Superchargers vs. Turbochargers - Settling the Debate

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 3 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 94

  • @cd5143
    @cd5143 4 роки тому +20

    Dang that was way better than most explanations on UA-cam. Thank you so much.

  • @Nick-1992-SRB
    @Nick-1992-SRB 4 роки тому +16

    Thank you man for explaining everything exactly I supercharged my 2017 GT Mustang the car is a beast I enjoy every second of driving it. 👍🏼👍🏼

  • @ital1489
    @ital1489 4 роки тому +16

    Great video man, explained everything nicely.

    • @Pablo.Gutierre12
      @Pablo.Gutierre12 4 роки тому

      So mice makes me wanna buy a 370z and slap a twin turbo on it

    • @ital1489
      @ital1489 4 роки тому

      @@Pablo.Gutierre12 Yea, but for me I like to keep cars near stock, unless I get really attached to my car and keep it for a long time. Then I'll do big upgrades on it over time or restorations.

  • @steverussell6642
    @steverussell6642 22 дні тому

    Nice job👍

  • @ofto5872
    @ofto5872 5 років тому +6

    looking forward to the install

  • @KpxRagDoll
    @KpxRagDoll 3 роки тому +8

    Basically if you got stick go turbo and if you got AT go super

  • @DennyBalance
    @DennyBalance 4 роки тому +1

    It's up to which one you get a better deal on 😂 or tradition

  • @grantgundesen6284
    @grantgundesen6284 2 місяці тому

    Awesome Information thank you 🕊

  • @jeffreymoore4132
    @jeffreymoore4132 4 роки тому +2

    I didn't see it mentioned, but after a couple decades of turning bolts one thing that has really stood out to me regarding aftermarket turbos (and apologies for stating the obvious) is that NO aftermarket kit/company can approach the testing/QA/QC you get with a factory boosted car. This is really obvious with the turbo manifolds. So many manifolds crack and consider how many people are actually daily driving their boosted cars?? OEMs design their boost to get beat on. Aftermarket companies have a FEW test cars.
    Additionally, until somewhat recently, the ECU for aftermarket boost has always been inferior to OEM. We now have multiple options for very fast/realtime correction ECUs that are fast enough to save our motors. However, plug n' play solutions are still somewhat limited. If I were to add boost now, there is no way I'd use any ECU unless it was fast enough to use safeguards and save the engine.

    • @spooler7828
      @spooler7828 3 роки тому

      Fast Intentions for the record. No cracked exhaust manifolds, period.

    • @robertvanruyssevelt7159
      @robertvanruyssevelt7159 Рік тому

      When I got a bigger turbo for my RB30 I got a custom high rise manifold made. I would not consider an off the shelf or postal map. You need a tuneable ecu and get it tuned by a competent tuner on a dyno.

  • @PR1NCETD0T
    @PR1NCETD0T 3 роки тому +5

    Superchargers are definitely more linear and reliable than turbo chargers but turbo chargers give you more potential and the feeling of hitting boost in a turbo car is unmatched.

    • @krebgurfson5732
      @krebgurfson5732 3 роки тому +1

      no lol, the feeling of turbo lag is not "unmatched" it's awful and i'd change over to supercharging in an instant if i could.

    • @FlipFlab
      @FlipFlab 2 роки тому +1

      @@krebgurfson5732 turbo lag is barely real anymore man let’s be real

  • @og6340
    @og6340 3 роки тому

    So basically a super charger will blast out the door but lose power on the big end if your racing and a turbo will lag out the door but wooo make crazy power on the big end so tie is are better for racing and super charger is good for just showing out and making dig outs . I’m looking to build a sleeper so I think turbo will
    Be best for what I’m trying to do because we race a lot

  • @Slow_Gary
    @Slow_Gary 5 років тому +6

    Im planning to buy a 370z soon i wish i could turbo charge it later in life too

    • @thecarizon504
      @thecarizon504  5 років тому +8

      Hey, you might get the chance some day, never put it past yourself.

  • @_wenjo
    @_wenjo 3 роки тому +3

    Nobody really tells you that centrifugal superchargers get all the lag of turbos without being connected to the exhaust. Roots and screw blowers though that's a whole different story instant power and torque.

