Time Team S11-E12 Roxburgh,.Scotland

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 вер 2024
  • Five hundred years ago, a major city occupied what is now a large and empty field in the Scottish Borders.
    Founded by a king as a hub for international trade, Roxburgh was, along with Edinburgh, Stirling and Berwick, one of the four great centres of medieval Scotland.
    But while the other three became thriving cities, Roxburgh simply vanished. There are plenty of documents but only a ruined castle remains as a clue to the town's layout.
    It has lain untouched since its final decline in the 16th century - now Tony and the Team have a unique chance to uncover whatever remains under the pasture.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 286

  • @CravingCanada
    @CravingCanada 3 роки тому +34

    One of my favourite episodes. Has it all. Geophysics, aerial, landscape, digging, pinpoint trench decision making, historical documents, deduction. Roads, church, houses, residents, burials, defences, dateable finds, and even a medieval market!! Magical.

    • @MrWompz
      @MrWompz Рік тому +2

      A true showcase if the talent that this team had.

  • @dlawrence2052
    @dlawrence2052 6 років тому +121

    Ahhh, Professor Mick's sweater. I hope it's in a museum somewhere so I can go see one day.

    • @Jigger2361
      @Jigger2361 4 роки тому +25

      ...next to Phil's hat

    • @TheDarthMushroom
      @TheDarthMushroom 4 роки тому +4

      I’d guess in the University where he was attached to

    • @pattimessenger6214
      @pattimessenger6214 4 роки тому +4

      Jigger2361 Phil is still out there, wearing those old hats and making videos. ua-cam.com/video/5wNFPW0SWqk/v-deo.html

    • @tracywebber3318
      @tracywebber3318 3 роки тому +11

      His jumper was at the Somerset museum in Taunton 😊

    • @annarushlau9722
      @annarushlau9722 5 місяців тому +1

      When I first saw him in this episode I literally said, out loud, “oh nooo Mick! Where are your stripey clothes?!?!”

  • @cogidubnus1953
    @cogidubnus1953 8 років тому +149

    When Stewart is highlighted in this programme it's wise to listen...he's very rarely proved wrong....nobody reads a landscape like he does...

    • @LawsonMcLaren
      @LawsonMcLaren 3 роки тому +4

      When I first started watching this two years ago a guy on YT told me to listen to Stewart and that he's almost never wrong. Definitely the guy to watch in this series.

    • @aserta
      @aserta 2 роки тому +2

      I wouldn't say he's never wrong, i'd say he's an excellent read of land and is very through and unwilling to hedge his bets on fairy tales.

    • @benediktmorak4409
      @benediktmorak4409 2 роки тому +2

      i think nothing can beat or is better than years and years of experience. sometimes one just needs to look at something and can say it is,it can be, it could be or it is not.

    • @davidtownsend6092
      @davidtownsend6092 Рік тому

      Yea he's the goat

    • @davidtownsend6092
      @davidtownsend6092 Рік тому +1

      He would've been a kickass commander in the past

  • @klaasklapsigaar1081
    @klaasklapsigaar1081 7 років тому +19

    This is rock & roll amongst archeaology

  • @robertwbraiden
    @robertwbraiden 10 років тому +74

    Tony: "But dark forces are at work, in the form of Stewart Ainsworth"

  • @davidshelow5334
    @davidshelow5334 4 роки тому +12

    Love this show! I would like to see a seminar with Stuart on the methods he uses to observe the landscape and read what is beneath.

    • @JamesSmith-fz7qk
      @JamesSmith-fz7qk 2 роки тому +4

      I ran across a video like that last year. Just search on UA-cam for him.

  • @mver191
    @mver191 11 років тому +27

    Steward is cool, with Phil my favorite person

    • @Nellsbells79
      @Nellsbells79 4 роки тому +1

      Wild Woody same. I love Phil

  • @tphvictims5101
    @tphvictims5101 6 років тому +23

    The year is 2018 going into 2019, drones and new high tech equipment will change so much.
    This was an excellent series.

    • @dr.douglaswilde1155
      @dr.douglaswilde1155 5 років тому +2

      Yes, it will be wonderful to see how technology will be applied in Archaeology.

    • @Cadadadry
      @Cadadadry 5 років тому +3

      People should join together and demand a "Time team 2" to come back to this site and at least geophys the whole area !

    • @rhondasmith3042
      @rhondasmith3042 4 роки тому

      2020 now we have the mid evil plague return!

    • @icelandviking1961
      @icelandviking1961 4 роки тому

      Rhonda Smith “Bring out your dead!”

    • @littledikkins2
      @littledikkins2 3 роки тому

      It is now late 2020, and advances in techniques for sequencing ancient DNA have made huge advances in both archaeology and anthropology. Also, a drought that hit the British Isles turned up all sorts of evidence of ancient settlements and assorted types of tombs.

  • @johnlumb1078
    @johnlumb1078 4 роки тому +24

    In a strange twist of fate I ended up working for the current (2020) Duke of Roxburgh and whilst doing research on my family tree, more specifically my mother's side(Scottish) turns out that 500yrs ago my 12th Great Grandfather was actually the elder son of what would have been the Duke of Roxburgh he was murdered by his younger brother and he took the Dukedom and the rest, as they say, is history and fate.

