Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Episode 64 || Reaction & Discussion
Вставка
- Опубліковано 12 лис 2024
- Gain Early Access, Clear, and Extended Reactions to ALL episodes now!
Patreon ► / castsenpai
Follow me on Twitch!
Twitch ► / castoreh
Socials:
Twitter ► / castsenpai
Instagram ► / castsenpai_
TikTok ► tiktok.com/Cast...
Buy me something? (Throne) ► thrn.co/u/cast...
Check out what anime I have seen before you request reactions! Follow me on AniList!
AniList► anilist.co/use...
Copyright:
All clips and images used in this video were used ONLY as a means to review and criticize and should be considered as FAIR USE, under the Copyright act.
#FMAB #FullmetalAlchemist #Reaction
🖤
Fun fact, the only reason Ed and Winry didn't kiss at the end is because the author said that she didn't know how to draw two people kissing, so she opted for a hug instead.
I guess this is also the reason why nobody ever kiss in this show
what's crazy about that is that this was the original manga artist's problem.....not the anime production team's. THOSE artists are fully capable of such a simple artistic feat. I've seen many shows in this kind of style....and you don't need crazy advanced gushy lip animations to convey....a kiss...even a passionate one. The head and the mouths are angular....you just overlap a few shapes and voila!....kiss. It was such a dopey thing to omit.
@@no1guy825 they respected the source material and many people enjoyed it was a hug rather than a kiss. watch any other show if you want to see kissing that much
It’s very comforting that such a skilled mangaka as her couldn’t draw a kiss, a true inspiration to artists all around the world! Love that she was honest about it haha
@@no1guy825 doesn’t matter… if the creator isn’t happy with how it looks or would look.. then it should not be forced… one thing about artist .. in general.. not just art/drawings.. but musicians too and etc… they are highly sensitive about their own work… out of respect for that.. the animation team also didn’t force it thus did non of wut u said despite how simple it would be.. so I prefer it being as is.. even this topic on this makes me appreciate that scene even more… 🥹 personal I’ll never “fix” or “change” or add to anyones work if they don’t ask an I don’t ask for permission…
I read somewhere that the way Ed holds his kid mirrors the way Hohenheim held him in their first and last family photo. But where H had tears streaming down his eyes, Ed had a huge smile mirroring his son's. Showing after everything that happened, he regrets nothing.
Fun fact: In the manga, the last chapter was what in the anime were episodes 63 and 64.
That means that:
1. In the last chapter of the manga pretty much EVERYTHING was resolved, while the last episode of the anime was mainly to close the loose ends and give the series an epilogue.
2. The studio of the anime (Bones) added some scenes, such as Havoc's (It seems like Arakawa-sensei forgot about him in the last chapter). Also, scenes such as Winry's seeing Al body for the first time in years were way shorter in the manga.
While I think overall the manga is better, I think Bones nailed it for the finale!
Thankfully Havoc wasn't completely forgotten in the manga. There was a photo where he was re-learning to walk after being healed, coached by Breda and Ross.
@@ZealSeraph i think thats a way better ending for him then it just getting magically fixed via the philosophers stone tbh
I think in terms of selim being a homunculus still, yes. He might not have all the philosophers stone souls but a homunculus is just an artificially created human. Selim was never born but was created by father so he is technically a homunculus and can never not be. But it can be noted that the homunculus still only have flesh and blood bodies and without the extra souls from the stone they get injured and die exactly the same as people.
On that note, I think that the thing on his forehead is a Band-aid.
@@chrishemry7 i think it makes more sense if its a kind of birthmark, the homunculi "zombies" also had these symbols on their back or head
In terms of endings to a series, I think this is one of my two favourites along with The Last Airbender. I can appreciate complex morality and how things don’t always work out how you hope, but sometimes it’s just nice for things to just work out well. Characters grow and take the lessons they learned throughout the series while still remaining true to who they are. Nothing wrong with a show leaving you feeling satisfied rather than with mixed feelings imo.
I hope he watches the bloopers afterwards!! :)
@Zirath Ashe OOOOO gotcha thx
@Zirath Ashe thx!
