Pratik Borade is not really a film reviewer. He is merely a right wing extremist who analyses and divides every film into Left, neutral or right. He bashes the film if its 'left' or 'neutral' according to him.
@@Tintin_Quarntinousme aur dhruv rathee mein koi antar nahin hain...... Main bhi leftist logon se nafrat karta hoon lekin Pratik jaisa nahin hoon...... Jab use Tumbadd pasand nahin aaya tha toh woh uski choice thi maana...... Lekin Kantara ko Tumbadd se compare karke Jo woh kar rahan tha woh galat tha........ Dekho dono hi achhi movies hain....... Kantara aur Tumbadd dono mujhe pasand aayi lekin woh apni galti chhupane ke liye Tumbadd ka image barbaad kar rahan tha.....
I am with you on this brother, and I have no problem in calling out religious dogmatism as long as its not one sided. Indian film industry is replete with examples where "Hindu" religious dogmatism have been called out - and it should be, no two way about it. I wish we could say the same things about how the dogmatism of Abrahamic religions have been portrayed in Indian cinema. Unfortunately everybody including Ray might have weighed in the implications of "Fatwa" and "Hellfire" that would have followed suit and as a result played safe with their art. I would rather adopt the French style of liberalism in cultural transformation (read Charlie Hebdo) than the Communist style that thrive on selective affiliation. Till then the Pratiks of the World will have enough ammunition to flourish with their propaganda. Sad state of affairs indeed.
at least you are the only guy who raised a voice about this selective outrage in the name of protecting this so called 'secuparism' and 'progressiveness'. from my pov, pratiks are the outcome of selective narrative of secularism run by bong intellectuals and academicians. these guy always ignored the much more toxic dogmatism of abrahamic faiths, as a result radical hinduism came forward to fill this void as a repercussion.
Agree with you guys, I don't understand why can't people think and understand of their own what is happening and what should happen. Perhaps there is a scarcity of people like this, and this is the same reason why we don't find ourselves a group to thrive our thoughts. Every contemporary side is flawed and needs to get checked.
@@SuperBooboohaha Also Prithviraj Sukumaran starer Adam Joan.. But they are less in no, that's is also a reality.. But yes particularly in Malayalam film industry We can find this type of movies
@@subhaschandrabosekijay4130 Intellectuals are critical of religion , in west you will find movies like Life of Brian , angels and demons so on . Most screenwriters in bollywood are non abrahamics, they will criticize what is familiar to them therefore crooked babas are a trope . In malayalam you will find many catholic writers and directors ( their background is evident from their names ) hence you will find catholic priests as embodiment of greed , power etc. Unlike bollywood movies malayalam won't express it blatantly , you have to read the subtext .It's pretty absurd to claim that 'only Hindus are the target ' Director or the screen writer is using the world which is familiar to them to make a larger or a universal point .
@@hrishikesh07m the child actor who played the role of Mini in Kabuliwala was Oindrila Thakur, sister of Sharmila thakur. Hence, Apur Samsar was her first film.
@@arafbhuiyan4417 The director of Jurassic Park, Steven Spielberg made a Movie named ET in 1982 which had strikingly similar story line with a cancelled Ray movie which he was about to make in Hollywood with paramount studios, called "the Alien" in 1967.
@@rahulghosh9528 hey man I just that The Director of Jurassic Park inspired from Satyajit Ray & what is masala film Martin Scorsese will never understand this word 🤣🤣
If 'Ganashatru' released today, Pratik type of person could have shouted out for banning it. So as for Mahapurush, Devi even 'Hirak Rajar Deshe'. Satyajit Ray was a fearless creator. Pratik should watch his work before commenting. He was extremely progressive. He was even being attacked by Right wingers in his time as well. In one of his interviews he in fact said it very clearly. He was the God of progressive thinking in his personal life and in his creations.
Satyajit Ray is just not a legend,he is an emotion ,can't compare him with anyone else......................................................................................
যারা সত্যজিৎ রায় পড়েনি, শোনেনি, দেখেনি সবথেকে বড় কথা যারা বোঝেনি তারা ওনার ব্যাপারে " সঠিক " বলবে কি করে? তিনি সত্যজিৎ রায়। আমাদের কাছে ওই নামটাই যথেষ্ট ওনার যেকোন কাজ দেখার জন্য।
Pratik review is an opinion and so is urs.... I dislike Ray because they mutilated the stories. We need to counter Religious Dogmatism. Ray himself mentioned in his interview that his film " Devi " was criticized badly by a segment of people which he himself referred as " religious dogmatism". But, on flip-side of coin Religious Dogmatism is not specific to " Hindu " religion. The issue is in recent pop culture films r always putting Hindu dogmatism under spot light and at the same time giving free pass to other religion. This will hurt religious sentiment of few. Pratik is one of such. I believe we need to counter religious dogmatism as a whole. Bashing one and giving free pass to another will cause disparity and division.
Please Don't waste time on him. Trust me he don't deserve. I always watch his video just to laugh. Becoz kiya bolne wlaa hai wo to maloom hi hai. Wo same hi hoga always.
Pehli baat har koi Pratik ke tarah nahin hota.... Bahut kam log Prateek ko jaante hain...... Main bhi thoda bahut BJP ko support karta hoon . Mujhe bhi BJP achha lagta hain lekin Pratik Borade, Akash Banerjee jaise log pasand nahin jo film critics ke naam pe politics kare...... Ab Akash Banerjee bhi thoda bahut films ke baare mein batata hain....... Toh andhbhakt kahna band kijiye......
pratik himself speak in beginning that whatever he speaks is HIS opinion not you called his opinion propaganda. so according to you why should not we call RAY movie a fully propaganda ??. if Bengali does it then it's ART. but when pratik does it, then it's propaganda.
Pratik thinks that sexism, homosexuality, any kind of discrimination etc are a part of some "propaganda" and not the reality. He even has a problem with sexual liberation 😂 What do you expect from such a rigid and conservative person?
@@shishirsrivastava976 Tumhare dilme kya bachpan se hi Bangaliyon ke khilaaf nafrat hai kya? Inta takleef kyun hai tumko? Tumko Satyajit Ray aur unke filmon se ghanta bhar ka bhi matlab nahi hai.
After watching your video, I saw his review on RAY. Where did he disdained SATYAJIT RAY sir?? He tried to counter the things done by the directors who adapted his stories , he didn't like it , he said it with points. What's wrong in it?? And when there were no such elements in THE SATYAJIT RAY's work ,how dare they make such changes?? Are they of SATYAJIT RAY'S level?? And I always see you finding problems in his review. Some times I agree, but you always try to project him in a bad light. When he did Hindu-Muslim?? He majorly counters communist ideology and the breaking india forces. What's wrong in it?? I don't know about him. But I have seen you sharing fake news regarding CAA. You made video stating that muslim will lose citizenship through CAA. Please tell that how many Muslims have lost citizenship because of CAA, which has got no relevance with INDIANS?? First you should be doing your Homework properly before commenting on others. First you were the ones who made fun of him became he talks about ignored pains of Hindus and the rampant HINDUPHOBIA of bollywood, later you only had to agree with him when you reviewed LEILA on Netflix. So please stop your drama. We very well know your political inclination, when I saw your RRR controversy video where you tried to play pseudo-secularism card. PLEASE STOP THIS
@@indiandaredevil7497 ohh so everything the authority said is false or rather fraud🤦♂️🤦♂️ My god🤦♂️ If you are ARITRA's blind follower then I won't be wasting my efforts, but if not then please go through the video of LEILA review first where he mentioned about Pratik Borade And the author said that these directors are not even close to the mastery of SATYAJIT RAY, that is also false or by your language"FRAUD"? If that is so, then only GOD can save you Edit: And I forgot to mention that even SATYAJIT RAY's son SANDIP RAY expressed his discontentment with the film, now don't tell SANDIP RAY is narrow minded
I have lived in Bengal since my birth. The guy in the video is just another "Progressive" Bengali who just sits and judges people and misleads others into believing Indians are dumb and regressive. Never fall into the trap of following such people, who try to portray that they are above all and clarify their path to righteousness.
