चकमा जनजाति विवाद Chakma Tribe controversy in Arunachal Pradesh Tripura Assam Mizoram & Bangladesh

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 2,2 тис.

  • @mrpatgiri1322
    @mrpatgiri1322 3 роки тому +74

    I have lots of chakma friends from Assam n they are very friendly ❤️😊.. I love them 🥀❤️

  • @sanamlaxar916
    @sanamlaxar916 3 роки тому +13

    I belong to the Chakma tribe but still even though I don't have much knowledge about the history of Chakma and even we most of the Chakmas still don't know our alphabet yet because we still don't have our permanent land so. Now we Chakmas living in India for many years but sometimes we feel like we Chakmas living here temporarily because of the poor situation and everyone against us and despise us. I wish one day we will be own our land and make feel proud India as an India......we love India 🇮🇳, by the way, thanking you for sharing this video and encouraging us......Honestly, we Buddhist Chakmas appreciate you faithfully♥🙏👍

  • @bojummosing9247
    @bojummosing9247 6 років тому +434

    Tripura is best example for all the NE states where the ST has been out populated by the outsider n now they can't even protest in there own state.

  • @islamapologist5756
    @islamapologist5756 7 років тому +61

    I have chakma friend .....He is one of our favorite student in our class

    • @tumbihurohotteyjaa6199
      @tumbihurohotteyjaa6199 3 роки тому +15

      Thank you for sweet compliment towards our people ❤️

    • @suman64emo
      @suman64emo 3 роки тому +5

      oh i hav too, and he is my best frnd 😁

  • @yahatabia8865
    @yahatabia8865 6 років тому +72

    Never been so cleared with the chakma case until Now.. thank you Dr. garg..
    Praying for godspeed well being of all the chakmas 🌸

    • @walkwithmisuk
      @walkwithmisuk 3 роки тому +5

      I'm also a Chakma from Khagrachari,CHT Bangladrsh..And Chakmas came from Burma...we are mongolian and tibetan -burmese in origin

    • @mongoloidgypsy3025
      @mongoloidgypsy3025 3 роки тому +4

      Chakma take opportunity and very communial

    • @tousefahmed3987
      @tousefahmed3987 3 роки тому +1

      @@mongoloidgypsy3025 learn to because human first before throwing the mud on others.

    • @shahjadatalukder2706
      @shahjadatalukder2706 3 роки тому

      @@walkwithmisuk chittagong atleast hill tracts wasn't apart of bengal
      Cht is the closest to burma
      So some mixing obvious took place but u guys are indegenious to cht and by extension Bangladesh as much as a bengali

    • @walkwithmisuk
      @walkwithmisuk 3 роки тому

      @@shahjadatalukder2706 It's indeed true that CHT never was a part of Bengal nor anything related to Bengal and it's people. Due to the Brithish rule and Pakistan-Bangladesh annexation we got stuck here. Before the British rule this CHT used to be a part of Arakan. We also had our own independent kingdom. But in today's world it has become a history only.

  • @deeppatel9740
    @deeppatel9740 7 років тому +290

    wrost situation for Arunachal Pradesh and all seven sisters and chakmas. i think chakma should be shifted in developed state like Gujarat ,MH

    • @kimikimey4125
      @kimikimey4125 7 років тому +48

      Deep Patel.. thank you for understanding the situation of our Arunachali people. We don't want to share our lands with chakmas.

    • @jibokomiuli9800
      @jibokomiuli9800 7 років тому +10

      will you accept rohingya..?

    • @deeppatel9740
      @deeppatel9740 7 років тому +17

      Jeremy Miuli never bro

    • @ChitranjanKumar12345
      @ChitranjanKumar12345 6 років тому +21

      Kimi Kimey you should accept chakma as they look same like you people and follow Buddhism and hinduism

    • @shivamize7975
      @shivamize7975 6 років тому +75

      Chitranjan Kumar kushwaha. accept Pakistani and bagladeshi 2 they r also look simillar to u people.

  • @Romelchak
    @Romelchak 7 років тому +104

    Dear Gaurab garg.. thank you for the wonderful video .. i am sure many people will be benefitted from this video. I personally feel its a noble approach, please keep doing the same.
    Having said that i want to add few points, i am sure you have done intensive research to present the facts but there are few points i want to offer clarity or the truth.
    Yes many chakmas fled to india during the mentioned years but not all chakmas in india are from then east pakistan. There were good numbers of chakmas already present in mizoram, assam and tripura even during 1947( when india got independence)....
    Also when chakmas fled to india..along with them many mizos and mog fled to mizoram.
    Many mizos who were part of myanmar came to mizoram but history choose not to mention that because culturally they were same with the major population in mizoram.
    The CHT shares boundaries with mizoram and tripura and when officially boundaries were defined after india's independence some CHT part fell in tripura and mizoram.
    Research papers and articles about chakmas were manipulated badly ..i am sharing the truth which was not highlighted by many writers..
    You got good followers and i want them to know the hidden truth ...
    Please dont get me wrong ....soon i will share a video about chakma community and will mark you personally because you do good for students-knowledge sharing..
    Important point: when India got independence many chakma people hoisted india flag because CHT people wanted to be part of india .. but 🇧🇩 bangladesh (then east pakistan) army attacked the chakmas. CHT was princely state and governed by chakma kings. Many princely state like tripura, sikkim etc voluntarily joined india but the chakmas faith has been the worst. Even today many chakmas are there in myanmar but these numbers are not the reason of kaptai DAM. They were part of myanmar since 500 years ..
    And about demanding for union territory for the chakmas (the chakma land) needs to be reelooked.

    • @megamind6000
      @megamind6000 6 років тому +13

      Romel Chakma
      I totally agree with you brother. Chakmas are a persecuted ethnic group and should get their rights.

    • @peterdebbarma940
      @peterdebbarma940 6 років тому +5

      even chakmas are refugees and intruders,immigrants from Bangladesh

    • @Ps-ce2lh
      @Ps-ce2lh 6 років тому +15

      But please dont keep eyeing arunachal coz u never belonged there in d first place... u were given shelter during hard times n u repay AP by demanding more....u r given indian citizenship so y dont u settle somewhere else in india where u are allowed to... as responsible citizens please vacate AP or if u want to stay amicably please stay just like other non arunachalis staying peacefully among d locals without demanding for land rights n rights that d locals are protected with in their own lands

    • @doga5768
      @doga5768 6 років тому +3

      @@Ps-ce2lh well said, point to be noted.

