Visiting the Meuse-Argonne American Cemetery I THE GREAT WAR Special
Вставка
- Опубліковано 18 чер 2024
- Meuse-Argonne App (iOS): bit.ly/CemeteryApp
Meuse-Argonne App (Android): bit.ly/MeuseArgonne
Meuse-Argonne American Cemetery Facebook Page: bit.ly/MeuseArgonneFB
During our trip to France we visited the Meuse-Argonne American Cemetery and Monument in Romagne. The cemetery contains the largest number of American military dead in Europe and was already dedicated when the war was still raging in Europe.
» HOW CAN I SUPPORT YOUR CHANNEL?
You can support us by sharing our videos with your friends and spreading the word about our work.You can also support us financially on Patreon: / thegreatwar
You can also buy our merchandise in our online shop: shop.spreadshirt.de/thegreatwar/
Patreon is a platform for creators like us, that enables us to get monthly financial support from the community in exchange for cool perks.
» WHERE CAN I GET MORE INFORMATION ABOUT WORLD WAR I AND WHERE ELSE CAN I FIND YOU?
We’re offering background knowledge, news, a glimpse behind the scenes and much more on:
reddit: bit.ly/TheGreatSubReddit
Facebook: bit.ly/WW1FB
Twitter: bit.ly/WW1Series
Instagram: bit.ly/ZpMYPL
» CAN I EMBED YOUR VIDEOS ON MY WEBSITE?
Of course, you can embed our videos on your website. We are happy if you show our channel to your friends, fellow students, classmates, professors, teachers or neighbours. Or just share our videos on Facebook, Twitter, Reddit etc.
We are also happy to get your feedback, criticism or ideas in the comments. If you have interesting historical questions, just post them and we will answer in our OUT OF THE TRENCHES videos. You can find a selection of answers to the most frequently asked questions here: bit.ly/OOtrenches
» CAN I SHOW YOUR VIDEOS IN CLASS?
Of course! Tell your teachers or professors about our channel and our videos. We’re happy if we can contribute with our videos. If you are a teacher and have questions about our show, you can get in contact with us on one of our social media presences.
» WHAT ARE YOUR SOURCES?
Videos: British Pathé
Pictures: Mostly Picture Alliance
Background Map: d-maps.com/carte.php?num_car=6...
Literature (excerpt):
Gilbert, Martin. The First World War. A Complete History, Holt Paperbacks, 2004.
Hart, Peter. The Great War. A Combat History of the First World War, Oxford University Press, 2013.
Hart, Peter. The Great War. 1914-1918, Profile Books, 2013.
Stone, Norman. World War One. A Short History, Penguin, 2008.
Keegan, John. The First World War, Vintage, 2000.
Hastings, Max. Catastrophe 1914. Europe Goes To War, Knopf, 2013.
Hirschfeld, Gerhard. Enzyklopädie Erster Weltkrieg, Schöningh Paderborn, 2004
Michalka, Wolfgang. Der Erste Weltkrieg. Wirkung, Wahrnehmung, Analyse, Seehamer Verlag GmbH, 2000
Leonhard, Jörn. Die Büchse der Pandora: Geschichte des Ersten Weltkrieges, C.H. Beck, 2014
If you want to buy some of the books we use or recommend during our show, check out our Amazon Store: bit.ly/AmazonTGW
NOTE: This store uses affiliate links which grant us a commission if you buy a product there.
» WHAT IS “THE GREAT WAR” PROJECT?
THE GREAT WAR covers the events exactly 100 years ago: The story of World War I in realtime. Featuring: The unique archive material of British Pathé. Indy Neidell takes you on a journey into the past to show you what really happened and how it all could spiral into more than four years of dire war. Subscribe to our channel and don’t miss our new episodes every Thursday.
» WHO IS REPLYING TO MY COMMENTS? AND WHO IS BEHIND THIS PROJECT?
Most of the comments are written by our social media manager Florian. He is posting links, facts and backstage material on our social media channels. But from time to time, Indy reads and answers comments with his personal account, too.
