POOR THINGS Movie Review, Deeper Meaning & Ending Explained

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 9 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ •

  • @BrainPilot
    @BrainPilot  Рік тому +146

    Everyone was saying that you shouldn't watch Saltburn with family... i'm warning you now, when this comes out, if you watch it with family you'll be sitting there wishing you never put it on in a family environment lol. Let me know what you thought of the movie in the comments below! 👊

    • @catherinebreitfeller669
      @catherinebreitfeller669 Рік тому +22

      This is NOT a family movie.

    • @frederickschneider3165
      @frederickschneider3165 Рік тому +10

      The movie is fascinating, however, the ending is puzzling. She has grown into intellectual brilliance and has surgical expertease. Why didn't she transfer God's brain into her ex's body? That way, she could share her lusty discoveries and help him develop his own healthy sexual identity, as well as allow him to continue his strange but important work. He would finally have a MUCH more satisfying (and longer) life and they could actually grow old together, like a 'normal' couple. C'mon, it could happen for them.

    • @kemmayr
      @kemmayr Рік тому +5

      Just back from watching Poor Things ,absolutely brilliant, Emma Stone gives us an amazing performance 👍

    • @MarkFilipAnthony
      @MarkFilipAnthony Рік тому +2

      I'd say it's as much a family movie as Barbie is. They both explore the same themes, just in two different ways.

    • @linapesz313
      @linapesz313 Рік тому

      ​@frederickschneider3165 exactly my thoughts

  • @lizettegratacoswys2958
    @lizettegratacoswys2958 11 місяців тому +95

    Godwin survived the cruelty of his father (cutural conditioning) and he created Bella free of it all; resilient to life experiences by instincts...

  • @mirandawoodsballard7764
    @mirandawoodsballard7764 11 місяців тому +317

    Good review but I really wish you would have touched on Bellas relationship with sex and intimacy. I think it’s very telling how sex is such a huge focus of the movie despite Bella having the brain of a child - she is more easily manipulated and sexualised because of her diminished brain capacity. Despite her being literally a child, sexualisation is a huge part of her existence right from the start.

    • @eli_p25_
      @eli_p25_ 11 місяців тому +35

      She is a child up to a certain point. You noticed that by the way she talks and the way her body moves, but as the movie progresses, so does Bella. Don't think about a child having sex, that's horrible and disgusting, see how she starts speaking like a baby and by the end of the movie, her eloquence is impressive. She grows in the movie, she doesn't have the prejudices towards sex and of society behavior. I think it's her innocent perspective of the mind of a kid (how a child wonders easily, how kids say things that are in their mind without filters, and how that sometimes makes grown-ups uncomfortable).

    • @miccorr99
      @miccorr99 11 місяців тому +4

      The Control is the Key. Just like Godwin, Bella become a person who likes control the others, at the end of the film she is the boss but in a disturbing way. She wanted to make the world a better place during the movie, but in the end she failed because she became another person who likes to be in the top of the pyramid. Very pessimistic ending.

    • @ConeTheBoss559
      @ConeTheBoss559 10 місяців тому +20

      @@eli_p25_ That's not really true, though. By the time she has furious jumping with Duncan she can still barely walk properly

    • @Vgallo
      @Vgallo 10 місяців тому +3

      Wow your choosing to focus on a very small aspect of the movie, but in every encounter bella turned the exploitation to her advantage.
      You guys are just like the cynic in the movie, your unable to bear the weight of pain in the world, so you become fixated, pessimistic and see only that aspect in literally everything, but the truth is their more to it than that, but you haven’t come to the realisation that you see what you believe.

    • @allsaints1951
      @allsaints1951 10 місяців тому +6

      @@ConeTheBoss559no, the other commenter was correct. Emma Stone said that the script was broken down into 5 stages of development for Bella, she grows from a toddler to a 35 year old woman. Her choice of language is simply because she isn’t being appropriately educated, no one is teaching her s-x ed. I learned about Emma’s comments after the watching the film, and even then It was pretty obvious & heavily implied that Bella is aging rapidly.

  • @momoneylessproblems9183
    @momoneylessproblems9183 10 місяців тому +129

    Mark Rufallo was the best part of this movie. Dude was downright hilarious

    • @lold6130
      @lold6130 7 місяців тому +1

      Poor Things was ruined by Ruffalo's TERRIBLE English accent. It's as bad as Dick Van Dyke's accent in the original Mary Poppins.

    • @sabrinacochran9808
      @sabrinacochran9808 7 місяців тому +3

      @@lold6130I think it added to it in the weirdest way. It fit the fraudulent nature of his character.

    • @raritica8409
      @raritica8409 2 місяці тому

      Can’t stand that lack of skill sardine

  • @dcdad556
    @dcdad556 11 місяців тому +76

    Fisheye, to me, puts forward the mad scientist narrative: it's what you see thru a microscope.

    • @BrainPilot
      @BrainPilot  11 місяців тому +7

      That's a cool way to look at it!

    • @LilCrashOutFr
      @LilCrashOutFr 6 місяців тому

      damn thats genius

  • @s_orax
    @s_orax 11 місяців тому +184

    You completely failed to mention sexism. This movie wasn't just about life it was about the female experience in patriarchy. Men drooling over your innocence

    • @Tavera12
      @Tavera12 11 місяців тому +20

      Yes, I saw it as a subversion of that really problematic, born sexy yesterday trope. It was really good, I really liked it.

    • @CrippledSanity
      @CrippledSanity 10 місяців тому +2

      YES.

    • @emperorthylord
      @emperorthylord 10 місяців тому +10

      That's a nice way to start the self victimization train.

    • @harshavardhana2950
      @harshavardhana2950 10 місяців тому +1

      You don't know what Sexism is.. do you?

