Amit Shah & Mallikarjun Kharge Engage In Fiery Debate Over Article 370 Verdict | Parliament Session
Вставка
- Опубліковано 10 гру 2023
- Article 370 verdict Updates: The Supreme Court upheld the constitutional validity of the abrogation of Article 370 through a presidential order in 2019. A five-judge bench, headed by Chief Justice of India DY Chandrachud, held that the abrogation stands valid and that the provision under Article 370 was temporary, which was a result of war conditions at the time.
The verdict created an uproar in the Parliament where in the Rajya Sabha Home Minster Amit Shah & Congress Chief Mallikarjun Kharge engaged in a a war of words while discussing the Jammu & Kashmir Reorganisation (Amendment) Bill 2023.
In the verdict, the top court also noted that the President's order was not mala fide and that Article 370 provides for integration of Jammu and Kashmir and not for disintegration.
#article370 #article35a #supremecourt #jammuandkashmirnews #cjidychandrachud #NayaJammuKashmir #parliamentwintersession #amitshah #mallikarjunkharge
Subscribe to India Today for NEW VIDEOS EVERY DAY and make sure to enable Push Notifications so you'll never miss a new video.
All you need to do is PRESS THE BELL ICON next to the Subscribe button!
India Today TV is India's leading English News Channel. India Today UA-cam channel offers latest news videos on Politics, Business, Cricket, Bollywood, Lifestyle, Auto, Technology, Travel, Entertainment and a lot more.
Stay tuned for latest updates and in-depth analysis of news from India and around the world!
WhatsApp Channel: whatsapp.com/channel/0029Va2A...
Download App: indiatoday.link/wHaj
Follow us: Official website: www.indiatoday.in/
Twitter: / indiatoday
Facebook: / indiatoday
I mean what is congress fighting against? Against the integrity of India? There should be a limit on shamelessness.
They r not thinking it is against iintegrity of india.,As if they r only humans n largeheartedness , n the other community is communal,.But what injustice done to majority by these leaders in the guise of seculsrism, constituion etc is cheating of hindus, hidden all these years , fr kashmir to kanyakumari, only docile hindus suffered ,god only knows .sc in future also observe the real facts n deliver verdicts.
What about fee North East states?
@@pristlinpaulp4033 Keep trying and failing
Looking at this session I have become a fan of Shri Jagdeep Dhanwad... He really hold the speaker chair with so much respect and authority.. salute to him.
Dhankhar
Exactly
Very true, I used to think of him as a noob Modi puppet when he was Governor of West Bengal. Now, after looking at this session I seeing him as a very alert, sharp referee
Yes. Dhankad is knowledgeable qualified experienced human being.
Till date no chairman or speakers are seen cross questioning MP of LS and RS in Parliamentary sessions. It's good for the Indian democracy.
and with dignity
Modi is so lucky to have a opposition like this...
The stand of congress is very clear , stupidity at its peak….
😂 looking at this argument , I feel that congress will remain in opposition forever
Sir, Not for ever, only for 10 years. Later there will not be Khan Grace dirty party
New congress can emerge after the present set up.Meanwhile a strong hindu party also should start to save hindus, to protect its culture,revive the Dharma of centuries old, honest, serving people replace the present corrupt n greedy , selfish class.. Bharat was famous fr its virtuos, dharmic qualities. Once again sbould shine like that. Thks,
The true colour of congress is out.
Jai Bharat!
Farooq Abdullah should have been tried in the international court of Justice for genocide of kashmiri pandits as chief minister.
It may also happen in near future.
@rachaiah8187 This family successfully exploited weak Indian leadership from 1947 till 2014 and became billionairs from catching and selling fish in Dal Lake.
I expect such stupidity from DMK. But why is Congress goin along with it?
I'm losing hope in Congress the more I listen to their leaders and their stand.
Because Congress and DMK anti India and anti Hindu.
