Steam Stoker Engine: Setting up the Main Casting on the Metal Planer

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 13 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 300

  • @chrischapel9165
    @chrischapel9165 21 годину тому +113

    OMG, the STOKER is BACK! I've been waiting for this for what,2 yrs maybe 3? ...

    • @danielcobbins8861
      @danielcobbins8861 21 годину тому +1

      Me, too. I was wondering when Keith would restart this project.

    • @zorbakaput8537
      @zorbakaput8537 20 годин тому +8

      Try 5 years.

    • @chrisquinn3751
      @chrisquinn3751 19 годин тому +8

      I remember it coming into the shop and some of the earlier machining - but I can't remember how long ago it was! I'm bowled over to see it on the shaper, maybe that is what they used to machine it originally. This will be the most interesting Vintage Machinery project in some time, and that is saying an awful lot. Good luck Keith, there will be a lot of people rooting for you. A very happy Christmas to you and your family and a healthy and prosperous 2025.

    • @chrischapel9165
      @chrischapel9165 19 годин тому

      @@zorbakaput8537 really? WOW

    • @tpobrienjr
      @tpobrienjr 17 годин тому +1

      I recall seeing one of those in operation on a N&W locomotive, courtesy of my grandfather, who let me hitch a ride in the cab, for a very short run between Crewe and Farmville, VA. It was amazing, and no shovel was required!

  • @Blondihacks
    @Blondihacks 9 годин тому +12

    So wonderful to see this back, Keith! This is probably my favourite project of yours. 😄 Wonderful work, as always.

    • @Pamudder
      @Pamudder 4 години тому

      My thoughts exactly

  • @thirzapeevey2395
    @thirzapeevey2395 14 годин тому +9

    So glad to see this project back on the front burner. Really sorry that the crankshaft guy suffered so much.

  • @jamesbonnema1041
    @jamesbonnema1041 20 годин тому +25

    I can't see you ever getting bored during retirement! And I'm thankful to you for sharing your projects!

    • @DavidSellars-b8l
      @DavidSellars-b8l 13 годин тому

      I'm not sure that Keith knows that he's retired. More like just doesn't go to one job anymore but full time at his part time gig. At some point, that shop will have to acquire more square feet and hopefully a bridge crane.

  • @FredMiller
    @FredMiller 19 годин тому +19

    As a LONG time viewer I am so pleased to see you working again on this project. Since you started the Planer rebuild I had an idea that its first big job would be this casting. Best of luck on making the tooling. They certainly have the right man with the right machine for this very special job...

  • @billdoodson4232
    @billdoodson4232 17 годин тому +22

    I recall that Adam Booth had a go at this with his big shaper and due to tool access issues he couldn't do it. Looking forward to seeing how it goes on the planer.

    • @philipmackin1025
      @philipmackin1025 16 годин тому +2

      I remember that. Hopefully Keith can make his tool rigid enough for the job.

    • @garybrenner6236
      @garybrenner6236 8 годин тому +1

      This should be a lot of laughs!

    • @ydonl
      @ydonl 3 години тому

      @@garybrenner6236 huh? If you’re saying what I think you’re saying, I’m not sure I’d want a friend like you.

  • @markbernier8434
    @markbernier8434 19 годин тому +12

    This one goes back so far maybe it deserves a playlist of its own.

  • @Turbo-Drew
    @Turbo-Drew 16 годин тому +13

    Really "Stoked " to see this Again... Hope i live long enough to see it Completed :D

  • @geneard639
    @geneard639 20 годин тому +14

    YAY! Finally its back! Its been close to 5 years since we last saw this!

    • @Hoaxer51
      @Hoaxer51 16 годин тому

      It doesn’t seem that long, time sure flies!

  • @namespacetoosmall
    @namespacetoosmall 20 годин тому +14

    I'm surprised nobody said yet they're stoked to see this project back 😉

    • @phlodel
      @phlodel 17 годин тому +2

      Somebody needed to say it. This is one of those times you get to be somebody.

    • @CothranMike
      @CothranMike 16 годин тому +2

      I see what you did there!

  • @donkultgen4643
    @donkultgen4643 17 годин тому +6

    Great...now I have 17 videos to watch from the Stoker playlist!!

