This season's about to bring some Heroes vs Villains vibes. I might have to stay off reddit for a while once the winners come back. Probst knows there's probably gonna be a ton of spoilers for an all-winners season.
Would've liked to have seen Todd Herzog and Chris Daughtery but I really think this cast will bring a good season and interested to see which one's going to win. Also would've interested to see Fabio just to see how different he plays after being almost 10 years older.
Yeah unfortunately due to Todd's health I thought he wouldn't be on the list but he is one winner I would like to see play again as he was one of my favourite survivor winners. Hopefully his health continues to improve.
Chris Daugherty shat on production so he was on the blacklist and Todd Herzog dealt with alcohol addiction but even tho he’s been sober a while now, production didn’t care because they were worried they’d call and Todd would pick the phone up drunk so they didn’t call him. I would’ve much preferred Todd to be on instead of Ben
Just became a Patreon Pal... found you two around 2 months ago. I produce a popular podcast and this is absolutely a “practice what thou preacheth “ moment. You both love the game as much as I do...or I love the game as much as you do...or... yeah. Keep up the great work. It’s all about heart😊
The game has evolved so much and I think players like Boston Rob and Parvati understand how the game is being played now. However, are they bigger threats than people like Tony, Jeremy, Sarah, Wendell etc who have played during the "new era" of survivor and understand this voting block that seems to be a reoccurring trend. Boston Rob and Parvati are huge threats, but Tony, Sarah, Wendell etc have mastered the current way Survivor has been played and that would scare me even more if i were playing. Also I think Amber's resume or lack there of is a huge advantage to her. I can't see people going after her over Dani, Kim or Sandra etc even though she's married to Boston Rob. She'll make it far
Great podcast. I am currently halfway through, but I just wanted to suggest this before I forgot... If you guys are planning to do a Winners Boot List Game, I would just like to recommend you guys do it before the beginning of July. The season will probably be spoiled immediately after they get home. You can just do that one way in advance. I don't think anybody would have a problem with it, and it's the only fair way to do it. Keep up the good work!!!
this cast is great but imagine -richard, ethan, brian, chris d, yul, earl, todd, boston rob, tony, and jeremy -tina, vecepia, jenna, sandra, amber, danni, parv, kim, natalie A, and michelle
I can do without Jenna and definitely without Brian though I appreciate him as a player and probably could've done without Amber but hell yes to everyone else
Great podcast. I usually don’t want to read/hear casting spoilers but this one I couldn’t resist. You guys did a great job and to see how excited you are. C’mon January 2020. That seems soooooo far away.
When I first looked at the list I saw quite a few people who stated they would never play Survivor again or I assumed never would. It's crazy how easily minds change when it's an all-winners season. I just hope it lives up to the sky high expectations and some of the iconic and old school winners make it far.
Bummed about the loss of Ashley from Survivor China. Just picked up the last merge buff from Amazon. China is one of my favorite seasons even though it started kinda slow. There weren’t any buffs from pre-merge China. Survivor MUST get back to basics. Push off from Fiji. It costs waaaay more but the locations were a huge part of the show‼️
Rich, Vecepia, Brian, Chris, Tom, Todd, Bob, Natalie, Fabio were not contacted to what I’ve heard. I don’t think Cochran wanted to come back plus he works for cbs. Earl had to decline because he had a child born within the last month. The fact that we have Jeremy, Tyson, and Amber instead of Rich, Todd, and Tina is just shocking. Also I heard they cut Tina because she is too old plus has had a few opportunities to play. I sadly predict Amber and Denise going early until I see the tribes
I’m shocked Rich isn’t back. Todd not so much, he’s still recovering from addiction and all and that should be his focus, and Tina is great for nostalgia but her in the game wouldn’t change all that much. Chris (S9) not being contacted is really crazy tome
@@liambacon7060 I just didn’t want too many winners who have played multiple times on this cast when we have one time winners I’d rather see. Plus I thought Tyson and Amber wouldn’t play again; Jeremy maybe
@@TheMurrmursonbottle JT was a bad move away from winning HvV, he was absolutely running that Heroes tribe and had he of been right about the Russell situation, he'd be the 2x Champ
@@aztecgoji His play was based on a lack of information. It's true if Russel flips they get down to six but I think the heroes would still blindside him at the end. But the problem was he trusted people well known for being villains.
