Some of the people in the comments are pathetic, Jisook is not some evil mastermind bitch who manipulated the cameras to keep focusing on her a lot during the performance, thats the cameraman's choice. I really don't get the logic of some kpop fans.
I can't blame the members themselves for screen time. I think Jisook is fine to lip synch other parts, I mean she may use that tactic to make sure she is ready for her own parts, which is good. But the cameramen could do their homework and learn who sings what! I mean it's not THAT difficult (especially since line distribution in this song is evil, sooo....) .
You guys are crazy, the camera man does what he wants and as for Jisook lip syncing the other's parts during the performance other groups do it too you know you may not know it but sometimes they like the other parts in the song they don't sing as well. Jisook didn't do anything wrong.
#레인보우 #블랙스완 #Rainbow #Rainnous #Innocent ♥ Kim Jaekyung ♥ Oh SeungAh ♥ Koh Woori ♥ Kim Jisook ♥ No Eul ♥ Jung Yoonhye ♥ Cho Hyunyoung ♥ Black Swan ♥ I love you so much my 7 goddes ♥ Mis reinas ♥
These performances are rehearsed on stage so the director can note what camera angles he wants to broadcast. If he wants to put Jisook on cam in any given part of the song, then it's his choice.
OMG, how naive are you guys, saying Jisook is doing the lipsync of other members, just to be more on camera. Please, a lot of people does that, so they don't get lost in the lyrics. Woori is the rappers and always open her mouth to sing other parts, besides her rap.
i've noticed that in almost every GsD live performance Hyeri is lipsynching the other girls parts and she doesn't get all the camera time. She probably does it to remember what part she has
You guys should be complaining about the camera man and not about Jisook instead.. I know 4minute have nothing to do with this but for example Jiyoon keeps on lip syncing at Gayoon's part too in 'Crazy' performance.. but the camera man is focusing on Gayoon. Hope you guys know what I'm trying to say here.. My English sucks from time to time xD
All this hate on Jisook is unfair, it's not her fault if the cameraman was biased and focused on her all the time, she has nothing to do with that. It's not the first time that happens, remember snsd's IGAB performance during Gayo 2013, the cameraman focused on Jessica for like 90% of the song and i never saw hate comments to her that time. Jisook was lipsyncing and so? It's common, many idols do that and me too when i sing, is helpful when u are trying to remember all the lines.
Jsyk they rehearse beforehand and send choreo videos to broadcast companies so they know who is singing what part hand where to focus. The cameramen/PDs can display bias too. Anyways that live was flawless, they got even better!
Sigh the camera man doesn't show yoonhye on her first oooh' part bc jisook keeps lip syncing it, then she sings her part. members of groups especially girl groups really care about their camera time, let her have her's! Edit: 'let her have her's' is directed towards the camera man, I'm not fking blaming jisook, i have no problem with her an never have.
People need to stop hating on Jisook it's not her fault. A lot of idols sing along with the song even if it's not their part. It's probably just a habit, I've seen it SO many times. If you're gonna hate on anyone hate on the cameramen. It's their job to already know who's supposed to be singing. Anyways, love Rainbow
Should most of you keep in mind that in every performances, the cameraman will always be focusing a lot on a member who catches his eyes. It's simple as that. If you don't like this certain performance for Black Swan because the cameraman tend to focus a lot on Jisook, leave. There are other performances who focuses on other members and/or are fairly balanced about the airtime for the girls
for me jung yoon hye is so beautiful as jaekyung, but she is not focused, she almost doesnt appear on tv or interviews, perhaps because her name is so difficult at least for western fans like me. but how pretty she is! i am fan
im really mad at the kpop community ... this IS FOR DAMN SURE not the first time someone has lip sync someone else's part ..... ive been seeing it for 2 years (ever since i got into kpop) from damn near every group from SNSD, to WHO THE FREAK EVER .. they all do it .... and no it SHOULDNT confuse the cameraman .... they have practices of all this ... they know whos singing when and at what times im not surprised its not even down to the second on paper ... you cant blame one person for actually lipsyncing the whole song ... maybe she just really like the song???? ive seen all the major groups do it ... and no i cant point out specifically what link cuz all i use YT for is kpop now .... male and female all groups and group members have done it so blaming this one girl for giving her possible all to her preformance is an all time low ... just saying
Omfg, you haters and fans need to back up. It's not like Jisook manipulated or bribed the cameraman into focusing on her. He did it on free will. Geez. I hate the logic of kpop fans. RAINBOW FIGHTING!!!!