    • @ChristaFree
      @ChristaFree 4 місяці тому

      Nice. It's great that you can trace your family back that far!

  • @stevedavy2878
    @stevedavy2878 Рік тому +6

    Any experienced gardener will tell you that where you find a heavy concentration of stinging nettles you find human activity and disturbance

  • @jehansanzterre3956
    @jehansanzterre3956 11 років тому +11

    Loving all these episodes...thanks so much for sharing them!Cheers!

  • @chrispza
    @chrispza 6 років тому +18

    This is quality programme-making (barring the largely artificial three-day deadline), which is increasingly rare.
    Reijer, thank you so much for sharing.

    • @sent7127
      @sent7127 4 роки тому +6

      I read somewhere that the three day deadline was due to the professors and archaeologists tending to their day jobs at universities during the week.

    • @megelizabeth9492
      @megelizabeth9492 Рік тому +1

      Yeah, most of the people involved had day jobs, so this was something they did over long weekends.

  • @gaymoeller1545
    @gaymoeller1545 9 років тому +11

    they're all fun to watch for me

  • @MattiasDavidsson
    @MattiasDavidsson 6 років тому +5

    43.00-43.08 might be the funniest moment in the entire series! I want that edited out and looped forever.

  • @geocyclist
    @geocyclist 9 років тому +6

    One of my favorite episodes!

  • @olegal44
    @olegal44 7 років тому +5

    love this show. thank you for posting it

  • @brianvittachi6869
    @brianvittachi6869 8 років тому +20

    Stewart's got the best job.

  • @robertkerr8205
    @robertkerr8205 5 років тому +15

    My ancestors were from here (Roxburgh) in the 12-16th Centuries and so found it interesting. There was also a (Roxburgh) palace or Castle built on high ground that had little left due to the turbulent Border history. I remember that a Scottish King helped to physically build that according to The University of British Columbia books I read.

    • @kitskivich
      @kitskivich 4 роки тому

      I'm of the same line, Robert.

    • @littledikkins2
      @littledikkins2 3 роки тому

      The Royal Castle was built by King David. And the town was never rebuilt after King James II of Scotland was killed besieging it and it was destroyed.

  • @joanhamilton2651
    @joanhamilton2651 7 місяців тому +3

    At the 6:02 mark it looks like Mick has his leg thrown over Tony's. I laughed so hard!😂

  • @rhondasmith3042
    @rhondasmith3042 4 роки тому +24

    Poor carenza,, I felt so horrible hearing about what she went through!

    • @daylight8208
      @daylight8208 4 роки тому +2

      What happened?

    • @rhondasmith3042
      @rhondasmith3042 4 роки тому +12

      @@daylight8208 they miss diagnosed breast cancer and put her through a double mastectomy and she didn't have breast cancer

    • @mickeykindley9885
      @mickeykindley9885 4 роки тому +3

      Omg I love her

    • @foxandbarrettshow6916
      @foxandbarrettshow6916 4 роки тому +6

      What a sweet woman and to be misdiagnosed and mistreated like that how horrible

    • @lyneaanderman3316
      @lyneaanderman3316 4 роки тому +2

      Apparently, she wasn't the only woman the doctor misdiagnosed.

  • @SomeDaysYoureBarbra
    @SomeDaysYoureBarbra Рік тому +1

    This is one of my favorite episodes, right behind the one where they found the sword under the barbed wire.

    • @annarushlau9722
      @annarushlau9722 5 місяців тому

      Oooo which one was that? I’ve been BINGING so all the episodes have started running together 😅

    • @LordPubeck
      @LordPubeck 3 місяці тому

      @@annarushlau9722 Tracked it down: ua-cam.com/video/RkP7Z8U9BEA/v-deo.html

  • @MissCattitude63
    @MissCattitude63 11 років тому +6

    The girl with the magenta hair makes Roxburgh stand up and pay attention!
    Thumbs up for personality!

    • @michaelmelen9062
      @michaelmelen9062 6 років тому +1

      Yes, very striking! Coming soon after Dr. Roberts and Dr. Butterworth, I wonder how many young men decided to go into archaeology for non-archaeological reasons after watching Time Team.

  • @juliamills5204
    @juliamills5204 4 роки тому +4

    Got a family tree of Sims family that lived in Roxborough in that time. They were grandkids of bueth chieflain.

    • @juliamills5204
      @juliamills5204 4 роки тому +1

      Robert sims my 25th great grandfather.

  • @doggiesarus
    @doggiesarus 5 років тому +22

    I like that Phil. He should have played Dr. Who!

    • @MoosePantz
      @MoosePantz 4 роки тому +2

      Oh, yes! That would have been brilliant!!

    • @patlong3903
      @patlong3903 4 роки тому +2

      Phil as Dr. Who; that would be a hoot and a half (and may have gotten me interested in the whole Dr Who series).

    • @PerryTribeMetalBaker
      @PerryTribeMetalBaker 4 роки тому +3

      "Look out, Doctor! The cybermen are in your trench!!..."
      "Oh-argh, jigger...Niomi, chuck us tha' mesolithic hand axe- No, the axe there! Not the paleolithic hide-scraper, the one with the beautifully re-worked cutting edge. Wheeey, tha's it alright, lovely bit o'stone that, could go in my garden tha'..."