CONGRESS working really hard to bring in "0" seats in 2024! Guaranteed with our compliments.👍🇮🇳🇮🇳👍
DMK Member saying suppose if another govt comes ,n restore 370 article. Then it is against tbe Nation n will not happen. There r some enemies still to break Bharat ,waiting fr opportunity n we r hearing in the parliament itself by their speeches, ( Particularly some states ) so center should snub such elements, instantly. This is the concern of all indians.
I think congress cleared its position in the video itself, they are not supporting periyar.
Though , they are shoving their own leg.
Because khan-gress is equally stupid
Removal of 370 is called Bharat jodo, not the walking club caricature of Pappu Khan. Implement UCC to further cement this bond of one Bharat, one Bhartiya. Period.
how low congress can stoop to ? look at kharge, doesnt even have spine to condemn whatever seditious statement made by periyar. more over the person who quoted periyar also nurses the same view and endorses the same idealogy
Sir, Sonia congress is declared Anitinational party, identify people who vote for it.
@@harryshah6100 anti national*
@@harryshah6100😂😂😂😂
Very true.
Tiruchi, Janta tujhe uthaake desh ke baahar phenk denge.
You change your color. You are against the national integration. You do not belong to this country.
Congress is Pakistan party or Indian party why opposing the free kashmir like other states
Obviously, they have an agenda to bring back unrest in J & K, so they and their natural partners can make merry!
Congress is an Indian party which works for Pakistan.
Nehru referred to Periyar as a madman who should be put in a lunatic asylum. Does Sonia Congress agree with Nehru or not?
Huge respect to Shri Jagdeep Dhankar
This SPEAKER OF RAJYA SABHA is best in his duties. Great work.
I welcome to Speaker who stand for unite Bharath decision.❤❤❤
The whole country know who this Periyar was and his stand. We dont have to bother about what he said. Only a few tamilians consider him to be a hero. Congress is very upset their baby art 370 is now dead.
Only few ? Bet you are Brahmin 😂
@@VivekRajendran I am an Indian. May be only a few tamilians know who or what is brahmin.
@@VivekRajendranPeriyar was a mentally disturbed individual 😂
90 percent tamizh love periyar more than gandhi or nehru.
@@VivekRajendran page 21 - remember that - you Brahmin hater!
Vande Mataram!
10:55 Periyar has been ripped lol😂
I'm now waiting for DMK's "Hinthi Imposition" rant 😂😂
dmk is a Hindu Hating party that gives Gaalis to Hindus then speaks pakistan’s language.. just like congress, these Idiots will stoop to any low level.. but the people will teach these Morons a lesson.
Periya was a mad man as per Nehru
Periyar f c ked his own daughter
He encourages the bhalathkhar of women from other communities and he marries or uses his own daughter
dMK MLA's pulled the saree of a woman member of the opposition party at state Assembly. Because that was EV RAMASWAMY practice theory of DMK party,he was a originator of that party.
Nehru fans take note!😂😂😂
@@kabitabhaumik5829 DR BR Ambedkar also objection over betiyar(EV RAMASWAMY )dirty thoughts .
Now its Cristal clear congress and friends not against modi nor bjp...they are against integrity of india.
In this situation it becomes very important to know why they are doing that definitely not for vote
True face of congress
Like this the opposition will finish itself by going against the spirit of india...😢
85 year old man-child Kharge made some weird noise like a broken down Diesel Generator and ran away from RS, unable to bear Amit Shah's onslaught..... shameless fellow...
😂😂😂😂
What is the non sense with Congress to this country
The reason why Pakistan loves Congress party.
Khangrace party
Yes,Due to congi ,only pakistan formed. So natural .fr its love.
Yah yah I agree. 👍
Unfortunate congress is supporting dmk mps periyar statement shame on opposition
EVR was a separatist. He wanted British to continue ruling. DMK follows his policy. Siva says that from 1963 they wanted to be with India. Meaning they didn't want till then. Quiting EVR shows that reluctance even now. They hate India, majority Hindus, stand for separatism by this very fact of antigonism. Sick in mind by their perverted logic & expect people to respect this sickness
shame on Congress
Who is Periyar? Does he have any role in the running of this nation?
