What was the 'Canadian War of Independence'?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 вер 2024
- Get MagellanTV here: try.magellantv... & get an exclusive offer extended to our viewers: an extra month FREE. MagellanTV is a new kind of streaming service run by filmmakers with 2,000+ documentaries! Check out our personal recommendation and MagellanTV’s exclusive playlists: www.magellantv...
The War of 1812 was fought between the United States, the British Empire (including Canada), and various First Nations/Native American tribes, over possession of North America as well as maritime agitation and the Napoleonic Wars in Europe. Some have termed this the 'Canadian War of Independence', and in this video I'd like to look at in which ways this may be considered as a war of independence for Canada.
Raid the Merch Market: teespring.com/...
Go Fund My Windmills (Patreon): / historywithhilbert
Join in the Banter on Twitter: / historywhilbert
Enter the Fray on Facebook: / historywhilbert
Indulge in some Instagram..?(the alliteration needs to stop): / historywithhilbert
Music Used:
Eine Kleine Nachtsmusik - Mozart
Achaidh Cheide- Kevin MacLeod
Birch Run - Kevin MacLeod
Black Bird - Kevin MacLeod
Expeditionary - Kevin MacLeod
Firesong - Kevin MacLeod
Hero Down - Kevin MacLeod
Midnight Tale - Kevin MacLeod
The Pyre - Kevin MacLeod
Sunday Dub - Kevin MacLeod
Send me an email if you'd be interested in doing a collaboration! historywithhilbert@gmail.com
#Canada #USA #Warof1812
As an American, I think the (roughly paraphrasing here) saying that “The Canadians know they won, the Americans think they won, the British don’t remember it, and the Native Americans lost” is the best way to sum up the War of 1812
#notallamericans
Yeah, this is accurate!
I like this explanation.
The war was a land grab by the USA it failed Result Canada became closer the the UK they independence started in 1867
on interesting fact they were lest casualty on both sides in 2 years of war than in any one of the big Napoleonic battles in the European mainland
Canada's actual independence was 1982
Just a quick point... New Brunswick is not a town, it's a province. At the time of its creation, it was a colony created out of the already existing colony of Nova Scotia.
I was just going to point that out (as I was born and raised there).
Well, if I remember my history correctly Nova Scotia and New Brunswick was the French colony of Acadia, and the term "Acadians" devolved into "Cajun," because the French living there were deported and ended up in New Orleans. The British first got Prince Edward Island and Cape Breton Island as a colony. Then it got all of Acadia about 1743, because of unrest the French were deported and some time over the next 60 years Acadia broke into two and Cape Breton Island was made part of Nova Scotia.
He means that New Brunswick was a town at the time
" In this country you can say what you like, because no one will listen to you anyway!..."
Renowned Canadian author Margaret Atwood in 1981
actually you can't say what you want, our prime minister is trying to censor youtube now
@@micahistory Many things have changed in Canada since 1981... Apparently the last name of the PM is not one of them!...Hmmmmm!🤔
@@alexanderkarayannis6425 yes lol
@@alexanderkarayannis6425 His last name should probably be Castro anyway so it's alright.
@@G-Mastah-Fash that was always one of the stupider conspiracy theories
Canadians: the war we won yay.
US yanks: the war we won hurray.
Native americans: yet another doomed war for us.
Brits: war with yanks in canada? I don't rememb... ohh right that is the war where we burned their bloody white house down?
I wonder how invested British people were even at the time, considering what a massive threat Napoleon was?
This has been the most in-depth video on the war of 1812 I’ve seen. I especially like the homage made to French, Anglo, Black, and Native Canadian cooperation. This is to say, YES we want a video about the Native perspectives in this time period!
Check out the doc it's based on. Also, check out Canada: A People's History.
I can't believe that the Dutch were mentioned (3:48) with no musical accompaniment! 😮🥺
Who are you, and what have you done with Hilbert?!
ua-cam.com/video/blfTdqas3pg/v-deo.html Here you go!
@@ocramdouwstra8494 Not the clip he usually uses, but I imagine he'd approve! 😉
A lot of Canadians are very proud of the war. I remember doing four papers about it, which was a huge part of my grade in a history course.
I find that interesting as an American because I think most Americans see the War of 1812 as a war between Britain and America
@@IAmGlutton4Life I know what you mean mate. But it's kind of true in some way. I broke it down to three parts in my old essays.
First part is defense by mostly Canadians. Pushing back multiple invasions. Just back and forth American-Canadian border war.
Second part is when Britain joins in. After beating Napoleon, they went "Oh that's right. Crap in North America is going down". They then send in much needed reinforcements, and with manpower problem solved. A combined force of Canadian and British troops burned down the white house.
And the last part is Britain alone peaceing out with the US, without telling the Canadians. The treaty took a while to get to the continent and the US took one last small win before all sides learned it's over.
The last part upset some Canadians back then. Even today some if not all Canadians (except in the govt) find Britain or the UK annoying. Everyone is nice but if you ever seen someone trying their best to hide their "annoyed face". That's what many Canadians would do, whenever Britain comes up.
@tton4Life That's not how we see it. The OP is absolutely correct. The War or 1812 is a big part of our national mythology. For one thing, Americans think they were only fighting the British, but we know about the huge role played by local Canadian militias in the war. We also know about our Indigenous allies. You'se all lionise Tecumseh, but we remember that he fought on OUR side. And some of us remember how the Brits screwed him...
