For real. From the second that Vianai hit the bell prematurely on 2 and got pizza nachos, he was done. He was not having fun anymore. Then he ate some penis. And then Olivia got ziti and Shayne wanted to murder everyone in that room.
@@vincedibona4687 just because I like to just casually use the word "just" in a sentence doesn't just mean I have to just limit myself to just one use of the word in a sentence.
It’s scary when you can’t tell if Shayne is flexing his acting skills or if he’s actually regretting his life choices and is contemplating wether or not he should kill Garrett.
He knows full well which of his more extreme fans he can get to disappear garrett lol. You cant convince me all superfamous people dont remember offers of such.... services
Nah, he's acting. Committing to it, but acting. I think a real reaction would have more hurt in it. Edit: It's quite a complex portrayal still. I'm just a performer as well haha
Josh yeeting and Shayne’s dish were true surprises. Olivia calmly bringing over the yeet bucket while the others were chanting swallow was really sweet of her.
Josh and Garrett’s yelling match, The yeet bucket being used immediately, Nicole being in nonstop pain while Josh praises the ramen bowl, the entire group just casually chowing down on some nachos, and Shayne’s Joker origin story after the penis frites reveal makes this the best Eat it or Yeet it episode of all time
This was milk bean’s masterpiece. He made Josh yeet, Shayne cry and a big bite that everyone could enjoy family style. Well except for Shayne. He’s far away on Olivia’s planet, Pepperzonia, now.
I can imagine the next EIYI there's just not gonna be an intro it's just a broken down set with one light flickering and Garrett is strapped to the table and we only hear muffle screaming or crying while Shayne just has his back towards us laughing quietly.
This is one of the best ones. The editing at the end with all the brief cuts to Shayne, his acting being so good, the big bite being a normal dish after all that etc., top tier stuff
Everybody is so focused on Shayne's breakdown, but Olivia also immediately regretted her decision to join him, chucked her piece right away, and discreetly yeeted after Shayne refused to do so.
To be fair, it wasn't just the fact that Shayne ate a bull penis, but also the fact that Courtney said what it was while the thing was still in Shayne's mouth lol
I would say he probably wasn’t. He kept chewing it, after all. And I think if he was pissed, he would have spit it out then and there. It’s worth remembering that he’s an entertainer
What’s funny is that actually sounds like it’d be type of a chip brand… Shayne’s grandkids gonna offer him some Pizzle Potato Chips and then the Vietnam flashbacks will kick in 😂
I've got an idea for eat it or yeet it: "Advertisement VS Reality" where the participants are not shown the actual food at first, but a picture of what the food "should" look like, then, like usual, ring the bell and get served the dish (which may or may-not be a screwed up version of the food shown before)
Have Garrett participate in one of these, but hide a second smaller bib under the normal one, so that when he takes it off thinking he's safe HAHA NOPE
I love this episode so much, although I wish Trevor was there. The fact that Josh had to yeet, he still tried some of the other foods. I'd like to see Mythical Kitchen made an improved version of the last dish and have Garrett try it. Not many chefs use morels and that would be fun to see. Shayne was in the process of his "crying," and that's what makes him a great actor.
Just look at the Mythical Kitchen crew looking at each other and whispering as Shayne and Olivia are unknowingly chewing the pizzle. They know what’s happening. They look on in horror. They feel some of that guilt. But not enough to stop it.
15:00 oh the sad music as they're discussing what happens to it when cooking ..all the while poor shayne's chewing on it. Oh i can't take it 😭.rock made an amazing edit gotta say
Garrett giving Josh, Burger But Cold the Third (since Josh already made the sequel) while wearing a Burger But Cold is slick dedication...I love it. Garrett has truly lost his mind and we hope he considers joining our team. Together, we'd be the perfect duo to troll the rest of the world.
My favorite thing is Garret’s maniacal laughter whenever someone takes a bite of a bad dish. Complete silence as the eater takes a bite, tries to determine those initial first tastes, everyone else waiting with bated breath to see their reaction. And Garret, sitting in the corner, his laughter filling the empty silence as he takes enjoyment from knowing he has caused others suffering.
