this BTWBall was the montreal show, she was in pain and tired as fuck. but her singing was theatrical it slayed! like those «say my name i can't live without the fame» and «i want you to scream» makes the performance sooo much better.
wow you really can't compare the two performances. they're two COMPLETELY different depictions of the song. BTWB is more saint and heaven-like and JWT is more like dark and like hell. both are amazing! Gaga still slays like always! ❤️ #pawsup
JWT isn't a joke, all her performances are good, You guys set so high standards for her like a new Fame Monster tour, or another Fame album, you guys know it's hard to replicate that when the music industry is changing and people expect different things. Joanne the album wasn't a flop, or the tour, she personally said it herself she loves to change, it won't always be the same, but as long as she's happy making music that's the point. Y'all know she almost quit music bc all the world wanted a Fame Monster 2.0 album, so give her some time to find out what to do, bc y'all are just probably demanding or saying an era was better than another, I'll respect your opinion on that, but seriously this was a tour JWT that she worked hard on, and if y'all don't appreciate that, the more you set higher standards, the next time there might not be a Lady gaga, she just wants to be happy making music and preforming and even if some shows aren't sold out, even if Joanne didn't sell like the fame monster, you can't yourself sell like five mil albums every time, stop making a big deal that Joanne was a flop or Artpop was a flop, bc she's probably still trying to experiment or find out what to do with music, and we should respect that. As long as she is an happy artist who keeps on making music for all of us regardless if she makes music that y'all don't like,, she makes music and she's happy. You all know she loves her fans, but sometimes fans are supposed to support an artist right? She's been trying to do this for y'all, but y'all keep on saying Born this Way was much better or The Fame Monster was so much better, but what if she didn't make music anymore. What if Tony never picked her up and didn't prevent her from quitting music. Would y'all be happy? It's just an album before Artpop where people called it a flop, in which it didn't bc it just didn't sell as much as before, same thing with Joanne, didn't sell like before but she's happy making it. An artist makes music and if y'all don't like. That and wanted her to make music you want like tfm, that's not an artist. She's happy. Y'all respect that, she's working hard to give the music to all of you.
AGREE! Monsters create such high standards and then become just assholes, appreciate what is given, she works very hard just for us, and some of us just criticize her, since the ARTPOP Era some monsters are just really stupid and are destroying our amazing fandom
Darryl :D I strongly agree. People think a Fame Monster album would sound good or do well in today's music scene. Hell no. I just want Gaga to find her new sound that's good in quality & hopefully translates in to commercial success.
Love her work and I am true fan of her and love how she doesn't do what other are doing. She does what makes her happy. How many of us can say the we love what we do for a living not many.
Shes a very good musician and composer, but i've seen some videos of her new tour and it seems a bit boring. It doesnt grab all my attention, she is doing practically the same with her old songs. I will follow her music, i liked Joanne a lot, but as a "pop" performer she is getting behind. If she goes full rock, she will be bigger. I loved the guitars in Bloody Mary, by the way. Very Megaman X style
I love and appreciate the aesthetics of both performances. The BTW one has more of a futuristic vibe but I love all the crimson in the JWT performance fits Bloody Mary" perfectly. It's a tie for me. Gaga can't do no wrong in my book.
i love gaga, she's a true artist with a pure talent, a hardworker, and an inspiration., but seriously most of her fans are so annoying and negative minded people
Which main attraction is the most unforgettable of Rock in Rio 2017? Voto - L A D Y G A G A g1.globo.com/musica/rock-in-rio/2017/interatividade/enquete/2017/8/1/qual-atracao-principal-e-a-mais-imperdivel-do-rock-in-rio-2017-f0e0cb1a-76a2-11e7-9e87-0242ac110007.html#
I think BTWB is my favorite. Nothing beats the mysterious fog and ominous entrance through the gates, mwaha. MwaHaHA. MWAHAHAHAHA! Sorry. I'll see myself out.
