Tbh this song is criminally underrated. It might not be as exciting or unique as Black Mamba or Next Level, and I know ballads aren't everyone's cup of tea, but their vocals on this track are really beautiful and the harmonies are really top tier.
1)This song showed that they all can sing 2) I hope the next comeback is going to be be a fast song where Giselle and Karina are rapping 🖤🐍 3) There debut Black Mamba was the best debut song of all kpop idols for me
Eu também fico triste de ver o tempo passando tão rápido, eu fiquei tão feliz de descobrir a existência delas, elas são tudo e mais um pouco, mas, uma coisa boa do tempo, é que ele provou que todos os haters delas estavam redondamente enganados e maioria se calou, foi muito difícil por muito tempo ser fã delas, era ódio gratuito por todos os lados
I cannot stop listening to this song and it’s such a different pace than what their peers are currently releasing that I’m surprised that I actually like this so much. BEAUTIFUL LADIES ❤️ old school or not I STAN
I kid you not, I was vacationing in Florida recently, and had downloaded this song onto my phone; decided to set it as my alarm one morning. Best decision I ever made! Seriously though, if you aren't listening to this and immediately find yourself calming down from a rough day, then you just don't have a heart; honest!
You should try out some more SM ballads. They are known as the ‘Ballad Company’, their ballads are the best. I recommend EXO’s ‘Universe’, it’s a classic.
The genre of this song is like the OSTs for old Kdramas. This song feels nostalgic, I don't know but listening to this song brings back my childhood memories of being innocent while watching old Kdramas, barbie movies, and old Asian romantic series with kind male leads that made me believe in prince charming and knight in shining armor. (which is I don't believe now AHAHHAHAA)
aespa nailed both Black Mamba and Forever. It makes me wonder what kind of music aespa will bring to us next. Definitely looking forward to it, especially for our rapper Giselle.
This isn't really aespa's first comeback, it's just continuing the tradition from SM, to re-record their old songs. so please wait for the next real 1st comeback from aespa, please give more love in the future, aespa will show the next level from black mamba :D
Wait which one is the rapper? By line distribution, I’m guessing the black haired, black skirt? All have great vocals in this song.. I’m an occasional listener (well, of their debut song) but have a soft spot for Ning Ning but besides her dunno who is who.
This song is like telling the relationship between member and ae-member who can't get together because of the black mamba and also the relationship between aespa and my who can't meet because of the covid-19. It is full of meaning that we will stay together forever. Let's be together forever. aespa and my Will be forever
This comeback is Winter focused as 'Black Mamba' was Karina focused. It's honestly great idea for a concept! Can't wait for Giselle's rap song and Ningning's, probably ballad, song!
1st time when i heard Aespa's Black Mamba, i shocked with Winter's pretty voice. And this time i got a goosebump by Karina and Giselle. So refreshing. And ofc Ningning our main vocal, i know her unique voice from the start. They're so talented ❤️❤️❤️❤️. I can't wait for their comeback
SM vocal never fail me. They aren't mere idols who belt shouty notes out or 'selling' vocal timbre. They definitely have the technique! Solid chest, smooth head, nice runs. Super proud orz
Help, now we know aespa can do anything. This is not just any song, it depicts the 90s so well and their gestures are so properly coordinated. It's a very unlikely song for their generation but here they are, pure slayage! Truly SM the master and plays this game too well. Speechless! Brilliant!
omg the person deleted their comment JAJSHSKSHSK go away unhappy person and don't use snsd to blame aespa (taeyeon posted a frame of forever on her insta story)
I can see that SME's goal with aespa isn't solely focused on creating or breaking records. SME is showcasing these girls' incredible musicality. I mean, no one saw this concept coming. It's fresh. A Christmas-y song in February? They are defying rules. SME is proud of these talents' vocals. Literally, all of them are vocalists. That part which they take turns in making ad libs and runs is just pure art! SME had always prioritized their artists' singing prowess. I love this music!
@@illegaluser69 I didn't say that. I have a comment that says how underrated this song is cuz of the low number of views it has and then someone else commented that æspa only uses autotune. I love and have always loved æspa!
It's hard to find these type of soothing ballads by 4th gen groups, but aespa is an exception for this!!!They can confidently sing any type of songs... What a VERSATILE QUEENS 🤧💗!!!
