesliga #championsleague - Спорт
I think we’re caught between two eras of football.
There’s the past, where managers were the focal point and everything that happened at the club was the managers responsibility. Their signings, their tactics, their man management, their coaching, their management of player fitness, morale. If the club didn’t perform, it was their fault. If they won anything, it was their success.
And then there’s modern football, where we know that coaches exist, and recruitment departments and negotiation departments and medical teams and onboarding HR and everything is broken down. The manager doesn’t run that, the sporting director and the CEO and the owners run that.
But the media still acts like it’s the old days. If a club is doing poorly, regardless of what our eyes tell us, about how poor recruitment is, or players not keeping fit, or players not training well, or signings not landing, or negotiations taking too long, badly planned pre-seasons, bad player culture. They always go after the manager, or they go after a specific player, like everything will be fixed by replacing that cog.
And we know now, when you see Arteta at Arsenal, or Alonso at Leverkusen. This idea of big clubs needing to hire managers with big name value, it’s not true. And the whole project doesn’t fail because of the manager.
Best most reasonable post I’ve seen on a football article in years. Bravo
wow
Well said, great post. Modern football is a machine and all the cogs need to be well-oiled for consistent success.
most media doesnt paint it lke that nowadays, they aint all dinosaurs and cant blanket the lot
Bayern have been unmanageable ever since key players - Muller in particular, but also the other veterans such as Neuer - threw the towel to ensure Ancelotti got sacked 3 months into the season because they wanted him to train them like Guardiola. The same Ancelotti who is now kicking their butts.
Way too much player power there. Also winning 11 domestic titles in a row has distorted expectations and any manager will be judged against that. To put things into perspective: imagine if Heynckes had been sacked in 2012 after losing 2 finals and finishing 2nd in the league? There would have been no treble in 2013.
You can see the crack in the Munich dressing room post Lahm cus Alaba, Lewa unceremoniously left despite performing well and Alaba was supposed to be "the next" captain. Muller and Neuer hold too much power and wield it in a petty manner. When Lahm was captain he let Bastian Neuer and Muller have a voice.
U idiots are really clueless, no player epitomizes Bayern more than Thomas Muller and you clowns are accusing him of ruining him. THOMAS MULLER IS BAYERN MUNICH
@@shadow_realm47To be very honest, Bayern needs Lahm to come back as manager after he is done with the entire management of Euro 2024
It's funny to hear all this, knowing now that Bayern are looking to hire Vincent Kompany and Barcelona are trying to get Hans Flick. What a plot twist
Wow, they hustled Jan off *quick* when brought up dressing room spies.
Of course Karl-Heinz Rummenige has an offical role as member of the board of the Bayern München AG - which is not the club but the company of the mens football team, where the club owns 70% of the shares
Nothing better then seeing a new athletic pod in the feed 🎉
Love Jan's punditry. Him and Nedum Vs the rest of the fake incredulous hyperbole ESPN FC plebs
The ego of the bosses is so palpable it's gross.
I can imagine they're stinking up the place with that attitude.
They've forgotten that it is the people who make the institution.
If I were Bayern I’d try to convince Matthias Jaissle. Everyone forgot about him once he left to Saudi Arabia but I think he’s a good coach despite him only having two years of experience. Sampaoli, Van Nistelrooy, & Urs Fischer are the only ones I can think of that are relatively good managers that could work maybe? Either way Freund and Eberl lost respect when they were thinking of getting Ten Hag
Not even more Red Bull please 😂
@@MoRZ47 yeah I know but there aren’t many top managers like there where in the 90’s and early 2000’s
What a fantastic host. Props to Ayo
Watching this after Kompany’s appointment is funny
Great insight, thanks
Bayern have sacked so many managers after less than 2 seasons, I feel like part of the problem is that now good managers see this and don’t want to go to Bayern where they will likely be sacked within 12 months regardless of success.
Jose Maurino is there lurking.
Love it! 2 dinosaurs with main character syndrome and loose grasp of reality, clashing heads in Hoeness and Mourinho would be great entertainment.
