I think the Catrice one gives more volume and is much darker and the price is really worth it. I won't by an expensive mascara again, Kevin A was my last expensive one and it was good but not brilliant.
I ordered and received the MAC in Mega, Micro and a travel size. I applied the Mega on my top lashes and the Micro on bottom lashes. I absolutely love the formula. Darkened, didn’t clump and lengthened my lashes 😍♥️ .. I also felt it wasn’t too thick of a mascara or too thin …. Didn’t transfer after wearing all day .. ♥️😘
Okay, here goes. . . Even though the Mac is expensive it looks more lengthy and less messy. I did like the Catrice one at first but liked the Mac one from then on! Cleaner looking.
£23 difference, it's a no brainer- Catrice every time! I would never spend that amount on mascara anyway so was interested to hear about Catrice as I had never heard of it. Thanks Nisha. Have a great weekend! 💖
@@Debra_Barron so have I, had YSL and it smeared and was the devil to remove. I've been using Max Factor mascara for years and love it. If it ain't broke and all that.... Do you use lash growth serum ? Its fantastic! I've always had good lashes but the are super long and fluffy now. Been using for a year. All the best to you .
Bought Mac Stack last week having used Lancôme Hypnose for years and Dior Show. Mac isn’t a patch on them. Wouldn’t buy again and it clumps! Can’t wait to finish it so I can use Lancôme again 😣
Nisha, I have many high end mascaras ie Lancôme, Nars, Clinique, It, Dior etc but the mascara I’m reaching for most often of late is the Essence Lash Princess range which here in Australia sell for around AU$7, compare that to AU$40 to 50 plus for the others and I’ve found the Essence Lash Princess is as good if not better than the Teint Idole which has been my favourite until now. Thanks so much for all your wonderful vids, you’re a girl after my own heart. Julie Sydney, Australia
Both look great but I do think the catrice gives more volume as it looks darker at the root, like you have a bit of liner on ☺️ Thanks for reviewing the Mac tho Nisha ! 😘
Hello Nisha, thank you for the review. I personally like the Catrice mascara better. The Catrice looks darker and thicker in comparison to Mac; at least on the camera. Maybe it is different in real life but thanks for the review. XXOO 💜
I think the Mac one was the best! And the reason I feel as though it was the best is because, first, it is already very difficult to find a mascara that can give both volume and length effectively! But I think the Mac one gave you exactly that, both length and volume and I feel as though it was a much cleaner application than the Catrice.. and it could be because of the brush shape, which makes a big difference. Gotta try the Mac! I would use the Mac for my top lashes, because of the brush, and the Catrice for my bottom lashes. That would do great! (Btw... I tried the liquid foundation with hyaluronic acid and it is absolutely phenomenal, lightweight and perfect for summer in my opinion. Thanks again!) ❤️
Great explanation and demo! After a busy day in my sewing room, I get to watch you and hand quilt! I hope you have a fabulous week ahead! Thank you for your time, talent and posting this video!
Hi Nisha! We have a new mascara from Catrice in Quebec City but it's not the same one...it's the Glam & Doll false lash effect mascara! However, I personally prefer the Catrice to the Mac! I'm going to get the new false lash effect to see if I prefer it! Have a great weekend! xxx
I liked the MAC best but the Catrice looked best on you 😘 I like the Chanel le Volume in the luxury category and Benefit roller lash for everyday use, it gives length without clumping.
I think the Catrice one was darker and other than that, I couldn't tell the difference. Will have to check out the Catrice one - thanks my friend! ♥ Elle
So close. I think for the cost and what it does Catrice is the best choice. Also I find new mascara put more product on at first than ones you have used a lot which makes a difference on fullness and length. The packaging is pretty but no one sees it so it does make a difference to me. They both look great one you Nisha !!!
