Schön das endlich mal wieder anständige Musik im deutschen Fernsehen läuft! Aber verdammt ZDF WARUM PLAYBACK??? VOA ist eine absolute Live-Band...let the beast out of his cage damn!
Im Gegensatz zu 90 % der Schlagerfutzis die sonst dort aufschlagen, hätten sie es live auch genauso gut dargebotenen!!! Ich mag die Band von Anfang an und freue mich sehr, das es jetzt mit dem Linup so gut läuft!
I'm amazed at the success of the band Visions of Atlantis with the age group of people... and I'm not even surprised, when I bought the latest album Pirates, I keep playing it.
Love the band, hate German broadcast performances since it is all 100% playback of the song with the band just "performing" it. You can hear the layering of the vocals on the album as Clem is singing, the drums have no mics mounted, and half the time when Christian does a slide, you don't hear it at all.
I guess sometimes you have to sacrifice a little bit in return for a exposure, especially when it comes to German mainstream media who generally completelty ignore everything metal. It's a shame because they don't need it, but it's nothing they need to be ashamed of.
It was amazing seen them live (my 1st time) a few weeks ago in Weinheim, Germany, after that night, they became my #1 favorite band :D Hope to see them live many more times
@@MetaLMaDneSS1 Ну, во-первых, Клементина прекрасна сама по себе, а во-вторых, звук похож на волне живой, с подложенным минусом, конечно. И в любом случае, живое исполнение есть с того же Вейкена и многих других шоу, так что сомневаться в способностях группы это сыграть и исполнить явно не стоит. ;)
The first two lines reminded me of "Cruel Summer", but I didn't remember the title, so thanks for the one-hour mind search 😅 Great performance btw guys! 🙂 Thanks to Marko Hietala for introducing me to Clémentine and her beautiful voice! 😍
I'm so used to seeing them in live on youtube that this time in playback it's really weird. I don't understand why the TV show forces the artists to do playback when they are 100 times better in live?. I presume it's a lot of work for them you know to have sound ingenior, material and probably to evoid any problem. It's easier and safer to put a playback for the tv show :-(
They were clearly forced to mime this performance (looks like it's for broadcast, and btw terribly mixed) however they do perform live usually and they sound great live. Bands are often forced to do this for broadcast stuff. There are examples of artists protesting this, such as the banana protest by the mamas and the papas on the ed sullivan show.
Yes, VoA performed in a German TV show called "ZDF Fernsehgarten". Unfortunately they were forced to perform with playback. So you can hear the normal album version of the song.
Ich war für einen Moment LEICHT schockiert, aber ich gehöre auch zu den neuen Fans von Visions of Atlantis daher hab ich nicht alles nachverfolgen können :)
Après avoir visionné cette vidéo et écouté attentivement la chanson, je me pose vraiment la question si ce n'était pas du playback, il y a un écho comme la chanson enregistré avec le clip originale. J'ai également écouter un autre live (mais pas de cette chanson) et il y a clairement un rendu différent. Malgré tout j'adore le groupe et ce qu'ils font mais sur ce live je suis sceptique.
Symphonic metal in the broad daylight just seems a bit off. Still, they sound amazing. Clementine is an angel. Such wonderful stage presence, and so TALL...my beautiful gothic beanpole! 😍🖤🖤💔
They definitely sounds good live! Unfortunately it's the rule of ZDF Fernsehgarten to perform on playback. What you hear is the studio version of the song.
Wenn ich Musiker wäre und egal welche Musik ich machen würde(Alles bis auf Schlager, Volksmusik oder Ballermann Musik würde ich alles Produzieren) ich würde niemals in dieser Spießer Sendung auftreten.
Sorry... but it just doesn't sound that studio perfect, especially after all that jumping. 3:05-3:15 is exactly identical to the studio version, meaning we're listening to a playback. Anyone who's ever seen any band live, even amazing performers, knows that even if they sound better than the studio, they still don't 100% replicate every detail from the studio version, especially not after jumping around like that. Too bad, they're absolutely great live, so I don't know why they would do this. Or maybe the uploader did it, who knows. I just wanted to hear them do this song :/ EDIT: 3:28 - 3:32 part is also completely identical, EVEN during jumping. Come on, just why fuck with the audio, whoever it was?
These are the rules of the ZDF Fernsehgarten... Every artist who performs there must do it on playback. Of course, VoA have the potential to do it live, but that's the way it is...
