it kills me to watch this. poor, poor Louis. he already feels insecure about his voice (he feels more confident now since no control project tho), & now he could barely sing his solo cause he was sick :| love him so much. 😘
+BEA ALONSO HAZZA El no es un desastre, el esta enfermo y no puede esforzar su voz. Ademas, el se siente un poco inseguro de su voz ya que MUCHAS lo critican y no es justo, porque el tiene la voz más hermosa del mundo. Entonces, si vas a criticarlo mejor te callas.
+BEA ALONSO HAZZA típica piba que flashea casamiento con HAZZA. rayita una cosa el estaba enfermo pero igual cante o no aún así le pagan millones y tiene de novio a un jodido pibe que esta re bueno, deja de romper las pelotas
+slikpont I wouldn't see why. He tweeted out he had a sore throat. The poor boy was struggling to sing (as you can see he's coughing quite a bit as well).
"Fans" who comment "Louis, please leave, the band doesn't need you" how can you call yourselves fans? Seriously, if you love one direction, you love all of them, and if you hate on any of them then you're not a fan in my eyes and you're probably not a fan in their eyes either, especially Louis'. They're not perfect and they're aloud to have off performances, especially when they're sick! Louis tried his best and for that I am immensely proud of him. Without Louis the band wouldn't sound half as good as they do with him, Louis voice adds uniqueness to their sound, Louis voice complements each of his other band mates voices perfectly, especially Harry's. When Louis and Harry sing together and you hear their voices at the same time, it sounds so wonderful, if it were just Harry, it wouldn't sound the same, it wouldn't sound right. Every single member's voice is just as vital as the next! Every single member has had an off performance. Every single member deserves just as much love and support as the rest. So people who think Louis should leave the band, should leave the fandom, because you're not wanted here.
Harry Hepburn this comment is the best I’ve read and I entirely agree with you. Please appreciate Louis for his effort. He doesn’t deserve the hate. In fact, none of them do.
All I'm seeing is Louis, Harry and Niall in those comments, so I just want to say... Liam, my baby, you did it once again! I'll never get over his voice, it just gets to me every time.
Mama Bear Shares I just watched their experience on x-factor last night and he used to have the lead vocal on their songs! Now I feel like its the Harry show (harry is incredible as well but Liam just melts my heart!) And puberty has been very kind to him! SEXY MAN!
Louis had sore throat, but i remember in a "facts about LT" list i've read, he has tinnitus (ringing ear) and/or hearing problem. If it's true, naturally he cant recognise the key or changed key. I've suffered from tinnitus too and it's really disturbing cause it makes me harder to concentrate on music. So i always sing onto original key and never been able to sing if they changed the key. Again IF it's true, that means he has done a very good job in his entire life making music and catching up with 1D's :) and IF it's not, the cause maybe his sore throat. He pushed the voice and it became uncontrollable. No hate, we all love Louis Tomlinson.
@Militaru Maria She didn't compare any of the boys... She just said that she loved Harry and Niall's solo. She didn't say who did better or anything like that. So there is no need for you to get offended. Ofc all the boys put their tremendous efforts here and all of them killed it.
Not only was louis not feeling well i don't think he was feeling the change in key, regardless they all did really well let's pray they can do some more acoustic renditions like this for mitam esp live
+littlecoconutinc yeah i get what you mean bc he's a tenor isn't he?? I love his vocal ability i hope that in mitam it's emphasised (maybe seeing him doing not just the chorus but some harmonies okg sjcjsn djfjscn)
+Francesca Cruz He's a reedy tenor, yeah. The other guys can go low (especially Liam) and the key change did not help. The key change worked great for Niall though, he sounded really good.
that girl who carried a sign in harry's face all the vid.. i mean okay.. they read it.. i swear they read it like each one 15 times.. just drop it down!
The problem Louis had wasn't because he was sick. The original song (and the way they perform it live) is in C minor. Here, the guitarist chose to play the song two tones below the original one ( here he plays it in A minor). Performers normally do that when they have to sing a song in acoustic so as to be able to hit the song's high notes without any trouble. Sometimes it's hard to fit your voice in a song played differently from the way you are used to. That's all. (He has a great voice)
They all sound so good. Nialls voice stabbed me a thousand times Harrys voice nearly killed me Liams voice killed me Louis' voice slayed me. Even tho louis sounded sick i still think he sounds good.