I was lucky enough to witness the one from the BTWBT from inside the pit back in 2012 and I'll see her live again on December but I've to say that the first one is still my favorite
Which main attraction is the most unforgettable of Rock in Rio 2017? Voto - L A D Y G A G A g1.globo.com/musica/rock-in-rio/2017/interatividade/enquete/2017/8/1/qual-atracao-principal-e-a-mais-imperdivel-do-rock-in-rio-2017-f0e0cb1a-76a2-11e7-9e87-0242ac110007.html#
Both performances are incredible! I cannot choose which on is better because they are so different, the BTWB had a lot more character and was more creepy but the JWJ had much better vocals and dancing but Gaga was in so much pain during that BTWB performance because it was her final one and she has already broke her hip! Gags performances always slay and I will never choose a better one
2:29 BTWB 😭 HER VOICE IS CREEPY IN THE AMAZING WAY. JWT is beautiful as well though. But we need more darker elements on the JWT its what I miss from the BTWB
Bloody marry was a signature part of BTW so there will be more emphasis on the production, also she docent do the scream on BTW...id say they're both as good in different ways
Which main attraction is the most unforgettable of Rock in Rio 2017? Voto - L A D Y G A G A g1.globo.com/musica/rock-in-rio/2017/interatividade/enquete/2017/8/1/qual-atracao-principal-e-a-mais-imperdivel-do-rock-in-rio-2017-f0e0cb1a-76a2-11e7-9e87-0242ac110007.html#
y'know i always see comments like this and wonder why do i think ArtPop and Joanne are my favorite eras. I definitely think the first albums were spectacular, shocking, impacting, but the last two show me a side nobody in the industry have showed yet, the artist side. The part where Art comes in. The Human side too, sensibility, personal meaning. Both Joanne and ArtPop make me feel so free and take me back to an era where I was so passionate about the art.
I'm really curious about why she chose to include this song on the JWT. Its not the first song that comes to mind when you think about Born This Way! im so glad though, cuz it slays
I mean...as a little monster, both are amazing.....But in my oppinion, JWT is still my favourite as the stage really sets the mood....and the red really stand what BLOODY Mary is.....and theres much more movement with great new choreography......But i still like BTWB ....it gives us a Funeral vibe.....but its quite.....like just standing on hoverboards...and not much choreography....So basically I liked JWT more....but still i loved the Born This Way era
Enzo Lorenzo the interlude before her performance is her being crushed by two walls and her screaming for her life while being suffocated, which can probably mean people are pressuring her to become her BTW self or so called "old/dark gaga" she explained this during her concert she didn't know what to write about so she took time to learn about her aunt Joanne but is going back to being dark 🖤
If yall know why she performed BM in Joanne World Tour , do you really think the whole Joanne Album songs can fit in-in 1 to 2 hours, i mean you guys are not complaining about why Gaga is performing Paparazzi? so wth...U guys realise Paparazzi came out before BM even came out...
Random Person I mean she performed Schieße at Coachella and the JWT, plus she performed Teeth, Venus, Sexxx Dreams and Speechless at Coachella, so people shouldn’t be surprised to see her perform songs that weren’t singles in her newer shows.
Both are amazing! You can't really compare them but if you where to the BTWB Tour had more effects to it while the JW Tour has more of that hell feeling like I think the song itself has
*I just saw one comment in the reply section to a comment and they said the BTWB doesn't deserve to be on the top. both are best so whoever said that shut up*
Which show is the BTWB footage from? She only wore the neon green hair for the last 4-5 shows (starting at the St. Paul date) before she broke her hip, I think that puts the footage in February 2013.
Gaga performing Scheiße, Born This Way, The Edge Of Glory, Bloody Mary (and You And I during one show) from Born This Way (2 albums previous to Joanne) then only Applause from ARTPOP (1 album previous to Joanne) was not only weird but it was a big "FUCK YOU" to that era of pain for her.
Jesus Anguiano I can't understand it either but it's gaga and throughout every show she did I still love her performing. I'm glad she comes to my country
Sorry, i dont speak english haha. But of course all of the shows are cool, and i love Joanne but i dont feel the conection with the songs of Joanne and all the songs of the last era's. Greetings!
Matthew Streacker oh, i had no idea it was the same font lol. but having the same record label doesn't really affect font choice. it's usually the artist's creative team or something like that
Shes a very good musician and composer, but i've seen some videos of her new tour and it seems a bit boring. It doesnt grab all my attention, she is doing practically the same with her old songs. I will follow her music, i liked Joanne a lot, but as a "pop" performer she is getting behind. If she goes full rock, she will be bigger. I loved the guitars in Bloody Mary, by the way. Very Megaman X style
I think BTW era as a whole and especially Bloody Mary were so "out there" that the best way to make it work is to be just as outrageous and creative with the live performances and visuals. JWT is way more tame than BTWB and songs like Bloody Mary, Scheisse, and even Applause feel out of place to me.
