100-Year-Old Luise Rainer Talks About Her Work in The Good Earth (1937)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 кві 2020
  • Two-time Oscar winner Luise Rainer discusses embodying her character and the human condition in The Good Earth.
    --
    Look for these films on Watch TCM at tcm.com/watch.
    Connect with Turner Classic Movies:
    Visit TCM WEBSITE: myt.cm/TCMwebsite
    Follow TCM on INSTAGRAM: myt.cm/TCMinstagram
    Like TCM on FACEBOOK: myt.cm/TCMfacebook
    Follow TCM on TWITTER: myt.cm/TCMtwitter
    Subscribe now to watch more classic film content from TCM spr.ly/6017cTBT
  • Фільми й анімація

КОМЕНТАРІ • 220

  • @BellaFirenze
    @BellaFirenze Рік тому +23

    Luise Rainer (Düsseldorf, Germany 12 January 1910 - 30 December 2014). She was the first thespian to win multiple Academy Awards and the first to win back-to-back; at the time of her death, thirteen days shy of her 105th birthday, she was the longest-lived Oscar recipient, a superlative that has not been exceeded as of 2022

  • @james5460
    @james5460 4 роки тому +61

    She's still very theatrical, these actors never lose their craft.

  • @annbush1826
    @annbush1826 3 роки тому +21

    Luise Rainier in Pearl Buck’s “The Good Earth” was the blockbuster film before”Gone With the Wind.”
    She still looks and sounds amazing.

  • @josephappleton9611
    @josephappleton9611 4 роки тому +48

    This interview is wonderful.......Luise Rainer....Beautiful......5 Stars TCM!!!

  • @glennmalimban5256
    @glennmalimban5256 Рік тому +11

    She was the longest lived Oscar Best Actress. Olivia de Havilland almost came close. I still remember seeing her participating in two Oscars Reunion of Academy Award winners years ago.. Watching this video while she was already 100 and could answer sharply remembering all those past years of her work was amazing...

  • @isabelps812
    @isabelps812 4 роки тому +46

    What a life force! 100 years young 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

    • @12classics39
      @12classics39 Рік тому

      Indeed. “I fell idiotically on the back of my neck, which would break the neck of a person, but my neck they couldn’t get through.” GO OFF QUEEN!!

    • @akrenwinkle
      @akrenwinkle Рік тому

      @@12classics39 Judging from the way she walked, it is probable that Miss Rainer was afflicted with arthritis, as one would expect of anyone 85 years old, much less one hundred. I think she preferred to explain it away in an amusing fashion, so as not to be pitied. That she could walk at all at that age is a testament to her vivacity and determination not to let her audience down.

  • @khalidalali186
    @khalidalali186 9 місяців тому +4

    She passed away, aged 104, in fashionable Belgravia. She deserved nothing less. The best actress to have ever lived in my humble opinion.

  • @angelacarleton9575
    @angelacarleton9575 2 роки тому +11

    Luise Rainier was so wonderful in her expressive nature by telling us about her work in the Good Earth. What a gifted actress and as someone said, these actors never lose their craft and that is for sure.

  • @katherenewedic8076
    @katherenewedic8076 3 роки тому +12

    I think that he's the most respectful interviewer

    • @kittykat3052
      @kittykat3052 3 роки тому +1

      KATHERINE WEDIC 💕💕💕 HELLO TO YOU AND YES INDEED I THANK YOU SO VERY MUCH FOR YOUR 💯% TRUE AND CORRECT COMMENT 💕💕 BECAUSE MR. OSBOURNE WAS A BEAUTIFUL SOUL OF A HUMAN BEING 💕💕 PEACE AND LOVE TO YOU AND YOUR FAMILY ALWAYS """KATHERINE WEDIC""" 💕💕🙏🙏💕💕 AND TO ALL RIGHTEOUS PEOPLE FROM 🌞🌞 KATHERINE IN CHICAGO ILLINOIS ON TUESDAY MARCH 2 ,2021 AT 1:47pm 💙 💙 THE MARATHON CONTINUES 💙 💙

  • @SomeoneHasToSayIt2525
    @SomeoneHasToSayIt2525 4 роки тому +54

    Soooooooo happy I clicked "play". I've known about Ms. Rainer for many years but never saw her in an interview. This video should be made mandatory in all acting schools, the students would learn more in this 28 minutes than in a whole semester, at least more about what matters. Sublime.