    • @johndemeritt3460
      @johndemeritt3460 4 роки тому +3

      Sorry, but that'd never work. Phil would get so caught up in excavations that he'd never notice that the Daleks had overrun the entire universe. It's much like the difference between Ford Prefect and The Doctor: given the choice between a really smashing party and saving the universe, Ford would always choose the party, while The Doctor would always choose saving the universe. And Phil would always choose the trench.

    • @margomoore4527
      @margomoore4527 4 місяці тому

      Hasn’t anybody noticed the resemblance between Stewart Ainsworth and the Dr. Who with the similar accent, the one who said, “Every planet has a North”. But Stuart is quieter and less excitable.

  • @jeremyxman
    @jeremyxman 9 років тому +24

    I love this show and I have watched quite a few episodes now. Has anyone ells noticed that the host is always running around? Hes like the rabbit from Alice In Wonderland hahaha

    • @waderone3536
      @waderone3536 9 років тому +1

      +rebecah clifton that's all he does is walk and talk on his other show

    • @waderone3536
      @waderone3536 9 років тому +2

      by the way I love this program

    • @Lemma01
      @Lemma01 5 років тому

      @@waderone3536 I love it DESPITE the host...

    • @Nangleator22
      @Nangleator22 5 років тому +7

      I admire his planning for his intros and segues and aerial shots. If you pay attention, you can tell where things were shot twice or more from different angles, requiring planning. He's also pretty good at asking pointed questions.

    • @Cadadadry
      @Cadadadry 5 років тому +3

      @@Nangleator22 +1 and his english speaking is perfectly understandable for foreigners...

  • @MeMommyEms
    @MeMommyEms 4 роки тому +6

    “But dark forces are at work in the shape of Stewart Ainsworth.” Lol! 😂😂😂

  • @mercedes523
    @mercedes523 2 роки тому

    2021 watching! Love this show.

  • @behindthetree9022
    @behindthetree9022 3 роки тому +6

    28:10 "This is what I love about male archaeologists. They come into the trench to help and then they just stand there with a shovel and watch the machine!" Ouch... lol.

    • @boatfaceslim9005
      @boatfaceslim9005 3 роки тому +1

      Nothing is quite as ugly as a feminist's sexist whining.

    • @hansdorst3005
      @hansdorst3005 Рік тому

      More likely looking your curves, Bridge!

    • @Herr_Flick_of_ze_Gestapo
      @Herr_Flick_of_ze_Gestapo 4 місяці тому

      @behindthetrees. kindly take your misandrist sexist BS elsewhere!

  • @mermeridian2041
    @mermeridian2041 4 роки тому +5

    Love watching John and Stewart ("dark forces at work"! LOL!) work together to ferret out the information needed via entirely different methods. They're both so diligent and professional. Love how Tony makes a point to ask the experts to explain things that viewers might not know without making it obvious. Great job! (And Mick and His Sweater - you just can't get better than that!)
    But...*sigh*...I have yet to understand the point behind not being allowed to (carefully and diligently) archaeologically explore and document "scheduled ancient monument" sites much more fully especially when particular trenches prove extremely informative. It seems to my admittedly uneducated eye (that doesn't understand applying artificial limits to the dutiful and careful acquisition of information) that TPTB would rather those sites continue to degrade (erosion, vine and other plant life damage to structures above and below ground, rocks 'rotting' - something I'd never heard of until watching relevant Time Team episodes, underground animal/water incursions, stone/grave robbers, etc etc etc) than "risk" exploring, documenting, and preserving them more fully. It's almost as though TPTB are afraid of what they'd find! I guess I'm just flummoxed by the purposeful hiding (via not allowing exploration at all or by imposing artificial limits on actual digging regardless of how informative the particular dig site is) of information while allowing sites to continue degrading over time. It's just...frustrating.

    • @georgedorn1022
      @georgedorn1022 4 роки тому +2

      Underground archaeological remains are generally fairly stable on most sites. If a Scheduled site is found to be under threat through changing conditions then excavation is often undertaken to preserve by record what might be lost.
      One of the points of preserving stable sites is that, as the evolution of Time Team itself shows, archaeological technology and science advances rapidly. If you excavate a large proportion of a site now, you will understand less than if it was excavated several years in the future. Of course, this means for a stable site there is never a 'right' time so excavations that do take place tend to be small in scale and have very focused objectives.
      I don't think anyone is 'hiding' anything about this site, they are just reluctant to destroy a large part of one that is very important and will undoubtedly reveal more to future archaeologists than at the current moment.

    • @mermeridian2041
      @mermeridian2041 4 роки тому +1

      @@georgedorn1022 Thank you for taking the time to reply. Like you mentioned, I've enjoyed seeing the advances in the technology used and know that the future will likely bring even better ways of exploring the past while preserving even more of it. It's just...yeah, frustrating knowing that wonderful wonders of the past are RIGHT THERE but can't be explored because of artificial (read: paperwork) restrictions. The flip-side of that coin, though, is the hope that future tech. will provide even better ways of excavating those finds currently marked "explore later". Impatience is not a virtue!

