Edward R Murrow's final reply to Senator Joseph McCarthy's See It Now appearance April 13, 1954

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 5 сер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 198

  • @kaljic1
    @kaljic1 3 роки тому +145

    Lord, we need people like Edward R. Murrow today!

    • @rareblues78daddy
      @rareblues78daddy 2 роки тому +4

      Sadly, we'll never have someone with this much integrity again.
      There's a reason people call men like Murrow "legendary."

    • @jamiemoody2675
      @jamiemoody2675 Рік тому

      You do. The country is filled with traitors just like him and the truth will not be told till Shiloh come.
      All of your so-called "great" news casters:
      Edward R. Murrow
      Anderson Cooper
      Walter Cronkite
      Cookie Roberts
      Barbara Walters
      Eric Sevareid
      ...
      we're all trained at Quantico by the CIA. The older ones of WWII variety WERE trained by the OSS. ALL of the heads of every major media outlet are part of T-H-I-S conspiracy.
      All of them!
      McCarthy was murdered, as was dear little Dorothy [brave heart] Kilgallen, William Cooper along with the 26 witnesses to the Kennedy debacle in Dallas who saw the "clowns", the shooters behind the picket fence and new the Truth that the Warren commission was setup to cover-up.
      No!!
      Nothing has changed. The traitor Alger Hiss and the Luciferian Spangler sold the U.S. out at the League of Nations clownery of 1945 and later...in the U.N.
      The men & women you love: Obama, Ruth Ginsburg, the Clinton cartel, Rothschilds, Rockefellers, Hillary, Bill and the Bush crime family...will burn in Hell for what they have done.
      The poor, sole Americans who were murdered on the way to give true testimony...those killed in their sleep...the ravaging of the great Christian Republic of 1776 by embedded, generational moles, elitist, Fabian socialists and satanists have worked for this day.
      It is your hour!!!
      Satan is the god of Amerika.
      Jesus is calumniated.
      Christians are hated.
      Women are men.en are women. Our luciferian leaders hate the 3 foundational documents that were the basis of our greatness:
      The Bible
      The constitution
      The Bill-of-Rights
      Now, we have no honor, no morals, no borders, no God...and...soon...
      No hope

    • @caseystinnett6514
      @caseystinnett6514 Рік тому +5

      We have people like him today, but no one listens to them.

    • @jimroberts8140
      @jimroberts8140 Рік тому +6

      Murrow was a giant, propelled to fame by his gripping wartime broadcasts from London during the blitz. Rachel Maddow is the closest to being his equal as a crusading writer and broadcaster.

    • @davidbostock6933
      @davidbostock6933 Рік тому

      Strange, none of you bother to mention Bernie Sanders in your silly whines.

  • @kerrykeene6471
    @kerrykeene6471 2 роки тому +30

    I'd say the closest, if not equal, would be Walter Cronkite. LBJ said that, when he lost Cronkite's support for the Vietnam War, he knee the public's support would also decline. It did.
    Edward R. Murrow had integrity and the guts to call out McCarthy as a liar. I wonder how he'd be received today, as divided as we are?

  • @bigbob1699
    @bigbob1699 4 роки тому +61

    He made speaking an art form . Thanks a lot Ed.

  • @LPMAN02
    @LPMAN02 2 роки тому +44

    “Good Night, and Good Luck”
    RIP and long live Edward R. Murrow (April 25, 1908 - April 27, 1965), aged 57
    You will always be remembered as a legend and a hero.

  • @schroedericeman7200
    @schroedericeman7200 7 місяців тому +9

    One of the greatest disses in history

  • @timlewis1165
    @timlewis1165 3 місяці тому +4

    He was one of those civilised individuals who did not insist upon agreement with his political principles as a precondition for conversation or friendship.
    Chills

  • @amaramilligan349
    @amaramilligan349 2 роки тому +12

    Gather round little children and pay attention! This is real journalism not infotainment.

  • @matthewwhitton5720
    @matthewwhitton5720 Рік тому +19

    God bless Mr Murrow.

  • @messiahsbythesackful6267
    @messiahsbythesackful6267 2 роки тому +13

    We have learned nothing...