The way I snorted at "leaving his girl like him too" :"D
Tuned in every week and man what a journey. Even though I finished fmab beforehand this still gave me a bittersweet feeling 😭
Man, what a journey. I still remember that first reaction I watch of you. You were a little baby back then, but look at you now. You went through a lot to get to this moment, it was in danger of deletion and you had to stop for a while but you got past it.
Now you've reached the end of this journey, I can't wait to see your next.
I'm so proud of you, congratulations on finishing FMA:BH 🎉 and may your next adventure be enjoyable.
It's been a wild ride to be sure. 😌
Never used the thanks button before but consider it thanks for making my Sundays better every week!
Thank you for making me fall in love with this show all over again. Your insight was valuable and I could really feel the appreciation you have for it every single episode, especially these last perfect ones. Take this as a love letter to your reactions, a channel certainly made fullmetal.
Thanks, hope you can join me on other series as well. :)
Honestly one of the details I like the most here is that Ed is dressed almost exactly like Hohenheim.
What a ride this was!. Rewatching this show along your reactions was such an experience.
The way you took your time to analyze everything that the show had to offer you is something that not too many reactors that I now do, so that was a welcoming change for me. You made me love the show even more than before throughout your reactions and the way you analyzed some things that i never noticed before on my many rewatches.
Really glad you enjoyed the show and gave it the attention it deserves. I can't wait to see what else you have planned for this channel
Thanks for joining, much more to come :)
this has been one of the most engaging reactions to the series I’ve watched in a very long time. I think the thing I like the most is that you actually do take the time to really talk about some of the themes and such that you’ve noticed during the show.
just seeing the thumbnail makes me smile, love these characters so much 😭
It was amazing rewatched the entire anime with you, yours are one of the best reactions! Hope you keep doing this!
Watched the anime through over 10 times by now, with different people each time yet you were still able to bring a new perspective more times than I can count. Will no doubt watch your videos in the future, and perhaps give your twitch a try too
We cry, not from sadness but from joy
It's always nice to see people's reaction to the ending of this series. Everything felt perfect and everyone got an ending. I'm just sad they didn't adapt some of the extra stories in the manga like what Al decided to do with his old armor body and Hohenheim and Trisha's souls reuniting cause those two were heartwarming. You're gonna read the manga though so you'd probably see it one day.
I'm pretty sure what happened with Pride is Ed already learned how to use himself like a philosopher's stone. So he pushed a portion of his soul into pride and grabbed hold of his primary essence. Then he used alchemy to separate it from the philosopher's stone fused to it. Essentially pride is a homunculus with a single soul, and father's influence completely removed.
Thank you so much for going on this incredible journey! My #1 favorite anime of all time!
Thanks Blitz 😁
I was a new anime watcher, and this was an anime I have heard a lot about but never actually knew anything about it.
I finished the series within around 2 weeks, and then decided to watch your entire series for it.
You have definitely enriched my experience and memory for the series and definitely gave me a new perspective on how to think.
Definitely made my heart feel some type of way.
For that I thank you!
Hell yeah! Hope you can join me for some more anime!
Okay, so... There was no kiss because the mangaka didn't know how to draw people kissing.
I believe Roy was not fuhrer immediately because he was still too young. Anyways, Grumman, although kinda weird, is trustworthy and he's also Riza's grandfather; he constantly nagged Roy to get married to his granddaughter.
Roy and Riza CAN'T be together officially because they're part of the military. One of them should quit in order to get married and we know neither of them is going to do that.
I'm happy you enjoyed the show. It's my favorite anime ever and I love seeing people watching it for the first time bc it reminds me of how I felt when I first watched it.
"LEAVING HIS GIRL LIKE HIM" 16:49 WAS SO OUT OF POCKET 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
You noted how tall Ed got. It’s been confirmed that Ed’s growth was limited by Al being in the armor. Eds growth/food/energy however you want to describe it - was getting siphoned to keep Al’s body alive. When Al got his body back, Ed was allowed to grow again
As I heard, there was no kiss because the mangaka just couldn't draw one despite wanting to.
Can't wait to see a reaction to the Bloopers of FMAB. It's basically a tradition at this point for everyone to watch it after the show
I’ve watched a lot of people react to this show now, and your love and appreciation for it really shined through this whole series. It made it so enjoyable to watch and even made me emotional at points, despite how many times I’ve already seen it. I’ll miss this weekly dose of FMA!!