  • @robertmatthews4285
    @robertmatthews4285 19 годин тому +10

    Glad to see this back. This project is why I started watching the channel.

  • @WillyBemis
    @WillyBemis 10 годин тому +2

    So happy to see the stocker engine again! Looking forward to the story going forward.

  • @HaraldFinster
    @HaraldFinster 19 годин тому +4

    That's quite a coincidence: I talked about this (seemingly dead) project to someone and was wondering why you don't use your metal planer. Thus, I am delighted to see exactly this approach becoming reality. A special thanks for sharing your setup procedure and your "thinking aloud" while doing it. Personally, I find it pretty easy to show chips flying but really hard to explain the thinking behind any non trivial setup. You are doing an excellent job on this.

    • @Mishn0
      @Mishn0 16 годин тому +1

      I had a suspicion that the planer was such a high priority because Keith saw it as the solution to the stoker.

  • @edsmachine93
    @edsmachine93 9 годин тому +4

    Thanks Keith, nice setup.
    Big job for sure.
    Thanks for sharing.
    Have a great weekend. 👍🇺🇸👍

  • @Steve2024-y6h
    @Steve2024-y6h 11 годин тому +2

    An automatic stoker looks like every fireman’s dream machine. My late father drove locomotives for British Railways, his favourite comment was ‘people who like steam locomotives wouldn’t be so keen if they had to shovel forty tons of coal from Doncaster to Kings Cross and another forty on the way back’.
    (Kings Cross is in London).

  • @bryansmant870
    @bryansmant870 19 годин тому +5

    Great to see this project coming back! Looking forward to seeing the tool holder build.

  • @alexguir903
    @alexguir903 17 годин тому +3

    Stoker, stoker... o yes, the stoker!
    Any project you work on it is facinating to see how you always have the necessary tools. Also you always put the affort into getting the set up right so that the actual work is smooth, easy and accurate. Looking forward to that tool holder project.

  • @paulgammidge-jefferson9536
    @paulgammidge-jefferson9536 19 годин тому +5

    Thank you Keith. Wonderful. Spending time with you is always enjoyable and worthwhile.

  • @Pamudder
    @Pamudder 3 години тому

    It’s great to see the stoker engine project moving ahead again. And perhaps even greater to see the metal planer working, after having watched your major investment of time, effort and money into restoring that very ancient machine tool and then not having many jobs for it.

  • @masteruniverse3506
    @masteruniverse3506 15 годин тому +2

    As usual, you are rebuilding things to closer tolerances than the original build.

  • @311Bob
    @311Bob 18 годин тому +3

    always thought your hbm was for this,I guessed wrong. for awhile I thought I missed the finishing of this project, and was looking for it in your list of projects now I know why I couldn't find it. now if I can see diesel creeks gantry crane go up my life will be complete.

  • @normmcrae1140
    @normmcrae1140 20 годин тому +2

    Glad to see the Stoker Engine back! Sounds like you have a decent plan and solutions for a tough problem! Nice to see the 100+ year old Planer getting put to use to do a job that MODERN machines can't seem to do!

  • @johnmcanulty7341
    @johnmcanulty7341 14 годин тому

    I'm confident of project success, thank you for explaining the slowdown - now I'm excited to see the completed stoker in action.

  • @DAKOTANSHELBY
    @DAKOTANSHELBY 19 годин тому +2

    Christmas arrived early this year! It's the return of the Steam Stoker Engine!

  • @MickOhrberg
    @MickOhrberg 16 годин тому +1

    THIS is a blast from the past - this is too cool for school!

  • @WreckDiver99
    @WreckDiver99 18 годин тому +5

    Well, for the troll/hater that has been going after Keith for being a hack, and ignoring the stoker engine. Here you go. It's here!
    Thanks Keith, and 100% understandable why this has been on the back burner. It's great to see the engine getting some love. I agree with the assessment that this had a dedicated, single purpose machine working on this item. It isn't that uncommon for machines to be purpose made for one task. Having been in the automotive world, we quite literally have THOUSANDS of single task machines that are built for making parts or even assembling vehicles.

    • @CothranMike
      @CothranMike 17 годин тому +3

      That would be gary brenner

    • @paulcopeland9035
      @paulcopeland9035 12 годин тому

      @@CothranMike Yes, it would! Gary can now peacefully move on to other channels with his constant bitching and "know-it-all" attitude!!