  • @DrumToTheBassWoop
    @DrumToTheBassWoop 4 роки тому +1

    Alternate reality, Tony just driving down a busy modern street full of cars in the city of Roxburgh, but in this reality, due to the booming textiles industry of the 19th century, it expanded 5 fold, to engulf Kelso. It has a top division footie team, known as ‘Roxburgh and Kelso United’. And is the only major city between Newcastle and Edinburgh, people commute to the city using the M68R. It’s one of Scotland most important trader city’s so has attracted a lot of global businesses to set up in the area, and has in turn made the borders quite a wealthy area to live. But, this never happened, and it’s just a boring old field. 🙂

  • @TheHolyMongolEmpire
    @TheHolyMongolEmpire 8 років тому +6

    This show is badass

  • @billijomaynard8924
    @billijomaynard8924 5 років тому +6

    If you like this episode, give a quick shout out to Richard, Duke of Gloucester (King Richard III) for it was he who led the seizure of Berwick upon Tweed and won it back for England in 1482. If not for him, Phil and the team would have had nothing to dig. Do not think he meant to kill Roxburgh though, big oops on his part.

  • @justaguitardude
    @justaguitardude 11 років тому +2

    first episode iv seen them work the numbers so they continue a trench. heh. pill is my hero. cheers.

  • @anotherbrickoutthewall9237
    @anotherbrickoutthewall9237 Рік тому +1

    Ohhh arrrr Tony I do love a big dig! Stone the crows read it properly

  • @stannousflouride8372
    @stannousflouride8372 8 років тому +8

    Kay Brae is here:
    55.597499°N 2.448431°W

  • @carolcrass4322
    @carolcrass4322 7 місяців тому +1

    Can we show some acknowledgement for Ian (field archaeologist) who can operate a digger with such precision?!

    • @adamsjerome1839
      @adamsjerome1839 6 місяців тому

      A great shout out to Ian , the elder and Ian the younger. Both are magicians when operating the JCB. As a heavy operator skinning about 2 inches of soil, evenly is very, very difficult. I certainly can't do. Hats off to the Ian's.

    • @adamsjerome1839
      @adamsjerome1839 6 місяців тому

      A great shout out to Ian , the elder and Ian the younger. Both are magicians when operating the JCB. As a heavy operator skinning about 2 inches of soil, evenly is very, very difficult. I certainly can't do. Hats off to the Ian's.

  • @chinamanjw
    @chinamanjw 5 років тому +4

    Corenza😍

    • @philaypeephilippotter6532
      @philaypeephilippotter6532 4 роки тому

      *Carenza.*

    • @MelancholischerMond
      @MelancholischerMond 4 роки тому

      China man is a prophet. He had foreseen Corona. Hail to the Chinese prophet.

    • @philaypeephilippotter6532
      @philaypeephilippotter6532 4 роки тому +2

      @@MelancholischerMond Just to underline this to you as you seem ignorant of the fact, *Carenza Lewis* is a female *British* archæologist of considerable renown. She had _nothing_ to do with *_CoVid-19_* and *Chinamanjw* didn't either. I appreciate that such juvenile humour obviously makes you smirk while you are hiding behind the shed smoking but nobody else is amused.

    • @johnmoss6631
      @johnmoss6631 4 роки тому

      Phil, it is not worth wasting your time nor energy responding to a twit like melan.

    • @philaypeephilippotter6532
      @philaypeephilippotter6532 4 роки тому +2

      @@johnmoss6631 I know, I just get these occasional stupid urges. 🙃

  • @lavillablanca
    @lavillablanca 3 роки тому

    Thank God, history passed Roxborough by

  • @WashuHakubi4
    @WashuHakubi4 6 років тому +16

    "Umm... Ummm... Ummmm... Hmm..." That's why the experts get paid the big bucks.

  • @penguine342
    @penguine342 4 роки тому +3

  • @MissCattitude63
    @MissCattitude63 11 років тому +6

    Phil is great, isn't he just?

  • @JonFrumTheFirst
    @JonFrumTheFirst Рік тому

    There was a town of Roxbury just south of Boston, U.S.A., now annexed to the city. There were - and are still - rock outcrops exposed across the town, so maybe a coincidence.

  • @lainecolley1414
    @lainecolley1414 4 роки тому

    It's still tradition for the team to change when a building emerges from ground level x

  • @karmicpopcorn6440
    @karmicpopcorn6440 4 роки тому +1

    Holy cow, what did they spike Matt's coffee with? He was talking in fast forward.
    And that expert! 😂😂 "um um ahh umm"
    Are they grasping at straws with that last slab supporting a single grave? It looks like 2 very complete separate slabs?

  • @baongoc9889
    @baongoc9889 3 роки тому +1

    34:46 Time to call in an expert.
    The expert: "Uhm... eh... um... hmm... hmhm..."

    • @faithlesshound5621
      @faithlesshound5621 2 роки тому

      Contrived. They stitched together the beginnings of several different statements.

