WOOL by HUGH HOWEY (Silo Book 1): Dystopian Masterpiece Book Review & Discussion!"

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 8 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ •

  • @megansreadingrevelations
    @megansreadingrevelations  Рік тому +1

    Check out my review for Shift (Silo Book 2) here!
    ua-cam.com/video/71dVNLo_oyI/v-deo.html

  • @hardtruth4090
    @hardtruth4090 Рік тому +63

    Who came here after watching Silo series😂😂❤🎉

    • @q8no0na
      @q8no0na Рік тому +4

      Me😂😂

    • @hardtruth4090
      @hardtruth4090 Рік тому +2

      @@q8no0na ❤

    • @Endaxess
      @Endaxess 9 місяців тому +3

      I haven't read any books other than the stuff in school curriculum, I hope a dummy like me can learn to enjoy the books because I just bought the whole series on Amazon.

    • @triplemeatcombo2570
      @triplemeatcombo2570 7 місяців тому +1

      That’s awesome

    • @winifix
      @winifix 4 місяці тому

      what are books, last i read was harry potter. I just want to know whats up with this world and whats next.

  • @shifu9276
    @shifu9276 7 місяців тому +6

    In a weird way, I honestly couldn’t imagine reading wool without seeing the show first. Helps you visualize the silo in a way the book doesn’t really describe. And no real spoilers because the show is only the first half of the book and the second half is SO MUCH better so you’ll really want to read it after seeing the first season of the show.

  • @MoreRubberyThanTurgid
    @MoreRubberyThanTurgid Рік тому +14

    I read the books years ago, haven’t watched the series, but the books have stayed with me so deeply. I think about Silo saga often. You will live in that world when you read the trilogy, in a way that you won’t with most books. It’s so immersive and, yeah, pretty bleak at times. I’ve read all of Howey’s work and this is his magnum opus. Very much doubt he’ll come close to replicating this work qualitatively. And it’s in some quantity, too. Fantastic vision & scope.

    • @megansreadingrevelations
      @megansreadingrevelations  Рік тому

      That’s awesome. Thank you for sharing. I am still thinking about the themes he presented in this series :)

    • @MoreRubberyThanTurgid
      @MoreRubberyThanTurgid Рік тому +1

      @@megansreadingrevelations it’s pretty dark in the middle, don’t you find? Shift, I mean? Great, but very grim. It makes the third act all the more triumphant, I think.

    • @megansreadingrevelations
      @megansreadingrevelations  Рік тому +1

      I agree. Especially as Donald gets his memories back. The second book is my favorite.

  • @gw7120
    @gw7120 Рік тому +15

    I recently saw the series on appletv , and it does has a interesting premise, thanks for the review !

    • @megansreadingrevelations
      @megansreadingrevelations  Рік тому +2

      Thanks for watching ❤️

    • @resistanceisfutile520
      @resistanceisfutile520 Рік тому

      I just found out about the show two days ago, already waiting for episode 8. It’s a really fascinating story I’m defiantly going to be reading the book! Kind of excited there is even a book series.

  • @BTY11
    @BTY11 Рік тому +40

    Anyone else have a problem with Mechanical being in such low regard in the Silo's social and power structure? Common sense would have the people in Mechanical be as important as the doctors. If the power and water systems fail...everyone dies. Judicial and IT can disappear but Mechanical is the lifeblood of the Silo.

    • @emma.greenwood
      @emma.greenwood Рік тому +24

      Isn't that how we live in the world today though - a lot of the most important roles that keep society functioning are the lowest paid, under-appreciated and sidelined folk. Eg. Nurses, carers, waste disposal, etc etc ... I felt like it was a deliberate choice to paint them this way. Blue collar Vs white collar

    • @marsrock316
      @marsrock316 Рік тому +5

      This reflects current social stratification. I worked in the lower basement of a high rise maintaining large equipment like boilers, chillers and water pumps. As you say, it would make sense to respect the people in that department since we kept them from freezing in winter or boiling in summer. They had water 500 feet in the air.
      One owner/resident claimed only about five people in the world understood his work. I have a college education and value critical thinking and asked him what it was about. He said, "Oh no, you work with your hands, you wouldn't understand."

    • @hixttait753
      @hixttait753 7 місяців тому

      I’d say it’s pretty close to real life. The government puts emphasis on restricting farmers and the like yet unimportant (or rather less necessary to support life) roles are put on a tall pedestal. I know it’s still a jump from agriculture to mechanical, but the lines seem pretty parallel to me

    • @mjk6335
      @mjk6335 5 місяців тому

      I think that’s the point. Mechanical was the biggest threat. They would be the ones most likely to figure out what’s going on. Keeping them separated from everyone else kept them in check.