Absolutely right to say for Pratik barode, Pratik bhai har cheezh main dharam ko daal dete hai, woh asaram ke bhakt hai woh unke liye accha hai jo jail main hai,
@@RajeshSarkar-so3veif you want some examples ...APJ abdul kalam, begom rokeya, kaji najrul Islam, AR rahaman, Mohammad Rafi, Javed Akhtar, SRK, Gulam Nabi, Abdul kalam Azadd, Gaffar khan, Murshid kuli khan, Zakir hussain, ......
No reviewer ( non- Bengali) talks about Satyajit Ray or his work .... Pratik did. His review on Apu triology .. ua-cam.com/video/nigS6z6z5Zo/v-deo.html Bengali chara rest of the India Satyajit Ray ke vulei jachhe.... at least he's trying to spread the word. Review ta loker personal opinion..... ote oto amol deoar kichu nei ..... in Ray they mutilated the stories as well as Characters.. They should have called it DEY instead of RAY
Listen. I don't agree with Borade but he can have his opinion bro. Even if it's a Political opinion. He might just get offended that's it. Note:Ray sir have talk in a interview how some people fool in the name of religion and how it's affecting artistic freedom.
@@Optimisticglory27 that's he is replying. Borade knows he will lost this argument that's why he will continue to ignore him. At the end.. Our Aritras time lose. That guy will gonna call out buy a lot of people. His controversial opinion has a long list. Until then wait end watch.
Pratik borade never saw Satyajit Ray's movies like Devi, Ganashatru and Jai Baba felunath...if he had saw those movies he would have known how much Satyajit Ray hated religious blind faiths
@Nandini Sen see they are free to come,live and work in our state.We love all Indians and UP,Bihar people are our brothers, but they should think twice before insulting fellow Indians...Jai Hind
satyjit ray he is very great person And honestly say ray series in Netflix Represent very bad way I know you also know that If this series given a better director nd without propaganda Then it will be very better This ray series represent very bad way to our legend satyjit ray sir
Sabash dada...etai dorkar chilo, amio age onek age or video dekhtam jokhon o actually review korto, ekta time er por theke propaganda cholte thake, jeta ekdom e posay na...ei answer er dorkar chilo
You are absolutely right brother... He is most Casteist person on the UA-cam, Jo koi bhi movie aur web series me Religion wala angle daal hi dete hai, Us borade ne Sarappta movie me Jo Sc St caste Ka Jo angle hai usey wo chubh Gaya....
@@subhasisbhattacherjee5202 thik bolechhen....r sudhu ekhane noi Bollywood e chirokal Hindu dhormo ke chhoto and muslimder mohan,osohai hisebe dekhano hoyechhe. Lokkho kore dekhben 90% Bollywood cinema r villian Hindu character dekhano hoy
exactly.. That's why I unsubscribed her channel long back and reported several after realising she connects max review with RELIGION. 😂 Now I connect with your words bro.. 👍👍 Your thoughts match with me
Let Pratik do his review and you do yours. What's your problem? :) opinions may differ and you don't need to defend anyone. Also, Srijit, despite being closest to Bengal... did the worst with Ray's stories compared to the two other directors. His work was very dark and Ray's work always had more 'rays' (light).
Aritra take a look at ur comments section..... u will find the issue with our society as well as ur & Pratik's review. People r fighting over BJP & TMC , Modi - Didi & Hindu-Muslim. In the name of protesting intolerance we have become intolerant towards any ideology which we r not familiar. Pratik's review is JUST HIS OPINION . So is urs. By creating another video in his reply what u achieved is NOTHING BUT CREATRING MORE DIVISION across people...... Also u didn't mention what Sandip Ray mentioned about this movie "RAY". For your info he mentioned " I am scared now to what this movie as I dont know to what extend they have rutilated my father's stories ".
How many stories of Shri Satyajit Ray where he used " Race Course Gamble " , " fraud" , " Cheating " ," Alcohol " , Bikers Gang, etc etc . Entire Shanku Series highly affected by scam and cheating of a person . sometimes reconstruct of old story with modern aspect is good for survival .
Jo baba wle me changes hn to jb ek jgh galat dikhaya hi tha to jisme shi dikhana tha wahaan kyu dharm badal dya... To bdla to dharm k basis pe hi to uspe baat kyu nahi kri ja skti uspe...bht si news hti hn jisme culprit dusre dharm ka hta h or photo me dusre dharm ki pic lgi hti h to koi bole bhi na iske baare me¿
that's why they call bihari people "HINDUSTANI" . they are sooooooooo open minded that they consider themselves ahead of India. their mindset are closed inside their state. I am not talking about all. but people like you are same
Even Satyajit Ray in an interview with Sanjib Chatterjee himself told that many stories of Feluda are not up to his mark... because he had to use the same plot everytime revolving around murder, theft or property conflicts to keep his work restricted to younger readers... In fact he disclosed that he had many brilliant crime plots regarding relationship conflicts and sexual violence issues but could never write it down otherwise Feluda series would become adult literature... Which he never wanted to do... So not all of his Felu stories are brilliant... he himself disclosed this...
Dear Aritra I saw Pratik borade review and no where in his review he has portrayed Satyajit ray in wrong light . He is just highlighting how Ray's story are shown with maker/director propoganda . *U tell me in Beharupiya in original story If it was a sadhu in Netflix adoptation why Peer is shown*?
@@sauron2000000 big or small that matters to the individual, so wat Pratik borade said is why the change at first place forget it will be issue or no . U tell me wen the maker paid one person for the role spent money on costume dialogue filming everything they did then why change the character ?
একদম correct বলেছ দাদা। আমি আগে pratik borade এর review দেখতাম। কিন্তু প্রায় 1 বছর হলো দেখা ছেড়ে দিয়েছি ঠিক একই কারণের জন্য। সব কিছুতে হিন্দু মুসলিমের topic টেনে আনে। ও movie review channel না খুলে কোনো religion channel খুললে কাজে দিত।
@Saptarshi Sikhism hindu se hi bana hai ...yaha sab mil kr rehte h ... Koi dikkat nhi h sikh logo ko ...hum gurudwara jate h wo mandir ate hai .,.. aur jinko problem h wo brainwashed ho chuke h .. history nahi jante h ...
But his son sandip Ray himself was extremely unhappy with the portrayal of his father's stories. Pratik borade never Insulted the great Satyajit ray in any manner, he just criticized the portrayal of his stories in the anthology. These people are just using Satyajit ray's name to hide behind the show's mediocrity
বাল। সন্দীপ রায় রে সিরিজের চিত্রনাট্যকে পছন্দ করেনি, কারণ গল্পগুলোকে অধিকাংশই বদলিয়েছে। আর ওই ছাগলমার্কা বহিরাগত হিন্দুস্তানির বাচ্ছাটা এটাকে সম্পূর্ণরূপে ধর্মীয় অ্যাঙ্গেলে টেনে এনে বালজেপি/বালএসএসের প্রোপাগান্ডা প্রচার করেছে। আর এটা ও প্রত্যেকটা ভিডিওতেই করে।
@@a___c_t_g তোর বাবার দেশ নাকি এটা বোকাচোদা?? আর বহিরাগত মানে জানিস গান্ডু?? বহিরাগত কাকে বলে সেটা আগে পড়াশুনা করে জেনে আয় মূর্খচোদার বাচ্ছা, তারপরে কমেন্ট করবি। আর হ্যাঁ, বাংলা আলাদা হলেই ভালো হত। অন্তত বহিরাগত গোবলীয় হিন্দুস্তানি অপসংস্কৃতি আর ভাষার সাম্রাজ্যবাদ থেকে বাংলা ভাষা আর সংস্কৃতি রক্ষা পেয়ে যেত।
Bhai pratik borade ki baat hi na bolo. Usse har chiz mein dharm aur politics ghusana aata he bas. Pehle baht dekhta tha uska video, ab jab bhi recommendation mein aata he to 'not interested' kar k chhod deta hu😂.