Disney Love actually have this and Judas back to back in the tour and it would have been an amazing part of the tour all the red the outfits the lights
![Lady Gaga - LoveGame [ LIVE COMPARISONS ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/HfwqlURjY4w/mqdefault.jpg)
No matter what you think of the performances, you can't deny that the vocal is so much stronger on the JWT.
The Btw ball was all style and no substance... JWT has heart
this BTWBall was the montreal show, she was in pain and tired as fuck. but her singing was theatrical it slayed! like those «say my name i can't live without the fame» and «i want you to scream» makes the performance sooo much better.
Extremely unpopular opinion: Bloody Mary is better during Joanne World Tour
GoodFunVideos i agree !! I dont get why everyone is hating on jwt i personally have loved it so far
I Agree.
GoodFunVideos EVEN MORE unpopular opinion: JWT is Gaga's best tour in terms of scenery, vocal performance and song repertoire.
GoodFunVideos I agree! Like wth, she's just spinning
I loved the guitars. It is like the only thing that i really liked from what i have seen of this tour.
Bloody Mary choreography for Joanne World Tour slays! Both performances are amazing 😍
wow you really can't compare the two performances. they're two COMPLETELY different depictions of the song. BTWB is more saint and heaven-like and JWT is more like dark and like hell. both are amazing! Gaga still slays like always! ❤️ #pawsup
To me the BTWB is more purgatory or limbo and has a petrified vibe. And then maybe the JWT performance is her moving from limbo to hell
In BTW Ball she adds some creepy sound effects to the verses
JWT isn't a joke, all her performances are good, You guys set so high standards for her like a new Fame Monster tour, or another Fame album, you guys know it's hard to replicate that when the music industry is changing and people expect different things. Joanne the album wasn't a flop, or the tour, she personally said it herself she loves to change, it won't always be the same, but as long as she's happy making music that's the point. Y'all know she almost quit music bc all the world wanted a Fame Monster 2.0 album, so give her some time to find out what to do, bc y'all are just probably demanding or saying an era was better than another, I'll respect your opinion on that, but seriously this was a tour JWT that she worked hard on, and if y'all don't appreciate that, the more you set higher standards, the next time there might not be a Lady gaga, she just wants to be happy making music and preforming and even if some shows aren't sold out, even if Joanne didn't sell like the fame monster, you can't yourself sell like five mil albums every time, stop making a big deal that Joanne was a flop or Artpop was a flop, bc she's probably still trying to experiment or find out what to do with music, and we should respect that. As long as she is an happy artist who keeps on making music for all of us regardless if she makes music that y'all don't like,, she makes music and she's happy. You all know she loves her fans, but sometimes fans are supposed to support an artist right? She's been trying to do this for y'all, but y'all keep on saying Born this Way was much better or The Fame Monster was so much better, but what if she didn't make music anymore. What if Tony never picked her up and didn't prevent her from quitting music. Would y'all be happy? It's just an album before Artpop where people called it a flop, in which it didn't bc it just didn't sell as much as before, same thing with Joanne, didn't sell like before but she's happy making it. An artist makes music and if y'all don't like. That and wanted her to make music you want like tfm, that's not an artist. She's happy. Y'all respect that, she's working hard to give the music to all of you.
AGREE! Monsters create such high standards and then become just assholes, appreciate what is given, she works very hard just for us, and some of us just criticize her, since the ARTPOP Era some monsters are just really stupid and are destroying our amazing fandom
Darryl :D I strongly agree. People think a Fame Monster album would sound good or do well in today's music scene. Hell no. I just want Gaga to find her new sound that's good in quality & hopefully translates in to commercial success.
Love her work and I am true fan of her and love how she doesn't do what other are doing. She does what makes her happy. How many of us can say the we love what we do for a living not many.
Darryl :D 😍😍😍😍😍 we always with our mother fucker whatever will be we still there with her.