The Team responsible for THE GREAT WAR is even bigger:
- CREDITS -
Presented by : Indiana Neidell
Written by: Indiana Neidell
Director: Toni Steller & Florian Wittig
Director of Photography: Toni Steller, Julian Zahn
Sound: Markus Linke
Mixing, Mastering & Sound Design: www.above-zero.com
Editing: Toni Steller
Motion Design: Philipp Appelt
Research by: Indiana Neidell
Fact checking: Markus Linke
The Great War Theme composed by Karim Theilgaard: bit.ly/karimyt
A Mediakraft Networks Original Channel
Based on a concept by Spartacus Olsson
Author: Indiana Neidell
Visual Concept: Astrid Deinhard-Olsson & David van Stephold
Executive Producer: Spartacus Olsson
Producer: Toni Steller & Florian Wittig
Social Media Manager: Florian Wittig
Contains licenced Material by British Pathé
All rights reserved - © Mediakraft Networks GmbH, 2017
Thanks for highlighting Meuse-Argonne American Cemetery. This cemetery is one of 26 managed by the American Battle Monuments Commission, an agency funded completely by the U.S. federal government. Two of the staff members there are American, and the others are French. We are fortunate to have dedicated staff that ensure these hallowed grounds remain beautiful and pristine. Thanks for sharing our app and Facebook page.
Thank you for giving us the opportunity to film on location. It was a great experience for all of us.
Thank you both for giving us, the viewers, the chance to see and learn about things that otherwise we'd never have the opportunity to see. I hope to visit one day.
ABMCVIDEOS as a former American Soldier thank you so much for taking care of my comrades who gave their lives in long pass Wars... also a very special and heartfelt thanks to your French employees who watch over men from a foreign country
Thank you xx I will surely visit this memorial.
MY GREAT GREAT UNCLE CLAUDE MCKINNEY FROM HAMPTON TENNESSEE FOUGHT IN THAT BATTLE AND WAS KILLED IN ACTION IN OCTOBER 1918 HE WAS IN THE US ARMY AND THE 5TH INFANTRY DIVISION SOMETHING LIKE THAT THE BROUGHT HIS BODY BACK TO EAST TENNESSEE.
Indy looks like a bond villain.
Clifton Duke "Do you expect me to film?"
"No mr. Neidell, I expect you to tour the cemetary."
"Choose your next Special Episode carefully, Mr. Neidell."
Clifton Duke "Do you expect me to talk?"
"Yes mr. Neidell, I do. Otherwise this would be pretty boring episode."
Dang, Indy has some style.
Blunderwood ikr
you can tell he did his shopping in sweden, every one looks like this here because it's the H&M fashion
defaultuser88 or maybe its because Indy is cool af.
maybe
Those puttees tho 👌🏽
"In my opinion, those soldiers died for my country. Some of them died for a freedom they would never experience. What would we do if we had to fight for another country's freedom?"
That hit me pretty hard.
A lot of Americans have died doing just that.
The French helped us against the british in 1776
tom bats that’s why we will always be friends to France 🇫🇷 🇺🇸
Indeed. They were extremely selfless and brave.
So true. If anyone remembers, France helped us in every major conflict we have been in, including the Revolutionary War. And some minor ones.
Leave it to France to make a war cemetery look like something glorious to be laid to rest in, and have a gorgeous lady take tender care of. Excellent video.
+Drowronin well, it's designed by an American architect but yes, they are taking very good care.
I don't think that has a place here even as a joke.
Dutch Dude And just like that, on a video that is about paying respect to the dead, you insulted the memory of millions of dead soldiers and their families.... bravo
Drowronin Not to discredit this particular cemetery, but you'll find that these type of cemeteries or war memorials from the world wars are usually very well kept across Europe, as they should.
oOkenzoOo please don't act so butthurt. It is in no way an insult or whatever, it's merely a statement of the fact that the french aren't that great at warfare.
Indy are you planning world domination?
He's not short enough.
He needs a white cat!
Says Kaiser Kermit
We could only be so lucky
Very powerful video. Thank you for sharing this; a real reminder that there were people behind the numbers listed as dead.
Will try to visit some other sights too.