Firstly, got amazed with Winter's Voice Second, got amazed with Giselle's voice Third, got amazed with Karina's Voice Four, got amazed with Ningning's voice This is proof that all member AESPA are vocalist.
10M views nicely done MYs I mean it wasn’t our goal but this song isn’t a lot of people’s taste but this is a huge step for us. If we can get views on the ballads then imagine the mainstream songs
As a 90s generation, this kind of song is really my fave.it reminds me old vibes music and i love and live for this kind onf music. Their voice so strong also feels so calming. The one with big and beautiful eyes is my fave. Im army but this group really has talent and have unique vibes. Im sorry for my bad english 💜💜💜
@@gm6041 feels bad to be you then. Dont like it just click off. Ballad is a beautiful genre and we love this side of aespa. No time for disrespecting, gotta continue supporting the girls
This song is a remake of Yoo Young Jin's "Forever". It is not a cover nor their original . The remake ver is theirs but the song is Yoo Young Jin's and he himself rearranged the remake. This is a promotional single and the main cb will be after some time
@@hessaa1712 In popular music, a cover version, remake, cover song, revival, or simply cover, is a new performance or recording by someone other than the original artist or composer of a song. There isn't really a difference. People still call I will always love you by whitney houston a cover even though it sounds different from the original.
Maybe because most of MYs prefer strong concept, or maybe focusing more in str3aming comeback mv's, but one thing is for sure Forever will be the place where MYs will go if they need some comfort
Their vocal is no joke. Giselle proves that she was on the choir team, her voices nice to hear. Karina, how she rapp and singing has different color voices. And so stand out! Winter and Ningning, no comment, they are amazing!
black mamba: older sibling that paved the way for the rest of the family forever: forgotten middle child next level: younger sibling that got all the attention
We should try to make Forever to be a trend mainly this Christmas. Also, let's give more affection to this song and stream it on UA-cam, music platforms, and any streaming platforms. Let's share and spread it!
Karina's charismatic and elegant voice, Winter's sweet and pretty voice, Ningning's powerful voice and technique vocal, and Giselle's charming voice, makes me more fall in love with aespa.
*"SM may not be the greatest, but SM has the greatest"* Looks like AESPA is continuing the legacy as well! Such great vocalists! Im a Reveluv by the way :)
This actually sounds like an OST for some romantic drama. Ig it is a Valentine's day song. Aespa members are such aces I mean they are slaying everything they are doing.
Only in aespa we get visual with killer voice, rapper with killer voice, main dancer with killer voice. No other group have that. So conclusion stan aespa
No no no blackpink ladies are the queens of all these so dont say that sweety No doubt aespa is spectacular but but but blackpink is queen AND THAT IS THE FACT so yea But goodluck to aespa❤💋
Oh well of course this is up to you haha, red velvet has visual with killer voice too, please don't blind . You can be fanatic but don't think for yourself, i love aespa by the way . Don't get me wrong
Their visuals, their vocals, the MV, the outfits, everything is PERFECT
Aespa perfeck💙👍
@@crystalflorenciaparenda307 o
Tbh this song is criminally underrated. It might not be as exciting or unique as Black Mamba or Next Level, and I know ballads aren't everyone's cup of tea, but their vocals on this track are really beautiful and the harmonies are really top tier.
Yeah, this song is such a bop. Just because it's a ballad doesn't mean that, we have to ignore it...
Hii just wanted to ask if this was an actual comeback? sorry im not familiar as im not in the fandom 😅
@@arleneleow8540 yes, it is
it's like what happened to stay of Blackpink :(
@@shinecircle9801 yes, the ballad songs are not important to some fans…
1)This song showed that they all can sing
2) I hope the next comeback is going to be be a fast song where Giselle and Karina are rapping 🖤🐍
3) There debut Black Mamba was the best debut song of all kpop idols for me
yesss the expectation is very high for them
Aespa supermacy! excited for their next comeback! aespa fighting!
BLACK MAMBA: Dancing Skills
FOREVER: Vocal Skills
Next comeback: Rapping Skills
2nd comeback: Dance, Vocal, Rap Skills
SNSD Into the NEw World thgo was forever the best. These Girls look up to them.
ALL SM GROUP DEBUT SONGS ARE THE BEST.
