But what about SOCIALIZATION? | The truth about homeschoolers and social skills

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 5 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 92

  • @FishHive
    @FishHive Рік тому +4

    When my cousin found out that my daughter is homeschooled her initial question was "what about their social skills?". I tried my best to explain that my daughter will grow up just fine but she is not convinced. Sigh.. some people are really ignorant.

  • @melanimontague3266
    @melanimontague3266 Рік тому +21

    I went to Public school and I’m a total introvert. I grew up having a ton of friends but the only friend I still have is my sister. She’s my absolute best friend. I’m homeschooling my two kiddos and our number one focus is family connection. 😊

    • @ThisHomeschoolHouse
      @ThisHomeschoolHouse  Рік тому +1

      It really is such a blessing!

    • @jimjohnson530
      @jimjohnson530 4 місяці тому

      All school friends moved away or lost touch. All that remains is family but they tell you thats unimportant.

  • @MariaTheVideoEditor
    @MariaTheVideoEditor Рік тому +18

    I'm a mother! And watching this video from Pakistan where homeschooling is still very rare, I really needed to hear these words from an experienced home schooler. Thank you so much for making this extremely useful video.

    • @sisterfleur7523
      @sisterfleur7523 Рік тому

      Why are you homeschooling in Pakistan if you're muslim ? Are you christian ? Are there christian schools there ? I was born in a muslim country and attended a private christian school (I am muslim by the way)

    • @ThisHomeschoolHouse
      @ThisHomeschoolHouse  Рік тому

      I'm glad it was encouraging!

  • @Growth234
    @Growth234 Рік тому +10

    My daughter went to school, didn't see any of the children outside of school. Not one student came over to play, all the parents were super awkward and apologetic toward eachother. When schools close down from covid, she gained so many friends in the neighborhood, it was wonderful. We've been homeschooling ever since. Homeschooling has far too many benefits to list honestly.

  • @julie9299
    @julie9299 Рік тому +13

    As a previous public school teacher I can't even begin to tell you how often I said or heard other teachers tell Elementary age students that they werent there to socialize. 😂 also when lunch or lines or classroom management runs long kids often miss out on their short recess and get very little time in play and interacting with others their own age. Some teachers do better. Most don't.
    Agree with the friends and coworkers in similar life stage not age.
    We love getting together with large families and childrens of different ages for our children to play with.

    • @ThisHomeschoolHouse
      @ThisHomeschoolHouse  Рік тому +1

      Yes! I remember being in school and there wasn't a lot of time to chat.

  • @jimjohnson530
    @jimjohnson530 4 місяці тому +3

    Speaking of first hand experience... I went to public school, hated it and was left ill equipped for the real world. Teaching home management skills and finance for instance would be a lot more helpful than trigonometry!
    Also anxieties from school are still the source of nightmares and irrational worry in adulthood. Trauma? Being stuck in a desk for 7hrs and disciplined if you move or speak out of turn, Pop quizzes, forgetting a project, failing a test, blowing a presentation etc.

    • @ThisHomeschoolHouse
      @ThisHomeschoolHouse  4 місяці тому +1

      Yep, the scrutiny is often very one-sided. It's a bit ridiculous.

  • @kristenkirchner7465
    @kristenkirchner7465 Рік тому +6

    LOVED this! I’m going to be homeschooling my kiddos and the socialization part has been my biggest concern really. I was actually talking about it with my husband today, so this was wonderful timing for me haha
    Also loved the ending about better to have a saved soul even if it means they’re a little “weird” (whatever that means nowadays looking around) point!

  • @erinjackson2360
    @erinjackson2360 Рік тому +4

    Great video and I couldn’t agree more! I homeschool my kids, oldest is 5 and she is extroverted while I am introverted. She wants to play with her neighborhood friends everyday; while I think a few times a week is more than enough. I try to keep her needs priority over mine but I sometimes feel very guilty saying no you can’t have this friend over because you saw her yesterday when I know if she were in traditional school she would see her friends everyday. I do think it’s so much more important for her to have healthy relationships with her siblings, so I prioritize that over friend time. I find it hard to let go of the guilt and feeling like I need to schedule in play dates and activities to overcompensate!

