An Emergency Landing Strikes Passengers and Paramedics | Trauma | MD TV
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 вер 2024
- When a plane makes an emergency landing, tragedy befalls not only the inevitable victims but also the paramedics who rush to the scene.
From Trauma Season 1 Episode 9 'Coming Home' - A plane makes an emergency landing & other Thanksgiving emergencies.
Watch full episodes of Trauma here: www.justwatch....
Welcome to MD TV! A channel dedicated to your favourite medical dramas! Featuring iconic moments from House M.D., Chicago Med and more. Follow the professional and personal lives of the hospital staff, as you go a journey right from the very first doctor's call to the E.R and beyond. MD TV is packed full of drama, intrigue, and plenty of medical emergencies!
#MDTV #trauma #MedicalDrama #MedicalTvShow
Thankfully accidents like this do not happen often, but that kind of system failure could either be terrible maintenance or just the plane being to old it just so happens to start falling apart.
Or new with defects.
@@karyannfontaine8757that too
@@karyannfontaine8757 no that is an older 737
@@aviationdoge8699 its a 737-300
Metal fatigue
😳 I’m paying attention to that safety demonstration at the beginning of my flight next time.
Please do! As a crew member myself its very important to know :)
Had a friend take a trip on a airplane. The staff were 'monsters' as she put it but not in a bad way. The moment the time came for the safety demo to start, The staff in the most polite way told everyone to 'sit down and shut up, put away ALL electronics besides what you need to hear, see or use via medicine (the insulin pumps phones). Then did the demo only to start over again if someone made a noise that wasn't needed (a child talking so to speak or a baby like that didn't count) It took the staff 20 extra minutes before the plane took off do to the no nonsense of the staff. The thing is that has not been a single complaint about the staff for the way they did the demos. As they were only 'monsters' when doing the demo and the rest of the time were sweet.
I always pay attention to it!!!
@@sassbratThat's the way it should be done!!! Kudos to the flight attendants for not taking any nonsense!!!
Sure, send two paramedics into a burning plane to do the job of firefighters, that makes sense. Next your gonna tell me the pilots were two TSA agents who decided to “step up to the plate”
Underrated comment 🤣
As far as I'm aware, firefighters have to have emt training too.
@@Voidi-Voidyep and vice versa.... actually they're both Firefighters and Paramedics it's usually dependent on their shift and the situation
@@Zephyr_Phoenix76 My home station has either specifically trained firefighters, medics who went through fire training after finishing NREMT, or medics, so as far as I'm aware there is no vice versa, Void is correct
So to the original comment, you wouldn't be seeing medics going into fires, it's only the firefighters, although most have medical training, however there was a little context missing, they sent in air medics, with proper protection, sent in for rescue, and usually from what I've heard from the other station guys, if they wouldn't be in immediate danger from the fire and can be protected, and there is a patient that needs immediate rescue, or locating they may send in a medic
isn't in US paramedics part of the fire department?
KELLY SEVERIDE? WHAT ARE YOU DOING HERE
Alameda Air Field is pretty much unused and torn up but the runway could still be landed on in a situation, albeit very unsafely. Oakland airport is literally just at the end of Alameda, maybe 2 miles by the crow south. SFFD and SFPD would NOT be involved since the crash would be in a separate city and county and across 2 bridges over the bay to get there. The plane would also not likely be ripped apart from a belly landing even at the rough unused airfield. In regards to medical evac and air evac, hospitals in SF would be on alert and treating passengers and crew, as they have when Asiana crashed at SFO. We have the trauma centers, so it would be full at that point. But so would Oakland and San Jose.
About the plane being ripped appart, it kinda depends on how the pilots landed it. If it was a totally flat belly landing then yeah I'd agree with you, but in this case they landed heavy on the tail first before the rest of the plane came down, which could cause the tail to rip off, but i doubt it would have been as perfectly split and settled like it was in this video
No one is going to be standing around the plane when the thing is still on fire
She gets shocked several times but it is immediately alert enough to hold her baby and cry. Sure...
that's not going to happen in real life
as a EMT myself i hate these kind of things
@@TOFMDrone Gee, almost like a TV SHOW isn't real life...