the comments here are stupid lolol always trying to find a reason to hate and be bitter. jisook is lipsyncing along, so what? most idols do that too, so they can concentrate. the cameraman must obviously be jisook biased since he's always filming her- it's not because he's confused. rainbow barely have comebacks and everyone just keeps complaining. just shut up, sit down and be grateful rainbow are back jfc.
YESS ~ so daebak! I Can't believe I really thought Rainbow Blaxx was the original group then, I saw rainbow and was like holy crap there's more 😂😂 but I still lovem.
It's too bad that they will stop promoting this only after 2 weeks!!?? I actually really liked it - more than Kara last comeback !! Poor rainbow members
I can't believe that the promotions to black swan already finished. I'm really upset. Just 2 weeks of promotion and no the bad man crying live ? Desapointed with DSP one more time... Still supporting you rainbow, more than ever.
You never really care about yoon and nogeul before, and now you're hating jisook because she "steals yoonhye & noeul screen time". You know that Yoonhye and Nogeul were the visuals in Gossip Girl era and Jisook barely got lines in that song? but, since nobody cared about them in that time, and there were a lot of people who liked Jisook (plus, she's best singer than Yoon & Nogeurie), so they keep give more lines (and screentime) to Sook. You're hating Jisook trying to look like a NoHye fan, and I hate that because I've been a fan of Noeul for years, and I never really care about her lines & screentime. Rainbow are sisters, if you're going to hate any of the girls pretending to be a Hye & Noeul fan, please go away of my fandom, ty.
All members are lip-syncing the "oohh" part not only jisookie , appearently the cameraman or whoever choosing the scenes either thinks its chorus part , or gets confused cuz jisookie is in the center during noeul's turn. And yeah jisookie's lip-sync isn't a a joke , either xD . i think the bunny is too excited in this comeback ^_^
They have a rehearsal AND tape that they provide the shows that designates who sings during which part so they know who to focus on. They aren't stupid. lol. Them focusing on Jisook is their choice, not her fault.
it's not jisook fault at all !! I think it's just a habit. woori do lip-sync also and catch the focus form other members although she's a rapper ! it's not their fault and the cameraman should know for whom this part, it was his choice to select woori and jisook to focus on them :) so stop saying that bad things ! all idols do like this even other rainbow's member but because cameraman choose jisook the other lip-sync members were safe !
Most of you, are so annoying. Jisook looks great. The "Ooohh" part, they showed Jaekyung instead of that other girl. Why ? Cuz the placed Jaek in the front. Just like they placed Jisook in the front in the 2nd "ooooohhhh" part. The other girl was in the back. I'm not saying to blame someone for this, but Jisook is DEFINITELY not to blame. Seriously.
2 weeks and done with promotions. This is why DSP sucks.They do not know how to promote , They only care about Kara. Aren't they planning on debuting a girl group this year? What's the point when they put no effort into one of their veteran groups. Now I heard this song wasn't charting very well but it's only been 2 weeks and it can take longer than that. G-Friend who are a rookie group are still promoting and their song came out a month and half ago. Wth, DSP? I worry so much for Ajax who they really completely ignored last yr. Don't debut a new group and then pay no attention to them. Rainbow gained a lot of fans when A came out but then DSP sent them to Japan and now their Korean base is fading away. They are definitely way more popular internationally. DSP should use that to their advantage.
its actually dsp along with the director in the control room that gets to choose who gets screen time. its not jisooks fault but it seems to me like jisook is in fact lip-synching to get camera time. if you observe her while watching their live performances, you'll see she usually only lipsynchs at certain parts where she's close either isolated, in the middle or front and in those certain parts, she's not absent mindedly just singing along like many claim. shes sees the camera capturing her and continues to lipsynch the others parts. i honestly find it unlikable (reminds me of what hyuna use to do to get attnetion) but then again maybe the other girls need to exert more so the camera will just stay on them or start lip-synching when its jisook's turn lol.