My winner pick is Yul. He’s in a middle season compared to the other winners in the cast, and I think there are bigger threats than him because people will forget how good he is strategically. He’ll fly under the radar but be controlling the game just watch
Yul is probably the smartest out of all of them and he's really nice too. I've watched some interviews and he was the nicest guy. I think he's got everything it takes to win,, he's strategic, physical and is someone you want to be friends with. At the same time he plays under the radar and is adaptable. My all time favourite winner.
So to disappoint Phil but even Michele is very unlikely to win All Winners and even if Michele does win All Winners , she's going to get a purple edit all the same. Too many big players in this season. She'll likely get the Nathalie White/Chris Underwood edit
I like this, but I think the idea of winners vs “the best to never win” *name pending* would be better. Imagine a tribe with FairPlay, Rob C, Russel etc.
Chris is gonna come in on day 39 in a helicopter and he’s gonna be able to vote out the other 2 people in the F3 with an idol and 2 idol nullifiers for the other 2 (who already have idols) at a surprise 2 extra tribals where Chris is the only one left and is the only one the jury can vote for
My predictions: 1st off-Ethan-I love Ethan and hate to put him down as the first boot but he is literally a fish out of water. He hasn't played in about 30 seasons and is the only one of the cast not to really play with idols (Amber too but we'll get to her later.) I feel his social and strategic game will lack and he just won't really have the ties necessary for longetivity. In a season like this with so many huge players you're more inclined to go for the easy vote and I feel Ethan will just be blown back. 2nd off-Parvati-There's four people I think are "titans" in the game. Parvati, Rob, Sandra and Tyson and they're gonna be in a lot of trouble. Parvati I think will just stick to her flirtacious game as per usual but it'll have run dry especially by players like Adam who are super fans and can see through the facade. Unfortunately she's just got a huge target on her back and I think she'll be gone really early. 3rd off-Tony-God I love Tony but he's screwed. I think he outlives the first boot on his tribe but will just end up being too mouthy and leading to his demise. He'll always be perceived as the lier and backstabber from Cagayan and Gamechangers has done him no favours showing how easily he can be beaten. He may have an alliance in the early game with Wendell, Adam, Sarah or Natalie but they'll betray him and kick him off before he gets any further into the game before he potentially immunity idol trains his way far into the game. 4th boot-Ben-God, poor Ben, I don't think he'll be able to keep up with the calibur of play. I don't think he'll have that many people around or supporting him and he'll just be identified as someone just out of the group and will be picked off before the tribe swap. HHH was a fairly recent season and nobody wants him to go on his immunity train again. *Tribe swap* 5th boot-Sandra-Just swapped into a new tribe and spat back out I reckon. By this stage I just can invision everyone going into must get Sandra out mode to prevent her making it to the merge. The Queen won't stay queen unfort, adios. 6th boot-Rob-He'll be a shield for the likes of Wendell and Jeremy but I think by this rate I think people would be satisfied by getting him out rather than keeping the protection around. I doubt he's on a tribe off the bat with Amber nor do I think he'll be luckily swapped onto the same tribe with her but people will acknowledge by this stage the couple threat looming around the corner on the merge horizion. 7th boot-Sophie-Again, with Ben, I don't think she'll make that strong of relations. I think the emotions will get the best of her like SP and she'll just mess up her game due to them unknowingly just before the merge. 8th boot-Tyson-Yep, the merge boot, the final titan. Despite probably playing a bit of a controlling dominant game like in Blood vs Water I think with the cast realising Sandra and Rob are gone he'll just be the next person to go. And it's Tyson Apostol, the guy that said he liked to see people cry, how do you not want him out before he destroys your game? 9th boot-Kim-I know a lot are fans of Kim but I just don't see her getting far into the merge. Her game was one of the most dominant but I think her experience of playing with the braindead One world cast (I mean literally Monica and Troyzan the only two of that season to finish top 3 in later seasons were complete goats, Colton quit again and Kat cried again.) I think upon playing a slow game during the pre-merge she'll go too agressive at the merge due to her lack of experience playing against others in such a long time, near 20 seasons. Might make some strong bonds with some young guys or women but not enough. 