Actually Singapore Army were trained by Israeli, especially the armoured force, not Taiwanese. They only in Taiwan for the large training ground where Singapore lack.
Hi. I am a singaporean man. I serve my NS a soldier for my country singapore. After watching all this and they talk about how SAF was form. They really do not know it at all. For 20 over years taiwan is still after all taiwan. Never change. They really knew noting and talk all rubbish. Too rubbish.
10 years old NDP…. We have moved to Hunter IFV Liao. Land Rovers.. These were British Surplus SG bought for 1 dollar each in the 1980s.. lasted so long. Is it still running?
one of the reasons Singapore's defence improved so much compared to Taiwan is because we don't have silly programs such as this. this program misinterpreted history, and claims credit with the sole purpose of increasing viewership. go on, you are doing a great disservice to your own people.
Get your history right before saying things! Singapore focus on friendships and ties building, not those what the program has said. Totally misleading and giving the wrong information!
Very disappointed with Taiwan. How can they allow their media to sprout nonsense. After 6 years, have we send our troops to China for training? Loss of diplomatic credibility.
@@Wong_wong565 I know some units used to train with Taiwan's military. But i guess 'not only that ' means not only tw, but also with Americans soldiers and Australian soldiers separately .
They got it wrong on Singapore's military spending. In 2013, Singapore's GDP was 297 billion US dollars. In 2013, Singapore's military spending was 3.4% of GDP. That amounted to 8.91 billion US dollars. The show reported 4.3 billion US dollars only, that's only HALF the actual amount. If Taiwan really spent 8.3 billion US dollars, Singapore actually spent more than Taiwan. Singapore was also recently the Top 5 importer of arms. Lol they anyhow say, talk rubbish.
We had never have taiwan personnel helping us set up SAF. Lol it was israel army. We only use the land in taiwan to train our soldiers. They are train by our own officers and sergeants. Usually the one that go taiwan is the infantry. My sergeant his scs time go taiwan before.
Don't forget this The RSAF first jets fighter were the Strikemaster and Hawker Hunter built by the British. So guess who trained the first batch of pilots? Only when RASF decided to acquired the A4 skyhawks then came the Taiwanese because they are more familiar to American aircrafts
太好笑了!! What a load of bullshit. After watching NDP for so many years, this is the first time I find it so interesting. They should be invited to host the show for us HAHA
Singapore development is a long-term planned programme from day 1 after independence. It is a concerted and collective effort by the government with clear objectives. National Day celebration should be viewed as an update to all citizens and residents living in Singapore the status of development and defense capability. Exaggeration, claiming credits to make everyone feel good and avoiding problems instead of trying to solve inherent national issues, keep on talking over again many times, will not make a country to progress. Ideology and not seeking factual truths will not result progress but remains stagnant and let others to overtake easily. 意识形态和不實事求事永远不会有进步！
真怀念有新聞龍卷風的夜晚😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅
Actually Singapore Army were trained by Israeli, especially the armoured force, not Taiwanese. They only in Taiwan for the large training ground where Singapore lack.
Taiwan is our brother always
我真的覺得這麼好的節目不該被從電視台下架
這麼好的綜藝節目沒有了少了很多樂趣
我很感恩我国国父李光耀先生 建立了三军能保卫我国国土 台湾的谋体是有一点错误的报道 我们现役军人也还在恒春军营训练 现在我军都在友好的国家联合交流军训 应该是正常的交流呀 不要说到新加坡很忘恩负意这样 谢谢您们✋😊
walao this one peak entertainment.
this is what freedoms of media gets you.. mayonnaise brains
Hi. I am a singaporean man. I serve my NS a soldier for my country singapore. After watching all this and they talk about how SAF was form. They really do not know it at all. For 20 over years taiwan is still after all taiwan. Never change. They really knew noting and talk all rubbish. Too rubbish.
Tell you this. I am so damn proud of my nation and my singapore gov. My honor is my total loyalty to my country.
Are they trying to stir trouble in the show?
10 years old NDP…. We have moved to Hunter IFV Liao. Land Rovers.. These were British Surplus SG bought for 1 dollar each in the 1980s.. lasted so long. Is it still running?