    • @sarahmcguire7332
      @sarahmcguire7332 10 місяців тому +3

      I felt it was about a womens experience and how we get treated by bad men and then Bella finds herself but she goes through so much to get there. Before you come at me I know all men aren't bad. Yes this film is very ambiguous. I was disgusted at parts and it wasvery explicit. But it defo got me thinking and that's wat films should do. This film is open for interpretation

  • @M_Sonata
    @M_Sonata Рік тому +62

    Great analysis. I am so glad you brought up the themes of Godwin Baxter's love towards Bella despite being experimented on. I've watched so many videos on Poor Things and they all bring up essential Povs/analysis, but not many shed enough light on Godwin's optimism and love in the face of adversity. Thanks for this breakdown.

    • @BrainPilot
      @BrainPilot  Рік тому +6

      Glad you enjoyed the video 😊 yeah Godwin was a character that could have an entire breakdown video on just him. His love for Bella was unique, but no different to how a father would love a daughter and it was beautiful. His past sounded horrific, but he didn't let it hold him back. Such a great character!

    • @pauljazzman408
      @pauljazzman408 11 місяців тому +2

      Optimism and love? Mmm more like control and heartless experimentation

    • @miccorr99
      @miccorr99 11 місяців тому +3

      The Control is the Key. Just like Godwin, Bella become a person who likes control the others, at the end of the film she is the boss but in a disturbing way. She wanted to make the world a better place during the movie, but in the end she failed because she became another person who likes to be in the top of the pyramid. Very pessimistic ending.

    • @notnow7973
      @notnow7973 10 місяців тому

      Good point.

  • @CrippledSanity
    @CrippledSanity 10 місяців тому +53

    It's quite insane how you did not even dare to mention the sexism that was flooding the movie, the female experience and how a woman was ''created'' and molded by men wanting to own her for all their lives; she is genuinely trapped in a patriarchal world. Not saying that it was a sexist or misogynistic film, but I truly believe the huge underlying sexism was there for a reason.
    Makes you wonder...

    • @s_orax
      @s_orax 9 місяців тому +7

      Yes I found it bizarre. It's a glaringly obvious part of the plot

    • @tenesinsixtiliev
      @tenesinsixtiliev 8 місяців тому +1

      is it sexism or is it the truth of reality

    • @AnnaCoolKid
      @AnnaCoolKid 7 місяців тому +4

      I do think it shows the prospective of a women towards the world and her self if she lived by her free will and instinct instead of what society tell her which is why Bella was brave enough to reject any form of controlling by men through the movie and she wasn’t ashamed of her desires as she analyzed everything by pure logic

    • @justagrlwithnoname
      @justagrlwithnoname 5 місяців тому +2

      Agree it was definitely blatantly obvious on purpose, it was part of the point as it is the reality we live as women

  • @antoinebrandt6105
    @antoinebrandt6105 10 місяців тому +29

    This movie was genius. A few people commented about her sexualization and I think it's interesting that most of the men could tell she wasn't of age, possibly mentally ill, or overall just not properly prepared to engage in sex, yet they all kept advancing except for 2 dudes... the literal 2% of men that are proper and good LOL. The rest couldn't resist. I think they depicted her as a grown woman from the start to really highlight the cruel physical standards and harsh objectification of women from an abominably early age. Very sad, however very allegorical of our society and how men are trained to operate and think within the patriarchy.
    I cannot decide whether this film was more successful in its depiction of women or men... I think it really was successful at commenting on both. I cannot help but want to make bets on the fact that an overwhelmingly large amount of men probably weren't bothered by the instructive father in the brothel, but could imagine what thoughts would have conjured in audiences if it were a mother instructing her daughters instead... This also highlights the negative ideals that fathers perpetuate in their sons towards women... My favorite lines in the film were when she replies to Duncan after he calls her a whore... and says something along the lines of being in production because of him and men everywhere for that matter.... as well as pretty much everything Jerrod Carmichael exchanged with her and the elderly woman on the ship. Something about this film also reminded me of original sin... given all the moments of temptation and not just sexual... but all inclusively speaking.
    To all of those saying that this isn't a family friendly movie I disagree... appropriate for young children absolutely not, but for a group of smart socially conscious pre teens with parents, possibly... I cannot fathom why getting through the entire film would be a problem with family from an educational standpoint. Young women everywhere should know that this is how fucked up men and the patriarchy truly are... Young women should see the negative consequences of abiding to the quo for comfort and acceptance instead of delving into their innate thirst for intellectual integrity... just like men can and do... not saying they have ever had the choice especially in the past and sadly still in some places today..., but this fear should incite a strong will to challenge that authority on all levels and at all costs. I think this idea is incredibly positive for young developing female minds everywhere.
    People have such large issues with discussing self pleasure, human pleasure, and human development... I would really like to make the argument that if people were told about these things earlier or properly educated even, maybe just maybe, some of her mistakes wouldn't have happened in the first place. Maybe if women were given the same capacities as men these worldly issues would become less of a problem or cease to exist altogether... We see this in the film... and in life... instead of anyone taking the time to properly educate her about her body they all start to shame her and perpetuate antiquated taboo themes around sex... she seeks then seeks her information in the wrong places in extreme measures... exposing herself to disease and prostitution. People saying this was disturbing are also so so wrong... it's absurdist and comparable to the rest of Yorgos Lanthimos' works which all seem to talk about regular common themes that are displayed within very garish ways for overall impact.
    The eIderly woman and Jerrod were such a dose of positive reality... just too two genuine friends bound by intellect, as opposed to any other ulterior motive from what it seemed. I was glad to see the movie highlight that all levels of society think about sex. Like people need to get over shame around one of the bests parts of human existence. I find it funny that the lower levels of society somehow seemed more morally intact, and that the higher levels less mentally intact.
    I also think desire for knowledge is also something not talked about as much when analyzing the film. some people were upset she didn't reanimate Godwin. They felt her detachment from him was cruel and rather empty however their relationship was the most pure to me. He created her out of his own desires... which probably were propelled by science and familial loneliness I'd assume. She didn't dishonor him fully. She left because she had to... It was inhumane to keep a mind restricted as such. Not only did she return for the closure that needed and deserved but she honors him by inheriting his practices. Setting aside emotion as he did and doing what has to be done for the "greater good". Sometimes we hate some of the things are parents did to us and realize after, that it was for the best. This ending was perfect to me, especially given the social, economic, and political state that challenges women everywhere today in our world.
    Overall takeaways for me as a cis-man include... There is much more to female existence than being a mother and bearing children. Sex work isn't at all even remotely evil for the person doing it. Wealth and education are a lottery and shouldn't be a reason to look down on others. People, especially women, are certainly not property to be claimed. People, especially women, don't depreciate after sex like used cars. People, especially women, can aspire to go, do, and become anything as they please... The standards for masculinity, male behavior, male emotional education, truly means must change. Last, women and women alone can and should be in control of legislation that concerns their sex.

