It’s called “idol” school.. not voice of Korea. The number one quality of being an idol is charisma, ofc visuals is a big part of that. Being a good singer isn’t as important. Let’s be honestly, we all appreciate seeing pretty faces on the screens.
chubbi chubz generally speaking yes we appreciate visuals but that doesnt mean they will not receive harsh criticism for being bad singers theyre ”idols” they are supposed to sing
I also appreciate not hearing whiny shrieky vocals... I dont have anything against these ladies, I honestly think this song was just not right for them and too difficult vocally. One of them sounded ok but her vocals also sounded extremely artificial so I am really curious what this sounded like live. I do however agree that they probably worked hard and they performed very well in all other aspects.. I do want to also point out though, that not being on Voice of Korea does not absolve all idols from criticisms of their talents.. Being an idol means you can sing, dance AND have charisma (in most cases anyway).. and you shouldn't just give them a pass because you think they are pretty. But hey, 2 of the worst singers in this group ended up in the final line up anyway so... things worked out for them anyway but that is because most of the other girls in the final line up can sing very well.
The way Nakko and Jiheon improved in the span of 2 years. Can't be more than proud. People who hated Jiheon way back then please see how our honey improved.
I mean so many hates comment in previous video and then mnet reupload. but i don't know exactly the reason mnet delete the video, maybe because hates comment. Maybe
I don't think this performance is bad. Their voices are fine, neither bad nor good. Except Somyeong, wow she sang it so good. For beginners like them, this performance is really good and stable.
Chi Chi lol maybe. They're begginers tho, don't have any experiences of being trainees plus they're still young. If only Nakyung get a proper vocal trainning, i bet she would got a good voice to sing later.
Nakyung has a distinctive sound color, and she can actually achieve high notes, but every time she sings she sounds uncertain and makes her hold her voice
Well, and support baby SoMyeong, she is really pretty. And here, she showed that she has a pretty voice. With more faith in her, and with practice can continue to show more of her talent.
their vocals are improving these days! watch fromis_9 and you will see how improved Nagyung and Jiheon are. i really am wishing that Somyeong and Jina have a bright future❤️❤️❤️
Why y'all think it's bad. If you think it's bad because you aren't the REAL KPOP LOVER and you're foreigner. I'm Korean and this sound in Korean is so good.All of Kpop song didn't SHOW the amazing voice like American or anything. Don't talk like this again OK?
NAKYUNG I WANT TO LOVE AND PROTECT YOU AND YOUR BEAUTIFUL ANGELIC FACE AND SMILE WIIL FIGHT THE WHOLE WORLD JUST TO SEE YOUR GORGEOUS HAPPY FACE EVERYDAY I LOVE YOU SO MUCH WANT TO CUDDLE YOU ANDKEEP YOU SAFE FOREVER SO YOU AN STAY HAPPY AND KEEP YOUR ANGELIC SMILE FOR THE REST OF YOUR LIFE WORDS CANNOT EXPLAIN HOW MUCH AFFECTION I HAVE FOR YOU I NEVER WANT TO SEE YOU SAD OR UNHAPPY MY LOVE FOR YOU IS INFINITE AND WILL NEVER END BECAUSE I CARE FOR NOTHING BUT YOU I VALUE YOUR LIFE OVER MINE AND WILL GIVE MY LIFE JUST FOR YOUR VERY HAPPINESS MY BEAUTIFUL ANGELI WILL NEVER STOP LOVING YOU AND YEARNING TO SEE YOUR ANGELIC FACE EVERYDAY I CAN'T CONTAIN MY LOVE FOR YOU NO MATTER WHAT I DO I WILL NEVER STOP LOVING YOU UNTIL DEATH
THIS SHOW IS CALLED IDOL SCHOOL FOR A REASON!!!! NONE OF THE GIRLS IN THIS VIDEO HAD BEEN TRAINED BEFORE JOINING THE SHOW, THEY ARE HERE TO LEARN!!!! You mean commenters should be ashamed of your hate!! They are trying their best to achieve their dreams and are improving at their own pace!! Yoo Jina, Lee Nagyung, Park Somyeong & Baek Jiheon fighthing !!!!!
