"Stakeholders vs. Shareholders": Haas faculty debate "Whom exactly should business serve?"

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 5 лют 2025
  • In this Oxford-style debate, Professors Ernesto Dal Bó and Dean Rich Lyons speak from the stakeholder point of view; Professors Hayne Leland and David Vogel champion shareholders.
    This is an Oxford-style debate for the purpose of academic learning. The faculty were assigned points of view that they may not necessarily agree with for the debate. These points should not be quoted or attributed to the faculty member in any way. (September 08, 2010)
    The University of California Berkeley Haas School of Business is one of the world's leading producers of new ideas and knowledge in all areas of business - which includes the distinction of having two of its faculty members receive the Nobel Prize in Economics over the past 15 years. The school offers six degree-granting programs. Its mission is to develop innovative business leaders - individuals who redefine how we do business by putting new ideas into action, and who do so responsibly. The school's distinctive culture is defined by four key principles - question the status quo; confidence without attitude; students always; and, beyond yourself.
    Visit our website at haas.berkeley.edu

КОМЕНТАРІ • 17

  • @wilsonhishono4980
    @wilsonhishono4980 3 роки тому +2

    very interesting discussion helping write my paper , i thank God the grace of learning and skills that is widely shared like this keep going gentlemen ...

  • @vincentmartin9667
    @vincentmartin9667 7 місяців тому +1

    Good stuff I think this 11:09 is where things get interest thou 16:22 probably a better jumping in for me personally.

  • @bibhavbasyal6545
    @bibhavbasyal6545 3 місяці тому

    anyone came here doing the assignment for the subject?

  • @SaadAlSubaiei
    @SaadAlSubaiei 10 років тому +2

    43:00 he keeps changing that hard question!

  • @alexovey
    @alexovey 7 років тому

    Wow. The debate was interesting. Lesson learnt is that profit maximization is not wrong provided its within ethical and legal boundaries. However, the lack of conciseness in ethics makes it difficult to have a standard base to execute decisions.

  • @shellydashing6090
    @shellydashing6090 3 роки тому

    Really informative and interesting...

  • @professagugurumba9057
    @professagugurumba9057 4 роки тому

    SO HIGHLY INFORMATIVE

  • @cferigoli
    @cferigoli 12 років тому

    pena não ter legendas para mais pessoas acompanharem (sorry not to have subtitles...more people to follow)

  • @sam-pf5ef
    @sam-pf5ef 9 років тому

    good video helping me write my paper as well lol

  • @cmhardin37
    @cmhardin37 6 років тому

    What is an example of a firm depleting an asset that belongs to Society? He said that this would be an example of theft for the shareholders.

  • @FernandoBezBrasil
    @FernandoBezBrasil 13 років тому

    very interesting

  • @plumi75
    @plumi75 11 років тому

    David Vogel seems to answer the students questions in a fuzzy logic way. A sign of not being able to answer or not willing to explain the obvious? Very interesting otherwise.

  • @ronnierbalan9453
    @ronnierbalan9453 6 років тому

    UWI in the house.

  •  5 років тому

    Blinkers that partition knowledge into units of limited understanding, are the gaps and ditches that companies and whole nations fall into. The idea of externalities in economics, as being areas of activity that one draws no revenue from, is a giant gapping hunting pit to fall into - When business school graduates should be well versed in phenomenon of cycle rates and turn around times, that is modeled from nature itself, because surely what goes around comes around, in an interconnected Universe.
    Unless you are live in a hermetically sealed flying fortress, and even then, we will shortly find no one else to screw over but ourselves at the end of the day. So that the only course of action is to get out of dodge and keep running, except that we've taken the whole world along with us. So that we now concoct ideas of infected aliens, or else sly savages
    (Indiana-polis who connect-e-cuts - leaving us with Washing-tons of soiled sheets and underwear, we cannot explain). Surely the work of xenobites with indo-bytic (insider) information
    Who practice divination and insider trading on fish entrails or pig guts, deer poo, or other types of mumbo jumbo, that has placed us all in this rat's maze we all find ourselves in.

  • @VinayVermaVINAYKUMAR
    @VinayVermaVINAYKUMAR 11 років тому +1

    Respected Board
    I felt, i can serve the global mass and society by serving the board.
    I mean, by joining as a yournest independent director member.
    for more detail HONBLE CHAIRMANS DESK | vinayakconsultancyservices
    Respected Board
    I felt, i can serve the global mass and society by serving the board.
    I mean, by joining as a yournest independent director member.
    for more detail HONBLE CHAIRMANS DESK | vinayakconsultancyservices