    • @juliettacrowder5453
      @juliettacrowder5453 8 місяців тому +1

      This is such a wonderful analysis and review of the movie! Genuinely better than the video because he neglected or wasn’t paying attention to the clear themes of gender, sexuality, and feminism that are at the core of poor things. Coming from a woman, I thought this review was written by a woman until that last part, because it is truly so insightful and understanding of female perspective and how this movie uses it. Couldn't agree more with everything you said!

    • @tsh.lalalaa
      @tsh.lalalaa 6 місяців тому +2

      Your analysis of this movie is the best I've seen, heard, or read anywhere. You touched on the core theme and analyzed it as it should've been done. About the last paragraph, I don't have enough words to appreciate how beautifully you put things together and how everything just made sense. Your insight about how things should be is truly accurate. Just loved reading it. ❤

    • @carmengoman
      @carmengoman 5 місяців тому +1

      @@juliettacrowder5453same! Thought it was a woman til the last paragraph. Made me so happy to see a man write this!

  • @pauljazzman408
    @pauljazzman408 11 місяців тому +218

    We are of course assuming's a baby girl's brain in Bella"s body. What if it was a boy's brain. that would get everyone going.

    • @ragnarox16
      @ragnarox16 11 місяців тому +21

      That would explain a lot imo

    • @Vgallo
      @Vgallo 10 місяців тому +11

      Wow mind blown 🤯
      Brilliant insight. That would make so much sense

    • @ntispe8891
      @ntispe8891 10 місяців тому +40

      It actually doesnt really make a diffrence, the diffrence comes thru the education and some part hormones after puperty but for an unborn baby it doesn't matter.

    • @gaawn
      @gaawn 10 місяців тому

      Oh yes.Assuming you have testicles in your brain😅

    • @ambiguoussarcasm
      @ambiguoussarcasm 10 місяців тому +3

      Its not to be taken literally

  • @MrHhoommeerr
    @MrHhoommeerr 11 місяців тому +110

    This is my Barbie movie.

  • @josephinedemarco8749
    @josephinedemarco8749 Рік тому +70

    Saw it yesterday with my brother and it is both of our favorites of 2023. It is so surreal, fantastical and sweetly inspiring. Max and Bella are EVERYTHING! They are so freaking cute together. I know Willem Defoe and Mark Ruffalo are getting more supporting actor attention but honestly Ramy Youssef is being underrated. He is so sweet and supportive of Bella through her journey and he gets the girl ❤

    • @M_Sonata
      @M_Sonata Рік тому +5

      Could not agree more. Ramy's acting as Max McCandless was amazing. He was precise with his humor while also balancing out with a genuine sense of purity and love.

    • @pauljazzman408
      @pauljazzman408 11 місяців тому +4

      Sweetly inspiring? I saw a comment from a mother who has a neurodivergent daughter and this film made us both sick.

    • @curtisthomson4209
      @curtisthomson4209 10 місяців тому

      @@pauljazzman408 Interesting. My son and I both have Asperger’s and my wife and daughter both have ADHD. I loved this movie.

    • @pauljazzman408
      @pauljazzman408 10 місяців тому +2

      @@curtisthomson4209 good for you. If you had a young daughter with learning difficulties how would you feel about her being pursued sexually by a much older man? Bella has a babies brain don't forget.

    • @caitlynford3001
      @caitlynford3001 10 місяців тому +1

      @@pauljazzman408couldn’t agree more. This movie is disgusting

  • @Adrien-r5y
    @Adrien-r5y Рік тому +74

    I loved how much autonomy Bella had over her being and body.

    • @claudiatrinity
      @claudiatrinity 11 місяців тому

      She really didn’t, she has the brain of a baby/child

    • @dlc2479
      @dlc2479 10 місяців тому

      Lmao she couldn't get an abortion and tried to commit suicide and then was "saved" by a freak, doesn't even have her own brain anymore, groomed by older men when she had the mind of an infant, sold her body to make money after her husband stole hers and you think that autonomy? Yikes!

  • @dutchjefe5363
    @dutchjefe5363 Рік тому +44

    Someone said it was a frankenhooker remake and now I can’t unsee it

    • @BrainPilot
      @BrainPilot  Рік тому +3

      Oh no lol

    • @TheRachag
      @TheRachag 11 місяців тому +1

      Nightmare Before Christmas

    • @unholyroller11
      @unholyroller11 11 місяців тому +1

      Omfgggg nooooo 😂

    • @dutchjefe5363
      @dutchjefe5363 11 місяців тому +1

      @@unholyroller11 my mom even agreed 😂she’s the reason why I know that movie

  • @jasminfrederickson5277
    @jasminfrederickson5277 11 місяців тому +17

    Bizarre to not at all mention the struggle of the female experience and saying that this a part of the human experience.