And the war plays right into our struggle to maintain an independent and distinct identity from our American neighbors.
we canadians are very proud of this war, back in 2012, I remember there were many exhibitions about it
An American friend of mine came to visit me in 2012 and she asked me what all the 1812 banners hanging on the streetlights were about. I told her it was the centennial anniversary for the war of 1812. And she said, what's that?! I told her it was when America tried to invade Canada but Canada got the jump on them and we burnt down the Whitehouse instead. It's used to very quietly celebrate the fact that we're not American.
@@amandabeaty1492 Well, not exactly. The British burned the white house in retaliation for the American forces having burned down York, aka present day Toronto.
@@johnhughes9878 We burned down the White House. Canada was British and ruled from London. The British armed forces were our armed forces. WE, not THEY.
@@johnhughes9878 true
@@amandabeaty1492 yes
"If some countries have too much history, WE have too much...geography!"...Canadian PM Mackenzie King back in 1936, speaking in the House of Commons on the difficulty of governing a country as big as Canada, second biggest country in the world after Russia, and even after the breakup of the Soviet Union!...😁
The thing is; nobody lives in most of Canada's very inhospitable Northern lands.
@@jamespettigrew7026 The thing is; who would want to!....
"...Most of us are still huddled tight to the border, looking into the candy store window, scared by the Americans on one side and the bush on the other"....
Canadian writer Mordechai Richler in 1989
@@jamespettigrew7026 It is still difficult to govern a country that big because the population is all stretched out over a very very long strip near the border
@@jk-gb4et I've forgotten the exact percentage, but it was really high like 90 to 95 percent of Canada's population lives withing 100 miles from the U.S. border. I thought it was because of the nearly year long extreme cold.
You kept on saying that the native Americans helped defeat the "British" when you meant that they helped defeat the "Americans" @18:29 19:11 19:17
That's pop culture for you, Americans are never defeated :P
@@makouras vietnam would like to counter that
@@User91459 America won in vietnam.
@@Colon-D... huh how did they didnt the vietcong capture saigon in 1975 and created the communist government which still runs the country also its widely known that vietnam was a failure maybe you thought about korea
@@User91459 I may be wrong but from memory I recall that Vietcong officers remarked that if the US had stayed for a few more months they would've just given up. Take that with a pound of salt since memory is unreliable.
But the Tet offensive was a military success in terms of military gains. The issue was television of combat and casualties. Such stuff that didn't happen in Korea.
By 1990 the old government was completely replaced by communist reformers who encouraged Private Ownership of Farmland.
This period of North American history is fascinating 🧐
I completely agree!
If interested there are reenactments usually in the summer throughout Canada and the us on the war of 1812 and also reenacting group's involved in the hobby
wow
@@HistoryNerd1814 Depending where you go to see the re-enactment, a different side will win!! xD
Thinking of the war of 1812 as being the Canadians 'fighting for the British' is naive to the modern meaning of the war. The French and Indians weren't pro-British, they simply were not American and cared enough about it to fight for it. The reason it's symbolically important is that was the key moment of distinction where the North American continent split into two countries and not one, there was the United States of America and then this 'other' peoples in the north from mainly two origins who would come together and fight for their shared goal. It is clearly an important war for the development of a unique Canadian identity and therefore I think the title of the war as a sort of 'war of independence is justified.
I disagree most if not all Aboriginals within upper and lower Canada were just as loyal if not more loyal than the settlers. This is because many of them were refugees and were forced out by the Americans. Sure some Aboriginal nations like those that occupied the Ohio region were not as pro British as those living in Canada but they still saw the British as being a better alternative because of the Royal Proclamation. It is important to realize that the Aboriginal people did not align themselves to just one ideology instead they aligned themselves with various different beliefs and ideas of how they should go about.
I think it would be more accurate to say that the British had demonstrated that they would preserve French language and culture in Canada, as enshrined in the British North America (Quebec) Act 1774. In contrast, the Louisiana Purchase in 1803 contained no provisions for respecting the language and culture of those former French citizens who had become Americans by fait accompli.
The Canadiens had no reason to believe that the Americans would respect their French way of life, so they sided with the British who had proved that they would.
Fun fact in Quebec we are habs and the Montreal hockey team is the habs it’s comes from what the French still living in France called us les habitants , it was actually ment to be rude as we where seen as low class , but in our normal form we just took that in passing 😂
If any war was the Canadian War of Independence, it was the First World War. In typically Canadian fashion, we won that independence by fighting alongside the country we won it from. Canada went to war as a colony, with no say in the matter, but ended the war with a separate seat at the big nation's table, signing the Treaty of Versailles as an independent power. While the idea of a united Canada may have begun at Chateauguay, Lundy's Lane and Crysler's Farm, Canadian independence was created at Ypres, Hill 70, Passchendaele, and Vimy Ridge.
Beautifully articulated
Yeah, committing heinous war crimes is oh so Canadian......
I say that cynically, but not ironically.
Ok, so a couple of things, the war of 1812 has always fascinated me more than the American War of Independence, especially when seeing the Canadian side. Second, I saw you on the Ongezellig comments.
It plays a much greater role in Canadian history, especially in Ontario's history (and to a lesser degree Quebec's), than it does in American history particularly when it comes to national myths. From the American point of view, the War of 1812 seems to often be portrayed as an affirmation of American independence. The expansionist side of the war seems to be less emphasized there than it is in Canadian schools.