Lol I can’t stop looking at “jourenys” on the sign
I will never live this mistake down 🤣🥲
Lmao hey, it happens to the best of us my dude. 🤷♂️ Just one more thing to make this finale reaction memorable lol
This sounds like an excuse but the letters fall out of the sign all the time and I must have haphazardly fixed it. I can spell I swear.😂
16:58 man, Winry with the epic burn on most of the fans.
imo one of the most satisfying endings to a series I've seen
I'm going to miss FMAB Sundays! This has been an incredible journey. Looking forward to what's coming 🙌
I'm going to miss FMAB on Mondays.
Mustang accepting the treatment from the stone is different from the Elric brothers doing it because mustang didn’t have a choice in performing human transmutation he is a victim in losing his eyes. Where ed and al do have the sin of committing human transmutation .
My Sundays will be empty without you watching FMAB 😭😭 This ending will always make me emotional, always. At the same time it motivates me, it shows me that I can also overcome my difficulties.
If you think about it, Ling and Mei are brother and sister, just with different mothers. Their father is the Emperor, so they’re fully related by blood. This is the only time they’ve come close to interacting as actual siblings. The whole search for immortality is basically just a nationwide-scaled sibling rivalry-
can't believe this is the end! It's been such an awesome series and I've loved re-experiencing this amazing show again, loved all ur commentary and reactions, you always picked up on so much about the characters and all the details that is filled into this show, and point out new perspectives I hadn't thought of before. It's been such a fun one to follow along, so thank you :) I remember back when I was travelling, I would always try catch up on ur vids whenever I got wifi on long train journeys lol, always looked forward to them.
The last episode always makes me so emotional hahaha. Now I don’t know what to do with myself💀
Hi Cast! I met you because I wanted to watch this wonderful anime again and at the same time practice my English listening, I think I started seeing you since you were in chapter 22. I really enjoyed your company a lot, I usually don't like it when those who do reactions stop every minute the chapter, but with you it was always interesting and satisfying to listen to your theories, opinions and reflections. I'm so glad you enjoyed this anime as much as I do.
I hope watching was both fun and educational, your English seems good to me. :)
This has been a great ride, Cast! Thanks for being a perpetual face, a vicarious friend of sorts, on my Sunday mornings -- showing me another newcomer's lens into one of my favorite stories, and brandishing some perspectives and insights I hadn't necessarily heard/thought of despite how many times I'd seen it. In the time you've published this series of videos, I've gone from depressed, unemployed burnout who wanted no part of life other than working reclusively on creative projects after finishing undergrad, and making others happy when I couldn't be, to new grad student who *might* see a modicum of hope in their future as a professor. (One of the many reasons I relate most to Hohenheim.) I appreciate the stability, and the reasons to look forward to the next week, that you've contributed along the way. I don't know what's next for your channel, but I hope to keep watching along with ye~!
Congratulations on the progression of things. I know how that former position feels. Here’s to a better future! 😎
@@CastSenpai Thanks man, I vastly appreciate it! And I hope you've found/are finding fulfillment yourself, too ^_^
What a journey! Thanks for letting us join you.
The pout at the hug is hilarious!
Thanks for bringing us along on your journey watching this show. This was one of my favorite rewatches. I hope if you ever decide to watch FMA03 we can keep you company again, but either way really excited for whatever you have planned ☺️
Besides Madam Shan, no full blooded Ishvalan is ever named in the entire series
Don't forget the bloopers. Thank you for sharing your experience with us
the only photo hoenheim took with his entire family had him crying. the only photo ed took with his entire family had him have a wide-ass smile lol
An absolutely perfect ending for an absolutely perfect show
Now that the series is at the end I really thank you for giving us these amazing reactions. I very much enjoyed your analysis in each episode. They were very insightful and helped me view fmab in a new perspective. It was a wonderful journey with you.
The ending to the series was perfect in that even though it was a satisfying conclusion, you still want to see and know more of these characters.
So the idea of ‘taking 10 and giving 11’ that Alphonse talks about is something that we’ve seen Ed do twice in the show.
The first is when he heals himself after sustaining a lethal injury. The second is when he turns Selim into a baby.