    • @ThisHomeschoolHouse
      @ThisHomeschoolHouse  Рік тому +1

      It actually sounds like you've got a really good balance going on. :)

  • @jessicaladd85
    @jessicaladd85 Рік тому +4

    I am reading Gabor Mate's "Hold on to Your Kids". Its amazing so far! Speaks directly to the idea of friendship within the family unit

    • @ThisHomeschoolHouse
      @ThisHomeschoolHouse  Рік тому +1

      I've had that book on my "to read" list for years! I really need to get it!

  • @laciemarvel6074
    @laciemarvel6074 Рік тому +3

    Couldn't have said it better myself. You are spot on momma. My issue is that a lot of kids aren't being raised the way I am raising my wn kiddos and end up teach my kids bad habits. For that reason, we tend to keep to ourselves 🤷🏼‍♀️ it does keep us a close knit little family which I did not have growing up. I love your video. Thank you for letting us join you and your homeschool ❤

    • @ThisHomeschoolHouse
      @ThisHomeschoolHouse  Рік тому +2

      Yes, I can totally understand that. You're very welcome!

    • @jessicaladd85
      @jessicaladd85 Рік тому +2

      Yes! Oh goodness if we could keep to ourselves together lol!!

  • @nicolesmith1267
    @nicolesmith1267 Рік тому +3

    I love this! My kids are currently too young but we plan on homeschooling and this issue has come up when talking with others. My son turns 3 tomorrow and he is great friends with the girl next door who is 11 years old. In the school holidays she is at our house for atleast an hour everyday and they both love it. She is a little gem and that is quite the age gap

  • @milehighhomeschool
    @milehighhomeschool Рік тому +5

    Oh my goodness! Say it again, louder for the people in the back!! As aanother second gen homeschooler I agree with this video so much!!! I feel like I have this conversation with people every day!

  • @sunshineandsaltwaterhome
    @sunshineandsaltwaterhome Рік тому +3

    I loved this message so much! The next time someone tries to talk to me about home school and socializing, I’m directing them to this video ❤

  • @tammyron5705
    @tammyron5705 Рік тому +2

    I am currently homeschooling my 5 & 8 year old. I attended public school my entire academic life and didn’t know anyone who was homeschooled. I know A LOT of individuals who are socially awkward, anti-social and extremely introverted. None of them were homeschooled.

    • @ThisHomeschoolHouse
      @ThisHomeschoolHouse  Рік тому +1

      Yep, I think that homeschooling is the easy pick because it's an obvious difference. However, there are plenty of socially awkward people who were public-schooled.

  • @Brynnmarieblack
    @Brynnmarieblack 3 місяці тому +1

    Thank you for this! 🙌🏼

  • @Aswelearnhomeschool
    @Aswelearnhomeschool Рік тому +1

    We are originally in dance for socialization bc my kids are so shy. And it’s been great and they love ballet. We also can’t do a co-op.
    Then we decided kids needed swim lessons and didn’t want to pause dance. Man it was exhausting swim has ended and I’m really grateful and we won’t be doing that again if we need more swim lessons then dance has no choice but to pause.

  • @lanajohnson2346
    @lanajohnson2346 Рік тому +3

    Love, love, love this!! So encouraging and reassuring! I so agree with the mixed age groups. So much magic can happen when you have a group of kids of varying ages playing together. The young ones may have the ideas but not know how to carry them out, where as, the older ones do have the skills to carry it out. Its beautiful to see the team work, learning and social skills that are being used when in situations like that.