As a proud Indian J&K is India and those who oppose it are not Indian.
Jk is not in India anymore its now occupied territory. If article 370 was temporary its also applies fr jk bjp modi has not taken jks elected members into confidence its done without the WILL of the people by using indian armed forces and several jk people are still in jail without fir
Jk is not in India anymore its now occupied territory. If article 370 was temporary its also applies fr jk bjp modi has not taken jks elected members into confidence its done without the WILL of the people by using indian armed forces and several jk people are still in jail without fir
Jk is not in India anymore its now occupied territory. If article 370 was temporary its also applies fr jk bjp modi has not taken jks elected members into confidence its done without the WILL of the people by using indian armed forces and several jk people are still in jail without fir
Jk is not in India anymore its now occupied territory. If article 370 was temporary its also applies fr jk bjp modi has not taken jks elected members into confidence its done without the WILL of the people by using indian armed forces and several jk people are still in jail without fir
Jk is not in India anymore its now occupied territory. If article 370 was temporary its also applies fr jk bjp modi has not taken jks elected members into confidence its done without the WILL of the people by using indian armed forces and several jk people are still in jail without fir
Kharge says freedom of speech That does mean he is supporting Abdulla and Pakistan ? He has no guts to condemn Abdulla's words. Coward.
He is an Islamist. Pak China Congress all same.
The only person whose freedom of expression is being infringed upon is Mr Aroda😂😂😂
Listening with respects , humanity poisoned ! ! Blessings to the Hon'bl Members !
Congress is slowly becoming Synonymous to Pakistan with their mindset n thinking… wot a sorry state of this party… they ll loose by huge margin in 2024 for sure
It should be expunged because it was quoted by EVR! 🙄🤣
Mr. Dhankar is one of the best VPs of independent Bharat.
Day for celebration for SC Verdict on 370....
Victory for BJP and Modiji's and amitshajìs efforts
Jai J&K ,jai sri Ram
Not just expunge mr Mohd Abdullah. Remove him from Rajya Sabha
Our PM is great
Respect, salute & bow to the way Chairman Jagdeep Dhankar handled!
And to Mr. Kharge - everything written need not be uttered, that to in parliament, & specially not in the name of freedom of speech.
Lost all respect for Kharge. These guys don't condemn anything & just rant freedom of speech, rule of law.
Congi speak as tution.
How shameless these leaders are.We the people of this country reject these leaders.
Jagdeep dhankhar is great Vice President. I have never seen speaker so strongly put foot down. He is a no nonsense man. Thumbs up to him👍. DMK is surely going to lose election.
A big salute to the Rajya saba Speaker
Deshdrohi dmk and congress
It has come to pass that every institution has a price. The end.
I like the byline - no more tukde at any level
Sri Jagadeep Dhankar is the best chairman of the Rajyasabha I have ever seen. Congratulations Sir.
Simplify the procedure of the house regarding judgement of supreme court and rule out the business of the House
What a tough time the chairman has.
देश की जनता ध्यान रखना ये कभी इस देश के नही हो सकते
By this Kharge's logic if you quote a terrorist its ok because you just quoted someone else in the parliament. What kind of filibustering is this?
Sooper sir. My salutations to you sir. Put them in their place.
I urge people of india to understand the congress to what extent they can go they want to support revoke article 370 and support militancy
It is pity
What a kind of leadership today leading the a century old party.
The word Shameless has a new meaning .. UPA /I.N.D.I Alliance
Periyar was like jinnah divide & rule
Shame on congress
Those who. Vote for Congress look at what they are supporting they are supporting the breakup of Bharat
Danke!