    • @elainelosee7974
      @elainelosee7974 3 роки тому +5

      Yes, great comment.
      She is a Wise woman, stood up for herself, dignity
      Is not for sale.
      Atta girl, you are
      Young at ❤ 🤍 💙

  • @thomaslucia3059
    @thomaslucia3059 3 роки тому +23

    What a gloriously beautiful woman, inside and out. A person and personality to marvel at and truly admire. How honored and gifted are we to have had her so long...even if her professional career was so short. This left me in tears.

  • @carolward9455
    @carolward9455 4 роки тому +32

    One of the special things in this stay at home virus time...able to watch the festival at home. Luise Rainer is one of my favorites. What a treat to see her talk. Miss Robert Osborne...treat to see him more too.

  • @chriscross7454
    @chriscross7454 4 роки тому +52

    That new show Hollywood on Netflix brought me here

  • @davorpavlovic948
    @davorpavlovic948 4 роки тому +19

    So beautiful... this lady was fabulous...

  • @larrydirtybird
    @larrydirtybird 3 роки тому +12

    Thank you for posting this. I lived a short walk from the Egyptian at that time, wanted to go but missed it. It’s amazing how wonderfully expressive her face was even at 100. Her eyes had the same sparkle that they had in the 1930s. The Rainer from her Hollywood days totally shone through.

  • @globalspiritualrevolutionmedia
    @globalspiritualrevolutionmedia 2 роки тому +4

    Every single time I listen to this great Woman tears flow down my face because of the Ultimate Beauty of Her Wisdom, Knowledge and The Spiritual Innerstanding of Mr. Rainer🙏🕊✝️She is greatly missed!

  • @hayleyannamathieson674
    @hayleyannamathieson674 4 роки тому +15

    Bravo! What a fabulous lady.💖🤗✨💫

  • @hortensebediam1032
    @hortensebediam1032 4 роки тому +13

    RIP Luise Rainer
    1910 - 2014

  • @elainelosee7974
    @elainelosee7974 3 роки тому +6

    How lovely and with
    Great wit. Love her
    Beauty, at this age, she still has her
    Beautiful attitude and style. That you
    For sharing this
    Woman, her story.
    Robert is and was
    One classy, well
    Knowledge of the
    Industry. Thank you
    Both for this.

  • @ryann6569
    @ryann6569 3 роки тому +4

    I just stumbled upon this video from my bed at night in a UA-cam rabbit hole and now I’m sitting here crying

  • @marylizakowski706
    @marylizakowski706 8 місяців тому +3

    Robert was so wonderful with her.

  • @alistaircroll1036
    @alistaircroll1036 2 дні тому

    She used to be my customer at our food market in the Kings Road Chelsea .
    Indomitable spirit .
    Always very lovely with everyone especially small children.
    She was the queen of sampling.
    Everyone knew she was famous but they didn’t know what for and tbh didn’t care either.
    Her Diva like presence is sorely missed .

  • @annazizzo6631
    @annazizzo6631 4 роки тому +12

    She was a great actress!❤️❤️

  • @spockboy
    @spockboy 4 роки тому +20

    She was beautiful.

    • @gailbrown9505
      @gailbrown9505 4 роки тому

      SpockBoy, she is beautiful.

    • @spockboy
      @spockboy 4 роки тому +2

      @@gailbrown9505 I said she WAS because she is no longer alive.