    • @xtalks1207
      @xtalks1207 5 років тому +1

      @@Ps-ce2lh who are u ha to help ha did u make Arunachal

  • @sothakp
    @sothakp 7 років тому +225

    Chakma's, Get up, Stand up, and fight for your right, take your land and religion back from the invaders.

    • @rickbo88
      @rickbo88 7 років тому +32

      Prem Thakoer yes in cht Bangladesh

    • @kimikimey4125
      @kimikimey4125 7 років тому +43

      Prem Thakoer.. yes they should fight for their lands in Chittagong hills.

    • @shalusaini2134
      @shalusaini2134 7 років тому +5

      Prem Thakoer yai kam to une bhut phale he start ker dena chaiya tha

    • @mr.random369
      @mr.random369 6 років тому +28

      Chittagong was land of Tripura..Later chakma came from burma after defeating by Arakan kingdom of burma..Because of chakma peoples Chiittagong became there place..that's ok..now they want more land in north east area..Chakma community doesn't deserve north est..

    • @ashishverma7435
      @ashishverma7435 6 років тому +9

      Shi kha inko apne adhikaro ke liye ladna chahiye chitagong bangladesh me na ki india me... India me inka koi adhikar nhi h

  • @85anuswami
    @85anuswami 4 роки тому +23

    You have explained the plight of Chakma tribals right from their Origin in a very clear manner, Thanks

  • @uzochiokeke4328
    @uzochiokeke4328 5 років тому +84

    Bangladesh is doing to the CHT exactly what west pakistan did to bangladesh in 1971. Such hypocrisy.

    • @anamulhaqueshaun3286
      @anamulhaqueshaun3286 4 роки тому +2

      Don’t compare my country with Pakistan. We did nothing with tribal peoples.

    • @rt9637
      @rt9637 4 роки тому +5

      @@anamulhaqueshaun3286 lol.

    • @anamulhaqueshaun3286
      @anamulhaqueshaun3286 4 роки тому +1

      @@rt9637 bloody bastard

    • @rt9637
      @rt9637 3 роки тому +8

      @@anamulhaqueshaun3286 pussy cat, hide as much as you want, we are going to make another Bangladesh out of Bangladesh.

    • @anamulhaqueshaun3286
      @anamulhaqueshaun3286 3 роки тому

      @@rt9637 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣bloody bastard,,

  • @pushpraj1810
    @pushpraj1810 6 років тому +16

    We should give space to Chakmas too. Treat them with brotherhood

  • @sashilemla6229
    @sashilemla6229 6 років тому +26

    India should have tried to work towards settling the chakmas in their own areas in Bangladesh...we hv bn so large hearted to accept all refugees that later on, it causes untold miseries

  • @deepaknautiyal528
    @deepaknautiyal528 7 років тому +487

    मुस्लिम बहुल इलाकों का पूरी दुनिया में यही हाल है, ये लोग दूसरे धर्म की इज़्ज़त करना ही नही जानते।
    #कटु सत्य।

    • @shubhamchaurasiya4520
      @shubhamchaurasiya4520 7 років тому +8

      shi bola yrr...

    • @bastarchattisgarh9967
      @bastarchattisgarh9967 7 років тому +7

      और आपके आरएसएस और बीजेपी के गुंडे किनसे कम हैं, बलातकारी बाबा, डोंगी बाबा, फर्जी देशभक्त

    • @deepaknautiyal528
      @deepaknautiyal528 7 років тому +48

      Bastar Chattisgarh जो गलत हो गया उसे BJP से जोड़ दो, और भाई सुन, मैं कोई कार्यकर्ता नही हूँ, सच बोल रहा हूं जो दुनिया मे हो रहा है, जहाँ भी मुस्लिम की आबादी बढ़ जाती है वहाँ दंगे फसाद भी बढ़ जाते हैं।

    • @deepaknautiyal528
      @deepaknautiyal528 7 років тому +27

      Bastar Chattisgarh जहाँ आज 50 से ज्यादा इस्लामिक देश हैं, पहले कोई और धर्म के देश हुआ करते थे।
      क्यों और कैसे हुआ उनका इस्लामीकरण ये किसी से नही छिपा है।

    • @shivarockful
      @shivarockful 7 років тому +17

      Bastar Chattisgarh har bat ko bjp se jodane pr wo bt sahi ni hojayegi muslim puri world k liye khatra h

  • @wamanchena9846
    @wamanchena9846 5 років тому +54

    26:50 Modi government Please don't repeat Nehru's mistake AGAIN

  • @gautammane369
    @gautammane369 3 роки тому +13

    Very sad history of Chakmas. 😢
    But India should protect the interests of week minorities.

  • @iriliral6366
    @iriliral6366 3 роки тому +13

    India should have taken that CHT during partition and chakmas could stay peacefully there any entire NE could be connected by ship from Calcutta.Nehru was really an idiot😡

  • @chakmaprii
    @chakmaprii 3 роки тому +18

    Thank you for this ❤️ I actually didn't know much About my own tribe And now I am clear about it.
    Btw I am a Proud Indian 🇮🇳

  • @rajarohit9370
    @rajarohit9370 7 років тому +74

    सर् आप वो काम कर रहे हैं जो हमारी मीडिया ने नहीं किया।

  • @shamkarade3037
    @shamkarade3037 5 років тому +6

    डॉ गौरव गर्ग अपने बहुत अच्छी तरह से समझाया, ये जानकारी हर भारतीय के लिए जानना जरूरी है। बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद सर।।

  • @opinion_poll
    @opinion_poll 5 років тому +50

    We don't know ground level situation, but we should protect our people first then other

  • @gentlemenking2973
    @gentlemenking2973 6 років тому +25

    I appreciate your research on chakma .
    Sad 😢 killing of peoples and tribes in the name of religion caste origin. World is changing

  • @zachscombat
    @zachscombat 5 років тому +70

    Bengalis has taken over the kingdom of Chakmas...

    • @iamchirantan2183
      @iamchirantan2183 4 роки тому +7

      Chakmas have relationship with burmese

    • @walkwithmisuk
      @walkwithmisuk 3 роки тому +19

      I'm also a Chakma from Khagrachari,CHT Bangladrsh..And Chakmas came from Burma...we are mongolian and tibetan -burmese in origin

    • @aayushkumaryadav8445
      @aayushkumaryadav8445 3 роки тому +7

      @@walkwithmisuk are you want to CHT merge with India?

