Cows Are Not Harmed In My Village | Satvic Milk | Q & A | Christ University | Veganism

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 5 лип 2024
  • If cows are raised lovingly as mentioned in the scriptures, there are no forced impregnations, calf is allowed to have it's fair share of milk and the cows are not killed once they reach old age, it is okay to consume said milk?
    ___________________________________________________________________________________________________
    You can now support my work via Google Pay as well : arvindanimalactivist@oksbi
    Google Pay : arvindanimalactivist@oksbi
    Patreon Link : / arvindanimalactivist
    Also if you are non vegan please do not become a donor. Don't give money for a cause that tries to abolish animal exploitation while exploiting animals yourself in order to cancel out your guilt. Please do not support me financially if you are not a Vegan yourself.
    Thanks!
    ___________________________________________________________________________________________________
    You can also choose to follow me on :
    Facebook : / arvindanimal. .
    Instagram : / arvindanima. .

КОМЕНТАРІ • 382

  • @arvindanimalactivist8192
    @arvindanimalactivist8192  Місяць тому +53

    For the Vegans out there who want to and are in a position to financially support my work, please read the following. If you like the work we do and feel you can support us when it to comes to the maintenance, repair of our equipment and also our overhead charges please consider supporting our Patreon or making a donation via Google Pay. Please note that I will not be making any exclusive content for Patreon as me and my partner are too occupied making content for our current social media handles. Thanks in advance.
    Google Pay : arvindanimalactivist@oksbi
    Patreon Link : www.patreon.com/ArvindAnimalActivist
    Also if you are non vegan please do not become a donor. Don't give money for a cause that tries to abolish animal exploitation while exploiting animals yourself in order to cancel out your guilt. Please do not support me financially if you are not a Vegan yourself.
    Thanks!

    • @Glikokuyo
      @Glikokuyo Місяць тому +3

    • @LouisGedo
      @LouisGedo Місяць тому +3

      👋

    • @RightSideOfHistory123
      @RightSideOfHistory123 Місяць тому +4

      Keep up the good work Arvind!

    • @rishyasirungen9211
      @rishyasirungen9211 Місяць тому +3

      I consume eggs, flesh , even bones of chicken , goat . Rarely eat vegetables so i am not eligible to donate..

    • @mihirsaxena2530
      @mihirsaxena2530 Місяць тому

      Don’t give a single dime to this fraud

  • @10ON10
    @10ON10 Місяць тому +83

    *Beautifully explained, I'm saving this to assist me in explaining things when I get into an argument on the dinner table*

    • @JagadguruSvamiVegananda
      @JagadguruSvamiVegananda Місяць тому

      There are TWO reasons why vegans comprise a fraction of one percent of the population:
      The main reason is due to humans’ failure to care about what they put into their own bodies - as long as it tastes good, who gives a damn about the consequences to one’s own health, or to the ethical concerns regarding other creatures or the environment?
      The other reason is due to vegan advocates and animal rights activists being inept in their understanding of morality, as well as their abysmal grasp of human physiology. Almost every single vegan activist I know of, wrongly believes that we are omnivores, and they are CLUELESS in respect to metaethics and applied ethics.
      However, this is not the most unfortunate thing about the matter. The saddest thing is, that there is hardly a single vegan activist willing to spend even a single hour or so, in order to study proper diet and meta-ethics with the current World Teacher Himself, Jagadguru Svāmī Vegānanda, despite him freely offering to do so on his social media platforms. 😩

    • @annto1971
      @annto1971 Місяць тому +4

      Love is higher than any argument, just love the animals, one will automatically become vegan by own

    • @Mayur_Kedare
      @Mayur_Kedare Місяць тому +5

      @@annto1971 One need not love animals to be vegan. It is just ethical thing to be vegan. For example, I don't like some people and I don't love some people still I don't pay someone to murder them. I leave them alone. So veganism is just that. We have to respect the rights to life for them.

    • @msavitri3409
      @msavitri3409 Місяць тому +1

      I too do the same, I save all Arvind 's videos, they are all so well explained

  • @yahuyahu1362
    @yahuyahu1362 Місяць тому +79

    Vegans should learn to speak like him to support their cause. Non vegetarians are bullies out there.

    • @JUSTDOGTHINGS
      @JUSTDOGTHINGS Місяць тому +3

      right🎉

    • @semicolon6499
      @semicolon6499 Місяць тому +1

      हम 😢

    • @criticalpsyche
      @criticalpsyche 26 днів тому +3

      if other than arvind have told me about veganism i may have gotten toxic but with his insight i answer will calmness and keeping my patience contained.

    • @samwienska1703
      @samwienska1703 21 день тому

      ​@@semicolon6499 yes! you, Semicolon, are a bully 👿😤
      🤪😄😂

    • @munirajc3575
      @munirajc3575 12 днів тому

      What the problem with u.U want to cease to animals exist

  • @amitgambhir1090
    @amitgambhir1090 Місяць тому +61

    Let’s stop looking for the right way to do the wrong things.

  • @lauratanln
    @lauratanln Місяць тому +15

    India supposedly has the highest number of vegetarians in the world. Hope India can have the highest number of vegans and become the most compassionate nation in the world.

    • @religionofpeace782
      @religionofpeace782 25 днів тому +5

      The only thing that had kept india vegetarian for so many centuries was compassion. It's gone now. Hope compassion is revived in the hearts of Indians once again and they go vegan.

    • @ronitlenka9205
      @ronitlenka9205 24 дні тому +1

      Look i used to be non vegetarian.
      I am a vegetarian now. I will be honest, I am having a hard time switching to veganism.
      I am trying but it will take some time.

    • @lauratanln
      @lauratanln 24 дні тому +1

      @@religionofpeace782 it's when you have compassion that you go vegan, which is an ethical stance against causing suffering and killing. It's not the plant based diet that makes you become vegan as veganism is Not just a diet alone.

