Rob Reacts... Jarred Gillett Mic'd up | Exclusive Look at Referee's Perspective of an A-League Game
Вставка
- Опубліковано 4 кві 2021
- Jarred Gillett's last game in the A-League in Australia. We get to hear what sort of things referees say during a game of football. Do you think we should hear this all the time? I do!
Jarred Gillett is now officiating in the English Championship!
23rd September 2021 - This weekend will be Jarred Gillett's first Premier League Match!
Original Video: • Mic'd up | An exclusiv...
If you would like to support me then 'Buy me a beer' and gain access to extra content: www.buymeacoffee.com/robreacts
Discord: / discord
Tech I'm using:
Camera - Logitech StreamCam: amzn.to/2NlFrAN...
Microphone - Blue Microphones Logitech Yeti: amzn.to/3liyuwQ
#Footballreferee #robreferee #JarredGillet #ALeague #Soccer #MicdUp - Спорт
This Referee, Jarred Gillet about to become the first foreigner to officiate in the EPL, and he’s an Aussie, great stuff
Jarred Gillett didn’t actually know it was being recorded, because it was the same equipment as usual that was used. It also wasn’t broadcast straight away
I honestly think a lot of the reason Rugby referees are respected so much and are known as household names is because they're mic'd up. A lot of the human interactions get picked up and the audience feels a connection to them. You then find that audiences are far more forgiving of the 50/50 decisions, or even mistakes, because we can hear why they made their decisions. Ultimately all of that feeds back into respect for the referees, as children and grassroots level players have this ingrained in them from watching the professional level on TV. We often talk about football referees not getting the respect they deserve-I think this could be a hugely positive move!
It needs to be introduced. Its better than people demanding refs to answer questions after the game.
Jarred is a great guy and a good referee. The Premier League and English Football are lucky to have him.
Just shows how much clearer decisions are given. Add in the review on the jumbo screens for all to see as well. Would / could / should make the players wings and swear less at the officials ... the should never do so anyway but they do and that’s the image presented to the kids.
Its something we need to bring in. Like I said in the video, it should stop the nonesense pundits talking rubbish.
10:10 In Australia (at least) the pundits WOULD carry on talking about it and spouting their garbage on TV endlessly. Plenty of video replays too.
Yea and this is the issue. By having the refs mic'd up for everyone to hear then how can you question their decision.
I was a referee beside these guys at referee training each week, they were great guys and many years before this. I have shared this video 30+ times to refereeing forums and groups.
I believe it would be advantageous to clear up any confusion about decisions on the field and for training purposes after the fact.
I think broadcasters being able to get a live switch to referee communications at crucial times could clear up and encourage referees not to be a little one eyed let's just say.
I have heard that at top level rugby matches in the UK that spectators can purchase headphones tuned to the ref channel. I think that would be marvelous. That could help the football situation too. Taming the TV audience is one thing but the stadium audience is a different "beast' of an immediate concern.
Yea I heard that as well so they can hear the ref and tmo
@@RobReacts1 I think the biggest thing at taming crowds at rugby matches is that the review is shown on the big screen in the stadium. So even tho you cant hear the ref in the stadium, seeing the replay in slow motion at the same time as the ref really helps calm the crowd as nobody is confused as to what actually happened (even if people disagree with the decision).
Gillett was superb in the EFL Championship Play Off Semi Final 2nd leg between Brentford and Bournemouth just recently. His control, quiet authority and experience as an international official shone through in a very tough match.
I think he is getting promoted to the premier league if I'm not mistaken
@@RobReacts1 He certainly is. One of four refs to be promoted to the Premier League. There was a general consensus that the standard of officiating in the Championship wasn’t good, but Gillett was head and shoulders above most of the other refs.
Jarred Gillett has done three games this season already, makes his Premier League debut on Saturday and has quietly and efficiently been going about his work so far. His experience above all else makes him slot easily into the plans that the authorities have for him.
great clip, really old now but the audio didnt go live to air - all added in post
As someone that has walked rugby (both codes) and football, I think the openness of rugby due to moving refs and the transpracy with to calls is fantastic for spectators as you can hear and see why decisions are made even if you don't like them. At the moment you're guessing sometimes in football. Oh and don't get me started on var where they seem to take 10 minutes sometimes deciding on offsides or fouls! 🙁
mate you have it spot on and i cant argue against what you said.
7:40 it was his last Hyundai A-League game before moving to the EFL then eventually the Premier League
If the ref is mic'd up they somehow become a part of the game in my eyes. otherwise they look to me like 3 blind mice most of the time. I am all up for new technology in football. although calling almost 200 year old wireless radio a new technology is a bit of taking the piss.
But the referee is apart of the game
This wasn't aired live. They released it about a week or two after the game. I know because I was at the game.
Shame it wasn't live on air
I dimly recall a Premier League ref getting mic-ed up in the 90s and it was an absolute PR disaster, with the ref getting sworn at repeatedly, nearly constantly, by players.
I also dimly recall a Championship, or possibly League 1 side experimented with only the captain talking to the ref and that season they got less cards than any other team in the league ( disclaimer, this may be inaccurate, I didn't pay that much attention to football at that time)
See thats the real reason they wont 'mic up refs' because they know how football players are dreadful and it will make them look bad. But so they should look bad! Thats the idea, then they will behave themselves and shut their mouths!
Deliberately slowing the game down like that should be a yellow all day long ☠️
But not giving its goes along the lines of managing the game as refs are taught.