Where's the Liam appreciation?! All I hear is Louis,Niall and Harry. I understand that Louis is sick and stuff but anyways ....... Liam, Babe you did amazing 😘👏
+Lovee1DForEva There is little to say about Liam because it is simply perfect. Clarified that is not my favorite, but I recognize that it is the most balanced of all.
my boys 💖 my little Lou was sick.... but he still sounds beautiful don't worry my sweety ✨ Harry slays so much , Liam slays so much with this low notes, Niall was just perfect too 🔥🔥 they just amazing no matter what lol
give guys a break they did this for a great charity rays sunshine. my daughter was thare this day and they sang to her Wat makes you beautiful. sang it amazing. was best day ever for her. these guys are incredible to take time of to spend time with these kids with illnesses last thing they need is criticism.. RESPECT them.
Niall slayed it! 💚 Harry was on point! 👌 Liam sounded incredible! And Louis' raspy voice is so mesmerizing! And he was sick so give him a break! He seemed so dissapointed. I love you Lou! 💙
Liam was amazing, he always sounds so good and will never stop saying how much I love him from all of my heart and how talented he is. I really do love him more than everything and he deserves the very best.
I 'm so proud of these boys, especially Louis right now, even sick he was there,trying so hard to give his best. I love this boy so much.. please, God, protect our baby,he's rare.
We all know Louis can sing very well and it's clear that he was sick here coz he couldn't even sing the nobody nobody part! Some might say other wise but damn I've heard him live and his voice is just sooooooo amazing!
harry was so sweetheart. he bring up the mood after loui crack voice and liam's note change. he said to the audience to sing along with them. such a sweetheart
my son :(( this still makes me sad but he tried so hard and if i see anyone bashing him idc if it's a comment from last year i will ROAST them like fuckin cashew nuts no one gets to insult my (and harry's) ball of sunshine
I showed this video to my vocal coach and no, he wasn't sick. He just started off on the wrong key (probably one that he can't even sing on) and couldn't find his way back to the key he should be singing on so he gave up. Now that been said, this video is very old and i heared that he's been taking vocal coaching so hopefully he's better now. It's clear in this video that he needed work so it's good that he's taking it. I also asked her about Harry specifically and she said "He is a proper singer" and i couldn't agree more.
It's nearing the end of the tour has Niall just had a boost of energy like he's been singing good for ages but itS LIKE HES SUDDENLY RISEN FROM THE DEAD
Louis seemed so sad when he couldn't finish his solo, baby we love you, always.
+Talia “Horan” From 5 Seconds Of Summer even tho
he was sick
🥺💙💙
@@jill5852 i think he was used to sing it live with the music and the acoustic threw him off
He started singing in the wrong key and got a bit lost
it kills me to watch this.
poor, poor Louis. he already feels insecure about his voice (he feels more confident now since no control project tho), & now he could barely sing his solo cause he was sick :|
love him so much. 😘
It really is heartbreaking. We know how talented he is! I know he was sick, but it hurts to see him give up so easily and not try. :(
+Tammi Laura it really does hurt. it's obvious he's STILL a little bit insecure about his voice cause he barely even tried singing his solo. 😭😔
+ Elizabeth Damian PUEDE CANTAR SOLO CUANDO TIENE AYUDA DEL EQUIPO ,,,,SOLO NO PUEDE CANTAR NADA,ES UN DESASTRE,
+BEA ALONSO HAZZA El no es un desastre, el esta enfermo y no puede esforzar su voz. Ademas, el se siente un poco inseguro de su voz ya que MUCHAS lo critican y no es justo, porque el tiene la voz más hermosa del mundo. Entonces, si vas a criticarlo mejor te callas.