Pratik borade রিভিউ মানেই হিন্দু মুসলিম, কংগ্রেস বিজিপি হেন তেন সে পলিটিক্যাল ভিডিও বানালেই পারে। মুভির মধ্যেও ধর্ম ছাড়া উনি কিছু টেনে অানতে পারেন না। অার নিজেকে বলে মুভি ক্রিটিক্স
Ben can't make any sense or a good web series...so they will come and defame Hindi series... Just ignore them...let them criticise...end of the day they also consume Hindi content and it helps our Hindi entertainment sector.
Ekhane Amar ekta problem ache, je Satyajit Ray kintu superpower e bishashi chilen, mane jetake bhogoban mana hoy, shetai uni bishash korten, but hoyto bhogoban bole dakten na. What he was fully against, was Religious Dogmatism, mane religion r through diye manush ke boka banano, and misuse of power, shetao dekhbe manik dadu r onek movies, stories eo ache.
Kya tum BHI wahi kar rhe same wo Hindu Muslim krta h tum Bengali Bengali kar rhe, WB India me h ki India me WB h, HM use Sahi NHI bol rhe par agr wo glt to tum BHI glt ho, Wo religion KO btata h tum state bta rhe country unity ki toh koi baat hi NHI kar rha
Basically Pratik Borade is not an open-minded person to accept creative items as they are.. He does not understand technicalities as well.. He only pushes his thoughts in his videos.. In past, I used to follow him but unfollowed that fellow.. He praises few Bengali items and authors only to collect views.. He basically mislead people.. Last time I watched his review on 'Money Heist' and it was just impossible and unbearable.. It was so brilliantly made.. But watch his review please.. If people cannot take a creative piece of fiction as it is made and always correlate it with practical life, political views and religious views after some time it becomes unbearable.. That person may need some careful attention of a Doctor I guess.. He should atleast make atleast a brilliant creative piece before using such words..
So you can criticize anyone for mistepresenting a Bengali icon but Prateek can't criticize others for mistepresenting hindu icons??? Stop being so hypocritical...
@@കേരളബ്ലാസ്റ്റേഴ്സ്ബ്ലാസ്റ്റേ Bro maybe not in this series... But there are loads of other movies in which they have been misrepresented... Check out gemsofbollywood twitter account just once...
@@കേരളബ്ലാസ്റ്റേഴ്സ്ബ്ലാസ്റ്റേ And btw Pratik didn't say anything bad about Satyajit Ray in any of his videos... He quoted what Satyajit Ray's son and his viewers were commenting... Many Bengali people who don't even understand hindi are spreading hate in his comment section mindlessly...
Satyajit Ray এর ব্যাপারে যখন ওর ভিডিও তে কমেন্ট করতে গেলাম, তখন আমাকে অ্যান্টি হিন্দু বলে লম্বা একটা paragraph রিপ্লাই দিচ্ছে। মানে আজব তো, যেকোনো লজিকের অ্যান্টি লজিক ওর কাছে অ্যান্টি হিন্দু 🙄
@Saptarshi নর্থ ইন্ডিয়ার নয়ডা,গুরগাও এর ধারে কাছে ঘেষার সামর্থ্য আছে তোদের? একবার নিজেদের সাথে ওদের মাথাপিছু আয়, এফ ডি আই তুলনা করে দেখিস, এরপর দেখবি কারা পিছিয়ে আর কারা এগিয়ে।
Ek right wing youtuber ne tum logo ki sulaga rakhi hai.wo tum logo ko ghass nhi daalta lekin tum aur charcha with bhurani wala totla uske naam pe views bator lete ho🤣.aaj video dekho kitne jyada views mile honge tumhe pratik ke naam pe .aur mera comment mat delete kar dena
His each vedio is heavily backed by ....evidences ......u don't have any comparison to his entelect .....aur Satyajit ray work is genius artist .... Aur Bengal ke baare me pura hindustan janta hai ....
Just becoz he glorifies his country his religion and was is not a liberal and so called secular like you that doesn't means he is right , you always try to take views on his name 😂😂😂😂 that's what his position is 🔥
"The second, the necessity to keep an eye on the censors, rather than causing despair, should in fact encourage subtlety of expression. It may, after all, be more fun to imply intimacy rather than to display it." - Satyajit Ray
What you said is okay! But in that sense then you are also spreading propagandas that films like Satyamev Jayate are jingoistic, Although I agree that it's a bad franchise..criticize the film naah, why you are touching the philosophical aspect like Pratik Borade... I reminded you this in case if you forgot or trying to be a hypocrite idk. And adding to that, we all know that sex, violence and vulgarity is present in every society... But there is no such thing that we are bound to promote it. Does a progressive society means that we should accept films which intentionally shows sex scenes and vulgarities to gather the audience??? Do reply Aritra Da BTW your short film (NAXAL) was amazing. 👍
Have you seen any of Ray's films ? Either you didn't get Aritra's point and misinterpreting it or you actually have misconceptions about it. Films which intentionally shows sex scenes and vulgarities... are made in Alt Balaji or Ullu... If the scene requires metaphorical representation of sex or violence it should be shown. If a scene contents the Society of a slum or lower class people or Gang muffias or College ingenious , vulgar Language can be used. And if you're progressive enough you'll get the context... not the propaganda. If you're progressive enough you'll see the truths not the propaganda.
@@samanwaychakraborty5802 what seems progresssiveness to you is actually a subtle ignorance that bangla intellectual fed you for years. your progressiveness will not come to save you when a particular community will change the demography of your locality and then intimidate through loud speaker that 'convert or die'. on that day, the guys whom you address 'gutkhakhor' will somehow be able to save themselves but you 'liberals' will fall into trap and gonna sacrifice your mother and sister. that day is not very distant.
@@samanwaychakraborty5802 you people are progressive yet on verge of become Bangladesh 🤣trust me ek din aayega jab tum bhaag bhaag ke aaoge assam,up,jharkhand, karnataka jab ye so called progressive film makers tumhe bachane nhi aayenge kyonki they will run to some other countries
@@a___c_t_g wo din dur nhi hai.it happened with Sikh people in jammu, it happened in few localities of up and it will definitely happen in Bengal. Bengali hindu exodus will happen just like 1990 Kashmir Pandit exodus
Thik ache tai bole muslim der o support kora bondo kora uchit....ora to aro conservative...mea der burkha te rakhe..and plz muslims are not open minded be it bengali or urdu muslim....mea der kono adhikar nei..
Perfect reply. I always believed Pratik's movie reviews are less about the movie and more about political propaganda. Kudos to you brother.
Best Roaster = Bad Villager 🌋
Pratik Borade is not really a film reviewer. He is merely a right wing extremist who analyses and divides every film into Left, neutral or right. He bashes the film if its 'left' or 'neutral' according to him.
Bhai mene pratik bhai ko ek suggestions diya tha Review ko lekar tho pratik bhai ne mujhe hi ban kardala va bhai va itni giri hui harkat 😒
@@Tintin_Quarntinousme aur dhruv rathee mein koi antar nahin hain...... Main bhi leftist logon se nafrat karta hoon lekin Pratik jaisa nahin hoon...... Jab use Tumbadd pasand nahin aaya tha toh woh uski choice thi maana...... Lekin Kantara ko Tumbadd se compare karke Jo woh kar rahan tha woh galat tha........ Dekho dono hi achhi movies hain....... Kantara aur Tumbadd dono mujhe pasand aayi lekin woh apni galti chhupane ke liye Tumbadd ka image barbaad kar rahan tha.....