From the Canadian perspective, it's one of the foundational moments in our national identity because it ensured we'd evolve to be something different from the US. That "stalemate" outcome kept the revolutionary and loyalist/French colonial populations evolving apart, albeit as neighbours. Although at the time the colonists undoubtedly perceived their goals as simply "remaining British" or "not being invaded again" (in the French Canadian case), peace after the War of 1812 was the point where absorption into the US ceased to be an active military threat to Canada (although the perception of possible threat continued throughout the 19th century). It didn't birth the modern country but it created the conditions that allowed it to happen in the future.
Viewing each other as actual allies took another century or so. The friendship really gelled after Canada gained control over its own foreign and defense policy in 1931 and the risk of Canada getting dragged into any Anglo-American disputes (still a real possibility as late as the 1920s - concerns about that rivalry helped drive the Washington Naval Treaty) ceased to be a real concern. Our strong collaboration in WW2 and afterwards kind of sealed the friendship, with the Suez Crisis probably being the key turning point when Canada opted to align mostly with the US position rather than the UK one.
@@paranoidrodent Hmm, I wonder what it must’ve been like for the border people on both areas, how did they see each other?
In Ohio, we have a history class in primary school called "Ohio History" in which we spend the entire year going from Ohio's birth in 1803 to about the 1940's after WW2. We extensively talk about the Battle of Fallen Timbers, which forced the British Canadians and Native Americans out of Ohio, and the War of 1812, as Fort Meigs and Fort Stevenson were in Northern Ohio, and still to this day we have a huge pillar called Perry's Monument commemorating Commodore Perry's decisive victory against the British Canadians in the Battle of Lake Erie. If you want to visit, it's interesting and fun to take the 40min ferry ride from Catawba Island to Put-in-Bay.
What other war could they have had in 1812? Here in the US we call it The War of Maple Syrup Aggression.
As an American I can conform we have no beef with Canada and after all we have to the aid to each other time and time again
Speak for yourself 🇨🇦=🤢👎
Support the thin red line! Rally to the King!
Huzzah!
Having learned about this as an adult, I'm disappointed in what I learned in school about the War of 1812. We didn't learn that it had anything to do with Canada, or that America started it opportunistically.
That's because it didn't have anything to do with "Canada". Canada didn't exist, it was a vast, sparsely populated territory, ruled over by Britain. America had beef with Britain, so they invaded British territory. The only thing it has to do with Canada is that some of the battles were fought on the land that eventually became Canada.
@cJones You're literally wrong. Yes, Canada was still technically a colony but Canadians by that time had a distinct identity and a large degree of self-governing autonomy. We even had a name -- as reflected in the provinces of Upper and Lower Canada.
And try telling the people who lived besided the St Laurence and the Great Lakes that they lived in a "sparsely populated territory...."
But you keep on believing your American cultural imperialist propaganda. Your ignorance will be your shield, as is usual for Yankees.
@@RealMacJones Right, and we didn't learn any of that in school. None of what you said has anything to do with my comment.
Let's get something straight about slavery. Americans wanted it. Canadians didn't. An Act Against Slavery was legislated in Upper Canada, (Ontario), in 1793; the slave trade was outlawed under British rule; and, the few slaves that were in Canada were being freed eventually, long before it was abolished across the British Empire in 1834. Slavery in the United States was still legal in 1865.
I had a teacher at OCS that said if the leadership says it will be easy, you should really worry. He used the War of 1812 as the primary example.
The war of 1812 in North America was also known as the Blunder's War, as so many mistakes were made by both sides, they could make a comedy out of it.
Chateauguay is pronounced sha-toh-gay, not sha-toh-gway (the English phonetic version is essentially just the French word with some English lexical stress added to the first syllable and the resulting weakening of the other vowels).
Also, as other have noted New Brunswick was a new colony apart from Canada and it was formed out of the part of New France called Acadia, which was to the east of the French colony of Canada. The bulk of the Loyalists in the two Canadas were in Upper Canada (what is today Ontario) and a smaller number in the urban centres (esp. Montreal) and the Eastern Townships of Quebec (today the region of l'Estrie - the part that lies roughly just north of Vermont). A large number of Loyalists also ended up in New Brunswick and Nova Scotia but these colonies were not a part of Canada until 1867.
Another factor in the American decision to go to war that often goes very overlooked is the Chesapeake incident. The reaction to it was similar to that of the sinking of the Maine. The difference being that the Chesapeake incident wasn't a false flag.
Pretty sure the Maine explosion was an accident, not a false flag.
Considering how unreliable and dangerous those ships were, it probably was an accident
I would have taken more time to explain what was Canada in 1812 and what were the other British colonies in North America at the time. For the rest, pretty accurate and concise.
I feel like it was the entirely opposite. It was the canadians basically saying that they support the British
Thinking of the war of 1812 as being the Canadians 'fighting for the British' is naive to the modern meaning of the war. The French and Indians weren't pro-British, they simply were not American and cared enough about it to fight for it. The reason it's symbolically important is that was the key moment of distinction where the North American continent split into two countries and not one, there was the United States of America and then this 'other' peoples in the north from mainly two origins who would come together and fight for their shared goal. It is clearly an important war for the development of a unique Canadian identity and therefore I think the title of the war as a sort of 'war of independence is justified.
@Albert Fels Either way, saying they fought for "independence" seems a bit misleading. They fought to maintain the power and status of an autocracy from an expansionist republic.
