19 Years go by, Thrawn rises with Crimson Dawn, Han Solo defects, finds Leia and goes with her, Luke's Jedi journey begins and the Republic-Crimson Dawn war rages on until Luke becomes a Jedi Knight
Luke may have helped him find Obi Wan. So, Luke’s journey might start sooner because of that (this would also mean Han never becomes involved with the Rebellion).
@@starwarsquill Does that mean a possibility of Obi-Wan training both Luke and Ezra three years earlier? How does the confrontation with Thrawn on Lothal play out with Obi-Wan there? Heck Obi-Wan may go with Ezra and Thrawn, taking Luke along so he'd have uninterrupted decades to train both? Honestly this scenario can go in so many ways besides this one. It'll be fun when someone finally does it.
Anakin was lucky that the Council painted him as the hero; he had withdrawn a vital piece of information and had it not been for Ahsoka's warning, the consequences could be disastorous. The best scene was Palpatine's discussion with the senators, and the Senate session that followed. Once again you show how manipulative he is. Even while battling multiple Jedi masters, he was always planning his actions carefully.
Wow I liked this one! This was very unique in that it deferred the climax of the story beyond a point which most stories don't even consider. The vast majority of fan fiction treats the confrontation that happens in ROTS as close to the limit for when the jedi will confront Sidious and either they already know he's Sidious or he will reveal himself in that moment if he hasn't revealed himself to Anakin already. This is unique in that it departs from that 'fixed point' without totally derailing the original plot and I really found it to be an interesting approach.
What an excellent Video/Fan Fiction basedd on What if Anakin Didn’t tell Mace Windu about Palpatine being Sidious. Can you please create a part2 based on What if Anakin Didn’t tell Mace Windu about Palpatine? Thank you Star Wars Quill.
What if Revan wasn't found in stasis until the first year of the clone wars? That would mean that Revan in his prime would be alive and well, and Darth Vitiate's spirit would still be dormant since Revan didn't awake his spirit at Yavin.
I would say after this that either Plagueis or Palpatine would come back. We know Anakin is the chosen one who will destroy the Sith, so having other Jedi destroy them would be going against the property. I would say that they try to call Anakin back to the order but initially he refuses. He later changes his mind based on 2 things: (1) He realizes that the return of the Sith is a threat to his family and (2) he views this as a way to atone for his past mistakes by finally ending the Sith threat once and for all
Anakin came within a hairs breadth of doing the right thing. It was Mace Windu trying to perpetrate an extrajudicial killing of Palpatine pushed Anakin over the edge into the Dark side.
What if Count Dooku became General Grevious? Dooku, early into the war, suffers a horrific injury and is forced into the same suit Grevious would have originally had
i think after some time had passed after anikin left the order he’d have started training luke and lea in the jedi arts and regained his place in the jedi order as a master that eventually learned how to balance both light and darkside powers bringing a new jedi order into power
What if captain Fox stumbled across Windu v Palpatine fight, but not knowing that the wrinkled up electric boi going unlimited power on Windu, shot him dead?
If SW wasn't bought by Disney, to continue on this storyline, Anakin&Obiwan would had finally mentioned their encounter of the Yuuzhan Vong on Zenoma Sekot. In the Clone Wars cartoons, the 6&7th season would had been about the clone troopers' encounter with the Vongs&possibility of a Yuuzhan Vong invasion. So instead of dismantling the CIS' droid armies, they'd be repurposed for dealing with the early Vong invasion.
It's an odd way, but in his silence and plan to save Palpatine, Anakin did bring balance to the Force! He killed Dooku, he trained Ashoka, who caught Maul, and by his response, or lack of, to Ashoka's words, him plan reviled Darth Sidious. His actions and inactions brought balance to the Force! Anakin would not be called back to the Jedi Order as there was no need for him!
I don't know if this is good but here goes. What if Vader killed Palpatine NOT to redeem hismelf but make himself a Sith master, still wising to make Luke his apprentice?
@StarWarsQuill What if Anakin refused to leave Tatooine until his mother is freed and that mint that Qui-Gon Jinn and Ob-Wan Kenobi would have to return to Tatooine to Teach Anakin
@harmannbhasin9170 Yeah Palpatine would be like"This young Padawan defeated a dark user more powerful than council members.....I will watch his career with great interest....