Of course Olivia would love the most horrendous dish. Liv, what is WRONG WITH YOU?!? 🫣🫣🫣 Also, Josh yeeted?? Garrett, you have achieved the unthinkable! 😂
It’s videos like these that really make me appreciate that Good Mythical Morning acquired Smosh *Josh* : “You ate the ball sack?” *Olivia* : “I did 😁.” *Josh* : “Did you like it?” *Olivia* : “Yes 😏.” *Josh* : “Sometimes it’s just easier to swallow 😉.”
For anyone wondering whether Shane is flexing his acting skills.... that's rage that's pure rage. It took every ounce of his energy to not walk over there and just punch Garrett in the face.
If it hasn’t started already, this is the beginning of shayne’s villain origin story.
For real. From the second that Vianai hit the bell prematurely on 2 and got pizza nachos, he was done. He was not having fun anymore. Then he ate some penis. And then Olivia got ziti and Shayne wanted to murder everyone in that room.
At first i though your comment was a v2 of those stupid “finally its here”comments
It’s The Chosen’s origin story, this is why he walks the lonely road
He's like Homelander. Handsome and strong, could get anything. Except for what he truly wants.
wdym he's already hunting people to make chilli out of them
Josh can swallow brain, bugs, blood, but not Garret's cold burger lmao
He's a chef, not insane
omfg
Burger but cold but good but bad
Also couldn’t swallow the sour version
I think Josh accidentally spat some Cold Burger at Vianai 3:03
A moment of silence please for Shane's taste buds, trust, and sanity
He’ll have ultimate grave mouth after this
I'm not normally religious but I think this calls for it 🙏
@@georgedaveis4129 if anything he just lost all belief in the world and a higher power. No one was watching out for him this day 😂
😭
He needs therapy now
Shayne just being uncharacteristically quiet from the trauma he just endured after seeing Olivia just getting pasta is hilarious
You used “just” three times in one sentence. Stop that right now.
@@vincedibona4687 just because I like to just casually use the word "just" in a sentence doesn't just mean I have to just limit myself to just one use of the word in a sentence.
@@vincedibona4687 just relax dude
@@jorbur3604what he means is, you should do it MORE
Olivia sux
Nicole and Josh knowing exactly what Shane got is funny
them whispering to each other and smiling lmao
A lot of GMM fans also recognized the pizzle. Boiled for safety.
GMM watcher. I knew immediately.
It’s scary when you can’t tell if Shayne is flexing his acting skills or if he’s actually regretting his life choices and is contemplating wether or not he should kill Garrett.
He knows full well which of his more extreme fans he can get to disappear garrett lol. You cant convince me all superfamous people dont remember offers of such.... services
For real tho, swear the man was about to have a breakdown on camera
Hes acting dingus.
Nah, he's acting. Committing to it, but acting. I think a real reaction would have more hurt in it.
Edit: It's quite a complex portrayal still. I'm just a performer as well haha
@@chand911 I never seen him act dingus before
Josh yeeting and Shayne’s dish were true surprises. Olivia calmly bringing over the yeet bucket while the others were chanting swallow was really sweet of her.
She IS sweet. She has done a lot of such small but sweet acts in many videos and bloopers videos.
Genuinely between that and trying it so he didn't suffer alone were both adorable gestures
Well, Garrett finally managed to traumatize Shayne without using malic acid. Poor dude was messed up
Now you’ve made me wonder if Shayne would have preferred a malic acid soaked bull pizzle.
Well I mean it is pride month lol
@@QuantumJuicE3 might not be the first d in Shayne's mouth, who knows
Tbf Garrett got Shayne with the banana episode
Now every dish Shane gets is gonna have dick instead
Josh and Garrett’s yelling match, The yeet bucket being used immediately, Nicole being in nonstop pain while Josh praises the ramen bowl, the entire group just casually chowing down on some nachos, and Shayne’s Joker origin story after the penis frites reveal makes this the best Eat it or Yeet it episode of all time
This was milk bean’s masterpiece. He made Josh yeet, Shayne cry and a big bite that everyone could enjoy family style. Well except for Shayne. He’s far away on Olivia’s planet, Pepperzonia, now.
pizzlezonia
Planet Sui
“Milk bean”?