@@Kerorofan1990 hence why they STATED REAL LIFE SO THEY OBVIOUSLY KNOW THE DISTINCTION
They used a Boeing 727 cockpit on a 737-400, it very clearly has 3 engine fire exstinguish handles, and 3 engine steam gauges like come on..
As an avgeek it always hurts
Commercial airliners have belly landed before. They don't crash the way this video showed. The only way a plane could crash land & break up is if they didn't land level, as was the case of United Flight 232 or Asiana Flight 214!
Well yeah but...there is the possibility that jet engines will explode also it did look like before the belly landed the engine was already of fire and burning so they probably forgot to dump fuel
@@Zephyr_Phoenix76 I think, judging by the start of the video, the engine was already on fire, which was part and parcel of the reason for the emergency landing. Also, it's possible that (given it's said that there was something wrong with the hydraulics for the landing gear) the landing gear may have been partially down, or that one or more might not have been dropping, so that might have caused it to not land level.
when i saw the baby got out i breathed finally, god that was scary
This video is the reason I believe in God
Why would they triage next to the burning wreckage?
TV drama.
This is the most unrealistic clip I've seen in a while. That's not how a belly landing would work. That's not how that aircraft would respond. That's not how fire fighters would respond. They would never establish triage so close to a vehicle that could explode if it was actually on fire and there was such a lack of response with foam trucks. Folks would be directed to get as far from the wreckage as possible as soon as they evacuated regardless of injuries. Its like this show had absolutely no budget to do research or consult anyone in the industry.
heck thats not the worse parts need arff
And there shouldn’t be life threating injuries atc is wrong.
It's a show it doesn't need to be realistic shut up and watch the damn show
All they needed to do was watch The Flight Channel to see what happens.😂
They made do with budget available to them. Filming a realistic belly-landing crash would have been far too costly for a tv series especially when the crash is only a portion of the episode.
Don't know why they didn't lower the landing gear. You can still lower them without hydraulics as gravity will pull them down. No guarantee they will lock into place but better than landing on the belly of the plane
Dire situation, even gravity failed.
Depending on HOW they failed, they might not have been able to. In most cases yes, just a generic failure gravity works. But in other cases, they might fail because of a different reason preventing them from lowering in general, though those cases usually only has one gear with the issue, not all.
He said “we don’t have time to lower them manually” 🥴
Yeah, that was where the clip lost it for me. In most cases they would have done a gravity drop (as long as nothing prevented them from opening the doors for it.) and hoped they locked into place. But they were like "we don't have time to lower them manually" and I was like "what? is the co pilot going to crawl down into the cargo hold and flip a special switch or something?!?!"
I believe they said they didnt have time
But i agree. Some reason they seem to love "3min isnt enough to activate the back up" is takes less than a min to deploy
4:24 wait a minute, what’s the point in the heat resistant suit if you’re gonna take off your gloves?
The tarps are colored for triage of dealing with the most urgent medical conditions first. You don't want to be dragged to the black tarp.
I’m assuming black tarp = deceased.
Edit: watched the video some more,
it does in fact mean deceased.
@@IansGamingVault Deceased or soon-to-be-deceased.
@@jr637-1oh I don’t think I knew about the soon-to-deceased part.
What are the tarp colors?
@@sethcourtemanche5738
- Red for major and urgent injuries
- Orange for major but and not urgent
- Green for minor injuries but not majorly urgent
- Black, well Deceased or not viable for care
Just saying the cockpit is incorrect for the plane
its a dc-10 cockpit with a 737-300 external model lmao
@@topgun1457 XD
@@topgun1457 Well no wonder they crashed, it's a patchwork plane from 2 different manufactures! LOL
Best to learn how planes work before making a TV show out of it
Omg the baby is ok thank goodness ❤❤
Hey it's Severide
You know you watch too much Mayday when you can spot a million problems in this clip in the first 15 seconds.