But i believe in Into the New World and Replay Supremacy!💁🏻♀️
I miss aespa era as a rookie😢 Without realizing, you guys really grew up so fast. Keep chasing your dreams my dear aespa ❤❤❤❤
Eu também fico triste de ver o tempo passando tão rápido, eu fiquei tão feliz de descobrir a existência delas, elas são tudo e mais um pouco, mas, uma coisa boa do tempo, é que ele provou que todos os haters delas estavam redondamente enganados e maioria se calou, foi muito difícil por muito tempo ser fã delas, era ódio gratuito por todos os lados
omg me too, rookie aespa was SM fun 🥺
I cannot stop listening to this song and it’s such a different pace than what their peers are currently releasing that I’m surprised that I actually like this so much. BEAUTIFUL LADIES ❤️ old school or not I STAN
ME NEITHER❤❤😭
The only thing Christmasy about this is the snow. It fits Valentine’s Day better.
The VOCALS overshadowed everything. 🥰
This is boring btw
You forgot the literal Christmas trees and presents
whatever it fits with, they are so flexible with any of vibess!
@@offgun6466 lol they were so small and the vocals so great I forgot about them 🤣😂🤣😂
@@nupenda2183 true true SM vocalist be the best for anything
This song is so forgotten and it is criminally underrated
Yesss
That's what I'm saying. Like this is literally my favorite AESPA song.
Fr people sleep on ballad songs
@@anna-ci4ji ikr :c
@@Riyu0203 true and this is a masterpiece but people prefer to ignore this,MYs' are also not paying attention.This is a beautiful song
One thing i love for Aespa. All of them are singer. I really like their voice.
These girls are a miracle that fell into the hands of SM
😍🥰
Their vocals are so relaxing
I'm crying🤧😭
I kid you not, I was vacationing in Florida recently, and had downloaded this song onto my phone; decided to set it as my alarm one morning. Best decision I ever made!
Seriously though, if you aren't listening to this and immediately find yourself calming down from a rough day, then you just don't have a heart; honest!
Blackpink can't relate lol
.....
@@acrushwithjoy9553 Lol toxic "fans" like you are the real reason of fanwars💔
I can’t believe these girls are the ones who sang black mamba and next level
Yas..
Forever is so calming and Black Mamba and Next Level are energetic =D
But all songs are amazing!
@@shairinjannat6052 True
JYP be like:am I a joke to you
listen to twice and itzy of jyp!!
their vocals!!omma save me!
@@shairinjannat6052 so true
They sure have different genre already
진짜 항상 느끼는거지남 에스파는 무슨노래를 불러도 다 잘부르냐... 진짜 너무 사랑스럽다❤❤
DAMNNNN, those runs and vocalsss they be flexin' everything as a rookie monster
@@enhypenengene7381 tf go to your idol's channel. tf are doing here? trespasser.
@@enhypenengene7381 You're such a miserable clown🤡. 😂
Useless
@@shototodoroki4970 i'm sorry for that toxic engene.
@@chocolatecake7445 i'm sorry for that toxic engene.
Black Mamba - Fierce / Hot Vibes
Forever - Soft Vibes
Next comeback - Summer concept ?
2nd comeback - Creepy Comeback ?
3rs comeback - sad pop ?
@@06082-t i neeed creepy cb lol
@@gotthebeans319 woah 😭👍🏼
I mean they are SM artists, of course all of them can sing, not just the main and lead vocalist even the rapper and dancer too
@@enhypenengene7381 🤦♂
@@enhypenengene7381 wat a low life trolls you are
@@enhypenengene7381 what? fat?
Ikr like theyre ALL talented af
Oh yesss true because red velvet Irene is a rapper but she can still sing
2024년에 듣는 사람 나 밖에 없나..?
I love this song
Me ❤ 2024
I also listen❤
Listening now
❤
This song is proving that aespa can pull off any genre of music
Usually I don’t really like ballads, but this song stuck with me
Me too=))
SAMEE SIST
You should try out some more SM ballads. They are known as the ‘Ballad Company’, their ballads are the best. I recommend EXO’s ‘Universe’, it’s a classic.
Me too😍
@ThεWαlкεяs•2000 tahun yang lalu stop spamming
The genre of this song is like the OSTs for old Kdramas. This song feels nostalgic, I don't know but listening to this song brings back my childhood memories of being innocent while watching old Kdramas, barbie movies, and old Asian romantic series with kind male leads that made me believe in prince charming and knight in shining armor. (which is I don't believe now AHAHHAHAA)
I want them to release more songs like this.