  • @txkingg
    @txkingg 5 років тому +1

    im thinking about a supercharger since the z lacks in the early revs

    • @txkingg
      @txkingg 5 років тому

      And you debunk my myth lmao, what about running one turbo instead of 2?

    • @HungNguyen-sf1ew
      @HungNguyen-sf1ew 4 роки тому +2

      @@txkingg you'd have more turbo lag if it's a larger turbo.

  • @stupidboy1746
    @stupidboy1746 3 роки тому

    Best explanation on UA-cam I downloaded this video great job 😎🔥

  • @YourRacingChannel
    @YourRacingChannel 4 роки тому +5

    Awesome video thank you
    Subbed...

  • @youravantgarde
    @youravantgarde Рік тому +1

    $7k for 100hp is not worth it at all. Turbo is the way to go

  • @k-d321
    @k-d321 2 роки тому

    Hi, is there any supercharge or turbocharge for Nissan VQ40 ? thx

  • @eddiegarcia2556
    @eddiegarcia2556 4 роки тому +1

    Very helpful!
    thank you

  • @videomaniac108
    @videomaniac108 10 місяців тому

    Thanks, but I'll keep it simpler with increased displacement and higher compression, along with lower vehicle weight. Someday I'll rebuild my VQ37 in my 370z with a 4.3 liter bored and stroked engine with a 12:1 compression ratio. 8'm currently getting about 380 peak crank hp with an intake, exhaust and tune.

  • @nachoyoutube3378
    @nachoyoutube3378 3 роки тому +1

    Great video bruh.. Seems like your talking about TT VS SuperCharger.. Most ppl out here are not TT their cars.. So a SuperCharger will produce more power than a Single Turbo??

    • @clipofthedayyup4907
      @clipofthedayyup4907 Рік тому

      No. A big single turbo will spool slower than TT. This is depending on the size of turbos your working with. But if the two systems produce similar peak HP the TT system should spool quicker overall.

  • @ELxJEFExSN1P3Zz
    @ELxJEFExSN1P3Zz 3 роки тому

    Thanks for the info... great video by the way

  • @VoltDisaris
    @VoltDisaris 4 роки тому +1

    Should I get a turbo for my g35 then? Or a supercharger?

    • @Boostedandyy
      @Boostedandyy 3 роки тому

      Yeet God supercharge it that’s wht imma go for

  • @dropful2347
    @dropful2347 4 роки тому +4

    Is this reliable for the car tho ? Any damages to the car ? What do we need to switch out in order to be ready for supercharger?

    • @mikedurk9439
      @mikedurk9439 4 роки тому

      Just better fueling, ie injectors and pump for low boost. High boost, most cars will need atleast stronger rods.. you will need a tune regardless of boost added

  • @MemosGarageAZ
    @MemosGarageAZ 4 роки тому

    Thanks for the great breakdown and explanation man.

  • @spooler7828
    @spooler7828 3 роки тому

    Buy Once, Cry Once. Fast Intentions hands down. The best system out there.

  • @reneflores8832
    @reneflores8832 3 роки тому

    What’s that rally car that had both a turbo and super charger?

  • @Mark-vo1zy
    @Mark-vo1zy 3 роки тому

    What about twin supercharger ?

  • @enovah2151
    @enovah2151 3 роки тому +1

    so turbocharger thank you

  • @Criticalthinking788.
    @Criticalthinking788. 3 роки тому

    Perfect

  • @testerman8181
    @testerman8181 4 роки тому

    Great video man!

  • @al3zmi
    @al3zmi 4 роки тому +3

    Great video, i just wanted to point out, in superchargers you have to replace the intake manifold with the supercharger, the supercharger is much safer on the car but not as effective as a turbo system, i have seen cars catch fire after few runs with turbos, also people seem to forget adding extra power means upgrading the cooling system and other internal parts, last one if car from factory did not come with Forced induction than it is not good idea to do it, i doubt VQ engine can handle 500+ on stock internals

    • @kadinallan2436
      @kadinallan2436 4 роки тому

      Its not the engine, its the transmission

    • @al3zmi
      @al3zmi 4 роки тому

      @@kadinallan2436 uhh you're saying slapping turbo or supercharger on high boost and run it won't cause internal parts to break? The 370z transmission is actually decent

    • @kadinallan2436
      @kadinallan2436 4 роки тому

      @@al3zmi the transmission is going to slip because of the added torque before the engine goes out

    • @al3zmi
      @al3zmi 4 роки тому +1

      @@kadinallan2436 lmao k

    • @Cdcniners
      @Cdcniners 4 роки тому +1

      @@al3zmi bruh it’s been proven if you do enough research on VQ engines that transmission is what blows first

  • @rubend0592
    @rubend0592 3 роки тому

    Great explanation 🙌🏽

  • @itsmistersmoke
    @itsmistersmoke 2 роки тому

    Nice channel dude

  • @bamudeadson
    @bamudeadson 4 роки тому

    Great video!