🤦🏻♂️
I just want to say that Olivia is a real one for giving Shayne an out when everyone else was chanting sallow.
She's the one that guilted him into eating it in the first place
@@naveenanthanendra3478 To be fair she didn't know what it was at that point though.
Rewatching this is golden... With Olivia mentioning a ducks peepee, through Shayne mentioning that Garret has lost his mind... Gold, pure gold.
I cant tell if it's some Topp tier acting or Shayne has officially lost it
Usually u can tell when he’s acting lol and now I’m genuinely worried for his sanity 😂
He needs a priest
Sammmmeee
That was just like the Shayne Topp look of ultimate regret
Shayne is done with this show
Oh shit Shayne actually went through all the five stages of grief, that's crazy
Shane's face when Olivia gets the pasta is just beautiful.
I can imagine the next EIYI there's just not gonna be an intro it's just a broken down set with one light flickering and Garrett is strapped to the table and we only hear muffle screaming or crying while Shayne just has his back towards us laughing quietly.
Omg yeessss
Or there could just possibly be another revenge Eat It or Yeet It video courtesy of Shayne.
@@matthewelliott7294 I mean, yeah, that makes more sense……………….. I still like OP’s idea tho :>
I feel like this would be a great intro for the Halloween episode.
That would so amazing as a short
I don't know if Shayne takes hugs, hand shakes, or high fives for sympathy and comfort, but I think we need to send all of those through the Internet.
He said in a vid that his family doesn’t like touching
I'm up to sending him my pizzle
This is one of the best ones. The editing at the end with all the brief cuts to Shayne, his acting being so good, the big bite being a normal dish after all that etc., top tier stuff
plus the big bite being a normal dish with a completely insane presentation for no reason, lmao
Everybody is so focused on Shayne's breakdown, but Olivia also immediately regretted her decision to join him, chucked her piece right away, and discreetly yeeted after Shayne refused to do so.
I like that Shayne's reaction wasn't disgust so much as betrayal. Shame, horror, sadness - all emotions I would not expect from a food challenge show.
I’m at a coffee shop trying to not die of laughter over Shayne’s misery
I’m working at one trying to not do the same
Rock's editing made it top tier too
Guys, I think Garrett finally won…he broke Shayne…like I’ve never seen Shayne just that damaged.
Garret hasn’t broke Damien
He managed to break Josh, that's even more impressive.
big W for Garret this episode, he broke both gravemouth Shayne and Freak chef Josh in the same episode
Oh no…our Shayne…he’s broken!
To be fair, it wasn't just the fact that Shayne ate a bull penis, but also the fact that Courtney said what it was while the thing was still in Shayne's mouth lol
Shayne dissociating towards the end had me dying🤣🤣🤣 dumpster wizard be like-looking to enter the black hole and never return eh 😂😂😂
Who ever edited shayne`s mentality shattering with the glass deserves a raise 🤣🤣
Shayne was definitely ACTUALLY pissed but did his acting thing to hide it 😂
Reasonably so
I would say he probably wasn’t. He kept chewing it, after all. And I think if he was pissed, he would have spit it out then and there.
It’s worth remembering that he’s an entertainer
you're laughing. shayne is literally about to become the joker and you're laughing
Then who will be his batman? Damien?
@@kanevivi damien will become naruto. Ian the legendary batman
@@kanevivi Spencer!
Shayne need to get his revenge. They did my boy dirty.
He already had a revenge episode
@@muhammedbadjie1960 we know but he needs another one after this
I AGREE LOL
@@symphonixblades You know after watching this Imma have to agree, what happened to Shayne was vile as hell
@@muhammedbadjie1960 id eatdick fritters every day for a month if i got one month of shayne topps salary for it. Ya boy makes bank
As a former chef, the concept of guest starring on this show is anxiety-inducing.
Why
@@by9diz8 Because I would never know what the hell I'm eating, because the person who makes the dishes is a sadistic demon.
I feel like we all should chip in for Shayne's therapy after this episode.
He can be his own therapist!