@@foreveryoung213 AHHH YES I KNOW EXACTLY HOW YOU FEEL AND WHAT YOU MEANNNN
This song is remake. The original one is Yoo Young Jin - Forever
But I like both!
This song makes me cry
For me it feels more like those Christmas songs.
너희가 제일 맑고 너희나 계속 행복하고 내가 너희 옆에 있을게 천사같은아이들아 .. 너흰 내 첫눈이다 ☃️
Forever
Flower
This basically proves that Karina, Winter, Giselle and Ningning are now eligible to sing for OST's. Like did you hear that? WOW.
All of them no need to mention🎉🎉🎉
@@enhypenengene7381 If you have nothing nice to say then don't say anything at all
clearly you didn't come here to enjoy the song
@@enhypenengene7381 child
The iconic group
@@enhypenengene7381 Who are you to judge??
people really can't appreciate this kind of music that much? compare to their other songs ,this is my vibe.
I feel bad for people who doesn't appreciate this beautiful song :(
i'm born in 90's, i love this kind of music, sounds nostalic like early 2000's music, maybe nowadays kids can't enjoy music like this
Yass.. So true.. I think this song has same vibe like Tamia's son entitled Officially missing you"
@@simplyme2306 omg i just realized that 😳
@@RAINSUN_ cuz it is a 2000s song, This song is a remake
*Popular opinion: Everyone in aespa is a visual and talented*
*Stan Treasure too.🥺 Keep streaming don't sleep if you can? Let's reach more than 10 M can we?*
that’s truee
AESFLOP 💩💩💩💩💩💩💩
Copy Blackpink 🙈👎👎👎,.
SM IS KNOWN FOR THEIR VISUALLY ATTRACTIVE IDOLS
@@jisooya3077 lmao where ? just bc because aespa has 4 members doesn’t mean they are copying blackpink lmao
Best vocal
When black mamba releases, everyone is a main dancer and when Forever releases, everyone is a main vocal! No one can do it like Aespa!
@@kingmashiho6149 people can stan if they want, don't spam like that in other artist MV pleaseeeeeeeeee
EXACTLY!!
🥺
Aespa showed her dance in the first song, visual and vocal in the second song, then rap era will be in the next song so I hope so.
Omg ur name is spitting facts! Aespa best gg of the new generation wbk
we all wish to have a bside with kariselle rap
@@yerinhwaj3250 I just can't wait for the future to see Karina and Giselle have a part of just them rapping it'll be such a serve😭
aespa nailed both Black Mamba and Forever. It makes me wonder what kind of music aespa will bring to us next. Definitely looking forward to it, especially for our rapper Giselle.
Most certain of it :)
Really hoping for a rap song
This isn't really aespa's first comeback, it's just continuing the tradition from SM, to re-record their old songs. so please wait for the next real 1st comeback from aespa, please give more love in the future, aespa will show the next level from black mamba :D
Wait which one is the rapper? By line distribution, I’m guessing the black haired, black skirt? All have great vocals in this song..
I’m an occasional listener (well, of their debut song) but have a soft spot for Ning Ning but besides her dunno who is who.
@@zxczxctiga7487 do you know who is the original singer? Or group?
i dont get why people dont like this like this is a masterpiece
I feel like we haven’t seen songs like this (slower kinda throwback songs) as a single and this makes me happyyyyy
ua-cam.com/video/K1XDpus5Gek/v-deo.html
Like Exos....
@@poppingunicornshit7186 I haven’t been keeping up with exo lately but I like seeing this kind of music style!!
This song is like telling the relationship between member and ae-member who can't get together because of the black mamba and also the relationship between aespa and my who can't meet because of the covid-19. It is full of meaning that we will stay together forever.
Let's be together forever. aespa and my Will be forever
@UCtFPsSHQudoEbWEiBqiHcbg nope it’s actually you lol
@I LOVE ALL aesflop
@@armyoncesthebest7312 stfu loser
@@junhoes7547 your idol flop
this BLACK MAMBA girls are on the NEXT LEVEL and will be FOREVER in my heart
Love it! ❤️
nice
Ur PFP is familiar....
@@addictaedtokookie1622 go on
@@glennmcqueen655 I feel like I've read the manhwa before... But at the same time, the art style looks generic >< *still awesome tho * 😩💗💖💕💞💝💓🍓
This is beautiful.