  • @kitskivich
    @kitskivich 4 роки тому +1

    The Time Team also did a dig at Codnor Castle. Henry de Grey, Baron Grey of Codnor was my 26th great-grandfather. Within three generations, one of Henry de Grey, Baron Grey of Codnor's first great-grandsons (and my direct line), Andrew Gray, Lord of Broxmouth (brother of Henry de Grey, 1st Baron of Codnor, who inherited the direct line of the Lords of Codnor), "obtained from King Robert [Bruce of Scotland], for his good and faithful services [in the War of Independence], a grant of several lands", one of which was Broxmouth Castle in Roxburghshire, Scotland. The next seven generations lived in the castle, the last of which was Andrew Grey, 2nd Lord Grey, Sheriff of Forfar, Justice of Scotland (born circa 1446 Roxborough Castle, Broxmouth, Roxburghshire, Scotland. Death: February 1514 Foulis Castle, Perthshire, Scotland (United Kingdom), my 16th great-grandfather. From Wikipedia: "Roxburgh Castle is a ruined royal castle that overlooks the junction of the rivers Tweed and Teviot, in the Borders region of Scotland. Its castleton developed into the royal burgh of Roxburgh, which the Scots (under James II) destroyed along with the castle after capturing it in 1460." Naturally, when one goes this far back in one's family tree, the characters feel like more than historical figures than forebearers. Still, the episode was fascinating to watch.

  • @mikeburgess944
    @mikeburgess944 Рік тому

    Interesting,since I was born in Roxbury, Boston, Massachusetts, USA. This could be the origin of the name.

  • @oldschoolman1444
    @oldschoolman1444 2 роки тому

    By the looks of it, that area is most likely prone to flooding. I can see why it was abandoned.

  • @lilmee7469
    @lilmee7469 4 роки тому +3

    I wonder how three year old Phil sounded.🤣

    • @phoule76
      @phoule76 4 роки тому +3

      at woulda been summat

  • @Rockcreek83
    @Rockcreek83 3 роки тому +1

    I don’t understand why the land owner wouldn’t let them dig like they “wanted” to?
    It will all grow back. The country could really use as much info for the local history and their country????
    Geez....?...

  • @waderone3536
    @waderone3536 9 років тому +1

    Love history. . wow nice to have evidence of the past. . Please dig at somewhere with suggested past life where Brian forester goes. pleeeeeeeeese?

  • @tompahdea9263
    @tompahdea9263 5 років тому +3

    The attempt at aligning land owners woud have been essier with a platform of Styrofoam and pins to temporarily attach yet moveable with further reading.

  • @dawngriffin3550
    @dawngriffin3550 6 місяців тому

  • @gerhardheydrich3146
    @gerhardheydrich3146 4 роки тому +1

    All this land belonging to Charles Robert George Innes-Ker is the 11th Duke of Roxburghe.

  • @andybyers2490
    @andybyers2490 Рік тому +1

    Whilst this is great, can we talk about how they've totally misplaced Edinburgh on that map? Not even close!

  • @VictorRochaGaming
    @VictorRochaGaming 3 роки тому

    Thanks to Mick, I now know what a Black Country accent sounds like.

    • @Happyheretic2308
      @Happyheretic2308 Рік тому +1

      Try listening to Robert Plant’s speaking voice. He’s Black Country born and bred, too.

  • @jamiemcnealis6768
    @jamiemcnealis6768 Місяць тому

    At 5 min 30 sec, shows a map of Scotland, Does anyone know why Edinburgh is in the wrong place,,,

  • @randyfiore1311
    @randyfiore1311 5 років тому +1

    Everytime he says geo fiz it crackes me up.lol

  • @littledikkins2
    @littledikkins2 3 роки тому +1

    The town was destroyed when James II of Scotland was killed besieging the town.

  • @maddog2771
    @maddog2771 4 роки тому +2

    Dec 2019

  • @dot2562
    @dot2562 Рік тому

    Ohhh arre Tony...Mary and katt

  • @Gremriel
    @Gremriel 3 роки тому +1

    Time to call in an expert. Uhm, eh, um, hmm, uh, uhm.

  • @TeresaTrimm
    @TeresaTrimm 3 роки тому +1

    First aired March 21, 2004.

  • @mohammedfrancis
    @mohammedfrancis 5 років тому +1

    Where does the soil come from to cover layers of archeological periods? It it from natural erosion or do are they buried after they fall out of use?

    • @joshschneider9766
      @joshschneider9766 4 роки тому +1

      Depends on location but usually a combination of nature and people robbing stone and such.

    • @joshschneider9766
      @joshschneider9766 4 роки тому

      also as with most of the world of it was a good place to make a structure it usually had multiple residents over the centuries.

    • @DubFocus89
      @DubFocus89 4 роки тому +2

      the movement of worms and rain over 100s of years causes the stone to sink a little , bird poo and dead leaves will compost over time and add a layer, loads of factors, on a grander scale, ice ages, volcano eruptions, plates shifting etc to reshape and "take back" the earth

    • @theskip1
      @theskip1 4 роки тому

      thats where all the leaves,dead grass etc. go that fall in the autum

  • @l2bboc930
    @l2bboc930 6 років тому +3

    Why would the church be outside the earthworks?

    • @Cadadadry
      @Cadadadry 5 років тому +1

      It might have been attached to a monastry ?...

    • @philaypeephilippotter6532
      @philaypeephilippotter6532 4 роки тому +1

      *L2 BBOC* Churches, cemeteries and monasteries are often outside the commercial areas of a town.

  • @pauloboyle477
    @pauloboyle477 7 місяців тому

    And Henry screws up again. The one guy whose entire job is done by a machine gets I wrong. Alwaysss

  • @alexhayden2303
    @alexhayden2303 4 роки тому +1

    Duke of Roxburghe
    What's it like to own 60,000 acres and a castle?