Westie" and I'll catch you guys...in the next video" -Westie
My great grandfather survived this battle, thankfully. Major Milton C. Portmann Sr. 89th D Company E. He was severely wounded though but did survive. May he and his brothers in this video RIP. Thankful and humbled by their service.
As an American, I thank these men for their service and I'm sad that they never made it home again.
What a gentleman Indy is. Notice towards the end he is carrying the box for her.
@@personaljesus4278yeah, she was breathing so hard, I felt so bad for her.
😢😢😢❤❤❤
My great uncle, Francis Sulley, is buried at the Meuse-Argonne American Cemetery. He died after the armistice, in January 1919 of pneumonia, probably after catching the Spanish flu. He served with a trench mortar battalion during the Meuse-Argonne offensive and that is why he is buried here. My great grandmother, Elizabeth Sulley, visited the cemetery in August 1930 as one of a group of Gold Star mothers -- the U.S. Government paid for the trip to Europe and the visit. I really do appreciate The Great War drawing attention to the cemetery with this special episode.
I should also mention that Francis Sulley was one of the Yarrowdale sailors, who was held as a prisoner of war by Imperial Germany before the U.S. entered the war from January 1, 1917 until March 11, 1917. I know Indy mentioned the Yarrowdale men during an episode of The Great War earlier this year.
I grew up on a NATO base in Belgium--we had a US scout troop (of which I was a part), and we would visit the cemetery every couple years, spend the night, and clean the tombstones.
I also attended a Canadian school on base, and visited Vimy Ridge several times on field trips.
If you grow up in that area of the world, you just can't get away from the repercussions of the war. It's everywhere.
"We don't have any Generals."
Telling, isn't it?
There are a couple of Generals buried at our other WWI cemeteries. One at Sureness and one at Aisne-Marne. Both were Brigadiers. Also one has to remember that families were given the option of repatriating the dead, so just because none are buried at Meuse-Argonne doesn't mean one couldn't have ended up there.
Did you know statistically in the American civil war it was more dangerous to be a General than to be a private. Because so many generals were killed. Examples being Stonewall Jackson, General Reynolds, General Cleburne.
Generals are not placed close to battle if it can be avoided. If killed or captured, their experience is lost, and if forced to talk, a lot of knowledge can be obtained by the enemy.
@@828enigma6 Maybe that would end the war.
Did you ask how such facilities were treated during the WW2 occupation? It makes me wonder if the Germans allowed general upkeep and turned a blind eye... or perhaps even allotted resources for it... or even closed the areas off.
Robert Strader this question has been asked on other internet forums. Summation: the Wehrmacht didn't interfere with any cemetaries during WW2 (whether Jewish gravestones were interfered with by SS or Vichy French is another question). regarding great war memorials in towns and villages, the majority were also left alone, provided they weren't showing anti-German sentiment. An Australian memorial in the Somme region was destroyed because it showed a Digger bayoneting an eagle.
marksandsparks1 Fascinating insight, who knew us Aussies would piss the Germans off in the middle of France haha
www.ww1westernfront.gov.au/mont-st-quentin/visiting-mont-st-quentin.php
Thanks for sharing the info marksandspark.
mergele my pleasure
4:27 I bet his last thoughts before he died was "I just survived the largest bloodbath in human history, and now im gonna die from the goddamn flu."
Probably a lot of people felt that way. The flu pandemic had a particularly cruel aspect - elderly people were left weakened by it but tended to survive, young people died, especially in the age group to have been called up for the military. Franz Kafka was perhaps in an intermediate group - he was affected by the flu pandemic while in his late thirties, but barely survived it, only to die of TB in 1924.
I'm pretty sure the Meuse-Argonne is ranked as the most intense battle the US ever fought in front of the biggest battle ever fought being the Battle Of The Bulge.
I bet he did not get the flu shot...
Thank you for sharing this. I recently learned that my Great Uncle is buried here. He was KIA less than a month before the Armistice. He gave his name to a nephew he would never meet, my grandfather.
Floyd H. Andrews H 29-36
So many Americans have died during that offensive. Gas,Machine Guns,rogue horses,grenade storms,trolling comrades using the lift gate were the main causes of death.