    • @akrenwinkle
      @akrenwinkle 4 роки тому +1

      @@spockboy I'm going way out on a limb and guess that Gail Brown meant that because Luise is captured on film, she is and always will be beautiful.

    • @spockboy
      @spockboy 4 роки тому +2

      @@akrenwinkle Agreed, :)

  • @steveflor9942
    @steveflor9942 2 роки тому +6

    Great interview. Dear, charming and inspiring woman.

  • @larasemerad2605
    @larasemerad2605 11 місяців тому +1

    I seen the movie The Good Earth-Great movie and WOW on how the story was told. Happy 100 back then.

  • @lenwelch2195
    @lenwelch2195 3 роки тому +17

    What a wonderful interview. She heard everything - she’s an actress and did a great job here in one of if not her last performance . Acting was her way of being creative . It shows what an inquisitive expansive mind she has . She doesn’t think of acting as lying . She sees it as a way to bring out the humanity in people who constantly work and shut themselves off in order to answer all the responsibilities of life . She loved life and this was a regular day for her. She made sure her life followed the path not traveled often by others . A creative courageous lady the world was lucky to have had the pleasure of being entertained and moved by . Thank you ms Rainer .

  • @robertwilkins8357
    @robertwilkins8357 11 місяців тому +4

    Oh my I am so glad I found this, she is so clear in speaking of The Good Earth. She was an angel in films.

  • @HananAwaad
    @HananAwaad Рік тому +2

    I share the same birthday as hers .. I am obsessed with her now!

  • @jovanrameau3578
    @jovanrameau3578 8 місяців тому +1

    Now, that is an Artist... pure, raw, truth and beauty and wise.

  • @curewish574
    @curewish574 Рік тому +3

    "Humans - seem different but all 'feel the same'"; what an inspirational human being; a gem that Hollywood didn't cast !

  • @conormitchell309
    @conormitchell309 2 роки тому +5

    I'm glad she spoke about the beginnings of the film and wonder if the actress she was speaking about Anna May Wong. I would hope so, but I don't know if I am putting "character" onto someone who I admire.

    • @fredjoned9495
      @fredjoned9495 2 роки тому +3

      It was unfortunate for Anna May and so many others of Chinese ancestry that the prevailing 'anti-Chinese' law(s) prohibited so many things, including mixed marriage, what we now term 'hanging out' with other races, like Jim Crow in the south.

    • @goplad1
      @goplad1 16 днів тому

      Anna May Wong felt she was born to play the part of O-Lan. When MGM decided to cast Caucasion actors to play Chinese characters it put Anna into a deep depression. This resulted in her traveling to China for the better part of a year. It's a blemish on old Hollywood that they forfeited the opportunity to cast the sublime Anna May Wong to play a Chinese woman because they were afraid of betraying some ridiculous anti-Chinese law that really didn't exist by the later 1930s.

  • @Makimaki304
    @Makimaki304 3 місяці тому +1

    even at the age of 100, you can still see the vibrant emotions from her eyes. Her eyes haven't changed.

  • @1966marlon
    @1966marlon 2 роки тому +3

    Great lady. She was the star until her last days. She loved her fans... and she did not pretend ...I will love her forever.

  • @classicfilmlover7844
    @classicfilmlover7844 3 роки тому +6

    This is so precious💕 thank you so much Robert and TCM!

  • @anniem9595
    @anniem9595 4 роки тому +8

    Wow! ❤❤❤
    Thank you!

  • @donaldhaynes8317
    @donaldhaynes8317 3 роки тому +3

    She was Olan! Thank you!

  • @bfwetzel
    @bfwetzel Рік тому +3

    She is a marvel. Exquisite actress.