    • @dhanush4792
      @dhanush4792 18 днів тому +1

      ​@@ronitlenka9205 Being vegetarian itself okay bro... don't follow veganism....veganism is a shit every childrens drinks milk upto adulthood. If they follw veganism they'll be in danger

    • @munirajc3575
      @munirajc3575 12 днів тому

      What the problem with u.U want to cease to animals exist

  • @Batman67991
    @Batman67991 Місяць тому +24

    Be vegan 🌱✅ 🙏
    👇

  • @Deepayadav9488-c1p
    @Deepayadav9488-c1p Місяць тому +19

    Sir I am class 10 student from up. You have answers of all question. In 2022 I stopped the eating eggs and now after listening you I also stopped the dairy products

    • @WarriorOfTruth
      @WarriorOfTruth Місяць тому +2

      ensure that you get b12 supplements and eat other sources of calcium like sesame seeds, chia seeds, soya chunks, cinnamon

    • @ajaymehra8839
      @ajaymehra8839 Місяць тому +1

      I really appreciate your empathy ☺️

    • @shivamkukreja1991
      @shivamkukreja1991 Місяць тому

      You guys have gone crazy

    • @ajaymehra8839
      @ajaymehra8839 Місяць тому

      @@shivamkukreja1991 I think, people have few empathy. What about you??

    • @Gardabah
      @Gardabah 29 днів тому

      Welcome to the community! Thanks a lot for joining!

  • @julioandresgomez3201
    @julioandresgomez3201 Місяць тому +13

    Earth can satisfy everyone's need (enough plants for each and every one), but not greed.

    • @criticalpsyche
      @criticalpsyche 26 днів тому

      M gandhi

    • @religionofpeace782
      @religionofpeace782 25 днів тому +1

      ​@@criticalpsycheGandhi was a bigtime hypocrite. He drank goats milk, slept with his nephews and PS and still Indians(fools) considered him a Mahatma.wow

    • @munirajc3575
      @munirajc3575 12 днів тому

      What the problem with u.U want to cease to animals exist

  • @AvS0225
    @AvS0225 Місяць тому +16

    Amazing how you patiently explained everything and how patiently he listened everything.

  • @SuMiTMeshram25
    @SuMiTMeshram25 Місяць тому +16

    In my mothers village there are people who works as "Gadaria"(I am quoting here as profession and not caste) who takes all cattle with them to meadows and in jungle for free roaming where they eat and rest and do thing while spending the whole day so they are practically free there only part is that Gadaria keep eye for safety and count of cattles there are few males which are kind of alpha "Sand" as you already know so their prgnancy happens in most natural way, this practise is getting rare and rare everyday, however at my mother's native village its still exists.

    • @prajwalmuralis2101
      @prajwalmuralis2101 Місяць тому +2

      Sad to say but this practice will also go extinct as time passes and more urbanization takes place.

    • @SuMiTMeshram25
      @SuMiTMeshram25 Місяць тому +1

      @@prajwalmuralis2101 sad indeed, bull are already have been almost useless in farms almost everything is taken over by machines like trackers

    • @stillsimple-np7mc
      @stillsimple-np7mc 23 дні тому +2

      ​@@SuMiTMeshram25 These people should have promoted this thing because Shri Krishna himself used to do this.
      But no, rather than providing real solutions they are working for some propaganda so that cows go extinct.

  • @user-px4jj2ou6z
    @user-px4jj2ou6z Місяць тому +12

    But to be frank activist aravindh Sir's words are upto the point. We can't search right ways to do wrong things

  • @krishna369-t4o
    @krishna369-t4o Місяць тому +6

    I hope these people realize what happens to GoMata in the dairy industry once she becomes old and can’t produce milk.

  • @GarudAtma
    @GarudAtma Місяць тому +6

    Glad that comment section is filling the wisdom and practical aspects

  • @ladyaudrey9976
    @ladyaudrey9976 Місяць тому +15

    Great work. Thank you. Be vegan everyone 💚💚💚💚💚💚

    • @shivamkukreja1991
      @shivamkukreja1991 Місяць тому

      @@ladyaudrey9976 I'm consuming dairy products at the time of typing this comment lol😂

    • @criticalpsyche
      @criticalpsyche 26 днів тому +1

      @@shivamkukreja1991 be vegan, go vegan

  • @user-jk3nm9lm1w
    @user-jk3nm9lm1w Місяць тому +5

    Don't try to find exuse for your cruelty‼⛔ Be vegan🌱💚💚..

  • @capucinebellucci3476
    @capucinebellucci3476 Місяць тому +7

    Thank you for speaking up for animals 💖💖💖💖

  • @nicolathomas5125
    @nicolathomas5125 Місяць тому +7

    👑 Arvind 👊🔥👊🔥👊🔥👊
    Smashed it, again 💚🌿🕊️

  • @therealgrimreaper68
    @therealgrimreaper68 Місяць тому +30

    Keeping cows in good conditions, not forcibly impregnating them, not taking away the baby and not selling them to the slaughterhouse is simply not profitable. Milk is subsidised as is and to be profitable they need even more subsidies to be profitable.

    • @Mayur_Kedare
      @Mayur_Kedare Місяць тому +4

      Exactly! For continuous supply of dairy products they need to be pregnant yearly otherwise people who wants milk daily will get milk some days and some days they won't.

    • @ajaymehra8839
      @ajaymehra8839 27 днів тому

      The thing is.. not everyone is thinking like you

  • @that.taurus.beauty
    @that.taurus.beauty Місяць тому +14

    🌷🙌My goodness the amount of patience Arvind as to keep during these sessions. . Enjoyed watching this one. Great insights on veganism👍 I turned vegan this year❤

  • @GarudAtma
    @GarudAtma Місяць тому +2

    We all know cows are exploited in that manner. So do horses and cats and dogs. The point is, that we are taking so much from them, at least we can take care of them in return instead of just seeing them as products and reselling them as meat after their usage ends.
    That's why the animal from which we get so much, we call cow as a mother, not really a mother but to form an emotional bond with her.
    Whereas the bull is called a Nandi. Nandi is the bull of Trimurti Shiv

  • @ateen1
    @ateen1 Місяць тому +7

    Great arvind ❤❤❤

  • @preetamrawat4939
    @preetamrawat4939 Місяць тому +2

    What plant-based alternatives to cow's milk can provide similar byproducts like curd and ghee, while also being economical and creating jobs for people? Are there options that could support local economies in the same way dairy farming does?

  • @cynicalidealist11
    @cynicalidealist11 Місяць тому +2

    I would disagree strongly about lab grown meat. As far as I’m concerned lab grown meat is vegan because the only reason vegans don’t buy animal products is because they oppose the rights violations that animals have to experience to get the meat, like rape, torture and murder. If we can procure meat without those rights violations then there’s no ethical problem. Lab grown meat is a blessing to the vegan movement, it is our best and maybe only chance to create a world without slaughterhouses, by rendering the whole process of farming and slaughter obsolete. The same way horse travel is an obsolete means of travel when we have motor vehicles.