  • @TarmoRiutta
    @TarmoRiutta 5 місяців тому +1

    Slavoj Zizek said: ”Poor Things claims to be a feminist film, but it is simply ableist and misogynistic and disgusting. Watch Barbie instead, same story but better.”

  • @jasonpatrickolynyk8174
    @jasonpatrickolynyk8174 10 місяців тому +24

    Q. Why didn't she put Godwins brain in the the Generals Body? could have still put the generals brain into the goats body for laughs

    • @judithholder2537
      @judithholder2537 10 місяців тому +7

      Exactly what I thought / wanted. Better resolution

    • @rneoman
      @rneoman 9 місяців тому +3

      Yep i for sure thought thats what they were going to do. Loved the film but the ending could have been awesome had they given godwin a new complete body especially seeing how his father had mutilated him and deprived him of a normal life.

    • @Crowelephant
      @Crowelephant 9 місяців тому +1

      EXACTLY!!!!!
      THAT'S WHAT I THOUGHT THIS VIDEO WAS ABOUT!
      T H I S N E E D S T O B E T A L K E D A B O U T ! ! !

  • @phattykill
    @phattykill Рік тому +17

    I got the pleasure of watching this on January 2nd in theaters. It was phenomenal!

  • @andreeailiescu2220
    @andreeailiescu2220 11 місяців тому +6

    The production design on this was class ❤ insane! I was blown away by Saltburn, but I think this is definitely above it

    • @BrainPilot
      @BrainPilot  11 місяців тому +3

      Yeah there's way more complexity and a deeper story to this!

  • @ceciliaSF-TX
    @ceciliaSF-TX 11 місяців тому +12

    Like Everything/Everywhere: I had no idea what was happening & why! It took me a while what it was telling me. Once I got there, I truly appreciated the movie & had no idea how it was going to end. Fabulous!!!
    Like you, my first theater experience in a very long time & this movie needs a second watch. 💖

    • @BrainPilot
      @BrainPilot  11 місяців тому

      I love it when a movie gives that feeling!

  • @cherylrleigh1912
    @cherylrleigh1912 Рік тому +7

    I haven't had the chance to watch "Poor Things" yet, but I'm looking forward to doing so soon. With so many great films from 2023 to catch up on, I recently had the pleasure of watching "The Anatomy of a Fall" and "The Lesson," and I must say, they were absolutely brilliant.

    • @BrainPilot
      @BrainPilot  Рік тому +1

      Two great movies! Poor Things is one that's definitely worth the watch too!

    • @pauljazzman408
      @pauljazzman408 11 місяців тому

      Don’t watch it. It is sick in a bad way

  • @mariaki5220
    @mariaki5220 11 місяців тому +15

    Formidable!!❤

  • @joneshoward17
    @joneshoward17 Рік тому +14

    Willem nods to Osborn by saying "I'm somewhat of a romantic myself."
    Did Godwin die at one point too? He was experimented on a lot.

    • @BrainPilot
      @BrainPilot  Рік тому +1

      Personally I don't think he did. Yeah you can only imagine the horrors that Godwin went through

    • @joneshoward17
      @joneshoward17 Рік тому +6

      @@BrainPilot I don't know, I'm on the fence. Because he had the knowledge to bring someone back so I'm assuming that his father knew how to bring him back.
      **SPOILER ALERT**
      I'm a little disappointed with the ending though. I wish that Godwin's brain was in Alfie and Alfie's brain was in the goat.

    • @tudorm3607
      @tudorm3607 10 місяців тому +2

      ​@@joneshoward17the switch between God's and Alfie's brain was surely on the director table. I don't know why the team didn't go for it

    • @joneshoward17
      @joneshoward17 10 місяців тому

      @@tudorm3607 it was right there.

  • @neildobbs7278
    @neildobbs7278 11 місяців тому +7

    how about the entrapment of too much hedonistic pleasure/ the power relations between Bella and her partners. Her desensitization to the nature of her actions and her need to find a true purpose

  • @mr.k905
    @mr.k905 9 місяців тому +1

    In the end, Bella is no better than the guy she turns into a sheep.
    You can dismiss it as a innocent(!?) joke and say that he deserved it, but if you just think about it, you realize the brutality of what she did. She is just as sick as her ex-husband. She has learned nothing and her progression didn’t mean anything.
    A very strange and pessimistic message but very fitting our times. Just like jokes that nowadays everyone makes about white old men for example, without hesitation, thinking they are not racist, sexist or evil.
    So if bella does the evil, it seems ok to many viewers because she is part of our identity group. We don’t even identify it as wrongdoing.
    That’s very disturbing. …or at least it should be disturbing to everybody, not funny.

  • @yingyang1615
    @yingyang1615 10 місяців тому +1

    I just watched this movie and it was incredible…the fish hole camera gave me a feeling of like looking through a peephole or even a microscope…as we were observing Godwins experiment

  • @jyotsnaamin6970
    @jyotsnaamin6970 10 місяців тому

    Loved the overall summary I find it so relevant and precise...

  • @calviv1
    @calviv1 10 місяців тому +7

    We are going down hill to
    Think this is Oscar worthy

    • @Pimientaellieeee
      @Pimientaellieeee 10 місяців тому +1

      I would love to hear your opinion please!

  • @JSchlo401
    @JSchlo401 9 місяців тому +2

    This is one of the best movies that I will only recommend to a select few people. The majority of my friends and family would find it too confusing or disturbing 😅

    • @BrainPilot
      @BrainPilot  9 місяців тому +1

      Yeah I get what you mean there haha

  • @katarzynakaczmarska7864
    @katarzynakaczmarska7864 11 місяців тому +5

    I feel like this review is shallow and don’t touch on so many amazing things that were presented. I want to see a woman take on it at this point

  • @karnubawax
    @karnubawax 9 місяців тому

    This reminds me so much of the controversy around Peter Greenaway's films - a director that women loved but men hated.