We honor your sacrifice.
5Ratar 45 It's the deadliest in my country's history with #2 being the Battle of the Bulge which was under 20,000. It's a shame that it's pretty much unknown to my fellow Americans. Even though WW1 wasn't really an American war(we were only in it for about a year and a half compared to almost 4 in World War 2), it's still the deadliest battle or offensive in American history so you'd think it would be better known than it is.
Michael Hill Growing up my best friend's grandfather was an officer who rode a glider the night before D Day and fought for his life when he was caught in the bulge. Even when I knew him in advanced age he was a huge man, around 6'4" with the most booming, commanding voice I've ever heard. He didn't talk about his experiences to us much, but his bronze and silver stars spoke for themselves.
Paul Rigsby I can imagine. They truly were the greatest generation. I'll never understand how the ones that survived didn't freeze to death(I know a lot of people did) and were still able to fight and hold off the Germans until Patton was able to relieve Bastogne.
Michael Hill yes, those Germans weren't a bunch of stooges. They where desperate by that point in the war, but never smart to poke American soldiers with a stick when their back is against the wall.
My friends grandfather did enjoy (almost as much as we did) bring out everal weapons to show us, 3 handguns and an MP-40 which he had brought back as trophies of war. He never came out and told us exactly how he obtained them, but he made it clear to us that the German soldiers didn't just hand them to him...
nicolas esteban orbes zolezzi I'm not disrespecting you, your country or any of it's many brave ventures. I'm just trying to reminisce about a personal hero of mine.
I had the honor of being able to visit this cemetery in the summer of 2019. While the video did an excellent portrayal it was nothing like visiting in person. The wall of names in the chapel listing the soldiers whose whereabouts are unknown is very sobering to say the least. The whole experience was very emotional. Absolutely make a trip here if you possibly can and bring a box of tissues.
To my 2nd great uncle, Peter S Owens, died October 18, 1918, Meuse-Argonne Offensive. Private, 325th Field Artillery Regiment. Buried Meuse-Argonne American Cemetery, Plot D, Row 22, Grave 26. R.I.P.
Thanks to everyone at The Great War channel for showing us the beautiful but somber cemetery. It is a great reminder that there were people behind the names and casualty counts. May all their stories never be forgotten.
It chills the bones to see so many crosses.
For anyone who is interested I looked up Cpl. Stowers's MOH action.
During an attack Cpl. Stowers company ran into an ambush and the German machine guns killed or wounded about half of the unit including the lieutenant commanding Stowers' platoon and the senior non-commissioned officers. Corporal Stowers, a section leader of a rifle squad, was now in command of his remaining platoon.
He crawled toward a German machine gun nest and ordered his men to follow. The platoon reached the first German trench line and knocked out the German machine gun positions. Stowers then reorganized his men and led a charge against the second German line of trenches. During this assault, Stowers was hit, but kept going until he was shot a second time. He collapsed from blood loss but ordered his men to continue and take out the German guns. Inspired by Cpl. Stowers' courage, the men forged ahead and successfully forced the Germans from the. Cpl. Stowers, then died from his wounds.
Dear France, thank you for this beautiful place where our sons and daughter rest for eternity.
it was quite moving to hear Manon refer to them as "Our Soldiers". Bless the French and other Europeans who still appreciate the sacrifices of American soldiers on their behalf throughout the 20th Century.
hey indy what's it like being the most fashionable man alive ?
Indiana Neidell hey indy so glad you saw my comment I cannot express how much your channel means to me the sheer amount of knowledge you give us all truly is amazing keep up all the great work you and the team do much love and respect Oh fashionable one 😊
It is very touching to see people in another country who care so much about our fallen.
the young lady deserves a shout out for her presentation. Nice video.
As long as those men remain in the hearts of whom their lives were given for, they did not die in vain. They served with honor and continue to show that some die so that others can be free. Thank you France for remembering those fallen
A touching and well done video, bravo!
Thanks, glad you liked it.
I've never seen a cemetery with such perfect organization. Well done.