Oh jisook please.... she wass making the cameraman to confuse about who is actually singing.... this is unfair to other members, maybe the members don't care but I really care about it if my bias don't get her screentime. If this is her habit, then it's better to change it, although I knew that the same thing always happen in other girl groups too (especially hyeri of gsd) *I'm not the hater of anyone
Well i think you're a hater bc you only complain about jisook.Almost all of them sing along and you only look at jisook.The camera man decides who he want to film and not jisook.God why are you so......
So...what? Well I think you're a fan of jisook, it's fine. The part they sing a long is definitely the chorus part, so I have no problem with that. Camera man decides who he wants to film? Are you kidding me? Oh please so if he is only the fan of jisook then he can only focus on her, because you said that he can decide who he wants to film right? LOL.
Don't know much about Nine Muses but this song is kinda boring. Just opinion. Everybody is saying Jisook (the one who looks like TaeYeon right?) took the screen time of other members. I think it was the cameraman should be blame for this. Don't just hate her because of this.
Why are you gonna hate on her when she's not doing it..? Blame the camera man, she just gets on stage and dances..the camera man is the one not focusing on other members. She has no control over the camera. So stop trying to come up with a lame ass excuse to hate on her...
jisook is not "making the cameraman confused", she's trying to steal screen time on purpose (we can all tell, she does it repeatedly) because we all know how rare screen time is and how jealous girls are in groups
![[HOT] Rainbow - Whoo, 레인보우 - Whoo Show Music core 20160312](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/tULekjOF0hI/mqdefault.jpg)
![[HOT] Rainbow - Whoo, 레인보우 - Whoo Show Music core 20160312](/img/tr.png)
![Rainbow’s Comebeack Stage as gorgeous Black Swans, RAINBOW - Black Swan! [M COUNTDOWN] EP.413](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kuxThES2LWI/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Comeback Stage] RAINBOW - Black Swan, 레인보우 - Black Swan, Show Music core 20150228](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/6ahN3jdFZ70/mqdefault.jpg)
i'm just waiting for jaekyung to take over the world
Me too ^_^
Empress Jaekyung sounds legit to me
Im from the future. It is now 25 june 2019. Yes, shes already took over the world.
Jisook loves this song. She likes all the parts. I love her.
People stop hating Jisook.
Some of the people in the comments are pathetic, Jisook is not some evil mastermind bitch who manipulated the cameras to keep focusing on her a lot during the performance, thats the cameraman's choice. I really don't get the logic of some kpop fans.
jaja preach it gurl
Love ur comment
They put too much focus on Jaekyung, finally there's a "fancam" of Jisook... lol.
Lol - jisook as an evil mastermind :DD
It's the cameraman who doesn't know who sings which line ;/
ikrr
I can't blame the members themselves for screen time. I think Jisook is fine to lip synch other parts, I mean she may use that tactic to make sure she is ready for her own parts, which is good.
But the cameramen could do their homework and learn who sings what! I mean it's not THAT difficult (especially since line distribution in this song is evil, sooo....) .
You guys are crazy, the camera man does what he wants and as for Jisook lip syncing the other's parts during the performance other groups do it too you know you may not know it but sometimes they like the other parts in the song they don't sing as well. Jisook didn't do anything wrong.
1:22 that pan was amazing!! Add some music video feel to this tbh
The camera man loves Jisook!
My Poor Yoonhye and Noeul. lol
Jaekyung is beautiful, I think she's one of the prettiest girls in Kpop. And Hyunyoung is sexy~
#레인보우 #블랙스완 #Rainbow #Rainnous #Innocent ♥ Kim Jaekyung ♥ Oh SeungAh ♥ Koh Woori ♥ Kim Jisook ♥ No Eul ♥ Jung Yoonhye ♥ Cho Hyunyoung ♥ Black Swan ♥ I love you so much my 7 goddes ♥ Mis reinas ♥
When woori says "like black swan" and "it's perfect" I get chills. The black swan makeup looks so good on her. She's absolutely gorgeous.