@@VoASailors That's too bad :( it's basically not allowing the band to actually flourish because they're so insecure about the artists playing wrong or badly that they don't even give the band a chance to show what they're truly made of, just because they want it to sound good. That's the feeling I get everytime an event or place has a rule like that.
Beim ZDF sind sie es nicht gewohnt, dass Interpreten auch live performen könnten....das kennen sie von den Schlagerdödeln nicht, die es ja nicht mal schaffen lippensynchron Playback zu "singen".... 😄
Schön das endlich mal wieder anständige Musik im deutschen Fernsehen läuft!
Aber verdammt ZDF WARUM PLAYBACK???
VOA ist eine absolute Live-Band...let the beast out of his cage damn!
Im Gegensatz zu 90 % der Schlagerfutzis die sonst dort aufschlagen, hätten sie es live auch genauso gut dargebotenen!!! Ich mag die Band von Anfang an und freue mich sehr, das es jetzt mit dem Linup so gut läuft!
RIP Nichole Bogner 😇🥲 This is GREAT!
Oh to be in such a small intimate audience hearing my fave VoA song!
Germans are hard core! This is a good morning program!
Aye, aye, Captain Clementine!
I really like Clementine's angelic voice
I'm amazed at the success of the band Visions of Atlantis with the age group of people... and I'm not even surprised, when I bought the latest album Pirates, I keep playing it.
Bin zufällig bei Spotify Auf VOA gestolpert und seid dem Schon einige Male Pirates Gehört hat mich voll von denn Socken gehauen 🤘🤘
Den Standard-Zuschauer hat es da sicher rückwärts vom Stuhl gedrückt.
ja weil der Sänger lächerlich ist
Der Sänger kann singen im Gegensatz zu den Schlagersängern und Sängerinnen Metal ist kein Mainstream wie Schlager🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🎸🤘🖤🎸🤘🍺🍺🍺 Mfg Robert
Endlich mal vernünftige und gute Musik im Fernsehgarten
Wenn sie (also das ZDF) nun auch endlich wieder Live-Musik zulassen würde, statt alles mit Playback zu verhunzen...
Neue Zielgruppe
Love the band, hate German broadcast performances since it is all 100% playback of the song with the band just "performing" it. You can hear the layering of the vocals on the album as Clem is singing, the drums have no mics mounted, and half the time when Christian does a slide, you don't hear it at all.
I guess sometimes you have to sacrifice a little bit in return for a exposure, especially when it comes to German mainstream media who generally completelty ignore everything metal. It's a shame because they don't need it, but it's nothing they need to be ashamed of.
who doesn't Love this ?
Mal ein ganz anderer Fernsehgarten...SUPER...und Kiwi sah toll aus .❣️❣️
Da muss ich zu stimmen. Das stimmt, denn Kiwi sieht toll aus 😘
Best live footage, yet!
She is pretty wonderful!
I loved you in exit Eden and still do great music
Gänsehaut pur danke für den tollen Tag im Fernsehgarten liebes ZDF!!
BULLSHIT!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I really like Clementine's operetta voice, I get chills when I hear her sing, she has a beautiful voice.
I really liked this song and very cool band!!
A Clémentine tem uma beleza única!
Guter Rock , war top im Fernsehgarten
albm super la chantesue merveilleuse voix, look charmante jolie en capitaine .
Love this song..
Любимая ушастенькая француженка
прикольная барышня. Не знаю чем, но меня она привлекает. Да и голос нравится
My friends, my friends, I love these people! Finally getting the recognition they deserve!
GREAT SONG
Beautiful 🖤🤘🙏
It was amazing seen them live (my 1st time) a few weeks ago in Weinheim, Germany, after that night, they became my #1 favorite band :D
Hope to see them live many more times
Sehr schön
Such an amazing preformce by everyone!!! The guitar, the the drums, the bass, and the vocals it's truly breath taking!!!
just Playback , as always in the Fersehgarten
if you couldn't tell that this wasn't a live performance then you're a lost cause
Amazing!
Fabuloso , terrible.bandaaaaa !!! Vamosss.Clementine !!!
Très belle 2e performance à la télévision allemande! 🤩
Super Lied.
BULLSHIT!!!!!!!!
Clementine 🥰😍
Awesome. Greetings from Norway.