It’s a very close contest, I slightly prefer the Mac one but Catrice is so close it would win on price as I have sensitive eyes so declutter mascaras often. I have the Catrice mascara and like it but I prefer the Glam & Doll Easy Wash off which is a tubing mascara that removes with just warm water. Great video thanks xx
Thanks Nisha I just ordered the mac I had been thinking of getting it anyway. At the moment I am using lash princess by wilko at under £4 performs well for the price x
I think the Mac gave your eyelashes more definition. But, how easy is Mac to remove? Because I love Hourglass mascara .but it's terrible to remove . But it looks lovely on your eye's. 💋
Hi Nisha they certainly look the same to me. Both look excellent, but for the price l would go for the cheaper one. I use the Sky high by Maybeliene. Really like it. Thanks Nisha.💞
I like the Mac one. Do you curl your lashes? Mine don't curl up unless I use a eyelash curler. I have never build up mascara. I'll try it. Thanks Nisha 🙂
I do see that the Mac mascara gave you more length, but it gave you more volume, too. I prefer it. The Catrice is nice, though and in my price range. That's the one I will try. Thanks for the comparison, Nisha. It was very useful. xo~linda
Hi Nisha,I loved both 😍I. Still on Lancôme which I love but as you say drugstore mascara if you get the right one can be just as good,love my mascara,well all my makeup lol xxx
Thank you , Your lashes are so beautiful . I don’t see a profound difference . Considering mascara has to been thrown out in maybe 2 months for sanitary concern’s I prefer to use a drug store brand . This was a beautifully demonstrated testimony ❤️. Have a Beautiful day 🤗💕
So funny because back in the day I wasnt one to wear MAC but lately I’ve been purchasing MAC products to try. I have to say I’m really enjoying it. The eyeshadow primer is 👌 and their blushes are beautiful. So I’m interested what you think about the mascara, I love their GIGABLACK.
You will never believe this Nisha but I was actually going to ask you to review this just yesterday 😲😂 cos I’ve been looking at it since it’s launch! I’m so happy 😂 going to watch the video now but I couldn’t believe my eyes when I saw this 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 xx
Right I’ve watched it and i Would be interested to see how long it lasts in the tube Nisha . I stopped buying Nars cos it uses up very quickly but I do love the way this looks . Your lashes looked less clumped with the mac but both very lovely . I think I will try it to see for myself as I can’t resist 😂 xx
I received a travel size in my monthly Allure Beauty Box. (I’m in the U.S.) Didn’t know it came in a micro version, that sounds perfect. Thanks Nisha! Do you have family in Poland? Are they ok? 🤗💕
I think mac does look a bit better & longer but I dont think Id pay that for it.The bottom looks the same to me.Good video I liked seeing the comparison.
They both look the same so would go for the cheaper one! Your eyelashes are amazing though, they look false, mine are very short. I had botox for the first time yeterday and have been left with a terrible bruise. its been 10 days now and its still there! Has this ever happened to you? It's put me off and I'm worried when it will finally disappear xx
No, I have never had a bruise from botox, I did get it from fillers once. Maybe change the therapist. Also your comment is a bit confusing , you said you had it done yesterday and then you say it has been 10 days xx
On screen it looks like Catrice got more volume. I certainly don't see enough difference to warrant paying the price. Thank you for the comparison. Your eyes are stunning. 🤗
I have got the golden Maybelline mascara 🤣🤣🤣 and it gives me same results .. even though my lashes are short and thin..but it gives me the volume of Me putting fake lashes...so why change it for expensive brands??😅😅😅😅
Good morning, Nisha. The Mack mascara made your lashes look longer to me, but the Catrice made your lashes thicker. Personally for me i would chose the Catrice. Anyway, hugs 💕 and have a wonderful day! Give Handsome Louie a big hug also! 💕
i like the mac side better...i think it looks, ummm...alittle cleaner. I think the other looks more like clumps some...but not alot of difference really.
I prefer the Mac lashes but there’s not that much in it, and considering the cost difference I’m not sure. I love Mac and the packaging looks fantastic but I dispose of mascara every 6 weeks so I tend to stick to drug store brands. How did the Mac mascara wear, any panda eyes or flaking? 😘
I think the cheaper one looks so much better on your eyes .I think mac mascara is over priced and over rated I always get a better look with my cheaper mascara, x
I think the Mac gave your eyelashes more definition. But, how easy is Mac to remove? Because I love Hourglass mascara .but it's terrible to remove . But it looks lovely on your eye's. 💋
I think the Catrice one gives more volume and is much darker and the price is really worth it. I won't by an expensive mascara again, Kevin A was my last expensive one and it was good but not brilliant.
Yeah but it's clumpy
I ordered and received the MAC in Mega, Micro and a travel size. I applied the Mega on my top lashes and the Micro on bottom lashes. I absolutely love the formula. Darkened, didn’t clump and lengthened my lashes 😍♥️ .. I also felt it wasn’t too thick of a mascara or too thin …. Didn’t transfer after wearing all day .. ♥️😘
I like the Catrice better, it looks darker at the root and at the price difference I won't get one. Thanks for the review xx
Okay, here goes. . . Even though the Mac is expensive it looks more lengthy and less messy. I did like the Catrice one at first but liked the Mac one from then on! Cleaner looking.