Great segment, but it would take SFPD at least half an hour to get across the Bay Bridge to Alameda NAS. More likely Oakland and Alameda first responders would have gotten the call.
ah yes i clearly remember the 737-300 having the cockpit of a dc-10 idk why they did not just use a real 737 flight simulator the cockpit
I want that “morgue” blanket for my house.
emergency landing without "brace for impact", a burning plane and everyone chills there ON THE LANE? Crowded everywhere instead of leaving a possible exposion zone?
It honestly looked like there were skips
Ok first of all, san Francisco would NOT respond to Alameda, even for mutual aid. And second, if they can't make Oakland international airport, what makes you think they can make Alameda field? They're right next to each other. I know this because I lived in the bay area half my life
Oh belly landing those are rough
um actually with how it landed it would have felt like a slightly hard landing
All these comments saying how unrealistic this crash is puts my mind at ease. Especially since I have anxiety about flying.
I love how the firefighters are using just water for the fire on the plane XD I'm not an expert, but aren't you meant to use foam on a jet fuel fire? Water alone doesn't put fuel or oil fires out
And this is why I hate flying.
You must also hate travel on road as well since most of the incidents and accidents are on ground compared to aviation
The black tarp says “morgue.”
I'm looking at thsi and I'm like... The crash sequence is horrifying but inaccurate as it appears 1) they were at 5,000ft one moment and 1,000ft the next so they could definitely have unlocked the gear and let gravity lock them into place, 2) they're using the wrong cockpit, and 3) they're heading down at -5,000ft a minute one moment and -200ft a minute the next
That’s one way to get shaken baby syndrome
yeah I was thinking that
20 years later:
"Why are you afraid of flying?"
"I don't know. It just happens."
They were fortunate the plane didn't explode on contact with the ground
1:14 thats why people should look out eh?
you know, all things considered, that was a pretty good landing.
Yeah looks like one death maybe more at least one confirmed when they placed him on the black tarp
Nooooooooo not the baby boss😂
hello to all the aviation experts in the comments
Hi there!
Hi
Reminds me of Sully.
NTSB(national transportation, safety board) we have to investigate through this
That's kind of their job
Who names these jobs
the pilots failed to lower the landing gear. They could have done a better job at landing unless something broke with the landing gear. Also gear up landings have been done before but in that case, that plane landed intact and didn't break up.
There's mention of the gear hydraulics being damaged, and the pilots say something about "not having enough time to lower manually," so it's possible that the gear was partially extended (due to gravity) but not locked, or that they couldn't retract it/lock them back once they'd made the initial attempt, thus possibly leaving them with some but not all gear down.
@@Mokiefraggle Okay thats good to have brought in the context so as why the landing gear couldn't be deployed. And i get the crash was all for drama but realistically, it is possible to land a plane without landing gear.
So not real. The cabin looks like it went through extreme turbulence. Masks and intense shaking don’t come from an engine fire
DÉBORA JOÃOPAULO ❤️ ❤️ ❤️ ❤️
Flipping heck 😮😮😮😮😮
We all gonna die 1:00
1 minute in the video and all I'm thinking is 'is the baby ok?' 😮
I know its a television drama series.
I would have done a water landing (seeing that the landing gears were inoperable)
On the other hand, the runway should have been foamed completely.
(I have a background and experience in disaster management, logistics and preparation. I also do disaster exercises at our two airports on island)
Dominica 🇩🇲
Atleast the baby is ok
How do the writers even keep their jobs? They would not keep passengers that close to a plane on fire and there were no airport emergency vehicles spraying foam. Poor writing and research.
Wow, this looked so cool,
Until you realize people died
Not so cool when people can die!!!
Wait what movie is this?