10th boot-Yul-I don't really have much to say on Yul I just think he's that early-ish boot that is sort've just agreed upon to get out. I can see him earlier on in the game idolling someone else out so perhaps that catches up to him and gets him. 11th boot-Adam-Idk, I feel like he's a winner pick for some but I just feel his MvGx game was overrated, he got away scott free with a lot of things and I think he just won't be able to do that this time. His game will be good, like previously, but he'll make some hiccups and eventually get caught out. With youth on his side too I can see him being fairly good at immunity challenges and seen as a threat that way. However, I think a Nick, Wendell and Adam "young boys" alliance has got to happen. 12th boot-Michelle-I have high hopes for Michelle, I think she'll genuinely be one of the most underrated winners going into this by the fans and other winners and therefore I think she can get away with a lot. She's smart, pretty fit and I think she'll use her looks and cute smiles to her advantage to ease through the start. But I fear she'll play a little like Aurora in EOE where she gets too friendly with the bigger players and not with other castaways and so eventually is picked off due to losing a substantial amount of alliance members. 13th boot-Danni-Despite being now in her 40s in comparision to 20s in her season she won I think Danni will go under the radar. I can see her aligning with Kim and Michelle and can play the role of the person that sows doubts in others minds and gets others to vote for others due to a few strategic words. She'll make it mid-merge and will sneak through the cracks. 14th boot-Amber-"Oh yeah, didn't Amber like win a season?" "Yeah but it's whatever." Essentially what I think will happen in this season in regards to her. She'll play the "I havent played in so long" Ethan might play but actually use it well. Moreover with Rob gone I don't think Amber goes for a while and I think she'll be unexpectedly good with idols considering she's never had idols in her season but would've obviously learned about them through Rob. She might idol some big names out and magically get away with it that's how much I think she'll be underestimated. 15th-Jeremy-I think Jeremy pulls a Joe and is just unkillable for half of the merge. I fully expect him to do well in immunity challenges and will probably supplement any loses and vunerability with idol plays to protect himself. He's smart and I don't think he'll be targetted plus he might be viewed as an asset and worsehorse to the tribes he's on and so he'll be kept around. But I think he'll lose some immunity challenge without an idol as a back up and he'll go out about here. 16th off-Sarah-I can see her being not as underestimated as some might imagine like I think, especially by beating Tony and Sandra she'll be a recognised threat. That being said, it'll be annoying to get her out. I can see Sarah being the person you can't get out pre-merge because there's so many other legends you need to remove early and then in the merge you can't cause she is super likeable and has a lot of people in her alliance so you have to chip away at her alliance then finally go for he-and she's won immunity. That's how I feel Sarah will play out, she's just impossibly hard to get out when you want her out. 17th off-Denise-Unfortunately against the 3 others I've pitted her against Denise just hasn't got the experience in survivor in so many years that she'll probably be worse at making fire in contrast to Nick fresh out of David Vs Goliath. I think she's at that perfect stage of winning where she's acknowledged but not to the point she's freshly acknowledged and people are screaming for her to go. Being at the tribe that constantly losing in the Philliphines I think will have her battle hardened to endure what a game can throw at her, expect a fire making challenge. 3rd place-Wendell-I think he'll be seriously underrated for co-conducting one of the most dominant alliances in suvivor history. He just lives and breathes survivor and i don't think he's ever stopped getting out of "How could I have improved my survivor GI game?" And does a lot of survivor events. He'll win maybe 2 immunity challenges and might cement his name in the game with a well played idol but I think at the end he'll receive a vote or two but probably won't be responsible for the large amount of moves in the game. 2nd-Nick-Ol' Kentucky boy I don't think is losing his charm. Sure, his season was probably the most reason the winners have watched and probably know all about him but I think that works well for him. Every alliance he's had he hasn't betrayed unless they betrayed him first and he is likeable and i think the winners will just struggle to get him out expecting him to be just a young dumb boy and not really utelising his brain. Still gets some votes, maybe does a good move or two, wins an immunity challenge, plays an idol but doesn't win. 1st-Natalie-I told myself if Natalie plays in another season she would be first again so there ya go. I just see her as a sweet girl but with a cutthroat instinct like in SJDS. I think she'll play a silent but deadly game being the "puppet master" and will always be kept in the loop of what will be going on.