Shes a very good musician and composer, but i've seen some videos of her new tour and it seems a bit boring. It doesnt grab all my attention, she is doing practically the same with her old songs. I will follow her music, i liked Joanne a lot, but as a "pop" performer she is getting behind. If she goes full rock, she will be bigger.
I loved the guitars in Bloody Mary, by the way. Very Megaman X style
No contest. JWT performance of Bloody Mary is faaaaar superior.
I love and appreciate the aesthetics of both performances. The BTW one has more of a futuristic vibe but I love all the crimson in the JWT performance fits Bloody Mary" perfectly. It's a tie for me. Gaga can't do no wrong in my book.
I'm late but, FACTS!!
i actually like the joanne tour version because her vocals are better also the outfit goes with the song theme more..alien vs biblical horror
*"Say my name, I can't life without the fame.'* Shivers, every single time
Both great performances, but I LIVE FOR THE JWT LOOK
Joanne was honestly more about her talent than the actual props and costumes. It was an amazing show! I felt the connection with her.
I can't decide tbh. The visuals on JWT are more appealing but that moving dress was everything.
Living for this scream
Make up, vocals, hair, costumes, stage, lights, everything is creepier on The BTW ball
i love gaga, she's a true artist with a pure talent, a hardworker, and an inspiration., but seriously most of her fans are so annoying and negative minded people
First time i saw bloody mary performance in btwb its gave me chills
JWT 😍😍😍😍😍 the red light color suits better with the song
Idk which to choose they're both great to me
JWT is the BEST!
Which main attraction is the most unforgettable of Rock in Rio 2017?
Voto - L A D Y G A G A
g1.globo.com/musica/rock-in-rio/2017/interatividade/enquete/2017/8/1/qual-atracao-principal-e-a-mais-imperdivel-do-rock-in-rio-2017-f0e0cb1a-76a2-11e7-9e87-0242ac110007.html#
JWT of course, there she's actually dancing and there's more theatrics
When she Screeched "gaga" in the btw video I almost had a stroke 🤧🤤🤤🤤 I want her to scream at me
Both are the best.gaga queen of pop
BTWB sound effect is so good but JTW is more fantastic. so JTW BETTER.
Both are good in their own ways. I remember seeing this in the BTWB, it brought me back good memories
I love both to death but i think i like to watch the JWT version more since the choreo is cute
i believed in this song sooo much when it came out.... I still do...
both performances are great.... i personally prefer the last one at JWT...
I think BTWB is my favorite. Nothing beats the mysterious fog and ominous entrance through the gates, mwaha. MwaHaHA. MWAHAHAHAHA! Sorry. I'll see myself out.
The joanne world tour version is way better than the born this way ball tour , the queen will always slay
Janne World Tour are Stefani Joanne Germanotta with little touch of Lady Gaga, Queen of Pop and more . JWT is better .
Both! Btw was creepy and JWT is tamer. Artist change over time so don't compare her work!
both =]
I was lucky enough to witness the one from the BTWBT from inside the pit back in 2012 and I'll see her live again on December but I've to say that the first one is still my favorite
Which main attraction is the most unforgettable of Rock in Rio 2017?
Voto - L A D Y G A G A
g1.globo.com/musica/rock-in-rio/2017/interatividade/enquete/2017/8/1/qual-atracao-principal-e-a-mais-imperdivel-do-rock-in-rio-2017-f0e0cb1a-76a2-11e7-9e87-0242ac110007.html#
Who else cried a little
JWT😍
YASSSSSSSSSSS
Both performances are incredible! I cannot choose which on is better because they are so different, the BTWB had a lot more character and was more creepy but the JWJ had much better vocals and dancing but Gaga was in so much pain during that BTWB performance because it was her final one and she has already broke her hip! Gags performances always slay and I will never choose a better one
Queen lady gaga slays.
2:29 BTWB 😭 HER VOICE IS CREEPY IN THE AMAZING WAY. JWT is beautiful as well though. But we need more darker elements on the JWT its what I miss from the BTWB
look the amazing stage btw o.o
Bloody marry was a signature part of BTW so there will be more emphasis on the production, also she docent do the scream on BTW...id say they're both as good in different ways
Desfintely JWT
Which main attraction is the most unforgettable of Rock in Rio 2017?