In both of these instances, Ed uses his own energy to bend the laws of equivalent exchange. Because if a Philosophers stone is just an accumulation of a bunch of souls, it stands to reason that an individual can use their own life force as a stone. It’s in this way that they theorize they might be able to undo something similar to Nina’s condition.
In theory, if enough people were to get together, they could all give a piece of themselves. That combined with an altered human would give enough power to meet the equivalent exchange principle.
after saving the fucking world ed and al becomes scientists/researchers... lmao
Been following your fmab reactions since the beginning, and I've really enjoyed every step of the journey. I've watched SO MANY FMAB reactions, but this has been one of my absolute favorites, you gave the show so much serious thought and consideration, and you enjoyed the silly comedy while also embracing the dark serious aspects as well. You put a lot into this series and it really shows, thank you so much for starting this channel & sharing your experience with us! 💜
Been here from the start and just wanna say that you have made an amazing show even better for me. I’ve really enjoyed seeing you go through many of the same emotions I went through when I watched this show years ago. Even though I’ve seen the show twice before I feel that I’ve been able to see the show in a whole new light now thanks to you. You’ve somehow made a masterpiece even better with all of the insight you have brought into your reactions. Ive loved every minute of your videos and am bit sad to see FMA end for you. However, I’m super excited to see you react to more shows in the future. Can’t wait!
One interesting thing is Ed now dresses like his father
I genuinely love this series and part of what makes it great is the closure. This ending is just legendary
This was such a good show and your videos have been an amazing way for me to rewatch it. Gonna miss these videos I really enjoyed them
I think what I love most about FMA's ending is that it both is and isn't an ending in the best ways. Sure we stop following them, and that particular story is done, but we also see that their stories aren't. We know exactly what they did. They continued to grow, and love and change, all the best parts about being human. And that's what Truth wanted to teach Ed from the beginning, the greatest and simplest truth in life, is in humans learning to love being human
It’s been great finding ur channel last year for these reactions
The depiction of Roy with a beard was actually a mistake.🤣
The author did not intend to grow a beard; it was just an accidental smudge under his nose. The incorrect first draft was published in a magazine. The wrong manuscript was then handed to the animation production team, which was working on the animation at about the same time as the manga, and the same wrong manuscript was handed to them, so Roy grew a beard at the ending.
The stain was corrected in the manga when it was compiled into a book. That beard is extremely valuable!👍
By the way, now that you've seen it all, why don't you take a look back at ED1? I think you will get goosebumps in the first few seconds.
What a journey, congrats for finishing the series and your first react series. Here's to the future.
Now i will have to find something new to look forward to every week ;P
But in all seriousness ... your channel is one of my favorite reaction channels and I'm looking forward to the day where those subscription numbers will be through the roof ;)
More series on the way, no worries 🤫
I a rando has stumbled onto your channel I hope you decide to react to the bloopers as well for the people who have watched you every week reacting to this series.
OMG I can't believe I never caught the apple pie. I've watched this so many times!
What a powerful and satisfying ending. Every time I watch it I love it all the more. Thank you for sharing your journey with us, Cast.
My RoyAi (Roy x Riza) heart needs everyone to know that in the manga before Roy and the team transfered to Central, Roy was having a chess match with Grumman. They had a conversation where Grumman was offering his granddaughter's hand in marriage so she maybe the first lady of Amestris. It was never stated in the manga or anime but in one of the guidebooks for FMA Grumman's granddaughter is Riza.
Basically...Grumman ships it. The current Furher wants Roy and Riza together. 😏
Just wanted to point out how it must have felt to her to hear Al say "Stop. That tickles.".
Edit:
On that train station, when they hugged... She realized something. He's taller than her.
Hi!! Thanks a lot for your reactions to this amazing show. You thought’s always very pleasant to hear, so I really appreciate your videos!! It’s almost a year now, since you finished it and I have a question - did you watch OVA’s? They are as good as show itself and if I’m not mistaken it’s only 4 of them
you got good job for reactions this masterpiece anime. Which hold first place in MAL for such long time.
My journey with this series start in 2006 from watching first anime. In 2008-2009 I was reading manga as it ongoing. I was very glad that story go another way then in first anime "Full metal alchemist".
I glad to see that adaptation based fully on manga take so much proud from so many people. And it has such good ending and conclusion about their loong journey.