  • @TheFrogfather1
    @TheFrogfather1 Рік тому +11

    I watched this yesterday and, even though it's only January I don't think I'll have a stranger 2 hours for the rest of the year. I think I need to see it again tbh.

    • @BrainPilot
      @BrainPilot  Рік тому

      It was amazing wasn't it. I'm looking forward to a rewatch when it eventually gets released!

    • @TheFrogfather1
      @TheFrogfather1 Рік тому

      @@BrainPilot I may have to have another cinema visit soon :P

  • @bbqR0ADK1LL
    @bbqR0ADK1LL 10 місяців тому +2

    This did not explain the meaning at all.
    It explained literally what happened, but not the metaphor. I'm still trying to figure out exactly what that metaphor is, but this video didn't help.

  • @Cc-dr2en
    @Cc-dr2en 11 місяців тому +1

    @BrainPilot Where did Duncan come from, I saw the movie yesterday and it looked like he only merely went through the second floor open window, touched her knee and they went off while she was still engaged to be married?

    • @BrainPilot
      @BrainPilot  11 місяців тому

      He was a lawyer brought in by Godwin who drew up the contract of engagement for Max and Bella's marriage. Then from there he saw Bella and he devised his plan

  • @himanshuwiz
    @himanshuwiz 10 місяців тому +1

    story is not complicated but the beauty is in the direction of the movie

  • @serennikki6303
    @serennikki6303 4 місяці тому

    'her brain inside her mother's body' ?? no, my innerstanding is that is is 'her baby's brain now placed inside her head' Bella being pregnant when she jumped from the bridge - and her baby's brain placed in her head as a part of reviving her... (a few spoilers in this video above). also re: feelings and emotion - not sure the extent to which Bella/ other character's in this film 'feel'... actually, not with a sense of depth feeling, love or empathy with them generally, more at times of a caricature... similar to Lewis Caroll representation of Alice - and seems Bella is wearing similar Alice colours/ clothes i.e. her blue jacked, yellow skirt... Alice too an Adventurer in Consciousness - and, as Bella similarly is exploring 'other worlds' (more external) too. Curiously, the 'fish-eye' lens too reminds me of 'The Rabbit Hole' the 'Through the Looking Glass'' i.e. to enter 'other worlds' 'other realms of consciousness' often we need to go through a portal/ initiatory experiences - which may be bizarre, surreal; i.e. we a 'thrown into the unknown.' 'Only Chaos can give birth to a fallen star' Nietzsche, this too comes to mind in seeing Bella's evolution, Life unfolding. And, these themes too in Alice/ in Poor Things too resonant of many Victorian (ie also Gothic novels) at the time - and, paramount, in the consciousness of these Novels at the time also themes such as 'Science and Ethics' and 'Woman's Emancipation' 'Oppression of Women' 'Pathologising of Women i.e. 'hysterical woman in the attic' Victorian Novel archetype. I.e. at this time also this film so poignant because ALSO we are many of us and riGHtly (!) questioning and 'calling to account' some of the agendas of current day Scientists and A.I. peddlers - where are the Ethics? to what extent are these Technologies in the hands of the benevolent, the ones with good intentions?! Ethics, technology, science, A.I. - when to intervene? Listening to Ram Dass share stories my-steries of his guru in India Neem Karoli Baba there are times when Maharaji (also his name0 visits the sick and they 'heal/ are healed' and other times when he 'leaves things be' - he's moving with the Tao, he's become a part of the Tao; he's not 'playing God' he's with an 'acting' so Right that this is the Mysterious Cosmos 'moving through him.' In other words, Action can be 'artificial' and interference or a 'meant to be' - this contemplation occurs to me re: this film i.e. with God (also simply short for Godwin) and Bella.../ Coming back to the representation of Feeling/ Emotion yes a touching love yes between Bella and Godwin/ and feels more a filial love with Max. not a feeling of the representations of Love here being 'romantic' in the original sense of the word i.e. this is not so much a film about 'sensibility.' i.e. feel that Bella does have an 'automaton' quality, not a sense of her deeply feeling into choices, no sense of a cognitive or enhearted complexity i.e. she feels more with a 'scientific' categorising 'brain' journeying through life on impulse often primal and Will (will of a 2 year old, 'the terrible twos!') and latterly will of a more embodied, awakened woman i.e. her new-found hunger for books/ knowledge. It matters too i feel to acknowledge that this film was inspired by the book Poor Things, Alasdair Gray whom it seems was profoundly influenced by and inspired by Mary Shelley's Frankenstein too. Possibly other Victorian Gothic novels. For sure, it's a visceral film - felt very 'under the skin' - and, inciting of much dialogue, contemplation. Bold and brave, 'wow!' to the creation of this film!

  • @JeffSans
    @JeffSans 9 місяців тому

    Bella's brain matured, she was no longer a child when she was whorin. Her growth was faster than usual, no teen would explore philosophy if not exposed early in life.

  • @karnubawax
    @karnubawax 9 місяців тому

    From the Wikipedia page: "Mick LaSalle at the San Francisco Chronicle called the film "a 141-minute mistake" and asserted, "Worst of all, it's dishonest. It purports to be a feminist document, but it defines a woman's autonomy as the ability to be exploited and not care."
    So if any of you are wondering what the hell the whole NXIUM cult was about... now you know. Some of y'all are late for your brandings.

  • @MAXWELLOKOTETE
    @MAXWELLOKOTETE 11 днів тому

    When are getting silo episode 7 review?

  • @brucethomson168
    @brucethomson168 11 місяців тому +3

    I too loved this movie and yes; the seagull scene did remind me of The Lighthouse Keeper.