Nisha ,essence lash princess ( the green one ) is hard to beat . X
My thoughts exactly!
£23 difference, it's a no brainer- Catrice every time! I would never spend that amount on mascara anyway so was interested to hear about Catrice as I had never heard of it. Thanks Nisha. Have a great weekend! 💖
I just can’t afford those high priced mascaras. Are they worth it? I was given an Estée Lauder mascara for Christmas…. No better than Maybelline ☃️
@@Debra_Barron so have I, had YSL and it smeared and was the devil to remove. I've been using Max Factor mascara for years and love it. If it ain't broke and all that.... Do you use lash growth serum ? Its fantastic! I've always had good lashes but the are super long and fluffy now. Been using for a year. All the best to you .
For me, I always use a primer (Lancome Cils Booster) prior to putting on mascara, it makes a world of difference for me.
I totally agree and it also helps in keeping the mascara off of your eyelids and face
Bought Mac Stack last week having used Lancôme Hypnose for years and Dior Show. Mac isn’t a patch on them. Wouldn’t buy again and it clumps! Can’t wait to finish it so I can use Lancôme again 😣
I think the volume at the base of the lashes looks nicer with the Catrice, love your channel you make me chuckle x
They both look amazing on you nisha, my go to mascara atm is maybeline sky high just can't put it down thank-you for reviewing them 😍❤
Nisha, I have many high end mascaras ie Lancôme, Nars, Clinique, It, Dior etc but the mascara I’m reaching for most often of late is the Essence Lash Princess range which here in Australia sell for around AU$7, compare that to AU$40 to 50 plus for the others and I’ve found the Essence Lash Princess is as good if not better than the Teint Idole which has been my favourite until now.
Thanks so much for all your wonderful vids, you’re a girl after my own heart.
Julie
Sydney, Australia
Yup the Catrice lashes look darker and fuller! You have beautiful sky blue eyes! Thanks for the comparison! Have a great weekend ❤🌷❤
I just got the Mac and it’s amazing.. intense black color and volume!! Love it 😍
I like the cat rice as well
Love the Mac 👏👏
Thanks Nisha😘
Both look great but I do think the catrice gives more volume as it looks darker at the root, like you have a bit of liner on ☺️
Thanks for reviewing the Mac tho Nisha ! 😘
It’s a close race but I think for the price it’s definitely catrice for me!!
Hello Nisha, thank you for the review. I personally like the Catrice mascara better. The Catrice looks darker and thicker in comparison to Mac; at least on the camera. Maybe it is different in real life but thanks for the review. XXOO 💜
They both look beautiful. My favorite mascara is the Voluminous Original from l'Oreal. I usually put 2 coats 😀.
It appeared that the Catrice gave more volume and looked darker! Happy Friday! 💕
I think the Mac one was the best! And the reason I feel as though it was the best is because, first, it is already very difficult to find a mascara that can give both volume and length effectively! But I think the Mac one gave you exactly that, both length and volume and I feel as though it was a much cleaner application than the Catrice.. and it could be because of the brush shape, which makes a big difference. Gotta try the Mac! I would use the Mac for my top lashes, because of the brush, and the Catrice for my bottom lashes. That would do great! (Btw... I tried the liquid foundation with hyaluronic acid and it is absolutely phenomenal, lightweight and perfect for summer in my opinion. Thanks again!) ❤️
Great explanation and demo! After a busy day in my sewing room, I get to watch you and hand quilt! I hope you have a fabulous week ahead! Thank you for your time, talent and posting this video!
Have a wonderful and joyous day! Thanks Nisha Jennifer 🤗🌼
You too!!
Hi Nisha! We have a new mascara from Catrice in Quebec City but it's not the same one...it's the Glam & Doll false lash effect mascara! However, I personally prefer the Catrice to the Mac! I'm going to get the new false lash effect to see if I prefer it! Have a great weekend! xxx
I liked the MAC best but the Catrice looked best on you 😘 I like the Chanel le Volume in the luxury category and Benefit roller lash for everyday use, it gives length without clumping.