The main rapper can really sing. Before forever came out. I love watching Giselle teaser cause pf her rap skills but my goodness she can sing
truly an ace
fun fact she joined the choir when she was in high school
Yeah SM thingzz
ua-cam.com/video/Bad6q6zr5GQ/v-deo.html
GISELLES VOCALS ARE SO UNDERRATED IM CRYING
Giselle's voice is like magic..If you listen clearly with headphone or any omg😭
FACTS
And Karina’s too Y lee sooman dont let them sing
This comeback is Winter focused as 'Black Mamba' was Karina focused. It's honestly great idea for a concept! Can't wait for Giselle's rap song and Ningning's, probably ballad, song!
@@girlsgenerationsone3501 stop spamming and get a life
@@girlsgenerationsone3501 u can mfing leave snsd didnt work their asses off to have fans like u
@@girlsgenerationsone3501 is this a comeback? I ain't updated sorry I got so much going in my school. Please respond if this is a comeback
@@girlsgenerationsone3501 It's not that deep. Go outside and smell some flowers, or maybe eat makeup so you can be pretty on the inside.
one of my favorite songs of aespa
Me too
me too!!!
Popular opinion: Aespa's rappers aren't just rappers, they're also great vocalist and iconic dancers
aespa's rapper has used to be a choir member lol she's an all-rounder
periodt.
ua-cam.com/video/u2ZeWPQk0zY/v-deo.html
Only Sm including aespa main rapper can sing like main vocal.
@@Lajririrkt Padus
NINGNING AND THE COMPUTER SHOULD JUST LIVE TOGETHER FOREVER
@@latasharma3244 there was a computer with her too in Black Mamba M/V
it's an aespa trademark hahahaha
Jajajsjjsjaj
Hhhhh
1st time when i heard Aespa's Black Mamba, i shocked with Winter's pretty voice. And this time i got a goosebump by Karina and Giselle. So refreshing.
And ofc Ningning our main vocal, i know her unique voice from the start.
They're so talented ❤️❤️❤️❤️. I can't wait for their comeback
*Giselle
ua-cam.com/video/kMX5H7xMqQY/v-deo.html😍
오랜만에 한번 들어봐요
진짜 추억이네요 데뷔한지가 어저께 같은데
I will always streaming this underrated and forgotten aespa song
Me too ♪♪
Same
SM vocal never fail me. They aren't mere idols who belt shouty notes out or 'selling' vocal timbre. They definitely have the technique! Solid chest, smooth head, nice runs. Super proud orz
while TWICE and itzy keeps winning
Wow...yess.. aespa vocal so outstanding
@@twiinkle2350 Lmao shut up hater. Stop hating every idol you moron. You even hate aespa. Do something in your life.
Most hit group of sm 😌
@@vc5831 ??
Help, now we know aespa can do anything. This is not just any song, it depicts the 90s so well and their gestures are so properly coordinated. It's a very unlikely song for their generation but here they are, pure slayage! Truly SM the master and plays this game too well. Speechless! Brilliant!
Yess 4aces
이제 곧 2024년이야 ,, 🥺🥹
Black Mamba 👺🐍👿
Forever 🌺⭐🌈
Next level 💎❤️🛸
They all are visual and vocal. No one can't sing. Amazed with karina too cause she is rapper
Do you mean Giselle? She's the rapper of the group
I guess karina was primarily trained to sing
Remember she is a rapper BUT from SM ;)
@@NelleBear But Karina is a rapper too
this is one of the few ballads that I don't find boring, these girls can adapt to every concept can't wait for their album
Winter's vocals took me to sky. This song fit her alot
OMG ...GISELLE PROOF US THAT HIS VOCAL ARE NOT PLAYING WITH US
*her
*her
ua-cam.com/video/jew7q9eD4RU/v-deo.html
Giselle is a dude? 😯
*her
I think we all can agree that this remake exceeded everyone’ expectation. What 𝑎𝑒𝑠𝑝𝑎 gives us is beyond our imagination.
