yappp B.I wrote this song, but Bobby and Mino helped change the lyrics. It wasn't orginally about love, B.I was just talking about how empty he felt after losing WIN.
mino wrote the lyrics in rap parts, I think B.I just wrote the chorus and intro part. he wrote this after loosing in WIN and gave this song to WINNER for a gift
I wonder what it would sound like if B.I. & co cover it. Not that it isn't perfect now, because it is. But since it was written and composed by B.I. after losing WIN, I wonder how it would be with his voice and emotions. *sigh* It will probably never happen tho.
@Mofaizer Anamon, he left because he found it stressful. He also had been suffering from mental health issues since he was a trainee and had only gotten worse after debuting.
To clear things up for those who said that this song was just contributed by Hanbin....Empty was originally from B.I and the love thing part in the lyrics was probably rearrange or added from Mino or Bobby. Because now that I think about it Empty's lyrics really relates to what B.I must probably be feeling after losing WIN, I mean it just all makes sense after B.I said himself that he wrote this after losing to WINNER(Team A).. just by the title itself.. Hanbin felt empty losing WIN. The lyrics was full of genuine feelings from Hanbin though and I love how Winner sang it and delivered it to listeners very well it was full of emotions~~ WINKON :')
Yeah he wrote and composed this song during the darkest time of his life (he got depressed after WIN ended). He is the main producer for this song which is why people mainly credited B.I.rather than bobby and mino cuz i also think they only wrote the rap parts.
+lala la Basically, it's originally not a girl that Empty lyrics is about, but WIN which became his light from YG Dungeon... the lyrics "it's like I came back to reality; My reason to live is gone, my head is complicated" it was really WIN he's talking about... I felt sad for him after WIN.."people around me look at me with pity"
***** that's what I said~ I said Winner conveyed the song so well.. basically I was praising both sides~~ So please don't get me wrong.. I love both iKON and Winner because they love each other too! :3
beruk H because it's a gift for Winner~ and iKON was not even sure if they're going to debut at that time.. they were just trainees supporting sunbaes/hyungs.
No-one is downgrading Winner success in anyway. And no guarantee that if iKon to sing this song,it will be as successful as Winner. Winner gave this song justice and because of them, this song was successful. But because B. I. came up with the idea of this song and he contributed the most to the song which is why we associated this song more with him and try to understand his feeling and thinking through the lyrics of this song.
I know this song was composed by BI but reading that it is his feeling after WIN. it is sadder when I listen to. It is sadder than thinking it was from heartbroken.
I immediately came here because i read this in ikon's facts lol. "B.I cried a lot when Team B lost. The song that he wrote after crying so much was WINNER's Empty."
That's also why i think of this song when i first heard of "mirror", hanbin's soundcloud song. The referencing of a manlooking in the mirror feeling lost and empty screams to me like it was written by a very sad and lonely man. # Hanbin
Came here to read the lyrics because BI said he was the composer and lyricist of this song. He was just 18 years old when he composed this. WOW! just WOW!
Mino's voice at the start really remembers me of TOP on Let's Not Fall In Love, he's like, the kid between GD and TOP owo i'm so in love with Jinwoo, ah my bby
Alisu Kishinuma hahahah I dont know!! Its the first time that I cant choose a Bias LOL. Its SOOOOO hard Mino is HOT, Seung Yoon is kind of serious and is an awesome leader, Jin Woo is sooooo cute *-* so pure and so handsome, Taehyun is so different lol idk he is the maknae but he is so matture when he wants and HOT loool did you see the "Im young" MV? I was like WHAAAAATTt???? Thats our maknae lol. Seung Hoon has such and amazing voice and is so cute, such a gentleman. So..... yes... Im stil looking for a bias in WINNER hahaha. Which one is yours?
jeon jungduck .. I saw this comment and I really do agree like.. People are comparing both of these groups even though both are different as one notice in their concepts.. Like.. They say that people would really compare these two groups but comparing them is unnecessary..