Pratikji's review of Ghare Baire:
Satyajit Ray ek Vikrut Mansikta ke Urban Naxal the🤣🤣🤣👍
Bhai dekh or pinned comment ami comment kotechi o r ekta Logan Paul fan boy ki senseless reply korche amy ja tah
Ghare baire film hai ya story?
@@thesheldoncooper Film. Based on a story.
@@sauron2000000 where can i watch this?🤔
@@thesheldoncooper Maybe Mubi.
If Satyajit ray present today.... tons of FIR would lodge against him for blasphemy😭
I am with you on this brother, and I have no problem in calling out religious dogmatism as long as its not one sided. Indian film industry is replete with examples where "Hindu" religious dogmatism have been called out - and it should be, no two way about it. I wish we could say the same things about how the dogmatism of Abrahamic religions have been portrayed in Indian cinema. Unfortunately everybody including Ray might have weighed in the implications of "Fatwa" and "Hellfire" that would have followed suit and as a result played safe with their art. I would rather adopt the French style of liberalism in cultural transformation (read Charlie Hebdo) than the Communist style that thrive on selective affiliation. Till then the Pratiks of the World will have enough ammunition to flourish with their propaganda. Sad state of affairs indeed.
at least you are the only guy who raised a voice about this selective outrage in the name of protecting this so called 'secuparism' and 'progressiveness'. from my pov, pratiks are the outcome of selective narrative of secularism run by bong intellectuals and academicians. these guy always ignored the much more toxic dogmatism of abrahamic faiths, as a result radical hinduism came forward to fill this void as a repercussion.
Agree with you guys, I don't understand why can't people think and understand of their own what is happening and what should happen. Perhaps there is a scarcity of people like this, and this is the same reason why we don't find ourselves a group to thrive our thoughts. Every contemporary side is flawed and needs to get checked.
Guess what you haven't seen movies like 'Trance' from India.
@@SuperBooboohaha Also Prithviraj Sukumaran starer Adam Joan.. But they are less in no, that's is also a reality.. But yes particularly in Malayalam film industry We can find this type of movies
@@subhaschandrabosekijay4130 Intellectuals are critical of religion , in west you will find movies like Life of Brian , angels and demons so on . Most screenwriters in bollywood are non abrahamics, they will criticize what is familiar to them therefore crooked babas are a trope . In malayalam you will find many catholic writers and directors ( their background is evident from their names ) hence you will find catholic priests as embodiment of greed , power etc. Unlike bollywood movies malayalam won't express it blatantly , you have to read the subtext .It's pretty absurd to claim that 'only Hindus are the target ' Director or the screen writer is using the world which is familiar to them to make a larger or a universal point .
Devi, Kapurush o Mahapurush, Joy Baba Felunath - Satyajit Ray himself has shown how people are misled and fooled in the name of religion
Ganashatru too
pasupatinath's charan amrit is 100 times better than penicillin - in joto kando katmandu te, Gonosotru is also based on similar topic
Pratik never said that Ray is conservative ..
He just addressing hypocracy of Ray short flim ..
Where sadhus are fraud and peer babas are not
@@crforfun3041 when the film show us that sadhus are fraud??
Sanatan is not religion it's Dharma , first know the difference between Dharma and religion
A small correction, "Devi" is NOT Sharmila Tagore's first film.
Apur sangshar was her first film
@@priyaghosh194 actually kabiliwala. But she was a kid then.
@@hrishikesh07m the child actor who played the role of Mini in Kabuliwala was Oindrila Thakur, sister of Sharmila thakur. Hence, Apur Samsar was her first film.
Oindrila (Tinku) Thakur Minir choritre abhinay korechhilen.. Apur Sangsar-e Sharmila Thakurer pratham prakash..
SATYAJIT RAY isnt just bengal’s icon he’s a worldwide icon and he even inspired MARTIN SCORSESE to make films.
@@arafbhuiyan4417 ওনার সিনেমা তোর মাথায় ডুকবে না ।
@@arafbhuiyan4417 he's not the director of jurassic Park...
@@arafbhuiyan4417 The director of Jurassic Park, Steven Spielberg made a Movie named ET in 1982 which had strikingly similar story line with a cancelled Ray movie which he was about to make in Hollywood with paramount studios, called "the Alien" in 1967.
@@arafbhuiyan4417 Jurassic park is not a world class film it is a masala film, Satyajit Ray made better films than Jurassic park
@@rahulghosh9528 hey man I just that The Director of Jurassic Park inspired from Satyajit Ray
& what is masala film
Martin Scorsese will never understand this word 🤣🤣
If 'Ganashatru' released today, Pratik type of person could have shouted out for banning it. So as for Mahapurush, Devi even 'Hirak Rajar Deshe'. Satyajit Ray was a fearless creator. Pratik should watch his work before commenting. He was extremely progressive. He was even being attacked by Right wingers in his time as well. In one of his interviews he in fact said it very clearly. He was the God of progressive thinking in his personal life and in his creations.
Creations - yes, but pl read Manoj & I by Bijoya Ray to know about him as a person. You might be in for a surprise :)
But mam BJP was not there during active period of Ray...... And even I am also right leaning but I love Ray
if Pratik Borade try to watch HIRAK RAJAR DESHE,he will be in ICU
Exactly bro
I disagree. Because he wouldn't get any references or satires
Savage 🔥🔥🔥
তুই তো প্রতিক এর ভিডিওর কমেন্ট এ হেগে এসেছিস দেখলাম।
Prateek k Debi dekahleo khisti marbe Ray babu keo
Satyajit Ray is just not a legend,he is an emotion ,can't compare him with anyone else......................................................................................
Fun fact: he was a fellow Ashramik of Asharam Bapu
Yes, we know. He tried defending him in some videos.
যারা সত্যজিৎ রায় পড়েনি, শোনেনি, দেখেনি সবথেকে বড় কথা যারা বোঝেনি তারা ওনার ব্যাপারে " সঠিক " বলবে কি করে? তিনি সত্যজিৎ রায়। আমাদের কাছে ওই নামটাই যথেষ্ট ওনার যেকোন কাজ দেখার জন্য।
Ar Borade er kache Pir Baba jothesto.
@@sauron2000000 bhai cholen oke report mari
@@mdalamgirhossain6511 sotti ami tai korechi
Proper ❤️
@@mdalamgirhossain6511 ei betake dekhiye dite hobe je bangla nie kichu na jene , baje kotha bolar fol ki hoy report pratik
Pratik review is an opinion and so is urs....
I dislike Ray because they mutilated the stories. We need to counter Religious Dogmatism. Ray himself mentioned in his interview that his film " Devi " was criticized badly by a segment of people which he himself referred as " religious dogmatism".
But, on flip-side of coin Religious Dogmatism is not specific to " Hindu " religion. The issue is in recent pop culture films r always putting Hindu dogmatism under spot light and at the same time giving free pass to other religion. This will hurt religious sentiment of few. Pratik is one of such.
I believe we need to counter religious dogmatism as a whole. Bashing one and giving free pass to another will cause disparity and division.
Ekdm...this is the exact point
Only correct comment
Only sensible comment in this section.
Accurate!
Please Don't waste time on him. Trust me he don't deserve.
I always watch his video just to laugh. Becoz kiya bolne wlaa hai wo to maloom hi hai. Wo same hi hoga always.
Lmao same here. Watch him for comedy.
Mat dekho bhai. Uska views barega.
Same
This is what he says in every freaking video
Feminism bad 😭
Sexual liberation bad 😭
Ek pizza parlour chalane wale gawar se or kya expect karte ho 🤣🤣
Life lesson 101 : Never take bhakt-logic seriously 😂
andh bhakt*
Pehli baat har koi Pratik ke tarah nahin hota.... Bahut kam log Prateek ko jaante hain...... Main bhi thoda bahut BJP ko support karta hoon . Mujhe bhi BJP achha lagta hain lekin Pratik Borade, Akash Banerjee jaise log pasand nahin jo film critics ke naam pe politics kare...... Ab Akash Banerjee bhi thoda bahut films ke baare mein batata hain....... Toh andhbhakt kahna band kijiye......
