이건 조금 비방일수도 있지만 징거씨만 아니였으면 시크릿 수명 훨씬 길었을거임 전효성이야 솔로활동 하면서 시크릿 내에서 남팬들 싹쓸이였고 한선화는 예능싹쓸이 송지은 비주얼로 대박쳤었고 그에비해 징거는 너무 비중이없어서... 저자리에 걸스데이 민아나 혜리같은 친구 들어갔으면 시크릿 훨씬 잘됐을텐데
Seriously..it breaks my heart to know that they are not an extremely popular group because they deserve it so much....they sing live throughout the whole song, they look healthy and sexy (without the need to look like a stick) they dance great (eventhough i'm not a big fan of this one choreography) and just overall the song is amazing...why is SECRET still underestimated?? but hey as long as they keep doing what they are doing with the same passion, everything is fine with me..no need for a hype..but just don't disband anytime soon please...you girls rock!! FIGHTING!!
They were really popular I think around 2011-2012? But then one of the members, Hyosung, said a politically incorrect thing about South Korea which caused a lot of controversies and hate towards her and the group. Then they came back with a cute song which a lot of people didn't like, so their popularity has been on a downfall ever since. 'I'm in Love' is such a fierce song, I was hoping that they would slay with it but unfortunately that didn't happen :'(
ooh i see! thank you for the information...that really sucks :( it shows how you have to be super careful if you're famous...i think the korean audience is also not very forgiving....they take everything super serious...
LadyTurquoise You're welcome! ^^ Ikr! you have to be extremely careful if you're an idol in Korea, especially since idols already get a lot of hate to begin with :/
actually during 2010-2012 they're the trend with their hit Songs such as Magic,Madonna,Shy Boy,Starlight Moonlight,Love is move,poison (2012)but their company TS Ent made a stupid decision to send them away to Japan in 2012 and focused on their new Boygroup
secret is seriously underrated. theyreally are talented and so strong women. i loved all their comebacks until now. they can dance so sexy and look sexy and they smile. they are like the girl version of shinee ♡ they all so sing live so what can i wish for more?!
Re-watching in 2021, you don't see performances like this anymore, they're singing live and they're doing it in high heels, 2nd gen ggs will always be the best.
A Korean music fan since 2006, came back to watch this in 2022. You don’t get this kind of performance these days; LIVE, not pre-recorded. You can hear all members singing clearly while dancing, in heels. Heck Jieun even nailed the bridge part. These days those performances focus more on visuals than the music.
I think Jieun has one of the best (and my favorite) sweet voices in kpop/that I know of from the world music I listen to. I prefer when she sings slow songs because its really comforting to me to listen to~ I love secret so much!
WOWOWOWOWOWOWOW I DIDNT KNOW THAT JIEUN WAS SUCH A GOOD SINGER, I found this group yesterday and I thought she was just a visual but her voice blew me away
Polar Light I found it before this song and i loved the concept of it, I was so upset that she didn't get enough attention for it, I knew she was a good singer but I never really payed attention to her so I regret that a lot. Looking foward to her solo song tho- it's coming soon
2014 was the most memorable and historical event in KPOP. Because all of the greatest Groups disbanded and release their final songs with co-golden era artists. Their era will never be replace
2022 and still rewatcing all their performances, idols dont perform like this anymore sad but its true their just showing their visual and dance no hate but i miss this era so much this is what i called IDOLS
세트도 분위기 있어서 좋고 여름이라서 보기에 하얀 코디도 시원하고 과하게 안마르고 사람답게 말라보여서 좋고 라이브도 멤버마다 시원시원하고 그래서 후렴구 사운드도 풍부하고 춤도 다들 열심히 추고 끼도 다들 잘하고 속이 시원해지는 퍼펙트한 무대에요 심지어 노래가 좋아서 찾아본 무대인데 말이에요 약간 에바라면 저렇게 열심히 하는데 체력 다 앗아가고 아플 신발 정도요
My Unnies. 😭 It's still unfortunate that TS wasn't able to protect their artists well. But I'm glad they're finally free and are still striving. I miss them so much though. 🥲
Ok but can we talk about how EXCELLENT this live performance was vocal-wise? I've seen so many good performances from them over the years, but either I didn't watch this one when it was uploaded, or I forgot. But damn that was good from start to finish.