@Albert Fels What? I'm referring to the U.S. when I say republic, and Autocracy when I'm talking about the British
@Albert Fels If Canada had been taken by the U.S. there would be States rather than Provinces, Canadians would have ended up fighting in both world wars at a later date as Americans, and when Americans forget that Canadians are not Americans and ask them who they voted for U.S. President, they could actually answer.
@Albert Fels Dude, What are you on about? Having a king as head of state makes it a monarchy. There's also the fact that everything was still essentially ran by the English nobility. By all accounts Britain at the time was autocratic
The natives who started fighting with the British had actually moved from the south because the Americans had already had a short war with them when they'd tried to make a tribal coalition to retain and protect their lands. It was totally separate from the beaver wars and its a shame that you didn't look at the past of the natives leader Tecumseh you mentioned.
The natives and especially Tecumseh liked Brock and trusted him and he also fought for them. When he died they lost the one man who was truly fighting for the natives rights and its interesting to think about what the treatment of the natives after might have been like if he'd survived.
Thank you for pointing out that the US wanted to annex canada. Somehow, many americans claim this wasnt a reason for war despite it being the main one by far.
Yeah the War of 1812 and the French and Indian Wars arent as well known as the should be. Apart from the American Revolution and the Civil War, many people (especially americans) dont know about the many small to medium scale conflicts fought on the continent.
Maybe some videos on the wars between the settlers and tribes of the 1600s or the spanish exploration of the continent between the 1500s and 1600s would be a cool idea.
Regardless, keep up the good work and take care.
Same could be said about the Mexican-American and Spanish-American Wars.
I'd never even heard of The Philippines-American War until I visited a museum in Manilla. At the time The Philippines was a U.S. territory. Another thing that doesn't get explained well enough is that The American Independence War was actually a civil war and not a revolution. It's so ingrained, that this statement is often met with outrage.
When I was in high school here in Canada, the Seven Years' War/French and Indian War (New France taken over by the British), the War of 1812 (Canada avoids becoming American, subsequent shift in British relations with indigenous communities) along with the 1837-1838 Rebellions (the catalyst for future Canadian self-governance - the rebellions were quashed but the rebels essentially got everything they wanted within a little over a decade, starting the ball slowly rolling towards gradual independence later) essentially played the same historical role as formative conflicts as the American Revolution and Civil War do in American schools. The Red River and Northwest Rebellions and the two world wars (esp. WW1) were also important in shaping the national consciousness.
Still waiting on that Shropshire video hilby.
I will always be waiting
Soooooo....this war was pretty much just
-Both sides burned down each other’s cities.
-Both failed to invade each other.
-Both failed to win
-And the Indians lost their territory again.
Where are you from?
Pretty much!
@@TheIceman567 A Place that wasn’t a Part of the US yet, when this war happened
@@anthonymarchiano9774 Canada?
@@TheIceman567 No im from the USA
Thanks for a great presentation. Cheers from Vancouver.
The Australian war of independence is played on the cricket field against England every couple of years.
Also, the USA was divided. The state of Connecticut passed a law saying that it would secede from the Union IF peace with the British was not made within a few months. Yes, Connecticut was the first state to secede, NOT South Carolina.
As an English person Connecticut is now my favourite state
Didn't formally do it though
23:10 "If anyone was defeated, it would be the Native Americans"
Reminds me of that John Green line, "We now enter the period of 'it was great for everyone but the Poles'.
When did that end?
Oh 1989"
Every Canadian kid has grown up hearing this song. I can still recite it by heart.
ooooh come back proud Canadians
To before you had TV
No hockey night in canada!
There was no CBC (oh my god)
In 1812 Maddison was mad
He was the president you know
well he thought he'd tell the British
Where they aught to go
He thought he'd invade canada
He thought that he was tough
Instead we went to washingon...
And burned down all his stuff
[chorus]
And the white house burned burned burned
And we're the ones that did it
It burned burned burned
while the president ran and cried
It burned burned burned
And things were very historical
and the americans ran and cried like a bunch of little babies
wah wah wah!
In the war of 1812
Them Hillbillies from Kentucky
Dressed in green and red
Left home to fight in Canada
But they returned home dead
Its the only war the Yankees lost
Except for Vietnam
And also the alamo
and the bay of... Ham
The loser was america
the winner was ourselves
so join right in and gloat about
the war of 1812
[chorus]
In 1812 we were just sittin around
Mindin our own business
Puttin crops into the ground
we heard the soldiers coming and we didnt like that sound
so we took a boat to washington
and burned it to the ground
ooooh we fired our guns but the yankees kept-a-comin
There wasn't quite as many as there was a while ago
we fired once more and the yankees started runnin
Down the mississippi to the gulf of mexico-oo-oo-oo-oo-oo-ooo
They ran through the snow and they ran through the forest
They ran through the bushes where the beavers wouldnt go
The ran so fast they forgot to take their culture
Back to America and the gulf of mexico-oo-oo-ooo
so if you go to washington
its buildings clean and nice
bring a pack of matches
and we'll burn the white house twice
and the whitehouse burned burned burned
but the americans wont admit it
it burned burned burned
it burned it burned it burned
it burned burned burned
how that made them mad
and the americans ran and cried like a bunch of little babies
wah wah wah
in the war of 1812
Great video and very accurate. This war also really helped the french Canadien keep preserving their language.
Actually it’s not this video is garbage
the native americans actually still have a lot of power here in Canada mostly in Manitoba and Nunavut. But also in Quénec and northern Ontario.
Ahh the war with no winners.
We burned the whitehouse down. I count that as a win.