Some people are always try to manipulate audience and you try to stop it through this feedback. Aritra you are doing a such a good job...
but irony is no one is gonna this shitty feedback
@@a___c_t_g make your english skills better before making a comment
pratik himself speak in beginning that whatever he speaks is HIS opinion not you called his opinion propaganda. so according to you why should not we call RAY movie a fully propaganda ??. if Bengali does it then it's ART. but when pratik does it, then it's propaganda.
Pratik thinks that sexism, homosexuality, any kind of discrimination etc are a part of some "propaganda" and not the reality. He even has a problem with sexual liberation 😂 What do you expect from such a rigid and conservative person?
He wants to end pseudo secularism from India 🤣🤣😆😆
True
Prathik borade jo bola o sahi hai, Bollywood hamehsa hindu ke khilaf hi prapogenda ki ya hai, the wrong is always wrong no matter who did.
Satyajit Ray aapke jaise roodivadi nahi the.
@@sauron2000000 satyajit roodivaadi nhi to bhi kya badalav aaya bengal me.up se bhi jyada poltical killing ho rhi .
@@shishirsrivastava976 Tumhare dimaag mein kya bhara hai? Yahan hum filmon ki baat kar rahe hain.
@@shishirsrivastava976 Tumhare dilme kya bachpan se hi Bangaliyon ke khilaaf nafrat hai kya? Inta takleef kyun hai tumko?
Tumko Satyajit Ray aur unke filmon se ghanta bhar ka bhi matlab nahi hai.
This channel is about films, not Religion. Take your Hindu Muslim propoganda somewhere else.
Satyajit Ray is an Indian ICON not only Bengali Icon...his work is inspirational and a cultural icon.
After watching your video, I saw his review on RAY.
Where did he disdained SATYAJIT RAY sir??
He tried to counter the things done by the directors who adapted his stories , he didn't like it , he said it with points. What's wrong in it??
And when there were no such elements in THE SATYAJIT RAY's work ,how dare they make such changes??
Are they of SATYAJIT RAY'S level??
And I always see you finding problems in his review. Some times I agree, but you always try to project him in a bad light.
When he did Hindu-Muslim??
He majorly counters communist ideology and the breaking india forces. What's wrong in it??
I don't know about him. But I have seen you sharing fake news regarding CAA.
You made video stating that muslim will lose citizenship through CAA. Please tell that how many Muslims have lost citizenship because of CAA, which has got no relevance with INDIANS??
First you should be doing your Homework properly before commenting on others.
First you were the ones who made fun of him became he talks about ignored pains of Hindus and the rampant HINDUPHOBIA of bollywood, later you only had to agree with him when you reviewed LEILA on Netflix. So please stop your drama.
We very well know your political inclination, when I saw your RRR controversy video where you tried to play pseudo-secularism card.
PLEASE STOP THIS
Your whole comment except the first para is a fraud
@@indiandaredevil7497 ohh so everything the authority said is false or rather fraud🤦♂️🤦♂️
My god🤦♂️
If you are ARITRA's blind follower then I won't be wasting my efforts, but if not then please go through the video of LEILA review first where he mentioned about Pratik Borade
And the author said that these directors are not even close to the mastery of SATYAJIT RAY, that is also false or by your language"FRAUD"?
If that is so, then only GOD can save you
Edit: And I forgot to mention that even SATYAJIT RAY's son SANDIP RAY expressed his discontentment with the film, now don't tell SANDIP RAY is narrow minded
Well shot bhai
You are spreading fake news against Aritra. Time to report your malicious comment.
I have lived in Bengal since my birth. The guy in the video is just another "Progressive" Bengali who just sits and judges people and misleads others into believing Indians are dumb and regressive. Never fall into the trap of following such people, who try to portray that they are above all and clarify their path to righteousness.
Absolutely right to say for Pratik barode, Pratik bhai har cheezh main dharam ko daal dete hai, woh asaram ke bhakt hai woh unke liye accha hai jo jail main hai,
"Humanity is the best religion" - Swami Vivekanand 💕
ISIS has a clear religion and it's not humanity.
@@RajeshSarkar-so3veif you want some examples ...APJ abdul kalam, begom rokeya, kaji najrul Islam, AR rahaman, Mohammad Rafi, Javed Akhtar, SRK, Gulam Nabi, Abdul kalam Azadd, Gaffar khan, Murshid kuli khan, Zakir hussain, ......
@@RajeshSarkar-so3ve every Muslim is not an ISIS
@@ds86496 amader class text book e chilo nursery te, and I have a calendar, sekhaneo eta lekha ache
@@ds86496 "মানব ধর্মই শ্রেষ্ঠ ধর্ম" Line টা এইটা ছিলো
No reviewer ( non- Bengali) talks about Satyajit Ray or his work .... Pratik did. His review on Apu triology ..
ua-cam.com/video/nigS6z6z5Zo/v-deo.html
Bengali chara rest of the India Satyajit Ray ke vulei jachhe.... at least he's trying to spread the word. Review ta loker personal opinion..... ote oto amol deoar kichu nei ..... in Ray they mutilated the stories as well as Characters..
They should have called it DEY instead of RAY
That's what I am trying to explain he loves bengali films infact he is the only the reviewer who has reviewed every regional film
*thumbaad*
Everyone:-keya movie hai re...👌
Pratik:-cheeee cheee....
*Narendra Modi movie*
Everyone:-cheee cheee...
Pratik:-keya movie hai re....👌
Tui sala tmc r paa chata mal,vaccine chor
@@rajeshrohit.rrecordmandal2190 অার তুই হলি মোদি কুত্তার বাচ্চার নুনু
@@rajeshrohit.rrecordmandal2190 I'm a communist bro😎
@@koustavbanerjee8221 laal salam ✊✊
@@koustavbanerjee8221 LAL SALAM
Listen. I don't agree with Borade but he can have his opinion bro. Even if it's a Political opinion. He might just get offended that's it.
Note:Ray sir have talk in a interview how some people fool in the name of religion and how it's affecting artistic freedom.
The same way aritra can have his opinion on Pratik.
@@Optimisticglory27 that's he is replying. Borade knows he will lost this argument that's why he will continue to ignore him.
At the end.. Our Aritras time lose. That guy will gonna call out buy a lot of people. His controversial opinion has a long list. Until then wait end watch.
I agree with both of you
In same way The director also 🤣
He made a video about ..why web serieses are made based on sunny leony and u converted it with boudi series and hoichoi....o hoooo
Pratik borade never saw Satyajit Ray's movies like Devi, Ganashatru and Jai Baba felunath...if he had saw those movies he would have known how much Satyajit Ray hated religious blind faiths
To my dear Bengalis and other fellow non andh bhakts- lets all comment on Pratik's video and teach these people what Ray stands for
@@shishirsrivastava976 tum aao yar bengal mai, bohut saare gutka chabane wale bhakto ko mai bhi dhoya hoon
@@shishirsrivastava976 humare yaha banarasi bande rickshaw chalate hai, aur rahi baat development ki, aao kabhi saltlake, rajarhat ya newtown meh, aajao yar aur milke jao aapne pradeshi bhaiyo.se
@Nandini Sen see they are free to come,live and work in our state.We love all Indians and UP,Bihar people are our brothers, but they should think twice before insulting fellow Indians...Jai Hind
@@pratyaykundu711 Maharashtra mein aaiye. Cultural diversity milega
@@rajatbadade20 yeah i love all states, and maharastra is one of India's greatest
satyjit ray he is very great person
And honestly say ray series in Netflix
Represent very bad way
I know you also know that
If this series given a better director nd without propaganda
Then it will be very better
This ray series represent very bad way to our legend satyjit ray sir
ওই লোকটা দোকানের শাটার নামায়, বাড়ি আসে, হাত পা ধোয়, গোমূত্রের একটা পেগ বানায়, নিয়ে বসে পড়ে
Che che lagga nei vaccine chor, chal chor r a
Haaa 😂
Ekdom vai
Jaa bolechis bhai 😂😂😂
@@rajeshrohit.rrecordmandal2190 jab atta nhi bengali bolna kiu bol raha hai
After your video, i watched pratik's videos.... I seems he quietly right. Pratik having great approach & perspective
About what?
