There is a difference between disagreeing with the policies of any nation at a particular time and disagreeing with a nation existing for your entire life without regard to its policies and which party or ruler it has over the years.
Your wrong, a day after the attack on 7th October people were pulling down the pictures of the hostages taken from Israel . When Israel was attacked on 7th October most people would expect and even insist "Israel had the right to self defence as a duty to its own citizens
Although antisemitism, especially since Israel's response to Hamas' despicable attacks on October 7 is a real problem, it's common practice for some who support Israel, to use false accusations of antisemitism as a means to discredit those who criticise Israel. When decent people around the world see the evidence of what Israel has done to Gaza, the deaths and the destruction of schools, hospitals and homes, it's hardly surprising that there's so much anger, but there's no excuse for antisemitism.
Hey. I am Jonathan Hines Israeli friend that he mentions. A few points from me (and dont bother with nasty responses as I only engage in positive dialogue). 1. Jonathan is most def not anti jewish, he is curious and asking questions about subjects that he is trying to understand. 2. I love the questions Jonathan sends me personally, which are always authentic. 3. I would take someone asking tricky, edgy, badly worded, nieve or sensetive questions anyday rather than someone claiming to have all the answers and spead over simplfied opinion masked as facts. 4. Be kind. Dont lable someone you dont know (its hurtful). Sending peace and love and hoping for better days when humans learn not to be a bunch of power drunk arseholes and ask questions about eachother and our world x
Your video is a bit of nothing. Of course you can criticize the Israeli government and its decisions, although you could also recognize that it's a democratically elected government. Part of that is recognizing the legitimacy of that government. You should also know that if Bibi gets thrown out the government policies will not change that much though maybe the coalition will not include the most extreme elements. We'll see. What goes into Jew hatred is when people say the Jews (usually uniquely) have no right to their own state in Israel. Some Jews agree, but it's still hate of most Jews.
What if someone's solution was to replace it with a secular democracy with equal rights for everyone, including Jews, as opposed to a Jewish ethno state
@@Gazaawareness It's a great idea! Do you know if a world where it could happen? Because it's not gonna happen in this one. (by the way there are other ethnostates in the world... If minority rights are protected why can't the Jews have one?). 70%+ of the 2 million Arab citizens of Israel support the state... So maybe you're wrong.
Tho thinking thy protest too much.. You say the same thing over and over again for the whole video. You are not making your point any clearer. You're just being obnoxious.
incorrect framing of the question. Of course one can oppose certain polices of the government of Israel. But, if one argues directly or indirectly, that the State of Israel should not exist, can't take normal steps to defend its people, etc., that is anti-Jewish, just as arguing those things about Mexico would be anti-Mexican.
You are obviously trying very hard to show you are a 'good person' who doesn't hate Jews just the Israeli goverment. What for protecting their people and lands against a murderous bunch of terrorist nutters that even torture and murder their own people. Do me a favour pal. You don't like Iserael and you don't like jews in fact I'll go further you really can't stand the English common man. You belong to the chattering metropolitan bores who no-one listens to expect of course the other chattering metropolitan bores! Here's something for you to talk about. Most British people don't want Islam in this country or woke ideology or in your case chattering metropolitan bores bullshit! Hope tou got the message!
@piratejack2469 I'm a Reform UK voter. On The Middle East, I'll be honest with you and say I'm really struggling to get my head around it and understand it. I've been invited by a childhood Jewish friend who lives in Israel now to come and see the country, which I'd love to do. No, I really really do not dislike Jews or Israel. JH
Your friend hates the IRISH government??😢 (that's what was broadcast) or the ISRAELI government?? who are committing genocide against Palestinian people 🇵🇸🇵🇸❤❤
There is a difference between disagreeing with the policies of any nation at a particular time and disagreeing with a nation existing for your entire life without regard to its policies and which party or ruler it has over the years.
On a venn diagram, the beliefs of people who are antisemitic and those who are anti Israel are concentric circles. They map on cleanly to each other.
Your wrong, a day after the attack on 7th October people were pulling down the pictures of the hostages taken from Israel .