Voto - L A D Y G A G A
g1.globo.com/musica/rock-in-rio/2017/interatividade/enquete/2017/8/1/qual-atracao-principal-e-a-mais-imperdivel-do-rock-in-rio-2017-f0e0cb1a-76a2-11e7-9e87-0242ac110007.html#
Fuck it. Both.
Love this
Coming from a person that listens to her music but not a fan- I personally like both performances-
she sings it better in JWT for sure, but I like the concept in BTWB. Both performances were amazing though
btw era in general cant be toped
y'know i always see comments like this and wonder why do i think ArtPop and Joanne are my favorite eras. I definitely think the first albums were spectacular, shocking, impacting, but the last two show me a side nobody in the industry have showed yet, the artist side. The part where Art comes in. The Human side too, sensibility, personal meaning. Both Joanne and ArtPop make me feel so free and take me back to an era where I was so passionate about the art.
Gamepablo artpop and btw was revolutionary for that reason...joanne visuals at the tour sure but not the album itself
Arnez Juggins oh yeah, yup, i agree, Joanne visuals could have been better.
jwt bloody mary perfromance>>>>> btwb bloody mary performance. stop putting btwb on top lol, this performance was better at the jwt
EnMX 03 well that's your opinion and where allowed to have ours
I'm really curious about why she chose to include this song on the JWT. Its not the first song that comes to mind when you think about Born This Way! im so glad though, cuz it slays
I mean...as a little monster, both are amazing.....But in my oppinion, JWT is still my favourite as the stage really sets the mood....and the red really stand what BLOODY Mary is.....and theres much more movement with great new choreography......But i still like BTWB ....it gives us a Funeral vibe.....but its quite.....like just standing on hoverboards...and not much choreography....So basically I liked JWT more....but still i loved the Born This Way era
BTWB because I find it off that she would perform it now at the current tour. And that moving dress was everything.
Enzo Lorenzo i agree. I was like huh? Why is she performing bloody mary at the jwt
Enzo Lorenzo the interlude before her performance is her being crushed by two walls and her screaming for her life while being suffocated, which can probably mean people are pressuring her to become her BTW self or so called "old/dark gaga" she explained this during her concert she didn't know what to write about so she took time to learn about her aunt Joanne but is going back to being dark 🖤
If yall know why she performed BM in Joanne World Tour , do you really think the whole Joanne Album songs can fit in-in 1 to 2 hours, i mean you guys are not complaining about why Gaga is performing Paparazzi? so wth...U guys realise Paparazzi came out before BM even came out...
Random Person I mean she performed Schieße at Coachella and the JWT, plus she performed Teeth, Venus, Sexxx Dreams and Speechless at Coachella, so people shouldn’t be surprised to see her perform songs that weren’t singles in her newer shows.
i Remember the Born this way ball. i loved this song when they did that with the segways
ILL TELL THEM MY RELIGISUE LMFAOOOOO GAGAS SO FUCKKING FUNNY
The BTWB was so dark, JWT is my favorite.
Not saying ones better than the other, but the energy just isn't the same
Both are amazing! You can't really compare them but if you where to the BTWB Tour had more effects to it while the JW Tour has more of that hell feeling like I think the song itself has
I love BTWBT
Extremely unpopular opinion: Bloody Mary at the Born This Way Ball is a very underrated performance
both are so diferrent and amazing
Love you moooooom
*I just saw one comment in the reply section to a comment and they said the BTWB doesn't deserve to be on the top. both are best so whoever said that shut up*
JWT of course
For me Bloody Mary at the Born This Way Ball was better but i love the costume change at the Joanne World Tour
Which show is the BTWB footage from? She only wore the neon green hair for the last 4-5 shows (starting at the St. Paul date) before she broke her hip, I think that puts the footage in February 2013.
That bloody mary performance in montreal was the more dramatic and amazing of the whole tour. SAY MY NAME I CANT LIVE WITHOUT THE FAME
JWT is so fucking perfet omg
Gaga performing Scheiße, Born This Way, The Edge Of Glory, Bloody Mary (and You And I during one show) from Born This Way (2 albums previous to Joanne) then only Applause from ARTPOP (1 album previous to Joanne) was not only weird but it was a big "FUCK YOU" to that era of pain for her.
I love BTW more because it's so creepy and awesome
Joanne world tour
Joanneee
Performance BTWBALL vocals jwt
BTWBall is the most extra era.