    • @BrainPilot
      @BrainPilot  11 місяців тому

      Haha, glad I'm not the only one!

    • @BearFattfilm
      @BearFattfilm 11 місяців тому

      I thought the same thing. Bad luck to kill a sea bird!

  • @tanushreex
    @tanushreex 2 місяці тому

    Visuals are extremely beautiful in this movie but has anyone noticed Bella's dresses were very different than the era she was in?. Her clothes looked more like high fashioned than victorian. Even the sunglass and shoe she wore were indifferent to any other women in the movie.

  • @PricessaY3k
    @PricessaY3k 9 місяців тому

    I thought those shots with the little circle were like her sunglasses that she has throughout the film so it’s like you’re seeing things through her eyes

    • @BrainPilot
      @BrainPilot  9 місяців тому

      That's definitely a possibility!

  • @rachelyoung7261
    @rachelyoung7261 Рік тому +5

    Beautiful art!

  • @terrancepemberton4648
    @terrancepemberton4648 5 місяців тому

    I'll admit I was more than a bit uncomfortable at first when Bella discovered sex etc, it was beyond awkward considering the circumstances of her being. But I guess I kinda got over it at some point. I honestly thought it was an amazing movie and it was so entertaining and intriguing watching Bella's progression. Love her lol. I don't follow the awards shows etc but if Emma Stone didn't receive some accolades for her performance SHE SHOULD HAVE and it's a damn shame!! Loved the movie overall once I got past that initial uncomfortable feeling near the beginning, and I thought it was brilliant.

  • @Ann-vi5ns
    @Ann-vi5ns Рік тому +5

    Just saw it. Amazing.

  • @alexanderbailer8310
    @alexanderbailer8310 9 місяців тому

    How can you not mention Alasdair Gray's work?

  • @monzersaid
    @monzersaid 10 місяців тому

    It was actually 24-25 minutes of black n white u said 45 which I’ll agree it def felt like

  • @douglaswright2143
    @douglaswright2143 11 місяців тому +3

    Maybe read the book, there are far more levels of complexity

  • @cruxvox
    @cruxvox 8 місяців тому

    The first black and white section got distracting every time Emma Stone's American accent popped out while being a character recently having been brain-born in Victorian London.

  • @kooksaroon
    @kooksaroon Місяць тому

    wild how no religious symbolism was mentioned by you AT ALL. great take though. amazing movie from the cinematography to the audio. actors nailed it

  • @carolokoli7874
    @carolokoli7874 10 місяців тому +1

    Horrible disgusting movie a nod to Kinsey. Not surprised holly weird gave it all those Oscar’s, and Balenciaga still in business

  • @tinagolomb9203
    @tinagolomb9203 10 місяців тому

    This was such a visually stimulating movie! I loved it!!

  • @debbiesazo7392
    @debbiesazo7392 11 місяців тому +4

    I really want to see this movie ❤

  • @mollyfletcher7746
    @mollyfletcher7746 6 місяців тому

    The cinematography was next level.

  • @kirstenlane6632
    @kirstenlane6632 9 місяців тому

    Maybe the black and white was a reflection of her baby like view of the world as infants see in black and white when born.

    • @BrainPilot
      @BrainPilot  9 місяців тому

      Yeah that's definitely one way to look at it!

  • @BikiDasOG
    @BikiDasOG 10 місяців тому

    “It’s another life, not the bella baxter’s”

  • @vanessazlatic7849
    @vanessazlatic7849 9 місяців тому +2

    Life is meant for living. This includes pedophelia, I guess? Great movie. Made by a sick mind for sick minds. So much to look forward to in this brave new world that they are pushing on us.

    • @griffinhyatt
      @griffinhyatt 9 місяців тому +1

      Postmodern garbage movie.

  • @clemensg.5101
    @clemensg.5101 11 місяців тому +66

    Am I the only one who absolutely does not like this movie?

    • @BrainPilot
      @BrainPilot  11 місяців тому +2

      Not the only one! There are a few that aren't a fan

    • @pauljazzman408
      @pauljazzman408 11 місяців тому +26

      You are not alone. This is a terrible nasty horror porn of a film

    • @james3v17
      @james3v17 11 місяців тому +13

      This movie is beyond adult themes… inhumanely immoral, it’s demented and gross! Cynical too! Didn’t laugh once, didn’t cry, didn’t like any of the characters!

    • @travisderose
      @travisderose 11 місяців тому +5

      Yes

    • @ProdigyX117
      @ProdigyX117 11 місяців тому

      @@pauljazzman408that would be Serbian film, Irréversible, or legit a lot of things on spookyrices channel. This doesn’t compare.

  • @MilleHassenkam
    @MilleHassenkam 11 місяців тому +2

    I had a thought that the black and white part was a reference to the thought experiment “Mary in the black and white room”🤔
    The experiment is used to distinguish humans from artificial intelligence. In it, you have Mary who is Color scientist and knows everything about color, the wavelengths, the numbers and so on, but she has never experienced color, as she lives in a black and white room. When she leaves the room, she becomes the human.

  • @mpslegalcom7697
    @mpslegalcom7697 10 місяців тому +3

    Beautifully filmed and artistically designed, this "edgy" film (at least its "Dogtooth" director is) was essentially an empty exercise in exploitative "furious jumping" that took over 3/4 of the audience's time with a pointless absurdist pseudo-agenda that bored rather than inspired. Pedophiliac, necrophiliac and exploitative of the human condition rather than inspiring, this is destined to be a cult movie. John Waters' Pink Flamingos comes to mind!

  • @reesetwist2290
    @reesetwist2290 10 місяців тому

    Great movie nice and different. To me Mark Ruffalo was great in his roll. He definitely needs an award for this, had me dying from laughter. The style of Poor Things reminded me of a Wes Anderson style movie.