What's mundi doing during all this tho? Smoking spice while muttering under his breath "but what about the droid attack on the wookies?" while stuck on mygeeto , forgotten by his troops, with a broken communicator?
What if anakin fell in love with luminara unduli or what if luminara unduli fell in love with anakin. This is an interesting one sense both have different interpretations on the code and life
@@matthewbarabas3052except it’s a what if, they’re tons of possibilities for this story that would do anything including involving yoda, he maybe a baby but look at how Ahsoka was able to communicate with him despite him being a baby.
I think with anikan leaving and seeing how the jedi's fear of emotion and self-righteousness is what led to anikan seeking palpatine for support, and after a few months of anikan and ahsoka being non-jedi force users with families and jobs, raising luke and leia with healthy attachments rather than no attachments, the jedi would hopefully change their tune and request them all back in the order after massive changes. For instance, they are not part of the republic but individual jedi can have lives outside the order, including, working with the republic. and 2 children who want to become jedi are trained at jedi schools but live with their parents, and adults can become jedi too.
Only issues i have is 1. Anakin didnt destroy the sith. 2. He didnt bring balance to the force. So if you did a part 2 i feel like an ancient sith would have to return and corrupt anakin and have him destroy the order and than later on Anakin would destroy this sith
Remember, Yoda in the movie said that the prophecy could be misread. Anakin destroyed the Sith unintentionally since that listening device was on him, informing the Jedi so he was present from a certain point of view. Remember, we never see the text of the prophecy. I could argue that he didn't destroy Palps in Return since Star Wars characters including Maul have survived falls. In fact, a fall would be the last way I'd kill a mortal enemy. Comes back to bite you to much in stories. Yes the reacter was below, but the Force was a thing. I'm not saying the movies did it wrong, I'm merely providing context for fanfics like this.
@@darthbane3937 The sequels are subpar in quality and full of plotholes due to each movie having a different person writing/directing it. In terms of Maul it was "he was too angry to die" and rebuilt his lower half (with a spider body) to allow himself to survive. Palp was thrown down a tube electrocuting himself before the death star blew up so I doubt he survived or had any faint chance of surviving. And while yes the prophecy could be misread the way it was in canon which is Anakin had to bring balance to the force (aka destroy the jedi) and than destroyed the sith.
You know what is Interesting what if is that what if Anakin didn’t turn but was the only Jedi that survived order 66
What if u did that? I dont mean that in a disrespectful way but why give such a good idea to someone else?
@@krankkid7394 simple why not giving this idea to someone else plus I don’t have time to thing like this
@@kage_fire well by that logic you'd end up giving all your ideas away and never doing anything
@@krankkid7394 welcome to society
19 Years go by, Thrawn rises with Crimson Dawn, Han Solo defects, finds Leia and goes with her, Luke's Jedi journey begins and the Republic-Crimson Dawn war rages on until Luke becomes a Jedi Knight
What if anakin just called mace windu instead of leaving the Sith Lord they’ve been looking for alone
that would have been a much, much, better idea.
A Hishe idea
@@0predaking0 that’s where I got the inspiration from
What if Ezra Bridger missed Obi-Wan and stumbled onto Luke Skywalker when he went to Tantooine?
Luke may have helped him find Obi Wan. So, Luke’s journey might start sooner because of that (this would also mean Han never becomes involved with the Rebellion).
@@starwarsquill
Does that mean a possibility of Obi-Wan training both Luke and Ezra three years earlier? How does the confrontation with Thrawn on Lothal play out with Obi-Wan there? Heck Obi-Wan may go with Ezra and Thrawn, taking Luke along so he'd have uninterrupted decades to train both? Honestly this scenario can go in so many ways besides this one. It'll be fun when someone finally does it.
@@starwarsquillthe rebellion needed smugglers so maybe they would have crossed paths briefly
Han still could at some point.
29:51
Darth Corleone....foiled yet again!
Anakin was lucky that the Council painted him as the hero; he had withdrawn a vital piece of information and had it not been for Ahsoka's warning, the consequences could be disastorous.
The best scene was Palpatine's discussion with the senators, and the Senate session that followed. Once again you show how manipulative he is. Even while battling multiple Jedi masters, he was always planning his actions carefully.