Taehyun is and always will be my winner bias. I hope he gets through everything that is troubling him and i hope that after everything is over and done he will continue to live his life peacefully and healthily. I know he will get better in time, and everything happens for a reason. God bless him
Their style is so different compared to other YG artists, but that's what I love about them! They could have so easily gone down the "next bigbang" route, but I'm glad they didn't!
I'm here again to feel the lyrics translation after B.I win the best songwriter award. He wrote this bcs of his emptiness after losing win but knowing that he didn't easily give up and doing his best until now make him get to achieve now.
The lyrics break my heart, to think 17 year old B.I felt like this when he lost Who is next. He's so selfless to give the song to winner even though it has such a deep connection to him, Winner did amazing
Who says he gave it....as trainees they turn in songs they've written....so probably yg liked it and told Hanbin he was going to give it to Winner...on WinnerTV YG was saying Winner needs to debut but he didn't like any of the songs they were writing...and that Hanbin was working harder than any of them staying later than anyone else alone in the studio making music all night long and not even going home to sleep. double ouch when song is about feeling empty after losing his dream of debut...and then to have Winner who beat their team sing his song and win awards with it. That is also when Hanbin got Nihilism tattoo....means life is meaningless....just like song Empty.
@@adekawaruwu still would be cool to have an iKON cover of this. i'm sure all of them(except Chan) felt the same as BI when he wrote this song. the lyrics are just perfect for them
@@klassiconetea9983 yeah, i actually liked Mino's rap more even tho i like ikon more overall. But it would be cool of they didn't change the lyrics. Winner's version is talking about a woman and breakup. The original by Hanbin is about how empty it feels after losing and failing, and how he hated being pitied by the people around him. Imo it's more touching that way.
I want to say thank you for doing this video. I stumbled across this 3-4 years ago accidentally and was so moved by the beat/vocal/everything. It was like an instant connection. This video was what made me into an INCLE and watching this again brings back so many memories. WINNER is such an amazing group and I'm so happy I stan them. I would probably still be a fan even if I didn't stumble across this video but that would mean I stan them after Taehyun left and that would be just so sad. I'm so glad I got to experience an OT5 comeback with WINNER because of this. Thank you so much for doing lyric videos for kpop groups and I hope you keep on doing it. Have a great day ahead.
I can't imagine how bad our lil Hanbinie was hurting when he wrote this. He was 17 for crying out loud, there was just so much pressure on him💜 I'm so greatful that things worked out for B.I, iKON and Winner💜
Taeyhuns part in this song is what I really love this song is my definition of his memories in winner!! Recently I'm really happy that he is interacting with winners pretty eomma(dara) and minzy also with Se7en oppa 💗💗💗 yg og fam I miss them!!
i swear to God korean songs really has a nice tune(?) and lyrics are so meaningful so even if i dont understand it first time i listen to it but i start to like how it sound i search the lyrics on yt and it melts my heart how i wish i know how to speak korean :)))
The lyrics are wonderful and their vocals are so angelic..just touched my heart...Maybe I liked this song cause it reminds me of my pains but it does not even feel bad...Sweet vocals just healed my pain....
I'm going to miss Nam Taehyun ! this song is just getting me in my feels! I've cried finding out about this ! I wish the best for you Nam Taehyun ! We love you
![VIXX - Error [Hangul/Romanization/English] Color & Picture Coded HD](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/_rbnVdy4WIk/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Soyu (SISTAR) & Junggigo (ft. Lil Boi of Geeks)] Some (썸) Hangul/Romanized/English Sub Lyrics](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/j2NghJuQrRo/mqdefault.jpg)
Describes hanbin's situation now so well. Hope he never stops making beautiful, honest music like this
I never know this and this is one of my favorite song winner. YG just take out something unique and talent.
YG has talents but can't get their shit right
hope all this adversity result to beautiful music like this
i love Mino's deep voice rap at the beginning omf
+Sarah V Me too.........
+Sarah V i know right :)
J's same
same
B.I is such a genius song writer and composer. Woah. And plus the amazing vocal talents of winner members had this song into perfection ❤️
B.I wrote this song ????