  • @Obiocha
    @Obiocha Рік тому +4

    Vignette shot

  • @damianstarks3338
    @damianstarks3338 11 місяців тому +2

    This movie is definitely a surprise

    • @BrainPilot
      @BrainPilot  11 місяців тому +1

      Yeah it really was!

  • @sarahmcguire7332
    @sarahmcguire7332 10 місяців тому +1

    Most interesting film ive watch in a while

    • @BrainPilot
      @BrainPilot  10 місяців тому

      Yeah it was a good one!

  • @werther3736
    @werther3736 9 місяців тому

    The movie got socialism right, in its promise, its appeal, its virtue, and in some important ways (such as a temptation to equate science-knowing about the world-and Progress) its misuses.

  • @sam-mw2zb
    @sam-mw2zb 11 місяців тому +3

    People seem to love this movie, I just don’t get it
    Looked amazing just found it annoying

    • @BrainPilot
      @BrainPilot  11 місяців тому

      Really? What was annoying about it?

    • @leighcochran7303
      @leighcochran7303 11 місяців тому +1

      Did they HAVE to make her a prostitute? Typical male fantasy!

    • @unholyroller11
      @unholyroller11 11 місяців тому +1

      Sometimes we don't get things when they just don't speak to us.

  • @cianareid5034
    @cianareid5034 11 місяців тому

    This year has started really well film wise, productions I really want to see at the cinema. I agree it did get better and better as you watched. Im glad I found your review as you added things I hadn't thought about! I will say at the end I was surprised the revenge they took on the general wasn't to put God in his body. They loved God and this way God could have lived on in a body that hadnt been abused...........A treat for me this week after seeing the film, I was lucky enough to be able to see the costumes at the Barbican London!

  • @MichaelSG_
    @MichaelSG_ 11 місяців тому +1

    María Magdalena?

  • @Pottercraft278
    @Pottercraft278 11 місяців тому +9

    Half the theater got up and left during the sex scene with the children. This was just gross porn.

    • @BrainPilot
      @BrainPilot  11 місяців тому +7

      To be fair it was an 18 rated movie

    • @jonnyboy1001
      @jonnyboy1001 11 місяців тому +1

      Wife wanted to leave after 20 mins, we lasted until 50 mins. It's basically the sexual grooming and abuse of a (depending on your point of view) a retarded adult with the mind of a 4yr old or an actual child. Either way it's a horrible movie IMO. I don't understand why someone would want to film such sex scenes or why some people consider it 'art'.

    • @ktom5262
      @ktom5262 11 місяців тому

      LOL, you are dumb.

    • @unholyroller11
      @unholyroller11 11 місяців тому +4

      It really showed the toxic way men have throughout history handled sons coming of age. It wasn't uncommon for centuries for a dad to take his young son (as young as 14, 15) to have his first sexual experience with a prostitute. Now....watching dad do the deed is kinda....different lol I don't know if that's something that happened as well, but it reminded me of that same mindset. Maybe the toxic nature needed to stand out in a more shocking way, more obvious. I have to wonder if the book sheds more light on this.

    • @ktom5262
      @ktom5262 11 місяців тому +3

      @@unholyroller11 Nothing toxic about it. Just good parenting. There should be basic sexual education in schools. The entire film is, among other things, about the problems and obsession men as a gender have with sex and sexual desires.

  • @FelinaFairyphonic
    @FelinaFairyphonic 8 місяців тому +1

    this would have been a great movie if it wasn´t for the pedo scenes

  • @ProdigyX117
    @ProdigyX117 11 місяців тому +2

    Amazing movie the only thing that really comes close is The City of Lost Children from 1995 but only by the trippy confusing aspect of it. My only gripe with the movie is the amount of sex scenes, they could’ve made their point with about half the amount or less. Highly suggest watching this on shrooms for a bonkers time, acid if you mad lad. Don’t eat for the first half…. Made that mistake at a draft house. Also I thought this was horror at first but it’s actually a dark comedy that hurts the ego of fragile npc men. 9/10 nothing really like this.
    Edit: one last thing do not watch this with family members cause awkwardness or atleast parents cause the point will fly over their clouded heads, the older generation doesn’t know how to think and ponder with their minds.

  • @iDewThis4Yu
    @iDewThis4Yu 16 днів тому

    Idk I just feel like the lust storyline took over the majority of the movie😂. It was basically a movie making its case for heathenism.

  • @Vgallo
    @Vgallo 10 місяців тому

    First movie I’ve seen at cinemas this year too.

    • @BrainPilot
      @BrainPilot  10 місяців тому

      And what a good one to choose!

  • @jai_lyricz
    @jai_lyricz 11 місяців тому

    Can u explain the curse show on paramount plz

  • @vickyvanadium
    @vickyvanadium 11 місяців тому +4

    it is so confusing to me when poor things and barbie nominated for oscars, while one is the marterpiece other one is overrated garbage.

    • @dimitris4661
      @dimitris4661 11 місяців тому +3

      Maybe some people don’t love to watch sex scenes for 30 minutes? And the comedy was better in Barbie than here

    • @BlackofAzur
      @BlackofAzur 10 місяців тому

      Both are overrated garbage imo

  • @livelong6685
    @livelong6685 9 місяців тому +1

    this movie was about feminist

  • @noname-by3qz
    @noname-by3qz 11 місяців тому

    I just saw it last night. Its impossible to find the right adjectives. Far above average. See it!

  • @katiacomk
    @katiacomk 11 місяців тому

    I thought this video would focus more on the end… I enjoyed the movie at first but it felt long midway and some of the sex scenes weren’t needed to convey what was happening… I didn’t enjoy the end as much because it didn’t complete a cycle… I suppose it was the happy ending we could have with her newly created family and the new possibilities in terms of work… I would’ve prefer if her biological dad got killed in self defence and she inherited all his money and made good use of it… alas. It is what it is… her choice I guess 😅

    • @judithholder2537
      @judithholder2537 10 місяців тому

      I agree - too many liaisons. I kept thinking, "OK, not get on with her evolution." I also wanted God's brain put into her husband's body.