    • @saifsaifu4455
      @saifsaifu4455 3 роки тому +1

      assam, tripura, kalkata, mageloya,muzuram bangali ka heyn

    • @Debasish33
      @Debasish33 3 роки тому +1

      @@walkwithmisuk mui yu Chakma bhai tripura india🥺🥺

  • @vickykumarsharma3115
    @vickykumarsharma3115 5 років тому +8

    @Chakmas we love you, brothers and sisters. Please for God sake India and Bangaladesh government must resolve these issues for Chakmas.

    • @vickykumarsharma3115
      @vickykumarsharma3115 5 років тому +1

      I really don't understand why this CHT Accord is not being implemented. After all, it is the land of Chakmas, plz Bangladeshi friends have a concern about @Chakmas

    • @anonymoussssss201
      @anonymoussssss201 3 роки тому +1

      Thank u brother agar Bangladesh accord ko implement nahi karega tab oh din dur nahi ki sabi chakma hatiyar utayenge abni matra bhumi ke liye aur sahid honge

    • @anonymoussssss201
      @anonymoussssss201 3 роки тому +1

      Jahe 2 lakh ki Bangladesh force ho

  • @ashik121
    @ashik121 5 років тому +92

    Bangladesh ne Chakma community ke saath bohot bura Kiya😢😢. This Bangladesh and Pakistan should be destroyed fully😠😠

    • @Pungsung931
      @Pungsung931 5 років тому +4

      support us bro

    • @kwthardebbarma3806
      @kwthardebbarma3806 3 роки тому +4

      get lost bangladesi supporter chakmas

    • @kirsumbomjen9866
      @kirsumbomjen9866 3 роки тому +2

      Asaa kiya h bol k abi arunachal pradesh meaa aakr distrb krnah kya??? Jo b hoo apna jaga waps chala jana h na...

    • @kirsumbomjen9866
      @kirsumbomjen9866 3 роки тому +3

      @Bappo Chakma yes you loss and you don't have any right to Distrb Arunachal

    • @amranrahman2320
      @amranrahman2320 3 роки тому

      😁

  • @miltonchakma9651
    @miltonchakma9651 4 роки тому +5

    I am also a member of Chakma community. My home is in Bangladesh. I can understand Hindi language. The history of the hilly region of Bangladesh is a very painful history. In 1986, I was just one year old. Then, with the help of the Bangladesh Army, the Bengali Muslims hacked to death hundreds of Jummas. Killed my mother, grandmother, and cousin from my family. I was so young that I can't remember my mother's face. Then we took refuge in the Indian state of Tripura. I thank the Government of India for this.

  • @sachink4499
    @sachink4499 6 років тому +9

    A ready Reckoner, a Short Summary, an awesomely explained & interesting guiding video about the Chakmas...
    From today, I'm ur fan Dr. Saab....😀🙌

  • @akg2282
    @akg2282 5 років тому +25

    Feeling sad for chakmas , indian should accept chakmas, because they supported india in 1947

  • @hemujin493
    @hemujin493 5 років тому +56

    Thank you so much sir 😭😭 for making this video 😭😭
    n we are suffering alot😭😭 in everywhere

    • @dr.darklight4076
      @dr.darklight4076 5 років тому +9

      I seems chakma students bitten by Thi khamti students in school in Arunachal Pradesh, because of jealousy the khamti peoples are very racist on chakma peoples but no one told about this . Now chakma need their own politician in Arunachal Pradesh.
      India need to stop the Arunachal state government ruling
      Maybe in future their relatives or Asian Buddhist from other countries trafficking to live in Arunachal by politicians and government and they got money, funds etc from other countries . And India don't know about that India knows Arunachal had big land then why separate remember the history Arunachal a part of Assam but Assam share lands and the tribes are so selfish they just looks nice but not really good stop the separate state and government sate

    • @deathx9660
      @deathx9660 4 роки тому +1

      Then come to India

    • @walkwithmisuk
      @walkwithmisuk 3 роки тому +4

      I'm also a Chakma from Khagrachari,CHT Bangladrsh..And Chakmas came from Burma...we are mongolian and tibetan -burmese in origin

    • @peace719
      @peace719 2 роки тому

      @@Potatoalex538 why?
      Aren't chakmas similar to you in looks ?
      Aren't chakmas Buddhists like most of you in Arunachal?

  • @SushilSimplicityCook
    @SushilSimplicityCook 5 років тому +53

    Sir thanks for this video
    Sir I feel cry whenever I watch the video regarding Chakma and Hajong issue because Chakma and Hajong are not accepted as a human being so if they could have accept as a human being they would have grant the citizenship.
    Sir we the Chakma and Hajong have nothing Spiritually ,Mentally,Physically,Financially & Educationally also Economically we need love and support.
    This I am writing with emotionally from the bottom of my heart because the situations that we are facing is unspeakable.
    Please Do pray my dear friends for the Chakma and Hajong.

    • @OPSEComnipotent
      @OPSEComnipotent 5 років тому +10

      Bunch of weak people..go and protest in bangladesh not in others lands

    • @dipikachakmavideocreator1281
      @dipikachakmavideocreator1281 4 роки тому +13

      @@OPSEComnipotent shut up bloody hell we are Indian and we always fight for india we stay here before 50 years ago this is our motherland 👈 ok so think positive don't behave and don't think like a uneducated and backward peoples we are same human don't make a fool and don't bahave like animals

    • @vikasbanarsi330
      @vikasbanarsi330 4 роки тому +1

      CAA for you sis

    • @travellingtuesday8189
      @travellingtuesday8189 4 роки тому +1

      @@dipikachakmavideocreator1281 Sendoki hugurore Sendoki Gori jobab Dena c

    • @newsofarunachal6728
      @newsofarunachal6728 4 роки тому +3

      @@dipikachakmavideocreator1281 just get lost u blady idiots...

  • @shivamshrivastava4143
    @shivamshrivastava4143 7 років тому +201

    A complete failure from our Govt. They just concentrate on Uttar Pradesh and Bihar. Open any news channel also every thing is from UP, Bihar, and Delhi. All they focus on these states yet these are among worst place to live in India. A complete failure of our education system non of the books till 10 teach any thing about North-East India. As I observed during my Engineering North-East people are treated as a sex toys. All because they drink, people think they can sleep with them or they had slept with many. It will be a very good if you make a video of condition of the North-East people in other part of India. With due respect Dr. Gaurav Garg let's us first accept North-East people wholeheartedly in other parts of India then we will have the right to tell them to accept the Chakana tribe. The hated of the indigenous people is justifiable because they themselves don't get resource how can anyone expect that they share what they get with others.