yeah they give their best despite that they;re never trained before , not doin dance routine , vocal routine etc , all trainee things... give them proper training for 2-3 years... u get VISUAL and TALENT... but if you're ugly and only had talent... well u cant really survive on this industry
Jina and Somyung could've been such good fromis 9 members, sad they were considered "old" I actually glad Nakyung and Jiheon learnt how to sing properly
안제라최 there are some stages that will be difficult, c’mon they aren’t robots, if you look in pinnochio she was amazing and u will find out that she is not only visual, besides right now in fromis_9 she’s one of the best dancers cause her moves are really soft and looks amazing and her voice has improved a lot
See 1. the original song had the same child-pitch-squeaky vibe so I didn't mind it too much 2. Their story is like boombayah team 2 from pd48 (it's just about as sad), which y'all support 3. Clearly some of you haven't watched the episode
Correct me if I'm wrong but weren't the groups base on their strongest asset? So these girls clearly has Visual as their main weapon. If so, I think it's understandable that this group lacks in vocal and dancing skills. If one or two of them would debut, I'm sure they'd get the visual/center position, so it doesn't matter if they sing/dance well cause their role is to be pretty. Most korean girl groups has positions for a reason. Don't hate someone for only being pretty if that's what they are set for. Isn't this something like a position evaluation? Again please correct me if I'm wrong.
han ah no, this is not visual team. If you watch the whole eps, this is beginner-dance team, which means they'r low-skilled dance. Their opponent is beginners performance, which means they'r lack of charm when they're in the stage. 6the epsiode, there are pro-dance, beginner-dance, pro-vocal, pro-performance 1, pro-performance 2, standard-performance 1, standard-performance 2, low-performance.
muhammad apriliansyah i see, i don't really watch the show i just try to update myself with the current rankings and performances but if its base on those skills then yes they do lack in both singing and dancing. Hope they would improve in time :/ i think 1-2 visual with little to no talent is enough to be in the final group.
Nikky true that's a pretty bad line up. I have nothing against those with only visual as their strong point but put them all in one gg then I don't know what will happen to that group
This is not about being a good singer dancer etc. This is about how to entertaining people NO MATTER HOW GOOD SINGER OR DANCER YOU ARE WHEN YOU HAVE NO CHARM YOU CANT BE STAR
Golden Maknae if you're good singer/dancer they can at least build a personality versus if you can't ever sing just lip syncing is fine lol but I see what people are saying
i wouldnt say twice is in the same level as them... i mean twice became famous because their voices are really unique than the other girl groups(which i notice that typical girl groups usually use nassal voice) but their's (the school idol group in the vid)... already uses nassal voice and still not good... although the other one, somyeong, has a good voice... the rest is just meh.
This is so iconic! Can't believe I am rewatching this today July 29, 2022. I believe this is where they got their debut name Fromis. Sadly the news broke today that Gyuri will now leave the group. She is pretty and talented but she is actually the dark horse of the group. I hope she did not debut in the first place if only, Natty took her place.
@@TAEHEONJI Hello there I rewatched this video as I am currently watching Universe Ticket and their final is about to come. To answer your question it means the little-known competitor who unexpectedly wins. Gyuri was not popular among her batch then suddenly she rose and debuted that is why I call her dark horse just like Kim Chae-won from Izone she was not popular in pd48 but she debuted at the end.
Well i don't know their name, but they are so cute and beautifull. They can improving their talent though. Ahh, my mind keep repeating, "Beautifull, beautifull, beautifull, beautifull, beautifull,,, "
it's sad how so many people are so brave behind their phones to criticize these girls because I can bet my life that most of them won't do any better if they were put in a show like this
heyheyhey that’s why they’re not on the show and in the comments. They don’t have a desire to be an idol/singer doesn’t mean people can’t pass judgement on singing abilities. If they can sing they can sing if they can’t they cannot. That’s they way it is.
nakyung is so amazing and more improved ❤she's as beauty as tzuyu I like them a lot ❤oh my gosh !it is so touch my heart ❤ let's fight our real visual and singer 👊👊
Hello im back after a year and omg look at Nagyung and Jiheon's improvement. I wonder where Somyeong is doing nowadays she deactivated her IG like almost a year ago. Jina looks like she's doing great with her normal life. And yes, please stan fromis_9
Going back here, I think this performance was not bad at all. Maybe there are just people can't do this or just jealous. All of this girls are visuals but they have talent.
They only had a few months and now they have a lot of talent. They didnt have training before, its normal to them to lack in something if they didnt train.