I think at this point, Shayne yeeting the stool at Garrett is completely justifiable
One day Shayne's kids will say, "Eat a pizzle, Dad." and Shayne will have a flashback to this trauma.
"I have son....sadly I have...."
What’s funny is that actually sounds like it’d be type of a chip brand… Shayne’s grandkids gonna offer him some Pizzle Potato Chips and then the Vietnam flashbacks will kick in 😂
Haha noooooo
I've got an idea for eat it or yeet it: "Advertisement VS Reality" where the participants are not shown the actual food at first, but a picture of what the food "should" look like, then, like usual, ring the bell and get served the dish (which may or may-not be a screwed up version of the food shown before)
thats a sweet idea
I like that idea
Top tier idea, they should def do that
You should repost this idea on their newest video!
@@VioletRay-Art Good Idea!
Shayne looks so genuinely mortified, I can't tell if he's acting or not. By the end of it, he looks so be on the actual brink of tears.
i dont know whats funnier: Shayne's frozen reaction to what the dish is...or his reaction after he ate it
Everybody was too polite to say anything as both Nicole and Vianai dinged in too ealry, before the countdown ended. Shaynes "okaayyyy" at 8:19 got me😂
Have Garrett participate in one of these, but hide a second smaller bib under the normal one, so that when he takes it off thinking he's safe HAHA NOPE
Like 5 of them. He’s got it coming
Bring back the wheel, but make it all Garrett.
YESSS
This was a solid episode. Pour one out for Shayne.
Shayne staring into space contemplating his life sent me into outer space. 💀 I felt so bad but DIED laughing.
same
Shane needs another revenge episode. But it’s all the worst expensive foods possible.
" Kill em Josh! Kill em" is such a funny reaction to that whole situation.
I'm surprised that out of everyone, Josh is the one that yeeted the food
Dude same.
I love this episode so much, although I wish Trevor was there. The fact that Josh had to yeet, he still tried some of the other foods. I'd like to see Mythical Kitchen made an improved version of the last dish and have Garrett try it. Not many chefs use morels and that would be fun to see. Shayne was in the process of his "crying," and that's what makes him a great actor.
Just look at the Mythical Kitchen crew looking at each other and whispering as Shayne and Olivia are unknowingly chewing the pizzle. They know what’s happening. They look on in horror. They feel some of that guilt. But not enough to stop it.
"Sometimes it's easier to just swallow" -Josh always makes me laugh so much
15:00 oh the sad music as they're discussing what happens to it when cooking ..all the while poor shayne's chewing on it. Oh i can't take it 😭.rock made an amazing edit gotta say
Shayne contemplating all of his life decisions towards the end was the best thing i've seen on this show
Nicole: you guys are so mean to him
Garett: *MINIACLY laughs seeing his friends in pain*
THEY MADE ME WHO I AM
@@garrettpalm you made them too XD
"friends"
Is miniacly when you behave like a minion?
Shane truly played himself here "the way this episode is going, I think Garret truly has lost his mind"
famous last words
Garrett giving Josh, Burger But Cold the Third (since Josh already made the sequel) while wearing a Burger But Cold is slick dedication...I love it. Garrett has truly lost his mind and we hope he considers joining our team. Together, we'd be the perfect duo to troll the rest of the world.
Nice one, Kim Jong-un
Those Shane scene interjections as they enjoy Olivia's dish was pure *chef's kiss* Better luck next time Shayne LOL
Will Shayne ever be able to be on this show again? Will Shayne ever be able to eat again? Is Shayne going to be okay?
Find out next time on Dragonball Z
watching Josh cry is just so satisfying. it's like revenge for the anxiety that runs through me when I watch him cook.
Josh calling out "other Josh" is the best. I would love to see that head to head.
Everyone:*laughing*
Meanwhile Shayne:*crying*
My favorite thing is Garret’s maniacal laughter whenever someone takes a bite of a bad dish.
Complete silence as the eater takes a bite, tries to determine those initial first tastes, everyone else waiting with bated breath to see their reaction.
And Garret, sitting in the corner, his laughter filling the empty silence as he takes enjoyment from knowing he has caused others suffering.