I’ve liked them since i was in junior high. And after all this time.. i still think that secret has the most stable live singing-while dancing performance compared to all girlgroups i have seen so far
I almost agree with you, coz there is also Brown Eyed Girls, their skill is insane. Sistar has 2 big vocalists, but the other 2 have little singing part. Bora handles all of rap part, while Dasom has quite a weak voice.
![Secret (SECRET) [Talk That] @SBS Inkigayo Popular song 20121209](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/jnrwyOPfDXc/mqdefault.jpg)
씨크릿은 역시 매직-마돈나-포이즌 같은 트럼펫 섹소폰 소리 뽱뽱거리는 노래가 최고 ㅋㅋ 금관악기 맛집
섹소폰ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ색소폰임
뽷뽷~♡
색소폰은 목관악기ㅜ
@@Score_arranger 헉 리드땜에 그런가 ㅋㅋ 전 악기 클라리넷 하는데도 몰랐네요 ㅠ 플룻은 목관이라 알았는데
@@맞춤뻡파괘 리드때문도 그렇고 마우스피스가 클라리넷이랑 흡사해서 목관악기로 분류가 된다고하네용
진짜 회사에서 노래 하나만큼은
기가 막히게 뽑았음 이런 걸그룹
진짜 안나올거 같다 ,,, 안녕 ,, 중학생 때
첫사랑들,,,
사람도 너무 잘뽑음..
노래도 잘 뽑았는데 춤도 진짜 파워풀하게 잘춰서 완전 시원시원했었음
근데 그 회사가 졸라 싫음 ㅅㅍ
왜 하필 릿은 거기서 시작해야만 했을까
그 운명이 원망스럽다 ㅜ
이건 조금 비방일수도 있지만
징거씨만 아니였으면 시크릿 수명 훨씬 길었을거임
전효성이야 솔로활동 하면서 시크릿 내에서 남팬들 싹쓸이였고
한선화는 예능싹쓸이 송지은 비주얼로 대박쳤었고
그에비해 징거는 너무 비중이없어서... 저자리에 걸스데이 민아나
혜리같은 친구 들어갔으면 시크릿 훨씬 잘됐을텐데
@@인우-i7g 글쎄요.저는 시크릿에서 하나의 랩도 컸다고 생각.그 독특한 허스키한 목소리의 랩.거기다 래퍼인데 노래도 수준급.매직 마돈나 샤이보이 포이즌 전부다 하나의 랩이 없었다면 그렇게 훌륭한 곡이 될 수 있었을까 싶으면 아니라 보네요
후렴에 4명이 전부 라이브로 불러버리니까 이어폰으로 들을때 보컬 개 꽉차네 ㅋㅋㅋ 누가누가 잘하나 시합하듯이 하네. 완전 좋다 ㅋㅋ
보통 저때도 후렴은 립싱크였는데 ㄷㄷ
송지은 ㄹㅇ 존예 다들 옛날인지 모를만큼 세련됐다
진짜 독기 그득그득하게 라이브 부르고 몸 부셔져라 춤추는 거 넘 멋있다.. 지금 4세대에선 절대 못 느끼는 2세대들만의 독기 ㄷㄷ
비주얼 실화냐.. 진짜 너무이쁘다 다들 송지은 전효성 레전드
한선화도...
정하나도😘
@@gooc9cbe2be ??
와 후렴에 보컬 꽉차는 거...ㅎㄷㄷ
1:26 나는 갠적으로 송지은 연기도 물론 좋아하지만 가수활동때 그 느낌 아무도 못 따라간다고 생각함... 진짜 개이쁘고 노래도 너무잘해...
이걸로 1위 한번더 찍었어야 했는데..