    • @garybrenner6236
      @garybrenner6236 8 годин тому

      @@CothranMike Hallelujah, Hallelujah, this should be lots of laughs!
      And BTW I am not a "hater", I just have the balls to say what any competent machinist is thinking when watching this guy!
      Case in point, what he is trying to machine off is a layer of metal that he and an accomplice weld layered onto the floor of that casting, now he is indicating off of those surfaces that are warped, and possibly hairline cracked, from the heat of that welding!
      I am a machinist, and when I want to enjoy a good one I go to CEE, I just watch this guy for laughs!

    • @CothranMike
      @CothranMike 5 годин тому

      @garybrenner6236 Gary, you know Keith had nothing to do with any welding on the stoker. He had nothing to do with the metal addition done by both Lance and Adam. Also, that work was done at non-welding temps if you remember. Would you have done this in a different fashion? Please tell us in some detail what YOU would do.

    • @ydonl
      @ydonl 2 години тому

      @@garybrenner6236 Are you sure you don’t have some kind of ego problem? Always trying to prove how magnificent you are?

  • @williamhastings7182
    @williamhastings7182 6 годин тому +1

    Been waiting to.see this stoker engine again for like 3 years ago and even when Abom took a stab at it too...let get a plan and get it done...been waiting for I think 3 years to see it again

  • @GooseGosselin
    @GooseGosselin 18 годин тому +1

    Can't help but think of the term "herding cats" seeing you get that levelled out, well done!

  • @fireotters
    @fireotters 20 годин тому +2

    I am fairly certain that this is the first project I found your channel through as you were disassembling this stoker. Glad to see it again!

  • @joe74ta1
    @joe74ta1 7 годин тому

    That's very impressive accuracy nice group Sam

  • @marcpavlik
    @marcpavlik 16 годин тому +1

    I figured this was one main reason for that planer. Great to see the stoker again.

  • @bulletproofpepper2
    @bulletproofpepper2 Годину тому

    Thanks for sharing. Great set up video explaining you findings.

  • @scania357
    @scania357 11 годин тому

    Can remember this project well and wondered what had happened to it. Glad to see it back, very interesting.

  • @phillipjones3342
    @phillipjones3342 5 годин тому

    Well alright finally a challenge for you Mr Keith can't wait to see your new tool go to work

  • @pdxRetired
    @pdxRetired 13 годин тому

    It will be fun to see the old planer earn it's keep! Making the tool holder will also be interesting from the standpoint of DIY.

  • @rgigliotti7576
    @rgigliotti7576 19 годин тому +2

    Nice to see the Stoker back!!!!

  • @patrickcolahan7499
    @patrickcolahan7499 16 годин тому +1

    This thing has sure made its rounds. Difficult access. Looks like the planer is the final answer. Thanks for sharing.

  • @tudedude
    @tudedude 9 годин тому

    Nicely done - a lot of work just preparing to cut.

  • @sbrunner69
    @sbrunner69 4 години тому

    This is a bold endeavor.

  • @russtuff
    @russtuff 20 годин тому +2

    It's back!!

  • @walterplummer3808
    @walterplummer3808 20 годин тому +2

    Good morning Keith! Good to see the project come back. Have a great weekend.

  • @marcelpost4052
    @marcelpost4052 12 годин тому

    I just watched the first episode of the stoker engine project and boy, do you look a whole lot healthier now! Good on ya, Keith!

  • @paulputnam2305
    @paulputnam2305 8 годин тому

    Woohoo! Way to go on the setup Professor!

  • @Prewarpostwaramdmore
    @Prewarpostwaramdmore 16 годин тому

    I got so excited when I saw the stoker engine back. I had completely forgotten about it.

  • @frankerceg4349
    @frankerceg4349 5 годин тому

    Thank you Keith!

  • @TomokosEnterprize
    @TomokosEnterprize 8 годин тому

    Hi Keith, I always loved the challenge of doing a setup like this one. Subtle movements that can suprize a fella with the smalest of tightining up this or that or the same as for the opposite. I once set up a large 20 cyl ships like engine that took 2 of us 2 weeks. Well my friend. Looks like this winter is going to be a great time. Onward my friend.