  • @Filmstarindamaking
    @Filmstarindamaking 3 роки тому +6

    And the Oscar goes to....Luise Rainer. This interview is definitely worthy of a third Oscar. I couldn’t stop watching. She was profound and spoke volumes even when she said very little as she expressed her feelings from deep within. Though she struggled to hear, read, and speak she captivated the audience with her storytelling like any great actor would do. Loved how she called out the sexiest, misogynist, racist Hollywood studio system as she relayed her encounters with the MGM heads without saying an evil word against them. She spoke beautifully about everyone. Here is someone at peace with herself and everyone and everything around her. What a wonderful human being!

    • @12classics39
      @12classics39 7 місяців тому +1

      Exactly. Actors didn’t have much power in the old studio system, but Luise fought back against the racism and sexism in every way she could. She deserves to be applauded for speaking up and saying she wasn’t right for the part (the implication is, obviously, because she was white) and for straight-up calling the makeup artists “mad” for thinking a Chinese character was no more than a caricature mask for her to wear. She did what she could; kudos to her.

  • @j.louisv.123
    @j.louisv.123 4 роки тому +8

    The purest form of what true acting is meant to be and is: Miss Rainer.

  • @annazizzo6631
    @annazizzo6631 4 роки тому +18

    Can’t wait to watch her and muni next in the good earth !!!

  • @cheyenneasiafoxe292
    @cheyenneasiafoxe292 3 роки тому +5

    Still lovely at 100

  • @hilbillie
    @hilbillie 10 днів тому

    She all radiated with beauty... kinda a twinkle. So entertaining and joyful!

  • @jessicaT12345
    @jessicaT12345 5 місяців тому

    what a marvelous interview!

  • @j1st633
    @j1st633 Рік тому +2

    Wow! Wonderful interview.

  • @gnehzeey
    @gnehzeey Рік тому +1

    what a wonderful, truthful and graceful actress,lady and artist!what a wonderful host! of beauty,feelings of universality and humanity❤☮️

  • @immaterialimmaterial5195
    @immaterialimmaterial5195 2 роки тому +2

    A very special lady and a wonderful film

  • @VILA1963
    @VILA1963 3 роки тому +9

    I watched THE GOOD EARTH 30 years ago on TV. Loved her performance. Anna Mae Wong would have been great . And Louise's face in the film reminded of Meryl Streep's. Check the photos.

  • @howdy268
    @howdy268 3 роки тому +4

    Well done this interviewer was so incredibly respectful Excellent

  • @dizmop
    @dizmop 4 роки тому +17

    Is she talking about Anna may wong at 7:03?

    • @dylanwashington2419
      @dylanwashington2419 2 роки тому +5

      SHE WAS!!!!!!!!! Every actor in hollywood at that time campaign and was rooting for Anna, but Hollywood as usual missed the mark.

    • @12classics39
      @12classics39 7 місяців тому +3

      Yes. Kudos to her for basically telling Thalberg “this part is hers, not mine, you bigot.”

  • @cheyenneasiafoxe292
    @cheyenneasiafoxe292 3 роки тому +6

    now that's a star!!!!!!!

  • @NAPARED
    @NAPARED 4 роки тому +2

    She never forget and never be forgotten..

  • @0rangeberri547
    @0rangeberri547 2 роки тому +2

    No editing just letting her do her thing in the audience participation write it down💜👍🏾

  • @cheyenneasiafoxe292
    @cheyenneasiafoxe292 3 роки тому +12

    "its not acting its BEING" [Luis Rainer] That and She and Barrymore ---now that's a tandem of Hollywood royalty.

  • @ollierobinson4339
    @ollierobinson4339 3 роки тому +2

    Unforgettable

  • @howdy268
    @howdy268 3 роки тому

    Love 💕 love 💕 such a great actress BRAVO 👏

  • @BasudevBhattacharya
    @BasudevBhattacharya 4 роки тому +2

    Excellent.

  • @wesleyedwards3031
    @wesleyedwards3031 3 роки тому +6

    Good grief: So many actors today need to see this.