  • @pcbacklash_3261
    @pcbacklash_3261 10 місяців тому +20

    Once upon a time, Joseph Welch devastated McCarthy by asking him, _"...Have you no sense of decency, sir? At long last, have you left no sense of decency?"_ McCarthy had no reply. Now, nearly 70 years later, the GOP finally has an answer: _"Nope."_

    • @badgeswedontneednostinking5571
      @badgeswedontneednostinking5571 8 місяців тому +1

      Exactly right

    • @EuropeanQoheleth
      @EuropeanQoheleth 8 місяців тому

      Hitchens had no decency either.

    • @johnhummer265
      @johnhummer265 4 місяці тому +3

      Dalton Trumbo, a screenwriter, who was one of the 'Hollywood Ten' who refused to testify before HUAC summed it up best in reference the the committees conduct during the HUAC investigations...." It will do no good to look for heros or villians, because there were none, only victims."

    • @glennvastine5713
      @glennvastine5713 29 днів тому

      This from the Party of Jeffery Epstein?
      I’ll assume you were kidding.

    • @pcbacklash_3261
      @pcbacklash_3261 29 днів тому

      @@glennvastine5713 So _who_ is the "party of Jeffery Epstein? The Democrats, because Epstein partied with Clinton? Or the Republicans, because Epstein partied with Trump?
      I stand by my comment. The currency of today's GOP is lies, lies and more lies.

  • @deanfiora4227
    @deanfiora4227 Рік тому +9

    I strongly recommend Joseph E. Persico's 1988 biography, "Edward R. Murrow: An American Original."

  • @tonnnyy7766
    @tonnnyy7766 6 місяців тому +3

    This great reactionary radio commentator is much needed today.
    Big business is in bed with big government these days. Monopolies run everything and hold change hostage.

  • @adolfeichman9919
    @adolfeichman9919 2 роки тому +28

    Murrow would be called a radical now because he told the truth. In an Era of deceit telling the truth is a revolutionary act. Also J Edgar hoover was right about Mccarthy "Sen Mccarthy is nothing but an opportunist and lacks any real reason or logic"

    • @matthewgabbard6415
      @matthewgabbard6415 28 днів тому

      Which is just a bit ironic coming from Hoover. But he was right this time

  • @richardwrynn824
    @richardwrynn824 4 роки тому +71

    Imagine what McCarthy would have been like if he had twitter...

    • @WalkmanYT
      @WalkmanYT 3 роки тому +10

      LMAO

    • @paulzapodeanu9407
      @paulzapodeanu9407 3 роки тому +23

      All one needs to do is look at Trump'# tweets. Though you probably lose 1 iq poin every time you read one.

    • @WalkmanYT
      @WalkmanYT 3 роки тому +10

      @@paulzapodeanu9407 Yea, and it's also weird to imagine it the other way around, as if Donald never had Twitter.

    • @DorvellTStewart
      @DorvellTStewart 3 роки тому +4

      I assume that’s meant to be sarcastic, tongue in cheek or whatever; we don’t need to imagine, as the current occupant of the White House could easily be McCarthy 2.0 at least.

    • @skymaster4743
      @skymaster4743 3 роки тому

      Down with Cultural Marxism
      #COMMIEINFILTRATION

  • @mikehersh6192
    @mikehersh6192 8 місяців тому +2

    Good night and good luck. We The People 2023. 🌵🌵🌵💃🕺👩‍🎓👨‍🎓

  • @bryanthomsen5551
    @bryanthomsen5551 4 роки тому +46

    Somebody needed to stand up to McCarthy and expose him for the bully and the blowhard that he was.

  • @brettfavreify
    @brettfavreify Рік тому +7

    "I require no lectures from the junior senator from Wisconsin...."

    • @mikehersh6192
      @mikehersh6192 11 місяців тому

      None of us do

    • @MericaMotherFucker
      @MericaMotherFucker 11 днів тому

      Epic takedown. One of the very best when you consider the follow through.

  • @AGMundy
    @AGMundy Рік тому +6

    A devastating destruction of the horrible McCarthy.

  • @arsinoe92283
    @arsinoe92283 11 місяців тому +5

    "Anchors having an opinion isn't a new phenomenon. Murrow had one and that was the end of McCarthy. Cronkite had one and that was the end of Vietnam."