+BEA ALONSO HAZZA típica piba que flashea casamiento con HAZZA. rayita una cosa el estaba enfermo pero igual cante o no aún así le pagan millones y tiene de novio a un jodido pibe que esta re bueno, deja de romper las pelotas
they need to do more accoustics
+Sophia Horan i dont think louis s agree w this
+slikpont I wouldn't see why. He tweeted out he had a sore throat. The poor boy was struggling to sing (as you can see he's coughing quite a bit as well).
Accoustic four
Tai Lan yeess!!
They...
I just can't stand it how some people in the comments are hating on Boo Bear. Please understand that he was sick. Please.
the funny thing is that I have not yet seen a single bad comment about Lou here lmao
AVeryProfessionalFangirl Well there are loads over here. But no need to find bad comments about someone though!
AVeryProfessionalFangirl yeah
•esha• One Direction is awesome
@@averyprofessionalmieke I have. people saying he can't sing, ever, and he should leave the band. like wtf
we understand louis. get well soon bby xx
+anindya kusuma So can somebody explain with why Louis didn't make like a effort ?
+Miaew Make effort for what?? That poor boy is sick. Leave him alone..
Ok I didn't know, thank you for the answer.
+Miaew well its answered
Miaew
no problem
I love it when the crowd sings for Louis
Coz he needs help. He can't sing 😂
nimbi concepcion GET THE FUCK OUT HE WAS SICK
@@cerenlik he always perform like that tho. He can't sing.
@@hestnb5771 you're sick. please leave the fandom
@@hestnb5771 no he definitely did not. absolutely discusted by you. leave the fucking fandom. you support all or none.
Man Harry freaking SLAYS on the last part!!! Gives me the chills.... WOOhooo Harry I love you!!!!!!!!!!
right bruh I died
Same! I loveeeeeee Harry most!
Hannah Lewis he's mine😜😂
Hannah Lewis 2:56
All the time ❤
Harry was so soft and his voice at the end is just perfect.
Harry was so soft and his this vioce at the end is just perfect
Harry's voice is just so magnificent that I still get chills sometimes even after all these 5 years!
"Fans" who comment "Louis, please leave, the band doesn't need you" how can you call yourselves fans? Seriously, if you love one direction, you love all of them, and if you hate on any of them then you're not a fan in my eyes and you're probably not a fan in their eyes either, especially Louis'. They're not perfect and they're aloud to have off performances, especially when they're sick! Louis tried his best and for that I am immensely proud of him. Without Louis the band wouldn't sound half as good as they do with him, Louis voice adds uniqueness to their sound, Louis voice complements each of his other band mates voices perfectly, especially Harry's. When Louis and Harry sing together and you hear their voices at the same time, it sounds so wonderful, if it were just Harry, it wouldn't sound the same, it wouldn't sound right. Every single member's voice is just as vital as the next! Every single member has had an off performance. Every single member deserves just as much love and support as the rest. So people who think Louis should leave the band, should leave the fandom, because you're not wanted here.
Harry Hepburn this comment deserves a million likes, is amazing💖🌼
Harry Hepburn this comment is my fav comment
Harry Hepburn this comment is the best I’ve read and I entirely agree with you. Please appreciate Louis for his effort. He doesn’t deserve the hate. In fact, none of them do.
I Love this but, Nobody’s saying that(no hate)
Que hino de comentário 🌹♥️
All I'm seeing is Louis, Harry and Niall in those comments, so I just want to say...
Liam, my baby, you did it once again! I'll never get over his voice, it just gets to me every time.
Liam is so kind ;-; his voice is gorgeous
+Its Just Lisanne Liam is my favorite! I never understand why more people don't talk about him!
+Its Just Lisanne LOVE LIam! He is for sure my favorite, his voice is like butter. :)
Mama Bear Shares I just watched their experience on x-factor last night and he used to have the lead vocal on their songs! Now I feel like its the Harry show (harry is incredible as well but Liam just melts my heart!)
And puberty has been very kind to him! SEXY MAN!