  • @user-zz1zb1ki2f
    @user-zz1zb1ki2f 29 днів тому +2

    8:22 Most important point ❤❤🕉️🕉️

  • @worldisamazing9679
    @worldisamazing9679 Місяць тому +7

    Just amazing ❤

  • @eashanism
    @eashanism Місяць тому +3

    Ur awesome Arvind a true and a worthy Brahmin. Hats off man. Keep up the good work.👏👏👍

  • @AlokKumar-je9hd
    @AlokKumar-je9hd 15 днів тому

    Excellent Arvind: I like the way you skillfully handle the question with right logic. Keep it up.

  • @mohlini1
    @mohlini1 Місяць тому +5

    well said Arvind!

  • @ValeriaRossellini
    @ValeriaRossellini Місяць тому +5

    Great work as usual, thank you 💗💗

  • @brilliantgeneratinggenius7498
    @brilliantgeneratinggenius7498 Місяць тому +7

    ❤❤❤❤❤😊😊😊

  • @Indianocean324
    @Indianocean324 28 днів тому +5

    He says that cows have a low natural likelihood of becoming pregnant. That means, ceasing artificial insemination and refraining from using their milk would remove the necessity to care for them, potentially leading to their extinction. We must be pragmatic; achieving absolute non-violence is impractical. Instead, we should strive to minimize harm. The dairy industry can be regulated and reformed to become more animal-friendly rather than completely boycotting it.

  • @NathanBlackberry
    @NathanBlackberry Місяць тому +71

    Don't steal milk from cows, be kind to animals and choose Veganism💚💚💚🐮🐮🐮❤️🫂🌱🙏🙏🙏

    • @MrOutstandingtuber
      @MrOutstandingtuber Місяць тому +17

      So the plant's and trees are growing vegetables and fruits for you??...Don't steal fruits and vegetables...

    • @NathanBlackberry
      @NathanBlackberry Місяць тому +14

      @@MrOutstandingtuber plants are here for us🙏🙏🙏🌱🥦🍇💚💚💚
      Please be kind to animals🐥🐥🐥🫂🫂🫂❤️❤️❤️

    • @therealgrimreaper68
      @therealgrimreaper68 Місяць тому +22

      @@MrOutstandingtuber since you care about plants so much, the first thing you should do is to stop eating meat, livestock eat wayy more plants than humans directly.

    • @MrOutstandingtuber
      @MrOutstandingtuber Місяць тому +6

      @@therealgrimreaper68 That's why I am eating meat to save my dear plants...

    • @therealgrimreaper68
      @therealgrimreaper68 Місяць тому +1

      @@MrOutstandingtuber 🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @scienceislove2014
    @scienceislove2014 Місяць тому +1

    On earth , our existence is temporary... we're not gonna be here forever...so why make somebody else's existence (I'm talking about animals) painful and hard..their life doesn't have to be miserable 😖..
    Plus.. we wouldn't be around for more than a century anyway.. and you don't die on a plant based diet.. infact it's quite the opposite if planned smartly ... So i don't see any reason to not be vegan...
    And there's so much information on the internet..and amazing recipes like this one..

    • @aftabsayed2825
      @aftabsayed2825 Місяць тому +1

      Yes, why take life of others !?
      Why kill the babies of plants !?
      Why slaughter and cook plants !? They also have life,😢

  • @SimbasPawsomeFamily
    @SimbasPawsomeFamily 27 днів тому

    Very thoughtful and respectful conversation bw both 👏❤ Arvind as usual rocks , and liked how he talks with facts logic so that evryone can understand.

  • @ishpatel553
    @ishpatel553 Місяць тому +5

    Man! 🙌🏾🙌🏾

  • @rewananadar1547
    @rewananadar1547 Місяць тому +5

    🌱

  • @AdirajThakur-kt1jk
    @AdirajThakur-kt1jk Місяць тому +1

    I proud to be vegan

  • @Tuisosuiso
    @Tuisosuiso Місяць тому +2

    By strict definition, plastic is non-vegan because it derives from fossil fuels, primarily petroleum or natural gas. These are processed into monomers like ethylene and propylene, which polymerize into plastic. Some plastics include animal-derived additives such as stearates and glycerin.
    What brand is your water bottle, I would like to google and find out if it uses a plant-based bioplastic that is a vegan-friendly alternative.
    Having said that, your water bottle looks suspiciously non-vegan.

    • @Mayur_Kedare
      @Mayur_Kedare Місяць тому

      Are you saying vegans are hypocrite?

    • @Vegan123
      @Vegan123 Місяць тому

      You miss the point.
      If you are Vegan or become Vegan then you are reducing suffering by the maximum amount.
      Concentrate your actions on the 95%

    • @Tuisosuiso
      @Tuisosuiso Місяць тому +2

      @@Mayur_Kedare That is not what I am saying, that is what he is demonstrating.

    • @Tuisosuiso
      @Tuisosuiso Місяць тому

      ​@@Vegan123 Is that another way of saying you're not quite ready to commit to being a vegan because it would be a great inconvenience to you? Consistency in ethical choices is important, don't you think? As things stand, congratulations on being a part-time vegan aficionado.

    • @Mayur_Kedare
      @Mayur_Kedare Місяць тому

      @@Tuisosuiso If there is no hypocrisy then I don't have anything to discuss. The fossil is from era when Dinosaurs lived and died and it gets converted into fuel, but it is indirect way by that logic every atom that you breathe has come from animal. I don't think glycerin and stearates are derived from animals and they can come from plants or their oils. I don't think you understand what he means he means strictly directly from animal. Like the secrections like blood, urine, semen, honey, eggs, milk etc, and their body parts such as skin, flesh, organs, bones etc. So a lab grown meat is real flesh not made from animal it is made from animal cells that were procured from an animal. The point of upholding this principle is to convey a message that animals should not be viewed as object.

  • @ganesharvind867
    @ganesharvind867 Місяць тому +2

    watch 8.21, really right Argument and truth. By the way i m vegan since 2012.

    • @Narasimha_TheSher
      @Narasimha_TheSher Місяць тому

      Great! Can you please describe the changes you have witnessed in your health life after staying vegan for this long time...
      Have you encountered any deficiency like that of B12 or any bone-related issue?
      I'm asking because I can't take supplements...