@@sauron2000000 about exposing qseudo liberals and pro Islamic flim makers in India
@@livemusic7801 Sure.
He is a real manipulating expert no doubt you also got caught in his trap
Prarik is not a film reviewer . He is here to promote BJP.
Absolutely CORRECT
kintu satyajit roy er chele nijea boleche je ei flim takea bikriti kora hoyeche ato boro boro kotha to sandip roy emne emne bolbe na
Correct
Tumi MOMOTA chamcha holo
@@Anunakinamya Onek valo. 2024 toh jabe tokhon ki korbi
Sabash dada...etai dorkar chilo, amio age onek age or video dekhtam jokhon o actually review korto, ekta time er por theke propaganda cholte thake, jeta ekdom e posay na...ei answer er dorkar chilo
You are absolutely right brother... He is most Casteist person on the UA-cam, Jo koi bhi movie aur web series me Religion wala angle daal hi dete hai, Us borade ne Sarappta movie me Jo Sc St caste Ka Jo angle hai usey wo chubh Gaya....
Amake ekta jinis bojhao je Sadhu ke Sadhu na dekhiye peer sahab dekhiye ki experiment holo??
R Sadhu ke Sadhu dekhale ki khoti hoto??
Etai kichu bolbena o...Islam ke positive dekhalo r Hinduism ke chhoto korlo... dogmatism sobei thake bt erkm selective vabe dekhano ta obossoi vul
@@subhasisbhattacherjee5202 thik bolechhen....r sudhu ekhane noi Bollywood e chirokal Hindu dhormo ke chhoto and muslimder mohan,osohai hisebe dekhano hoyechhe.
Lokkho kore dekhben 90% Bollywood cinema r villian Hindu character dekhano hoy
exactly.. That's why I unsubscribed her channel long back and reported several after realising she connects max review with RELIGION. 😂 Now I connect with your words bro.. 👍👍 Your thoughts match with me
Her channel and she connect? 😕 Who? 🤔
@@jayjumnani sorry for the bad sarcasm 😂 her refers to Pratik
Let Pratik do his review and you do yours. What's your problem? :) opinions may differ and you don't need to defend anyone.
Also, Srijit, despite being closest to Bengal... did the worst with Ray's stories compared to the two other directors. His work was very dark and Ray's work always had more 'rays' (light).
Aritra take a look at ur comments section..... u will find the issue with our society as well as ur & Pratik's review. People r fighting over BJP & TMC , Modi - Didi & Hindu-Muslim. In the name of protesting intolerance we have become intolerant towards any ideology which we r not familiar. Pratik's review is JUST HIS OPINION . So is urs. By creating another video in his reply what u achieved is NOTHING BUT CREATRING MORE DIVISION across people...... Also u didn't mention what Sandip Ray mentioned about this movie "RAY". For your info he mentioned " I am scared now to what this movie as I dont know to what extend they have rutilated my father's stories ".
You shows courage against Pratik is awesome
How many stories of Shri Satyajit Ray where he used " Race Course Gamble " , " fraud" , " Cheating " ," Alcohol " , Bikers Gang, etc etc . Entire Shanku Series highly affected by scam and cheating of a person . sometimes reconstruct of old story with modern aspect is good for survival .
Pratik Borade jode Mrinal Sen and Ritwik Ghatak dekhe tbe to mone hoi ICU te chole jbe😂
😂😂
True true 🤣🤣🤣
ওর কাছে এরা সবাই তখন হিন্দুত্ত বিরোধী, বামপন্থী, দেশ দ্রোহি হবে।
@@dassss25 Haa er Mrinal Sen and Ritwik Ghatak - 2jon ei বামপন্থায় biswas korten...tbe Pratik er hisab e to tara joghonno filmmaker holen 🙄🙄
@@sayanmaji2955 Seta onader personal byaper... keu leftist hotei pare... but Pratik er kache jara radical hindu bade sobai leftist...
Devi is Sharmila Tagore's 2nd film ...
Pratik gave average review to tumbad. Why? 😏
Because Hindus can never be greedy.
Pm modi ko accha movie bataya tha usne 🤣
@@sauron2000000 🤣🤣
Bcz he is an udgandu
Bhai jaake uski best flims of 2018 dekh le
Aur ha uski Apu trilogy ka review bhi dekh Lena kitni tarrif ki hai satyajit Ray ki
Jo baba wle me changes hn to jb ek jgh galat dikhaya hi tha to jisme shi dikhana tha wahaan kyu dharm badal dya... To bdla to dharm k basis pe hi to uspe baat kyu nahi kri ja skti uspe...bht si news hti hn jisme culprit dusre dharm ka hta h or photo me dusre dharm ki pic lgi hti h to koi bole bhi na iske baare me¿
It's true.. bengalis are very open minded people.. ❤️
that's why they call bihari people "HINDUSTANI" . they are sooooooooo open minded that they consider themselves ahead of India. their mindset are closed inside their state. I am not talking about all. but people like you are same
@@jayntsngh because they are bihari filled with a lot of bad and backwards thinking . And we told you earlier that we are open minded haven't we?
Netflix's Ray has destroyed the innocence of the stories by Satyajit Ray....
Absolutely right bro
Sandeep roy er movie te peye jabe same to same ja golpe lekha ache segulo dekhte paro
Raa dada adaptation mane ki adeo bujhen?
@@rockyvai8958 Theek.
*Aritra Brahmo samaj e keu nastik chhilo na , tobe murtipujo te biswas korto na, upanishad er ek obhinno brohmo ke biswas korto*
They believe im single God
That antisoul or paramatma
pal pal paramatman is not anti soul....in fact if you read upanishads or vedanta...atman is not soul ....atman is self....or pure consciousness
Aritra boleche Religion mana hoto na. Eta thik.
Even Satyajit Ray in an interview with Sanjib Chatterjee himself told that many stories of Feluda are not up to his mark... because he had to use the same plot everytime revolving around murder, theft or property conflicts to keep his work restricted to younger readers... In fact he disclosed that he had many brilliant crime plots regarding relationship conflicts and sexual violence issues but could never write it down otherwise Feluda series would become adult literature... Which he never wanted to do... So not all of his Felu stories are brilliant... he himself disclosed this...
Ys bro... I agree with you
Where is that interview?
@@mayankmandal8053 Check out the documentary Feluda : 50 years of Ray's Detective
@@ramitmitra3821 where is it available?
I don't even ***** know how the hell filmi indian and pratik borade has a lot of subs.... Review er nam e Hage r loke tai khay...chiii😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑😑
Dear Aritra
I saw Pratik borade review and no where in his review he has portrayed Satyajit ray in wrong light .
He is just highlighting how Ray's story are shown with maker/director propoganda .
*U tell me in Beharupiya in original story If it was a sadhu in Netflix adoptation why Peer is shown*?
Is it such a big issue? And if Sandip Roy has no issue with it, what is your problem?
@@sauron2000000 big or small that matters to the individual, so wat Pratik borade said is why the change at first place forget it will be issue or no .
U tell me wen the maker paid one person for the role spent money on costume dialogue filming everything they did then why change the character ?
@@sauron2000000 who said tha Sandeep roy had no issues , first read his statement than tell anythinyg.
Tum secularism secularism karta rahiyo aur muslim bengal ko dusra kashmir bana dega 🙏
Ok.🙏
Rehne de bhai ye nhi samjhenge. Abhi sikh logo ko samjh aaya ,jaldi inko bhi aayega, bhaag ke phir aayenge up ,jharkhand, karntaka
I personally have mixed opinions. Follower of Pratik's channel but agree with you on the topic about satyajit ray.