@@Ozzy_2014 oh no you burned someone's house down. How did America ever recuperate from this tragic event I will never know.
@wulpurgis Who are "they". The only people I see bringing it up aren't American. If anything Americans seem not to care
@wulpurgis what point are trying to get across exactly
Yeah, no, Canada won. Well sort of Canada.
I think you have to remember that Canada had an ok thing going with Britain for many years they did lots of trade together that benefited Britain and Canada and people often saw themselves as British descendants and relatively content with it and the Native Indians were more fearful of the US,and there wasn't the spark to push them over the edge like in the US where small grievances piled up over a short time
Hilbert: At this time, Canada was split into Upper and Lower Canada.
Sad Maritime Noises
To be fair, the Maritimes were completely separate colonies at the time (they joined Canada in 1867, 1873 for PEI) but unless I'm mistaken, the War of 1812 affected them too (as part of the Atlantic naval theatre rather than the Canadian land warfare theatre). That really should get covered better in Canadian history books.
Much love to our eastern cousins! Stay safe!
@@paranoidrodent actually a good portion of Maine was occupied for the duration of the war. The duties collected help fund the foundation of Dalhousie university. As well the New Brunswick Fencibles marched to Montreal during the winter of 1813.
So ...no word of the role played by the Hudson's Bay Company?
Ultra fascinating.
Also remember that the British continued to occupy upstate NY, basically north of Albany, right up until about 1808, in violation of the Treaty of Paris of 1783. The US government was always protesting that that land was illegally occupied, and the British left because they needed the soldiers to fight Napoleon and were tryin to reduce tensions with the Americans.
Will you do a video on maori musket war?
Our "war of independence" was World War I. The war of 1812 was a war between Britain, and America, Canada had no national identity. World War I is the war that lead to Canadians seeing themselves as a distinct society separate from Britain. It was not the war of 1812. The war of 1812 was literally just that time the rebels down south got all uppity again while old mumsy was dealing with the lil corporal. They came up here made Canadian lives more difficult for a bit, until the real fighting was over in Europe, then they got spanked.
You've done a very good job there - yes, a little meandering (as you admit), but balanced and comprehensive for such a short video. I know the events precede all this by over 50 years, but for some reason I couldn't get the image of "The Death of General Wolfe" from my mind (the painting featured prominently in a rather jingoistic history book of my mothers I read as a child that dates from the 1960s). If you do read this, please keep up the good work. I only occasionally dip into your channel, but I'm always glad I did and it reminds me I must do it more often. Best wishes from an Irishman, in London, across the Noordzee.
War of 1812 I perfer to call it the Canuck Kerfuffle
Basically by 1814 the USA swept the British and Canadians from the Great Lakes and the British controlled the Atlantic seaboard, so even though the Duke of Wellington was asked to conquer the USA, he refused, saying Britain would never hold it so peace was made.
For those really interested in this war, id highly recommend Pierre Burton's books 'The Invasion of Canada' and 'Flames Across the Boarder.' They use narrative history to really bring the conflict and major historical figures to life.
American sneeding incoming
What's sneeding?
@@lucifer2b666 Sneed and Feed, formerly Chuck's
Oh I’m gonna sneed alright
Night of the long rakes will come for the leaves
Top fuckin Sneed
I'm from Niagara Region on we have a lot of the 1812 battlefields here locally. And my military unit was also in the war of 1812. The Canadians wouldn't of been able to push the Americans out if it wasn't for the militia
While I do agree that the war of 1812 was a war that helped start Canada's identity, I wouldn't say it was out war of independence. Canada actually did try this in 1837-38 there was the Canadian rebellions but they failed. I would honestly say that WW1 was our war of independence. Some of the soldiers said that they went into the battles as British soldiers, but came down as Canadians.
Where........ Where is "Het Wilhelmus"?
Sad Dutch noises
Remember that although many Americans lived in Upper Canada at the time, the Americans came in and started to loot and burn and people who would have been sympathetic to their cause joined the British militia. The Americans burned the capital of York, today's Toronto, and this shocked all the participants in the Napoleonic wars, losing the American government any support it may have had in its invasions. Washington DC was burned in retaliation.
When I started watching this video it was just 18:12 (6:12 PM) lol
I like your work
this was the war that united us and made us into the country that we are today
The War of 1812 is only "Canada's War of Independence" in the context of our relationship to the United States. The thing is, we didn't gain formal independence until the Statute of Westminster, 1931. Even then we still had to ask the British to change our constitution (it was a British law) until it was patriated in 1982. Arguably, then, our war of independence was World War I in which the Canadians fought as Canadians rather than as reinforcements for British formations and, after 1917, as an independent command in the Allied armies. Canada entered the war when Britain declared war on Germany, but signed the peace treaties separately from Britain and received its own seat in the League of Nations. During the 1920s the Liberal governments of Mackenzie King fought for recognition of the fact of Canadian independence that had been won in World War I. Canada asserted its independence during the Chanak Crisis of 1922 and by refusing to get the British government to co-sign the 1923 Halibut Treaty. As a result of the Balfour Report and the Imperial Conference of 1926, Canada and the other White Dominions gained the immediate right to establish our own foreign relations while negotiating our constitutional separation from the British government. Due to it's bankruptcy during the Great Depression, Newfoundland reverted to the status of Crown Colony by 1931 while Canada, Australia, New Zealand and South Africa gained independence. In terms of Canada, the crown became the Canadian Crown in 1931, a separate institution from the British Crown, although it is held by Charles III. Canada has still not changed the succession rules from strict male primogenitor. As a result, in Canada, Prince Louis superseded Princess Charlotte in the line of succession when he was born.