@@konzza😂
@@konzza Yep, and throw in the egos of Neuer and Muller who are are nostalgic for the training methods of Guardiola and you've got a fantastic soap op recipe.
Mourinho still a free agent? Could be good for bayern if no one else available
Because they know trophies are an impossibility with Harold in the team.
Why did they fire nagelsmann?
7 days later and Tuchel is being begged to stay by Bayern because no-one else wants to sign for them
Agrees on principle, then rejects them on their terms of agreement.
Ayo not laughing off Ragnick and recognizing his positive job at Austria NT shows how good he is as a host.
It would have been easy for him to just go on and ignore what he did after the United debacle to give some hyperbolic rhetoric but he instead tried to make a sense out of the Bayern approach.
I think that one of the reason is the owner wants a “quick change “ The coaches could not have a enough time to build for his team.
It took Klopp at least 4 or 5 yeas to be successful at Liverpool.
what? Klopp cam in end of 2015
He led them to UEFA Europa League final in 2015/16 and the UEFA Champions League final in 2017/18,
Because Bayern as currently constituted is a freaking mess. They need to rid themselves of at least 10 current players and they need to start to rebuild that porous defense. Given some of the statements from top management about keeping the team together, I would like for a 4th or 5th place in next year’s Bundesliga.
Because the let a manager go thinking he was the problem when in reality the players had a dip in performance as a whole even with a new manager
Guardiola and Ancelotti are former players
Players not wanting to renew and poor transfers in recent times, Bayern could fall off if Leipzig, Dortmund and Leverkusen even Stuggart keep goinh upwards in their trajectories. Also, apart from Pavlovic where are the young players in the squad? Musiala wants to not renew and then all the politics going on. Yes on paper its a good job but in practice you can see why people don't want it.
I agree with everything you said except that Bayern fall off. Munich is a powerhouse, there is not a chance that BVB, Leverkusen and Stuttgart will rise ENOUGH to reach and overthrown Bayern from the top of Bundesliga. For them it's always a "one off" season, like this one for example with absolutely phenomenal Leverkusen team. But in a long run? Heads of top management will roll, complete reshuffle of the board, any kind of cataclysm but no way that Bayern will give breather big enough for competitors to catch up
Musiala hasn't said anything like that , don't make up bullshit
Mate, this is Germany. Teams like Leverkusen and Dortmund peak for 2-3 years max and then disappear. The likes of Werder and Stuttgart even managed to get relegated after winning the league and being CL regulars throughout the 2000s. That is if they can avoid having their players plucked by Bayern.
There has always been an abundance of ex players who coach
Because Harry Kane is there 😂
Why do all the top teams never go for Bielsa😂😂.Strange how everyone always praises him as been so brilliant but no one wants him. Could it be that he is not really a top manager 😂😂
Standard of bucket isn’t good enough for him at the European elite 🪣
He is too sexy and players get jealous.
his attacking football leave defend vulnerable
Difficult to control. Has his own principles he's very hard to get to budge from. Unpredictable. These days he's also old. Many of those things are undesirable for the top clubs.
He's too good for any top team. He's like the Sun, great to praise and like, just from far away.
Because they are like Chelsea and sack managers way too often. I think they will try to get Klopp after his break in a year or two but I think he's too wise to what goes on there.
not a chance
Klopp wont do that to Dortmund, their entire reason for living is to "one day" take Bayern down.
Go for Amorim.
I'll save you 30 min. It's Uli Hoeneß
It's hilarious. One of the richest clubs in the world wants something money apparently can't buy
Go again with tuchel
Their search is going worse than Tottenham’s 2021 managerial search
They want Ten Hag. But Ten Hag stays at United
Because no-one wants to be tainted by the Curse of Kane
bayern hotspur are down bad
Because of the club culture. The heads of Bayern Munich have a lot of control and are over opinionated. Pep will not train Bayern again because of that.
Hurts to read this
Wait... they haven't had a manager?
Disappointed nobody asked Seb how his gates are
Another trophy-less season for Kane
Another insightful and ground breaking comment regarding Kane's career.
@@ulfricstormcloak4230 imagine being sensitive about a person who doesn’t even know you exist
These guests need to get better microphones
SEBB🙌
*I blame the roster.*
Players did conspire against Nagelsmann.