The sessions in both the houses are conducted to discuss the expectations of the people who have opted to send you to both houses not to disturb the session providings.What goes on there is most humiliating.
Bjp why did you give escape route to khangres, you must have raised presumption of their consent 13:43
Well, BJP is letting the DMK and Congress do these comments , so that they say or support this divisive ideas and BJP gets the benefit.
I love how everyone is shouting. It should be a Netflix show.
Abdullah and team of Kashmir became nothing they should forget their past good days
Very disappointed by these loose mouth comments on the integrity of our nation. Seems some are still bent on split nation governance and waiting for their chance to split it. They must be disciplined coz they do not rightly represent us on the policy & legal forum like Rajaya Sabha
I doubt Kharge was aware of Article 370.
Because of such people who leads congress today congress never remained as national party , it has become headless as a result they always stand for nonsense even knowing and chairman is saying that it is direct hit on the heart of mother India, shameful
Great chairman good Modi for ur choice
Amit sha is the very greatest leader.
We are losing precious time in criticism instead of talking about development
💐💐💐💐💐💐🙏🙏🙏🙏
I am ashamed as a Congress supporter. Making me to think is I am supporting a correct party 😢😢
F kaangres
@@suryakantsattam4818 Yeah bro. What a anti national party. 😒😞
@@shankars4281😢
What congress member K.C. venugopal speaking of Periyar is rubbish. Periyar demanded continuance of Britishers rule to continue whereas the freedom fighters and indian national congress fight against britishers. Congress supporting them is itself shows the present state of congress partys pitiable condition.
Why these oppositions are howling like fish bazaar
If i have to learn patience, i need to watch Hon Speaker Shri Jagdeep Dhankar. Ram Ram
This guy K.C. Venugopal is the shame of the Congress
EVR was Anti Hindu whicj followed by DMK, same song they sing now.
Seriously......i could see the ignorance of the opposition and LOP is protecting their member's ignorance.
Take your seat..😂pls take your seat😂
The Chairman in Parliament is too lenient n the attitude of the opposition parties conduct proves ,they r not fit to be the representative of the voters....jst give them black n white warning of their behaviour, failing which they will be barred frm attending the parliament for 6 months n if it still continues they will be black listed...
What a mannerless home minister, interfered when someone is speaking.
He is the best Home Minister India ever had.
@@eitisingh3342 Are you kidding
Let all of this respected leaders came to North East MIZORAM and let them attend on Mizoram assembly.
This is Shameful.
good 👍
Everything is possible in India. All the written guides are just a showcase.
I respect my VP alot but pta nhi kyu usko dekhte hi hasi aa jaati hai.
یار اتنی زیادہ آوازیں تو ہمارے کراچی مچھلی بازار میں نہیں ہوتی اتنا شور کھوکھا چنا باجے گنا
Jagdeep dhankar is so damn partial. Most partial VP india ever got.
We don’t allowed periyar words in entire nation if DMK interest you discuss with in your party
Supreme Court judgment can be discussed and even trenchantly criticized by parliamentarians in Parliament. Nothing wrong. That is what People's representatives are expected to do.
Dismiss that MP from the house permanently know
Mr. Arora bole ki nahi finally
Fish Markets are calm and smooth!
Jai shree ram ❤❤❤❤
status of upper parliament has become kahaai kahani ghar ghar ki..You can watch it for cheap thrills..Feels like big boss 😂😂
Whatever the government do (even if it benefits the country)....opposition has to oppose it...mantra of opposition
Kharge ji reciting shers reminds of the movie Loha and the epic Sher war between Lukka and Pakhiya 😂
Have been to many countries in Europe, Asia, Africa..... Never seen such low level of politics in any civilized country.
Mr Arora,, speak bro speak.
Very unfortunate we got like a Dhanwar!!!!!!!
Why kharge against abrogation of article 370. Is it merely opposing Modi and BJP but at the cost integrity of india?
Really we proud of you Sudhansu Tribedi sir 🙏