    • @asamobodh6353
      @asamobodh6353 6 років тому +1

      So true

    • @saisager9612
      @saisager9612 6 років тому +3

      True,Politicians fight for their own sake..... Never think about original social issues

    • @sohailKhan-yd9fe
      @sohailKhan-yd9fe 5 років тому +2

      may our all hindu brothers have thinking like you bro. keep it up.❤️❤️❤️

    • @LONEWOLF-ss5dy
      @LONEWOLF-ss5dy 5 років тому +15

      Totally right sir, we Gorkha's of sillgari , darjeeling dist is also facing Bangladeshis problem, if we resist, then bengal government n Police comes n kill us.
      They made us minority from 1990's after Gorkhaland agitation against W.bengal. We came with the land in 1947 our territory was included in W.Bengal, india.
      So thats why we need Gorkhaland as a state within INDIA to protect our culture n community .
      Jai GORKHALAND jai HIND.

    • @DavidKoyu777
      @DavidKoyu777 5 років тому +10

      Treating someone as a sex toy is an outcome of their cheap mindset , it doesn't matter whether someone is from NE or from their own place, whether they drink or not. They will do the same for all.
      Every NE people isn't a drinker . people from mainland also drinks..
      Your statement might delude other people that NE people are drinkers ..so, I don't entirely agree with you.
      A little observation made while an engineering experience won't justify you.

  • @wangoago2488
    @wangoago2488 7 років тому +28

    If chakmas are to be given citizenship then Tibetans came earlier then them so by that logic all Tibetans should also be given citizenship ...courtesy 🤗

    • @mayuresh19697
      @mayuresh19697 5 років тому +4

      Tibet is a spiritual country every spiritual man has a special place in india

    • @gnanam715
      @gnanam715 5 років тому +3

      India helped Shik Mujiber
      Rahman to gain independence from Pakistan after that Bangladesh began subjugating Budhists and Hindus India kept silent then Buddhist and hindu people started mass exodus in to india
      For their safety from Islamic violence it is shame India let the Islamic terror on Buddhists and Hindus at
      It s doorstep

    • @tedtalker101
      @tedtalker101 4 роки тому +2

      They are Indians after independence they came to India just like punjabi and sindhis they came to india

    • @rajkumarnegi2753
      @rajkumarnegi2753 4 роки тому +1

      Tibetan are not really interesting Indian Citizenship coz they want go back to Tibet when China get out from Tibet,, But i think Chakmas are really need ,,

    • @walkwithmisuk
      @walkwithmisuk 3 роки тому

      I'm also a Chakma from Khagrachari,CHT Bangladrsh..And Chakmas came from Burma...we are mongolian and tibetan -burmese in origin

  • @victoriachakma1161
    @victoriachakma1161 7 років тому +23

    An authentic narrative.Thank you so much for making this video

  • @rupantachakma
    @rupantachakma 3 роки тому +16

    Thnks you sir....🙏 For explaining clearly and simply chakma miserable history....😭 🙏🙏🙏

  • @indrajitbaruah4973
    @indrajitbaruah4973 5 років тому +12

    It's a very clear explanation of a unfortunate story of chakmas .. thank you

  • @jarmansingh1808
    @jarmansingh1808 6 років тому +7

    Great video I love the way gaurav sir teach...now picture is very clear to me with respect to chakma controversy

  • @nunubi123
    @nunubi123 7 років тому +33

    Thanks for this video. One correction, not all chakmas are refugees. Some of them are there before 1947.

    • @Ps-ce2lh
      @Ps-ce2lh 6 років тому +17

      AP Chakmas are refugees 100%... please dont be greedy n try to snatch arunachali land rights... please go bsck to ur motherland... y do u like fighting with those who gave u shelter so much

    • @naturelover9194
      @naturelover9194 5 років тому +3

      P s right bro .we Tripuri people never say to chakma that Ur not from north easte they think they r Indian but they use slang word for our king but we never say. one day I also say that what is Ur community the chakma tribe get angry only for this then I said to read newspaper it is written jumma community and the chakma girl get angry on me than we can also say foreigners to them but we treat them sister bro..but biswasghat ki on logo ne humare jamin par kehkar aur humare raja ko hi slang word use ki aur

  • @rickbo88
    @rickbo88 7 років тому +7

    Arunachal is the most peaceful state in whole North East India. But now Supreme Court n central government is trying their best to make it another Kashmir. Granting citizenship is going to be the biggest blunder of the SC n central government. God bless Arunachal pradesh.

  • @tseringjunk
    @tseringjunk 3 роки тому +8

    CHAKMA is a big big issue in Arunachal Pradesh...Govt must act on this...🙏👍

  • @uzochiokeke4328
    @uzochiokeke4328 5 років тому +14

    As an indian i'm in a dilemma. I would be happy if the chakma gained indian citizenship because i understand they are suffering but at the same time i cannot betray the people of arunachal who are already fellow indians. What can we do? 😢

  • @debbarma1302
    @debbarma1302 3 роки тому +2

    Lot of thanks IQ sir ji 🙏🙏🙏 Excellent explained 🙏 love from Tripura North East India 🙏

  • @SatwikSatapathy
    @SatwikSatapathy 7 років тому +53

    There r so many Bangladeshi muslim refugees in Odisha also... In Bhadrak district they r in 3-4 lac... They should b abandoned... coz they r the main reason for BHADRAK RIOT...

    • @manojsircomputer
      @manojsircomputer 6 років тому +5

      BJD GOVT IS SUPPORTING MUSLIM BANGLADESHI

    • @akashparui3504
      @akashparui3504 5 років тому +6

      Yes also in bengal

    • @mtarkes
      @mtarkes 3 роки тому +4

      I wish instead of Bangladeshi Muslims, Chakma buddhists and Hindus had come to Odisha from Bangladesh. Shameful Indian govt cannot take a single rational decision.

    • @rohandas5643
      @rohandas5643 2 роки тому

      @@manojsircomputer no it's TMC 😡 west bangal is shit

  • @SouravOfficial17
    @SouravOfficial17 7 років тому +55

    Sir there should be more deep Discus needed about Tripura, Otherwise it will affect our People & economy in future, they are popping in more & more crossing by the border.