What about a video about Geronimo?
Would be awesome
I came across some lines from an old history of the Greek War of independece (1821-1830) that mention Canada. The historian wrote them to give an example regarding the policy of neutrality by a protectorate of Britain(*) towards the revolutionary cause: "It must be noted that the british-ionian government did not command the Greeks of the Heptanese not to take part in the hellenic struggle, but warned them that such behaviour would deprive them of its protection, thus considering them free to take any action, to their own responsibility. It (the government) also set the same healthy conditions which in the *latest rebellion of Canada against British rule* were kept invariably by the federal provinces of Northern America (?). During the rebellion a great number of citizens of the american provinces near Canada went to fight alongside those who took up arms against British rule, while their government declared itself neutral. Britain did complain, but the neutral gov. of America didn't act in any other way than to declare that if a citizen fighting for Canada was cought by the British, he would be deprived of its protection." I don't know what event he was referring to, but reading that was the reason why I watched your video.
* en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_of_the_Ionian_Islands
Remember, no Cs.
we all ways just called it the war of 1812. i've never heard it described as a war of indepence for us, always presented as the country coming together to resist foreign invaders.
As an American though the Canadians did do a great job in the war of 1812 i wouldn't necessarily call it a war of independence for Canada. Yes they alone where able to defend themselves without British aid Canada was still part of the British Empire and would continue to support the British for decades after they officially became a nation in 1867.
Canada became a Dominion in 1867 (a locally autonomous state with foreign affairs and defense controlled by London). The federation created in 1867 would later evolve into a sovereign state but one can't really talk about Canada having de facto sovereignty before 1931 (and the case is stronger after 1949 and self-evident by the Suez Crisis where Canada sides with the US rather than the UK). The repatriation of the constitution in 1982 was the final legal split although, in reality, Canada had been acting as a fully sovereign nation for decades and was already a fellow G7 member by then. 1982 was mostly about sorting out and modernizing the incredibly messy constitution that had evolved out of being a collection of colonies that gradually became independent.
Arguably, the process of Canadian independence was a slow 142 year long process from the Act of Union 1840 to the Canada Act 1982 (arguably going back to 1837 if you include the rebellions that led to the Act of Union and the granting of responsible government). 1867 gets held up as the country's "birthdate" because that's the birth of the modern federation we call Canada today. Canada as a place goes back to French colonial times (it was the name for the colony that geographically corresponds to modern Quebec - "canadiens" started as the ethnolinguistic term for the French colonial descendents from Canada (as opposed to "acadiens" from Acadia further east) and the meaning changed over time).
@@paranoidrodent I think Australia's constitution still includes New Zealand despite that being defacto independent.
@@news_internationale2035 I believe it still includes a clause that would allow New Zealand to join the country if it wishes. An open invitation, if you will. It doesn't change that they are distinct political entities. Like Canada, Australia was formed by the amalgamation of a number of neighbouring British colonies. New Zealand simply never opted in.
The American Articles of Confederation included a similar open invitation to Canada (basically modern day Quebec at the time) in article 11.
us: attacks uk
also us: calls it second war of independence
The uk really did provoke the war
Nothing wrong with getting independent-er.
Did you even watch the video?
@@compatriot852 of course I did
AND an Indian reservation was set up in the Ohio valley in 1763 and the denizens of the American colonies hated it. Once they got independence the Americans lost 5 armies trying to conquer the Ohio Valley and only won by inviting the Indian leaders to talk a peace treaty in Philadelphia while another army massacred the women and children in the valley.
Great video, just to point out that the iroquois term, although not quite incorrect, should not be used to reffer to the Haudenosaunee, as iroquois is a term created by the french colonist and does not revindicate the autonomy and origin of the Houdenosaunee people
At around 18:20 the video describes Laura Secord (which should be pronounced "Sea-cord") helping the British defeat the *British* at the Battle of Beaver Dams. She actually helped the British defeat the *Americans*.
Small correction, the Natives didn't defeat the "British" at the Battle of Beaver Damns, they defeated the Americans. Beaver Damns is a short distance from Niagara Falls. Only a few small plaques are on display in the area which is much disturbed by the building of the Welland Canal Systems over the centuries. Laura Ingalls Secord was of course commemorated with a Chocolate and Sweets franchise but did you know that her Ingalls ancestry means that she was a distant relation to the celebrated American character Laura Ingalls of "The Little House on the Prarie" fame?
Eeks a couple more gaffs where you have the Mohawks fighting AGAINST the British at Chateauguea, nope against Americans. It should also be noted that Americans ALSO had native allies, most notably the Delaware (Lene Lenape) and some Senecas serving mostly as guides and scouts. Many of the Iroquois sat this war out having been stung in the previous War of Independence. They viewed the war as White people killing White People, just stay off my lawn.
My stepmother, who lives in Niagara Falls, was driving one day and had to stop for a handful of soldiers crossing the road. They were American soldiers, in 1812 garb. True story. Niagara Falls and Niagara on the Lake are filled with history and battles... and ghosts...
"Saskatchewan is much like Texas...except it's more friendly to the United States!"....U.S. Statesman Adlai Stevenson
Not to mention that just prior to this the Royal Navy was officially at war with not just the French but with the International Slave Trade. Ships carrying slaves were allowed, by British Law, to be boarded, the ship seized and its crew pressed into service in the Royal Navy. I wonder if this could have angered the Americans?