+J-hope's wifeu and we both hates snakeu This B.I's lyrics
yappp B.I wrote this song, but Bobby and Mino helped change the lyrics. It wasn't orginally about love, B.I was just talking about how empty he felt after losing WIN.
mino wrote the lyrics in rap parts, I think B.I just wrote the chorus and intro part. he wrote this after loosing in WIN and gave this song to WINNER for a gift
NIERRA ROOFERS ahh~ winkon feels 😍😏
This song have Hanbin's feeling on it and I'm proud that Winner delivered it to the listeners nicely.
I wonder what it would sound like if B.I. & co cover it. Not that it isn't perfect now, because it is. But since it was written and composed by B.I. after losing WIN, I wonder how it would be with his voice and emotions. *sigh* It will probably never happen tho.
+Melina Valencia u can go watch mix n match final! they sang it together with winner hyungs ^^
+Melina Valencia maybe they secretly have and their just not releasing it ;)
+Mel V maybe he have a demo of this song? he usually sing in the demo....ahhh... I wonder that too...he was so depressed when he wrote this.
"I was happy, don't forget me" We won't Taehyun, and that's a promise.
stan astro yes :(
He is so handsome and has really good voice 😥😥😥😢😢😢
stan astro why did he left winner?
@Mofaizer Anamon, he left because he found it stressful. He also had been suffering from mental health issues since he was a trainee and had only gotten worse after debuting.
You forget let's meet again..😢
To clear things up for those who said that this song was just contributed by Hanbin....Empty was originally from B.I and the love thing part in the lyrics was probably rearrange or added from Mino or Bobby. Because now that I think about it Empty's lyrics really relates to what B.I must probably be feeling after losing WIN, I mean it just all makes sense after B.I said himself that he wrote this after losing to WINNER(Team A).. just by the title itself.. Hanbin felt empty losing WIN. The lyrics was full of genuine feelings from Hanbin though and I love how Winner sang it and delivered it to listeners very well it was full of emotions~~ WINKON :')
Yeah he wrote and composed this song during the darkest time of his life (he got depressed after WIN
ended). He is the main producer for this song which is why people mainly credited B.I.rather than bobby and mino cuz i also think they only wrote the rap parts.
+lala la Basically, it's originally not a girl that Empty lyrics is about, but WIN which became his light from YG Dungeon... the lyrics "it's like I came back to reality; My reason to live is gone, my head is complicated" it was really WIN he's talking about... I felt sad for him after WIN.."people around me look at me with pity"
***** that's what I said~ I said Winner conveyed the song so well.. basically I was praising both sides~~ So please don't get me wrong.. I love both iKON and Winner because they love each other too! :3
beruk H because it's a gift for Winner~ and iKON was not even sure if they're going to debut at that time.. they were just trainees supporting sunbaes/hyungs.
No-one is downgrading Winner success in anyway. And no guarantee that if iKon to sing this song,it will be as successful as Winner. Winner gave this song justice and because of them, this song was successful. But because B. I. came up with the idea of this song and he contributed the most to the song which is why we associated this song more with him and try to understand his feeling and thinking through the lyrics of this song.
I know this song was composed by BI but reading that it is his feeling after WIN. it is sadder when I listen to.
It is sadder than thinking it was from heartbroken.
Hanbin's must be really sad that time when he wrote this song :( its so deep and sad it hurts :(
I immediately came here because i read this in ikon's facts lol.
"B.I cried a lot when Team B lost. The song that he wrote after crying so much was WINNER's Empty."
That's also why i think of this song when i first heard of "mirror", hanbin's soundcloud song. The referencing of a manlooking in the mirror feeling lost and empty screams to me like it was written by a very sad and lonely man. # Hanbin
I just knew ittt,😻😻B.I. so awesomeee
Came here to read the lyrics because BI said he was the composer and lyricist of this song. He was just 18 years old when he composed this. WOW! just WOW!