OKEY BEFORE BAD COMMENTS COME, i wan to tell you something. ALL OF THEM IS NOT AN EX-TRAINEE. They havent participate in any varietyshows. And they don't have experiences trainee like the other girls. But hey look, if you see the whole episode they're improve so much especially jina. We can see she is doing bad at dance at first eps (if you watch it lol) when si an(?) And jina are the one who can't remember the choreo but jina's effort is unbeatable.. Second, mgt's dance is hard af. But u can see again jina can manage it with low skill of dancing. After that, jina admit it she can't see the red-light camera ASAP. But in this performance, she improve so much:) I don't want to talk about visual bcs jina is so beauty.. In Idol school, we can't just see the talent, we see about the effort too.. In the 6th episode's ranking not just placed by vote, but the teacher too.. That's why someyong got into 9. And we can't see they are improve or not, who can see is the teacher who train them almost everyday, the teacher see their effort. AND THEY DONT USE THE BACKTRACK:) so dont judge them. Thankyou. Sorry for my bad grammar
In my opinion, this perform was worst than the first performance for Jina & Somyung especially. Jina & Somyung not this bad when they perform me gustas tu, but now it getting worst. And talking about improve, i dont see a big improve, if we see Kim Sohye at Produce 101, she lack of talent at first 5 eps, but after she perform "Full Moon", we can see a big improve there and also has a big impact for her image. But thats not happen in this case, maybe they improve, but not at that much, and if they keep performing like this till the final eps, i dont think they deserved for top 9. Thats my opinion
Muh Alfatri i kno sohye, she is greatly improving when fulmoon stage. I can explain that why you see jina and somyeong is not improving from mgt. First, they'r low-skilled dance group. In their group, they don't have anyone who can teach them dance, so their choose an easy choreo, meanwhile mgt is hard-choreo type. Second, in mgt, jina and somyeong didn't get line so much. But this performance their got many line. Somyeong is doing a high note, meanwhile jina is the one who have many line. Two of them is not vocal-type, so.. In your view, you see that jina and somyeong in this performance is worst than mgt's performance. I said it again that we can't see their effort, but teacher can see it, that's why teacher can vote for them bcs their effort. Sorry bad grammar hehehe
muhammad apriliansyah Even you try to explain with long ass essay to them. Is still useless, majority of them even didn't know how the show work and not even watch the show. they only stated opinion from what they watch and not to do some research about it. just ignore them and report it. I personally think this perfomance isn't as bad as ppl think, they did well from someone with beginner level and also the originally song itself sound like this. btw I appreciate your comments ^^
Came here from sia, dahee and nayeon's performance and wow i cant believe 2 of the girls here made it to the last line up of fromis like they barely can sing while the other 3 sing like angels so effortlessly.
![Idol School [6회]반전 드라마! 아름다운 하모니'꿈을 모아서'김나연,신시아,이다희 @학업성취도평가(보컬) 170824 EP.6](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wYmLprUGMYk/mqdefault.jpg)
![Idol School [6회]반전 드라마! 아름다운 하모니'꿈을 모아서'김나연,신시아,이다희 @학업성취도평가(보컬) 170824 EP.6](/img/tr.png)
![Idol School [최종회]어머머 넌 피노키오 못말려♥ ′피노키오′ 박지원,이나경,이채영,박소명,백지헌,유지나@최종 데뷔멤버 선발전 170929 EP.11](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/oVnTLMFUHP8/mqdefault.jpg)
![[놀면뭐하니] 눈 뜨고 보기 힘든 내 동생들의 연애 MBC241020방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/UdqulRnXIjw/mqdefault.jpg)
![Soo Young Wants to be in The Center This Time Too!! [Running Man Ep 432]](/img/n.gif)
It’s called “idol” school.. not voice of Korea. The number one quality of being an idol is charisma, ofc visuals is a big part of that. Being a good singer isn’t as important. Let’s be honestly, we all appreciate seeing pretty faces on the screens.
chubbi chubz generally speaking yes we appreciate visuals but that doesnt mean they will not receive harsh criticism for being bad singers theyre ”idols” they are supposed to sing
I also appreciate not hearing whiny shrieky vocals... I dont have anything against these ladies, I honestly think this song was just not right for them and too difficult vocally. One of them sounded ok but her vocals also sounded extremely artificial so I am really curious what this sounded like live. I do however agree that they probably worked hard and they performed very well in all other aspects..
I do want to also point out though, that not being on Voice of Korea does not absolve all idols from criticisms of their talents.. Being an idol means you can sing, dance AND have charisma (in most cases anyway).. and you shouldn't just give them a pass because you think they are pretty. But hey, 2 of the worst singers in this group ended up in the final line up anyway so... things worked out for them anyway but that is because most of the other girls in the final line up can sing very well.