Clementine ❤️
Waoooooo excelente!!!!!!!! Saludos desde Panamá City 🇵🇦
Estos tipos de bandas llegaran a nuestro pais algun dia😕🙁?
И огромное спасибо твоей команде.. вы лучшие...настоящие!!!
Шикарное исполнение. Клементина неподражаема 😍❤💓
исполнение чего ? Если это не живой звук.
@@MetaLMaDneSS1 Ну, во-первых, Клементина прекрасна сама по себе, а во-вторых, звук похож на волне живой, с подложенным минусом, конечно. И в любом случае, живое исполнение есть с того же Вейкена и многих других шоу, так что сомневаться в способностях группы это сыграть и исполнить явно не стоит. ;)
@@user-hn7re4wo5y я и не сомневаюсь что они могут вживую сыграть.
Super 💀 Auftritt 🎸🤘🔥🎤
Fascinating.
Nichts gegen die Band aber der Spießer ZDF Fernsehgarten und ihre Playback Vorgaben sind echt "Großartig".....
thank you for your persistence
Se escuchó increíble ahora que vinieron a tocar a la cuidad de Mexico 👏👏👏👍
Like it lol great song lol
The first two lines reminded me of "Cruel Summer", but I didn't remember the title, so thanks for the one-hour mind search 😅 Great performance btw guys! 🙂 Thanks to Marko Hietala for introducing me to Clémentine and her beautiful voice! 😍
I LOVED
Mantap jiwa 🤘
Greeting from Indonesia 🇮🇩
Kalo ga salah vocal nya mantan Van exit edden bukan
Sehr schön! Danke
Очень зашло. Вокал шикарный
This deserves more views....
Bravo,Clemi 💗
♥️
Tolle Band und ein super Song.
BIST DU TAUB??????????
Хороши !!!Особенно вокал Девушки!!!
Danke fürs hochladen! Super Lied und tolle Band 😍
BULLSHIT!
such a great band!
Oh, mein Gott! Das ist wunderbar!!!
Что я слышу? Реинкарнация Nightwish и Sonata Arctica в одной группе?
Обожаю тебя''My Black Angel ''
🖤🖤🖤
🤘🤘🤘🙌
österreichischer metal beim fernsehgarten, sau geil \m/
Es war so mega gut🥰
Love Clementine
🦇🦇🦇🦇🦇
I don't know why in this rock in rio shit they don't call bands like Visions Of Atlantis, Delain, Epica, Ex Libris!😠. Há sim! Eu sou do Brasil!
Call them
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Take this to Eurovision pls
я уже слушаю две недели подряд каждый день по 5 раз это. что мне делать??
👏👏👏👏🤩🤩🤩🤩
I'm so used to seeing them in live on youtube that this time in playback it's really weird. I don't understand why the TV show forces the artists to do playback when they are 100 times better in live?. I presume it's a lot of work for them you know to have sound ingenior, material and probably to evoid any problem. It's easier and safer to put a playback for the tv show :-(
Where's the original audio of the performance? This is the studio version of the song. 🤔
This is the "original" audio. They had to perform this song on playback..
@@VoASailors I see. That's unfortunate.
It's a TV show! Not a concert...
They were clearly forced to mime this performance (looks like it's for broadcast, and btw terribly mixed) however they do perform live usually and they sound great live. Bands are often forced to do this for broadcast stuff. There are examples of artists protesting this, such as the banana protest by the mamas and the papas on the ed sullivan show.
Yes, VoA performed in a German TV show called "ZDF Fernsehgarten". Unfortunately they were forced to perform with playback. So you can hear the normal album version of the song.
Ich war für einen Moment LEICHT schockiert, aber ich gehöre auch zu den neuen Fans von Visions of Atlantis daher hab ich nicht alles nachverfolgen können :)
Après avoir visionné cette vidéo et écouté attentivement la chanson, je me pose vraiment la question si ce n'était pas du playback, il y a un écho comme la chanson enregistré avec le clip originale. J'ai également écouter un autre live (mais pas de cette chanson) et il y a clairement un rendu différent. Malgré tout j'adore le groupe et ce qu'ils font mais sur ce live je suis sceptique.
Hello, yes unfortunately VoA had to play on playback because it's prescribed by ZDF Fernsegarten. All bands have to play their on playback.