I like your reaction. you take this discussion in the middle of episode. when you're thoughts are so hot))
good job.👍 Hopefully your journey on upload anime reactions on UA-cam keeps you on fun side of it. Good luck 🤞
An amazing end to a masterpiece of a show
suggestion for anime to watch (or not)
The Pet Girl of Sakurasou, aka Sakurasou no Pet na Kanojo
24 eps (not as large as FMAB), cool story, humor, -lil bit of fan service- and the ending similar to FMAB, light and happy.
16:56,
We all got called out here.
yeah, such a perfect ending, they didn't kiss but they had a kid
it was a long journey, a year folowing you in the travel that now unites us even more, it will leave a huge void, but we will continue together as comrads, hope to see you soon
what a journey dude. best wishes for your future ventures.
the ending of FMA is truly special the only other anime with an ending this special for me is code geass but FMA was such a really cool experience b/c of how well it was structured and stuff but the ending is so satisfying
Speaking of endings, has he done code geass? One of the best anime endings as well.
I cant wait for the bloopers there a must watch
I hope he watches the 4 Koma Shorts
such a smart and smooth fun reactions man !
A wonderful journey is over and I thank you for this experience.
If you want to continue making fullmetal content, I would love to see your opinions and reactions to the 2003 version.
I believe this version has its own charm, mainly because the story and plot are quite different.
It seems to be an alternate universe only more dramatic and tragic.
The ending will also be different (in a movie if I'm not mistaken...).
😭😭😭😭😭you did great bro!! An amazing reaction and journey !! Full metal !!
Thank you for this amazing journey. Your unique way of reacting was really entertaining. I kinda want to see this unique way disecting 2 really good animations " Last Church" and " Hellsreach". Keep up the good work 👍👍👍😎😎
Now we just wait for your reaction to the bloopers✌️
I watch FMA a couple of times and i am inlove with EDWARD ELRIC MORE 🥰😍😘 and also ROY MUSTANG hahaha FMA is my alltime favorite anime 🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰
This show is a Top 5 show of all time to me. It is so fucking fantastic, start to finish. If I could have changed two things, it would have been giving Lan Fan more to do in the finale (particularly in that final confrontation between Scar and Wrath, I didn't super care for the motif with the sun, I know many loved it, but idk). And the second thing is that I wish Mustang had stayed blind. Idk, I feel like his ending felt kind of too good, particularly since everybody else seemed to have sacrificed something in the end... Mustang on the other hand seemed to have gotten everything he wanted and more, at no price, really? He's not gonna be held accountable as a war criminal, he's got his eye sight back, his squad is reunited and healed and he is worshipped as a hero... Idk, somehow I'm not satisfied with it?
Please watch the Original FMA from 2003 not many people react to it, so there is a large fanbase waiting, and after watching your reactions I think you would absolutely love it.
Hiromu Arakawa mentioned that she didn't have Ed and Winry kiss just because she isn't great at drawing people kissing
Goosebumps man
Can't wait for more Haikyuu reactions now that FMAB is completed 😅😅
you should watch the bloopers next
Very satisfying ending.
Best anime show ever man.
Yoki never did get his thumbnail image. 😞 😉
I *must* include him in the Q&A thumbnail.
Such a great show, please watch the OVA's!🙏🏻
The bloopers are fine but I think the 4koma episodes are funnier.
YESS
It it one of my all time favorite animes so I'm happy you finally watched it and now you know magnificence of it 😉😋 but more serious I think every person should watch this ones, it is great story about growing, healing and knowing your heart but also persistence and changes. Ahh
I really liked watching you reaction it was my 20 time if not more, but I really liked it, you talk about what you think what you see in interesting way and it was really fun to watch, so I hope soon you will watch some more in deep anime so we can watch you talk more about life and philosophy. Etc.
I recommend you to watch movie FMA: The Sacred Star of Milos. It is really fun and could happen any time in story, so when you miss our boys you can look it up.
PLEASE watch and react to the OVAs too!
Also, did you already watch Avatar: The Last airbender?
You should totally react to Re:Zero, if you haven’t watched it yet. I would love to hear your discussions!
I have seen it, season 1 is one of my fav anime ever.
bloopers
If you haven't already watched it you should watch the original full metal alchemist and compare them
Thank youuu for the journeyyyy
I hope you will watch the original Fma as well.