@@Shmaples who did you think sounded artificial?
As if miss girl killing the vocals isnt pretty and charming on stage....
The way Nakko and Jiheon improved in the span of 2 years. Can't be more than proud. People who hated Jiheon way back then please see how our honey improved.
Feels like Suzy + Krystal + Tzeyu in one team😂 strong visual team
Sierra Lau Tzuyu*
jiheon looklike " darren espanto" try to search it! :) hi!
in the philippines he is the famous singer hehe.
AIMAE D.
Yahh. Akala ko ako lang nakakakita sa kanya as Darren hahaha
Where is Krystal
And gowon of Berry good
mnet disturbed with hate comments, it mean mnet read our comment hhahahahaa
love nayeon they don't even give us subs
I mean so many hates comment in previous video and then mnet reupload. but i don't know exactly the reason mnet delete the video, maybe because hates comment. Maybe
Maybe the friends,family of a young student in idol school who is trying to learn being an idol are reading the comment of the self righteous i-viewer
I don't think this performance is bad. Their voices are fine, neither bad nor good. Except Somyeong, wow she sang it so good. For beginners like them, this performance is really good and stable.
Jeffrey boi their voices are a big trash srly
Chi Chi honest speaking, Nakyung's voice is good i was impressed by her in Cheer Up performance tho. Well, this song is a bad choice for them.
Jeffrey boi maybe i listen to Akdong too much... I said trash because i have a voice like them, weak - no emotion - always in cute tone
Chi Chi lol maybe. They're begginers tho, don't have any experiences of being trainees plus they're still young. If only Nakyung get a proper vocal trainning, i bet she would got a good voice to sing later.
Chi Chi listen to Glass shoes by the top9 girls aka fromis. If you say they still got no talent and sound trash you're just a salty hater lmao
ジホンちゃんめっっちゃかわいい😭💕
それ
Nakyung has a distinctive sound color, and she can actually achieve high notes, but every time she sings she sounds uncertain and makes her hold her voice
dont hate me but i think jiheon's voice isnt as bad as what the comments say though :/
LY ifntexoabts poor Jiheon...
LY ifntexoabts yeah
YEAH I KNOW RIGHTT
She just doesn't have the confindence in herself
TRUE
Nakyung improved so much❤️
この舞台が全部の中で1番感動するし好き
iam so happy that nagyung debuted she shines on every stage 💮
Can we talk about how miss Nakyung improved right now?
Like she's the 5th best vocalist of fromis
このメンツ好きすぎる。ジホン天使ですか？ナギョン色気がやばい♡そしてカチコチコンビ綺麗すぎる✨
原曲とかカバーしたアーティストとか色々見てきましたが
この曲の清純さと透明感を一番表現できてたのはこの4人だと思いました✨
そしてソミョンがとても歌上手くて驚きました✨✨
Who else shed tears when Somyeong started singing? If anyone saved this performance, it was definitely absolutely her.
このグループってファイナル綺麗に全員ピノキオグループ☺️❤️
日本人おったなかま
なかま
That crazy fanboy at 1:02 probably got noticed by Nakyung at 3:19 😂
Well, and support baby SoMyeong, she is really pretty. And here, she showed that she has a pretty voice. With more faith in her, and with practice can continue to show more of her talent.
somyeong's vocals is good tho. but i don't know about those three
この子達のこの時の実力でこの完成度、本当に本当にすごいよ本当にすごいよ🥲🥲🥲本当にー😢
their vocals are improving these days! watch fromis_9 and you will see how improved Nagyung and Jiheon are. i really am wishing that Somyeong and Jina have a bright future❤️❤️❤️
Jiheon still can't really sing but Nakko pretty much part of the vocal line now, shes really improved
@@바보Queen i guess not, she's really improving now.
Oh c'mon this was not even that bad, their voices are ok and I'm sure the'll improve overtime.
ナギョンとジホン可愛すぎ😍天使やわ❤
Starring
Beauty: The Girls
and the
Beast : Their Voices
Best comment from the original video😂
sparkle star i laugh at this for 3 min or more and i didn't even watch this show.
ohh my gosh thats actually very witty HAHAHAHAHAHA
Why y'all think it's bad. If you think it's bad because you aren't the REAL KPOP LOVER and you're foreigner. I'm Korean and this sound in Korean is so good.All of Kpop song didn't SHOW the amazing voice like American or anything. Don't talk like this again OK?
RAIN RUNG lol
RAIN RUNG keep trying....