I like ikon but t I also like winner. Please don't hate either of them 😢
winkon 😘
+xxAlana WinKon for life :)
Am I the only one who always cries at Winner's songs except for Really Really ?
same here ikon,winner,bigbang.2ne1 and bp i just love them
Winkon terbaik ❤💙
Mino's voice at the start really remembers me of TOP on Let's Not Fall In Love, he's like, the kid between GD and TOP owo
i'm so in love with Jinwoo, ah my bby
+Alisu Kishinuma yessss I htougth the same hahahah ... actually..... that is my favourite part of the song lol (both)
+Paula it's mines too! i really like seunghoons rap, his voice is just magical ♡ i love it a lot
listen 2:33 *-* That part gives me........ yeah..... I just love Seung Yoon soooooo much :3
+Paula omg that part is so amazing, and the lyrics are too x_x yes ah seungyoon is great♥ is he your bias? ;D
Alisu Kishinuma hahahah I dont know!! Its the first time that I cant choose a Bias LOL. Its SOOOOO hard Mino is HOT, Seung Yoon is kind of serious and is an awesome leader, Jin Woo is sooooo cute *-* so pure and so handsome, Taehyun is so different lol idk he is the maknae but he is so matture when he wants and HOT loool did you see the "Im young" MV? I was like WHAAAAATTt???? Thats our maknae lol. Seung Hoon has such and amazing voice and is so cute, such a gentleman. So..... yes... Im stil looking for a bias in WINNER hahaha. Which one is yours?
Taehyun: "Just a memory, I was happy, don't forget me."
Of course I never forget you Taehyun:(
i love the ''da ra dat dat" part
+pink daisy. I love it too. It's a very catchy and addictive phrase like their sunbaes' "Boom shakala" :)
I love how deep those lyrics are!!! Hahaha it's funny because the song has good lyrics but the ra da tat part is just so catchy!!
+bae seulgi i love it because that's the only part i can sing lol
bae seulgi yaa... I love it too..!! love! love! love!
there is no such thing as ikon is better or winner is better. they both created their own league and their own style which differs them.
+MrsDoubleKim exactly. UGH. these fanwars
winkon!
+MrsDoubleKim WinKon is the bestttttt
I agree #winkon4life
jeon jungduck .. I saw this comment and I really do agree like.. People are comparing both of these groups even though both are different as one notice in their concepts.. Like.. They say that people would really compare these two groups but comparing them is unnecessary..
Taehyun is and always will be my winner bias. I hope he gets through everything that is troubling him and i hope that after everything is over and done he will continue to live his life peacefully and healthily. I know he will get better in time, and everything happens for a reason. God bless him
Their style is so different compared to other YG artists, but that's what I love about them! They could have so easily gone down the "next bigbang" route, but I'm glad they didn't!
ttkk12 but Hanbin of ikon composed that song though
+Maerine Viar Hanbin didn't compose this song alone. And we are not talking about who composed this song but about Winner's overall style.
I agree. They are very classy and the smoother R&B which is awesome.
to me ,winner and ikon really different, they even not look like yg's style
Han Bin is such a music genius 💕
Han Bin Oppa made this? (Sarreh not Updated XD)
Wait which one is Han Bin?
Shehryar Ali He's in a different group called IKON or Team B. He made this song.
Hannah Flores OOO i know about Ikon i just didnt know their names besides Bobby,BI and Jinwhan. I thought it was one of these guys name.
Shehryar Ali Yeah, Hanbin is B.I's real name.
THIS SONG IS BLESSING MY EAR EVERYTIME I LISTEN TO THIS... B.I. & MINO's lyrics and WINNER's angelic, harmonize voice
Taehyun let's meet again
The lyrics omg hanbin 😭😭😭 winner's voices are very emotional to listen to 😢
The lyrics are a bit more true today. Who's crying? Not me!
i lost it at "I was happy, don't forget me"
EXACTLY!!
Emilie N. no matter whether we cried or not (even tho MAYBE I did...😭😭) let's all keep supporting Taehyun and Winner!
😭
Emilie N. Uhhhhhh
Hanbin aka BI was so depressed when they lost in WIN that's why he wrote this song which really reflected how he was feeling back then.
THIS SONG IS SO ADDICITING OMG
MY HEART HURTS SEEING THE LYRICS...HANBIN YOU DID WELL. YOU AND YOUR TEAM DID WELL. DONT WORRY😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Um hanbin?