  • @Rockcreek83
    @Rockcreek83 3 роки тому

    Better late than never...LOL LOL 👍👏

  • @JohnBeadling
    @JohnBeadling Рік тому

    Remember when Discovery channel was cool?

  • @victoriahhigman9611
    @victoriahhigman9611 2 місяці тому

    What is the expert in?

  • @FionaKumariCampbell
    @FionaKumariCampbell 3 роки тому

    It’s a shame that the current landowner still controls things, this is Scotland’s heritage, the whole site would be dug up

    • @faithlesshound5621
      @faithlesshound5621 2 роки тому +2

      The limit to the area that could be dug up did not come from the Duke. Digging up the whole of a scheduled ancient monument destroys all of it, so that is never allowed.

  • @liamgibson7471
    @liamgibson7471 6 років тому +2

    good at history not so hot on geography, Edinburgh a bit too far north

    • @Toontex
      @Toontex 6 років тому +3

      Liam Gibson ,I found out a strange thing , using longitude Edinborough is further west than Manchester.Don’t laugh go and check it out.I am over 50 and from Northumberland so found it hard to believe but it is true.Just for general info ,I thought you might like to check it out.The other thing is where I was born and raised is further north than a huge region of south west Scotland.I’d always though our shared island was more or less up and down north /south,east/west.I am writing this in friendship hope you are neither bored or annoyed

    • @liamgibson7471
      @liamgibson7471 6 років тому +2

      Geordie Lad, no problem at all it was just that on the map they showed during the programme Edinburgh was where Dundee is and a wee bit further west You are right about the Long of Edinburgh and Manchester!

  • @Pauldjreadman
    @Pauldjreadman 4 роки тому +5

    200 square meters? Let them do their job, Why bother letting them in and then restrict them.

    • @ghendar
      @ghendar 4 роки тому +1

      Pauldjreadman I agree. I mean, I understand that sites like these are protected but wouldn't it be best to know the real story of the site by letting the archaeologists properly excavate it? History does no one any good if it's hidden under the ground forever.

    • @philaypeephilippotter6532
      @philaypeephilippotter6532 4 роки тому +3

      @@ghendar
      The site is owned by the *Duchy Of Roxburgh* who limited the dig. It was the _first_ dig ever allowed there.

    • @ghendar
      @ghendar 4 роки тому

      @@philaypeephilippotter6532 Thanks for that information. Hopefully there will be more.

  • @caljaysoc
    @caljaysoc 4 роки тому

    Matt is such a baby!

  • @patrickkelly4070
    @patrickkelly4070 4 роки тому +1

    Where did Robin the archivist go?

  • @robertallan6526
    @robertallan6526 5 років тому +2

    Edinburgh is incorrectly sited on their map

    • @Jigger2361
      @Jigger2361 4 роки тому

      ...English map

    • @greenhorn6582
      @greenhorn6582 4 роки тому

      It's part of a cunning plan to misguide those treacherous English in case the try to invade Scotland once again ;)

  • @ansfridaeyowulfsdottir8095
    @ansfridaeyowulfsdottir8095 Рік тому

    *_"Founded by a king as a hub for international trade..."_*
    *WHICH BLOODY KING!?*
    05:18
    Thank you!
    {:o:Oo:}

  • @silverfrost1
    @silverfrost1 6 років тому +3

    I miss Jenni Butterworth. Also, until the last two episodes, S11 has been dreadful. Mick has been absent for half the shows.

    • @philaypeephilippotter6532
      @philaypeephilippotter6532 4 роки тому +2

      He suffered from ill-health which was why his friend *Francis Pryor* fronted so many digs in later years.

  • @johnnyllooddte3415
    @johnnyllooddte3415 4 роки тому +1

    our airborne lidar can tell you in an hour

  • @rachellee.9389
    @rachellee.9389 10 років тому +1

    "Stu's New Area" reads the graphic caption but it's STEWart Ainsworth, not STUart. They really should know how to spell the names of the team.

    • @AudieHolland
      @AudieHolland 9 років тому +1

      How do you abbreviate "Stewart?" English, like all languages, has its quirks and exceptions to the rule. For instance, John F. Kennedy was called "Jack." I don't know if that's and English, an English-American or Irish thing.

    • @AudieHolland
      @AudieHolland 9 років тому

      Celto Loco LOL so my name is Scottish too? James becoming Jim sounds more plausible than the John-Jack thing because they share more common sounds. I have no knowledge of dialects in common English but could it be that "James" could pronounced as "Jimms" in some parts of the country?

    • @AudieHolland
      @AudieHolland 9 років тому +2

      Celto Loco LOL Audie Murphy looks really young in those warmovies where he played himself. But in the documentary footage of him during WW2, he looks even younger! Looked like a boyscout.
      The thing I found out about Audie: it's a small form for Audrey, which is a girl's name. No disrespect meant: Alice and Susan are also names given to boys (Alice Cooper). In Italy, Andrea is a boy's name, which is Andrew in English, which in shortened form becomes Drew.
      John-Jack continues to confuse me. However, Bob, Dick and Beth, all kinda sound like the abbreviated form for: Robert (Rob-Bob), Richard (Rick-Dick), Elizabeth (.....beth). Lisa of course also comes from Elizabeth.