Great timing Nisha I'm looking for a new mascara, think I'll save my money and get tha catrice though. Xxxmaxine
Definitely the mac one x
Always interested in a great mascara !
Hi Nisha I have to agree I love 💕 mascara & foundation to
The Mac is a good one but not to much different in the other
🌸🌺🌼🥀🌹🌷🌻🌸🌺
I think the Catrice one was darker and other than that, I couldn't tell the difference. Will have to check out the Catrice one - thanks my friend! ♥ Elle
Catrice is the winner in my book! It make the lashes looks thicker and more black at the roots, like you have eyeliner!!!
Love the lipstick! The mascaras are very similar! The catrice almost looks slightly clumpy at the base of the lashes
So close. I think for the cost and what it does Catrice is the best choice. Also I find new mascara put more product on at first than ones you have used a lot which makes a difference on fullness and length. The packaging is pretty but no one sees it so it does make a difference to me. They both look great one you Nisha !!!
It’s a very close contest, I slightly prefer the Mac one but Catrice is so close it would win on price as I have sensitive eyes so declutter mascaras often. I have the Catrice mascara and like it but I prefer the Glam & Doll Easy Wash off which is a tubing mascara that removes with just warm water. Great video thanks xx
Nisha. I think catrise is thicker
Great job. 💖💖💖
Thank you 🤗
The caprice looks better on video way thicker. I'm going to try catrice!
Thanks Nisha I just ordered the mac I had been thinking of getting it anyway. At the moment I am using lash princess by wilko at under £4 performs well for the price x
I too use and love lash Princess. I have used it for 2years now very hard to beat. X
@Alex C for the money it’s excellent value and gives high end mascaras a run for their money
I like both but the catrice is darker and I love that most
Catrice seems thicker I don't really think the price difference is worth it both are beautiful 💖
I think the Mac gave your eyelashes more definition. But, how easy is Mac to remove? Because I love Hourglass mascara .but it's terrible to remove . But it looks lovely on your eye's. 💋
Hi Nisha they certainly look the same to me. Both look excellent, but for the price l would go for the cheaper one. I use the Sky high by Maybeliene. Really like it. Thanks Nisha.💞
I prefer the Catrice and moneywise what can I say
Good morning, Nisha! Decisions, decisions! I think I would go with the Mac, although it is a close call. Have a great day!
I think the Catrice looks better and I’m a total MAC fan but I will not be purchasing it at that price. How do we purchase Catrice in the UK? X
Hmmmm. I’m interested in the MAC. Thanks for the comparison
I like the Mac one. Do you curl your lashes? Mine don't curl up unless I use a eyelash curler. I have never build up mascara. I'll try it. Thanks Nisha 🙂
No, I have never curled my lashes they just are naturally curly xx
@@SugarPuffAndFluff lucky you! You are beautiful inside and out ❤️. Thank you for responding.
Both look gorgeous but I think the Catrice looks thicker, the Mac looks longer but I prefer the Catrice on you. Lots of love xx
They are close but I think I still notice that the Mac side is longer. But for the price I don’t know! I wonder how it would compare to” It” mascara
I love them both but will have to go on price. Thanks for sharing.
I do see that the Mac mascara gave you more length, but it gave you more volume, too. I prefer it. The Catrice is nice, though and in my price range. That's the one I will try. Thanks for the comparison, Nisha. It was very useful.
xo~linda
Hi Nisha,I loved both 😍I. Still on Lancôme which I love but as you say drugstore mascara if you get the right one can be just as good,love my mascara,well all my makeup lol xxx
Thank you , Your lashes are so beautiful . I don’t see a profound difference . Considering mascara has to been thrown out in maybe 2 months for sanitary concern’s I prefer to use a drug store brand . This was a beautifully demonstrated testimony ❤️. Have a Beautiful day 🤗💕
The c atrice looked great. And maybe if it was a brand new catrice it would have been a better comparison ???.
I like the darkness of the Catrice. I don’t think I can get in US.
I think the Mac gave a bit more length (brand new though), but the Catrice looks darker and thicker!
Great video! 💕 I think the drugstore kills high end in mascara.
How do you remove it?
So funny because back in the day I wasnt one to wear MAC but lately I’ve been purchasing MAC products to try. I have to say I’m really enjoying it. The eyeshadow primer is 👌 and their blushes are beautiful. So I’m interested what you think about the mascara, I love their GIGABLACK.