I'm an American veteran, and I was stationed in Germany driving back from Paris one long weekend and went to see this cemetery eight or so years ago, because the signs on the highway had my travel buddies and I interested in seeing what this was. Going into it not knowing anything about it, aside from some general WWI history, you're just blown away by it. It's amazing and humbling all at the same time, especially if you're there as someone who is wearing the "same" uniform, serving the US overseas to help protect other countries, not your own. I have a picture from the middle of one of the plots that I put up every Memorial Day, and the first time I did my Grandpa, who spent some time in Europe, immediately recognized it and we had a cool conversation about the power that this place has. Glad to watch this and get more information on some of the things I saw, but didn't have a guide (stopping in on a random Sunday afternoon) to educate me about. Keep up the amazing work!
It's fantastic how much work they put into preparing each grave for a picture. Shows a huge amount of respect.
Lovely tour guide who shows great respect for American war dead that gave their lives to protect her country. That was very surprising to me coming from such a young girl. But I have had friends who have visited other war sites like Normandy and have been shown the same respect. Locals Thanking us for sending our young people to protect their home land.
I had family who fought for the Americans in the Meuse-Argonne, thanks for making this incredible video. It's very humbling to see and understand what my ancestors were up against.
Wow. The world needs more thoughtful tour guides like this woman. Her comments about the inscription on the chapel are wonderful.
It's a little weird--though extremely warming--to know that some stranger on the other side of the world, takes such good care of dead countrymen of mine that I've never known.
Consider the number of Great War cemeteries in France and Belgium for Britain, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, US. They quite like literally dot he landscape, and each one is tended with loving care. The French don't forget.
Wow simply wow 😳. I fought in Afghanistan in 2010-2011, and I could never imagine what these men and women endured and had to go through. We made a fuss when we got to our JCOP and had no internet, these men slept in the mud. We had 3 part sleeping bag sleep systems, they didn't have anything close to what we had. In honor and memory of all these men who answered the governments call to duty thank you. And thank you to everyone at the Great War for bringing light on these past situations in which much of the general public these days don't quite grasp the enormity of that situation. Thank you guys so much and keep up the "Great" work
Thank you for your comments---and your tour in Afghanistan. My grandfather was with the 39th Infantry and survived. I will visit this cemetery in November this year.
My son and I visited this cemetery several years ago as part of a battlefield tour, and it is a very profound place. One of the MOH recipients buried there is one of the pilots who located The Lost Battalion.
It was very gratifying to see that in France, Belgium, Luxembourg and Italy, memories are strong and the sacrifices of those Americans who gave their lives to keep Europe free are very much appreciated.
PS: We also visited Verdun, which is practically beyond description.
Thank you for the dignified presentation. Brought a tear to my eye to see the reverence and respect shown. liked your channel before...but this brought it to new level. MSgt USAF (ret)
It was a great, formative experience to make this video too. Glad you liked it.
Terrific special. Also, thank you France for the cemetary and dignity of the place.
"What would we do if we were called to fight for another countries freedom?" A lot of people can answer that, Vietnam, Afghanistan etc.
Exactly. Sadly, so few Americans serve in the military these days that they don’t even think about these countries. When I was in Afghanistan, a steward on the plane made a point of thanking me for traveling halfway around the world to help his country.
This is a beautiful monument dedicated to the young Americans who traveled so far from their homes and loved ones to give their all in battle. It's good to know they aren't forgotten. I wonder how many people visit this memorial each year and where they come from? Thanks for this excellent episode, Indy. Well done.
Indy. Well done. Thank you and the crew for touring the cemetery. Manon is superb; she really does honor to our fallen and to France. My grandfather fought at the Meuse-Argonne, and survived; this veteran is grateful to you for showing us the scale and scope of the cost. It is such a beautiful and solemn place. Thanks again. Byron
I agree on Manon--amazing. My grandfather was with the 39th Infantry and survived as well. I will visit this cemetery in November this year.
A brave African-American soldier called Freddie??? Valiant Hearts!
I was thinking the same thing when she mentionned the two brothers buried side by side.
I tip my hat off to the camera man. I guess it was all done on the go, but the result is simply stunning. Great job!