Great sound, nice performance but the people don't look so excited 😅
old people and fernsehgarten is normally country/schlager :D
Tolle Band. Ich gönne ihr solche Auftritte. Aber warum wird in diesen Shows fast immer Playback gespielt?
Das sind leider die Vorgaben vom Fernsehgarten :/ aber immerhin ist es Promotion für Visions Of Atlantis.
@@VoASailors Schon klar. Ist halt sch****. Sind schließlich richtige Musiker. Und der Fernsehgarten ist generell Dreck. ^^
Der Fernsehgarten scheint mutiger zu werden. Aber die Zuschauer, die wie bei den dort sonst üblichen Schlagern klatschen... 🙈😂
Хочу туда.
А зачем ?
@@kb0acl303 Странный вопрос. А зачем Вы там, где Вы сейчас?
When are you coming to Belgium ???
Visions of Atlantis will come with their ARMADA tour to Belgium this fall. Check out the exact dates on their website or social media 😊
Leider alles immer playback im fernsehegarten, muss man live hören
espetaculo
Wau, deutsche Schlagerparade 😀 . Looks a little wierd this podium for the metal band.
Symphonic Metal deluxe? :) Is somewhere non deluxe Symphonic metal? :) Or germans has different type of metal? :)
No, we don't have that, but the presenter has no idea about the metal scene 😂
Symphonic metal in the broad daylight just seems a bit off. Still, they sound amazing. Clementine is an angel. Such wonderful stage presence, and so TALL...my beautiful gothic beanpole! 😍🖤🖤💔
bah, clementine est de lyon
is this playpack? looks like ;(
Unfortunately yes, but that's the rules of ZDF Fernsehgarten. All artist who perform their have to on playback:/
Why does it sound like the are autotuning their voices? They would sound good live?
They definitely sounds good live! Unfortunately it's the rule of ZDF Fernsehgarten to perform on playback. What you hear is the studio version of the song.
Hat ein bisschen was von Nightwish
AWESOME!!!! The Drums sound amazing and with no Mics on the drums hahahahahahahaha And there are no cables on the floor LOL
"Magic" 😜😂
ZDF Fernsehgarten - ein No Go für alle engagierten Rockmusiker !
Wenn ich Musiker wäre und egal welche Musik ich machen würde(Alles bis auf Schlager, Volksmusik oder Ballermann Musik würde ich alles Produzieren) ich würde niemals in dieser Spießer Sendung auftreten.
Dulu itu bekas exit eden
They should play live , fuck the playback
Its the rules by Fernsehgarten. Not the band's decision
Sorry... but it just doesn't sound that studio perfect, especially after all that jumping. 3:05-3:15 is exactly identical to the studio version, meaning we're listening to a playback. Anyone who's ever seen any band live, even amazing performers, knows that even if they sound better than the studio, they still don't 100% replicate every detail from the studio version, especially not after jumping around like that. Too bad, they're absolutely great live, so I don't know why they would do this. Or maybe the uploader did it, who knows. I just wanted to hear them do this song :/
EDIT: 3:28 - 3:32 part is also completely identical, EVEN during jumping. Come on, just why fuck with the audio, whoever it was?
These are the rules of the ZDF Fernsehgarten... Every artist who performs there must do it on playback. Of course, VoA have the potential to do it live, but that's the way it is...
@@VoASailors That's too bad :( it's basically not allowing the band to actually flourish because they're so insecure about the artists playing wrong or badly that they don't even give the band a chance to show what they're truly made of, just because they want it to sound good. That's the feeling I get everytime an event or place has a rule like that.
Beim ZDF sind sie es nicht gewohnt, dass Interpreten auch live performen könnten....das kennen sie von den Schlagerdödeln nicht, die es ja nicht mal schaffen lippensynchron Playback zu "singen".... 😄
wie das gestellte Publikum da immer apathetisch mitklatscht
Was soll man vom Spießer Fernsehgarten auch anderes erwarten.
@@MasterofTheUniverse1337 Dass sie bei Hier kommt Alex im Gesicht sehr irritiert aussehen, aber trotzdem brav mitklatschen?
oh man you cant play this band in a sunday morning Pensioners' show thats a no go
Vocal back track?
complete playback... the TV show demands it, not the bands decision
Nice song . but the only problem here is the amps are off . they are playing playback . and its not good for metal music 😔
Totally! But that are the rules of ZDF Fernsehgarten, unfortunately :/