  • @mdiggs6365
    @mdiggs6365 Місяць тому

    Wow. She was beautiful and looked like her younger self

  • @cheyenneasiafoxe292
    @cheyenneasiafoxe292 3 роки тому +17

    When stars were stars and classically trained in their art.

  • @rkomgm3932
    @rkomgm3932 3 роки тому +33

    Anna May Wong should have played her role on the Good Earth!

    • @julianmarsh1378
      @julianmarsh1378 3 роки тому +7

      No...Hollywood should have found more roles like these and Anna should have had some of those...Rainer did wonderful work in The Good Earth.

    • @jamiehernandez4746
      @jamiehernandez4746 3 роки тому +10

      @@julianmarsh1378 Anna May Wong should’ve played the role though, Hollywood tormented her and she couldn’t even play a role that consist of her own race, Anna May Wong would’ve done better.

    • @julianmarsh1378
      @julianmarsh1378 3 роки тому +3

      @@jamiehernandez4746 You can't know that she would have done better. And saying an acting role should be based on race is itself somewhat questionable.

    • @jamiehernandez4746
      @jamiehernandez4746 3 роки тому +14

      @@julianmarsh1378 no it’s not because at the end of the day they got a white actress and she did yellow face, Hollywood has a deep past about this, not right.

    • @julianmarsh1378
      @julianmarsh1378 3 роки тому

      @@jamiehernandez4746 Don't care.

  • @TheRoyKirklandShow
    @TheRoyKirklandShow Рік тому +2

    Wow! I saw The Good Earth in my 7th grade class in 1970's and was fascinated by her performance. I actually thought she was Chinese. I love this film.

  • @jeebsunabia7972
    @jeebsunabia7972 5 місяців тому +2

    Luise Rainer has made her mark in history, but let us be honest: 'The Good Earth' should really have gone to Anna May Wong. The Hays Code made sure that Anna May Wong would never have had the chance to play Olan.

  • @Zif-the-Old-Herring
    @Zif-the-Old-Herring 5 місяців тому

    A wonderful woman.

  • @familylifetoo9541
    @familylifetoo9541 10 місяців тому

    In Honor of her, please put closed captions on this video

  • @midnightteapot5633
    @midnightteapot5633 2 роки тому +1

    The Good Earth is a bloody good movie .

  • @12classics39
    @12classics39 Рік тому +6

    “I don't believe in acting. I believe in being.” She knew the secret to truly great performances. Also I love how she tears Paul Muni to shreds. What an egotistical nut, asking his wife to sit under the camera all day!

  • @robertwilkins8357
    @robertwilkins8357 11 місяців тому

    She is a dear dear lady!

  • @chanceDdog2009
    @chanceDdog2009 4 роки тому +15

    Wonderful lady. Such a shame they did not cast an actual Asian or Asian American for the roll. Difren times... And all that....

    • @NAPARED
      @NAPARED 4 роки тому +1

      Exactly

    • @randyacuna3248
      @randyacuna3248 3 роки тому +1

      If another actress ( regardless on nationally) would have done the Good Earth, I don't think she would have been as great . Way big shoes to full.

    • @Coffee_Enthusiast
      @Coffee_Enthusiast 3 роки тому +2

      Yeah. I’m sort of pissed that they white washed the movie, but as you said, different times. At least they made a movie on Asian culture back then.

    • @emdee3326
      @emdee3326 3 роки тому

      Like Ana May Song...?

    • @nickgreatpwrful5754
      @nickgreatpwrful5754 3 роки тому +3

      @@emdee3326 Anna May Wong. I think she's the actress Miss Rainer is referring to that wanted that part so badly.

  • @DTA-me3kv
    @DTA-me3kv 4 роки тому +1

    Hollywood did a number on her.

  • @alidz9885
    @alidz9885 4 роки тому +12

    Anna Mae Wong brought me here...