20:17 - Hilbert you should have used the '3 Lions' of England here juxtaposed with fleur de lys - the cross looks tacky as fk
I like this mans thumbnails
I am still here waiting for the OAS video
It should be important to note that many french canadians at the time supported and preferred British rule over American. During 7 years war, there was wide spread circulation of anti french propaganda in the 13 colonies and there were calls to erase the French identity in Quebec by many prominent politicians in the 13 colonies. Many French Canadiens remembered this anti french sentiment during the American revolution and the war of 1812 and feared the loss of their french identity in the event of an American takeover. Furthermore, the British governor of Quebec at time actually took great lengths to protect the french inhabitants of Quebec, such recognizing language rights, continuing to practice french civil laws and even going as far to banning american settlement of region. Which would incidentally be a major of the american revolution.
That Canadian historian at 8:00 seems a bit biased...
I love that you mentioned the heroin Laura Secord! I’m Canadian and the elementary school I went to was named after her and the teachers told her story every year!
I honestly find the war of 1812 very interesting I reenact the time period although I find the story of us by cbc isn't the best a lot of Canadians did complain about the series
anti-Americanism equals culture in Ontario, this war has a lot to do with that.
Why was there less support in the areas now known as Canada to oppose the export and stamp taxes imposed unilaterally by the British Parliament to recoup expenses incurred in the French-Indian War?
The Canadians never burned down the American capitol
Sorry Canadians
British and Canadian (British colony) troops did!
@@freddiecawston2892 I'm 99% sure that the soldiers were regulars shipped from Britain.
If Canada wants to be independentd from the UK then guess what, you no longer get to claim you burned down the white house.
@@Swift-mr5zi haha I'm from the UK
@@freddiecawston2892 we are still part of the commonwealth. Our Monarch and head of state just so happens to have other crowns as well. The governer general rubber stanps what the legislative branch passes. Though right now the joke of a PM ( puppet of China) is ruling by dictact while Parliament is not in session due to the kommie koof ( or more accurate the unscientific reaction to it. The current danger is not DC or London or even Paris, its Beiijing.
@@Ozzy_2014
This last statement you made is V true. N. America should consider carefully that despite our large land mass, we DON'T really need to fill every single part of it with people.
Canada was a glorified fur trading post until the late 19th century.
@wulpurgis I am not wrong you know.
@wulpurgis :^)
as a Canadian, that is true.
The French DID NOT hand over all their colonies, St Pierre and Migalon still are French. There were no supporters of the American revolution in Canada. There were ZERO English speaking people in what is today Canada, and the French were given more4 rights under the British than they had had under the French, so the French were happy to have the British run things. One third of the people living in the 13 colonies left as refugees in 1784, and they form the English speaking Canadian majority.
Hilbret something is surly wrong you mentioned the dutch in this video & no dutch amthem thingy. what happened in this video. its so wierd for you not to do it. haha.
Les Habitants, Canadien wasn't used until after 1783, were treated much better by the English than they had been by the French. Some of them still spoke Breton, an language similar to Welsh.
The "Americans" were interested in stealing land and eliminating Catholicism, hardly something that those in Quebec would find appealing.
New Brunswick is a province, similar to South Holland being a province of The Netherlands.
New Brunswick and Nova Scotia were created from the French colony of Acadia.
Lower's quote is ironic considering slavery was outlawed in Upper Canada in 1793 and not until 1865 in the USA.
In Chateauguay, neither "u" is pronounced. (Shato gay)
The Wyandot, the losers of the Beaver Wars, have ended up on reservations in Kansas and Oklahoma.
Other videos:
ua-cam.com/video/_L-vL5NFkYA/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/CPqFcLTR2w8/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/UQyPXOHvwEc/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/wLa0mUWAiVk/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/kHJ3yDfTS8A/v-deo.html
Canada: The Story of Us Episode 3 | War of Independence (a production of the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation)
ua-cam.com/video/xTOB5Jmi0A4/v-deo.html
Canada has never lost a war also the Canadian rebels trying to gain independence from Britain in 1812-1813 (here is the complete list of wars Vietnam has lost) 1 Combatant 2 Result
Han-Nanyue War
(111 BCE)
Nanyue under Triệu dynasty Han Empire Defeat
First Chinese domination of Vietnam
Dominated (111 BC-905 AD)
Edit
First and Second Chinese Domination (111 BC - 544 AD)
Edit
Conflict Combatant 1 Combatant 2 Result
Trung sisters' rebellion
(40-43)
Trưng Sisters rebels in Lingnan Han Empire Rebellion defeated
Second Chinese domination of Vietnam
Jiaozhi revolts
(100, 136-144 AD)
Chamic revolt in Rinan, by 136 it had been spreading to Jiaozhi. Han dynasty Rebellion defeated
Jiuzhen revolt
(157 AD)
Chu Đạt rebels in Jiuzhen Han dynasty Rebellion defeated
Wuhu revolt
(178-181)
Liang Long rebels in Hepu and Jiaozhi Han dynasty Rebellion defeated
Independence of Champa
(192)
Khu Liên revolts in Xianglin (Hue), southern part of Rinan Han dynasty Rebellion success, creation of the first Cham kingdom of Lâm Ấp.
Lady Triệu Revolt
(248)
Lady Triệu rebels in Jiuzhen Wu Rebellion defeated
Lady Triệu Revolt was suppressed.