@@RobReacts1 Is there an argument to be made that players know that though? They know the first incident is only going to be a warning, so they know they're going to get away with it. In this instance, with the game as it is now, it was probably the right call, but I think it would be good to get to a position where players don't think they can get away with it - because they don't. If it's an offence, it's an offence. If you deliberately delay a restart - it's a card. Wouldn't take too long for them to stop doing it. If course, they would no doubt come up with creative ways to get around it - they always do, but it slightly undermines the referee's authority (to my mind) if you have to break a rule twice before it is applied.
@@JamesChiles For me slowing the restart, kicking the ball away, taking the ball with you - should be a a yellow card every single time. After four weeks it should be clear, that it won't be accepted in any circumstances. Place the ball on the ground at carry on. Taking your shirt in goal celebrations makes much less harm and is a yellow every day of the week. At the same time you have to kick the ball to the stands or do it at least two seconds after the whistle to get booked. And every single dubious throw-in starts with opposing player taking the ball with him for a two-three seconds or throwing it to attacking player so high, that it flies for ever.
I like hearing the referee in rugby and think it would add to the experience of watching football. I didn't know that the refs were miked up in the A league as in 11 years down here I haven't watched a match from that league.
Im not sure if his last game was a one off. The top refs are always mic'd up but its not something thats broadcast.
@@RobReacts1 a quick search on Google suggests that this is a one-off event.
@Angus Smith seem like a wasted opportunity.
at 3:54 i am a referee, What i would do is depending on where the ball is if it is in a place where a goal can be scored with a significant chance or say it's a cup final in the 87th minute and A team is winning 2-1 and a defender commits a foul from Team A and then delays the restart i would show a yellow card there i agree no yellow card but a warning.
What do you think about doing a football info vid like the ones you've done about the laws and positions of rugby
But I already know about positions. I'm a football coach, ref and fan. But the rugby vids are about me learning 😊
@@RobReacts1 I was thinking to help aid non football people like my self understand better
Football players get away with the dives and bull they due partly because there’s not much strictness on the cards, in rugby if you get a yellow you go to the sin bin for 10 mins whilst in football you need two yellows to become a red, so if the offence fits the crime then that player and team should be punished because most teams do this willy nilly to gain an advantage. I believe at least TMO of an offence should be introduced to all sports not just to keep players safe but to make the fear of cheating become less of a thing due to all eyes on that TMO.
Having had the chance to be mic'd up as a rugby ref it takes a little getting used to at first but once you are used to it it is a great help. It allows you to use your assistant refs to watch things happening on the side you are not also they can watch what is happening off the ball and so many other things it is an aid to refs that makes life so much easier. It is always said the 3 officials work as a team and being in 2 way contact makes being a team so much easier and players are more aware that 3 sets of eyes are on them
For sure. Without mics at grassroots you have to go to them to speak, use more hand signals and sometimes you accidently go opposite directions to your assistants.
I understand managing the game but I think that stopping the restart should be a yellow every time. It is so frustrating to watch and is far too common in the game. Sure, there'll probably be a lot of yellows given out but players will soon stop doing it when they know it will be a yellow every time.
I can't disagree! It's almost because your not expected to give the yellow card.
I have seen this before. He's in the efl know. I like the idea, but I think the fa would be scared because of the Tony Adams and David Elerey video.
There is no real reason for it to not happen.
I agree and if the premier league sky and bt really want it then it probably will happen. Have you seen the eleray video 1989.
As a one eyed fan it's proberly best the Phoenix weren't playing in this A League match, as some of the A League reffing can be awful, for all the teams. But on topic knowing the why normally stops the cry.
For sure. Refs need to be mic'd up for people to hear! Glad to hear I have some Australian viewers ☺️
It’s definitely a good idea to put mic on the refs like in rugby and also the use of VAR should be changed, it shouldn’t be about warning the ref about a "clear error" but more like in rugby to check about litigious situations. IMO football referees should go more often to the screen. Also in that case they should have the ability to stop the clock so it doesn’t waste too much time
I think VAR should work along side the referee not just on the odd occassion!
@@RobReacts1 yeah I agree with you. I think it’s a mistake that it’s only the VAR officials that say to the main ref about checking this situation or not instead of the referee asking himself the check up. Plus I think that replays while checking should be put on stadium’s big screens (when they exist of course) so everyone could se clearly what’s happening
@@noelostetter8236 I think the assistant should freely be able to talk to VAR in the same way he can speak to his assistants!
@@RobReacts1 yeah absolutely agree with you. From what I’ve seen, especially in France is that the main referee will be more enclined to stick to his original decision rather than checking it a second time (mostly because there’s a weird notation system in France where changing your mind decreases your notation and also because French referee are atrocious but that’s another debate) which lead to absolutely horrible decisions
It's not used like it is in rugby as it takes up to much time. And for factual outcomes there's no need to go to the screen
The problem with referees potentially giving after match interviews is that all the public want to hear him say is "I f.cked up" because they've already decided that he has and any attempt to explain his decisions is not what they want to hear. And it wouldn't stop the pundits spouting their bollocks either unfortunately, they're paid too much not to lol.
haha your right. But the thing is most of the time the referee is right :D
@@RobReacts1 Naturally and we both know it too 👍🏻
Slowing down the free kick should advance the free kick 10m. Similar to rugby
Yea quite possibly!
@@RobReacts1 Only first time though, first time is 10m, second time is warning for full team that next infringement is yellow, then yellow. Works so well in rugby
It's AR not linesman or lino
You are right... But as someone who acts as an assistant Ref, im happy to be called a lino.
Penalise the first offence? How about we don't count the first goal scored? If it's a yellow it's a yellow!
if Joe Pesquali was my AR, I would take my earpiece out. Listening to that squeeky voice would break me.
Haha
You’re not FIFA so your opinion isn’t professional
mate you have no idea what you are commenting on
Erm, you know I'm a football referee right...
@@RobReacts1 yep and your still talking shit from across the world