These performances are rehearsed on stage so the director can note what camera angles he wants to broadcast. If he wants to put Jisook on cam in any given part of the song, then it's his choice.
Best underrated song of Kpop 😘
OMG, how naive are you guys, saying Jisook is doing the lipsync of other members, just to be more on camera. Please, a lot of people does that, so they don't get lost in the lyrics. Woori is the rappers and always open her mouth to sing other parts, besides her rap.
But no one said jisook was literally the first idol to ever to do this...
i've noticed that in almost every GsD live performance Hyeri is lipsynching the other girls parts and she doesn't get all the camera time. She probably does it to remember what part she has
You guys should be complaining about the camera man and not about Jisook instead.. I know 4minute have nothing to do with this but for example Jiyoon keeps on lip syncing at Gayoon's part too in 'Crazy' performance.. but the camera man is focusing on Gayoon.
Hope you guys know what I'm trying to say here.. My English sucks from time to time xD
All this hate on Jisook is unfair, it's not her fault if the cameraman was biased and focused on her all the time, she has nothing to do with that. It's not the first time that happens, remember snsd's IGAB performance during Gayo 2013, the cameraman focused on Jessica for like 90% of the song and i never saw hate comments to her that time. Jisook was lipsyncing and so? It's common, many idols do that and me too when i sing, is helpful when u are trying to remember all the lines.
Love the melody of this song
the costumes are really beautiful
hyunyoung i love
Omg Jaekyung soooo good live
Woori so beautiful
Jsyk they rehearse beforehand and send choreo videos to broadcast companies so they know who is singing what part hand where to focus. The cameramen/PDs can display bias too.
Anyways that live was flawless, they got even better!
OMG Jaekyun por que eras tan perfecta ? ♥
Sigh the camera man doesn't show yoonhye on her first oooh' part bc jisook keeps lip syncing it, then she sings her part. members of groups especially girl groups really care about their camera time, let her have her's! Edit: 'let her have her's' is directed towards the camera man, I'm not fking blaming jisook, i have no problem with her an never have.
Queen Jaekyung ^^
YOONHYE IS VERY BEAUTIFUL BUT DSP YOU NEVER CARE ABOUT HER !!!!
SHE CAN BE NO.2 RAPPER !!
I don't even know how to describe Jisook here. She's just so...mystifying.
People need to stop hating on Jisook it's not her fault. A lot of idols sing along with the song even if it's not their part. It's probably just a habit, I've seen it SO many times. If you're gonna hate on anyone hate on the cameramen. It's their job to already know who's supposed to be singing.
Anyways, love Rainbow
Should most of you keep in mind that in every performances, the cameraman will always be focusing a lot on a member who catches his eyes. It's simple as that. If you don't like this certain performance for Black Swan because the cameraman tend to focus a lot on Jisook, leave. There are other performances who focuses on other members and/or are fairly balanced about the airtime for the girls
I miss my rainbow 😭😭😭
Man I love this song,the performances,and the girls!!! Win already
for me jung yoon hye is so beautiful as jaekyung, but she is not focused, she almost doesnt appear on tv or interviews, perhaps because her name is so difficult at least for western fans like me. but how pretty she is! i am fan
everyday i cry about their disbandment :')
와 이노래가 내나이 20대초반에 나온걸로 기억하는데 진짜 세월이라는 단어하고 추억자체가 소름돋네요 유튜브의 알고리즘으로 나오더라고요 덕분에 저만의 추억의곡을 듣게되어 좋았습니다
i love those fan boys
I would of been there screaming lol
RAINBOW
im really mad at the kpop community ... this IS FOR DAMN SURE not the first time someone has lip sync someone else's part ..... ive been seeing it for 2 years (ever since i got into kpop) from damn near every group from SNSD, to WHO THE FREAK EVER .. they all do it .... and no it SHOULDNT confuse the cameraman .... they have practices of all this ... they know whos singing when and at what times im not surprised its not even down to the second on paper ... you cant blame one person for actually lipsyncing the whole song ... maybe she just really like the song???? ive seen all the major groups do it ... and no i cant point out specifically what link cuz all i use YT for is kpop now .... male and female all groups and group members have done it so blaming this one girl for giving her possible all to her preformance is an all time low ... just saying
Omfg, you haters and fans need to back up. It's not like Jisook manipulated or bribed the cameraman into focusing on her. He did it on free will. Geez. I hate the logic of kpop fans.
