Hi everyone, thanks for watching this video! If you have questions or comments you'd like me to see, please leave them on this comment so that I get notified. Cheers!
Seeing this made me look at your channel for videos I have not seen. Ended up seeing the video about your book and became a patron. I am reading the book now :D
I have a friend who for years has been living of passive income from PLC based control system videos he sells on Udemy. I am not in any position to give advice but I think you will find this interview with him interesting ua-cam.com/video/Rn6E_UehpJ8/v-deo.html
Thank you so much! I refer a small Junior level ECE course here because you do such a good job of explaining the effect of delays and how one can experimentally introduce delays to find delay margin... up until that point, the students have been given nice linear problems to evaluate... ;-)
and you can convert that time delay stability margin to phase margin with the rads it is oscillating. Helpful when you dont know the tf for the process. Gain margin can also be found with a gain block
Great video. Let's say there is a filler, this puts unstable volume bulk (approx 1.5% variation that oscillates in time vs targeted value) into box and takes its 12 cycles of machine to weight it. The problem is delay and how to correct box weight through change +/- of the filter capacity with that long delay. The system is trying to correct itself like in the car approaching corner example, is there any solution how to solve it to gain system stability around expected range?
im so dumb ill need to watch this whole series 15 times... i just wanted to flatten my temp and humidity curve in my environment controller, now im using matlab, reading scientific papers on pid algoritms, i wish i was hippie sometimes...
It's specifically a system that crosses the point of an open loop gain equal to -1, or more negative than -1, that makes a system go unstable. This turns negative feedback into positive feedback, which exacerbates the error instead of correcting the error. A negative phase margin means at the point where the gain crosses over unity, you have a phase that also has already crossed over a full reversal (i.e. 180 degrees), and this causes the transfer function to turn into -1 at the problematic frequency. Phase margin is how much phase delay you have remaining, before your system hits this point. So a negative phase margin, means you've already crossed the forbidden -1 value of your transfer function.
Time delay means it is a uniform number of seconds of delay, regardless of the frequency. Phase shift means the time delay is a function of the frequency, rather than a fixed constant. For instance, a phase delay of pi/4, means a phase shift of 1/8 of a period, regardless of the frequency, such that at 10 Hz this corresponds to 1/80 seconds, and at 100 Hz this corresponds to 1/800 seconds. Whereas a time delay of 10 ms, will be a time delay of 10 ms at every frequency.
Hi everyone, thanks for watching this video! If you have questions or comments you'd like me to see, please leave them on this comment so that I get notified. Cheers!
Seeing this made me look at your channel for videos I have not seen. Ended up seeing the video about your book and became a patron. I am reading the book now :D
Thanks! I hope you like what I have so far. I need to add more to the book ... I've been too busy with videos.
I have a friend who for years has been living of passive income from PLC based control system videos he sells on Udemy. I am not in any position to give advice but I think you will find this interview with him interesting ua-cam.com/video/Rn6E_UehpJ8/v-deo.html
I found the idea of getting a delay margin based on the simulation of the model very interesting, can you do something like that for the gain margin?
Thank you so much! I refer a small Junior level ECE course here because you do such a good job of explaining the effect of delays and how one can experimentally introduce delays to find delay margin... up until that point, the students have been given nice linear problems to evaluate... ;-)
The best possible way to explain concepts.. thanks for all amazing videos
Plus being a great lecture of control it's to me a symphony of concepts played in the ultimate harmonious level. 🎼🎵🎶🎵
and you can convert that time delay stability margin to phase margin with the rads it is oscillating. Helpful when you dont know the tf for the process. Gain margin can also be found with a gain block
thanks for ALL your videos! It is GREAT!
Great video. Let's say there is a filler, this puts unstable volume bulk (approx 1.5% variation that oscillates in time vs targeted value) into box and takes its 12 cycles of machine to weight it. The problem is delay and how to correct box weight through change +/- of the filter capacity with that long delay. The system is trying to correct itself like in the car approaching corner example, is there any solution how to solve it to gain system stability around expected range?
Brilliant Video!!!
Great video, I really liked that!
Awesome video, thank you.
Thank you sir!
Thanks!
Yes, an explanation of my futile attempts and instability of setting the temperature of my shower every morning! 🛁 🚿 💦 🥵 🥶 🥵 🥶 🥵 🥶 💀
Upload protocol related
3:12
im so dumb ill need to watch this whole series 15 times... i just wanted to flatten my temp and humidity curve in my environment controller, now im using matlab, reading scientific papers on pid algoritms, i wish i was hippie sometimes...
thank u so much
Why a negative phase margin means a system is unstable?
It's specifically a system that crosses the point of an open loop gain equal to -1, or more negative than -1, that makes a system go unstable. This turns negative feedback into positive feedback, which exacerbates the error instead of correcting the error.
A negative phase margin means at the point where the gain crosses over unity, you have a phase that also has already crossed over a full reversal (i.e. 180 degrees), and this causes the transfer function to turn into -1 at the problematic frequency. Phase margin is how much phase delay you have remaining, before your system hits this point. So a negative phase margin, means you've already crossed the forbidden -1 value of your transfer function.
Jewel
What is the difference between time delay and phase shift??
Time delay means it is a uniform number of seconds of delay, regardless of the frequency. Phase shift means the time delay is a function of the frequency, rather than a fixed constant. For instance, a phase delay of pi/4, means a phase shift of 1/8 of a period, regardless of the frequency, such that at 10 Hz this corresponds to 1/80 seconds, and at 100 Hz this corresponds to 1/800 seconds. Whereas a time delay of 10 ms, will be a time delay of 10 ms at every frequency.