  • @adventureswiththemacs8066
    @adventureswiththemacs8066 Рік тому +1

    First gen homeschoolers (since Covid). It could simply be the personality of my kids - or perks of homeschool - I see my kids BETTER able to have conversations with other people, especially adults, than their peers. My kids are involved in sports, classes at our library, co-op, etc. so they most certainly are getting socialization!!

  • @AR-k39
    @AR-k39 6 місяців тому

    Wonderfully said!! I think I definitely did to much her kindergarten year, to many co/opa and to many activities so I was definitely burned out after this year and going to make a change.

  • @f3nw1ckfamily
    @f3nw1ckfamily Рік тому +8

    I can't agree more that kids don't need a lot of friends and how it's about quality over quantity, even as a mom of an only child. Also so much "yes!" on what you said about overcompensating and your closing statement. Oh, the irony of people talking so much about diversity while pushing for everyone else to be just like them.🙄 I wish people would be smart enough to actually research homeschooling before jumping into ridiculous assumptions and generalizations. If they don't want it for themselves, that's fine, but they should not just throw around baseless judgments parroted from other ignorant fools. 🙃
    My daughter is one of the most consistently happy/friendly girls I know and handles frustrations/sadness well. She doesn't have crazy roller coaster emotions and is truly mature for her age, yet still has the innocence and wonder of a child. I know it's mostly because that's how God made her but I also believe being homeschooled and living with happily married parents and one set of grandparents has a lot to do with her being secure and content/peaceful.

  • @jimjohnson530
    @jimjohnson530 4 місяці тому +1

    She is a gem!
    Yes, challenging independent, critical, thought, thats what public school is about… (Chuckle) Its about conformity and obedience. The skepticism only goes one way. While facing ideological and social challenges is developmentally crucial, so is receiving support and encouragement. Family and faith based community do that best!

  • @ashleypnw6922
    @ashleypnw6922 Рік тому +2

    I'm a first generation homeschooler in my family. This is the number one comment, "What about socialization?" I hear from all my friends and family when they learn we are homeschooling; and repeatedly hear from them 4 years later. My mother just last week said it to me; and she is even on board with me homeschooling. She with heartfelt concern on her face, "What about them being weirdos, like super weird?" It's really starting to get under my skin; and I'm now trying to figure out a better short and concise response. I think it is actually a thought stopping technique that as soon as the person says it; it stops them from critically thinking of the true pros and cons of homeschooling. And inhibits their thinking from considering all the many wonderful benefits of homeschooling as compared to mass schooling; which there are a plethora. (USA)

    • @ThisHomeschoolHouse
      @ThisHomeschoolHouse  Рік тому +1

      Yes, it's ridiculous.

    • @sarasali3077
      @sarasali3077 Рік тому

      So true. The word weirdos paints a completely different picture in my head these days 😬 (also from the US) and it’s not a homeschooled child. Honestly though, we are deep down all “weird” in our own way! What makes people cringe so much with being themselves? Isn’t that what we want for our kids after all? --similar worries from my mother in law until the past year or so, now she keeps saying how smart homeschool is lol.

    • @ashleypnw6922
      @ashleypnw6922 Рік тому +1

      @@sarasali3077 I love that! We all have weirdness to us and I'm glad about that! I definitely see my kids being different from the mass schooling weirdness; which I'm proud of! lol

    • @sarasali3077
      @sarasali3077 Рік тому

      @@ashleypnw6922 yes! Me too! 😃

    • @shannonfbc1
      @shannonfbc1 Рік тому +1

      I'd respond oh yes I hope they are weirdos 😂😂😂😂

  • @saltandlighthomeschool
    @saltandlighthomeschool Рік тому +1

    I loved this video! It was very timely as this is our first year homeschooling and I went to public school so I am trying to navigate how to handle socialization. I especially loved the end of this video. It was very well done. Thank you!!