可愛すぎる
たしかにナギョンにあんなことされたらファンもあーなるわ笑笑
やはり、ナギョン可愛すぎる
てかこのグループ全員可愛すぎる！！
ナギョンちゃんに先生たちなんて言ってるんですか？
内田優 私も韓国語出来ないので、何を言っているかはわからないです😅すみません
@@ホモサピエンス人間 いえいえ！質問に答えていただき有難うございます！
nakyung so pretty,amazing👍👍😍😘😍
they are all so pretty but the one who looks like suzy is prettiest.
park chamsae Agree 100% and she's the one who sings best ❤❤❤
who look like suzy
nguyễn mai nhung Park SoMyeong google her. Suzy doppelganger
its shocking that she will be doing the highnote
She's Park Somyeong 97 liner, she used to be very unknown but finally she's in top 9 last week
This is one of my favorite performance! Their visuals and voice are no joke^^
@@emlaaicogaihaynangtien yes, and u? you're deaf right?
Baek jihoen's smile is really something
ずっとみてきて100回は再生してるくらい好き
somyeong visual's no joke,shes look alike iu and sowon gf and little bit of suzy too😍
syifasjs 27 ikr😂❤️
syifasjs 27 truee
When she smile with her mouth closed she really looks a bit like sowon
syifasjs 27 riteee
syifasjs 27 and also red velvet's joy
NAKYUNG I WANT TO LOVE AND PROTECT YOU AND YOUR BEAUTIFUL ANGELIC FACE AND SMILE WIIL FIGHT THE WHOLE WORLD JUST TO SEE YOUR GORGEOUS HAPPY FACE EVERYDAY I LOVE YOU SO MUCH WANT TO CUDDLE YOU ANDKEEP YOU SAFE FOREVER SO YOU AN STAY HAPPY AND KEEP YOUR ANGELIC SMILE FOR THE REST OF YOUR LIFE WORDS CANNOT EXPLAIN HOW MUCH AFFECTION I HAVE FOR YOU I NEVER WANT TO SEE YOU SAD OR UNHAPPY MY LOVE FOR YOU IS INFINITE AND WILL NEVER END BECAUSE I CARE FOR NOTHING BUT YOU I VALUE YOUR LIFE OVER MINE AND WILL GIVE MY LIFE JUST FOR YOUR VERY HAPPINESS MY BEAUTIFUL ANGELI WILL NEVER STOP LOVING YOU AND YEARNING TO SEE YOUR ANGELIC FACE EVERYDAY I CAN'T CONTAIN MY LOVE FOR YOU NO MATTER WHAT I DO I WILL NEVER STOP LOVING YOU UNTIL DEATH
bia sparkle mee too TT
Me at my dog
mood
みんな天使！！惚れた！
歌もかわいくて癒される〜♡
ジホン♡♡♡
THIS SHOW IS CALLED IDOL SCHOOL FOR A REASON!!!!
NONE OF THE GIRLS IN THIS VIDEO HAD BEEN TRAINED BEFORE JOINING THE SHOW, THEY ARE HERE TO LEARN!!!!
You mean commenters should be ashamed of your hate!!
They are trying their best to achieve their dreams and are improving at their own pace!!
Yoo Jina, Lee Nagyung, Park Somyeong & Baek Jiheon fighthing !!!!!
their visual is not a joke.. actually their vocal is not bad.. they sing really good and good stability
The girl in pigtails has a naturally warm face, even not smiling she still looks so kind lol
Lee Nakyung, I'm in love with you since the first time you appear on 1st ep, you are one of the precious girl
my eyes blessed but my ears bleed.
Same
😂😂😂
no jimin no jam preach sista!!
You should go to the doctor and stop listening your bts song, it will make your ears got worst
Ranxy Lex "listening to*"
"Ears get* worse"
No need to thank me😊😊
Visual over talent these days
yeap ...
yeah
they give their best despite that they;re never trained before , not doin dance routine , vocal routine etc , all trainee things...
give them proper training for 2-3 years... u get VISUAL and TALENT... but if you're ugly and only had talent... well u cant really survive on this industry
Rajha Yah I agree to you
Hiblo Chuck 👎🏽👎🏽👎🏽👎🏽👎🏽
Hiblo Chuck That's what this show is looking for lol 😂
why fromis_9 is so underrated i dont get it they are so talented like wtf people is so blind
カチコチコンビかわいいな！？！？好き
I think they re-posted due to the most liked comments being negative, due to their high rank and low talent.
yup.