    • @ganesharvind867
      @ganesharvind867 Місяць тому +1

      @Narasimha_TheSher yes. after following vegan diet 6 years later, suffered from anxiety, mood swing, vision related issues, confusions, burning tongue, mouth ulcer and many.
      Once in 2 years i check b12 level. Consult doctor and taken b12 injections . D vit difficiency still there. But I wish to follow till last breath.

  • @anacarinadelgado7267
    @anacarinadelgado7267 Місяць тому +3

    Loce your activism ❤❤❤

  • @user-br7bo7jc3x
    @user-br7bo7jc3x 16 днів тому

    Sir @8:19 it's blood milk!! Let's stop looking for the right way to do the wrong thing. 💚

  • @Korangamansi79
    @Korangamansi79 Місяць тому +4

    💚💚🌱🌱

  • @jaionutube1
    @jaionutube1 8 днів тому

    Brilliantly answered.

  • @tjk4929
    @tjk4929 Місяць тому +1

    Please make a video on animal killings during Eid and Christmas

  • @rohitrohit-wl9wv
    @rohitrohit-wl9wv Місяць тому

    should i need to take b12 supplement or are there any alternatives?

    • @Vegan123
      @Vegan123 Місяць тому

      Most Vegan products are fortified with B12.
      You can take a Vegan B12 supplement if required.
      If in any doubt get your bloods checked by a medical practitioner

    • @Mayur_Kedare
      @Mayur_Kedare Місяць тому

      Take a supplement it is cheap, safe and don't worry about it.

    • @rohitrohit-wl9wv
      @rohitrohit-wl9wv Місяць тому +1

      @@Mayur_Kedare How often should I take the supplement?

    • @aftabsayed2825
      @aftabsayed2825 Місяць тому +1

      Yes Eat Meat !! 😅

  • @shrutinagar3092
    @shrutinagar3092 28 днів тому +1

    Respect for you Arvind!! Please go vegan 👍🌱🌱 Be compassionate towards animals.

  • @user-ts1gk7uw9t
    @user-ts1gk7uw9t Місяць тому +4

    🙏💚

  • @akashyadav1335
    @akashyadav1335 Місяць тому +3

    ❤❤❤

  • @khushboomaurya5826
    @khushboomaurya5826 27 днів тому +1

    Beautifully explained 👍🏻🙌🏻

  • @scienceislove2014
    @scienceislove2014 Місяць тому +1

    God bless you guys 🙏🌱🙏🙏🏿🙏🏼🙏🏽🙏🏾🙏🏻

  • @TheRakeshgautam
    @TheRakeshgautam Місяць тому +1

    Those who are vegetarian from childhood onwards have huge protein deficiency already. Just check, the countries which are pure non-vegetarian are the wealthiest ones...why? Since their working class people from generation are getting all nutrition and protein. In fact even compare India with china...their normal population is much more productive than India. As a poor country we should be purely non vegetarian and when we become developed then only we should think about veganism. With humans morality also dies. Protect humans first.

    • @TobiSGD
      @TobiSGD 26 днів тому

      wahat a bunch of nonsense

  • @d.slifestyle3737
    @d.slifestyle3737 Місяць тому +1

    every vegan or promoting veganism is the dash drohi and rashtra dhroi

  • @BoldlyReal-mq9ti
    @BoldlyReal-mq9ti Місяць тому +1

    See bro I like your every video a I really realised it's unbearable pain we are causing them it's very painful
    But still so many people has given logic that we also kills plants it's also not fair and we should not eats plant too...
    And for a moment I felt that too.. and it's quite right
    But then I started a to explore that does plants really feel sense of pain
    If yes then whatever we are doing is neither right nor wrong it's just it because it's our biological need for food
    Then after exploring I got answer plants doesn't feel any sensations including the sense of pain
    And I got my answer that
    We do have option for healthy survival
    Still so many people eat meat including me too.. I also eat chicken and fish
    So I asked myself that why I eat chicken and meat ?
    4 things I realised in myself
    1) we eat it for pleasure of taste, this this the root cause. And root reason why most of the people eat meat
    If being honest
    It's not really reated to protein or health or anything of health
    In actuality it's simply because i get a sense of pleasure of taste eating that...
    2) other major reason is we have normalise it society as if it's not a big deal to eat meat
    Thus from childhood seeing everyone is eating meat creates a sense of okness that it's absolutely alright and nothing wrong
    3) this is also main reason and very very important cause and that is most of the people aren't really aware of what they really are doing
    They are just eating it normally without really knowing what actually they have done and contributed to...
    If they really become aware deeply feeling the pain of that animal
    They would be shaken from inside
    And after seeing your video it happened to me that I was even unable to drink the cup of tea realising what's ugly process behind this
    But one thing I don't like and disagree with you is that
    You can simply make people aware about what's really we are doing
    I.e the all the ugly painful process behind it that's absolutely enough
    Nothing more than that is needed
    By more I am saying that
    We don't need any kind identification like veganism etc etc... with it's rules.
    Simply making people aware of pain of animals is enough
    Not making people identify them with veganism and stuff...!

  • @greatbalance
    @greatbalance Місяць тому +2

    Arvind, you need to go live in the villages where such natural herds are reared. Even on UA-cam there are many videos of farms in places like Gujarat, Rajasthan, etc. where they rear herds which are organic family units. It is not so dire as you describe that cows are ALWAYS forcefully impregnated. Living in natural herds means that the bulls and cows behave naturally, i.e. the cows in heat have the desire to mate with the bulls as much as the bulls have the desire to mate with the cows. You seem to think that only bulls are horny and always have an erection, but cows never have sexual interest in the bulls. Nature is not like that. You should watch the videos where the cows themselves come to the bull and behave affectionately. One bull can mate with several cows, and thus have many calves, and provide sufficient milk. Through selective breeding, some of the breeds like Gir can produce up to 12 litres per day.

    • @GST6647
      @GST6647 Місяць тому +2

      So that justifies stealing milk from the mother and depriving the calf? He just explained right now, stop trying to do wrong things in a right way.

    • @GST6647
      @GST6647 Місяць тому +1

      @greatbalance
      So that justifies stealing milk from the mother and depriving the calf? He just explained right now, stop trying to do wrong things in a right way

    • @greatbalance
      @greatbalance 23 дні тому

      @@GST6647 It is absurd to think that the calves are deprived. The calves need to be healthy to grow up to be healthy adults to continue growing the herd. Nobody who rears cattle deprives the calves of milk. Stop falling for silly superficial slogans.