  • @quinm3
    @quinm3 4 роки тому

    great video

  • @fernandohood5542
    @fernandohood5542 4 роки тому +1

    In a full race scenario where you are changing above 5000 rpm the turbo will have less advantage.

    • @OddBallPerformance
      @OddBallPerformance 2 роки тому

      In a full race scenario where you would spend more time above 5000RPM you would simply size up the turbochargers. You lose a bit down low, but will gain it up top in trade. Plus, unlike a supercharger there will be no belt slip, especially at higher RPM.

  • @testerman8181
    @testerman8181 4 роки тому +3

    Are you in Jason’s garage from “engineering explained”? Is that his white board?!!! What have you done to Jason?!!!!

  • @spooler7828
    @spooler7828 3 роки тому

    The AAM twin turbo kit sucks. Where do you get all the BS from? You have a lot to learn.

  • @shanesmith8442
    @shanesmith8442 2 роки тому

    Here's the simplest way to explain this. Turbos are far more efficient than superchargers, superchargers takes power to make power and usually runs a little cooler than turbos. Will modern technology now we have turbos with little to no turbo lag. Turbos usually will end up made more power than superchargers but at the end of the day it is the one with the deepest pockets will have the faster car. Turbos may be a little bit more expensive but the results will be night and day though.

  • @Dudeman9339
    @Dudeman9339 3 роки тому +1

    Turbochargers are much MUCH better.

  • @kingrichee1817
    @kingrichee1817 3 роки тому

    I’ll set up the super charger and let them catch up to me in the long run lol 😆

  • @dsawyer8
    @dsawyer8 3 роки тому +1

    so essentially by the time the race is over between the two the supercharger will be faster lol

  • @cowboyjhon766
    @cowboyjhon766 3 роки тому

    The problem is turbos go out he didn't mention that supercharger don't

  • @carlaxeldinesen812
    @carlaxeldinesen812 4 роки тому

    And supercharger don’t cost less that’s turbo kits

    • @thecarizon504
      @thecarizon504  4 роки тому +2

      Most twin turbo systems I've seen run for about 10k, supercharger kits aroubd 6-8k. A single turbo setup might fetch less, really depends on the kit.

  • @andywu8558
    @andywu8558 4 роки тому +2

    You can hit 700whp on a supercharger though.

    • @darbauchiha3015
      @darbauchiha3015 4 роки тому +1

      really

    • @andywu8558
      @andywu8558 4 роки тому +1

      Darba Uchiha now its 900whp world record, lol

    • @darbauchiha3015
      @darbauchiha3015 4 роки тому

      @@andywu8558 lol how much we gotta spend now?

    • @andywu8558
      @andywu8558 4 роки тому

      Darba Uchiha like 20k lol

    • @spooler7828
      @spooler7828 3 роки тому

      @@andywu8558 More than that. That price barely paid for that engine.

  • @mrporsche4236
    @mrporsche4236 Рік тому

    Ive driven virtually everything. Ive yet to go in a turbo charged car that is fun to drive. Ive yet to go in a car that is supercharged that is not fun. Its night and day difference there is no comparison

  • @carlaxeldinesen812
    @carlaxeldinesen812 4 роки тому

    U don’t need to pull engine out unless if it’s a shitty twin turbo kit, this guy bro

    • @joshtheking1772
      @joshtheking1772 Рік тому

      Yes you do. If you aren't pulling the engine for fitment, you shouldn't be installing anything.

  • @JonzenHD
    @JonzenHD 3 роки тому

    Turbos use the heat in the exhaust not the flow to turn the turbine.

    • @joshtheking1772
      @joshtheking1772 Рік тому

      Heat and flow is velocity. Without either you get nothing.