What a wonderful episode. Thanks Indy and Crew!
it's easy to say "14200 dead and missing" but to see them is a thought provoking experience, thank you indy and team.
Imagine surviving the war, only to die of the flu after.
Worst century ever
Every 22 hour a veteran commits suicide, long after he came back to the US
Is the proof we french have the sens of gratitude about our allies and not the cowards that many foreigners immagine.
That coward thing is a bad joke out of control. No one can call the French cowards, especially in WW1.
Well its a "joke" as Indy said.
I've served side by side some French in the D-F Brigade and the only differance I noticed was the degree of dicipiline I always felt was higher amongst Germans- but that could have been me beeing german myself.
Louis Daribert My great uncle was killed during WWI in France, and the French government sent his family a large, ornate certificate thanking him for giving his life for France. It was very moving.
The poor soul that views the french as cowards knows not his history. The dead at Verdun are proof of this.
Never forget that around 75,000 or so French soldiers held rear guard action at Dunkirk 😉
Hey Indy, this is something I wrote a few months ago for school but it sums up WW1 a tiny bit : Both sides plan their battles 100 years in the past. Both sides use weapons 100 years before the plans. One side uses bright blue and red. The other uses dull grey. One fights with the sword. The other with machine guns. The people finally wake up from their dream of heroism, gentleman fights, and honor to find that the world has changed.
impressive that its still cared for after a hundred years. I know that here in the Netherlands the war graves of the Second world war are still being taken care of by volunteers. And there is a list!! If you want to take care of a grave...get in line... That kind of dedication and historical reverance I find inspiring. Would also make a nice item for your Second World War series
This was one of the most tastefully done cemetery tours I have ever seen.
You got an awesome coat. I like the boots too. You got style, man!
What she said about "this is dedicated to the memory of those who died for their country" and that they died for hers, to liberate her country, quite literally brought me to tears. the respect for something selfless like this...
This is especially true for the volunteers who fought in the French Army.
I'm a born and bred Pennsylvania, and have lived in rural environments for most of my life. That said, I can't imagine the conditions that the AEF went through in the Battle of the Argonne Forest. Hot, rugged terrain, and hidden German sniper and machine gunners around every corner. After months of that kind of fighting, I don't think I'd ever be able to set foot in a forest again.
It was an awesome day of shooting! And the results are amazing! Proud my image made it to the banner, looks great guys! Well done!
I along with my brother and Friend visited the Cemetery two weeks ago, during our trip to Verdun.
I visited the cemetery a year ago; my grandfather's older brother is buried there. Beautiful place. Was number one one bucket list for a long time (new number one is Ypres). One comment for the tour guide - I live in Yorktown VA, and we have a French cemetery for French soldiers killed during the 1781 battle. Your countrymen fought for us; and we repaid the favor.
Very touching in the way she said " Our Soldiers" .
11:25 you can see Indy being a real gentleman :) carrying that box. Anyway on the video it is really sad and really interesting. I did enjoy this video and hope to see more in the future.
What mastermind villain is this and how do we stop him?
Does it have Schlieffen in the title?
better call Saul??
We don't. We only give in to his million year reign
Greetings from just outside of Washington, DC. Thank you Manon for all you are doing to preserve the dignity and memories of American soldiers.
Excellent episode, as always. My great-grandfather Harold Goplen was stationed in France in WWI, he was very lucky to have been in the veterinary corps, otherwise he might still be there in France and I wouldn't exist to make this comment.
This was very educational! A profound thank you Mademoiselle Bart for your time, knowledge and obvious respect for the fallen. I am a retired NCO and France's remembrance moves me deeply, as does the work of the Commission.
Honestly, I don't want to be argumentative here, but it is such an embarrassing shame our own president couldn't be bothered to visit a place like this "due to rain", but could gas protesters out of his way to wave a bible. If you're uncomfortable with that, maybe you should be. The place for the bible was here.
In Flanders fields the poppies blow.
What a great insite, Manon. Americans died not for their country, but yours and many others too. Great episode, Indy.
The Meuse-Argonne Cemetery is an amazing place. I was fortunate enough to lay a wreath for all of the soldiers, and place American Flags for the soldiers from the state of Iowa.
invite her onto the show in the studio!