  • @michellecueto1072
    @michellecueto1072 2 роки тому +44

    Anna May Wong deserved that role

    • @gnehzeey
      @gnehzeey Рік тому +5

      Rainer did superb performance as Wong Long's wife🎉

    • @michellecueto1072
      @michellecueto1072 Рік тому +2

      @@gnehzeey y’all better not complain about the little mermaid being black if y’all allow this nonsense

    • @gnehzeey
      @gnehzeey Рік тому +2

      @@michellecueto1072 mermaids come in many kinds, just like their cousins on land 😊

    • @michellecueto1072
      @michellecueto1072 Рік тому +2

      @@gnehzeey and Rainer played a Chinese character in China

    • @gnehzeey
      @gnehzeey Рік тому +1

      @@michellecueto1072 universal humanity 💖

  • @chamberpot969
    @chamberpot969 2 роки тому +1

    My goodness an immortal

  • @i.am.bethanyanne
    @i.am.bethanyanne 2 роки тому

    🥰🥰🥰🥰

  • @raptorfromthe6ix833
    @raptorfromthe6ix833 8 місяців тому

    When was this filmed

  • @ForteExpresso
    @ForteExpresso 4 роки тому +3

    I am on the verge of completion of the novel The Good Earth.
    But I want to watch the movie too. But I can't find it anywhere what should I do 😭?

    • @screenactorsguilable
      @screenactorsguilable 4 роки тому

      i know a websitr show it freely

    • @screenactorsguilable
      @screenactorsguilable 4 роки тому

      @@felix.carbonel.3799 ikr

    • @TakeTheStep10
      @TakeTheStep10 4 роки тому

      It is free streaming on Amazon Prime Video.

    • @africatv9359
      @africatv9359 3 роки тому

      @@TakeTheStep10 I can send it to you if you are still looking to watch. A great film.

    • @lizbradshaw5747
      @lizbradshaw5747 2 роки тому

      I got the DVD from the library. I first watched the film about 10 years ago. I kept meaning to read the book. I finally read the book a few days ago and watched the film again today.

  • @goplad1
    @goplad1 16 днів тому +1

    When Miss Rainer referred to another actress who was lobbying for the part of O-Lan Mr. Osborne should have asked her who it was. That person was Anna May Wong. She was the first successful Chinese actress in cinema. She had read the book "The Good Earth" and immediately became enthralled with O-Lan. She felt she was born to play the part. Unfortunately because of the miscegenation law toward the Chinese at the time Anna wasn't given the part. It broke her heart and put her into a funk that resulted in her travelling to China for the better part of a year. Not to take anything away from the sublime Luise Rainer it's a shame Hollywood chose to cast Caucasian actors to play other ethnicities. As I watch Miss Rainer in the part of O-Lan I never for a minute believe she is Chinese. Or that Paul Muni is Chinese. There were many fine Chinese actors who could have played the lead roles in the "The Good Earth". Sadly Hollywood at the time wouldn't bank on these people so hiring Caucasian actors to play in yellow face was playing it safe.

  • @jessiklovecine
    @jessiklovecine Рік тому +3

    weird that at this day and age ppl are celebrating individuals who were part of outcasting asians and people of colour in the industry. lived 100 years and didn’t acknowledge her mistakes until the end, racism for yall.

  • @cheyenneasiafoxe292
    @cheyenneasiafoxe292 3 роки тому +3

    She was great--what a beauty-as great as Dietrich but she retired early....Love Robert Osborne

  • @susanmarie2231
    @susanmarie2231 2 місяці тому +2

    The tremendous vulnerability of her acting style comes to mind when I see Meryl Streep in “Sophie’s Choice.”

  • @lower_than_furries9727
    @lower_than_furries9727 4 роки тому +4

    Her portrayal of Olan was perfect. Despite her not being an asian.

    • @BuckyBrown-lt4ry
      @BuckyBrown-lt4ry 3 роки тому

      This is what acting is about. You don't have to be Asian to play one, you don't have to be black to play one(I just saw a show where a black actor played a famous white guy). It's called acting. Stop this race card playing!!!!