Parvati was targeted heavily for being a flirt on FvF... And even worse on HvV.... The cast is going to work Damm hard to get rid of her... She can't win it, but she's devious and plays nonstop.
@paula I meant OG in regards to HvV. But some of my beliefs in that post I previously had now have been updated due to more knowledge and knowing now how the tribe layout is.
Fabio would have been fantastic on this season! what a miss... Fabio has always been that WTF winner, and I think that would have been so interesting on an all winners season. My prediction is Chris Underwood enters the game on day 35, and wins after 4 days... becoming the GOAT 2x winner with like 17 total days played.
@@12354rony Just a really weak game player. If you listen to, or read, any list of the worst surivor winners, Bob and Jud are constantly the 2 named as worst, and I have to agree with that assessment.
@@rf5510 I've read some, and you have to agree as much as they claim to be objective, they are always subjactive. Now Bob and Jud are definitely not the most strong social players, they certainly had their moments from entertainment pov, and therefore I would've liked to see them on all winners. I get why Bob can't, but I'm disappointed that Jud didn't make the cut. Tbh it's kinda rare for a reality show for me, but I genuinely like most of the survivor winners lol, disliking maybe only Brian as a person.
@@12354rony I agree its subjective but its literally universally agreed. haha. But yea, I generally have liked most of the winners, or at least thought they deserved it. I was never a big fan of Brian, V, Ben, Tony, or Tyson as PEOPLE, but they played a good game and deserved the win. Likewise I like Jud, Bob, and Natalie White as people, but their gameplay wasnt top notch.
Ben Is super underrated,Ben could fly under the radar like Russell did at the beginning of HvV and could possibly start finding numerous idols ultimately getting him deep in the game
My winner pick for now is Michele Fitzgerald also, Sandra said there would never be another two time winner other than the queen. There is a 95% chance of that not happening
Not really. Sandra only competed against 3 other winners in order for her to get her 2x winner’s crown. Whereas it is default for someone to win in an all winners season against 19 other winners. See the difference?
Would have loved to see Fabio, Todd, Rich and Tina again, instead of the more recent winners (ie, Wendell, nick and adam). I guess this season will still be good since they still have the likes of Parvati, Tony and Danni on the cast.
Chris Daughtry is so underrated, and it sucks that he had the misfortune of being really close friends with Julie and getting stuck in Jeff’s blacklist.
Phil's potential tribe division did a pretty good job of splitting up the previous connections, but the first tribe seemed much more dominiant challenge wise: T1 - Rob Tony Ethan Nick Wendell Parvati Denise Danni Natalie Michele T2 - Ben Tyson Jeremy Adam Yul Sophie Sarah Kim Amber Sandra
@@TheMurrmursonbottle I almost listed Kim as the one exception from Tribe 2 I guess these starting tribes will likely only be in play for 2 rounds so it wont matter too much. They swap almost right away
The fact that Tina has been wanting all winners since 2001 just leaves me heartbroken that she is not back. She shoulda been a lock over Amber or Sarah.