RAINBOW FIGHTING!!!!
You can really see Music Core's backtrack rule coming into play here, I can actually hear their voices for once without the super loud backtrack
the comments here are stupid lolol always trying to find a reason to hate and be bitter. jisook is lipsyncing along, so what? most idols do that too, so they can concentrate. the cameraman must obviously be jisook biased since he's always filming her- it's not because he's confused.
rainbow barely have comebacks and everyone just keeps complaining. just shut up, sit down and be grateful rainbow are back jfc.
YESS ~ so daebak! I Can't believe I really thought Rainbow Blaxx was the original group then, I saw rainbow and was like holy crap there's more 😂😂 but I still lovem.
these girls should have joined the unit
In case nobody saw the article on Allkpop but Rainbow is disbanding next month :(
Este es el ejemplo de un concepto sexy bien utilizado!
It's too bad that they will stop promoting this only after 2 weeks!!?? I actually really liked it - more than Kara last comeback !! Poor rainbow members
nice song
반가워요~ 베로니카 박! 이에요~
their outfit look like kebaya(outfit from indonesia)
A great moment for kpop
I can't believe that the promotions to black swan already finished. I'm really upset. Just 2 weeks of promotion and no the bad man crying live ? Desapointed with DSP one more time... Still supporting you rainbow, more than ever.
👀
You never really care about yoon and nogeul before, and now you're hating jisook because she "steals yoonhye & noeul screen time". You know that Yoonhye and Nogeul were the visuals in Gossip Girl era and Jisook barely got lines in that song? but, since nobody cared about them in that time, and there were a lot of people who liked Jisook (plus, she's best singer than Yoon & Nogeurie), so they keep give more lines (and screentime) to Sook.
You're hating Jisook trying to look like a NoHye fan, and I hate that because I've been a fan of Noeul for years, and I never really care about her lines & screentime.
Rainbow are sisters, if you're going to hate any of the girls pretending to be a Hye & Noeul fan, please go away of my fandom, ty.
i hate how jisook keeps lip syncing to other members' parts tho don't get me wrong it is just her lip sync makes camera man confuse with others
thats a stupid reason to hate on jisook
All members are lip-syncing the "oohh" part not only jisookie , appearently the cameraman or whoever choosing the scenes either thinks its chorus part , or gets confused cuz jisookie is in the center during noeul's turn.
And yeah jisookie's lip-sync isn't a a joke , either xD . i think the bunny is too excited in this comeback ^_^
They have a rehearsal AND tape that they provide the shows that designates who sings during which part so they know who to focus on. They aren't stupid. lol.
Them focusing on Jisook is their choice, not her fault.
it's not jisook fault at all !! I think it's just a habit.
woori do lip-sync also and catch the focus form other members although she's a rapper !
it's not their fault and the cameraman should know for whom this part, it was his choice to select woori and jisook to focus on them :)
so stop saying that bad things ! all idols do like this even other rainbow's member but because cameraman choose jisook the other lip-sync members were safe !
Minho 😍😘
QUEEN FOREVER
It's perfect ;)
Jaekyung💕
Kim jae kyung
나만 이 노래가 좋은건가봐🤣😭
呜呜呜呜姐姐们好美🤤🤤🤤
i liked the song but why two members only sing for 3 seconds? or less .. hope they become more popular
Only 17? :/ Rainbow Fighting
Most of you, are so annoying. Jisook looks great. The "Ooohh" part, they showed Jaekyung instead of that other girl. Why ? Cuz the placed Jaek in the front. Just like they placed Jisook in the front in the 2nd "ooooohhhh" part. The other girl was in the back. I'm not saying to blame someone for this, but Jisook is DEFINITELY not to blame. Seriously.
I love this song but..think of an ex.. 😰
Jisook haters to the left.
Who at 2:46?? She remember me to Jiyeon at cry cry...