幸好我Google了相關資料，這視頻完全是誤導人家的歷史，1966年新加坡是開始照以色列軍事為樣本，由以色列訓練軍隊，空軍是由英國訓練，星光部隊是1975才有的。視頻一直強調中華民國，害我以為是中華民國是第一個支援的。這樣新聞評論，我真的是無話可說了。。。
刘仕成 ug
刘仕成 ffg
刘仕成 on
几十年前，我在学开飞机的时候，空军的教师是很多台湾来的。谢谢你
城老 所以你知道新加坡在看台灣新聞，和聽台灣人口說什麼台灣幫忙建軍心裡在想什麼嗎？
台灣根本就是井底蛙新聞嘛！做自己愛聽的。出了國就是笑死人。
想當年以色列軍官來新，你可想回教的馬來西亞和印尼是多麼抗拒的。
台灣只會作死自己的一天。自由，民主都是畸形的。
考北考幕？
新加坡军队在台湾演习什么时候参与台湾防守的战术，并且参与新加坡演习的台湾部队一般就几个连级单位，有那么严重吗？
从来没有。我们在台湾训练从来没台湾兵和我们训练、演习。最多是借几个驾驶兵资源一下。一般到训练区就只剩我们自己而已。可能休息点会有2-3个台湾驾驶闲坐着等分配驾驶任务。
真是二百五
Singaporean natives are actually ethnic Malays not Chinese
My heart is alway with Taiwan, seriously hope the special relationship between Taiwan and Singapore will stay forever and even stronger
最早年的星国軍官是由以色列軍隊训練，因邻近木斯林国家因素，而改去台灣，1986年我也有去恆春參加演習，相信至今新加坡武装部隊还有駐在台南
Singapore have to recognize these two talk condemned Singapore made sure they don't come to Singapore for tour.
我好爱❤️我的国新加坡🇸🇬
Like what you said already 40 year already thing have to change .
one of the reasons Singapore's defence improved so much compared to Taiwan is because we don't have silly programs such as this. this program misinterpreted history, and claims credit with the sole purpose of increasing viewership. go on, you are doing a great disservice to your own people.
新加波再添购八架 F-35 战机 , 预计2030年前交付 , 中期开始淘汰 F-16 战机 ， 更新空军整体作战系统 ....
Just let their own faith to the Natural Disasters the two of them talk so much & stress good luck .
Get your history right before saying things! Singapore focus on friendships and ties building, not those what the program has said. Totally misleading and giving the wrong information!
Thanks for telling everyone how much we grow, but we trained by Israel military. Thank you very much!
I think this type of Show very dangerous can created trouble if they telecast in Hong Kong what people think of Singapore sabotage.
小强国的光荣。新加坡万岁
Totally nonsense. No wonder Taiwan is in such a mess today.
agree with you...
This is a comedy channel in our country.
No evidence and nonsense is always their plot.
Very disappointed with Taiwan. How can they allow their media to sprout nonsense. After 6 years, have we send our troops to China for training? Loss of diplomatic credibility.
我们很想念李光耀。没有李光耀,就没有新加坡。其实我们走来不宜。一个小国家真的很不容易。所以我是新加坡人,非常骄傲。新加坡人都很善良的。
Penny Arts..是的, 我也非常想念新加坡国父李光耀先生。
那個哪裡是港口😂😂😂😂
It was Israel that helped us not taiwan when our military was just starting out.And singapore is a friend of taiwan! cheers
well its more than that.....
@@teogeorge3987 More your lj lah, tell us whats that? As usual talk cock singaporean.
@@Wong_wong565 I know some units used to train with Taiwan's military. But i guess 'not only that ' means not only tw, but also with Americans soldiers and Australian soldiers separately .
And not forgetting the New Zealand officers whom stay on after Singapore’s independence till 1980s.
新加坡的空军海军是台湾协助建立的，新加坡前期的空军海军司令是台湾人。。这些都是事实。可以参考一下新加坡老报人陈加昌2015出版的“我所认识的李光耀”。我是新加坡人
别又来反串吹牛了你决定不是新加坡人，新加坡的海军是由英国在1968到1971年训练的，新加坡的空军是由美国训练的，新加坡在1968就有F16 台湾在1997才有F16， 没连飞机都没有拿什么来训练新加坡的空军？ 开玩笑。
7年前的新聞，我們新加坡被阿共逼得扣坦克，差點被霸凌，都沒棄臺喔～
You keep on talk the same thing how many Years
They got it wrong on Singapore's military spending. In 2013, Singapore's GDP was 297 billion US dollars. In 2013, Singapore's military spending was 3.4% of GDP. That amounted to 8.91 billion US dollars. The show reported 4.3 billion US dollars only, that's only HALF the actual amount. If Taiwan really spent 8.3 billion US dollars, Singapore actually spent more than Taiwan. Singapore was also recently the Top 5 importer of arms. Lol they anyhow say, talk rubbish.
We had never have taiwan personnel helping us set up SAF. Lol it was israel army.
We only use the land in taiwan to train our soldiers. They are train by our own officers and sergeants. Usually the one that go taiwan is the infantry. My sergeant his scs time go taiwan before.
这么激动干嘛 我们都没当回事
Lol they say is firing blanks then no one will get hurt why cannot fire at live area ?
they should see our 2015 National Day Parade.