Pratik Ji Ne Kya Galat Kaha
Tu Murder,Rap, ko justified kr raha he...
Sex ko justify aapke purwajo ne bhi ki. Tabhi aap aaj comment kar pa rahe ho.
Pratikji ke ek beti hai. Unhone use kaise paida kiya hoga?
great..... I was really waiting for this reply
একদম correct বলেছ দাদা। আমি আগে pratik borade এর review দেখতাম। কিন্তু প্রায় 1 বছর হলো দেখা ছেড়ে দিয়েছি ঠিক একই কারণের জন্য। সব কিছুতে হিন্দু মুসলিমের topic টেনে আনে। ও movie review channel না খুলে কোনো religion channel খুললে কাজে দিত।
ব্রাহ্ম সমাজ নিয়ে যা বলেছেন, তাতে বুঝলাম শুধু ওনার নয় আপনারও পড়াশোনার প্রয়োজন আছে…
যাক কেউ একজন বললো! আমি আশ্চর্য হয়ে গেছিলাম এতটা আত্ম প্রত্যয়ের সাথে ভুল খবর বলা টা শুনে...
Ha brahmo nijei ekta relligion! Ja biodik adwaitobad er opor based
Respect Man Respect Artira ... you are a strong voice . Keep up the good work .
That's why West Bengal india se disconnect ho rha hai 😑
@Saptarshi i am not hindu ... I am sindhi
@Saptarshi Sikhism hindu se hi bana hai ...yaha sab mil kr rehte h ... Koi dikkat nhi h sikh logo ko ...hum gurudwara jate h wo mandir ate hai .,.. aur jinko problem h wo brainwashed ho chuke h .. history nahi jante h ...
Why?
@@jayjumnani So, Sindhi is a seperate religion?
@@sauron2000000 cast alag h, root alag h ...india m sindhi log majority m ate h in under Hinduism ...aur pakistan m sindhi close to islam hai...
But his son sandip Ray himself was extremely unhappy with the portrayal of his father's stories. Pratik borade never Insulted the great Satyajit ray in any manner, he just criticized the portrayal of his stories in the anthology. These people are just using Satyajit ray's name to hide behind the show's mediocrity
True.
বাল। সন্দীপ রায় রে সিরিজের চিত্রনাট্যকে পছন্দ করেনি, কারণ গল্পগুলোকে অধিকাংশই বদলিয়েছে। আর ওই ছাগলমার্কা বহিরাগত হিন্দুস্তানির বাচ্ছাটা এটাকে সম্পূর্ণরূপে ধর্মীয় অ্যাঙ্গেলে টেনে এনে বালজেপি/বালএসএসের প্রোপাগান্ডা প্রচার করেছে। আর এটা ও প্রত্যেকটা ভিডিওতেই করে।
@@indranilderia5947 ভারত থেকে আলাদা হয়ে যা, এতই যদি বহিরাগত বহিরাগত করতে হয় মমতাজ বেগমের মত।
@@a___c_t_g তোর বাবার দেশ নাকি এটা বোকাচোদা?? আর বহিরাগত মানে জানিস গান্ডু?? বহিরাগত কাকে বলে সেটা আগে পড়াশুনা করে জেনে আয় মূর্খচোদার বাচ্ছা, তারপরে কমেন্ট করবি।
আর হ্যাঁ, বাংলা আলাদা হলেই ভালো হত। অন্তত বহিরাগত গোবলীয় হিন্দুস্তানি অপসংস্কৃতি আর ভাষার সাম্রাজ্যবাদ থেকে বাংলা ভাষা আর সংস্কৃতি রক্ষা পেয়ে যেত।
@@indranilderia5947 Areee kisob😆😆
Pls galagal deben na
Pratik borade never criticized ray Sahab... He only criticized the adaptations of it Bollywood...
He has no knowledge about ray Sahab. He is a moron.
Satyajit ray hamara bengali ka icon he.. We loved him 💝💖
Ekdamm sahi baat....Ray film r satyajit ray er kahini 2toi gem 💎💎💎 ...,,, art k evolve hotei hobe.... Superbbbb seriesssss
Bhaiya don't give importance to prateek borade because he is not a critic because he always talks about hindi Muslim to create controversy
Bhai pratik borade ki baat hi na bolo. Usse har chiz mein dharm aur politics ghusana aata he bas. Pehle baht dekhta tha uska video, ab jab bhi recommendation mein aata he to 'not interested' kar k chhod deta hu😂.
Pratik borade রিভিউ মানেই হিন্দু মুসলিম, কংগ্রেস বিজিপি হেন তেন
সে পলিটিক্যাল ভিডিও বানালেই পারে।
মুভির মধ্যেও ধর্ম ছাড়া উনি কিছু টেনে অানতে পারেন না। অার নিজেকে বলে মুভি ক্রিটিক্স
Bengali only past ko lekar bolte h.. Unka present future kuch nahi h..
Bhai tum bhi Hindi review diya karo movie review kya hota he wo tum dusro se jyada jante ho sabhi movies ka hindi review tumhe karna chahiye 👍
Ben can't make any sense or a good web series...so they will come and defame Hindi series... Just ignore them...let them criticise...end of the day they also consume Hindi content and it helps our Hindi entertainment sector.
thank you for making this video
Ekhane Amar ekta problem ache, je Satyajit Ray kintu superpower e bishashi chilen, mane jetake bhogoban mana hoy, shetai uni bishash korten, but hoyto bhogoban bole dakten na. What he was fully against, was Religious Dogmatism, mane religion r through diye manush ke boka banano, and misuse of power, shetao dekhbe manik dadu r onek movies, stories eo ache.
Achcha na mention korecho porer dike, sorry
Kya tum BHI wahi kar rhe same wo Hindu Muslim krta h tum Bengali Bengali kar rhe, WB India me h ki India me WB h, HM use Sahi NHI bol rhe par agr wo glt to tum BHI glt ho, Wo religion KO btata h tum state bta rhe country unity ki toh koi baat hi NHI kar rha
Tumko bengali ko aapmaan karne ka iccha hai to jaake bangla Pokkho channel mein post karo.
But it is also true that bollywood in recent years is constantly bashing religion and related stuffs in every movie or series
Bollywood is targetting only one religion...
I seriously didn't know about this pratik .... But aapne toh pura dho diya
He is a great Maratha Stand up Comedian. Check out his reviews🤣
@@sauron2000000 .... After this video I think it's better to leave him alone... And I wish that may God bless him... And he should get well soon
@@somnathmukherjee9381 Naa bhai vari moja😆😆😆
Basically Pratik Borade is not an open-minded person to accept creative items as they are.. He does not understand technicalities as well.. He only pushes his thoughts in his videos.. In past, I used to follow him but unfollowed that fellow.. He praises few Bengali items and authors only to collect views.. He basically mislead people.. Last time I watched his review on 'Money Heist' and it was just impossible and unbearable.. It was so brilliantly made.. But watch his review please.. If people cannot take a creative piece of fiction as it is made and always correlate it with practical life, political views and religious views after some time it becomes unbearable.. That person may need some careful attention of a Doctor I guess.. He should atleast make atleast a brilliant creative piece before using such words..
So you can criticize anyone for mistepresenting a Bengali icon but Prateek can't criticize others for mistepresenting hindu icons???
Stop being so hypocritical...
Sorry brother, but i do not think any hindu icons has been misinterpreted?? 🤣🤣
@@കേരളബ്ലാസ്റ്റേഴ്സ്ബ്ലാസ്റ്റേ Bro maybe not in this series...
But there are loads of other movies in which they have been misrepresented...
Check out gemsofbollywood twitter account just once...
@@കേരളബ്ലാസ്റ്റേഴ്സ്ബ്ലാസ്റ്റേ And btw Pratik didn't say anything bad about Satyajit Ray in any of his videos...