    • @JonWestphall
      @JonWestphall 7 місяців тому

      I believe you're quoting a line spoken by the character Will McAvoy from "The Newsroom", a terrific HBO show done by Aaron Sorkin. The pilot episode's opening scene was fantastic with Will's rant at Northwestern on the state of America. It's no less applicable today. Sorkin clearly has a lot of respect for what the journalists of yesteryear brought to us that is now sadly lacking- truth spoken directly to those in power.

    • @nsnopper
      @nsnopper Місяць тому

      There is nothing wrong with a news anchor having an opinion. It becomes problematic when we have nothing but opinion and streams-of-consciousness rants - whether on the left or right. The opinions of Murrow and Cronkite mattered because they reported the news AS NEWS - as objectively and matter-of-factly as is possible (without spiralling down into phenomenological analysis which . . . well, let’s not go there). Cronkite was deemed The Most Trusted Man in America. When he spoke from the heart, he clearly said this was now editorial opinion, and people listened.

  • @jerometaperman7102
    @jerometaperman7102 8 місяців тому +3

    "He claimed but offered no proof..." This can and has been readily applied to Donald J. Trump today.

    • @annalisavajda252
      @annalisavajda252 Місяць тому

      Well actually Trump was also wrongfully accused of Russian Collusion by the Democrats but he did call the New York AG a communist too Americans seem to enjoy the red scare on both sides of the aisle and people are ignorant about it.

  • @prepostmodern1032
    @prepostmodern1032 2 роки тому +31

    Mc Carthy was a lot like many in the GOP and Trump today. The difference is that these days people don't take time to see through them.

    • @thebossbaby7402
      @thebossbaby7402 Рік тому

      Nah, if anything trump and the gop have witch hunts and definitely aren’t committed to the truth. Anyone who disagrees them is a “woke liberal commie” or something. I guarantee you if he were alive today, Murrow would denounce Trump and the GOP.

    • @lilajagears8317
      @lilajagears8317 Рік тому +1

      So says the leftist moron.

    • @thebossbaby7402
      @thebossbaby7402 Рік тому

      @@lilajagears8317 see that’s what I’m talking about. People like you say anyone who makes fun of your cult leader is a “leftist moron” or some shit. It’s like you have a hard on for him

    • @retiredusvet4396
      @retiredusvet4396 Рік тому +1

      Right. Ignore the liberal media covering up for and championing the disaster that is Sleepy Joe and his crooked, inept administration.
      I believe Mr. Murrow wouldn't be a part of that farce today that denigrates and attacks President Trump, and he'd be under the attack of liberals and democrats- and many RINOS, too!

    • @lilajagears8317
      @lilajagears8317 Рік тому +1

      @@retiredusvet4396 Absolutely no doubt about it.

  • @augustbear6548
    @augustbear6548 3 роки тому +12

    How timely.

  • @johnnyballenatl
    @johnnyballenatl Рік тому +12

    Think about it: If it wasn’t for Milo Radulovich, we would’ve had _President_ Joe McCarthy instead of John F. Kennedy.
    (Milo Radulovich, by the way, was the man responsible for the See It Now broadcast that led to McCarthy’s downfall; he died in 2007 at age 81)

    • @canofpizzasauce667
      @canofpizzasauce667 Рік тому

      Thank you Milo.

    • @ThomasPashko
      @ThomasPashko 16 днів тому

      Radulovich wasn't responsible for the broadcast, he was the subject of a news report by Murrow.

  • @PGar58
    @PGar58 4 роки тому +23

    ‘Good night and good luck.’ (mic drop)

  • @djnofly
    @djnofly 3 роки тому +36

    Thank you for posting. We need more Murrow's these days

  • @johncourt6434
    @johncourt6434 8 місяців тому +3

    I would like to have hear what he would think of todays USA. But I am sure he would not pull any punches re MAGA and Trump.

  • @edenalcantara8472
    @edenalcantara8472 4 роки тому +15

    The last nail to the coffin.

  • @donnasloane9031
    @donnasloane9031 23 дні тому

    Bravo!