    • @পিতমচেতিযা
      @পিতমচেতিযা 5 років тому +4

      Guli maruga

    • @lhamtashi2957
      @lhamtashi2957 5 років тому +14

      Bengalis are also issues in tripura & other North Eastern states,

    • @tangshang6858
      @tangshang6858 4 роки тому

      Work hard.. Move your lazy @$$ and do something.. Whining won't get you anywhere.

    • @paktummiji6635
      @paktummiji6635 3 роки тому +1

      @@পিতমচেতিযা Bangladeshi bangli spotted

  • @twiprasadebbarma7350
    @twiprasadebbarma7350 5 років тому +8

    In Tripura chakmas already received shedule tribe reservation and they are increasing more than indigenous people of Tripura..if India has to show humanity to chakmas then why only indigenous people of Tripura,Mizoram and Arunachal pradesh has to suffer..all the states of India should take equal responsibilty for chakmas

  • @tendar6666
    @tendar6666 6 років тому +2

    as tibetan refugee in india, i feel lucky to have his holiness Dalai lama and indian governmnet to help us. thank you india.

    • @ashishkalkal1079
      @ashishkalkal1079 6 років тому +1

      Thanks for appreciation my Tibetan brother..... actually Indians should thank Tibetans for choosing India and bless India with presence of HH Dalai Lama....long live Tibet and India

  • @psnabcdef8132
    @psnabcdef8132 3 роки тому +5

    India should help Chakmas and other tribes of Bangladesh to decide their future.

  • @timidbong
    @timidbong 6 років тому +5

    Kya awesome explanation hai Gourav Sir👌👌👌

  • @wangoago2488
    @wangoago2488 7 років тому +42

    No its not right i am from Arunachal and chakmas are living in our distt
    Thy have become very rich and highly educated,,sometime threatening even local tribes !! So they are more advanced then locals

    • @amarchhetri5836
      @amarchhetri5836 7 років тому +9

      Wt is wrong bro sry to use this words but you people dnt interact in a human interacting way when someone go rich or educated you people get jeoules

    • @thespectator3312
      @thespectator3312 6 років тому +1

      @@amarchhetri5836 he was picking the wrong information provided in video dumbass

    • @anantayeng6796
      @anantayeng6796 5 років тому +4

      So what....r u jealous...... why everytime northeastern states have desputes regarding tribes.??

    • @thejaneeyre
      @thejaneeyre 4 роки тому +2

      @@anantayeng6796 it's not wrong to be rich and educated but if you're using that power to suppress weaker folks on their land and state, then that's is definitely wrong. Aapna aukat me rehna hai refugee log.

  • @rakshith.k.g119
    @rakshith.k.g119 7 років тому +9

    Thank you Sir. It's just amazing, how you simplify really complicated issues so that we can understand it better. I owe you. Thanks a ton.

  • @adventurer2951
    @adventurer2951 4 роки тому +6

    Chakma ke bare aur janana ho to 'Nomadic Indian' ka vlog dekhe.... Best ever vlog hai... Jo ground level pe based hai.... North east india ko best explore kisine kiya hoga to wo "Nomadic Indian" ne kiya hai

  • @user-vabna
    @user-vabna 3 роки тому +6

    Very nice presentation and analysis
    Thanks a lot for detailing the histoty

  • @nitingautam144
    @nitingautam144 7 років тому +11

    It would have taken a lot of time to gather this much amount of info. Thank you sir, you are great.

  • @stephendebbarma4183
    @stephendebbarma4183 7 років тому +84

    In tripura.
    More than 90 % benagli refugee from bangladesh and their population is morethan 30 lakhs.in 2011 census....so because of bengali refugee the origin of tripuri people became minority in 2001 census tripuri people percentage was 36 % and in 2011 it was in 26% its just decreasing....
    Maybe after 20 year later the origin of tripuri people will be vanish from indian census because of bengali refugee...in now a days also the bengali refugee is coming and its not stoping and the interesting thing is before entering in india they are able to get voter i.d ration card and indian citizen through agent by giving money.... and state govt is not taking any action of this refugee
    Sir plese help us ......we also want to live .....
    If u dont beleive check in the census of tripura.....

    • @SatwikSatapathy
      @SatwikSatapathy 7 років тому

      Stephen Debbrma bhaiya kyun apna gussa rahul subhro pe nikal rahe ho... sidhe sidhe jawab mango manik sarkar se...

    • @SatwikSatapathy
      @SatwikSatapathy 7 років тому

      Avirup, rahul, subhro ne kuch nahin kiya... jo v kiya apka state govt kar raha hai...

    • @adityanawani8134
      @adityanawani8134 6 років тому +5

      Stephen Debbrma bro the only solution is that tribals should breed a lot

    • @gunnerscoyg839
      @gunnerscoyg839 6 років тому +3

      Stephen Debbrma so sad from Mizo's

    • @devgupta5492
      @devgupta5492 6 років тому +5

      Muslim Ko bhagana chahiye, jab muslim ke liye Pakistan or Bangladesh mil hi gya to use yha jagah q de

  • @roshnasinai
    @roshnasinai 7 років тому +38

    Gaurav sir today i knew we r in d far most happily living in our country compare to Chakmas....I think instant solution has to b bring by or govt...Govt must give a citizenship n make a special solution for their living n land...we should not forget we r human being before we go to decision

  • @jayprakashmishra6198
    @jayprakashmishra6198 5 років тому +28

    Chakma should be settle in India, they are our brothers and sisters.

    • @the_cemetery_guy8230
      @the_cemetery_guy8230 5 років тому +6

      Sahi kaha bhai... Chakma ko U. P. ya Bihar mai settle kara do bhai...

    • @mahabharatepisodes4378
      @mahabharatepisodes4378 5 років тому +4

      @@the_cemetery_guy8230 ha bhai Rajasthan bhej do hamare..ham le lenge..in logo ko yha

    • @the_cemetery_guy8230
      @the_cemetery_guy8230 5 років тому

      @@mahabharatepisodes4378 bhai woh keh rahe hai ki waha ke log toh apni betiyon ki khayal ache se nahi rhakte hain humare shat toh pata nahi kia karenge, ab bolo kia kare😂

    • @mahabharatepisodes4378
      @mahabharatepisodes4378 5 років тому +1

      @@the_cemetery_guy8230 bhai lowest crime rate state hai Rajasthan all India me...