When Israel was attacked on 7th October most people would expect and even insist "Israel had the right to self defence as a duty to its own citizens
They don't have a right under international law to conduct the war as they please
Although antisemitism, especially since Israel's response to Hamas' despicable attacks on October 7 is a real problem, it's common practice for some who support Israel, to use false accusations of antisemitism as a means to discredit those who criticise Israel.
When decent people around the world see the evidence of what Israel has done to Gaza, the deaths and the destruction of schools, hospitals and homes, it's hardly surprising that there's so much anger, but there's no excuse for antisemitism.
Hey. I am Jonathan Hines Israeli friend that he mentions.
A few points from me (and dont bother with nasty responses as I only engage in positive dialogue).
1. Jonathan is most def not anti jewish, he is curious and asking questions about subjects that he is trying to understand.
2. I love the questions Jonathan sends me personally, which are always authentic.
3. I would take someone asking tricky, edgy, badly worded, nieve or sensetive questions anyday rather than someone claiming to have all the answers and spead over simplfied opinion masked as facts.
4. Be kind. Dont lable someone you dont know (its hurtful).
Sending peace and love and hoping for better days when humans learn not to be a bunch of power drunk arseholes and ask questions about eachother and our world x
From the hostile comments, it's clear that you hit the bullseye.
Your video is a bit of nothing. Of course you can criticize the Israeli government and its decisions, although you could also recognize that it's a democratically elected government. Part of that is recognizing the legitimacy of that government. You should also know that if Bibi gets thrown out the government policies will not change that much though maybe the coalition will not include the most extreme elements. We'll see.
What goes into Jew hatred is when people say the Jews (usually uniquely) have no right to their own state in Israel. Some Jews agree, but it's still hate of most Jews.
A fascist ethno apartheid state is democratic? What are you smoking hasbar-t?
What if someone's solution was to replace it with a secular democracy with equal rights for everyone, including Jews, as opposed to a Jewish ethno state
@@Gazaawareness
It's a great idea!
Do you know if a world where it could happen? Because it's not gonna happen in this one.
(by the way there are other ethnostates in the world... If minority rights are protected why can't the Jews have one?). 70%+ of the 2 million Arab citizens of Israel support the state... So maybe you're wrong.
@@davidk2471 not the occupied Arabs in west bank
@davidk2471 they said the same thing about apartheid South Africa, that equal rights for all would be impossible but it happened
Tho thinking thy protest too much.. You say the same thing over and over again for the whole video. You are not making your point any clearer. You're just being obnoxious.
incorrect framing of the question. Of course one can oppose certain polices of the government of Israel. But, if one argues directly or indirectly, that the State of Israel should not exist, can't take normal steps to defend its people, etc., that is anti-Jewish, just as arguing those things about Mexico would be anti-Mexican.
You are obviously trying very hard to show you are a 'good person' who doesn't hate Jews just the Israeli goverment. What for protecting their people and lands against a murderous bunch of terrorist nutters that even torture and murder their own people. Do me a favour pal. You don't like Iserael and you don't like jews in fact I'll go further you really can't stand the English common man. You belong to the chattering metropolitan bores who no-one listens to expect of course the other chattering metropolitan bores! Here's something for you to talk about. Most British people don't want Islam in this country or woke ideology or in your case chattering metropolitan bores bullshit! Hope tou got the message!
@@piratejack2469 Hi there, I totally agree about Islam and Woke ideology. Looks like we're in agreement on that.
@piratejack2469 I'm a Reform UK voter.
On The Middle East, I'll be honest with you and say I'm really struggling to get my head around it and understand it. I've been invited by a childhood Jewish friend who lives in Israel now to come and see the country, which I'd love to do. No, I really really do not dislike Jews or Israel.
JH
@@johnnyhines2018 You are full of crap. You offer pseudo intellectual detritus to cover your cowardice and bigotry. Have the integrity to admit that.
Your friend hates the IRISH government??😢 (that's what was broadcast) or the ISRAELI government?? who are committing genocide against Palestinian people 🇵🇸🇵🇸❤❤
Hi ,
Israeli government!!
J x