Don't forget this The RSAF first jets fighter were the Strikemaster and Hawker Hunter built by the British. So guess who trained the first batch of pilots? Only when RASF decided to acquired the A4 skyhawks then came the Taiwanese because they are more familiar to American aircrafts
Fan Yin Luen Skyhawks already obsolete long ago.
主持质料有点错
新加坡现役军人是71,600人。備役军是500,000人（保守估计）。
新加坡2014军事支出是92.3亿美金，不是43.8亿美金.
潜艇是瑞典的，德国潜艇购买还没交接。
新加坡阿兵哥在台湾的演训发生意外与犯案的事情都是事实。我是云林县梅林斗六的星光部队中人之一 。民国七十年代的星光部队在当地演习如同身在战场。说到松散这一点我是认同的。主播与解说员在视频中所说的一切有九十巴仙以上的可信度。当年的我们都让你们台湾阿兵哥喊做少爷兵。在斗六的时候我就是被你们这么叫的。
新加坡部隊是台湾培养出来的.....Errrr
自己国内的新闻不好好报导，拿别国的事耒胡扯乱说一堆废话，真是无聊。
Taiwan is just a place where there is training ground if taiwan feel offended Singapore Arm Forces train in China don't Act like the US.
直播看的时候心情兴奋，在这看怎么感觉像赛马。
我是西元1972年出生 在那個年代我是裝甲部隊 我相信我和新光部隊是好兄弟, 因為軍人是不會忘恩負義的, 真正的問題是上面的領導人和 軍官將領， 軍人只有聽從命令，
Why everyone is screaming!!
新加坡的水是化学再生的，化学品会导致皮肤橘皮，掉头发，洗肾，风湿骨痛，大脑缺氧，你在新加坡街上看看有多少洗肾中心，秃头，橘皮，风湿，我记得20年轻新加坡不是这样的
哈哈哈哈！什么鬼？你这是什么歪理啊？
然而马来西亚人的寿命远低于新加坡人
2008 training troops have got some conflict with the Taiwanese yp / street gang
如果有一些世界觀, 認識一些歷史, 或是查找一些基本資料, 便知道什麼事, 這些所謂媒體真的無奈、無語, 也慢慢明白為何不發牌予它。 另也可了解一些東亞或周邊歷史, 便會知道是什麼回事, 不只是沒有fact check , 也是可能一個誤導。
Thanks Taiwan...but we Singapore will never sell away Taiwan to China ...
新加坡国防力量强主要是我们的政治稳定，一个国家的政治人物如果天天吵吵闹闹那么要谈什么发展呢？
What a load of rubbish! The facts are all wrong, is there no accountability in the programme?
讲到阳痿都会站。
太好笑了!! What a load of bullshit. After watching NDP for so many years, this is the first time I find it so interesting. They should be invited to host the show for us HAHA
不要看不起小國。沒有進步只有退步。沒有強的政府，在多的資源也會用完。
黃玉鳳 馬來西亞與新加坡就是一個例子... 我是馬來西亞人...
ikr loads of crap
看看台星兩國國旗，星星、月亮、太陽都有了
你门的报導新闻是一流, 我是新加坡人, 赞👍
How can they compare Singapore & Taiwan big Country they think Singapore have to look at Taiwan to grow their talk of Singapore is all wrong history
新加坡的海軍是到中國探親，沒什么意圖。台灣誤會了！台灣和中國都是和我們唱同樣的新年快樂歌，我國沒必要靠攏誰。
我们跟以色列借将，和台湾借地。
豹2???過時...
現在是梅卡瓦MK IV...
LOL!!!
不要看不起小國。沒有進步只有退步。沒有強的政府，在多的資源也會用完。馬來西亞與新加坡就是一個例子... 我是馬來西亞人...
这是新加坡的毒虾理论。不过里头的资料有质点
台灣跟新加坡是什麼關係 你們不知道嗎。。 怎麼可能會出賣台灣啦。。想多了吧。
新加坡跟台灣演習，中國大陸就施壓。。如果是跟大陸演習，台灣就在那裡嘴。。 難做。。。
所以不就扩建在澳的场地，能训练的科目也多，还有他们两也不需再借題发揮在吵闹。新加坡也乐的自在。
20:57 什么叫感觉我们的军纪比较散漫一点。 如果散漫你们干吗还怕我们到大陆。这主持人和来宾因该多作些功课而不是死读剧组给的稿。#IQ 38
記者就是讀稿 你把他當娛樂節目看好吧
台灣的名嘴媒體都不會考證,我承認這些電視節目都是娛樂性質而已,就連台灣人都覺得錯誤百出.請大家保持理性,就當看脫口秀!!
Kevin 台灣幫助新加坡是事實!!請問你，當過兵嗎?請問你，為國家貢獻過嗎?