So beautiful and so sad. Let us all hope that another cemetery like this will never need to be built again. RIP, brave young people....
I would like to thank you kind lady for taking care of our soldiers and Marines at this Memorial.
Bless you always
This video brought me to tears. Nothing but respect for every single one of these soldiers.
Great episode! My thanks to Manon Bart for her care of the markers and her dedication to memory of the men buried there. My thanks also to the people of France for the creation and maintenance of this monument.
I will consider to pay you more if you'll do more slick cuts like that one you've did on 12:44
Great treesition!
Toni Steller honestly you've done great work with this series I really love seeing the evolution of how you've progressed and made everything more fluid. You really do good work and I just thought I'd give you a thumbs up for it. (Even if you undercut that one part at 12:44 haha)
The photography is astounding and shows a wonderful final resting place for the WWI soldiers. What an excellent film to educate the public. It truly shows the massive effect of war by all those headstones for visitors. May their names not be forgotten
I just visited this weekend. Breathtaking and deeply moving. Driving through the countryside, over rolling farmland you realize how difficult the terrain was to fight in.
the French did fight for our freedom and we returned the favor
Twice.
The French help us financially ,we did the fighting
No, the French did not fight for our freedom. They provided financial aid and weapons in the Revolution. And they did it only because of their hatred for the British. There is no French equivalent to that cemetery in this video. Not even close.
Get your damn facts straight.
@@tomcarl8021 They also sent troops and a fleet which proved decisive for the victories at Chesapeake Bay and Yorktown. Also America never paid France back for their financial aid.
@@Heisenberg882 America paid off it's debt to France in 1790.
an very tasteful, thoughtful, and sobering special
Fantastic episode. In addition to seeing Ypres and the section of the Yser the Belgium army defended, I also visited the Langemark German War Cemetery last summer. 44,000 soldiers in mass graves. It was quite sobering.
Indi.... You are a man of class. The way you dress, your choice of guides, and of course this show. You and your group have done an amazing job on this show. The world will miss it when its over. Hope your next project, whatever it might be is as successful. Thank you so much.
The video, the guide, the cemetery, you & your channel, the chapel is best summed up at 15:30!
Staggering, I feel, is the best word to describe it. That massive graveyard, and for such small percentage of unbelievable number of casualties.
Awesome production! Its filmed really well. Great job Indy and crew.
Thanks team Great war for making this amazing documentary... It truely shows the immense scale of this conflict even after the war😟
Manon, Indy and team, thank you so much for this beautiful tour. This means a great deal to me as an American.
Indy-thanks for this episode, easily your best to date. It's one thing to see the grainy black and white photos of the dead in all your episodes. But nothing really hits home like the rows and rows of crosses over these young men who died in a far off place. It brought tears to my eyes. I hope to one day pay my respects personally. Thanks again for all you do for these young men who died so long ago. May they never be forgotten.
It was a new experience for us too.
I felt my eyes get watery a couple of times. I am Canadian of German descent. My mom's family was already in Canada by the turn of the century and so a few of them fought for the CEF. My dad's ancestors were not in Canada until later so they fought in the German army including my great grandfather. It makes me realize that it doesn't matter which side you are on, but war is fascinating, horrible, and depressing. That cemetery was huge and contained so "few" men. It really begins to hit the heart when you see that. As terrible as it is, this video was well done (as always) and with upmost care and respect, and I would like to go there someday. I also wish I could have made the 100 year anniversary of Vimy Ridge (a couple of my mom's ancestors fought there for the CEF).
This is a great history lesson. I never thought about the scale of soldiers that fought and died during WWI.
This was a really good episode.
You guys are so professional
The production quality is outstanding! Keep up the good work.
Thank you to the people of France for remembering the sacrifices made by our people. I had no close ancestors in WW1, but many others did.
WOW. Thank you. I never seen anything like that. SO MANY !! Seeing their headstones like that makes you really feel how many lives were lost because of war. We should never take our freedom for granted. They died so we would not be ruled by an outside force as extreme as the Nazis. We owe everything to them. Thanks for going there and filming this so that we can see it and learn. Thank you.