  • @twerkinthecityhuh6340
    @twerkinthecityhuh6340 3 роки тому +3

    Duh "write it" ..... Good thing the audience is there to save this mess!!!!! I wanted to see if Luise was still alive but sadly she passed in '14 a mere 13 days before her 105th bday

  • @jimjames2429
    @jimjames2429 Рік тому +5

    The irony... a German-Austrian Jewish woman, playing a role that was designated for Anna May Wong, albeit suggested to play, but because of optics, Luise was cast. Talk about a screw-you.

    • @12classics39
      @12classics39 7 місяців тому +1

      Luise herself doesn’t deserve blame for that. In the old studio system, actors had pretty much no say in what films they did or didn’t make; if you were under contract, you had to obey the studio head.

    • @jimjames2429
      @jimjames2429 7 місяців тому

      For sure and I agree. However, historically speaking, she's errantly listed as White woman, which in visible context she is, but to be correct Anna May Wong was wholly omitted from the narrative and this story. Bette Davis famously sued the studios, so one could bite the hand that fed them but few chose to. @@12classics39

  • @mr2ti41
    @mr2ti41 Рік тому +1

    Different times… but don’t bullshit. The only person who could play another ethnicity from what they are is Robert Downey Jr. Ha!

  • @roberttelarket4934
    @roberttelarket4934 3 роки тому +3

    Outstanding excellent movie! Luise Rainer(O-Lan) looks exactly like Meryl Streep who looks Asiatic herself.

  • @shmemi
    @shmemi Рік тому +12

    She may have been a great actress. And indeed a star. But her star power wasn’t the only thing that won her that role, it was also Hollywood’s deep racism. Let’s give credit where credit is due.

    • @yavrielsechelle7431
      @yavrielsechelle7431 Рік тому +1

      Let them have their heroes. They're losing ground everywhere else.

    • @brianoyler706
      @brianoyler706 Рік тому

      Shmemi... Luise Rainer worked for a movie studio. In the 30s, 40s and 50s when an actor was under contract to a studio, he/she was expected to do the roles he/she was assigned, otherwise face suspension or worse like being fired. Luise Rainer did not obtain the role of Olan due to anything racial. She was assigned the role by the studio like so many of her acting peers. What you should have commented is perhaps Luise Rainer believed that a real Asian actor would have "looked" better for authenticity, but the question remains: Would an Asian actor have been as good or better than Luise Rainer??? We have already seen what Luise Rainer did with the role!!!!

    • @shmemi
      @shmemi Рік тому +2

      @@brianoyler706 her name was Anna May Wong. She was a star. She had talent. And she was Taiwanese american. MGM refused to cast her despite screen testing her. Comments like these really don’t warrant a reply but this argument about “the studio system” is just patently false. How could it not be about race when none of the main characters were given to Asian actors?

    • @brianoyler706
      @brianoyler706 Рік тому

      @@shmemi Well, to put it to you bluntly so that you understand, MGM probably did not have any Asian actresses under contract. The role of Olan was offered to those actresses whom MGM had under contract. MGM was not going to go out of its way to hire actresses outside of the studio!!!!

    • @shmemi
      @shmemi Рік тому +1

      @@brianoyler706 thank you for putting it bluntly so I’d understand, I dumb. But pray tell, why didn’t MGM have any Asian actresses under contract? Don’t tell me it’s not about race.

  • @sammyishy.579
    @sammyishy.579 Рік тому +3

    I can't be the only one deeply offended by the good earth. Maybe a remake with actual Asians should be considered

  • @teasncrumpets6649
    @teasncrumpets6649 4 роки тому +24

    She is no doubt a talented actress but it hurts so much when white people portray us Asian characters...