まじでこのステージはいつ見てもにやける爆笑
Jina and Somyung could've been such good fromis 9 members, sad they were considered "old"
I actually glad Nakyung and Jiheon learnt how to sing properly
gyuri saerom and hayoung had the same age as these 2 ?
After listening to it many times it's starting to sound better. Also how does Jiheon smile like 24/7.
Unpopular opinion, I think nakyung has a nice voice.
gg trash with a sprinkle sprinkle of wanna one im with you
gg trash with a sprinkle sprinkle of wanna one i think so
high5
You are not alone
Jiheon's visual is no joke
久々に見たくなった笑笑
癒しやわ可愛すぎ💞
きょれ
ですよね！！みんな可愛い💕😍
ジホンの髪型がめっちゃ個人的に好きです！
I really like this stage ! Jiheonna fighting!
My ears burst don’t let miss Baek sing please just only smile that suit her
何度見ても美しい😭😭
Jina has a calm voice and has a very pretty tone i don't even know why the others in the comment section hated her voice
Jiheon's voice may be bad but she's good at dancing though so don't say she doesn't have a talent lmao
안제라최 there are some stages that will be difficult, c’mon they aren’t robots, if you look in pinnochio she was amazing and u will find out that she is not only visual, besides right now in fromis_9 she’s one of the best dancers cause her moves are really soft and looks amazing and her voice has improved a lot
See
1. the original song had the same child-pitch-squeaky vibe so I didn't mind it too much
2. Their story is like boombayah team 2 from pd48 (it's just about as sad), which y'all support
3. Clearly some of you haven't watched the episode
what lol no. the original song didnt have child-pitch-squeaky thing. Hyori and Ok joohyun had clear mature sounds there.
@@DMTHOTH nah imo they sounded pretty squeaky, bc they were trying to sing more cute
Correct me if I'm wrong but weren't the groups base on their strongest asset? So these girls clearly has Visual as their main weapon. If so, I think it's understandable that this group lacks in vocal and dancing skills. If one or two of them would debut, I'm sure they'd get the visual/center position, so it doesn't matter if they sing/dance well cause their role is to be pretty. Most korean girl groups has positions for a reason. Don't hate someone for only being pretty if that's what they are set for. Isn't this something like a position evaluation? Again please correct me if I'm wrong.
han ah no, this is not visual team. If you watch the whole eps, this is beginner-dance team, which means they'r low-skilled dance. Their opponent is beginners performance, which means they'r lack of charm when they're in the stage. 6the epsiode, there are pro-dance, beginner-dance, pro-vocal, pro-performance 1, pro-performance 2, standard-performance 1, standard-performance 2, low-performance.
muhammad apriliansyah i see, i don't really watch the show i just try to update myself with the current rankings and performances but if its base on those skills then yes they do lack in both singing and dancing. Hope they would improve in time :/ i think 1-2 visual with little to no talent is enough to be in the final group.
han ah all of them are in top 9. Imagine a group with 9 members and 4 of them cannot sing 🙃🙃🙃 that will be bad
Nikky true that's a pretty bad line up. I have nothing against those with only visual as their strong point but put them all in one gg then I don't know what will happen to that group
han ah well on two made it in the final line-up lol
Nakung and Jihoen fighting 💙 all are beautiful
Nakyong,Somyong and Jina are best voice in group
Actually i'm watching this again cuz i really miss jiheon
This is not about being a good singer dancer etc. This is about how to entertaining people NO MATTER HOW GOOD SINGER OR DANCER YOU ARE WHEN YOU HAVE NO CHARM YOU CANT BE STAR
Golden Maknae if you're good singer/dancer they can at least build a personality versus if you can't ever sing just lip syncing is fine lol but I see what people are saying
Golden Maknae Coming from a Twice stan. Yeah right.
i wouldnt say twice is in the same level as them... i mean twice became famous because their voices are really unique than the other girl groups(which i notice that typical girl groups usually use nassal voice) but their's (the school idol group in the vid)... already uses nassal voice and still not good... although the other one, somyeong, has a good voice... the rest is just meh.
indeed they're not entertaining me, the commments are
Well....They can't be an idol if they don't have talent either soooo :-/
This is just like most girl group nowdays sound like without Backup vocal 😂😂
Support baby somyeong please SHE HAS LIKE SO LITTLE INTERNATIONAL FANS
the screams when somyeong begins to sing!!!! YOU GO MY GIRL
wtf guys
theyre so good at being idols
what's wrong with this? stable vocals, good dance, powerful high note and extremely nice attitude
jina deserves more love and support istg im gon cry
The other vid is full of hate comment thats why mnet re upload this one. I think. Lmao. 🙄😂
陳天仁 I mean they cannot sing...thus far...
huhu
So instead of dropping ep. 7 teaser. Mnet reupload this ???
too many bad cooments on this video iguess .or dislike
mnet's protecting their child who's good at smiling. just smiling. *not dance neither sing*
You right maybe mnet protect the girls........
