What Went Wrong With Arcane?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 24 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 37

  • @Blockhaj
    @Blockhaj Місяць тому +11

    great sumation: s2 was not connected to s1 and was too short

    • @SuperGoody
      @SuperGoody  Місяць тому

      @@Blockhaj I would've loved a few more episodes but ofc that'd be a massive ask 😄

  • @AlphaHydrod
    @AlphaHydrod Місяць тому +6

    5:33 You're right about that. I remember necrit saying that Jinx in the lore should be around 40 or so in current time? Taliyah is also portrayed as a teenager in game but is currently a young adult for example.
    In Necrit's most recent Riot interview, we know that Warwick is "eventually" going to turn into the wolf and Jayce/Viktor are currently not dead. I not angry with Riot having inconsistencies for the nth time because anyone paying even a bit of attention to lore knows that much. You also mentioned how Riot is making Arcane canon for sales and I would strongly argue against that. The reason is that Riot has never showed an interest in handling its world building even now. We only get stories or lore updates when they need to add a new champ to game. They're using Arcane because the show has a coherent timeline where people we care about exist and not Ionia 500 years ago or some crap. Writers need to acknowledge that settings are largely a vehicle for storytelling and our current league roster has people only interact with only a few people on occasion. Your favorite champ is Shaco? Get bent says Riot Games. Viktor and the current Piltover/Zaun situation is going to be hell on the lore and getting them to a state where they can exist in setting is going to be a pain - assuming their personalities are kept intact. I actually do like new Viktor a lot, but turning him into a mage makes him lose so much of himself that I can see why ViktorMains are upset even if they do like Vik as he was in Arcane. The big "issue" in my opinion is that every champ not currently in Arcane is currently non-canon. It feels bad knowing they're going to drop the ball again like they've always done with every event and now the 3rd great lore overhaul.

    • @SuperGoody
      @SuperGoody  Місяць тому

      @@AlphaHydrod well put! Here's hoping the new canon is something we can all love 🤞🏽

  • @opiekunem
    @opiekunem Місяць тому +5

    I enjoyed arcane way more before it was 100% the canon and wanted more an idea on writing the characters going forward from what we already have in the lore to make the stories more fleshed out. We already had lore on lor that reflected the changes riot made in the last few years so just make it a platform to go way up

    • @SuperGoody
      @SuperGoody  Місяць тому

      @@opiekunem yeah I feel that, I kinda wanted to see how arcane would deviate from canon lore
      I'm so curious how Camille, zeri, seraphine etc would exist in arcane
      Kinda sad so much story will get overwritten

  • @TheJohnyFreeman
    @TheJohnyFreeman Місяць тому +4

    Bro, so much facts here summed up only in a 10 minute video - great job

    • @SuperGoody
      @SuperGoody  Місяць тому

      @@TheJohnyFreeman thank you, took a massive effort! ♥️

  • @goopo5320
    @goopo5320 Місяць тому +4

    The end to both WW normal form and viktor as a whole was too short and didn't make any sense to me.
    I am just glad I don't play league, I hope you can quit the addiction one day.

    • @SuperGoody
      @SuperGoody  Місяць тому

      @@goopo5320 I hope so too 😔

  • @chienduongquang8087
    @chienduongquang8087 Місяць тому +13

    ngl, I really enjoy Arcane ss2. Before arcane become famous, I waited like 6 years for ss1 and it was a masterpiece. And now to see it ending riddle with controversy is sad to me. Riot game is a mega corp now and making money become the priority number 1 and trust me when I say there is no way we gonna see anything ever top Arcane quality coming out from Riot anymore. Hope they can prove me wrong.

    • @SuperGoody
      @SuperGoody  Місяць тому +2

      @@chienduongquang8087 I absolutely agree. Even despite how it ended, I still adore arcane and I still consider it a masterpiece
      There has been some recent news about spin offs that look interesting so I'll digest that and some other thoughts into another video
      I think the talent at riot is just incredible and I can't wait to see more!

    • @Incepter.
      @Incepter. Місяць тому +1

      The thing is I didn't even feel like it was rushed when I watched it, of course I'm no scriptwriter and probably because I didn't have to wait for the acts.
      I was just enjoying Arcane and in my opinion Season 2 was better than Season 1. Looking back yeah it definitely feels rushed once I heard people point it out but that still doesn't change my opinion on Season 2.