羅誠德 uu
不知道内情就别乱做节目🙈🙈🙈🙈
台湾省的嘴砲 世界闻名 世界LP 1
几个军官就好像训练了正个军队
新加坡军人只记得以色列!!!!!
而且新加坡也在军物军购也帮了台湾省不少
但你们从来没提过 😂😂
Totally nonsense.
Its entertainment, its all nonsense. Its just for laughs.
新加坡军队从不去中国大陆演戏只是问侯,,我们去德国,澳大利亚，美国,印度,吹吧
突然发现新加坡国旗也有五颗星星啊，和大陆国旗好像，不过因为有穆斯林，有月亮哦。
新月表示新加坡是一个新建立的国家。
我们的邻居全是马来人。所以~
国旗上的五颗星，新月，上半红色和下半白色，全部都有它们各自代表的意义，跟种族和政党完全没有任何的关系，所以别吓猜吓扯。
Paker Zhu 日精的吊毛很棒棒喔？
新加坡国旗的五颗星是代表人民团结一致，新月代表新的国家。真的和中国没有关系，可以不要一直那么的一厢情愿的把一切都解读的和中国挂钩。
台灣沒辦法啦…超練嚴一點就有民意代表出來抗議騙選票，等到這個國家沒了，大家就高興了。
你们认为中国需要新加坡的支援吗？未免太小看中国了。我个人认为。如果真的武统，新加坡只会原兵不动。🤓
what the F!! Singaporean army offense discipline problem. Haiz>< I never heard it from singapore media. Covered up ady????
戴立綱很吵
胡说八道
Singapore development is a long-term planned programme from day 1 after independence. It is a concerted and collective effort by the government with clear objectives. National Day celebration should be viewed as an update to all citizens and residents living in Singapore the status of development and defense capability. Exaggeration, claiming credits to make everyone feel good and avoiding problems instead of trying to solve inherent national issues, keep on talking over again many times, will not make a country to progress. Ideology and not seeking factual truths will not result progress but remains stagnant and let others to overtake easily. 意识形态和不實事求事永远不会有进步！
台灣真的很悲哀，佬佬不愛 ，舅舅不疼，又出來一些禍國殃民的民意代表，唉，，，真的可憐
新加坡和台湾是老朋友了，有着相同的国民服役军队编织，再加上少量的正规军人扶持，和后备役军人。新加坡和中国有建交，多方面合作。中国及台湾问题是自己早年形势演变的，有些国家会把这当成内政问题，家事，所以不易牵扯新加坡。新加坡跟两边都是朋友，两边都有合作，也别要求新加坡选边站!
I use to drive the MAN truck to Kenting for picnic during weekend for RNR
台灣有資格嫌人小?
年青人血气方刚，如果属实的话，一定上军事法庭！
Is taiwan that gd?
請勿妄言!
好心啦！！新加坡🇸🇬的部队是由伊色列训练的啦！！！！麻烦查清楚一下！！不懂就别乱吠！！
No wonder china wana screw Taiwan
😑
瞎扯鬼扯，什麼都能胡扯，只為了賺通告費吧！把自己當做乞丐．．．
這個電視台在台灣是有名的"統媒", 這類節目成本低,收視率也很低, 好笑的是, 網路常常看到中國網民激憤的留言...
就是靠这个赚钱嘛。素质低的节目只能以娱乐夸大为卖点。
夸中带点讽
這怪誰？怪台灣八卦嘴巴太多！台灣八卦新聞太多！
吵死了
Don't come back! bye bye!
this is funny. rubbish show.
了解历史的人都知道！种族问题永远都不会消失！现在的美国黑人，当年的新加坡！赶紧回到祖国的怀抱吧！不是谁管谁，而是我们要团结！
等共產黨把人當人看的時候我就回去...
14151864153 你在还真信了仙岛的媒体，看来皿煮的媒体还真能影响到人。只有你与祖国有了时差，才能让你发现原来你的地位源自于祖国强盛。
省省吧
連日本都不敢動 強盛?
永遠也只會內戰而已
14151864153 那是你吧，中国在朝鲜，越南和东北西北边界用铁与血证明了自己的荣耀。
流血流汗、得到了什么? 还是俄国丶美国和欧盟的怀抱吗。😶😶
你们的驱逐舰比不上新加坡的
簡洨
台湾媒体最会吹牛，新加坡只是和台湾租地训练而已，,新加坡在海外租地训练的地方多的是，美国，法国，泰国，马来西亚，汶莱，澳洲都有不只是台湾，新加坡在1968就有F16了，台湾在1997才有F16 ，台湾连飞机都没有拿什么来协助新加坡空军？新加坡的空军是在美国训练的，别一直吹牛了，新加坡的海军是由英国在1968到1971撤离前训练的，新加坡的国防预算只占GDP的3% 左右，新加坡的年GDP是五千多亿美金😂😂😂
70% 胡说八道
胡说八道