In all stars amber did not beat rob, the jury beat him to the ground so the jury are the real bad winners. On russel hantz video he said that samoa had the saltiest jury. HAS HE SEEN ALL STARS AT LEAST IN THE PAST 10 YEARS!
seasons 43,44 or 45 needs to be second chance 2. we need to see players back like eddie from fans vs favorites, carter from philippines, micheal from ghost island, chrissy from HHH, hayden from blood vs water, dr mike from hhh, i’m forgetting her name but the girl who aubrey beat in fire, christian from DVG, seabass from ghost island, jay from MVGX, rick devens, and sprinkle in some older players as well. i haven’t seen many of the old seasons yet i’m still trying to get through them all. id love to see caleb from blood vs water but i don’t think he’ll play again, i’d also love to see john or baylor from BVW 2- but i also don’t think they’ll be asked back. my biggest want to see play again is keith’s son wes but i doubt they’ll ever ask him back. but yah i feel like another second chance season would be good to bring back some one time players who wouldn’t make other seasons now that there’s so many big players that they would rather cast for their third time.
Maybe Season 40 is gonna be called End of an Era. Jeff retires and they have a new host in 41, who knows Jeff probably wanted his last season to be a winners season. Boston Rob becomes the new host
I would have preferred Jenna M over Sophie. Sophie is so boring and there's not enough old school. But then again having Ethan and Jenna on together might have been awkward for them. Ethan and Jenna were a couple, even on The Amazing Race season 19 together in 2011, but split up a couple of years after that. Having exes compete would have been awkward maybe.
wanna make it crazier tyson apostle is on the list and he usually tweets something once in a while everyday kind of thing i have not seen him tweet in a while.
Ideal Team Split Blue Sandra Diaz-Twine Amber Mariano Sarah Lacina Danni Boatwright Denise Stapley Ethan Zohn Yul Kwon Tyson Apostle Jeremy Collins Nick Wilson Green Rob Mariano Tony Vlachos Adam Klein Ben Driebergen Wendell Holland Parvati Shallow Natalie Anderson Sophie Clarke Kim Spradlin Michelle Fitzgerald
Pretty much a player that never gets shown so when they do your like who's that... Pretty much players who contribute very little to the season... I think that's the idea
I don’t think overlap is that important to them - they put Tyson and Coach on the same tribe, James, Amanda, and Cirie on the same tribe, etc in HvV. and I’m pretty sure there were overlaps in Cambodia too. Plus, Parv was on the opposite side of Tyson, Rob and Sandra in their season, does that affect anything? Ethan and Amber dated, does that matter? There’s more to consider
I hope season 40 is not the last season I want plenty of years of you guys and plenty of years of making intros. Also in my area of Massachusetts, Jeremy is the legend
Stewart Palmer On some social media websites, when you reply to someone, you have to put @ and then their usernames. Basically, it’s saying “don’t come after me for my opinion” in a less serious way
Disappointed we aren’t getting Rich Todd, Earl, Fabio or Nat W. Indifferent we aren’t getting Tina, honestly don’t really find her that interesting and we’ve seen enough of her. Ethan’s the biggest shock for me and originally I wasn’t on board, but I think he could have an interesting story, I think an older Ethan will be more entertaining than the young Ethan we got twice before. Didn’t want Amber or Rob, although I new the season wasn’t happening without him. Two seasons in a row of him will be exhausting, hope he’s gone early in winners. I like Tyson, but honestly would have rather had Fabio in his place, another case of we’ve seen enough of him. I think he’ll probably do well this season. Best odds to win.... I would put Adam #1 Nat #2 and maybe Ethan #3
Go Michele Fitzgerald. I'm with you man, i hope she wins again. She's a nice pretty genuine girl. What's not to like? Finally a nice pretty girl won. I was so happy
To be honest I wanted heroes vs villains 2 instead of all winners. Some of the winners just don't have a chance to win again also I'm tired Sandra and Rob already
Day 36 Chris pops up!
Hopefully Chris D....
Lol ikr devens definitely should have won lol
Note survivor has booked Figi for 41/42 already so there is a lot of hope
The also just realized that Canada residents can apply now so I doubt they will do that if they were stopping
Plus their ratings arent really bad. I mean if you look at the ratings, they are still solid for 40 seasons.