Tuchel came and saw the cesspool the roster is, so he decided to leave as soon as possible.
The team needs to be purged so they can get a new coach. Nobody will take the team as it is now.
He decided to leave? Nah, far from reality. But i do agree that the roster needs a hard hand
@@pennywise1682
Tuchel did complain about the poor compromise from the roster as soon as they started to lose again.
He said he was leaving at the end of the season no matter what
You are correct. This isn't something novel at Bayern, it's been going on at least since Guardiola's departure 8 years ago. Players conspiring actively to undermine the manager for reasons as ridiculous as "training sessions are not hard enough" (which is what Muller said during Ancelotti's time - the same Muller who is now unable to play 10 minutes against Real Madrid without being gassed while Ancelotti's methods are working just fine).
There is too much player power, particularly the core of Neuer-Muller calling the shots and deciding what manager is worthy of staying.
@@rexcolt9742No they told him he was going. They actually asked him to stay recently and he agreed in principle. Then he saw their terms of agreement and changed his mind.
It's a real s--t show.
@@toomuchinformation
Yes.
Both Müller and Neuer, the leaders of the group, gave in and asked Tuchel to stay.
Tuchel is not an id**t. He is still leaving.
Alonso will coach his Real Madrid in 2 years time, when Carletto gets retired. Keep this txt.
Ancelotti said he would prefer to stay at least until 2028. Why would he get retired in case he keeps winning the Champions League?
Bayern have some great kids coming through the ranks. The new manager must be capable and willing to play them. That's the only way they can be moulded into generational talents, and Tuchel clearly was a short term success manager only.
Generational talents are not molded. They are born
I think popularity of the league is really underestimated.
Especially when WestHam can offer more money than Bayern
epl league lost a lot of attractions seen the quality of some games excl maybe city, arsenal.
Philipp Lahm would be perfect for Bayern
Perfect how? What is his style of play and preferred formation as manager? Has he even tried coaching at any level?
@@konzza he’s a Bayern legend he’ll get the respect from the players and the board and he’s played under some of the best managers of all time
He is a sporting director at Stuttgart
He might not be into coaching but more into team building
@@nickfury8973no he isnt, he is more of an advisor. He is the technical survisor of the Euros
SEB!!!!
Bayern Munich is one of those clubs that its run like a political party; that's always a problem during hard times because of all the mini-wars factions fight inside the club, and nothing gets really done until a faction finally "takes over" or some external guy comes to the club and starts amassing power to "really" get things working like an owner
That model of "paying associates" and "committees" and "elections" is total garbage in the long run
Sounded like a bad reporting to me but with each passing day this news is becoming a nightmare for me . Beckenbauer must be turning in his grave 🥹.
Frank Lampard
Idk how to say it but some of the songs almost do a good job experimenting but this album still feels simple. Also if you consider her pre release the album is much shorter. I feel like if she do what Taylor does and just make sure each album has a ton of songs so she has variation.
Trust a spurs fan to also be a Bayern fan. Need to get those trophies from somewhere I suppose, except when spurs players play for them. What a shameless loser.
Get Klopp if possible
Where is the generation of you're P. Lahm, Bastian Schweinsteigers Did any of them take up coaching
Lahm is the operating director of the Euro 2024. So he went into business/sports management. If anything he might be CEO of Bayern Munich one day. Schweinsteiger went into commentating/punditry
Lahm is a director at Stuttgart
@@nickfury8973advisor, not director
Should just keep Tuchel, Bayern are hardly any worse than they’ve been the last 5 years it just looks worse cuz Bayer haven’t lost.
And really, if Bayern wasn’t missing half their team to the Injured List allllllll year, they’d likely be a good bit better off.
Sure, spend the money this summer to get better, get rid of the injury prone guys in attack aside from Sane, and run it back and see what happens. Odds are that Bayer comes back to earth and Bayern are better than this year and win the league and start a new streak
Mmmmm
Mmmmmmmm
Mmm
Mm
Mmmmmm
Mmmm
🤡
This black guy can't even pronounce "Sané" right
‘This black guy’