  • @thegreatrenaldo7718
    @thegreatrenaldo7718 3 місяці тому +1

    Jerry Seinfeld sent me here via the Rich Eisen show interview

  • @rgplpc
    @rgplpc Рік тому +1

    Unfortunately, we Americans apparently have learned little from the McCarthy mess. We continue to elect individuals who boast of their love for their country while campaigning, but manifest their hate for any fellow citizen that does not agree after the election.

  • @nsnopper
    @nsnopper Місяць тому

    I recommend the movie Good Night and Good Luck (2005), which told story of the McCarthy - Murrow TV duel.

  • @mikehersh6192
    @mikehersh6192 Рік тому

    Spot on. 😊

  • @johnsradios484
    @johnsradios484 7 місяців тому +2

    And 70 years later we got Trump!

    • @JayCity10
      @JayCity10 2 місяці тому

      Who is among the greatest presidents ever. Thank you Sen. McCarthy, you were a hero. Despite what leftists and Communists say or do.

  • @KonElKent
    @KonElKent 3 роки тому +20

    "... We must conclude that [McCarthy] found [no errors of fact]."
    And the mic was dropped.

    • @BGNOLA
      @BGNOLA 3 роки тому

      The Venona transcripts proved McCarthy was more right than wrong.

    • @richardn6768
      @richardn6768 3 роки тому +3

      @@BGNOLA plainly and simply absurd

    • @BGNOLA
      @BGNOLA 3 роки тому

      @@richardn6768 This is obviously the first time you've heard about Venona, so it does come as a shock.

    • @oskarr5201
      @oskarr5201 2 роки тому +1

      @@BGNOLA To some degree, the documents may prove legitimacy of McCarthy's fear, but they do not rationalize his silencing of peoples, sowing fear with broad strokes or his blatant disregard for due process. Fear mongering and accusations born from slander and gossip is unprofessional and not warranted by the proof of spies.

    • @BGNOLA
      @BGNOLA 2 роки тому

      @@oskarr5201 All of those accused in the McCarthy hearings had due process. I think you're confusing him with HUAC.

  • @user-bo3qq3ux5k
    @user-bo3qq3ux5k Рік тому

    영상 잘봤습니다. 학교 과제로 사용해도 될까요?

  • @emiliek2269
    @emiliek2269 3 роки тому +23

    If only ANYONE in journalism or Congress today had the balls Murrow did, maybe the narcissistic former holder of the office of the President wouldn’t have been able to do such damage to American “democracy “.

    • @ronfarbman8124
      @ronfarbman8124 3 роки тому +1

      A PERFECT reply. Stand up, even if you stand alone!!!

    • @BGNOLA
      @BGNOLA 3 роки тому +4

      Right, because the media was too nice to Trump. ;)

    • @JDYTC
      @JDYTC 2 роки тому +1

      I think you’d be surprised how Murrow would expose the hypocrisy, demagoguery and race-baiting of the woke political left nowadays and how utterly ironic it is that after a year of BLM-riots Biden & Harris of all people got elected 🤡 (I don’t think there is a couple of politicians that carry more responsibility for the mass incarnation of blacks than those two lol.)
      Nonetheless, could you please elaborate and add some arguments to your hilariously baseless and empty opinion? What “damage” did Trump exactly do “to American democracy” and how did he do that??
      Since I am a libertarian i.e. against any form slavery, I myself am not a follower of the religion called “democracy”, or political authority at all for that matter, but I am just curious if and how you would backup your primitive and baseless claim? 🤡

    • @marcot3333
      @marcot3333 2 роки тому

      @@JDYTC What about the dog whistling to race haters, tax scofflaws, pedophiles, religious fanatics Republicans do?

    • @saeed7099
      @saeed7099 2 роки тому

      @@BGNOLA do you even read,/ comprehend what you right? How on earth could have much, if any, impact on African Americans being incarcerated?