+Its Just Lisanne I agree :) I'll never get iver his voice too ♥
Poor Louis .. I almost cry on seeing my baby sick :( .. And people don't even understand he was sick .. Please stop mock and hate him he's and angel
Louis had sore throat, but i remember in a "facts about LT" list i've read, he has tinnitus (ringing ear) and/or hearing problem. If it's true, naturally he cant recognise the key or changed key. I've suffered from tinnitus too and it's really disturbing cause it makes me harder to concentrate on music. So i always sing onto original key and never been able to sing if they changed the key.
Again IF it's true, that means he has done a very good job in his entire life making music and catching up with 1D's :) and IF it's not, the cause maybe his sore throat. He pushed the voice and it became uncontrollable. No hate, we all love Louis Tomlinson.
+Littleblackdress 95 Oh I didn't know that about him...interesting. And yes, we all love Louis and his voice.
+Littleblackdress 95 This comment should be on top of all the comments. And of course, we all love Louis and his voice. Hope he gets well soon xx
Waaaaaait a minute. He has tinnitus for sure or you think he might? No offense, but is this why he goes off key a lot? My mind is racing
+CHEL no I don't think he does. he said he had loss of hearing once (not tinnitus) but then corrected that.
***** yes he does
NIALL AND HARRY KILLED THIS
And Liam!!!!!! Poor Louis,
Best duo
YESSS
Louis and Liam too!!! Louis was sick poor baby
@Militaru Maria She didn't compare any of the boys... She just said that she loved Harry and Niall's solo. She didn't say who did better or anything like that. So there is no need for you to get offended. Ofc all the boys put their tremendous efforts here and all of them killed it.
niall is killing every performance these days like omg he's killing it
🥲
HArry was perfect at the beginning like actually it was a work of art
Reece Fougner-Rukus he's always perfect
Reece Fougner-Rukus like Niall, Liam and Louis too
dude he's always perfect ..screw that he's more than just perfect
honey, Harry was already perfect before he was even born. Yeah, that's how perfect Harry Styles is..
Harry sounds so beautiful
he always does
Poor Louis he felt so sad after singing his solo WE LOVE YOU LOUIS
NV RS yes
Right when I heard Louis I threw my phone. I can't put myself through this. my heart just shattered
me too
Same. I was almost in tears.
Me too😭😭
That was hard to watch
+miracle laila I literally paused it seconds after hearing him
i had to emotionally prepare myself for nialls solos
yo i literally saw you in like....1273728 videos of fetus one d acapellas and one video with "over again" and rain
lmao thats me
lol he is though?????
stockholmstylan ikr!!! He is beautiful
fastlane i will fight u
Not only was louis not feeling well i don't think he was feeling the change in key, regardless they all did really well let's pray they can do some more acoustic renditions like this for mitam esp live
😂
+littlecoconutinc yeah i get what you mean bc he's a tenor isn't he?? I love his vocal ability i hope that in mitam it's emphasised (maybe seeing him doing not just the chorus but some harmonies okg sjcjsn djfjscn)
+Francesca Cruz He's a reedy tenor, yeah. The other guys can go low (especially Liam) and the key change did not help. The key change worked great for Niall though, he sounded really good.
Harrys just so effortless 😍
Louis bby c'mon with me :(
he is sick, so... :(
+xdorothyworld ik, my baby feels bad :( I want hug him.
so little and so fragile ;--;
yes, so tiny so perfect :'(
Hey! Can U watch my very first cover? If you like please like and Give me a comment. If you did this would be awesome. If you don't have a great day!
and I swear NO one can sing harry's highnote ,he freaking slays it. legend af
omg louis baby...he was having such a hard time with his sore throat..:( :(
My only question. How the bloody hell did they get everyone so quiet
This was a charity event. Most of the people in attendance are sick kids with their parents 😁👍🏼
Harry sounds magnificent. This is beautiful all the boys did a really good job.
I never knew I needed to hear Harry sing this acoustic until I did. Absolutely beautiful and powerful at the same time.
Harry's high note 😭😍
Awww my Lou Lou, I really really wanted to hear him sing this acoustic :(, My poor boy :(
Harry just sounds SO GOOD!
Why nobody talks about Liam's fucking perfect voice ??!
Ariana Stylinson People are just stuck on Harry
that girl who carried a sign in harry's face all the vid.. i mean okay.. they read it.. i swear they read it like each one 15 times.. just drop it down!