시크릿만의 그 특유의 흥이 있음..
진짜 이 노래 경쟁자들보다 가장 멋있는 라이브를 보여 준다 느꼈는데 왜 성적 그저 그랬는지 아직도 이해가...
소형이 이정도면 대박 터트린거죵
어쩔수 없었다고 생각이 드네요
이 때 전효성 라디오에서 이상한 말해서 ㅇㅂ 이슈 엄청 심했을 때였어요
진짜 댄스라이브만 놓고 보면 시크릿만한 그룹 없는거 같음.요즘 안무 어렵다 하는데 다이어트로 젤 유명한게 시크릿 춤이고,딴 그룹이랑 다르게 후렴까지 걍 백퍼부름 mr제거하고 들어도 이거랑 백퍼같은
그때 큰 사고도 나서 ㅠㅠㅠ 활동을 많이 못했죠 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
팬덤이 약했지 그리고 대중들이 아이돌이라고 무시한 결과랄까
이때가 ㄹㅇ 리즈다 넷 다 존나 예쁨... 후 노래도 개좋은데 도대체 왜 이노래 못뜬거지 ㅠㅠ
Seriously..it breaks my heart to know that they are not an extremely popular group because they deserve it so much....they sing live throughout the whole song, they look healthy and sexy (without the need to look like a stick) they dance great (eventhough i'm not a big fan of this one choreography) and just overall the song is amazing...why is SECRET still underestimated?? but hey as long as they keep doing what they are doing with the same passion, everything is fine with me..no need for a hype..but just don't disband anytime soon please...you girls rock!! FIGHTING!!
They were really popular I think around 2011-2012? But then one of the members, Hyosung, said a politically incorrect thing about South Korea which caused a lot of controversies and hate towards her and the group. Then they came back with a cute song which a lot of people didn't like, so their popularity has been on a downfall ever since. 'I'm in Love' is such a fierce song, I was hoping that they would slay with it but unfortunately that didn't happen :'(
ooh i see! thank you for the information...that really sucks :( it shows how you have to be super careful if you're famous...i think the korean audience is also not very forgiving....they take everything super serious...
LadyTurquoise You're welcome! ^^
Ikr! you have to be extremely careful if you're an idol in Korea, especially since idols already get a lot of hate to begin with :/
actually during 2010-2012 they're the trend with their hit Songs such as Magic,Madonna,Shy Boy,Starlight Moonlight,Love is move,poison (2012)but their company TS Ent made a stupid decision to send them away to Japan in 2012 and focused on their new Boygroup
i love them too and they do deserve much more...but,they are not the only ones who sing live -.-"
시크릿도 전설로 남아야 됨..
아니 진짜 장난아니고 넷다 진짜 너무 예쁘다...
Am I the only have having a secret live performances marathon? I MISS THEM SO MUCH 😭😭😭😭
kyungseyebrows onfleek SAME
Saaame, I miss them especially Hyosung’s sexiness, then JiEun and Sunhwa’s visuals. ಥ_ಥ
@@sigrid.5994 you don't miss Hana's sexiness too ?
Sameee
Miss secret
이런 템포 빠르고 리드미컬한 곡은 시크릿 전매특허인데 그립넹
OMG are they actually singing live while doing all that dancing?! Holy shyttt that's some talent!!!
Secret is one of those groups
ㅑ6 7ㄱ ㄹㅇ4ㅡㄱㄹ6
아니 한선화 미ㅗ모 실화냐 근데 전효성이랑 송지은도 개 이쁘네.............................
어렸을 때 티비에서 한선화 처음 봤을 때 과장 안보태고 진짜 김태희 동생인줄 알았음
@@jaehyuncho9641 합리적 의심...
secret is seriously underrated. theyreally are talented and so strong women. i loved all their comebacks until now. they can dance so sexy and look sexy and they smile. they are like the girl version of shinee ♡ they all so sing live so what can i wish for more?!
Re-watching in 2021, you don't see performances like this anymore, they're singing live and they're doing it in high heels, 2nd gen ggs will always be the best.