    • @gabrielsanabriaibieta
      @gabrielsanabriaibieta 4 роки тому +7

      The great thing is that she recognizes that it was weird and that another woman was better for the part

    • @alixvhessen
      @alixvhessen 4 роки тому +3

      that was the 1930ies and I do firmly believe that she did it with all due respect that anyone could possibly have had (!)

    • @BuckyBrown-lt4ry
      @BuckyBrown-lt4ry 3 роки тому

      No, you miss the point. It's called ACTING. Stop playing the race card, racist.

    • @eo9245
      @eo9245 3 роки тому +3

      Right???? They did Anna May Wong dirty!

    • @marywebb9127
      @marywebb9127 2 роки тому

      It was a different time and place 🙄 Stop complaining about stuff that you can't change. It makes you look low IQ!

  • @brianoyler706
    @brianoyler706 Рік тому +2

    Michelle Cueto...it is very difficult to state whether one actor "deserves" a role over another. Did you not listen to Luise Rainer say that she had to feel the character. Just because Anna May Wong was Asian does not mean that she deserved the role. Perhaps Anna May Wong would have been great in the role of Olan or perhaps not. We have already seen what Luise Rainer did with the role .

  • @caurliflower7147
    @caurliflower7147 3 роки тому +7

    girlie did yellow-face, praising her for what?

    • @sambadace
      @sambadace 3 роки тому +2

      Right..

    • @marywebb9127
      @marywebb9127 2 роки тому +1

      Triggered 🤣

    • @michellecloud5159
      @michellecloud5159 2 роки тому +3

      @@marywebb9127 as we should

    • @marywebb9127
      @marywebb9127 2 роки тому

      @@michellecloud5159 🙄

    • @markcaserta1367
      @markcaserta1367 Рік тому +1

      This is what actors do. They are able to put themselves in other people's shoes so to speak. It take a great actor and actress to pull this off. She did. It could have gone badly, it didn't. Her portrayal is believable and touching.

  • @julianmarsh1378
    @julianmarsh1378 3 роки тому +2

    Considering the nature of many of the comments found here, it is no wonder so many people hate the Left. The self-righteousness is suffocating. No one ever said Anna May Wong should not gotten the role, but at the end of the day, this is something to wring one's hands about? I say in passing that Rainer did a good job in that role and the idiots on parade come out like so many peasants marching on Dr. Frankenstein's castle...it is a good movie as it is and as a viewer that is my interest in it. That seems too much for the holier than thou crowd.

    • @michellecloud5159
      @michellecloud5159 2 роки тому +8

      i disagree. i am not discrediting Luise Rainer, but anna may wong was done the biggest injustice. her whole career she was subjected to playing racist tropes and the role that was FINALLY for her, she couldn't play. The director himself said that Wong's audition could make a grown man cry, but she was too "Chinese" for the role and the studio had to adhere to miscegenation laws. It's not about being political so you yourself can get down from your high horse.

    • @brianoyler706
      @brianoyler706 Рік тому

      Michellecloud... Luise Rainer worked for a movie studio in 1937. In the 30s, 40s and 50s when an actor was under contract to a studio, he/she was expected to play the roles to which he/she was assigned. If the actor refused, he/she faced suspension or worse like being fired. Luise Rainer obtained the role of Olan by assignment, not through anything racial. I doubt whether MGM had any female Asian actresses under contract at that time. If Anna May Wong had been chosen for the role, questions still remain: would Anna May 's acting have been as good or better , or would the choice of an Asian actor have been the right choice due to "looks" and authenticity??? One cannot determine whether one actor "deserves" a role over another due to extenuating circumstances like race, religion, sexual orientation, etc ... We have already seen what Luise Rainer did with the role!!!

  • @SuperEmmitt1
    @SuperEmmitt1 3 роки тому +3

    This is absurd.

    • @sambadace
      @sambadace 3 роки тому

      Why?

    • @marywebb9127
      @marywebb9127 2 роки тому +1

      I would like to see how well you look at 100!