Rappers that sing as much as rap?! :o
♡.♡
endy s only mino
ScarletSkyJr but Seunghoon sings too...?
endy s Only in YG XD
+2SeungGDaeYang nice joke :D
+2SeungGDaeYang well... Young K from DAY6 (JYP) sings and raps and he slays both :)
I'm here again to feel the lyrics translation after B.I win the best songwriter award. He wrote this bcs of his emptiness after losing win but knowing that he didn't easily give up and doing his best until now make him get to achieve now.
listening to this after the recent news was even more heartbreaking. Hope he's doing well and his mental health is fine.
We will miss you Taehyun.
Jinwoo !!!
Jimin's Trash same
All his sad songs makes sense now. He was so sad back then but no one's noticing. Miss u hanbin
This is such a good song and winner sang it so well. My heart just hurts listening to this though, I wonder what hanbin had went through after win
Please love winkon ;-; no more fandom fights
Winner's vocals and rap and also Hanbin's lyrics made this song one of my fav song.
I think the two groups are so talented I really enjoy their music
Can’t believe who made this masterpiece left his group for something he didn’t even did:((
The lyrics break my heart, to think 17 year old B.I felt like this when he lost Who is next. He's so selfless to give the song to winner even though it has such a deep connection to him, Winner did amazing
Who says he gave it....as trainees they turn in songs they've written....so probably yg liked it and told Hanbin he was going to give it to Winner...on WinnerTV YG was saying Winner needs to debut but he didn't like any of the songs they were writing...and that Hanbin was working harder than any of them staying later than anyone else alone in the studio making music all night long and not even going home to sleep. double ouch when song is about feeling empty after losing his dream of debut...and then to have Winner who beat their team sing his song and win awards with it. That is also when Hanbin got Nihilism tattoo....means life is meaningless....just like song Empty.
still proud of how they won their first win with a ballad debut song
Hanbin is such a great composer
This song gives me some insight to how BI might be feeling right now...and that makes the situation even sadder!
Winner and iKON are just like brothers . But their fans , hurmm .
#Sorry for my bad english .
winkon 😁
winkon
#winkon
We will miss you Taehyun, never give up, get well soon and look after your self. SARAGHAE AND FIGHTING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
hanbin was hurting. :( its alright baby youve made this far..
First time hearing this and , not going to lie , made me cry a bit
it does have ikon feel
sanya because Hanbin wrote it
IKON wouldn't be able to sing it as powerful as them..different feeling and aura
@@adekawaruwu still would be cool to have an iKON cover of this. i'm sure all of them(except Chan) felt the same as BI when he wrote this song. the lyrics are just perfect for them
@@devvv4616 idk but its sure different because mino wrote his own lyrics and bobby had his own so winner's ver and ikon's ver is different
@@klassiconetea9983 yeah, i actually liked Mino's rap more even tho i like ikon more overall. But it would be cool of they didn't change the lyrics. Winner's version is talking about a woman and breakup. The original by Hanbin is about how empty it feels after losing and failing, and how he hated being pitied by the people around him. Imo it's more touching that way.
This will always be my Winner favorite song. Its so emotional.
I remember back when this just released, I listened to this song nonstop. Makes me so nostalgic and proud on where they are now.
I feel sad whenever I think about this song the feeling hanbin had during postWIN era but im also happy that Winner sang it beautifully
Just recently started listening to Winner and this song is on repeat for me. ❤❤❤
I want to say thank you for doing this video. I stumbled across this 3-4 years ago accidentally and was so moved by the beat/vocal/everything. It was like an instant connection. This video was what made me into an INCLE and watching this again brings back so many memories. WINNER is such an amazing group and I'm so happy I stan them. I would probably still be a fan even if I didn't stumble across this video but that would mean I stan them after Taehyun left and that would be just so sad. I'm so glad I got to experience an OT5 comeback with WINNER because of this. Thank you so much for doing lyric videos for kpop groups and I hope you keep on doing it. Have a great day ahead.
i just realized this was written by hanbin, that's why seunghoon's verse reminded me so much of him it sounded so much like hanbin's flow
it also sounds like their song Hug Me
I'm just here to say that this song is musically genius and absolutely amazing thanks bye
Genius Charisma leader of iKON ❤❤
Why is WINNER so underrated? I will never understand this. They deserve so much more. Love from Army who's also an inner circle.