A Korean music fan since 2006, came back to watch this in 2022. You don’t get this kind of performance these days; LIVE, not pre-recorded. You can hear all members singing clearly while dancing, in heels. Heck Jieun even nailed the bridge part. These days those performances focus more on visuals than the music.
Fr I miss 2nd gen quality performances
최근에 시크릿 곡 생각나서 다 들어봤는데 이노래가 젤좋네요....중독성 장난아니고 안무까지 중독성잇네 재평가 받아야할 곡..
전 포이즌
와전효성진짜 찰지게춘다 춤 맛깔나
송지은 음색 지린다..
i want a secret comeback!!!! 😢😢
시크릿도 다시 보고싶은 그룹ㅠㅠ 다들 너무 예쁘고 실력도 좋고 노래도 좋았음
노래 존나 좋아 요즘도 듣습니다
다들 미모 미쳤다 미쳤어...ㅠㅠ
라이브도 미모도 레전드급 너무 예쁘다
I love the cameraman... Every secret member get a faur amount of shots.. Good job... Secret jjang!!
라이브 개잘한다
이 노래 존나좋음 진짜 ㅠㅠ언제들어도 개좋음
Hands down, Secret is the best girl group to watch live!
7년전인데 진짜 세련됐다
송지은 흑발 너무 이뻐 ㅠㅠㅠ 나올때마다 헉한다
시크릿 너무 그립고 다시보고싶다
One of the best live girl group
전효성 춤 진짜 잘추는구나.. 외모에 실력이 묻혂다 진짜
I think Jieun has one of the best (and my favorite) sweet voices in kpop/that I know of from the world music I listen to. I prefer when she sings slow songs because its really comforting to me to listen to~ I love secret so much!
Secret has the best live performance out of all the girl groups and you can't even deny it. They sound exactly like the cd version they're amazing.
I'm still watching this on 2019. I really like this song
Yes! But I'm more like "I really love secret." 😭👍💕
라이브 맛집임 진짜... 노래 의상 안무 세련되고 멋있음
라이브 장난 없네..ㄷㄷ
이때 비주얼 노래 탑찍었네 다들 너무 이쁜데 👍
WOWOWOWOWOWOWOW I DIDNT KNOW THAT JIEUN WAS SUCH A GOOD SINGER, I found this group yesterday and I thought she was just a visual but her voice blew me away
I found the them after watching Hyoseungs Find Me
+Lily Christina omfg me too! I mean this is the first Secret song i've listened to.
Please listen to jieun's song 'don't look at me like that'. You will realised how good she is ❤
Polar Light I found it before this song and i loved the concept of it, I was so upset that she didn't get enough attention for it, I knew she was a good singer but I never really payed attention to her so I regret that a lot. Looking foward to her solo song tho- it's coming soon
I need this girls back😭
please comeback soon secret :-( i miss you a lot
Every live Jieun's outfit is the best
Era when most groups sing live and all real talents 😭
비쥬얼 실력 재능 진짜 ㅅㅌㅊ데 하 삼푸회사 빡치네
Their stage presence and live vocals are INSANELY GREAT
다들 리즈네 개이쁘다 ㅔ
These girls deserve more recognition!! They all can sing and dance very well. I hope they will win a trophy with their next comeback
5년전인데 진짜 예쁘네 ,,
반짝반짝 빛이 ✨ 💖 💕 나네요
🎵 노래가 신이 나네요 추억의 시크릿 이네요
I miss SECRET a lot!