  • @kennethtencza9209
    @kennethtencza9209 14 годин тому

    The stoker engine got me hooked on this channel and machining awesome.

  • @johnbaker1039
    @johnbaker1039 14 годин тому

    Wow, a blast from the past...

  • @Unrivaledanime
    @Unrivaledanime 20 годин тому +3

    Wow what a Christmas present its been how many years now since we first seen the stoker OMG.. Well i can only hope this finally gets done.. Once completed you need to do a compilation video of all the attempts with all the obstacles and with a video of the stocker installed and feeding coal.. WooHoo !!!!!

  • @transmundanium
    @transmundanium 13 годин тому

    I work like that too. Got a big project on the go, but a lot of little ones I call 'work avoidance projects' that divert my interest. :D

  • @davidcallista2580
    @davidcallista2580 13 годин тому

    My dad was a horizontal boring mill operator at the Standard Stoker co. during the 1930's and 1940's. If he were still around today I feel sure he would tell you that you should be using the machine behind you to do this job.

  • @andywithers592
    @andywithers592 12 годин тому

    Awesome! I’ve commented a few times over the years, here and on IG, when the stoker engine makes a cameo appearance on a pallet somewhere in your workshop. Really great to see the stoker engine is back on the job list.

  • @PaulStaples-h2f
    @PaulStaples-h2f 8 годин тому

    Wow amazing video keith, i can't wait for your future projects, have a great day.

  • @frankdoner8402
    @frankdoner8402 15 годин тому

    Thanks Keith, so much patience and work. I really appreciate the fact you take us on the journey 😊

  • @joehamblin3297
    @joehamblin3297 11 годин тому

    The Stoker is back and Metal Planer to the rescue :D

  • @ianbutler1983
    @ianbutler1983 14 годин тому

    Thanks Keith.

  • @phisigmakappa010588
    @phisigmakappa010588 15 годин тому

    So exited for the stoker, I've watched that series 3x

  • @geneard639
    @geneard639 19 годин тому +2

    Can I give this all the thumbs up? and, I still think a short Dog Leg Cutter, starting from the middle about 55% of the length and doing both sides, then swapping it around and finishing up doing the same might be the best plan of attack.

    • @pirtatejoe
      @pirtatejoe 18 годин тому +1

      I'm still a bit confused about what he's trying to accomplish. At this point, wouldn't hand scraping in that journal be better? I would think it wouldn't be much different than scraping in some square or box ways. After years of trying various machines and tooling and setups, I would think making a custom sized gauge block that you could blue up to scrape in those journals would be the easiest way to go about it. They don't seem particularly large and from what he was saying, he doesn't really have to machine away much metal. Could machine down a straight edge to blue the journal and even use the surface grinder along with his current setup to make sure the scraping stays in plane.

    • @CothranMike
      @CothranMike 16 годин тому

      ​@@pirtatejoe Joe, a journal is a round surface where a bearing runs. These are the undercut areas where the cross heads run in a linear fashion to create straight line motion for the crankshaft, the pistons go in and out, the crank goes round and round to make the worm gear turn the auger to move the coal chunks to the firebox.

    • @pirtatejoe
      @pirtatejoe 16 годин тому +1

      @@CothranMike I get that... from the video, can see the flat areas he is trying to machine that the pistons ride on. Still not sure why it can't be hand scraped.

    • @CothranMike
      @CothranMike 4 години тому

      @pirtatejoe Joe, the surfaces he is using to indicate from, the ones the parallel is supported on are the places the hold downs for the cross head bolts to. The surfaces needing work are below them and slightly up the sides of those finished ribs. Those flat surfaces were worn, pitted, and needed to be built up. Lance and Abom used a eutectic mixture applied as an atomized spray at Lance's workshop. They preheated the casting to around 350 to 400°F and sprayed the mixture at around 500°F. It built up nicely, just like they had practiced on other parts. This metal now needs to be milled and cut so it is correct for the purpose intended. Currently, it is rough, over-sized and would need several 10s of thousandth to be removed BEFORE any hand scraping could be done (scraping only removes .0001-.0003) there is literally hundreds of times that amount to be removed yet before anyone would consider scraping to be useful, if needed at all. These surfaces were not scraped originally. There was no need then or now.