    • @AudieHolland
      @AudieHolland 9 років тому +1

      Celto Loco Actually, I think 19 years old is a fine age for a soldier of present day armies. Very good learning skills, can adapt to different weapons and systems quickly and above all: doesn't question the fucking war he's fighting!
      Seriously though, I do think the US helicopter pilots in Vietnam were very good.
      www.vhpa.org/stories/stories.html

    • @AudieHolland
      @AudieHolland 9 років тому +1

      Celto Loco The doorgunners did have some influence over their fate. Like every crewmember, they acted like valuable extra eyes to spot enemy positions, obstructions and incoming fire. To the pilots, the doorgunner and crew chief were as much a member of the team as they themselves were. Typically, the senior pilot was the only one with real experience, the second pilot (Peter pilot) was only there to take over control when the commander was shot or when the commander thought his second pilot could gain some valuable experience.
      But if the doorgunner or crew chief shouted a lot of incoming fire let's get the hell out of here, the pilots usually listened to common sense. Because once the doorgunner or crew chief were gone, you were practically blind from that side and a sitting duck.

  • @carolynwells5293
    @carolynwells5293 4 роки тому

    Sorry, I hear Edinburg. Is it the same place , when did the spelling and pronunciation change. This old lady is going bonkers

  • @mercedes523
    @mercedes523 2 роки тому

    500 years in the future USA 🇺🇸.....what is that? Oh just a nappy. (Diaper)

  • @michellezoe4596
    @michellezoe4596 2 роки тому

    Why do they always use their middle fingers to point out things on a map?😂

  • @rachellee.9389
    @rachellee.9389 10 років тому +3

    I love Phil, too. Pity he never had kids because I think he would've made a great dad. One thing bothers me, though, and that is his extra long fingernails. I have noticed that John Nettles of "Midsomer Murders" has long fingernails as well. Is this a "thing" with English men, or guitar players, or what?

    • @fulkthered
      @fulkthered 10 років тому +5

      His bio says he's "A keen guitarist".

    • @zoomzoom73
      @zoomzoom73 9 років тому +7

      rachelle e. It is clearly for guitar reasons, as the nails are only long on his right hand, which he uses to "pluck" the strings.

    • @aylbdrmadison1051
      @aylbdrmadison1051 5 років тому +3

      @ Susan Hill : As a guitarist and instructor for nearly 30 years I can attest to this as well. The give away is that the nails are long on one hand, but absolutely *must* be short on the fretting hand (left hand = short nails for right hand players, etc). For me it's always been sad that I have to cut them short on the left hand. My sister wanted to learn to play guitar as well, but couldn't get past that little fact.
      Would love to hear Phil play one day. ^-^

    • @joshschneider9766
      @joshschneider9766 4 роки тому +1

      He's a finger picker doesn't use an external pick to play his nails are the picks.

    • @deborahparham3783
      @deborahparham3783 Рік тому

      I still can't find the videos that show Phil playing his guitar. That would be well worth watching.

  • @ian_b
    @ian_b 3 роки тому +1

    "All that remains are the decaying remains of a castle, and its Liberal Democrat MP."

  • @monaserwin2412
    @monaserwin2412 10 років тому +9

    I don't like the I know better Attitude of Carenza Lewis.

    • @marniesweet4677
      @marniesweet4677 9 років тому +18

      Carenza is surrounded by male chauvinist scientists who try to dominate the discussions and analyses. She has to fight for her professional life, so to speak.
      She does a great job.

    • @senortonyful
      @senortonyful 9 років тому +2

      Marnie Sweet
      Ha!

    • @djspbb
      @djspbb 9 років тому +12

      Marnie Sweet Carenza is surrounded by people who are educated and don't want their opinions to be discounted, just like Carenza. Ego not misoginy is responsible foe their attitudes. The males fight just as hard for their theories to be respected. Limited digging allowances mean not everyone's thoughts can be dug.

    • @scarletfluerr
      @scarletfluerr 5 років тому +6

      If she was a man she would be authoritative, but because she's a woman she's bitchy.

  • @OUigot
    @OUigot 4 роки тому

    I worked a long career in convention services and on job sites there were always offices like Time Teams "incident room," it's where the lazy people who avoided the work hung out, hiding. I notice after many of these episodes, Mick, the boss, is always out in the field and Carenza is always in the incident room puttering with some fluff that requires her attention, even the historians are all out in the field. I've seen far too many people like her, far too many times, over far too many years....she's lazy and avoiding the work.

    • @minimaker5600
      @minimaker5600 4 роки тому +5

      You're assuming a lot. We don't see that much of their activities to make a judgment of who did what. The fact that she came back year after year certainly says that they were satisfied with her work.

    • @OUigot
      @OUigot 4 роки тому

      @@minimaker5600 - My dear, Carenza rides people's coat tails and takes credit for the work other people do and avoids working herself. Those are the facts.

    • @minimaker5600
      @minimaker5600 4 роки тому +4

      @@OUigot And the source of your "facts" come from . . . ?

    • @OUigot
      @OUigot 4 роки тому

      @@minimaker5600 - every episode of Time Team she appears in.

    • @minimaker5600
      @minimaker5600 4 роки тому +1

      @@OUigot LAME!!!

  • @ebybeehoney
    @ebybeehoney 4 роки тому +3

    Nearly every beginning, Tony usually ask Mick something and he says "No, I don't think so." Usually in the context of getting the data they want in the time allowed... I can hear it in my dreams.