Hahahahah :)
keren
keren
maria tarhini exactly SO annoying 😠😠😠
These were ill kids it was a charity event, maybe she didn't even know what she was doing
every time he hits those high notes my lifespan increases by 10 years
L
really? I freaking die everytime😂
Niall always slays DMD like srsly💁👏🏼🔥
harry...... this voice
The problem Louis had wasn't because he was sick. The original song (and the way they perform it live) is in C minor. Here, the guitarist chose to play the song two tones below the original one ( here he plays it in A minor). Performers normally do that when they have to sing a song in acoustic so as to be able to hit the song's high notes without any trouble. Sometimes it's hard to fit your voice in a song played differently from the way you are used to. That's all. (He has a great voice)
Rodrigo Coarasa he was. sick
1d_vocals_slay_my_existence no, he wasn't, but that's okay
Rodrigo Coarasa he was sick u can tell from his voice and he was coughing at 1:22
He was sick, you can see him coughing.
Exactly and he's a tenor, his voice is not for low notes. But the key change really worked for Niall.
They all sound so good.
Nialls voice stabbed me a thousand times
Harrys voice nearly killed me
Liams voice killed me
Louis' voice slayed me.
Even tho louis sounded sick i still think he sounds good.
honestly is there ever a time when One Direction don't slay? they are so fuckking awesome
True gurl😭😍
HAARRRRY
HE SOUNDS SO WONDEFULLLLLLL
I like the way Naill sung I'm not scared of the dark
Niall*
+xKoekje Koekje oh sorry I mean Niall
Yeah some time we write wrong because of the phone they change the words
Where's the Liam appreciation?!
All I hear is Louis,Niall and Harry. I understand that Louis is sick and stuff but anyways .......
Liam, Babe you did amazing 😘👏
Yeah, Liam is my favorite!
+Lovee1DForEva There is little to say about Liam because it is simply perfect. Clarified that is not my favorite, but I recognize that it is the most balanced of all.
+Stars and Rainbows you gotta love them all
NARRY VOICEEEEee
yessss... niall's voice made me teary
+TheBinigurl same xD
HARRY SLAYS THIS
my boys 💖 my little Lou was sick.... but he still sounds beautiful don't worry my sweety ✨ Harry slays so much , Liam slays so much with this low notes, Niall was just perfect too 🔥🔥 they just amazing no matter what lol
When Liam harmonizes with the boys sounds so freakin good
Yas narry is owning this shit!!
Don't forget Liam!
+Tammi Laura Thats true. It's a shame that louis is sick though..
Stylan should live tbh
Liam too!!! And poor Louis, I heard he was sick that day
Harry's vocals are so good. Man can SING!
Harry's voice on the beginning 💟💟💟
Hight note do Harry 😍😍😍👏
HARRY SOUNDS AMAZING AS USUAL
Liam's voice is just amazing
can't get enough of Niall's voice
give guys a break they did this for a great charity rays sunshine. my daughter was thare this day and they sang to her Wat makes you beautiful. sang it amazing. was best day ever for her. these guys are incredible to take time of to spend time with these kids with illnesses last thing they need is criticism.. RESPECT them.
👏👏👏👏👏 Thnx for saying this. It means a lot for the Directioners.
THEY SOUND SO GOOD OMG THANK U SO MUCH THAT VIDEO IS WHAT I LOVE FOR BUT LOUIS WAS HAVING A HARD TIME WITH HIS SORE THROAT I HOPE HE'S OKAY NOW :(
Niall and Harry killed it 😍 and Liam you were amazing, as usual 🔥 and Louis get better bby ❤️
Niall slayed it! 💚 Harry was on point! 👌 Liam sounded incredible! And Louis' raspy voice is so mesmerizing! And he was sick so give him a break! He seemed so dissapointed. I love you Lou! 💙
liams deep voice 😍😍😍😍😍😍
Liam was amazing, he always sounds so good and will never stop saying how much I love him from all of my heart and how talented he is. I really do love him more than everything and he deserves the very best.