    • @scratchingthesurface3481
      @scratchingthesurface3481 Місяць тому

      I would say civilisation exists because of everyone, of all jobs. Þe deaþ of everyone from a loss of energy would be more immediate, but routing energy where it's needed, þats IT, and try keep people working togeþer for a common good wiþout some kind of auþority. Eventually, someþing would break, and individualism would facilitate breaking þe previous two systems

  • @broark88
    @broark88 Рік тому +6

    In Shift, we learn more about how the world above ended and it's probably not what you'd expect but in terms of ethical philosophy it made me absolutely livid.

  • @domlitt9001
    @domlitt9001 23 дні тому

    Cleaning is like floating in “The 100” that’s what caught my attention. It’s like that, but underground and not teenagers

  • @Jerryman1980
    @Jerryman1980 Рік тому +2

    I just finished reading Wool, can't wait to start Shift.

  • @techstudio6293
    @techstudio6293 Рік тому +6

    After watching Silo on #Apple tv 👀

  • @Cloneufc
    @Cloneufc 8 місяців тому +3

    Episodes 3,4,5,6 were painfully boring. I really liked Episodes 1,2,7,8,9,10. The beginning and end were really good, the middle of the story was meh.

    • @meowaintlow
      @meowaintlow Місяць тому

      finally found a guy who i agree with!!

  • @ThisIsNoConcept
    @ThisIsNoConcept 9 місяців тому +1

    I thought this was a good read but the plot dragged a little bit for me. I’m debating if I should finish the trilogy but we’ll see.

  • @levelswithvaluepod
    @levelswithvaluepod 8 місяців тому +1

    How many books you reckon you read in the last ten years Megan ? loving the channel by the way bout to subscuribe

  • @johnhoens
    @johnhoens Рік тому +6

    Yes, I got the book, Thanks! And I noticed on Apple TV a series called "Silo"? I guess that's Wool in Applespeak? Great review! Maybe the author is laying ground for the next book in the series? I love your videos!

  • @once-lers-one-and-only
    @once-lers-one-and-only 6 місяців тому

    I finished wool yesterday and it really was an amazing read. If I didn’t have so many books on my tbr I’d be running to buy shift right now haha

  • @GeoffryGifari
    @GeoffryGifari Рік тому +4

    how recycling (even of human remains) work in this world is so fascinating

    • @megansreadingrevelations
      @megansreadingrevelations  Рік тому +2

      Absolutely. Recycling everything possible is vital because they have such limited resources 🤯

  • @samsaldate5828
    @samsaldate5828 7 місяців тому

    This book sounds fantastic!! I’m going to get it for audiobook and start listening tonight. Side note the girl giving the review is really pretty.

  • @pattymack11
    @pattymack11 Рік тому

    Thank you for your review sweetie I just wanted to spoilers thank you, you give me enough I’ve looked for your third review do you have one hope so

    • @megansreadingrevelations
      @megansreadingrevelations  Рік тому

      My pleasure. I’m currently reading book 3 and will have that review up when I’m done. Thank you for watching 💕

  • @riverbenddrummer
    @riverbenddrummer Рік тому +1

    I’m on chapter 15 on Wool right now, I like how they go more in depth about how long it took Marnes and the mayor down to the bottom

  • @Tdr-jv2nc
    @Tdr-jv2nc Місяць тому

    I loved Wool just about to read shift

  • @healer81
    @healer81 Рік тому +1

    Thanks for the review

  • @bookreadingbilly8329
    @bookreadingbilly8329 Рік тому +1

    I really enjoyed wool, and the series as a whole although I think book 1 was my favorite of the 3

  • @user-soon300
    @user-soon300 Рік тому

    I'm new in your channel and I like this video keep going❤

  • @DerekFerguson90
    @DerekFerguson90 Рік тому +1

    Please review the other books in this series 🙏🏽

  • @slowmobius2136
    @slowmobius2136 Рік тому

    I thought the book was great. I kinda thought it ended abruptly but liked it anyways. I was hoping there would be a little more controversy at the end but oh well. Does anyone know if the third book goes back to silo 18? From what I’ve read, it seems like the second book doesn’t

    • @TuxMan20
      @TuxMan20 Рік тому

      The second book is a prequel. You actually follow, in part, the great uprising in the Silo's past... and you NEED this backstory to follow the third book

  • @inocanandrei6950
    @inocanandrei6950 Рік тому

    I enjoy the book but I agree with you that half way through the book I know here the action will go.

  • @cougsjohnson1
    @cougsjohnson1 Рік тому +9

    I remember when the Amazon Kindle was invented. I was excited & horrified at the same time. I was worried that by 2025 we would have to go to a Museum to view actual "Paper" Books. My question to you: "Are we completely out of the woods yet? Or should we be worried that traditional books may still disappear in the future?" There's nothing better than physically holding a book in your hand while reading!

