I see a lot of people debating the origin and semantics of the raga names itself which is definitely a worthwhile conversation to have with respect to scholarship. What this video illustrates though, which such finesse, is the distinct styles and traditions of the singing and the composition in the schools of music. While carnatic seems to be dealing with an almost erudite exploration of the movement of each note, Hindustan music seems to explore the pauses between the notes themselves. Beautiful!
Amr Tamimi no abheri dosent hv shudha dhaivatham....u r saying about the abheri concept of dikshitar.....the commonly used abheri is purely the janya of kharaharapriya...so no shudh dha....dikshitar named the commonly used abheri as karnataka devagandhari...actually the scale of abheri of dikshitar is :s p m p n s and s n d p m g r s....the avarohanam hv shudh dha...veenabheri is a famous composition of dikshitar with this scale.....the scale of commonly used abheri is s g m p n s and s n d p m g r s...this is purely the janya of kharaharapriya...so no shudh dha...
Balu sir, you are of course correct regarding the Abheri of Dikshitar, but my point was the following: there is no tradition of Abheri having chatusruti dhaivatam. Abheri in both Thyagaraja and Dikshitar school has shuddha dhaivatam. It is only in the 20th century that Nagumomu has been sung with Chatushruti dhaivatam. They changed the dhaivatam, but kept the name of the raagam the same, so now Abheri is established as having chatushruti dhaivatam which is incorrect in any school.
though the raag bhimplas was existing in carnatic music, they changed the name to abheri just to prove carnatic is better than hindustani.. why this ego. the song from konjhum silanghai - singara velane was titled as bhimplasi.
Ranganathan Srinivasan what do you mean friend? The number of similar ragas with similar names are just rare actually. If I say there is a dhanashree, abhogi, hamsadhwani(originally of south, now also in north), sindhubhairavi and a littlr more. All other similar ragas are named differently. Mohanam and bhoopali bilaval and sankarabharanam khamaj and harikamboji kafi and kharaharapriya Malkouns and hindolam Pantuvarali and puriya dhanashree the list goes on and goes on
I see a lot of people debating the origin and semantics of the raga names itself which is definitely a worthwhile conversation to have with respect to scholarship. What this video illustrates though, which such finesse, is the distinct styles and traditions of the singing and the composition in the schools of music. While carnatic seems to be dealing with an almost erudite exploration of the movement of each note, Hindustan music seems to explore the pauses between the notes themselves. Beautiful!
Intelligent selection of raagas. This is to be appreciated . They chose Naata and Jog in one episode and here they have chosen Abheri and Bhimpalasi .
mellifluous rendition! ..beautiful blend of two different schools of music.. this is India..
Mind blowing performances..very excellent aalaap. God bless. Thanks
Thank you for watching this video
excellent, where is ja jaare apne mandirva with sreeranjani
Excellent by both singers
EXCELLENT...*****PL HAVE MORE... SUCH COMBINATIONS...
You both together really mesmerize us...very good ❤️
Carnatic vertion is amasing too.
Thank you
the holy Ganga and Yamuna merge here duly. What are heavily moment this is !!!
🎉🎉🎉
Exploring Raga Abheri and Bhimpalasi in Carnatic & Hindustani styles see Ttle
Just Beautiful
Thanks
Nine minutes of Heaven
Excellent performing
mystified....great rendering.
Both singers are experts in their own right. Is Gayathri Sokan the same as Gayathri who hosts the Malayalam show "Khayal'?
yes
Too good!!!!
Thank you for watching this video
Brilliant !!
Puli & Eli aayippoyo?
Excellent Allaap
👍🙏👍 Super
good.. fusion
Both are malayalees and trained carnatic singer.gayatri is a playback singer in Malayalam.
I think ms asokan is trained in Hindustani and not carnatic
@@anumohan8669 Gayatri is trained in both carnatic and hindustani
aha arumaiyana aalabanai
WORLD CLASS WORLD CLASS.
please mention singers names. it is excellent
very nice. but no names of artists have been mentioned in title card. please do mention it
@@meerabai9050 hindustani-Gayatri asokan carnatic-Sreeranjini
Attractive singing. Please stop calling this raaga Abheri though, it is karnataka devagandhari, abheri has shuddha (dwisruti) dhaivata (komal dha).
Amr Tamimi no abheri dosent hv shudha dhaivatham....u r saying about the abheri concept of dikshitar.....the commonly used abheri is purely the janya of kharaharapriya...so no shudh dha....dikshitar named the commonly used abheri as karnataka devagandhari...actually the scale of abheri of dikshitar is :s p m p n s and s n d p m g r s....the avarohanam hv shudh dha...veenabheri is a famous composition of dikshitar with this scale.....the scale of commonly used abheri is s g m p n s and s n d p m g r s...this is purely the janya of kharaharapriya...so no shudh dha...
Balu sir, you are of course correct regarding the Abheri of Dikshitar, but my point was the following: there is no tradition of Abheri having chatusruti dhaivatam. Abheri in both Thyagaraja and Dikshitar school has shuddha dhaivatam. It is only in the 20th century that Nagumomu has been sung with Chatushruti dhaivatam. They changed the dhaivatam, but kept the name of the raagam the same, so now Abheri is established as having chatushruti dhaivatam which is incorrect in any school.
@@narayanagaula you are correct sir
Amr Tamim
You are Fromm
very nice aalap
Excellent
Thank you
Suuuuuuuuper
If kaushiki chakrabarthi sit in place of gayathri....... 🙏🙏🙏
queen among young generation vocalists
though the raag bhimplas was existing in carnatic music, they changed the name to abheri just to prove carnatic is better than hindustani.. why this ego. the song from konjhum silanghai - singara velane was titled as bhimplasi.
Ayyo Rama....similiar ragas are known in different names in carnatic and hindustani system. Hindolam in carnatic in known as Malkauns....and so on.
Ranganathan Srinivasan
what do you mean friend? The number of similar ragas with similar names are just rare actually. If I say there is a dhanashree, abhogi, hamsadhwani(originally of south, now also in north), sindhubhairavi and a littlr more. All other similar ragas are named differently. Mohanam and bhoopali
bilaval and sankarabharanam
khamaj and harikamboji
kafi and kharaharapriya
Malkouns and hindolam
Pantuvarali and puriya dhanashree
the list goes on and goes on
dubakoor question
whole video wasted with the aalapanai itself add the song also
Both are too technical- where is the soul in this?
I disagree. They are singing soulfully!
You're the one who has no soul