    • @greatbalance
      @greatbalance 23 дні тому

      @@GST6647 "Stealing"??? LOL. This shows your lack of knowledge of basic biology. Have you heard of breast pumps for women? These are devices which help pump out the excess milk from breastfeeding women to give them relief. No baby, however healthy it is, can consume all the milk the mother produces. It is the same with cows. They need to be milked regularly otherwise they experience extreme discomfort, because the calves don't suck the milk dry from the cow.

    • @GST6647
      @GST6647 23 дні тому

      @greatbalance OK now I'm sure you've never been to an actual dairy farm or have any knowledge how this industry works. Male calves are directly sent go slaughthouses and other calves are given the bare minimum and a Ton of growth hormones to grow up quick so they can be impregnated for milk. These animals don't have any sort of exercise or quality of life and they're kept pregnant all their lives and are often sent pregnant to slaughterhouses pregnant too. They never get used to it or over it, they're in constant pain as they're bred to produce milk beyond their natural capacity. Producing dairy is resource intensive so even if the farmer wants to treat them better he/she can't as the milk prices are set aritifically low with supply from everywhere and they're incentivized to keep doing this to survive. Watch MA ka dhoodh documentary if you can't research and find out the truth for yourself.

  • @Batman67991
    @Batman67991 Місяць тому +19

    Who is vegan ❓ ✅😇🙏🏻
    👇🏻

  • @KP-lw3fh
    @KP-lw3fh Місяць тому

    Hi Arvind , Please guide us on how to explain to our kids about veganism..My baby is 3 yrs..It is so hard for me to keep her vegan..Every now and then somebody gives her a chocolate..even in her school..and in social gettogethers and birthday parties..it is so hard..Can you please help us with this..to help kids understand..and make them stay vegan when everyone around them is not

  • @starthere5665
    @starthere5665 19 днів тому +1

    In my village we leave cows outside the home and in the evening they come by themselves, and they also pregnant naturally,
    Yes it is possible it's not a fantasy at all 😸
    Focus more on reducing animal abuse rather than just making everyone vegan😑

  • @fsa88dd
    @fsa88dd Місяць тому +1

    this guy is trying very hard to prove himself right not giving the student any chance. Satvic milk is just the leftover milk and this guy should fight the capitalists which made this mess.
    stop fighting with the product start fighting with the manufacturer

  • @sinojthomas6056
    @sinojthomas6056 19 днів тому

    Don't eat just any cows, eat only the "holi" cows, it is very good for enlightenment.

  • @scbandla
    @scbandla Місяць тому +11

    Vegan is the western concept cow has been a integral part of our agricultural system. Milk was never a commodity dung was the most important by product. Only excess milk was taken. Ghee buttermilk milk was a integral part of our diet.

    • @prajwalmuralis2101
      @prajwalmuralis2101 Місяць тому

      yep it was, and then there was no capitalization. Its not a question of if you should leave your tradition, its a question of morals that have been passed down in our tradition of harming the animals. Now every industry is done for making money and by anymeans.

    • @Bl4ckheart
      @Bl4ckheart Місяць тому +4

      Just because something was, doesn't mean it should be now as well. It also doesn't mean it should have been in the first place. Do you also think sl4v3ry was integral and world couldn't have existed without it?

    • @thunderred5263
      @thunderred5263 Місяць тому

      Back then we barely had any food

    • @prajwalmuralis2101
      @prajwalmuralis2101 29 днів тому

      @@thunderred5263are you referring to invasion and colonial period?

  • @GovindaDevDas-Vision-Darshana
    @GovindaDevDas-Vision-Darshana Місяць тому +1

    And certainly you don’t need to be a billionaire to have ahimsa milk there are plenty of ahimsa Goshalas small and huge. Vegan propaganda doesn’t realise that India is the only civilisation that has sustainably demonstrated over millennia that a symbiotic and relationship is possible between all living beings. Modern societies are systems of exploration but the traditional system of taking care of cows and working with bulls and oxen has immense value and potential to counter the influence of Kali Yuga.

  • @AdirajThakur-kt1jk
    @AdirajThakur-kt1jk Місяць тому

    I really appreciate your work

  • @aks9817
    @aks9817 Місяць тому

    My question is that is it okay to buy non veg pet food for dogs and cats or it goes against veganism

    • @Vegan123
      @Vegan123 Місяць тому

      Cats are 'Obligate Carnivores'
      Dogs can have Vegan Food

    • @aks9817
      @aks9817 Місяць тому

      What about rescued animals ?​@@jaybolt100

  • @stillsimple-np7mc
    @stillsimple-np7mc 23 дні тому +2

    8:24 please at least leave our Lord Krishna out of your propaganda, he is lords of lord, if he would have been here, he would have 100% looked for solving the problem rather than doing what you're saying because he is God and he can do anything.
    And second thing, did you ever looked for solving this problem from it's root cause because what I've observed from you all people is that ultimately you want to let cows go extinct.
    Please, for whom you'll are working for? beef companies? Or anti Hindu/Indian culture man/community?

  • @subodhkumarpanda9
    @subodhkumarpanda9 26 днів тому

    No one pets a Bull in local villages...They roam freely....When cows heat up they roar High and people just tie her outside thier house if there a chance se mates...Otherwise the cow go grazing every day..They get fertile in the fields...There is no force involved....Nor there is any hurry for the farmer to make her fertile by artificial insemination...Is it okk??

  • @vinothyogesh2416
    @vinothyogesh2416 29 днів тому

    I think maintaining protein intake is very difficult for vegans because the bioavailability is less than meat. For example, if we take 8 gram from kidney beans, body will consume only 4 grams. DIAAS score for plant protein is so low. If the above comment is not correct, kindly let me know i will update my knowledge

    • @BrijeshBv
      @BrijeshBv 28 днів тому

      The DIAAS scores are usually calculated with Pigs as the reference animal. Not sure if we would get the exact same results on human beings as our digestive tracts are different. More importantly, look at outcome data. There are plenty of vegan body builders and athletes who perform very well at their chosen sport. Does it matter to the average person if they are getting the 2-5 % benefit they are deriving from animal protein vs plant protein ? That's a question each person should answer for themselves.