    • @terencedavis8434
      @terencedavis8434 Рік тому +4

      Personally, I prefer reading on the Kindle and there is nothing better than being able to take literally hundreds of books with you everywhere you go and the ability to get new books without needing to go anywhere etc… I don’t think physical books will disappear, but I can definitely see them taking a backseat other than being collectibles

    • @patriciapalomino7188
      @patriciapalomino7188 Рік тому

      I hope books slowly disappear its not good for the wheatear and for the world world climate, we can read from kindle, I understand the feeling of holding a book in your hand while reading, but giving it a deep thought its selfish if its affecting so much now days, just like plastic and so many things more.

    • @TheDinger
      @TheDinger Рік тому

      It's the words that matter, not the device (book/e-book/parchment/stone tablets/cave wall) you read it on. I thought the same until I got my first Kindle. I was ignorant.

  • @angelfieseler5358
    @angelfieseler5358 Рік тому

    You got a subscription from me because you have the Expanse series in your library

  • @kakhak
    @kakhak 5 місяців тому

    Cute. And book author is unique person. Mini-series is mindblowing, epic, shockingly great.

  • @kennethmunyi
    @kennethmunyi 6 місяців тому

    We’re most of them not rebels?

  • @nirupamasingh-l6u
    @nirupamasingh-l6u 3 місяці тому

    From india, liked your explanation

  • @robertsabino21
    @robertsabino21 Рік тому

    Do you have a video for the 3rd part of the series of the books?

    • @megansreadingrevelations
      @megansreadingrevelations  Рік тому +1

      I plan on starting that book July 1 and will review it when I’m done ❤️

    • @robertsabino21
      @robertsabino21 Рік тому

      @@megansreadingrevelations you do it great , thanks for answer me ❤️

  • @THEnoaliens
    @THEnoaliens Рік тому +1

    Julliet being sherif is better explained in the show

  • @aaronwe21
    @aaronwe21 11 місяців тому

    I also read the trilogy. First book was the best for me. But what I didn‘t get is why it is called Wool? 😅

    • @megansreadingrevelations
      @megansreadingrevelations  10 місяців тому +1

      Hmmm I never looked into it. Maybe something to do with the saying pull wool over their eyes???

    • @shifu9276
      @shifu9276 7 місяців тому +1

      It’s what they use for cleaning the outside cameras.

  • @gilesclone
    @gilesclone 5 місяців тому

    Maybe it’s just me, but although I enjoyed the story, the science was so bad as to be distracting. And it only gets worse in the second book. (Haven’t finished the 3rd book yet). This is a common problem with post-apocalyptic books but was really bad here.

    • @megansreadingrevelations
      @megansreadingrevelations  4 місяці тому

      I read it more as a post-apocalyptic story and less a focus on the science aspects. The second book really was dense and took a while for me to read.

  • @candacedonald4087
    @candacedonald4087 Рік тому

    Just finished Wool. Shift and Dust are on the way

    • @megansreadingrevelations
      @megansreadingrevelations  Рік тому

      Cool! How’d you like it?

    • @candacedonald4087
      @candacedonald4087 Рік тому

      @@megansreadingrevelations I loved it!!! Read the whole thing in a week should have ordered the other books sooner!

    • @megansreadingrevelations
      @megansreadingrevelations  Рік тому

      I found the whole series at a used bookstore years ago and wish I’d read it sooner.

    • @candacedonald4087
      @candacedonald4087 Рік тому

      ​@@megansreadingrevelationshave you watched the TV adaptation yet? Curious how you thought it was

  • @readbooksfaster
    @readbooksfaster Рік тому

    Nice review! I loved the book and didn’t find it as predictable as you (but that probably says more about my naïveté 😅). For those of you who don’t have time to read the entire book, I’m working on a chapter by chapter summary on YT!
    ua-cam.com/video/6k2nNYwOhqU/v-deo.html

  • @Derpikus
    @Derpikus Рік тому

    Spoiler at 1:05. The same one you're talking about at 9:23

  • @thatsmyart
    @thatsmyart Рік тому

    thanks

  • @shifu9276
    @shifu9276 7 місяців тому

    You think they’d have eventually developed elevators.

  • @prettyproblem16
    @prettyproblem16 Рік тому

    Are you wearing contact lenses or is that your natural eye color

  • @tevin_maestrolive
    @tevin_maestrolive 2 місяці тому

    Came here after Silo

  • @joodwaleed7570
    @joodwaleed7570 Рік тому

    شكرا جزيلا 👍

  • @sorelsuareztube
    @sorelsuareztube Рік тому +1

    If you liked the book Don't watch the series!

    • @Alex-sr3ez
      @Alex-sr3ez 5 місяців тому

      Why is that?
      I’ve already watched the series and just received the this book today.

  • @hunterxhunter4396
    @hunterxhunter4396 Рік тому

    U said it was predictable and still read through it, isn't it kinda funny

    • @megansreadingrevelations
      @megansreadingrevelations  Рік тому +3

      I still enjoy reading and sometimes what I think is predictable turns out not to be 😂

  • @F4gardens
    @F4gardens Рік тому

    i hate this book but i liked your eyes.