Y'all know that Liam exists right
Of course, he it's perfect. It's a shame his solos in this song are minimal.
Atlease Niall Finally got a big solo:)
Duh😂😂we all love Liam... People usually just don't care and move on,,, I don't,,, I scream my head off when his solos come,,,
No. I wouldn't know from his big solos in every song....
okay Niall sounds so so good for what
Niall voice is everything
i think they are doing fine without zayn.
+roter13 nobody asked you tho
Tbh I'm a huge directioner and I agree
+hey itsanahoj Don't ruin the moment. Nobody needs to be asked for him to share his opinion.
+hey itsanahoj and nobody asked you to comment...
Olivia Delaney why you care tho?
Harry's voice is so fucking HOT! I can't even... SDFSADFADF
I just love how harry does this small break between 'baby you're my' and 'soul' and he says soul like ssssoul, my heart skipped a beat #100%fangirl
LOUIS MY BABY!!
PS where's the Liam appreciation!?!
hopefully Louis gets well soon. he's wonderful.
Niall definitely slayed it!
Harry is a true vocalist to be able to sing the series of notes at the end without his voice cracking
HARRYS HIGH NOTE THO LIKE AHHHHH
Nialls voice is like an angle came down from above to be in one direction ✨⭐️✌️❤️💘👍🌻
I 'm so proud of these boys, especially Louis right now, even sick he was there,trying so hard to give his best. I love this boy so much.. please, God, protect our baby,he's rare.
the crowd participation is so important
it’s the way niall ate up this whole performance for me
Harry = Perfection
We all know Louis can sing very well and it's clear that he was sick here coz he couldn't even sing the nobody nobody part! Some might say other wise but damn I've heard him live and his voice is just sooooooo amazing!
Aaaww Lou hope you get better. I find it cute how the boys, Harry, sang Louis' solo for him. 😍
harry was so sweetheart. he bring up the mood after loui crack voice and liam's note change. he said to the audience to sing along with them. such a sweetheart
Harry's high notes I can't
my son :(( this still makes me sad but he tried so hard and if i see anyone bashing him idc if it's a comment from last year i will ROAST them like fuckin cashew nuts no one gets to insult my (and harry's) ball of sunshine
PREACH
Yash LARRRYY
awww i know, poor nugget was sick and just didn't quite catch the change of key :( he looks so sad after, poor thing.
I showed this video to my vocal coach and no, he wasn't sick. He just started off on the wrong key (probably one that he can't even sing on) and couldn't find his way back to the key he should be singing on so he gave up. Now that been said, this video is very old and i heared that he's been taking vocal coaching so hopefully he's better now. It's clear in this video that he needed work so it's good that he's taking it. I also asked her about Harry specifically and she said "He is a proper singer" and i couldn't agree more.
No he was actually sick u can see him coughing and he also apologized in the interview before that he had no voice or smth
Lou, your voice is amaizing 💜
awh i bet Harry hugged louis and made him drink some hot tea
I loved how everyone supported Louis and sung with him.❤😍
NIALL AND HARRY KILLED IT, poor louis
The boys and the fans were so supportive of him..Louis deserves all the love
LOUIS!!!AAAAWWWHHH MYYY LITTLLEEE BABBEEEE😭💔💔💔💔
Niall is always killing performance. He has got a great voice, the better of the boys after Liam
Woww beautiful voices and also Louis wowww
harry and niall ate this up!!!
Feel so sorry for Louis but on a higher note, I'm so proud of Niall!! His voice is so much stronger now!!
Louis had a sore throat but his voice still gave me shivers
I love how no one cheered while Harry singing. Everyone just listened. That was awesome
HARRYS HIGH NOTE IM DEAD
Did we just got a narry collab!!
It's nearing the end of the tour has Niall just had a boost of energy like he's been singing good for ages but itS LIKE HES SUDDENLY RISEN FROM THE DEAD
o solo do louis e do liam me causaram dor física
The moment when Harry starts to sings. My goooood
OMG Harry's solos were PERFECT
He and niall were great louis I hope u get better soon and liam good job
once again Liam's voice save them... perfect always..