Sorry about my english. ^_^
Noeul
Rainbow disappears for almost two years and they all come back looking mature and sexy af....I like this! >_
Nal anajuseyo nal badajuseyo
Fuck i love kpop it's unique to me :)
2 weeks and done with promotions. This is why DSP sucks.They do not know how to promote , They only care about Kara. Aren't they planning on debuting a girl group this year? What's the point when they put no effort into one of their veteran groups. Now I heard this song wasn't charting very well but it's only been 2 weeks and it can take longer than that. G-Friend who are a rookie group are still promoting and their song came out a month and half ago. Wth, DSP? I worry so much for Ajax who they really completely ignored last yr. Don't debut a new group and then pay no attention to them. Rainbow gained a lot of fans when A came out but then DSP sent them to Japan and now their Korean base is fading away. They are definitely way more popular internationally. DSP should use that to their advantage.
its actually dsp along with the director in the control room that gets to choose who gets screen time. its not jisooks fault but it seems to me like jisook is in fact lip-synching to get camera time. if you observe her while watching their live performances, you'll see she usually only lipsynchs at certain parts where she's close either isolated, in the middle or front and in those certain parts, she's not absent mindedly just singing along like many claim. shes sees the camera capturing her and continues to lipsynch the others parts. i honestly find it unlikable (reminds me of what hyuna use to do to get attnetion) but then again maybe the other girls need to exert more so the camera will just stay on them or start lip-synching when its jisook's turn lol.
No Breath
anyone can tell me who that girl with the black hair tied into a ponytail is?
Idk if you found out who she is yet but that's hyunyoung! :)
They didn't focus on No Eul and Yoon Hye :(
진짜 곡이 이상함. 곡만 아니었음 컨셉, 의상 다 좋은데. 곡 컨셉은 좋은데, 토슈즈나 거울속에 비친 내가 내가 아닌것 같다는 그런 컨셉 자체는 좋은데, 표현이 드럽게 안됬음 ㅠㅠㅠ 곡을 잘 만났으면 대박났을 수도 있을텐데
+1♥️
Oh jisook please.... she wass making the cameraman to confuse about who is actually singing.... this is unfair to other members, maybe the members don't care but I really care about it if my bias don't get her screentime. If this is her habit, then it's better to change it, although I knew that the same thing always happen in other girl groups too (especially hyeri of gsd) *I'm not the hater of anyone
Well i think you're a hater bc you only complain about jisook.Almost all of them sing along and you only look at jisook.The camera man decides who he want to film and not jisook.God why are you so......
So...what? Well I think you're a fan of jisook, it's fine. The part they sing a long is definitely the chorus part, so I have no problem with that. Camera man decides who he wants to film? Are you kidding me? Oh please so if he is only the fan of jisook then he can only focus on her, because you said that he can decide who he wants to film right? LOL.
2020
***☝️😎(😘)RainBow***
capping on jisook for what 😂 not her fault she got alot of screen time.
Don't know much about Nine Muses but this song is kinda boring. Just opinion. Everybody is saying Jisook (the one who looks like TaeYeon right?) took the screen time of other members. I think it was the cameraman should be blame for this. Don't just hate her because of this.
Jisook try too hard. I dunno why i dont like her here....
Me too! Gosh finally someone speak out my mind lol
Imelda Theresia hahaha 👋
Maybe she try to match her expression with the song.. but that is just.... not match hahaha
lmao so bitter. there's nothing wrong with her expressions.
jinlissul thats just my opinion 😊
they never show yoonhyee, it's unfair, poor girl.
Jisook...I can't with her, she's annoying.
Yoonhye : 2 times
Noeul : only when her part (1)
Why are you gonna hate on her when she's not doing it..? Blame the camera man, she just gets on stage and dances..the camera man is the one not focusing on other members. She has no control over the camera. So stop trying to come up with a lame ass excuse to hate on her...
+Rex Warrior dude, your comment made me like rofl xDD
This camera sucks!
jisook is not "making the cameraman confused", she's trying to steal screen time on purpose (we can all tell, she does it repeatedly) because we all know how rare screen time is and how jealous girls are in groups
The outfits are horrible.
노래 참...
하..