From you guys who judge them so hard where the girls still in training.
OMG IT'S A KEYAKIZAKA46 FAN
This is so iconic! Can't believe I am rewatching this today July 29, 2022. I believe this is where they got their debut name Fromis. Sadly the news broke today that Gyuri will now leave the group. She is pretty and talented but she is actually the dark horse of the group. I hope she did not debut in the first place if only, Natty took her place.
Dark horse???
What's does that mean???
@@TAEHEONJI Hello there I rewatched this video as I am currently watching Universe Ticket and their final is about to come. To answer your question it means the little-known competitor who unexpectedly wins. Gyuri was not popular among her batch then suddenly she rose and debuted that is why I call her dark horse just like Kim Chae-won from Izone she was not popular in pd48 but she debuted at the end.
ツウィに似ている人がいるのは気のせい？
I like Nakyung, JiNa and JiHoen.
3:33 kkoheon💝
Well i don't know their name, but they are so cute and beautifull. They can improving their talent though. Ahh, my mind keep repeating, "Beautifull, beautifull, beautifull, beautifull, beautifull,,, "
i'm proud of this girls. they keep improving everyday omg
so sad that have people who only know judging
it's sad how so many people are so brave behind their phones to criticize these girls because I can bet my life that most of them won't do any better if they were put in a show like this
heyheyhey that’s why they’re not on the show and in the comments. They don’t have a desire to be an idol/singer doesn’t mean people can’t pass judgement on singing abilities. If they can sing they can sing if they can’t they cannot. That’s they way it is.
David Dacus he or she said if. IFFFF
NAKYUNG MY BABY! 💕
カチコチ 恋しいよおおお；＿；
ジナもソミョンも今何してるんだろう；＿；
この子達のインスタあるよ
事務所無所属だからただの一般人たけど
Nakyung so beautiful
nakyung is so amazing and more improved ❤she's as beauty as tzuyu I like them a lot ❤oh my gosh !it is so touch my heart ❤ let's fight our real visual and singer 👊👊
I like her so much,too. 😍😍❤
Jiheon-aaaa you're so beautiful!
I swear that girl looks like Krystal
Xingqiao of Girls planet 999 reminds me of JINA😭💛 they're both my no. 1 pic lol
Hello im back after a year and omg look at Nagyung and Jiheon's improvement. I wonder where Somyeong is doing nowadays she deactivated her IG like almost a year ago. Jina looks like she's doing great with her normal life. And yes, please stan fromis_9
idk why people are hating, they aren't even that bad. They have pretty decent vocals just two of them need a bit more training on their vocals.
I thought mnet gonna upload other. But they repost lol
Jina fighting! Attitude makes a lot of differences 😘
lmao mnet deleted because of the comments. they're protecting their child, jiheon who's good at smiling. just smile. 😁😂
Kisses Warriors true. But not only smile. She got visual.
Finally someone who not so blind XD
Kisses Warriors sound terrible... And the thing is they're just lip syncing... Imagine if it was live lmao xD
neko kawaii EXACTLY WHAT I WAS THINKING
Kisses Warriors since idol school start, i realize that jiheon only smile smile smile smile 😂😂😂😂😂
Going back here, I think this performance was not bad at all. Maybe there are just people can't do this or just jealous. All of this girls are visuals but they have talent.
Jiheon's smile always make my day 😍😍
The original song by Finkl sounds exactly like this. I don't know why people are bitching. The girls did fine.
for nothing, do not sound similar and less sing like ock joo hyun
They just need training gave them 2 or 3 years
rita flores there is no way, if they get on top 9 until end they will debut. There is no training again
no need for that some of them already havs training b4 they join the show. its just that they really have no talent in singing
Don't worry guys they are still training under Pledis now, not totally mean training but you know to improve
They only had a few months and now they have a lot of talent. They didnt have training before, its normal to them to lack in something if they didnt train.