Look how they have a stage presence, sing live, dance, anyway ... beautiful!
hyosung....daaaamn gurl. keep working it, cuz u doin it right
It's real live singing!!!! I miss them
still the best live girl group ever. They are unmatched when it comes to live vocals as a group
I need a SECRET comeback. Right now T_T
same
Honestly SECRET always brings out amazing songs... it's annoying how they're not getting the attention they deserve
2014 was the most memorable and historical event in KPOP. Because all of the greatest Groups disbanded and release their final songs with co-golden era artists. Their era will never be replace
시크릿 노래 다 좋음
0:20 도입부 너무 찰짐 빰빠밤
I will never stop listening to this
2022 and still rewatcing all their performances, idols dont perform like this anymore sad but its true their just showing their visual and dance no hate but i miss this era so much this is what i called IDOLS
ji eun looks so good with black hair
세트도 분위기 있어서 좋고 여름이라서 보기에 하얀 코디도 시원하고 과하게 안마르고 사람답게 말라보여서 좋고 라이브도 멤버마다 시원시원하고 그래서 후렴구 사운드도 풍부하고 춤도 다들 열심히 추고 끼도 다들 잘하고 속이 시원해지는 퍼펙트한 무대에요 심지어 노래가 좋아서 찾아본 무대인데 말이에요 약간 에바라면 저렇게 열심히 하는데 체력 다 앗아가고 아플 신발 정도요
OMG ALL OF THEM ARE SOO PRETTY
My Unnies. 😭 It's still unfortunate that TS wasn't able to protect their artists well. But I'm glad they're finally free and are still striving. I miss them so much though. 🥲
after KARA comeback we need them ASAP they were the best
period
Their Vocal and Visual is no joke . Kpop Now Need something like this . True Talents .
진심 진짜 다 아름답다...
They never showed disappointing performances.The most professional group ever.
I remember this girls... 2019 😭😭😭😭
Years later and there're still no one doing it like Secret.
song ji eun voice is beautiful..the best voice in her group..just my opinion..
섹시 청순 다 잘하는 이런 걸그룹을 매력 잘뽑아낸 만큼 잘 대우해줬으면 좋았을텐데 그저 돈버는 기계로만 봤으니 쯔쯔 소속사 망할놈들
노래 너무 좋아 ㅠㅠ 이것도 떡상했으면 ㅠㅠ
정말 밸런스가 잘 맞는 걸그룹 ㅠ 그립다
헐 다 죤나 예뻐.....
라이브를 너무 잘해서 음원으로 듣는 것 보다 라이브만 들음.. 농담아니고 라이브만 듣는 가수는 시크릿 밖에 없음
후렴 너무 좋다
Ok but can we talk about how EXCELLENT this live performance was vocal-wise? I've seen so many good performances from them over the years, but either I didn't watch this one when it was uploaded, or I forgot. But damn that was good from start to finish.
Almost 2 years without comeback. Seriously I need their music !!!
I miss Secret so much 😭 5 years soon
선화 너무말랐다ㅜㅜ
다들 너무 이뻐진듯!특히 징거랑 지은이 너무이뻐요-
hyosung is really pretty without bangs. :D
시크릿 존예네;; 어릴때 왜 몰랐냐..
2ND GENERATION ARE VERY TALENTED AND PRETTY. I STILL LOVE THE 2ND GENERATION LIKE SECRET, SISTAR, 4MINUTE, ETC ETC
I'm starting to love these Girls,they are so talented :)
SoneKath and pretty
secret comeback plsssss!!!
I’ve liked them since i was in junior high. And after all this time.. i still think that secret has the most stable live singing-while dancing performance compared to all girlgroups i have seen so far
I almost agree with you, coz there is also Brown Eyed Girls, their skill is insane. Sistar has 2 big vocalists, but the other 2 have little singing part. Bora handles all of rap part, while Dasom has quite a weak voice.
They r all really pretty and talented but ji eun and hyosung r really vry beautiful
노래 춤 레전드 헤메코 개찰떡 ㅠ
I can't believe it's been five years! They were great.
it's already 2019 and swear I still listen to this song aloot! can't believe it's been 5 years already 😭
Anyone missing them in 2019? :(
4명다 비주얼 상타치인데 무대 표현력도 다들 씹 상타치라 그냥 무대를 꽉 채우고 씹어 먹어버리네...
I need Secret in my life!!!
The fact that they're singing LIVE, Im in love
Kimberly Rey their live vocals are so clear