    • @pirtatejoe
      @pirtatejoe 4 години тому

      @@CothranMike Ahhhh so the answer is he has too much material to remove. Could see those areas between the surfaces he was indicating from that he was going to machine, but from what he said, I was under the impression he was just trying to "clean up" those areas. He never really said how much material needed to remove.

  • @peterdolamore7808
    @peterdolamore7808 20 годин тому +1

    Hi Keith. Looking forward to seeing this project progressing!

  • @mr.b2232
    @mr.b2232 10 годин тому

    Looking forward to seeing that job completed 👍😎.

  • @chrispekarik3889
    @chrispekarik3889 15 годин тому

    I always learn something! Thank you!

  • @truracer20
    @truracer20 14 годин тому

    I was really hoping that this was the project that the latest planer refresher was for.

  • @garyfeltus9801
    @garyfeltus9801 14 годин тому

    Been waiting a long time to see this stoker engine get done.

  • @WobblycogsUk
    @WobblycogsUk 18 годин тому

    Great to see the planner being put to work.

  • @timmienorrie
    @timmienorrie 7 годин тому

    About bloody time!

  • @MorseB
    @MorseB 16 годин тому

    The Stoker! I figured that got outsourced. You could say.... I'm stoked....

  • @SettledBatches
    @SettledBatches 3 години тому

    22:21 - Looking GOOD!
    28:02 - Hard to do better than that. Good luck.

  • @WilliamLeue
    @WilliamLeue 18 годин тому

    It's geat to see this project back on track. The planer looks like the perfect tool to restore the slides in the case.

  • @tonyn3123
    @tonyn3123 9 годин тому

    Not a machinist by any means, but I remember this project well and wondered several times if it was still possible. I also remember it from Adam Booth's efforts. I can easily see your challenge with anything but a specialty machine for production runs, as you stated. I think you have a good solution if the tool holder is rigid enough and not be too brittle. I am looking forward to the actual cutting. Best of luck! Thanks.

  • @stevem3413
    @stevem3413 14 годин тому

    This was my first video and it got me hooked on this channel for the better 😅

  • @stephaniewilley727
    @stephaniewilley727 18 годин тому

    While making chips is kinda the goal, setup is everything and is often 90+% of the work. Thanks for showing us this most tedious and precision part of the job.

  • @richardtaylor7199
    @richardtaylor7199 11 годин тому

    Great job.

  • @MartsGarage
    @MartsGarage 13 годин тому

    Hi Keith. Nice to see the stoker motor up on the planer. I just hope and pray it can cope with such a long tool stickout. Fingers crossed for positive news in the next episode. All the best, Mart in England.

  • @susannovotney1903
    @susannovotney1903 15 годин тому

    Great to see it back!

  • @irvine40
    @irvine40 19 годин тому +1

    Yes it’s back!

  • @markmonroe7330
    @markmonroe7330 18 годин тому

    Excellent presentation. Thank you. Love the projects.

  • @wendellgrange8557
    @wendellgrange8557 16 годин тому

    I have been waiting for this for years

  • @richardsurber8226
    @richardsurber8226 15 годин тому

    Thanks for the video Keith

  • @MrIRMOS
    @MrIRMOS 14 годин тому

    I've been waiting for this, thanks you. This is the machining part that got me hooked to your channel...

  • @timf6916
    @timf6916 12 годин тому

    Wow, a big job just to do the job. You got this.

  • @johncloar1692
    @johncloar1692 19 годин тому

    Nice setup a lot of changes good to see the Stoker back again. Thanks Keith for the video.

  • @KennyP88
    @KennyP88 17 годин тому +1

    Man oh man, sometimes getting something indicated in, can take many frustrating hours. Good job. As big as tool holder has to be, hope you don’t have to move the whole casting around again. Good luck.😊

  • @george-b3i-d2d
    @george-b3i-d2d 14 годин тому

    YEA!!!! stoker engine is alive!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @SciPunk215
    @SciPunk215 15 годин тому

    Keith must be stoked. 😆

  • @truracer20
    @truracer20 15 годин тому

    3 years ago I left the following comment,
    "Keith, you've spent the last year plus rebuilding a machine that is perfectly capable of doing this job. I would bet it was originally done on a planer. Your planer is plenty rigid and can use tooling that is rigid enough for the reach needed. I'm sure the top surface was fly cut as the witness marks show but that doesn't mean every operation used the same tooling."