  • @mubeenaparker9022
    @mubeenaparker9022 Рік тому +1

    Love this! Thank you for touching on this topic and clearing this huge Myth within homeschooling ❤

  • @jenwinfree79
    @jenwinfree79 Рік тому +3

    Do you have videos with your mom on your yt? If so, do you have one about building a family culture in homeschooling and how she modeled that? Blessings xx

    • @ThisHomeschoolHouse
      @ThisHomeschoolHouse  Рік тому +1

      I don't. I haven mentioned it to her but I'm not sure it'll happen. :) Maybe one day!

  • @HeatherCathey-p2n
    @HeatherCathey-p2n Рік тому

    Very encouraging video. I liked what you said about the quality of friends instead of the quantity. My son is an only child and we had concerns about homeschooling him because of the social aspect. After experiencing a few months of him being in public school, we are leaning more towards homeschooling him. My friend has 5 kids and homeschools them and is going to meet with me this week to give me some information. Thank you for your video!

    • @karolinakowalik9720
      @karolinakowalik9720 7 місяців тому

      My son is an only child too, but after his first year at school I am going to home school him for a year or two for now. I decided to do it because the school has been undermining my authority as a parent on a multiple occasions, hasn't taught him to read and has been incompetent in general. A waste of time. I started teaching him myself and he is doing so much better now. As for the social aspect, Im not concerned because he has his own friends from the neighborhood and other additional classes outside of school.

  • @desertrose6655
    @desertrose6655 Рік тому +1

    my son wants to be an introvert an do his own thing an i get so much grief on that from people. i have offered for him to do activities he just doesn't want to do it. my daughter only wants one friend out side the house an apparently people say it is not enough.

  • @oldporkchops
    @oldporkchops 8 місяців тому

    Wonderful insights and ageless advice that crosses cultures and generations. Especially what was said at the 15 min and 22 min marks. We homeschool and can attest to what was said in this video to be true. I was looking for a video to share with a family friend about socializing while homeschooling and this hit all the major points.
    If I may add something, some of the geniuses in modern history were "homeschooled". Homeschooled is in inverted commas because some geniuses were schooled by a tutor hired by their uncle after their biological parents died. These findings were published in a study done back in the 1950s, and has major implications for homeschooling and peer "socialization" as we know it. The conclusions would be quite radical (in a good way) by today's standards.

  • @wraparoundschoolhouse5352
    @wraparoundschoolhouse5352 Рік тому +1

    PREACH!! 🙌🙌

  • @bringinglifehome
    @bringinglifehome Рік тому +3

    My daughter is 7 and we have been homeschooling since kindergarten. We do quite a bit of activities with other kids but my daughter hasn't ever made a 'best friend' per say. She'll have so much fun playing but won't even ask the kids their names 🫣do you think with your experience being homeschooled this is enough at this age?

    • @ThisHomeschoolHouse
      @ThisHomeschoolHouse  Рік тому +1

      That sounds totally normal. :)

    • @sarasali3077
      @sarasali3077 Рік тому +1

      I have a 6.5 year old that is just like this also. Sometimes I am sad for her (her brother doesn’t know a stranger and makes friends wherever we go) but she’s my wallflower who will play but holds back. I just try to encourage her to be herself (and give her words to use for introductions etc). She’ll get there ☺️

    • @jessicaladd85
      @jessicaladd85 Рік тому

      Same here for my son! He'll play and play with other kids and doesn't catch one name. I think it's totally excitement over getting to know them. Lol!

  • @sarasali3077
    @sarasali3077 Рік тому +1

    Love this! Thank you!

  • @jamiesundblad9830
    @jamiesundblad9830 Рік тому +1

    Yes yes yes to all of this! Great video🥰

  • @sisterfleur7523
    @sisterfleur7523 Рік тому +1

    Wow thank you !!!!

  • @arikawithana3023
    @arikawithana3023 Рік тому +1

    Agree, wholeheartedly! I have 4 kids I'm homeschooling, two of which are highschoolers who were public schooled for almost all of it. I can tell you - they're weird too😂 Also, my daughter (15) lets know how all her past friends from our old town are all into drugs and sex, so I think I'll stick with what we're doing.