I can't imagine how bad our lil Hanbinie was hurting when he wrote this. He was 17 for crying out loud, there was just so much pressure on him💜 I'm so greatful that things worked out for B.I, iKON and Winner💜
Not anymore🙂
@@shxxdr_02 he's hurting more than ever now thanks
And now he is back😁
omg its my first time listening to this song like a few days ago & now i'm completely addicted to this song omg ;u;
I like winner now oh i love this song.. mino my heart is on you..
I'm obsessed with Minos verse at the begging. It's amazing
I feel empty like the song now My Unnie Ladies Code Rise and Eun B thank. You for sending flowers wreaths ❤️
B.I is such a genius producer and singer,song writer.
공허해 부분중에 태현이 부분이 ㅜ 지금이랑 넘 비슷해서 눈물나온다 .....
' 추억이 됐죠 행복했어요 날 잊지말아요 '
........
This song is my life. Love it so much!
i will always come back, my favorite song ever.
Taeyhuns part in this song is what I really love this song is my definition of his memories in winner!! Recently I'm really happy that he is interacting with winners pretty eomma(dara) and minzy also with Se7en oppa 💗💗💗 yg og fam I miss them!!
WINNER's songs are all amazing ❤
I love SeungYoon :) I love hearing to his parts in this song the most
I love this song!! is my favorite song of the winner.
i swear to God korean songs really has a nice tune(?) and lyrics are so meaningful so even if i dont understand it first time i listen to it but i start to like how it sound i search the lyrics on yt and it melts my heart how i wish i know how to speak korean :)))
I love this video. It's very clear who's singing. Thanks :)
The lyrics are wonderful and their vocals are so angelic..just touched my heart...Maybe I liked this song cause it reminds me of my pains but it does not even feel bad...Sweet vocals just healed my pain....
I'm going to miss Nam Taehyun ! this song is just getting me in my feels! I've cried finding out about this ! I wish the best for you Nam Taehyun ! We love you
Ive never been in love or had a heartbreak but man these lyrics go so deep i feel like i can relate even when i cant. so much emotion
One of the best kpop debut song 👌
I dont know but taehyun's voice really suited the song
i finally found this song again! and it still gives me the same feeling
WINKON 😍😘😙😗😋😋😚😌🙆🙆✌
"I was happy , don't forget me" 💔
this part makes me crying .. I just can't imagine winner without TaeHyun 😢😢
this song is sooo beautiful and sooo sad 😢 i loved it
I live for this song
I love winner and ikon thats all, just dont compare them 😢
MINO's voice is healinggggg 😍
Applause for the lyrics distribution 👏👏 really, no complain about it
Still my favorite song 😍 this is the most beautiful song. Whenever I hear this song it gives me goosebumps.
omg. the description talks about waiting for ikon's debut. I feel soo old!!!
mino's voice at the beginning never fail to flutter my weak heart
This is my lullaby. their voices are very angelic and smooth
I joined this fandom too late, but Taehyun's part still hit me like a truck ㅠㅠ
Music and songs is not just about rankings and awards, some band just win because of their fame but this song make my heart heart pound!
Just a memory i was happy, don't forget me. I will never forget u taehyun😔❤
I've been waiting for this and I'm very thankful for you! I hope this does not get deleted. :3
过了较久的时间但我还一如既往喜欢这首歌
Oh this song make me cry so much.And fighting WINNER.Seunghoon Oppa Saranghae😀
i love the high note at 3:07
목소리가 좋다
This is what I basically feel right now. I feel empty knowing Hanbin is no loner in ikon. But, ikon will always be 7 in my heart
😢😢😢😢
2019 yet still my fave 😍😍😍
I was trying to find this and I finally did! I love it
They are perfection OMG
the first group from YG that I like
노래로 입덕할뻔 했었지!! 초딩때인가... 지금은 부업으로❤️ 위너 흥하자
Hanbin was 18 when he wrote this and he was hurting.
I LOVE THIS SONG
this song....ugh I have killed the replay button!