    • @vinothyogesh2416
      @vinothyogesh2416 28 днів тому

      If diaas score is calculated with pigs, could you attach the article or reference link that explains it. Vegan athletes are taking protein supplements to meet their nutritional requirements, but most people can’t do that. Just want to know how to meet the basic 50g of protein by being a vegan. As per the diaas score, we have to take around 80 to 90g of plant based protein to meet 40 to 50g of protein, but many people can’t eat that much even if they did it causes bloating for some person. I just want an explanation and i too don’t want abuse animals seriously.

    • @thunderred5263
      @thunderred5263 18 днів тому

      Yes a vegan diet needs supplementation it's not perfect but we have to do it

  • @onkarwandare5508
    @onkarwandare5508 Місяць тому +1

    We call cow mother and father his is go for cutting and what about buffalos and western type cow we dont call them mether

  • @TT-xg7qd
    @TT-xg7qd Місяць тому +1

    Calf should drink mother's milk with certain amount 2 litres or minimum otherwise calf may die because of indigestible one of my calf died because of that, so after calf drink the milk other amount of milk is for humans first understand it that's why cows are like second mother to us

    • @Vegan123
      @Vegan123 Місяць тому

      Calves do not die from drinking their mothers milk.

    • @TT-xg7qd
      @TT-xg7qd Місяць тому +1

      @@Vegan123 only cow owners know about it , first know about it and ask if u have a doubt, calf didn't know how much milk to consume so cow owners help calves to drink certain amount that calf able to walk and remain milk is for us..if more milk calves consume more motion it have and indigestion happen, because the cows farmers have are slective breeds that the cows own for milk first ask with others if u have doubt ....

  • @HimanshuSingh-yj2wh
    @HimanshuSingh-yj2wh 25 днів тому

    no that does not happen they leave the cow & bull alone if they breed otherwise this is not the time

  • @nkauvmeaern10121989
    @nkauvmeaern10121989 Місяць тому +8

    Satvik milk is a myth

    • @apsnapsn4700
      @apsnapsn4700 Місяць тому

      No it's not it's just difficult

  • @frozenwings6035
    @frozenwings6035 27 днів тому

    Can you make a video recommending vegan chocolates which will be healthy and tasty at same time

  • @Ridhi-r22
    @Ridhi-r22 26 днів тому

    Well said 👍👍

  • @vanshsahay8470
    @vanshsahay8470 13 днів тому

    I do not find this student a devout hindu and please dont take my words as insult or something i am just saying vegan like this person should once debate with scholars of hinduism for example iskcon and i am not saying this statement to demean veganism i just think that will be a very healthy and peaceful,logical debate

  • @vikrantdeshpande7190
    @vikrantdeshpande7190 18 днів тому

    Thanks

  • @BrijeshBv
    @BrijeshBv 28 днів тому

    Thanks!

  • @cnk8766
    @cnk8766 19 днів тому +1

    Arvind be like : I'm a proud vegan but I know which religion to question because I care for my head. 😀😀😀

    • @mastrmind3421
      @mastrmind3421 12 днів тому

      Andhbhakt aren't u?

    • @cnk8766
      @cnk8766 10 днів тому

      @@mastrmind3421 you're a andhbhakt of periyar, aren't you?😂

    • @mastrmind3421
      @mastrmind3421 6 днів тому

      @@cnk8766 bjp bhakts better not talk about periyar

  • @scbandla
    @scbandla Місяць тому +6

    There used to be community bulls in every village and naturally mating used to happen . The system is broken today. Without cows agriculture cannot happen, if humans stop consuming milk with that agriculture will also stop. The system has change u can't blindly say change to veganism

    • @Mayur_Kedare
      @Mayur_Kedare Місяць тому +2

      Cows are not used for agriculture and the cows should not be used, you can keep them but using them is wrong.

    • @shivamkukreja1991
      @shivamkukreja1991 26 днів тому +1

      @@scbandla ever heard of Tractors
      They have replaced cows

  • @sh4unity204
    @sh4unity204 14 днів тому

    Hi there fellow human. Let's take into consideration the possibility that vocal chords are just our form to measure pain. And with that understanding of a possibility. is killing another lifeform right? Plants don't scream. Let's rephrase. You are killing a living being know to you as a complex photosynthesizing organism that you have no understanding of it's frequency of pain that it may be producing upon the act of tearing itself from the soil for all we know. So vegans, scientifically what you don't know is always going to haunt you when you eat a plant. What will save you will always be the fact you do it, is for survival. Can any vegan give me an articulate answer ?

  • @AshishKumar-hs5ky
    @AshishKumar-hs5ky Місяць тому

    Don't know how many of you have seen Clarkson Farms, but Jeremy Clarkson is one person I have seen that allows his cows roam freely on his massive estate and the bulls impregnate the cows own their own will during their season. Up until this point what they do is Satvikk according to us Hindus but then they sell them off to a butcher for food. I loved the show until this point where they believe that by first caring and raising them with best possible means and then slaughtering them for meat is actually the good thing for the animals and as an additional benefit it provides food for humans. Utter ignorance.

  • @ritujoshi8478
    @ritujoshi8478 18 днів тому

    Sir please make the video in Hindi also 🙏🙏🙏

  • @user-le5hj2si8j
    @user-le5hj2si8j 20 днів тому

    What about the poor people do , do they able to afford vegan😢

  • @_MahiRudra
    @_MahiRudra 26 днів тому

    Hey, Arvind bro I request you to please listen to Acharya Prashant to learn the exact meaning of yugas and I hope you will find that helpful❤

  • @jok3r335
    @jok3r335 Місяць тому +1

    watching this while drinking a cup of coffee with cheese toast is bliss....

    • @shoban1520
      @shoban1520 Місяць тому +5

      Provided it's vegan cheese and milk or the cheese and milk was made from breast milk provided by a willing human mother.

    • @Mayur_Kedare
      @Mayur_Kedare Місяць тому +2

      @@shoban1520 He is not ignorant, he knows what he is doing. He is stupid. Stupid means dismissive of evidence or argument. He is knows the truth, sees the truth but still believes the lies. No need to feed the trolls, they are just cancer waiting to spread stereotypes about those who are willing to do a genuine conversation.

    • @shoban1520
      @shoban1520 Місяць тому +2

      @@Mayur_Kedare Just a matter of time, Mayur. Nature has upped her game.