Wow I liked this one! This was very unique in that it deferred the climax of the story beyond a point which most stories don't even consider. The vast majority of fan fiction treats the confrontation that happens in ROTS as close to the limit for when the jedi will confront Sidious and either they already know he's Sidious or he will reveal himself in that moment if he hasn't revealed himself to Anakin already. This is unique in that it departs from that 'fixed point' without totally derailing the original plot and I really found it to be an interesting approach.
Kolar spoke up first because he was tired of dying in these what-ifs.
Never mind……..Finished the video
Never mind……. Finished the video.
What an excellent Video/Fan Fiction basedd on What if Anakin Didn’t tell Mace Windu about Palpatine being Sidious. Can you please create a part2 based on What if Anakin Didn’t tell Mace Windu about Palpatine? Thank you Star Wars Quill.
What if Revan wasn't found in stasis until the first year of the clone wars? That would mean that Revan in his prime would be alive and well, and Darth Vitiate's spirit would still be dormant since Revan didn't awake his spirit at Yavin.
What if the republic used droids and the separatists used clones in the clone war?
Interesting idea, man :)
@@starwarsquill Thanks
@@starwarsquill your what ifs are rly good
I would say after this that either Plagueis or Palpatine would come back. We know Anakin is the chosen one who will destroy the Sith, so having other Jedi destroy them would be going against the property. I would say that they try to call Anakin back to the order but initially he refuses. He later changes his mind based on 2 things: (1) He realizes that the return of the Sith is a threat to his family and (2) he views this as a way to atone for his past mistakes by finally ending the Sith threat once and for all
Why at 7:29 did padmes name turn into "batman"??
@@somethingyes5864 Padme is the “Coruscant bat”. She’s a fan of aggressive negotiations now. lol
Here's a fun one, what if Anakin stumbled upon the Yautja or more commonly known as the Predators
Anakin came within a hairs breadth of doing the right thing. It was Mace Windu trying to perpetrate an extrajudicial killing of Palpatine pushed Anakin over the edge into the Dark side.
Hilarious that the Jedi just kinda knew Anakin was married and didn't say anything.
What if Count Dooku became General Grevious? Dooku, early into the war, suffers a horrific injury and is forced into the same suit Grevious would have originally had
"007, I can be, Jedi Q branch, impressive they are!"
i think after some time had passed after anikin left the order he’d have started training luke and lea in the jedi arts and regained his place in the jedi order as a master that eventually learned how to balance both light and darkside powers bringing a new jedi order into power
A good potential for making the Grey Jedi cannon within the current Skywalker era!
what if anakin found a ghost fire kaber cystal and mastered the form trakata
That was a nice Al Pacino reference
Best character, that Bill Organa.
What if captain Fox stumbled across Windu v Palpatine fight, but not knowing that the wrinkled up electric boi going unlimited power on Windu, shot him dead?
Its true anderson should never have told master windows,should have gone straight to master yoghurt
If SW wasn't bought by Disney, to continue on this storyline, Anakin&Obiwan would had finally mentioned their encounter of the Yuuzhan Vong on Zenoma Sekot. In the Clone Wars cartoons, the 6&7th season would had been about the clone troopers' encounter with the Vongs&possibility of a Yuuzhan Vong invasion. So instead of dismantling the CIS' droid armies, they'd be repurposed for dealing with the early Vong invasion.
I have one. What if the jedi allow marriage and allowed families to be in the jedi temple
What if Anakin fell in love with Nute Gunray?
'After a brief brain reboot' ummmm, care to elaborate?
Anakin never got past his betrayal and the death of the Jedi masters he caused and became an abusive drunk.
I know that Fantasy Folklore did this, but what if Mace Windu killed Anakin in Revenge Of The Sith?
It's an odd way, but in his silence and plan to save Palpatine, Anakin did bring balance to the Force!
He killed Dooku, he trained Ashoka, who caught Maul, and by his response, or lack of, to Ashoka's words, him plan reviled Darth Sidious.
His actions and inactions brought balance to the Force!
Anakin would not be called back to the Jedi Order as there was no need for him!
I don't know if this is good but here goes.
What if Vader killed Palpatine NOT to redeem hismelf but make himself a Sith master, still wising to make Luke his apprentice?