    • @paulcopeland9035
      @paulcopeland9035 12 годин тому

      So, who cares. Did you listen to the video? The crankshaft has been in the shop for the last 3 years. He restored the planer, knowing it would be the tool for this job!

  • @alanchamberlin2384
    @alanchamberlin2384 18 годин тому

    Hey, good morning. I enjoyed watching your process on getting the casting all squared up on the table. I can’t believe how much work it is to get it dialed in. Nice work.

    • @Hoaxer51
      @Hoaxer51 15 годин тому

      I wonder how much time it actually took to get in all dialed in, I’d almost think you’d have to go over each axis at least 3 times, maybe more.
      Keith seems pretty efficient when it comes to these kinds of setups, or he’s really good at editing. Lol

    • @garybrenner6236
      @garybrenner6236 8 годин тому

      Hallelujah, Hallelujah, this should be lots of laughs!

  • @willemvantsant5105
    @willemvantsant5105 6 годин тому

    Tool stick out is extreme, looking forward to the chatter.
    HBM with end mill would be my choice.

  • @chrisrollins3519
    @chrisrollins3519 19 годин тому +1

    Will be pretty cool to see the planer doing this job. I believe I would have used the boring mill though. Seems set up would’ve been easier and probably could’ve found an off the shelf tooling option for reaching in there. That’s what’s cool about machinist, not a one of us will do something the same way 😂.

  • @Mishn0
    @Mishn0 16 годин тому

    Yay! The stoker engine is back! I've seen it appear in the background from time to time over the years but was afraid to mention it in case it was too much of a sore spot.

    • @garybrenner6236
      @garybrenner6236 8 годин тому

      Hallelujah, Hallelujah, this should be lots of laughs!

  • @Buckeystown
    @Buckeystown 16 годин тому

    I remember thinking it is going to be a real effort to put it back together once its milled. This should be interesting. I have been curious about this since the last video trying to do this.

  • @deemstyle
    @deemstyle 17 годин тому

    There's sure to be a lot of "OG" comments which made me wonder when I subbed (not that it's a competition; just a personal curiosity). Going back through your old videos, I recall the addition of the American Rotary phase converter to your shop, and I even recall the old "Shop Tour" series in 2017- but I don't seem to recall the shop build itself. Looks like I must have subbed late 2016ish. Man you have had a LOT of projects, change, growth, and loss over that time. It's been a fun ride for sure, and I know I speak for the masses on this one: it is really great to see an old project like this stoker engine return for some love. Keep kickin' Keith!

  • @elsdp-4560
    @elsdp-4560 19 годин тому

    Thank you for sharing.👍

  • @joseantoniofernandez8827
    @joseantoniofernandez8827 19 годин тому

    I was sure you did not give up in this “almost antique” project! ……you never do! And here it comes. A “modest” tool holder is not going to stop you; that’s for sure!

    • @garybrenner6236
      @garybrenner6236 8 годин тому

      Hallelujah, Hallelujah, this should be lots of laughs!

  • @dessilverson161
    @dessilverson161 9 годин тому

    I was only thinking the other day, what happened about the stoker engine. Good luck with it Mr. Rucker.

  • @axcs0119
    @axcs0119 16 годин тому

    YEA it's back!!!!

  • @Joewho99
    @Joewho99 16 годин тому

    Interesting video thanks for posting . Kep up the good work .

  • @chrisrhodes5464
    @chrisrhodes5464 19 годин тому

    I had to do a double take when I saw what Keith was working on today didn't believe my eyes to start with

  • @windrk_6754
    @windrk_6754 7 годин тому

    Great to see the planer do some work! Also, I was thinking, make sure the casting can't slide away on those bolts to the plate, ie that they are slid all the way in the cutting direction before final tightening.. I think it was Steve Watkins who commented on how hard the planer can push, & something shifting could be a real mess! Although I imagine the intent is to take light cuts...

  • @davidhudson5452
    @davidhudson5452 19 годин тому +1

    Nice to see it again will be better than new was i bet