@@girlsgenerationsone3501 are u fine bro?
omg the person deleted their comment JAJSHSKSHSK go away unhappy person and don't use snsd to blame aespa (taeyeon posted a frame of forever on her insta story)
I can see that SME's goal with aespa isn't solely focused on creating or breaking records. SME is showcasing these girls' incredible musicality. I mean, no one saw this concept coming. It's fresh. A Christmas-y song in February? They are defying rules. SME is proud of these talents' vocals. Literally, all of them are vocalists. That part which they take turns in making ad libs and runs is just pure art! SME had always prioritized their artists' singing prowess. I love this music!
Make this comment popular! ❣️
aespa flop
aespa copy itzy
@@exol607 thanks for the views. keep watching
@@exol607 y'all are so dramatic 😭 it's just music it's meant to be enjoyed eye---
Forever is literally so angelic and heavenly 😇 mesmerizing✨ can they release more songs like this?😭
I saw your comment saying they only use auto-tune and they can't sing. Did you now become a fan?
@@illegaluser69 I didn't say that. I have a comment that says how underrated this song is cuz of the low number of views it has and then someone else commented that æspa only uses autotune. I love and have always loved æspa!
I don't care if Christmas was 2 months ago, this song is still beautiful
@@JasmineFlorianna @*
im sorry i'm not anything catholic
Gisselle's perfect vocals even when she's the main rapper ????? Aespa vocal line = all the members
Well, they're an SM group.
It's hard to find these type of soothing ballads by 4th gen groups, but aespa is an exception for this!!!They can confidently sing any type of songs... What a VERSATILE QUEENS 🤧💗!!!
.....
This song so sweet
Firstly, got amazed with Winter's Voice
Second, got amazed with Giselle's voice
Third, got amazed with Karina's Voice
Four, got amazed with Ningning's voice
This is proof that all member AESPA are vocalist.
Imagine if we managed to get this to 100M😳 a ballad and remake song hitting 100M vi3ws! Let’s get it My’s!
Let's get it! Slowly but surely
Yep let's go for our girls♥️
10 months later and we’re struggling to hit 50 million 😭
🥬 Black Mamba - 211.7 Million
🥬 Forever - 48.2 Million
🥬 Next Level - 214 Million
🥬 Savage - 178.1 Million
🥬 Dreams come true - 66.5 Million
…….
Black Mamba - 218M
Forever - 48.7M
Next Level - 224M
Savage - 191M
Dream Come True - 75M
BLACK MAMBA -221,M
FOREVER- 48,9M
NEXT Level -227,4M
SAVAGE -194,9M
DREAMs Come True -77,6M
Black Mamba - 221m
Forever - 49m
Next Level - 228m
Savage - 196m
Dreams Come True - 78m
Pls the cabbages-
So comforting.
여러분 이 노래는 sm 막내 아이돌이 오랜 고전 슴덕들을 위한 선물로 준 번외곡 같은 겁니다. (유영진 forever 리메이크) ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
ㄹㅇㅋㅋㅋ이건듯
@@myway2506 이건듯 이 아니라 애초에 이게 맞음ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
그걸 완벽하게 소화한 갓스파
10M views nicely done MYs I mean it wasn’t our goal but this song isn’t a lot of people’s taste but this is a huge step for us. If we can get views on the ballads then imagine the mainstream songs
Nah it sucks i get it why this isnt alot of people tastes
@@gm6041 stay pressed 🤮
ua-cam.com/video/MnPaDBbDQf8/v-deo.html
As a 90s generation, this kind of song is really my fave.it reminds me old vibes music and i love and live for this kind onf music. Their voice so strong also feels so calming. The one with big and beautiful eyes is my fave. Im army but this group really has talent and have unique vibes. Im sorry for my bad english 💜💜💜
@@gm6041 feels bad to be you then. Dont like it just click off. Ballad is a beautiful genre and we love this side of aespa. No time for disrespecting, gotta continue supporting the girls
They're all literally all rounders.
Singing bops like Black mamba and then calming music like Forever
but still dont have albums 😢
They’re copying blackpink marketing
First they will release single like blackpink did and when they’re hyped up sm will release a album like blackpink did
ua-cam.com/video/IN0mJJx6SbI/v-deo.html who is your aespa bias?
@@laurence9825 such a waste like that
no way aespa has this vibe of songs😭
Cantik Banget Asli ♡
+ Kualitas vocal Yang gk perlu di perdebatkan
Iyalah..artis SM, bagus vocalnya
Setujuuu
10M - Complete
20M - Complete
30M - Complete
40M - Complete
50M - Complete
60M - Soon
aespa is FOREVER in MY's heart
Yes FIGHTING
FIGHTING!!!