    • @Peacewithin97
      @Peacewithin97 Місяць тому

      @@Mayur_KedareBasically if you are choosing to die out of starvation go ahead why you want everyone to follow your fate
      For a common man in India being healthy on a plant based diet is next to impossible u need to diversify your diet we are evolved as an omnivore The cognitive ability that we have today is because we started consuming animal based product We may not consume flesh today fine but atleast some eggs and milk are necessary to lead a healthy life completely switching to plant based diet will be a catostrophe for human being unless you are ultra rich

    • @Mayur_Kedare
      @Mayur_Kedare Місяць тому

      @@Peacewithin97 I need evidence for your claim for the following statements:
      1. "For a common man in India being healthy on a plant based diet is next to impossible"
      2. "The cognitive ability that we have today is because we started consuming animal based product"
      3. "...some eggs and milk are necessary to lead a healthy life completely switching to plant based diet will be a catostrophe for human being unless you are ultra rich"
      You seem to allude that it is necessary for optimal health but I need evidence. If you don't provide I can dismiss whatever you said since it is the cheapest as traditional homemade food and veg thali is cheap and healthiest from outcome data.

  • @KP-lw3fh
    @KP-lw3fh Місяць тому

    Would love to see you and one of the iskcon gurus talk about this..I love everything about iskcon..but they use dairy in every prasadam..I want to hear what is their say about all this..They are doing bhakti and someone has to be right and someone has to be wrong..Would be nice if you could present all these facts in front of them

  • @Thedigitalalex
    @Thedigitalalex Місяць тому +1

    Vegans have lost it.

  • @SeriousPreparation-h1p
    @SeriousPreparation-h1p 16 днів тому

    Thanks guys, we r left with more meat😋

  • @scienceislove2014
    @scienceislove2014 Місяць тому

    For those considering a vegan lifestyle cuz you're a compassionate being but not really knowing where to start.. I've got you covered..
    You don't really know what you can eat now that you've ditched meat and dairy..
    It can be quite confusing and intimidating even for those who didn't really care about what they were putting into their bodies prior to going vegan..
    If you're indian..you already eat a plant centered diet..so it's dairy for us..
    So if you , you the Indian , don't wanna support the cruel dairy industry..but still wanna avoid burning a hole in your pocket.. you can start with a simple meal plan.. a low budget but highly nutritious meal plan... Gather every dish you consider healthy..and then ..well... we'll get to that in a while..
    But first let's talk about two essential nutrients.. vit b12 and d3 ...
    If you don't get out in the sun for atleast 25-30 mins 3-4 times a week.. you're doomed to suffer from d3 deficiency...even CARNIVORES (humans ofc) struggle to meet their vit d requirements from food alone.. they can hardly hit 15 percent.. so.. you should either supplement every once a week or step out in the sun a bit more often..
    Now comes b12 ... You can either take shots (that's what I do..like every alternate month) or take pills every once a week .. and this is natural and safe..but be careful with fat soluble vitamins like vit D ...so it would be better if you talked to your doc before taking vit d (as they'll give you adequate dosage..) ... B12 is totally safe tho..
    Or you can take axbex or zincovit (multivitamin..) .. pop in a multi and you're set for the day.. this is especially important for pre-meds (or students) like me ...busy people ...
    Here goes the food.. this is what works for our household ..cuz these are our staples..
    Protein sources-
    Chickpeas
    Soy chunks (this is cheap and healthy..and has anti cancer properties..well anything soy has anti cancer properties except for soy bean oil)
    Soy bean/tofu.
    Beans like kidney beans or mung bean
    Lentils (a mix of lentils)
    Quinoa (quinoa is cheap.. and very healthy..)
    Amaranth (i buy muesli from peepal farm)
    Millets (Indians love millet..these are not particularly high in protein but they're amazing)
    Chia seeds (not just protein but amazing fats as well...but be sure to soak em)
    Flax seeds (these are literally superfoods..)
    Green peas
    Hemp seeds (we don't use it but they're really good)
    Tempeh (i don't have access to these but again ... they're so good)
    Legumes or Pulses in general are so good for you..
    Nuts and seeds (amazing protein and fats .)
    Greens -
    Cabbage/cauliflower/brocoli/Brussel sprouts (if available)
    Leafy greens like spinach or kale
    Beet root
    Carrots
    Cucumber
    Amla (it's a fruit but they're the best. Period)
    Bell pepper 🫑
    Bitter gourd
    And the list goes on and on..
    Be sure to eat regional vegetabls cuz India is pretty diverse ...so eat your greens..and go local ...
    Peanut butter (peepal farm)
    Try to incorporate more colour into your food ....or maybe give permaculture ... Or give permaculture a shot if you have the time..and space..
    Dishes i eat..
    Dosa (this is my fave )
    Lentil curry with rice
    Rajma chawal
    Idli sambhar
    Indian version of chilli (that has chickpeas , rajma , ground soy chunks , carrots , bell pepper, 🍅 tomatoes, etc)
    Yellow pea chat
    Litti chokha
    Soy bean biryani
    Soy bean ki sabzi (i eat lil to no oil)
    Chana masala (chickpea curry)
    Oat porridge with apples and bananas and chia seed on top
    Indian version of chilli (that has soy chunks , Pinto beans or white rajma , chickpeas , bell pepper 🫑, carrots , onion and garlic 🧄, indian spices, some soy sauce, tomato puree..and a bunch of other healthy ingredient..this can double as bhaji for pav bhaji)
    Quinoa oat cinnamon banana porridge without any milk.. you could add some chia or nuts of your choice..
    Black mung daal seasoned with salt
    South Indian style besan tofu sauted in curry leaves and mustard seeds with sauce..
    Chola chana chaat with aloo ki tikki .. (we make it bland cuz we like it bland..)
    Flax seed and jaggery dumplings
    Red lentil uttapam
    Yellow pea chat
    (Quinoa+daliya+millet+rice) mung bean khichdi with added veggies
    Daal
    Dhokla
    Pakal tofu paneer
    Mushroom biryani
    Oat dense chocolate fudge cake (dessert 😁)
    Mix veg soy bean sabzi (quite runny....pretty similar to a soup.. but very tasty.. i like bland stuff )
    High protein muesli ...
    Tofu scramble (we eat homemade tofu.. )
    Quinoa raita with (peanuts+cabbage+carrot+apples) and other temperings .. we use soy yogurt the one prepared at home...from scratch..cuz i don't use store bought food items / convenient foods into my body..unless I'm starving
    These were the dishes i grew up eating.. so it can be different for you.. so prepare a chart of essentials..
    I make sure that i eat atleast two servings of protein rich dish (any two.. like it can be chana masala in the morning and khichdi for lunch or dinner)

  • @shivangityagi6701
    @shivangityagi6701 Місяць тому +1

    Don't act stupid...it's like if you can care for that whole family of the animal...you can milk them...they are animals not humans who care much...even the baby boy of that same cow after being to a certain age will help reproduce...milk is so much required...if you care for that whole family it's ok...but if you cannot..just go vegan!