  • @Afreon
    @Afreon 3 роки тому +14

    "He was one of those civilized individuals who did not insist upon agreement with his political principles as a precondition for conversation or friendship"
    I remember hearing that line in Good Night and Good Luck and grinning from ear to ear. It would be naive and romantic to believe there was a time when that attitude could be assumed. But I would hope it isn't considered naive or romantic to have assumed that we, as a people, we're moving towards such a frame if thought. It saddens me that we (apparently at least) are not

    • @totallynotalpharius2283
      @totallynotalpharius2283 3 роки тому +5

      Yep. I'm a socialist , several of my friends are conservatives. When politics come up we disagree. We're still friends because we know each other as good people

  • @petersmith5219
    @petersmith5219 Рік тому

    The Edward R Murrows exist in of all places Australia. Take a look how Jonathan Swan deals with today's politicians. Australia is full of journalists like Swan who have drawn upon the example of Murrow in their own reporting style. Politicians as people are shown no deference - their position is held in high regard but not the individual. Not even their prime minister.

  • @Deadprez41
    @Deadprez41 Рік тому +3

    We need more man like him now. I think Keith Oberman is as close as we are going g to vet

  • @hmonster1XL
    @hmonster1XL 2 роки тому +13

    So basically Trump wasn’t even original in his methods.

    • @heathspencer8450
      @heathspencer8450 Рік тому +3

      Exactly. Demagogues have always existed in American politics, sadly, they're just becoming more effective these days.

    • @roystonmason9125
      @roystonmason9125 Рік тому +3

      ROY COHN was TRUMPS LAWYER

  • @user-eo9ie7zn9p
    @user-eo9ie7zn9p 6 місяців тому

    Yeah, THUAC went after Walt Disney, U.S. Army, Red Cross, Fed. French, Spanish, English American. MI KS native.

  • @jimmyflanagan5938
    @jimmyflanagan5938 7 місяців тому +1

    And a Walter Cronkite

  • @RobynHode8
    @RobynHode8 11 місяців тому

    Would have been interesting to see him put Trump in his place.

  • @JW4REnvironment
    @JW4REnvironment Місяць тому

    Trump sounds a lot like McCarthy, to our potential peril!

  • @mikeorclem
    @mikeorclem Рік тому +3

    ed was a true american..good man who stuck to his guns thru thick and thin.

  • @johnnyappleseed856
    @johnnyappleseed856 3 роки тому +1

    Wow, how the roles have reversed! Give it time!

  • @thomasupton2664
    @thomasupton2664 Рік тому +1

    Sound like Trump?

  • @Rabithebengali
    @Rabithebengali 10 місяців тому

    Murrow did not take on McCarthy till he was on the way out

  • @shaystern2453
    @shaystern2453 11 місяців тому

    sound like trumpism

  • @timm_3r
    @timm_3r Рік тому

    No wonder why msnbc thinks he's the cat's meow.

  • @fountbrooks2997
    @fountbrooks2997 Рік тому

    This was Tucker Carlson in 1956 pretty much.

    • @buckeyewill2166
      @buckeyewill2166 Рік тому

      Nope.

    • @roystonmason9125
      @roystonmason9125 Рік тому

      @@buckeyewill2166 YUP

    • @damianlynch872
      @damianlynch872 10 місяців тому +3

      To refer to tucker carlson in the same sentence as Mr Murrow should only be in terms of polar opposites in terms of temperament and conduct.

    • @jimmyflanagan5938
      @jimmyflanagan5938 7 місяців тому +3

      Carlson couldn't carry water for this great patriot.

  • @johnnyappleseed856
    @johnnyappleseed856 3 роки тому +3

    Hey, it's Tucker Carlson!

    • @richardn6768
      @richardn6768 3 роки тому +16

      comparing Murrow to Carlson is like comparing a pumpkin pie to a cow pie

    • @JC-jj7kt
      @JC-jj7kt 2 роки тому

      Mmmmm pumpkin pie

    • @lilajagears8317
      @lilajagears8317 Рік тому +1

      I will take Tucker over this leftist bozo anyday.

    • @johnnypastrana6727
      @johnnypastrana6727 Рік тому

      Carlson is the only real journalist in mainstream America...

    • @donlittle732
      @donlittle732 Рік тому +1

      Now Carlson is unemployed

  • @hawks7775
    @hawks7775 2 роки тому

    anyone looking for a great intelligent communicator look into jordan peterson..give him a chance in many topics before judging..

  • @BGNOLA
    @BGNOLA 3 роки тому +4

    McCarthy was right.

  • @mrearlygold
    @mrearlygold 3 роки тому +5

    McCarthy was right!