Bloody Mary deserves way better choreography but JWT is a good change.
Way better in born this Way tour technology showing in the stage. Galáctic alien theme. Its Just Way better
la del joanne worl tour es mejor
I prefer Born this way, because i cant undersant the concept in JWT yet.
Jesus Anguiano I can't understand it either but it's gaga and throughout every show she did I still love her performing. I'm glad she comes to my country
Sorry, i dont speak english haha.
But of course all of the shows are cool, and i love Joanne but i dont feel the conection with the songs of Joanne and all the songs of the last era's.
Greetings!
🐸☕️
i prefer the btw is better and horrorific
was Art Rave like her worst tour? There's no comparison or anything to that tour
ThisIsEvan717 she didn't perform Bloody Mary during artrave lmao
Well like a lot of the comparisons I'm seeing are of BTW rather than art rave
ThisIsEvan717 I need receipts
in your opinion what's her worst tour
Performance de Joanne World Tour bem melhor, no sentido de criação artística mesmo.
like
2:33 sounds like a cult chant
BTW Rules!!!!!! ICONIC MUSIC, ICONIC ERA, ICONIC MOMENT sorry Joanne
Who ever thinks the btw version is better they can choke, JWT is WAYYY BETTER
Sorry Joanne... There's a new girl in town.
BTWBALL.
The thumbnail used Lana font
its actually the artpop remix/G.U.Y video font
actsleazy they are both under interscope, so it makes sense that they use the same font
Matthew Streacker oh, i had no idea it was the same font lol. but having the same record label doesn't really affect font choice. it's usually the artist's creative team or something like that
Shes a very good musician and composer, but i've seen some videos of her new tour and it seems a bit boring. It doesnt grab all my attention, she is doing practically the same with her old songs. I will follow her music, i liked Joanne a lot, but as a "pop" performer she is getting behind. If she goes full rock, she will be bigger.
I loved the guitars in Bloody Mary, by the way. Very Megaman X style
aynosekeponer Boring? Omg
Lol megaman I’ve would’ve never guessed 😂 now I cant hear it the same
Bullshit. Just saw JWT and it was fucking incredible. Very mature show.
How dare you. Imma punch yojr face watch and see.
Born This Way Era is way better in ever sense .
I think BTW era as a whole and especially Bloody Mary were so "out there" that the best way to make it work is to be just as outrageous and creative with the live performances and visuals. JWT is way more tame than BTWB and songs like Bloody Mary, Scheisse, and even Applause feel out of place to me.
For me BTW Ball... creepy gaga .. haha
Born this way ball tour better
Joanne word tour is better
Lagy gaga mongolb
sigh the guy screaming ruined it and his voice is so awkwardly cringy but understandable
The helmet is so ugly
She was playing an alien renegade at the BTWBall... it was spooky af in real life
Please change this for an ARTPOP song!
what song would you want?
Danny Rodeck So its just Applause because its the only song that returned from ARTPOP to the Joanne Tour.
Jae Agree!
Ehh would of been nice to hear things like Artpop, Venus, Gypsy ect.
Joanne World Tour is the best show Gaga has ever done. But this song is overrated by Little Monsters. Judas would have been better
Disney Love actually have this and Judas back to back in the tour and it would have been an amazing part of the tour all the red the outfits the lights
Btw of course! Jwt is a joke
tatumalchik13 your life is a joke
tatumalchik13 they are both amazing.
the one where she just stands and spins the whole time? yeah ok
I can see somebody that its not capable to handle critics.
I'm sorry, Lady Gaga and her sold out tour can't hear you.
Adoro essa música e adoro a Lady Gaga, mas as duas apresentações são horrendas...
JWT is totally better just look at hoa strange she looks in BTWT, that is not cool is weird and creepy
rafael_eduardo 029 Well, if you know Gaga before the Joanne era, you would understand that she relates her song to the setting.
When you were successful and at the top of the world VS at least you're not dead
MatthewCarter jwt sold out
Who doesn't sell out an ARENA TOUR? At least she doesn't live on festival performances like in Cheek To Cheek
MatthewCarter Could you go perform to an arena and have it sold out? I don't think so 😄
ARENA TOUR?, HAHAHAHA OK DUDE :v
MatthewCarter 79k people at citi field AND SOLD OUT