What a wonderful piece of art. Just thinking about all the nuances if it puts me in awe! And as usual, Dr. Harris and Dr. Zucker infuse so much emotion and serenity into the descriptions with their soothing voices. This is a true feat for any art lover; great subjects, great commentary, and flawless execution❤
Certainly one of the most virtuosic of sculptors, if not indeed the single most virtuosic. His ability to render marble into a variety of apparent textures, as addressed here, is amazing.
I've thought this for many years. As a life-long atheist it is his sculptures alone that can bring me to weep in a kind of awe and ecstasy. I fully ascribe that to his extraordinary talent, not to any late Bronze Age set of beliefs.
I was raving to someone special last night about Smarthistory and how much I've learned here, which turned into a discussion of the Baroque (with emphasis on Caravaggio and Bernini). We had a good laugh when I shared about his version of David, so this is great to see today. And it started off with a bang! His self-portrait was great, but I was floored by that first view of The Ecstasy, then again by Santa Maria. He really was incredibly talented. I love the idea of bel composto - there really is something special about different forms of beauty in a comprehensive work. The reading was powerful... She did a great job describing her experience, yet it felt beyond comprehension... I'm reminded of how beautiful and transcendent having an intimate, devoted relationship with the Lord can be - very timely for today, post-church.
Wow Bernini was a master. I can look at this piece all day, all the elements from painting sculpture to architecture create more than an optical illusion but evoke as well a feeling of aspiration. I love art pre the reformation but this baroque style post the reformation is simply spectacular. God Bless ♥️
There should be a giant block of marble next to it to remind people that it's actually stone. Maybe a hammer and chisel with a sign that says "here, YOU try..."
I really wish there would be more to read on the internet about the stained glass window above the sculpture. I cannot for the life of me figure out why a chid is depicted in it, unless it was a slight against her from the church (which might be likely due to her circumstanses).
Honestly, I like the conversation in the original video better (which is actually one of my favorite videos on this channel), although this one has much better pictures
Yes. This is our third video about this work. We made the last one ten years ago and well, UA-cam now allows 4k; ten years ago 720p was the best resolution possible.
You should do one about Bernini’s Beata Ludovica Albertoni in San Francesco a Ripa church in Rome. The staging is not good as St. Teresa, but the touches are impressive
This Is ASMR...... I need an hour long lecture by Dr. Beth Harris and Dr. Steven Zucker 😍
I was really in ecstasy! You are the best! Thank you very much for giving us so much of your love.
What a wonderful piece of art. Just thinking about all the nuances if it puts me in awe! And as usual, Dr. Harris and Dr. Zucker infuse so much emotion and serenity into the descriptions with their soothing voices. This is a true feat for any art lover; great subjects, great commentary, and flawless execution❤
Thank you for another great episode in a fantastic series!
Bernini, always fantastic, maybe the best sculptor ever
Certainly one of the most virtuosic of sculptors, if not indeed the single most virtuosic. His ability to render marble into a variety of apparent textures, as addressed here, is amazing.
I've thought this for many years. As a life-long atheist it is his sculptures alone that can bring me to weep in a kind of awe and ecstasy. I fully ascribe that to his extraordinary talent, not to any late Bronze Age set of beliefs.
VERY CLEVER LECTURE THANK YOU
I was just watching your 10+ year old videos, didn't realise you guys still made them!
Super interesting. Their voices, and the mic's they use, are so soothing to the listener. Thanks.
Bernini is now my favorite sculpture since my trip to Rome
Michelangelo who
ha!
You reviewed my favourite sculpture in Rome (since reading Angels and Demons)! Thank you!!!
I could listen to them discuss the telephone directory I'd be *enthralled*
You guys provide great commentary and the images are high quality as well !
Thanks for noticing!
I was raving to someone special last night about Smarthistory and how much I've learned here, which turned into a discussion of the Baroque (with emphasis on Caravaggio and Bernini). We had a good laugh when I shared about his version of David, so this is great to see today.
And it started off with a bang! His self-portrait was great, but I was floored by that first view of The Ecstasy, then again by Santa Maria. He really was incredibly talented.
I love the idea of bel composto - there really is something special about different forms of beauty in a comprehensive work.
The reading was powerful... She did a great job describing her experience, yet it felt beyond comprehension... I'm reminded of how beautiful and transcendent having an intimate, devoted relationship with the Lord can be - very timely for today, post-church.
Wow Bernini was a master. I can look at this piece all day, all the elements from painting sculpture to architecture create more than an optical illusion but evoke as well a feeling of aspiration. I love art pre the reformation but this baroque style post the reformation is simply spectacular. God Bless ♥️
Such a great channel and the two presenters as well! Thank you!🙌
There should be a giant block of marble next to it to remind people that it's actually stone.
Maybe a hammer and chisel with a sign that says "here, YOU try..."
ha!
Keen observations by Beth and Steve.
All the amazing artists were in that era.
Nicely done❤
Dr. Harris and Dr. Zucker, please visit my AP Art History class in school!!! We love all of your videos
What a nice note, thank you. Please say hi to your classmates and teacher for us.
Hi Smarthistory
My name is Matias, and I'm 14 years old
Wow! Thank you -
Master piece.
I really wish there would be more to read on the internet about the stained glass window above the sculpture. I cannot for the life of me figure out why a chid is depicted in it, unless it was a slight against her from the church (which might be likely due to her circumstanses).
Honestly, I like the conversation in the original video better (which is actually one of my favorite videos on this channel), although this one has much better pictures
Not the onky one thinking this does not scream ASMR! educational too?! YES!
Wow, I felt it... like a prayer
Didn't you guys make this video before? is this a reupload?
Yes. This is our third video about this work. We made the last one ten years ago and well, UA-cam now allows 4k; ten years ago 720p was the best resolution possible.
You should do one about Bernini’s Beata Ludovica Albertoni in San Francesco a Ripa church in Rome. The staging is not good as St. Teresa, but the touches are impressive
Wow 🙏
dang - Bernini was a ferce queen
👏👏❤️👍