  • @faithfullyinfertile
    @faithfullyinfertile Рік тому +1

    Amen!!!!

  • @desertrose6655
    @desertrose6655 Рік тому

    my youngest is working with the Ministry of Education with speech and language and not im basically hunted by them because my kids dont want to socialise with the whole world.

  • @mandigibson30
    @mandigibson30 Рік тому

    For some reason I don’t think I’m getting your weekly emails. I got the first one but that’s it 😅

  • @shannonfbc1
    @shannonfbc1 Рік тому

    My children are social butterflies 😂😂😂😂 I admit I made that assumption about homeschooled children before though. My eldest child went to public school for the entire school career and she is by far my most socially awkward child (love you honey but its true) my second oldest is autistic and he went to public to grade 3 and has been honeschooled for 3 years and he was tormented at school and had terrible social skills and no confidence on himself and now hes a social butterfly still awkward but hes autistic so.
    My two youngest children strictly homeschooled extremely social, confident children.

  • @raes8520
    @raes8520 11 місяців тому

    I think public school has led to higher divorce rates. Let me explain. The public school mindset is that kids should only be with same age peers. For class time, for lunchtime, for recess. The same group all the time. Even up into high school a kid will often want to know whether a certain friend is in a new class with them. The class doesn't matter, the kid's interests or talents won't matter. It's they want friends in the class with them. It's like this culture where you have a bubble of people that are everything to you. They have to be with you all the time. It's quite restrictive because kids will sacrifice something they may be interested in or good at because the bubble public school started them with are not interested in it. I see it all the time with groups of public school kids where if one kid in the friend bubble starts an art class after school at a community center the bubble will start to push them out. That one individual interest or activity is weird to the collective group. And then they group up and expect spouses to be the same. Their other half, the same as them, with the same interests and activities and that they should only do things together. And the spouses do not get to grow as individuals within a relationship and often eventually split up so their individual needs can be met.

  • @faithfullyinfertile
    @faithfullyinfertile Рік тому +3

    Are any of your kids extroverts? I’m an introvert with majority extroverted kids. 😮

  • @sheopshops428
    @sheopshops428 Рік тому +1

    I am worried about having a only child then to homeschooling her.

    • @ThisHomeschoolHouse
      @ThisHomeschoolHouse  Рік тому

      This is a common concern for families with only one child, however, there are lots of homeschoolers doing it very successfully! :) The Waldock Way is one of them.

  • @RockSimmer-gal4God
    @RockSimmer-gal4God Рік тому +1

    I think homeschoolers hear the comments and struggle with the comments!!! I know I’ve had discussions about this topic with family members who believe my kids will be weird but they want my kids in sex only schools and I know my kids would struggle with that!!! Ppl’s ignorance annoys me!!! When my kids where at school they had friends who where in different year groups!!! I remind my family that I’m outgoing and I party homeschooled as a kid!!! My kids love hanging out with kids of all ages!!! I have friends who are older than me and I know my 2 in classes are already preparing for that with their social hangouts as I hear awesome stuff!!! Homeschool doesn’t take as long as public school so there is more time to socialise!!! Our school system offers extra curricular activities to homeschoolers!!!

    • @ThisHomeschoolHouse
      @ThisHomeschoolHouse  Рік тому

      Yes! There are loads of opportunities for wholesome socialization as homeschoolers.

  • @silverbeowulf5601
    @silverbeowulf5601 Рік тому

    I homeschool to not socialize...I real don't like being around people.
    I dont like it because of church, the more I learned about the lord and jesus the more depressed and miserable I became. I cant be near people for fear of god who for me is evil and dangerous..but thats me if it makes your heart happy go with it.

    • @ThisHomeschoolHouse
      @ThisHomeschoolHouse  Рік тому

      I'm sorry that you had that experience. :( My church is like my family and I'm extremely grateful to have it.