Fighting!!! ♡♡
Fighting!!!
FIGHTING✊💥💫
Aespa's vocals are no joke.
Winter - angelic voice
Giselle - soothing voice
Karina - calming voice
Ningning - 4th gen main vocal
AESPA FOREVER!!!
Yup. I'm a YG Stan and this is my First Group outside YG. Stan Aespa and Treasure as they have amazing vocalist
@@exol607 WTF
AGREE 100%
@dlssmss wiesd trying to setup BP again ?Okay
Gisel indo
ほんとに好きな曲✨いつかはLIVEで聴きたいな❣️
Giselle slapping those haters why she passed the hardest SM auditions..Main Rapper Giselle did that
This song is a remake of Yoo Young Jin's "Forever". It is not a cover nor their original . The remake ver is theirs but the song is Yoo Young Jin's and he himself rearranged the remake. This is a promotional single and the main cb will be after some time
a remake is a cover...
@@amare1367 A remake and cover is different. These two are so similar but not equal
@@amare1367 cover more it sound exactly like original.. But this have different type of music and rhythm
@@hessaa1712 In popular music, a cover version, remake, cover song, revival, or simply cover, is a new performance or recording by someone other than the original artist or composer of a song. There isn't really a difference. People still call I will always love you by whitney houston a cover even though it sounds different from the original.
Maybe it's a remake, not a cover because the original singer/writer rearranged the rhythm themselves? I guess
This song like the Christmas song and the concept too.
Feels like they wanted to release it on december but for some reason it got delayed.
this song is sooooooo underrated that hurts!!!!! this shows how every member of aespa can sing osts!!!
This is something the old SM would do. Not beeing affraid to release mv for ballads like not searching far SNSD's Time Machine.
it's the trademark for me, that's why i like sm and yg groups
Same for Red Velvet!
IT SEEMS LIKE THEY ARE ALL VISUAL AND VOCALIST !!
Talent and hardwork :) they’re also amazing at dance and have two very skilled rappers :D
They were
aespa ace group wbk
aespa all rounders 😔🤚
Hwang-yeji cute I love your band is incrible,love you,kisses.
Ok but this song should has been released during Christmas period cos this song gives me so much Christmas vibe in it
It's a winter song, not a Christmas song though
you guys will get used to it you're sm stan.
It's still Winter season and it's a "Winter" season vibe. Not Christmas.
Lol same, but i'm relating it to Valentines day
It's still christmas in kwangya
Now this is real music.
Forever is almost a year old, idk why it doesn't get the recognition it deserves. This song helps me relax and cheer up sm
Maybe because most of MYs prefer strong concept, or maybe focusing more in str3aming comeback mv's, but one thing is for sure Forever will be the place where MYs will go if they need some comfort
@@RIIZEaeH7N yes
deserves 50m!
it will be a year old on my birthday
ua-cam.com/video/wzuoe2SgQcc/v-deo.html
Their vocal is no joke.
Giselle proves that she was on the choir team, her voices nice to hear.
Karina, how she rapp and singing has different color voices. And so stand out!
Winter and Ningning, no comment, they are amazing!
black mamba: older sibling that paved the way for the rest of the family
forever: forgotten middle child
next level: younger sibling that got all the attention
Lmao this is so true
okay but why this soooo accurate im crying
IM GOING TO CRY
Lmao yes but
I'm crying T^T
This needs more attention.....
This is so accurate HAHHAHAHHA
she's not only powerful,
We should try to make Forever to be a trend mainly this Christmas. Also, let's give more affection to this song and stream it on UA-cam, music platforms, and any streaming platforms. Let's share and spread it!
Agreed! This song is just plain comfy. I even used it in one of my UA-cam videos.
Yesss
I'm with you
Let's make this 20M before their first actual comeback (It's rumored to be on march/april). Continue streaming MYs and be safe!!
Let’s reach 20M before February ends🙌
@@burgerandmilk7133 yes!! Aespaitinggg
It's probably april or may
@@ajreyes1262 i agree
@@-ningning2340
., 0.
.
. , ,
.. . ..
.
..
,
, ,
, .