It's from a show called Triage. I don't know what episode though
@@carbonwolf3865 thx
legitimate question, would landing in the water in an emergency landing be safer? Like would it soften the impact because the surface wouldn’t be soft rough concrete?
Edit: I mean in this situation, would landing in the lake instead of the runway have been better in this situation
That much mass at that speed, hitting the water is no different than hitting concrete. Also, given where they were, they'd most likely be landing in the San Francisco Bay, and...we have _sharks._ Like, I don't recall hearing a lot of stories about shark attacks there, but we have a city called Tiburon for a reason. Also, you have to worry about how quickly it'd sink, and a whole host of other things...probably not that much safer.
While the idea of landing on water is a desirable, it's probably worse to do so. The reasons are that landing on water at that speed would cause the plane to break up. Aircraft are not water tight, so landing in water will create a different hazard for the passengers, instead of fire there is water. Generally it is better to land on a runway or plateau than it is to land on water.
Specifically in this case, it was probably the best decision to land on the runway. It is safer for the passengers after landing due to the lack of water invading into the aircraft, the response time of emergency responders is practically instantaneous, and it provides an area for said responders to do their work.
Currents in SF Bay are very strong. Victims could potentially be swept out to sea. The water is also quite cold even in summer.
what show is this?
What about the baby is he still alive??
I hope the baby is ok❤ 😢
Wear your seat belt
Now this is what I don’t understand and I understand that this is a movie but still, how did everybody on that plane get injured or have like a mark on them but the baby didn’t get anything. And the baby wasn’t fastened in a seat. The mother was literally holding the car seat.
Triage and I believe it's a show
Why couldn't they land in the water?
Water landings have their own problems and are not really any safer. They also make it exponentially harder for any first responders
The Sully incident was a rare lucky exception but far away from the norm. Usually water landings with jets will cause the plane to break apart immediately and/or flip over.
@@pythagorasaurusrex9853 Yeah, because in most cases, impacts with water at high speeds (or from a considerable elevation) are like plowing into concrete. Water can behave as a non-Newtonian fluid, and basically becomes harder to cut through the more impact force applied across a broader space. It's why leaping off a bridge and just slamming flat into the water below will likely kill you or break bones on impact, but you could potentially survive by landing with a narrow point first (diving, or landing feet-first).
This means that the plane would basically be hitting something that despite being liquid, would essentially behave as a solid surface at the moment of impact.
The plane would rip in half on impact,no?
They would have been better off with a water landing if they don’t have landing gear
No. If there is no nearest suitable runway or at least open field to emergency land, water landing is the last resort.
With or without landing gear, you can still land a plane on a runway or a suitable open field.
❤❤❤❤❤
Why did the paramedic go in? That was silly! If it’s burning and someone is still in the priority is to get them OUT then revive! Doing too much for the scene! 😅😅😅
Can I help you with cpr 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Uhh this seems to be staged is that true still a thrill though
2nd
Shouldn't they have told the passengers to brace for impact?
In high shock impact its somewhat better to be limp and unprepared as the limp body rebounds a bit more against the shock but a tensed body creates a wall at 100 miles an hour meets a wall standing still
That was Sully. Different case. 🙃
I think that these are clipped, so we probably didn't see that part, or they might have just not had that be part of the episode, because they wanted to focus more on the passengers and/or the pilots. Hollywood doesn't always keep the practical.
@@pythagorasaurusrex9853It still applies to any aircraft incidents, not only on Sully
Glad they saved the mum and baby
I work as a patient roleplayer in the UK, sometimes running "disaster relief" scenarios exactly like this one, and honestly it's impressive how accurate this was. Better than some of the med students who've practiced triage on me in the past, haha.
2:42 yeah because at a scene like that with multipal red tagged Patients 2 Paramedics will care about a standing women xD
Ok am I the only one talking how that baby did even get the black smoke in her/his face
Interesting and sad vid.
They make this so real! It’s cool!!