    • @SuperGoody
      @SuperGoody  Місяць тому

      @Incepter. I'm the same, I only really noticed it in retrospect because I was enjoying the watch so much (especially s2 episode 7)

    • @John_Kennedy27
      @John_Kennedy27 Місяць тому

      Why are you doing ss instead of s for season? Are you doing one letter per syllable? 🤣

    • @chienduongquang8087
      @chienduongquang8087 Місяць тому +1

      @John_Kennedy27 I mean ss for Sea-Son. Also we just use to call shows ss1, ss2 in Vietnam.

  • @Alan-TFT
    @Alan-TFT Місяць тому +3

    I think they really captured Viktor's essence in TFT. The board wide stun is reminiscent of the Arcane finale.
    As for LOL, the general consensus I see is that he looks worse than his original design, which does agree with him losing 'the machine herald' title.
    Anyway, its good to see youre still making videos.

    • @SuperGoody
      @SuperGoody  Місяць тому

      @@Alan-TFT yeah I've been struggling recently but I always enjoy making a video
      Also, I do think that tft's portrayal is the closest but there's still inaccuracies so I'm torn 🤷🏽

  • @aprilmoon5330
    @aprilmoon5330 Місяць тому +1

    I loved season 2. It is cannon. Multiverse is cannon in LOL, that's why skins exists with their own stories. So yeah, I loved them embracing the crazyness, and I thinks they did it with courage and it was brilliant.

  • @hybrid2069
    @hybrid2069 29 днів тому +3

    For me, canonizing Arcane could've also represented an opportunity to ameliorate the existing lore, instead of being viewed as subordinate and constrained because of it. Viktor's arc proved that the writers had enough creative freedom to redefine a story without aligning it to a pre-established narrative. I believe the issue lies in the execution, for as ambitious their ideas were, they couldn't properly showcase them within Arcane before being deployed to other media. The external pressure and need of monetization is palpable, and it definitely hurt the overall quality and purity of the show.
    Great analysis, keep it up!

    • @SuperGoody
      @SuperGoody  29 днів тому

      @@hybrid2069I could feel the same sentiments with arcane
      also thank you, I will!

  • @sora2339
    @sora2339 Місяць тому +1

    Season 2 Spoilers explaining the storm
    The storm referenced is the storm that destroyed Piltover in the alternate timeline
    They initially setup for the hexgate being the cause but based on the alternate world Jayce corpse mirroring the fight at the end it is clear that Viktor winning causes it
    It is also possible that the iterations of champion in both League and TFT are not what we have seen yet
    If warwick is still alive (which I assume he is) the TFT version would be a midpoint in his evolution towards League Warwick
    Mels skills in TFT clearly outclass her skills in the show and are from a future version so it is relatively possible
    Heimerdinger still has a long way to go between Arcane and his in game presentation too

    • @SuperGoody
      @SuperGoody  Місяць тому

      @@sora2339 I tried to draw the same dots between the final fight with Viktor but it felt more like the infinite tsyukomi from Naruto
      But that's a great point, I wonder how far ahead they've thought of each character arcs

    • @sora2339
      @sora2339 29 днів тому

      @@SuperGoody They probably havent thought that far ahead. They have a habbit of just retroactively making things make sense or retconning stuff when they mess it up

    • @SuperGoody
      @SuperGoody  29 днів тому

      @@sora2339 you're probably right but I'll hope for the small chance they thought that far ahead 😁

  • @MisterG-Tv
    @MisterG-Tv 29 днів тому

    Nothing the video is finished. Thank you 🤚

    • @SuperGoody
      @SuperGoody  29 днів тому

      @@MisterG-Tv you're welcome 🤗

  • @fergusnicoll
    @fergusnicoll 28 днів тому

    Nothing it was great. Nothing will ever be good enough for the complainers.

    • @SuperGoody
      @SuperGoody  28 днів тому

      to be fair, i would usually agree with you but i do think the ending of s2 had noticeable issues, like the pacing
      i love the show so much, it's so close to perfect

  • @John_Kennedy27
    @John_Kennedy27 Місяць тому

    Honestly man you make good videos but you put so much unnecessary emphasis on random syllables and it's quite hard to listen to

    • @SuperGoody
      @SuperGoody  Місяць тому +3

      @@John_Kennedy27 that's fair, I apologise for that
      I'm in the process of learning how to read and speak in a proper way
      The journey is rough but hopefully I'll get there 😅

  • @VinnyB77
    @VinnyB77 Місяць тому +3

    Warwick went way wrong. I gave up watching once i saw what they did to him

    • @SuperGoody
      @SuperGoody  Місяць тому +1

      @@VinnyB77 I'm very curious where they will take him

    • @VinnyB77
      @VinnyB77 Місяць тому

      @SuperGoody all I know is he wins for worst TFT chibi. The man face is sooooo ugly