He quoted what Satyajit Ray's son and his viewers were commenting...
Many Bengali people who don't even understand hindi are spreading hate in his comment section mindlessly...
@@aayt2852 we are talking about this series here
@@aayt2852 all Bengali people are insulting both ray(becoz they have read the stories earlier) and pratik.
Darun bolecho … completely upright and honest …
With u aritra !!
I reported pratik's video on the basis of terrorism because I couldn't find stupidity .
Bro You need to learn more about Satyajit Ray
And who are you? Some sort of authority?
Telling bengali persons to know more about ray . Seriously what a joke 😒
Aritra tumi Pratik k besi importance dao, sensible lokjon Pratik k follow kore na
Jao, giye dekho koto public oke follow kore. O sobar mogoj dholai kore feleche😆😆😆. Baddho Pagol ekta
Ebar Satyajit Ray keo nijer propaganda r angshow banalo.
Artitra ok target kore khub sahoser porichoy dieche, hats off to Artitra.
একটা ফালতু লোকের জন্য কেন সময় নষ্ট কর। সবাই যদি সবকিছু বুঝতে পারতো তাহলে তো আর কোন কথাই ছিল না
Kopale ki mekheche ota... holud na ..😂
@@sauron2000000 ha ami ok block kore rekhechhi, jara or video te like kore tara hingsapremi....
Satyajit Ray এর ব্যাপারে যখন ওর ভিডিও তে কমেন্ট করতে গেলাম, তখন আমাকে অ্যান্টি হিন্দু বলে লম্বা একটা paragraph রিপ্লাই দিচ্ছে। মানে আজব তো, যেকোনো লজিকের অ্যান্টি লজিক ওর কাছে অ্যান্টি হিন্দু 🙄
@Saptarshi নর্থ ইন্ডিয়ার নয়ডা,গুরগাও এর ধারে কাছে ঘেষার সামর্থ্য আছে তোদের? একবার নিজেদের সাথে ওদের মাথাপিছু আয়, এফ ডি আই তুলনা করে দেখিস, এরপর দেখবি কারা পিছিয়ে আর কারা এগিয়ে।
@Saptarshi কাউন্টার করার মত লজিক না থাকলেই এসব বলেই গা বাঁচাতে হয়, সালার ভিখারি নপুংসক বাঙালী
@@a___c_t_g Noida Gurgaon er lokera jomi beche baralok hoyeche. Er moddhe achievement ki aache?
@@sauron2000000 আইটি হাব তো আর জমি বেচে হয়নি, আর জমির দাম আছে বলেই জমি বেচে বড়লোক হয়েছে, বাংলার জমিতে ত কুত্তাও মুতবে না।
@@a___c_t_g IT hub jomi bechei hoyeche. Jemon South India te hoyeche.
Bollywood se Oscar kaun jita ?
Bhanu Athaiya.
Ek right wing youtuber ne tum logo ki sulaga rakhi hai.wo tum logo ko ghass nhi daalta lekin tum aur charcha with bhurani wala totla uske naam pe views bator lete ho🤣.aaj video dekho kitne jyada views mile honge tumhe pratik ke naam pe .aur mera comment mat delete kar dena
What a reply 😂🔥👍
if he watch devi , jay baba felunath , ganashatru then he will die in heart attack
Hindu sadhu bhando hoy setar opor movie banano hoy.. Ray ki annyo religion er bhondamir dik ta dekhanor sahosh dekhiyeche?
Taito. Tar mane ki bolchen 😁
@@sauron2000000 aapni nije e assess karun..
@@sauron2000000 উত্তর নেই নাকিরে বাঁড়া?
@@a___c_t_g Satyajit Ray ki ei shob kotha bolten
@@Ranit1985 Muslim fakirder niye ke film baniyeche?
Telivision bole ekta Bangladeshi movie aache
His each vedio is heavily backed by ....evidences ......u don't have any comparison to his entelect .....aur Satyajit ray work is genius artist ....
Aur Bengal ke baare me pura hindustan janta hai ....
Kya Jaanta hai?
@@sauron2000000 এদের মাথায় বুদ্ধি নেই। অশিক্ষিতদের দল। Ignore করুন।
Satyajit Sir is the God Father of FilmMaker.......🙏❤️
Just becoz he glorifies his country his religion and was is not a liberal and so called secular like you that doesn't means he is right , you always try to take views on his name 😂😂😂😂 that's what his position is 🔥
You are correct, it doesn't mean he is right 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Pratik borade ta toh ja taa🤦🤦🤦 Politics besi kore Review theke
"The second, the necessity to keep an eye on the censors, rather than causing despair, should in fact encourage subtlety of expression. It may, after all, be more fun to imply intimacy rather than to display it."
- Satyajit Ray
What you said is okay! But in that sense then you are also spreading propagandas that films like Satyamev Jayate are jingoistic, Although I agree that it's a bad franchise..criticize the film naah, why you are touching the philosophical aspect like Pratik Borade... I reminded you this in case if you forgot or trying to be a hypocrite idk. And adding to that, we all know that sex, violence and vulgarity is present in every society... But there is no such thing that we are bound to promote it. Does a progressive society means that we should accept films which intentionally shows sex scenes and vulgarities to gather the audience???
Do reply Aritra Da
BTW your short film (NAXAL) was amazing. 👍
Have you seen any of Ray's films ?
Either you didn't get Aritra's point and misinterpreting it or you actually have misconceptions about it. Films which intentionally shows sex scenes and vulgarities... are made in Alt Balaji or Ullu...
If the scene requires metaphorical representation of sex or violence it should be shown. If a scene contents the Society of a slum or lower class people or Gang muffias or College ingenious , vulgar Language can be used. And if you're progressive enough you'll get the context... not the propaganda. If you're progressive enough you'll see the truths not the propaganda.
I hope you get my point
@@samanwaychakraborty5802 what seems progresssiveness to you is actually a subtle ignorance that bangla intellectual fed you for years. your progressiveness will not come to save you when a particular community will change the demography of your locality and then intimidate through loud speaker that 'convert or die'. on that day, the guys whom you address 'gutkhakhor' will somehow be able to save themselves but you 'liberals' will fall into trap and gonna sacrifice your mother and sister. that day is not very distant.
@@samanwaychakraborty5802 you people are progressive yet on verge of become Bangladesh 🤣trust me ek din aayega jab tum bhaag bhaag ke aaoge assam,up,jharkhand, karnataka jab ye so called progressive film makers tumhe bachane nhi aayenge kyonki they will run to some other countries
@@a___c_t_g wo din dur nhi hai.it happened with Sikh people in jammu, it happened in few localities of up and it will definitely happen in Bengal. Bengali hindu exodus will happen just like 1990 Kashmir Pandit exodus
কথা গুলো যখন আপনি বললেন দাদা পুরো গায়ে কাটা দিয়ে উঠলো, অসাধারণ বক্তব্য
Thik ache tai bole muslim der o support kora bondo kora uchit....ora to aro conservative...mea der burkha te rakhe..and plz muslims are not open minded be it bengali or urdu muslim....mea der kono adhikar nei..
I am completely agreed with u.
According to Pratik Borade ji...
Judge people by his lifestyle not by his works.
Who does not know about the Great Cinematic Icon and Oscar Awardee- Satyajit Ray. A prolific filmmaker.
Partik the legend once said that "KGF is a average film"🤣🤣🤣
KGF is a average film..may be above average nothing more than that
KGF above average.
@@ShantanuDey13 i didn't mean by economic status...he said it is a average film means it's not a good film though 🙂
Haan mujhe bhi itna pasand nehi aaya
Sorry ,but I also think that kgf is a average movie.
सुनकर अच्छा लगा कि,
बंगोली ओपन माइंडेड पीपल होते है
हमारे यहां बंगोली लोग कहते है कि, कोलकाता में एजुकेशन पर बहुत ध्यान दिया जाता है