Jin-Wu war
(263-280)
Anti-Wu rebels in Jiaozhi, backed by Jin dynasty Wu Jin victory
Jin acquired possession of Northern Vietnam from Wu.
Jin-Lâm Ấp war
(399-431)
Jin dynasty Lâm Ấp Jin victory
Cham attacks were driven back with heavy tolls.
Liu Song-Lâm Ấp war
(445-446)
Liu Song dynasty Lâm Ấp Liu Song victory
Capital of Lâm Ấp, Kandarapura, was sacked by the Liu Song dynasty.
Lý Bí Revolt
(542-545)
Lý Bí rebels in Jiaozhi Liang Victory
Establishment of Vạn Xuân under Early Lý dynasty.
Early Lý Dynasty (545-602)
Edit
Conflict Early Lý Dynasty
and allies
Opponents Result
Sui-Van Xuan War
(545-602)
Vạn Xuân under Early Lý dynasty Sui Defeat
Third Chinese domination of Vietnam
Third Chinese Domination (602-905)
Edit
Conflict Combatant 1 Combatant 2 Result
Sui-Lâm Ấp war
(605)
Lâm Ấp Sui dynasty Sui victory
Chinese briefly established in Champa
Lý Tự Tiên rebellion
(679)
Lý Tự Tiên's Li rebels Tang dynasty Tang victory
Mai Thúc Loan Revolt
(722-23)
Mai Thúc Loan rebels in Annan Great Tang Tang victory
Chen Xingfan revolt
(726-28)
Chen Xingfan rebels in modern-day China-Vietnam borderlands Great Tang Tang victory
Javanese raids in Vietnam coast
(767, 774 & 787)
Javanese raiders Tang dynasty, Champa Tang victory
Phùng Hưng Revolt
(791)
Phùng Hưng rebels in Annan Great Tang Defeat
Tang-Nanzhao war
(846-866)
Nanzhao and local rebels in Northern Vietnam Great Tang Tang victory
Exhaustion for the Tang Empire
Most English speaking people in Canada were "late loyalists," economic migrants from the U.S. who were referred to as Americans and had no interest in the outcome of the war. After the war, they were disenfranchised and new immigration focused on veterans of the Napoleonic wars and Ulstermen, whose loyalty was assured. Veterans for example had pensions conditional on remaining loyal. Colonial officials then created the militia myth, that the colonials had defeated American attempts at annexation.
I miss the Dutch anthem, even tho i new it was coming id burst into laughter everytime .
New Brunswick is a province, not a town. I despise how the English and as a result Americans, et. al., refer to Great Britain as "England". Remember al those kilted redcoats? You KNOW they weren't "English", right?
@Rusty Shackleford I know about that town, but it isn't in Canada. I assumed he didn't mean a town in the U.S. although I could be wrong.
Canada is unique in the Western Hemisphere as we became an independent nation by revolution against a European colonial power but by defending our mother country. Many Canadian historians place the moment of independence at the Victory of Vimy Ridge where 4 divisions of the Canadian Army all volunteers take the hull from the Germans . This was after both the French and Briish armies failed to do so. From that day onward Canada formed it's own foreign policy it was not dictated by the Brits!
I was at a museum at a Federally owned Canadian park.
They very much referred to Canada as being run by the British before becoming a dominion.
why is it that some people say Idear ??? Insted of IdeA
Hilbert, at several points you talk of "the British" when you're actually referring to the Americans.
At 19:11 and 19:17 you say British when you (assumedly) intended to say Americans. Though, given that you're talking about French and Natives fighting together, the distinction was probably moot to them.
I'm surprised you mentioned the Dutch without... you know...
The video mentions that the Portuguese were among the first Europeans to see the land that would eventually become Canada, although they mostly focused on fishing in its waters rather than settling there. This may provide the true explanation of the name "Canada": While our government has advanced other theories about the origins of the name and would probably be too embarrassed to endorse this, I've had it confirmed by a native Portuguese-speaker that in Portuguese, "ca nada" means "nothing there". I assume that any Portuguese fishermen who went ashore in the area would have seen that there were no cities or signs of advanced civilization there, which would justify the "ca nada" description. They might even have been in areas that few or maybe no aboriginal settlements which would make the "ca nada" description even more appropriate.
Simple: no. They weren't fighting for independence from Great Britain, they were defending their lands from the Americans.
Thinking of the war of 1812 as being the Canadians 'fighting for the British' is naive to the modern meaning of the war. The French and Indians weren't pro-British, they simply were not American and cared enough about it to fight for it. The reason it's symbolically important is that was the key moment of distinction where the North American continent split into two countries and not one, there was the United States of America and then this 'other' peoples in the north from mainly two origins who would come together and fight for their shared goal. It is clearly an important war for the development of a unique Canadian identity and therefore I think the title of the war as a sort of 'war of independence is justified.
@@Swift-mr5zi Never said they were fighting for the British. I only mentioned Great Britain because they were their overlords(is that a good term?) at the time.
But yeah, I get what you're saying.
@@Swift-mr5zi ahem* 3 countries. Mexico exists.
@@Ozzy_2014
Mexicans hadn't take their independence yet
@@quidam_surprise neither had canada
Very well explined. I asum there are few records of the role the natives played, thought it waould be interestinf.
I hve read of n attrocity committed at York by US militias and think it diserves some investigation.
Is it really a war for independence if you’re fighting to stay a part of an empire?