    • @machindrakhapung6039
      @machindrakhapung6039 5 років тому +2

      No India should take the land of chakma(now belong to Bangladesh ) as Russia has done in crimea to save the Russian

  • @triptachakma3389
    @triptachakma3389 3 роки тому +7

    Even if now India government will to take Chakmas
    I would love to chose India

  • @mithungiri3025
    @mithungiri3025 7 років тому +11

    SIR AAP JAISA KOI NAHI THANK YOU SIR

  • @bagherwal4
    @bagherwal4 7 років тому +5

    great Dr Gaurav. A detailed view and clear explanation. Thanks.

  • @david.648
    @david.648 6 років тому +10

    If the videos of study IQ were in English version (at least English captions) then it would've been genuinely helpful.. however I still find it informative because of the facts provided in English.. overall great video

  • @taarungohain5483
    @taarungohain5483 6 років тому +1

    Hi sir, my name is Tarun Gohain and i am from Arunachal pradesh. This chakma problem issue is increasing day by day in our state. And thanku for giving this crucial information.

  • @pandharinathpawar7567
    @pandharinathpawar7567 3 роки тому

    सर,बहोत अच्छी जाणकारी मिली ,डिटेल मे समजाया है आपणे, आपका धन्यवाद

  • @rohit8147-q1w
    @rohit8147-q1w 7 років тому +56

    India ko cht ko support karna chahiye aur in logo ko Bangladesh se azadi leni chahiye

    • @moviessongs4039
      @moviessongs4039 6 років тому +5

      rohit singh cht Ko India ka hissa hona chahiye

    • @lalochakma1076
      @lalochakma1076 6 років тому +5

      Bro main Bangladesh Rangamati se hoon,,,,,please bro hamey bachalo,,,,,eiye muslims louk hamey mar dega,,,,eye muslim louk chakma people ko hotta krta hain,,,,,,please bro help,,,,CHT ko india ka hissa banalo bro,,,,,please help karo bro

    • @lalochakma1076
      @lalochakma1076 6 років тому +7

      CHT ko Bangladesh se alak kar do,,,,or India ka hissa banalo,,,Jai Hind

    • @breakingnewsaie6512
      @breakingnewsaie6512 5 років тому +2

      @@lalochakma1076 দেশদ্রুহি কুথাকার

    • @deathx9660
      @deathx9660 4 роки тому +1

      @@lalochakma1076 why fk we want another war with Bangladesh sake of u . And world criticize , sanction India striping land from other countries world will hate us for it a land ?? Cant u live peaceful I went to Bangladesh it seem like they don't kill other religions ? It not19s black and white foul us

  • @glf_videos
    @glf_videos 7 років тому +71

    Mizoram and other North Eastern States are very very small states. . . You have to understand that Mizoram state has a total population around 10 lacs only and the Chakma population is already about 1 lac. . That means they are already threatening the very existence and survival of the indigenous Mizo tribes in Mizoram. . And now as if it is not enough, the Central goverment is planning to welcome more of these people through its Citizenship Bill. I think the Central government doesn't care about the survival and existence of the indegenous people of the northeast at all. There is no big difference between the attitude of the Bangladeshi govt towards the Chakmas and the attitude of the Indian government towards the indigenous peoples of the northeast. Will any of the big states in India stays silent if 10% of their population is already made up of some alien peoples and the government decides to bring in more of those people? That is exactly what is being done to the states and the indigenous people of some of the northeast states like Arunachal and Mizoram. .

    • @rickbo88
      @rickbo88 7 років тому +2

      Gideon Faihriem u r right.

    • @zonunralte4742
      @zonunralte4742 7 років тому +8

      Well said. I was about to leave a comment and seeing you've done it so, I am satisfied.

    • @dstuallawt285
      @dstuallawt285 7 років тому +1

      u are right Gideon

    • @rahultripura3816
      @rahultripura3816 6 років тому +2

      in tripura the bengalis already overtook tripuris

    • @pemaap5727
      @pemaap5727 6 років тому

      Gideon Faihriem that's right..

  • @prantikachakma3198
    @prantikachakma3198 7 років тому +30

    few corrections here,
    1) jum is a method of cultivation in the hills, all the indigenous ppl use this method, it's a slash and burn Technic which requires a fresh piece of land every year, making most of the hill tribes nomadic.
    2) the Tripura Mizoram and Cht hills are all connected, part of the same land mass. part of same hill ranges and before the political lines were drawn, even before the british, ppl moved about these hills without restrictions looking for new patches of land every year. this is true for all the tribes from now divided states and countries. you will find tripuri tribes in both Mizoram and Cht, you will find mizo tribes in both Tripura and Cht. and like wise you will find chakmas in both the Indian states

    • @hottinroof7159
      @hottinroof7159 2 роки тому

      Yes I have heard jhum kheti

    • @Pualleng
      @Pualleng 2 роки тому

      Mizoram Chakma is brought up by British for supplier, their origin is not Mizoram It's Bangladesh

    • @satyazmt5641
      @satyazmt5641 2 роки тому

      Chakma people they don't know how to behaved with other tribe they just want controversy now only I know before I hard chakmas are very free minded but practically I noticed chakmas are like snake

    • @amiyobala570
      @amiyobala570 2 роки тому

      @@Pualleng then what about your origin,you lushai also came from chin (chinlung) which is located in China,before Indian got independent you don't even have your own language,script,culture,etc

  • @Sunnynews1
    @Sunnynews1 5 років тому +21

    जहां-जहां मुस्लिम की संख्या बढ़ी है वहां-वहां अशांति होनी तय है

  • @pibirchakma2255
    @pibirchakma2255 Рік тому +2

    Thank you for explain in chakma history ❤❤

  • @umeshdn3486
    @umeshdn3486 6 років тому +4

    Explained in best way!!!
    Keep It Up Sir!!

  • @jarmansingh1808
    @jarmansingh1808 6 років тому +4

    The best video I ever get on study iq..thanks alot

  • @vansh0692
    @vansh0692 7 років тому +11

    Thanks sir.... Please make a video on naxalism sir how it started...

  • @hadibandhusardar5296
    @hadibandhusardar5296 4 роки тому +11

    Welcome Chakma and hujong
    Tribes.