  • @blvckluv3877
    @blvckluv3877 12 днів тому

    People who caring plants so much saying they feel pain, are killing millions of animals and birds everyday

  • @sangeetthegreat5719
    @sangeetthegreat5719 25 днів тому

  • @Rohith25-e1o
    @Rohith25-e1o Місяць тому

    "Hey buddy, I have a good suggestion: hit the gym, continue your vegan diet, build some muscle, look good, and you'll observe an impactful change. You can promote and prove that you can build muscle and a body even with vegan food. Nowadays, youth are more concerned with body and fitness strength, and I want you to be an example. And if you manage to build noticeable muscle and a good physique, I'll honestly try to turn vegan... and I'll convince my friends to turn vegan too."

  • @skmemes931
    @skmemes931 Місяць тому

    I am watching this video while eating....you know.

  • @jamesanthony8234
    @jamesanthony8234 Місяць тому +2

    what do you mean its not possible?, you grow plants on your farm? you dont have to be a billionaire. This Aravind dude has clearly not worked on a farm, ive worked on many farms and natural pregnant cows happen all the time.

  • @tej7282
    @tej7282 Місяць тому +1

    So ur saying natural conceptions in cows are not frequent.. 😂😂How do you think they have survived in the wild naturally for thousands of years

    • @Vegan123
      @Vegan123 Місяць тому

      They didn't- we have bred them and bred traits that we wanted.

    • @tej7282
      @tej7282 Місяць тому

      @@Vegan123 since when

  • @avadhootv
    @avadhootv Місяць тому

    I am not a vegan, but I can see logic in arvinds argument. He respects individuality of a cow while the person who asked the question thinks of a cow as a god, yet thinks care he provides is what is needed by the cow. In actuality it is the care provided to keep cow happy to be producing milk. It is exploitative.

    • @GST6647
      @GST6647 Місяць тому

      @avadhootv, Hi, friend. So why haven't you considered being vegan then?

    • @avadhootv
      @avadhootv Місяць тому

      @@GST6647 It can never stop, you have to draw a boundary somewhere even as a vegan. I am not conflicted enough yet to push it towards being vegan.

    • @GST6647
      @GST6647 Місяць тому

      @avadhootv what you're saying is called appeal to futility. And you'd never apply that to any other area of your life. For example you'd never say sexual assault will never stop let me take part of it as well. If you think about it, animal abuse is easier to phase out than sexual assault, corporations and universities estimate a number of assault cases each year and put aside some money to deal with them because it's not in their power to prevent it. And yet no sensible human says this is not preventable let me take part of it. Let's also look at the claim the other claim, is it really true that it'll never stop? Most of what arvind talks about is modern animal agriculture only started a decades back to feed an increasingly meat eating world, and if we continue this from an environmental perspective our species has no future so we must phase it out at some point. Our diet has always been changing based on the circumstances throughout history. People must've looked at slavery and thought this sort of exploitation will never stop why attempt to stop it, but now it's outlawed, if you think about it, most people despise cruelty towards animals so we can't pre decide anything yet. If you think about everything we have righy now, right from the right to vote, to womens education, to literal freedom and independence for us indians. its because someone imagined a better future and fought against what was normal and accepted by the public. Let's say it is true that humanity will continue to exploit, torture animals for long as it lives, as a non vegan some set of animals every year are being made to go through this and it makes no difference to them whether this is happening at a massive scale, or if it will happen to other animals too. They just want it to stop. If you think of it from the victims perspective, it's happening at a large scale and to others too isn't an explanation that makes it better for them.
      It makes the life of a difference to the animals who you don't consume literally. You would be making a real difference by standing up for what you believe is right, leave the world aside.

    • @avadhootv
      @avadhootv Місяць тому

      @@GST6647 I really appreciate your commitment. Currently I work with tribals, fishers, cattle headers who consume meat and dairy. I don't think they are evil or immoral. Infact their practices are deeply rooted in ecology and evolution. They are either apex predators, or because of their hearding activities they maintain local ecosystems. I agree with your point of big commercial modernized ranches and I do avoid meat from such places. But whats cruelty to you is sustainable livelihood for many. Till I am working with them I will live with their moral code. Thats why I said yet. May be in future, if I am not working with them, I will be happy to become vegan.

  • @pollyannamacintosh786
    @pollyannamacintosh786 Місяць тому +1

    Either be non vegetarian or vegan. If you are vegetarian, especially so called Sanatan vegetarian, it leads to a habit of lying like that questioner in the video.

  • @vegan_vignettes
    @vegan_vignettes 26 днів тому

    2:22 Arvind, I'm of the opinion that exploitation is the 'use' of an animal or secretion for your own benefit. So even if you take 'what's left' after the calf drinks their fill, you have exploited the animal.
    If a kid is selling lemonade on the side of the road and sells 9 of the 10 drinks with one left over that you know will not be sold. It would be exploitative to go up and take that last cup. It is not your cup. You have not been given consent to take the cup, you are USING the products of her labor, you have benefited off the work or ability of someone else.
    If the cow does not consent to you taking the last little bit of milk (she can't consent) then it's exploitation.
    When you say "she doesn't mind and you take it" I think that is making a massive assumption of the cow there. Just like if the little girl just stood there as I walked off with the last cup of lemonade and I said "she didn't mind"... (she didn't put up a fight/she didn't protest)
    What do you think?

  • @mowleeshward5375
    @mowleeshward5375 29 днів тому

    Thumbnail is bit of a stretch

  • @skmemes931
    @skmemes931 Місяць тому

    Wow, humans are comparing themselves with animals. Great. Point to be noted.

  • @ravitejkv2915
    @ravitejkv2915 Місяць тому +1

    👍🙏