i actually dig 3:44 and i think that’s what chopin should’ve done for this sonata haha. however I dont like the texture starting from 3:25 to 3:43 as i find that texture super clunky and i find that the sextuplets with that single tenor line more tumultuous and dramatic for some odd reason. really love the idea at 3:44 though. I like, really hope someone plays it like that!
as far as we know the Muse Press company have published an edition from the same movement including Liszt's variant (which you can find in here: muse-press.com/en/product/mp09201/ ), also the American Liszt Society have published their own edition through one of their journals
the catalogue on Wikipedia is pretty unreliable coz so many Liszt's previously unknown works have been catalogued since... also this was, afaik, only published recently by Muse Press: muse-press.com/en/product/mp09201/
Chopin was allegedly mad about Liszt's extemporaneous embellishments for one of his Nocturnes, not this piece. Also I don't think Chopin would have been mad about this faithful and more pianistic (if not necessarily better!) retranscription.
@@cnqrrules we're not that mean to post scam links smh but if you're looking for a digital score then perhaps I could try to share it through your E-mail so you shall try contact us (liszttuile@gmail.com), you cannot post your E-mail source in here cuz as you may probably know the comments filter are deleting a couple of messages that have E-mail sources or any other contacting source
what do you expect lul Chopin would have been very displeased were Liszt to further embellish this piece with his typical treatment (for the operatic fantasies for example)
probably the closest we've been to be Chopinist xD
also if you Chopinists are still confused, Liszt's contribution is 3:25 to 4:11
I hadn't listened to this piece in quite a while, so I was wondering when the Liszt bit was, and then 3:25 came and I knew!
Am I crazy or does the left hand play quintuplets at 3:25?
yup it does lol, check the description
Chopiniszt
this is beyond rare at this point
alkım koşş
atlantis's level of obscurity
4:18 I love that ending oh my goshh - has to be one of my favorite codas honestly!
chopin was going real insane there xd
For realll
I love the intensity becomes harder every 3 stages. the 4th stage(ending, C#) is the cherry on top
I never knew Liszt did this. Thank you!
indeed, quite a surprise even for us when we discovered this little contribution by Liszt xD
i actually dig 3:44 and i think that’s what chopin should’ve done for this sonata haha. however I dont like the texture starting from 3:25 to 3:43 as i find that texture super clunky and i find that the sextuplets with that single tenor line more tumultuous and dramatic for some odd reason. really love the idea at 3:44 though. I like, really hope someone plays it like that!
Beautiful Song Sounds good on the piano
Would be nice if there was an 8d version of this!
I love this piece
Quintuplets madness and totally ridiculous left hand leaps, liszt was going real wild there lol
but it fits so nicely lel, and arguably somewhat more pianistic than Chopin's writing here
@@LiszthesisI wouldn't call those quintuplets with super uncomfortable repeated notes pianistic :P
@@GUILLOMno u
Liszt Ferenc really knows how to make Pianist head bang
Why is it better 😭😭
Very interesting. Is there sheet music available anywhere?
as far as we know the Muse Press company have published an edition from the same movement including Liszt's variant (which you can find in here: muse-press.com/en/product/mp09201/ ), also the American Liszt Society have published their own edition through one of their journals
@@LiszthesisThank you!
Can you do the solo arrangement of Totentanz at some point?
maybe but not too soon :/
I searched this opus in the wikipedia catalogue and found nothing, where was this published?
the catalogue on Wikipedia is pretty unreliable coz so many Liszt's previously unknown works have been catalogued since...
also this was, afaik, only published recently by Muse Press: muse-press.com/en/product/mp09201/
@@Liszthesis also published by the American Liszt Society Journal lel
Can you do Liszt sonata in B minor?
there are already several great videos over this piece so I think it is not quite necessary to dedicate one video about it
Is this why chopin was mad
Chopin was allegedly mad about Liszt's extemporaneous embellishments for one of his Nocturnes, not this piece. Also I don't think Chopin would have been mad about this faithful and more pianistic (if not necessarily better!) retranscription.
We - members of Liszthesis, are going to rebel because of Chopin's piece! 😅😂😂
actually Liszt still had a say in this piece so not enough a reason to rebel 😂🤣
@@LiszthesisWow, I haven't read the title "Chopin/Liszt Sonata №3". 🤥🥲
Aren't you happy }}
where can i find the sheet music?
well it can be found on this edition so sadly you have to buy it tho: muse-press.com/en/product/mp09201/
@@Liszthesis is that site legit lol, just to make sure i dont get scammed
@@cnqrrules we're not that mean to post scam links smh but if you're looking for a digital score then perhaps I could try to share it through your E-mail so you shall try contact us (liszttuile@gmail.com), you cannot post your E-mail source in here cuz as you may probably know the comments filter are deleting a couple of messages that have E-mail sources or any other contacting source
@@Liszthesisalright thank you ❤
noIce
where is score?
sorry...
I'm japanese.I don't speak and write...
lol, I actually don't know what is the difference of the Chopin's original piece and the Liszt's arrangement
what do you expect lul Chopin would have been very displeased were Liszt to further embellish this piece with his typical treatment (for the operatic fantasies for example)