ソミョンめっちゃ可愛い
OKEY BEFORE BAD COMMENTS COME, i wan to tell you something. ALL OF THEM IS NOT AN EX-TRAINEE. They havent participate in any varietyshows. And they don't have experiences trainee like the other girls. But hey look, if you see the whole episode they're improve so much especially jina. We can see she is doing bad at dance at first eps (if you watch it lol) when si an(?) And jina are the one who can't remember the choreo but jina's effort is unbeatable.. Second, mgt's dance is hard af. But u can see again jina can manage it with low skill of dancing. After that, jina admit it she can't see the red-light camera ASAP. But in this performance, she improve so much:) I don't want to talk about visual bcs jina is so beauty.. In Idol school, we can't just see the talent, we see about the effort too.. In the 6th episode's ranking not just placed by vote, but the teacher too.. That's why someyong got into 9. And we can't see they are improve or not, who can see is the teacher who train them almost everyday, the teacher see their effort. AND THEY DONT USE THE BACKTRACK:) so dont judge them. Thankyou. Sorry for my bad grammar
In my opinion, this perform was worst than the first performance for Jina & Somyung especially. Jina & Somyung not this bad when they perform me gustas tu, but now it getting worst. And talking about improve, i dont see a big improve, if we see Kim Sohye at Produce 101, she lack of talent at first 5 eps, but after she perform "Full Moon", we can see a big improve there and also has a big impact for her image. But thats not happen in this case, maybe they improve, but not at that much, and if they keep performing like this till the final eps, i dont think they deserved for top 9. Thats my opinion
Muh Alfatri i kno sohye, she is greatly improving when fulmoon stage. I can explain that why you see jina and somyeong is not improving from mgt. First, they'r low-skilled dance group. In their group, they don't have anyone who can teach them dance, so their choose an easy choreo, meanwhile mgt is hard-choreo type. Second, in mgt, jina and somyeong didn't get line so much. But this performance their got many line. Somyeong is doing a high note, meanwhile jina is the one who have many line. Two of them is not vocal-type, so.. In your view, you see that jina and somyeong in this performance is worst than mgt's performance. I said it again that we can't see their effort, but teacher can see it, that's why teacher can vote for them bcs their effort. Sorry bad grammar hehehe
Yeah, thats why i keep watching this program, to see "are these trainees has improving? Or not? Are they getting more beauty?" Hehe ^^
muhammad apriliansyah Even you try to explain with long ass essay to them. Is still useless, majority of them even didn't know how the show work and not even watch the show. they only stated opinion from what they watch and not to do some research about it. just ignore them and report it. I personally think this perfomance isn't as bad as ppl think, they did well from someone with beginner level and also the originally song itself sound like this. btw I appreciate your comments ^^
An Intellectual Stan omg someone understand this situation:') thankyou ^^
Jiheon I love you❤️
Jiheon is way overrated.
Quỳnh Như Dương She's overrated and she's in the higher ranking and yet all she did is smile
I agree.. but its jiheon
Quỳnh Như Dương I don't agree
Nope, she got the best smile in the industry. She is necessary. Jiwon, hayoung, gyuri, seoyeon and chaeyoung can take care of talent aspects
I got curious about fromis because of her smile in Love Bomb's thumbnail. Irresistible tbh
0:40 did anyone else get Tzuyu vibes from her??? even the expressions are on point.
omg their visual 😍
omg their voices 😭
マジ神回かわいすぎる
why jiheon only smile?? ... whats her talent?? smile?
alexia Ramirez yeah , and because of her talent she in top9 🙂💔
alexia Ramirez i think so...she can't do anything different :) dislike haha
It is smiling. And she is in top 9 🙃🙃🙃
alexia Ramirez haha 😂
Nikky how she got in top 9? I mean mnet just give it to her?
They reuploaded the performance??? I'm fine getting more Park Somyeong... will watch it again any time of the day..
Sorry for Nakyung , but she can't sing💔 just pretty
Nagyung can sing, you should watch her previous performance, Cheer Up. It just about training, Nagyung never got training before.
Chanyeol's Fairy I watched but I think the another's student have a
Really beautiful voice better than nakyung (sorry for my bad English)
i disagree. she's good at singing. are u deaf or somethin lmao i'll agree if u said jiheon can't cause she really can't
Kisses Warriors This is my opinion , so don't say im deaf
NORAH OTAKU At least she is better than Jiheon😂
Came here from sia, dahee and nayeon's performance and wow i cant believe 2 of the girls here made it to the last line up of fromis like they barely can sing while the other 3 sing like angels so effortlessly.