I used to wear Gigablack years ago, somehow MAC is no longer popular on UA-cam but it is still a great brand xx
I am tempted to buy MAC, although. Cat rice is slightly darker! 🙏
You will never believe this Nisha but I was actually going to ask you to review this just yesterday 😲😂 cos I’ve been looking at it since it’s launch! I’m so happy 😂 going to watch the video now but I couldn’t believe my eyes when I saw this 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 xx
Right I’ve watched it and i Would be interested to see how long it lasts in the tube Nisha . I stopped buying Nars cos it uses up very quickly but I do love the way this looks . Your lashes looked less clumped with the mac but both very lovely . I think I will try it to see for myself as I can’t resist 😂 xx
I really like this mascara, it wore very well too (although most mascaras wear well on me) and I love the tube it is so pretty xx
@@SugarPuffAndFluff yes the packaging got me too 😍😍 I’m having it thank you Nisha 😘 xx
I received a travel size in my monthly Allure Beauty Box. (I’m in the U.S.) Didn’t know it came in a micro version, that sounds perfect. Thanks Nisha! Do you have family in Poland? Are they ok? 🤗💕
Caprice looks more full. I like it
Catrice I prefer
Nisha, you have such pretty blue eyes!! Lashes are so close to looking the same....Hugs sand love Loretta
I have never found a MAC mascara that wore well.
I think mac does look a bit better & longer but I dont think Id pay that for it.The bottom looks the same to me.Good video I liked seeing the comparison.
I think one is Darker than other, brings your blue eyes out..the right one has fancy, and longer, but I like left one better..Love'nHugs Barbie..
i like the Catrice better....it looks thicker on the base and it makes the lashline look like it has more eyeliner...
but both are cute
They both look the same so would go for the cheaper one! Your eyelashes are amazing though, they look false, mine are very short. I had botox for the first time yeterday and have been left with a terrible bruise. its been 10 days now and its still there! Has this ever happened to you? It's put me off and I'm worried when it will finally disappear xx
No, I have never had a bruise from botox, I did get it from fillers once. Maybe change the therapist. Also your comment is a bit confusing , you said you had it done yesterday and then you say it has been 10 days xx
On screen it looks like Catrice got more volume. I certainly don't see enough difference to warrant paying the price. Thank you for the comparison. Your eyes are stunning. 🤗
They both look similar. 😊
I have got the golden Maybelline mascara 🤣🤣🤣 and it gives me same results .. even though my lashes are short and thin..but it gives me the volume of Me putting fake lashes...so why change it for expensive brands??😅😅😅😅
I got it for £20 with look fantastic and I’ve got next day free delivery subscription
Found Catrice in USS. Out of stock.
To say the Catrice mascara is old, I can't see much different....yet there is a huge difference in price!
I haven’t tried them but the Mac looks much more defined and natural to me…
Good morning, Nisha. The Mack mascara made your lashes look longer to me, but the Catrice made your lashes thicker. Personally for me i would chose the Catrice. Anyway, hugs 💕 and have a wonderful day! Give Handsome Louie a big hug also! 💕
i like the mac side better...i think it looks, ummm...alittle cleaner. I think the other looks more like clumps some...but not alot of difference really.
Personally, aside from the effect, to me it’s also very important how easily it can be removed……..
It removes quite well, it is not too stiff but Catrice removes a little easier I think x
@@SugarPuffAndFluff thank you!
The cheaper one looks much prettier and softer
I prefer the Mac lashes but there’s not that much in it, and considering the cost difference I’m not sure. I love Mac and the packaging looks fantastic but I dispose of mascara every 6 weeks so I tend to stick to drug store brands. How did the Mac mascara wear, any panda eyes or flaking? 😘
It wore great xx
Catrice is better
I think the MAC side looks better. If you can afford it, it does look better and the lashes are longer.
I think the cheaper one looks so much better on your eyes .I think mac mascara is over priced and over rated I always get a better look with my cheaper mascara, x
Not a lot in it just prefer the Mac xx
Your lashes look better with the MAC , they look longer.
You can apply mascara with your mouth closed, omg.. 👀🧐😬😬 HOW!?
It flaked on me. Not crazy about it
I think Catrice gives a fuller nicer look to your eyes, sorry not Mac impressed.
Mac?....not for $28.
I think the Mac gave your eyelashes more definition. But, how easy is Mac to remove? Because I love Hourglass mascara .but it's terrible to remove . But it looks lovely on your eye's. 💋