So to add some Background to the Orville C. McKim:
He was named after his Great Grandfather Seaton Taylor (Orville's actual name was Orville Seaton McKim. Somewhere between birth and marriage he changed the spelling to a "C" instead of an "S"). Born In Missouri in Agust 1890. He was the son of Daniel and Matilda McKim and one of 8 children. He was married in 1915 to Faye Dawson. Between 1915 and 1917, he and his wife moved to Wyoming where he registered for the draft. He would later enlist in Engineer corps of the U.S. Army. Orville McKim was a Private and a member of the 80th Transportation Corps Company.
I took interest in when she was talking about the 2 brothers buried side by side, one of which was in the French army. I have been reading "A Rifleman Went To War" by Herbert W. McBride. He was an American that joined the Canadian army and spent over a yr on the Western front well before the US got into it. Of course, there were Americans flying for the French and British too. I'm curious how many fought for other countries before US entry, and more to the point of this particular video, how many are buried there? I've been to France several times, but not to the WW1 battlefields or cemetery(s). My wife has an ancestor that fought @ Argonne offensive and we've been researching what his unit did; So this area of France is next on the list. Great video as always!
Awesome video guys! the drone footage was terrific in particular. Very informative too, added it to my must see list when/if i ever get over to europe. Keep up the good work!
Team Indy, thanks for visiting the cemetery of those fallen American Soldiers loving cared for. Indy seeing all the head stones as you stated does give you a little glimpse of the scale of the dead from The Great War. I have often stop at old cemeteries on the east cost of the United States, looking for the oldest sections in those cemeteries and you almost always find Civil War graves and WWI graves. Again Team Indy thanks for the visit.
I'm surprised at you, Indy. Outside our Civil War, ALL our wars have been fought for someone else's freedom. I know many would argue with that, and we have certainly fought in cynical, seemingly self-serving conflicts, and often we've left a trail of rubble and tears behind, but it's still a fact. That's uniquely American, I think
(well, Canada can say the same, just less often). Standing in a field of white crosses, all bearing the names of our fallen, moves me to my core. Thank Manon for the respect and dedication she shows them, will you?
You fought for freedom in Iraq, Afghanistan and in Vietnam?
Not to mention that in WW1 the US came on the side of colonial powers fighting against colonial powers over the question of state sponsored terrorism.
@@univeropa3363 Yes, we did. "State sponsored terrorism" -- lol, oh brother.
@@brocklanders6969 Sure, you fought for freedom in those places.
@@univeropa3363 Correct. Glad you agree.
@@brocklanders6969 Must be wonderful having one's thoughts clouded with nationalistic myths.
The filming and editing was on point. Great interview and delightful guest :)
having walked around a couple of these (althought WW2) I watched this with tears in my eyes in deep respect for these people taking the time and going through this trouble.
My Great Uncle William "Willie" Carpenter was one of the many soldiers who survived the war, but died due to the Spanish Flu before returning home. He had contracted the flu, and had been treated and returned to the field. He then, due to his weakened physical condition, contracted pneumonia and died. His parents had him returned to the U.S. and is buried in Reynolds county Missouri, near the village of Redford.
My hats off to the people of France for honoring our fallen and keeping our cemeteries immaculate after all these years.
In 1966, when President De Gaulle pulled France out of NATO, he ordered that all American troops must leave France immediately. He was asked by US Sec of State Dean Rusk, "Does that include the ones who are buried here?" De Gaulle, clearly embarrassed, did not answer and left the meeting.
So beautiful, yet so sad! Thank you Indy and team for your work!
Everytime he says "I'm Indy Neidell" I say "Hi Indy". I was wearing earphones in school while watching a video once and said that out loud. Everyone just stared at me, then I just slowly put my phone away in embarrassment.
I think this is an outstanding and poignant episode. The entire program must be life altering for the crew members. I know this particular episode will be remembered for all your lives. I imagine that you could notr conceive at the beginning how far this program would take you.
Well, we've all been to France before, it's just a day trip by car but yeah, it's cool that we can do it for "work".