  • @kannadasnaidu126
    @kannadasnaidu126 3 роки тому +5

    Their area in Bangladesh should be liberated by India and given to them and make a new state of India that is chakma Pradesh

  • @Mithalal98
    @Mithalal98 7 років тому +6

    It is very useful for competitive exams thank you sir

  • @PolkaGeekmm
    @PolkaGeekmm 5 років тому +28

    I have the answer to all of your questions. After the 1997 Chittagong accord, if at all the
    Indian government wants to do something for the sake of humanity, for the chakmas, it should fund for proper rations and settlement of the chakmas who return to Chittagong...instead of throwing the burden on the already struggling tribals of northeast.
    SIMPLE!!!
    I don't understand why you guys are even debating about chakma and humanity anymore
    To all the people saying, Ismein chakma ka kya galti hai, Put yourself in the shoes of chakmas, etc etc.
    You have no idea about the rate of reproduction these chakmas have. They've gone from 5000 to 2 lakhs in only 50 years (since 1970 in Arunachal). How's that humanly possible???
    2nd, Chakmas in Arunachal live like they own the land. They've occupied thousands of hectares of land, and threaten the locals.
    Oh and they are very well educated Their Arunachal Chakma unions are full of lawyers and UN representatives and what not.
    Lastly, they are doing the same thing to Arunachal's local tribes, what the Bangladeshis did to them.
    If anybody here need to Ingram some empathy into themselves, it's the chakmas. They've been through it, and yet are willing to pour onto their host the same misery that they had to go through, more or less.
    Plus, with all the efforts and money they invest on legal fights against the State and people of arunachal, they could've instead invested the same on fighting for their Chittagong rights

    • @anonymoussssss201
      @anonymoussssss201 3 роки тому +5

      Racist Mizo spotted

    • @md.shirazulislam4605
      @md.shirazulislam4605 3 роки тому

      Incomplet report. chakmattible orginale comes china in anciant time.They leves india& bangladesh today. Bangladesh intrnel affiars no talk.

  • @furrysfriend5150
    @furrysfriend5150 4 роки тому +9

    I am from ladakh. We follow Tibetan Buddhism

    • @modhurshirecipes1292
      @modhurshirecipes1292 4 роки тому +1

      Do want to take them to your ladakh Beacuse the budist chakmas are being tourcherd by muslims in bd

    • @furrysfriend5150
      @furrysfriend5150 4 роки тому +5

      Yes. I will. And other Buddhist in India who are being tortured by Hindu. Does this happen in India? Where some people being tortured , other people from other state take them ? Is this the solution? Where is your logic. Are you human or cow?

    • @lunaSA321
      @lunaSA321 3 роки тому

      @@furrysfriend5150 buddhist tortured by Hindus.... Wow....in which state.... Even those Hindus gives refuge to Tibetan....don't bark anything here....we all are brothers...don't bite someone's hand who helped u during bad times

    • @furrysfriend5150
      @furrysfriend5150 3 роки тому

      @international beggar imran 🐴

    • @lunaSA321
      @lunaSA321 3 роки тому

      @Tanushka Agarwal i know am talking about Tibetans read my comment...

  • @balisc1
    @balisc1 5 років тому +5

    Excellent presentation. Well done!

  • @Ptomify
    @Ptomify 7 років тому +11

    really nice video. informative. i think chakmas are innocent. agr hamare sath esa hua hota to.

  • @sejalahuja6747
    @sejalahuja6747 6 років тому +62

    bangladesh chittagong hill ko capture kr le india😒😒😂 problem solve ho jayegi😒😒 bangladesh wale kuchh ukhad nhi payenge

    • @odyssey-অভিযান
      @odyssey-অভিযান 6 років тому +2

      Start once time u will see where u can go..
      Bravery is in bottom of heart
      Not in mouth.

    • @resonanceosillations3685
      @resonanceosillations3685 5 років тому +1

      Bhai China bus chicken neck ke pas hai Bangladesh ko support karne me time nahi lagega

    • @pradipchakma1537
      @pradipchakma1537 5 років тому

      LoL , when Chittagong hill will be part India then we will show you what the brav.....

    • @resonanceosillations3685
      @resonanceosillations3685 5 років тому +1

      @@pradipchakma1537 do you even know that chittagong want to be a part of India but it cant because India has to loose kolkata India fighted for chakma autonomy it taken more than 40000 chakma refugee

    • @pradipchakma1537
      @pradipchakma1537 5 років тому +2

      @@resonanceosillations3685 bro thanks, do you know Chittagong hill tracks how important for India, all the northeast terrorist group take shelter in Chittagong hill,if India brought back Chittagong hill India doesn't need to beg to Bangladesh govt.action against terrorist.

  • @thetribe2101
    @thetribe2101 3 роки тому +5

    India should have invaded Chittagong in 1947 as a reply to pakistani invasion of Kashmir

  • @moksh647
    @moksh647 7 років тому +14

    Chakas are very peaceful people. they are victim of islam and politics.

  • @sauvaghyachatterjee9131
    @sauvaghyachatterjee9131 7 років тому +1

    Excellent presentation.Historical analysis of the ill fated people of chakama tribe. surely we need to do more for them at this point of time.

  • @rajpootgirl2276
    @rajpootgirl2276 5 років тому +2

    Very well taught....thnku ......request u for please summarize in your next video about imp tribes expected in upsc

  • @SouravOfficial17
    @SouravOfficial17 7 років тому +38

    Sir M from Tripura...Plzz Discus abt Tripura...

    • @thesaviour6325
      @thesaviour6325 6 років тому +1

      Sourav Debbarma
      Why u locals kick them out
      We all are behind u
      Central government will do nothing

    • @prakashnarain7111
      @prakashnarain7111 5 років тому +2

      in continuation..
      No any Indian like their stay in india but they are now vote bank.any party who will solve this problem in their favour ,will become celebrity for them.all votes will go in that party.for any such reaction,action must be done immediatly in favour of india-nation.

    • @Debasish33
      @Debasish33 3 роки тому

      Main bhi tripura se hu 🥺🥺🥺 CHAKMA

  • @MrCholani
    @MrCholani 7 років тому +23

    As an Arunachalee, let me share my view. The livelihood of majority of the tribal people of my state still depend on forests resources, like hunting, shift cultivation, fishing, wood for house building and cooking, selling forest products etc. Since this chakma-hajong community settle in forest area and starts spreading their area, thus threatening the livelihood of my people.
    2) The majority of students depends only on state government jobs, since no industry is present there for private jobs. And we can't compete for the central jobs. And today's generation of Arunachal is in great risk, every year around 10,000 students complete 10+2 but the jobs vacancies is very less in compare to students produces. So, unemployment will be a big social problems in coming 5 years. It's upto state and central govt to solve this issue fast.