  • @patrickn8355
    @patrickn8355 11 місяців тому +2

    *WAY* too much hype imo. Went in so excited and left feeling…..well, meh?
    Cinematography was amazing no doubt, but story wise, I was just not all too impressed considering the buzz.

    • @BrainPilot
      @BrainPilot  11 місяців тому

      That's a shame! There was definitely hype about it, but it actually surprised me to be honest!

  • @GhostGazcoyn
    @GhostGazcoyn 10 місяців тому +2

    Definitely didn’t need the copious amounts of sex scenes… I feel like that diminished the credibility of the storyteller. Almost seemed like an agenda was being pushed… overall I liked the idea and story but the execution was poorly done

  • @dcdad556
    @dcdad556 11 місяців тому

    It's a delicious mish-mash of Frankenstein, the Island of Dr. Moreau, Zola's Gay Ninties novels about proper hypocritical upper classes and prostitutes; Metropolis and the literary genre of the picaresque in Voltaire's Candide.

  • @mr.k905
    @mr.k905 9 місяців тому

    sex = life (??) …How old was the man who wrote the plot? 14?

  • @cassiecarpenter
    @cassiecarpenter Рік тому +6

    This movie owes a lot to ORLANDO (1992) and BRAM STOKER’S DRACULA (1992). You won’t find it so original after watching all three. Poor Things has gratuitous sex and corny CGI critters. The ending was awful.

    • @NB-bu9re
      @NB-bu9re Рік тому +7

      poor things is based off a book that came out in 1992

    • @leighcochran7303
      @leighcochran7303 11 місяців тому +1

      Yeah! And why no explanation of the puzzling ending in a video called "Ending explained "? Huh? You expected God's brain to be placed in the husband's body!! Thus giving him a functional body AND good looks.

    • @leighcochran7303
      @leighcochran7303 11 місяців тому

      BTW "Orlando" is my mpst hated movie of all time and I've seen thousands of movies. Lots of beautiful images and stilted acting and dialogue. So there! But I can see your point.

  • @imcnagpc2
    @imcnagpc2 10 місяців тому +1

    Why did Bella talk abut herself in the third person? Children don't do that.

  • @Jennifer-z4v
    @Jennifer-z4v 10 місяців тому

    Love it

  • @griffinhyatt
    @griffinhyatt 9 місяців тому +1

    I thought it sucked.

  • @gunesgunday1847
    @gunesgunday1847 11 місяців тому

    Great Film - excellent analysis. I will See it for the second time at the cinema.

    • @BrainPilot
      @BrainPilot  11 місяців тому

      Thanks, glad you enjoyed the video!

  • @Itsyagirllizzy69
    @Itsyagirllizzy69 7 місяців тому

    Um this movie was absolutely unwatchable and uncomfortable. Don’t forget that this woman has a brain of a baby in a fully grown woman. Plus this movie is trying to be so many things at once. It’s a no

    • @jordanloux3883
      @jordanloux3883 6 місяців тому

      Yeah, you definitely would hate Dogtooth

  • @andrealee8561
    @andrealee8561 9 місяців тому

    Love William

  • @Vgallo
    @Vgallo 10 місяців тому

    i cant beleive you compared this masterpiece to that terrible adolescent eeaaO

  • @davidfitcher2953
    @davidfitcher2953 11 місяців тому +2

    What do they mean by "poor things"? Men?

    • @senseisprotege3632
      @senseisprotege3632 10 місяців тому +1

      I think it can be applied to every character in the film. Depending on their situation, everyone suffers, which is a part of life.

  • @sniper8560
    @sniper8560 4 місяці тому +1

    This movie was disgusting

  • @lighteningsnips
    @lighteningsnips 11 місяців тому +6

    This is truly one of the worst movies that I have watched in my life.

  • @Citizen-Shayn
    @Citizen-Shayn 8 місяців тому

    10 minutes of stating the absolute obvious

  • @honeybling5228
    @honeybling5228 10 місяців тому

    This is is baseless Children actually ask to many questions they dont take decision...

  • @BryceChillis
    @BryceChillis 11 місяців тому +1

    Why does emma stone keep shoving her terrible acting down our throats?

    • @BrainPilot
      @BrainPilot  11 місяців тому

      I didn't actually think she was bad in this lol

  • @georgesamaras2922
    @georgesamaras2922 10 місяців тому

    Vulgar Art

  • @YeLizardLords
    @YeLizardLords 10 місяців тому +1

    Pretty & pretty pointless.
    What if women could do stuff too, truly groundbreaking material in 2024.
    Terrible movie.

    • @griffinhyatt
      @griffinhyatt 9 місяців тому

      Wut if witawy gurls cud do what da bois do? Deep

  • @robd1859
    @robd1859 Місяць тому

    It's just a confusing pile of jumbled garbage that makes no sense

  • @catherinebreitfeller669
    @catherinebreitfeller669 Рік тому +8

    This is a movie made to “shock” viewers. Nothing else

    • @M_Sonata
      @M_Sonata Рік тому +13

      You might want to project less.

    • @webbe8292
      @webbe8292 Рік тому +13

      It's much more than that. It not only shocks, but entertains and moves the audience.

    • @cosankaradeniz2042
      @cosankaradeniz2042 11 місяців тому +3

      Yorgos is not for everyone

    • @petermoxham2625
      @petermoxham2625 11 місяців тому

      Rubbish!

    • @kodokushi8321
      @kodokushi8321 11 місяців тому +2

      If you didnt get the message and enjoy it for what it was; then you weren't the target audience.