. 0
,
. ..0 00 . 0 00. 0
,
Karina's charismatic and elegant voice, Winter's sweet and pretty voice, Ningning's powerful voice and technique vocal, and Giselle's charming voice, makes me more fall in love with aespa.
ua-cam.com/video/GQLyHKeUshs/v-deo.html
😖😖😖
ua-cam.com/video/BN2rQ7oXw10/v-deo.html
bcs Treasure Flop and Aespa soon Hahahahaha
we all are
@@bighitnewgirlgroup7164 need food dogs, i give u a bones
they've grown so much ahhhhh can't wait for the full album
aespa’s 1st full album Armageddon releases May 27th!
STAN EVERGLOW!!
I post Aespa edits and Other Kpop pls help me reach 2k.
Copying BLΛƆKPIИK💗🐷🐷🐽🐽🐽🙈🙈🙈👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎
@@channelfordreamies5289 mal
@@channelfordreamies5289 no copy
@@channelfordreamies5289 so why you here? No place for you
NINIGNING LIKE AN ANGEL AND ANGEL'S VOICE
KARINA LIKE A BARBIE
WINTER LIKE AN DISNEY PRINCESS
GISELLE LIKE AN GODDESS 👸👸👸👸
I like how SM is not just following trends and is giving them songs to showcase their talents
4 Vocalist
4 Rapper
4 Dancer
4 Visual
*"SM may not be the greatest, but SM has the greatest"*
Looks like AESPA is continuing the legacy as well! Such great vocalists!
Im a Reveluv by the way :)
@@twiinkle2350 you pressed that Aespa can sing?
@@twiinkle2350 Idc baby
@@twiinkle2350 Ur so obsessed with aespa. Just admit that you are a fan already
YES
As a sone, reveluv, meU and MY i can definitely agree
Black mamba is Forever on the Next level for being a SAVAGE.
creative comment👌
Wow!
Wow!!
Damn true!!!
Wow it was so creative!👌
black mamba era girls: hrr 😈🖤
forever era girls: meow 🥺😽
Kinda curious next level era
👉 ua-cam.com/video/Bad6q6zr5GQ/v-deo.html
@@beatlesisthebiggestboyband2881 stop
Curious 🥺🤪🤪
whos here after whiplash? 🤚
It's so rare to find a group where each member can actually sing. I'm freakin happy SM created Aespa!
Sm might not be the best but
They have the best artists
yeah man it's kind of shocking to see that for almost all groups at least 1 or 2 members can't sing... that's what makes aespa so special
I'm sorry, but there are kpop groups like that already
@@mj3000x yeah but op said it's so "rare", not that they've never seen one
More like a group whose members can support their vocals. Other groups all members can sing but can't support.
This actually sounds like an OST for some romantic drama. Ig it is a Valentine's day song. Aespa members are such aces I mean they are slaying everything they are doing.
Only in aespa we get visual with killer voice, rapper with killer voice, main dancer with killer voice. No other group have that. So conclusion stan aespa
ouh im worring in case haters will against u cause the fact that u mentioned lolz
ua-cam.com/video/kMX5H7xMqQY/v-deo.html😍
No no no blackpink ladies are the queens of all these so dont say that sweety
No doubt aespa is spectacular but but but blackpink is queen
AND THAT IS THE FACT
so yea
But goodluck to aespa❤💋
@@nupenda2183 yup here I am but I dont hate aespa or the commenter just some corrections they need to fit in their stats that's it😊
Oh well of course this is up to you haha, red velvet has visual with killer voice too, please don't blind . You can be fanatic but don't think for yourself, i love aespa by the way . Don't get me wrong
aespa
Karina
Giselle
Winter
Ningning
💙🌙⭐️🦋
They only have 4 members, but I can't even choose a bias.
Same
ua-cam.com/video/jew7q9eD4RU/v-deo.html
me too :")
same
Same here
I want Ning Ning highnote and Giselle rap on the next 1st comeback
69 uwu
SM always give the best on their artist 1st comeback, so im sure it gonna be a lit song just like RV-ice cream cake
yazzzzz
Let's see
Yess lets have our duo rapper in the first comebck, plisss
This is the proof that every member can be a Main Vocalist.
no
Itzy better
AESFLOP 💩💩💩💩💩💩💩
Copy Blackpink 🙈👎👎👎
@@jisooya3077 troll ignore this.
@@jisooya3077 and bp copy 2ne1
The entire bridge is so heavenly 😭