    • @kimikimey4125
      @kimikimey4125 7 років тому +3

      Namo Munglang.. hum bhi arunachal ka hai yayyyy :)

    • @GautamBuddhaSiddarth
      @GautamBuddhaSiddarth 7 років тому +7

      Namo Munglang you are concerning about the jobs of the native people on the cost of lives of chakmas. The persecution which they have faced can bring tears in anyone's eye, please show some humanity. Chakmas have faced lot of hardships without donig any mistake from their side.

    • @MrCholani
      @MrCholani 7 років тому +4

      Thank you sir for your reply. Sir, with due respect, Arunachal Pradesh is big in term of area but in terms of cultivation and residential wise, the land area is small. And the chakmas-hajong tribes are settling only in plains area. There is a dist- Changlang, the govt of india gave them land for their settlement in that district, but now the indigenous tribe-Singpho are being out number. And now their land is in danger. The 1500 citizenship is given in that district. They take settlement in the reserved forest ( declare by govt. of India), that forest area which is being preserved for our future generation is being taken by them. If they take settlement in hilly and mountainous area then it is ok because the density in that area is 1 per sq km.

    • @MrCholani
      @MrCholani 7 років тому

      wow.. can we be friend in FB?

    • @kimikimey4125
      @kimikimey4125 7 років тому +1

      Namo Munglang just because our state is big in area doesn't mean we should give permanent residency to Chakmas.

  • @akashkumardigal656
    @akashkumardigal656 7 років тому +4

    Sensitive case!! Humanity should be united to give basic rights to all minority communities. There must be an equal understanding between groups of different ethnic races.

  • @shubhadipchakma
    @shubhadipchakma 3 роки тому +2

    I always wondered to hear about these things, very well explained and thanks to cover it up.
    Please accept chakmas, my request to Arunachal brothers and sisters and others states they are being discriminated, ignored and unaccepted for a very long time by now.

  • @vikasbhat6077
    @vikasbhat6077 4 роки тому +1

    Thanks for sharing in details about Chakma people.

  • @karlilollen6129
    @karlilollen6129 5 років тому +3

    I'm from Arunachal Pradesh, n I'm Glad to know that you are covering Northeast India..
    At least your 6 MILLIONS Subscribers will get to know about us...
    Thank you.. N Yes.. Go Back Chakma Hajong!

    • @rupantachakma
      @rupantachakma 3 роки тому

      You kali lolen you hav no humanity

  • @TAKAR1-v3i
    @TAKAR1-v3i 7 років тому +35

    I m going to unsubscribe ur channel and report also.This issue is very sensible one,Your channel is a medium for information to other Indians and the centre govt also.You should have corrected ur information better.
    Chakma Refugees in Arunachal is not a mere 7000 but 54,000 given their own Chakma unions. As per our knowledge they have crossed 1 lakh.
    We Arunachalis are the one who's going to become a minority in our own land.And they are neither poor nor in malnutrition.Chakmas have occupied vast lands of local people.Your channel as well as the centre Govt is acting Dumb and blind to Arunachal again.M utterly disappointed by this video.

    • @user-yv2ss9fq6t
      @user-yv2ss9fq6t 5 років тому

      bro camp arunachali brother where should those chakma to be send??..

    • @sangteichhangte2055
      @sangteichhangte2055 5 років тому

      This channel is owned and operated by chakma...report all...

    • @PolkaGeekmm
      @PolkaGeekmm 5 років тому

      @@user-yv2ss9fq6t to your state

    • @kipayaniang9421
      @kipayaniang9421 5 років тому +1

      @Abhisakh Malick Bangladeshi log hai .. unka asli Ghar peh being jaruri hai

    • @thejaneeyre
      @thejaneeyre 4 роки тому

      @@user-yv2ss9fq6t back to their ancestors land

  • @skumarshishodia4360
    @skumarshishodia4360 7 років тому +5

    great efforts ..thanks a lot "Team Study IQ" very informative, in a very simple way....keep continue please

  • @mahimahiya188
    @mahimahiya188 6 років тому +2

    Lucidly explained .. Thank you sir

  • @MacZ_EditZ
    @MacZ_EditZ 3 роки тому +2

    At that time there was East Pakistan. Now Bangladesh. Now Chakma is given the highest facility in Bangladesh. They are citizens of Bangladesh. They can vote. Chakma students study in all the major universities of Bangladesh. They have become the most educated tribe in Bangladesh.

  • @rajlingking9727
    @rajlingking9727 5 років тому +8

    Chakma population is more than 1lakhs in arunachal not 7000

  • @RAVI-RA1N
    @RAVI-RA1N 5 років тому +3

    Good explanation sir. thanks for teaching.

  • @sangreetkaur4461
    @sangreetkaur4461 5 років тому +5

    You explain very well sir 🙏

  • @sniggdhajauhari
    @sniggdhajauhari 6 років тому +2

    Brilliantly explained. Great

  • @iamnotgreedybg2373
    @iamnotgreedybg2373 5 років тому +1

    Very nice explanation with clear voice

  • @aamalchakma1465
    @aamalchakma1465 5 років тому +5

    I m also from Chakma community

  • @tajangrai5501
    @tajangrai5501 3 роки тому +10

    Sir I'm from Arunachal and the population of chakma is not only 7000 as you mentioned. It's in lakhs.
    Another point, they have been given land by government. These days chakmas started selling off land. Locals buy at cheaper rates from them as it's much easy to bargain.

  • @kenlomninu4410
    @kenlomninu4410 7 років тому +5

    sorry...wrong information....the current population of chakma and hajongs in Arunachal is more than 1 lakh....and none of them has been granted citizenship so far....Because Arunachal is a full protected state under The Bengal Eastern Frontier Regulation 1873(BEFR) laid by the Britishers....Please read the details about it(BEFR).

  • @Epicurean999
    @Epicurean999 7 років тому +2

    Whoa now I was completely unaware of the infinite FACETS included in THIS VERY ISSUE OF CHAKMAS! thanks for uploading Doctor Sir 🤗