  • @angelwitchgirlspattaya218
    @angelwitchgirlspattaya218 8 років тому +2

    I wish they had more time to dig more thoroughly so that they can find more artifacts. Kind of bored looking at ditches, dirt and rocks.

    • @georgedorn1022
      @georgedorn1022 4 роки тому +2

      The archaeological contexts that the artefacts are in are what's most important to understanding a site. If you're only interested in artefacts then you are a treasure hunter, not an archaeologist.

  • @jeanneamato8278
    @jeanneamato8278 5 років тому +20

    Thank goodness I’m retired so I can spend days watching these and learn so much.

  • @peggyjenkinson4514
    @peggyjenkinson4514 6 років тому +53

    I'd like to add a comment from now-2018. I love watching these shows. I get to love each person and their specialty.

    • @jfebacher
      @jfebacher 6 років тому +7

      Yes, they are wonderful. In the process of trying to watch them all

    • @peggyjenkinson4514
      @peggyjenkinson4514 6 років тому +11

      Nice to know I'm not the only current viewer.

    • @JayWalkerTexasRadio
      @JayWalkerTexasRadio 6 років тому +6

      I'm watching the series again in 2018 as well, third time in 5 years...

    • @deetsy4jesus
      @deetsy4jesus 5 років тому +9

      @@JayWalkerTexasRadio Same, 3rd time in 5 yrs as well. Funny thing is that because there is so much information in TT, I didn't even remember anything about this episode. It was like I was watching it for the first time.

    • @tripleransom4349
      @tripleransom4349 5 років тому +1

      I'm going through them for the first time in 2019. What a pleasure, too. Great television.

  • @ZemplinTemplar
    @ZemplinTemplar 4 роки тому +10

    One of the most fascinating episodes of the programme, for me personally. :-) An old favourite of mine.

  • @toypupanbai3544
    @toypupanbai3544 11 років тому +9

    I would have thought that another really intriguing dig would have been where The Bruce spent his last years, the Manor of Cardross.
    It is surprising that so little is recorded of a such a special place.

  • @fudgeweasel
    @fudgeweasel 4 роки тому +3

    The map at 5:28 is... interesting. And by interesting I mean "has whoever made that map ever actually looked at a map of Scotland?" None of those place names are in the right location - Inverness isn't too far off, but wtf were they smoking when they produced, approved, edited and reviewed this?

  • @AudieHolland
    @AudieHolland 9 років тому +17

    It seems almost impossible. A major town, city having completely disappeared under meadows.

    • @jeremyxman
      @jeremyxman 9 років тому +18

      Makes you wonder what parts of our cities will look like in 400-500 years. Its interesting to look at places like Chernobyl, thats only been a few years and its already being reclaimed by the wild.

    • @Nangleator22
      @Nangleator22 5 років тому +10

      I'm always trying to figure out what it was like for the last person to just walk away from this or that castle, town, church, etc.

    • @Cadadadry
      @Cadadadry 5 років тому +4

      @@Nangleator22 It probably wasn't as peacefull as today... Imagine an entire (small) city mainly made of wooden houses catching fire and beeing raided by greedy soldiers !

    • @greenhorn6582
      @greenhorn6582 4 роки тому +1

      After the Brexit whole England will completely disapear under meadows...

    • @AudieHolland
      @AudieHolland 4 роки тому

      @@Nangleator22 One thing I have wondered about. What would a certain street you know look like at the end of time?

  • @Go-Dawgs
    @Go-Dawgs 6 років тому +6

    I am begining to notice john's attitude more during these episodes. Yeah it's a pain but gosh that is why you are there. It's such a mystery until uncovered & they need you to help hitting best targets. "Nettles"?????

    • @Wally-H
      @Wally-H 6 років тому +4

      You do get the impression that of all the team members, he would be the easiest to upset

    • @aylbdrmadison1051
      @aylbdrmadison1051 5 років тому +4

      Have you ever had to walk back and forth for over an hour through nettles?
      Edit: ?????* (

    • @Sapharone
      @Sapharone 4 роки тому +4

      @@aylbdrmadison1051 I had to pluck them for two hours.
      I also think John is keeping an eye on all the work he and his team have to do. On top of the geophys he's also dealing with his own team of people.
      Besides, I think that's just how John gets through a working day. Some people just thrive on complaining; they can't help it.
      I happen to like John a lot. Yes, he complains quite a bit, but he does get the work done.

  • @alexiswelsh5821
    @alexiswelsh5821 4 роки тому +3

    What's the episode where their stuff goes missing, and Phil says, "Where ever I go, my shovel goes Tony!"

  • @cleverclogs2244
    @cleverclogs2244 4 роки тому +2

    The stone with the carved tree had a very obvious serpent hanging in it - the garden of Eden, not Christ's crucifixion!

  • @cjamthepatricianakabilldoo7852
    @cjamthepatricianakabilldoo7852 5 років тому +3

    Alice Roberts wow

  • @trippames3000
    @trippames3000 7 років тому +6

    The map at @5:00 is amazingly inaccurate for TT unless one remembers the usual attitudes of the English toward anything Scottish. If London were identified on a map to be in the vicinity of Oxford, there would be angry mobs in the streets with pitchforks. I was very surprized that TT would allow anything so off scale.