Shayne has officially been defeated. Garrett will not be returning from work ever again.
lmao i've been laughing for like 10 mins over Shanes misery after that dish.
The nut comment from Olivia just made Shayne crack just that one bit more 🤣
Shayne reaction was like that ratatouille scene with Ego but opposite
The exceedingly broken look on Shane's face was brilliant 😅
I’ve been waiting for a Josh and Josh collab for a very long time
Oh my god Shayne’s face the moment he realized that Olivia’s dish was good. Man looked like he was ready to just give up on life. 16:52
After this video, Shayne can now taste malic acid like a normal person again
I feel like Garret has made it his personal mission to make Shayne question all his life choices every episode.
The existencial pain on Shayne's face is priceless xD
Olivia being such a sweetheart eating the pizzle dish with shayne and bringing him the yeet bucket when everyone's chanting "swallow" got me.
Rock did a great job editing this! I truly understood Shayne’s pain .
Of course Olivia would love the most horrendous dish. Liv, what is WRONG WITH YOU?!? 🫣🫣🫣
Also, Josh yeeted?? Garrett, you have achieved the unthinkable! 😂
the look of pure hatred on shayne's face while olivia is eating the ziti is absolutely increbile
At first I was bummed that Josh was safe after the first round but then I remembered he plays this game wrong and tastes everything no matter what 😂
Olivia just saying to Viana “wow ur so good at eating” lol I love it
Shayne genuinely looks like he's on the verge of tears oml
It’s videos like these that really make me appreciate that Good Mythical Morning acquired Smosh
*Josh* : “You ate the ball sack?”
*Olivia* : “I did 😁.”
*Josh* : “Did you like it?”
*Olivia* : “Yes 😏.”
*Josh* : “Sometimes it’s just easier to swallow 😉.”
Shayne has suffered the most. He needs his revenge.
For anyone wondering whether Shane is flexing his acting skills.... that's rage that's pure rage. It took every ounce of his energy to not walk over there and just punch Garrett in the face.
poor Shayne needs a break, yall should do an episode with Garrett in it and give him like five bibs and let Shayne make all the food
At 14:03 when shayne finds out what he ate, my UA-cam stop working so I think I can understand that it was mind-blowing
Shayne is just done after Olivia’s bite 😂😂😂
Garrett getting Josh to yeet is the "Eat it or yeet it" equivalent to Shane making Gus Johnson laugh.
these guests are BRILLIANT bring these people back for SURE they are hilarious!!!
Josh getting reaping and sowing backwards was so on brand
Honestly Shayne's trademark is just staring off into space with all the trauma of a war veteran
V, Josh and Nicole were some real troopers dealing with Garrett and his food crimes. Very fun!
Dude- Shane this entire episode is a pure MOOD.
There's something nostalgic about just one guy creating weird food for a challenge, it feels like a throwback to the origins of Mythical Kitchen.
Shayne’s look of betrayal. He should just know that if he’s going to avoid the big bite, it will automatically be delicious.
You can see the exact moment the light leaves Shane's eyes and he finally snaps.
I’ve never laughed so hard at shayne’s pain 🤣
Shayne's face went from disdain to betrayal to depression acceptance too many times in this one 😅
Shayne is internally punching and kicking the air right now🤣
This was the funniest thing, just kept getting funnier. I already had to take a break before even getting to shane and definitely wasn't ready
🤣😂🤣 Shayne just went completely dead face when he found out!
Shane...my poor Shane.... Best laugh I've had in a long time.
2:52 Lmao "You're a bad person!" and he sounds so hurt
"these videos are filmed in front of a live studio Kiana" didn't get NEARLY enough love😂😂❤❤
Courtney dresses like the literal embodiment of a forever 21 ad
Spicy is to Josh like what Sour is to Shayne and I love it 😂
Shane’s acting… I felt that broken soul/ villain origin story 18:42
That wasn’t acting… that’s just him.
16:22 cant believe josh would slander shayne’s favorite pizza place like that
olivia: i don't know it's like kind of nutty
shayne: of ALL the adjectives
loll
We need the podcast back just to hear more about the aftermath of this episode for Shayne😂😂