@StarWarsQuill What if Anakin refused to leave Tatooine until his mother is freed and that mint that Qui-Gon Jinn and Ob-Wan Kenobi would have to return to Tatooine to Teach Anakin
What if Palpatine got dementia?
(Saw it a in comment somewhere but it hasn’t been made by anyone yet)
What if general grievous trained anakin?
What if Obi-wan became Darth Vader instead of Anakin skywalker
I think he’d have to be somehow mind controlled for that to happen :)
No it could happen if driven to it. It was said that he nearly fell when maul killed qui gon
@@starwarsquill true
@@starwarsquillI think if Anakin died in battle of Naboo Palpatine could've start to turn obi wan to the dark side
@harmannbhasin9170 Yeah Palpatine would be like"This young Padawan defeated a dark user more powerful than council members.....I will watch his career with great interest....
What if padime formed the rebellion before the end of the clone wars
What's mundi doing during all this tho? Smoking spice while muttering under his breath "but what about the droid attack on the wookies?" while stuck on mygeeto , forgotten by his troops, with a broken communicator?
Here's one: What is the NARRATOR of the story was a Jedi?
What if Padme killed Palptine and became emperor
So is this a reupload or a revamped what if?
What if anakin fell in love with luminara unduli or what if luminara unduli fell in love with anakin.
This is an interesting one sense both have different interpretations on the code and life
Oooooh good thought!!!!
What if Padme was the emperor parts 1 through 5
What if Anakin told Grogu that palpatine was sidious?
wouldnt do anything. grogu is basically a baby.
@@matthewbarabas3052except it’s a what if, they’re tons of possibilities for this story that would do anything including involving yoda, he maybe a baby but look at how Ahsoka was able to communicate with him despite him being a baby.
Palpetine isn’t strong enough to win a 5v1 lol let alone at the age he was
awesome
What if Ezra and Sabine were in love
How do you think that will go?
Would have changed Ezra's choices when he yeeted Thrawn to the unknown Regions(Peridia) by sacrificing himself, he may have did something else
@@starwarsquill Sabine will know how heroic Ezra was dealing with the Inquisitor
I don't think we need a what if for this one😂😂. I think they will fall in love in the next season of Ashoka.
I think with anikan leaving and seeing how the jedi's fear of emotion and self-righteousness is what led to anikan seeking palpatine for support, and after a few months of anikan and ahsoka being non-jedi force users with families and jobs, raising luke and leia with healthy attachments rather than no attachments, the jedi would hopefully change their tune and request them all back in the order after massive changes.
For instance, they are not part of the republic but individual jedi can have lives outside the order, including, working with the republic. and 2 children who want to become jedi are trained at jedi schools but live with their parents, and adults can become jedi too.
subspace transmission? they stole it from star trek- :P
Batman? What?
Jajajajajajaja!
9:24 CNN?
Only issues i have is 1. Anakin didnt destroy the sith. 2. He didnt bring balance to the force. So if you did a part 2 i feel like an ancient sith would have to return and corrupt anakin and have him destroy the order and than later on Anakin would destroy this sith
Remember, Yoda in the movie said that the prophecy could be misread. Anakin destroyed the Sith unintentionally since that listening device was on him, informing the Jedi so he was present from a certain point of view. Remember, we never see the text of the prophecy. I could argue that he didn't destroy Palps in Return since Star Wars characters including Maul have survived falls. In fact, a fall would be the last way I'd kill a mortal enemy. Comes back to bite you to much in stories. Yes the reacter was below, but the Force was a thing. I'm not saying the movies did it wrong, I'm merely providing context for fanfics like this.
@@darthbane3937 The sequels are subpar in quality and full of plotholes due to each movie having a different person writing/directing it. In terms of Maul it was "he was too angry to die" and rebuilt his lower half (with a spider body) to allow himself to survive. Palp was thrown down a tube electrocuting himself before the death star blew up so I doubt he survived or had any faint chance of surviving. And while yes the prophecy could be misread the way it was in canon which is Anakin had to bring balance to the force (aka destroy the jedi) and than destroyed the sith.
What if Anakin didn't tell Mace Windu that Palptine wasn't Sidous and what if Anakin was a spy for Palestine ?