People thought Survivor would stop at season 10, 20, etc. If they didn’t stop there, they won’t stop at 40.
This season's about to bring some Heroes vs Villains vibes. I might have to stay off reddit for a while once the winners come back. Probst knows there's probably gonna be a ton of spoilers for an all-winners season.
Heroes vs Villains season 20 was supposed to bring Micronesia 2.0 vibes, but we all saw how that turned out.
reid strand what do you mean heroes vs Villains was supposed to bring micronesia 2.0 vibes???
Winners at War definitely wasn’t Heroes vs Villians 2
@@adamsbriee6330 Yeah, I know. I said this over a year ago when the season hadn't even aired yet...
Bradley Peterson i know i wasn’t telling you that you were wrong i just was saying in retrospect. I think it would’ve better if it was
I'm here for Parvati, Yul and Tony. LET'S GET IT!!!!!
Hope Parv is able to us Tony as a meat shield... I don't think Yul will play with Parv.
It’s great Tony won eh?
Would've liked to have seen Todd Herzog and Chris Daughtery but I really think this cast will bring a good season and interested to see which one's going to win. Also would've interested to see Fabio just to see how different he plays after being almost 10 years older.
Unfortunately Todd isn’t in the best state in terms of health... but yeah I thought of Fabio too that would be cool.
Yeah unfortunately due to Todd's health I thought he wouldn't be on the list but he is one winner I would like to see play again as he was one of my favourite survivor winners. Hopefully his health continues to improve.
Chris Daugherty shat on production so he was on the blacklist and Todd Herzog dealt with alcohol addiction but even tho he’s been sober a while now, production didn’t care because they were worried they’d call and Todd would pick the phone up drunk so they didn’t call him. I would’ve much preferred Todd to be on instead of Ben
I can totally see Natalie winning this type of season as people would probably underestimate her.
💯
Welp
Gets voted out first, comes back at 5 and needs immunity either thru an idol of necklace for the rest of the game
It will be interesting to see Natalie Anderson and Kim Spradlin play against ACTUAL competitors!
Natalie has some competition but Kim didnt
Natalie has Jon Reed Jeremy and even missy and Tina were goid
SJDS had a lot of players
Everyone Kim's played against with who got to the merge in the other seasons have been Troyzan and Monica both goats in gamechangers and BvW
Kim had competitors. She was just much better.
Just became a Patreon Pal... found you two around 2 months ago. I produce a popular podcast and this is absolutely a “practice what thou preacheth “ moment. You both love the game as much as I do...or I love the game as much as you do...or... yeah. Keep up the great work. It’s all about heart😊
The game has evolved so much and I think players like Boston Rob and Parvati understand how the game is being played now. However, are they bigger threats than people like Tony, Jeremy, Sarah, Wendell etc who have played during the "new era" of survivor and understand this voting block that seems to be a reoccurring trend. Boston Rob and Parvati are huge threats, but Tony, Sarah, Wendell etc have mastered the current way Survivor has been played and that would scare me even more if i were playing.
Also I think Amber's resume or lack there of is a huge advantage to her. I can't see people going after her over Dani, Kim or Sandra etc even though she's married to Boston Rob. She'll make it far
They'll go after Kim maybe because she's a beast
Great podcast. I am currently halfway through, but I just wanted to suggest this before I forgot... If you guys are planning to do a Winners Boot List Game, I would just like to recommend you guys do it before the beginning of July. The season will probably be spoiled immediately after they get home. You can just do that one way in advance. I don't think anybody would have a problem with it, and it's the only fair way to do it. Keep up the good work!!!
this cast is great but imagine
-richard, ethan, brian, chris d, yul, earl, todd, boston rob, tony, and jeremy
-tina, vecepia, jenna, sandra, amber, danni, parv, kim, natalie A, and michelle
I can do without Jenna and definitely without Brian though I appreciate him as a player and probably could've done without Amber but hell yes to everyone else
Great podcast. I usually don’t want to read/hear casting spoilers but this one I couldn’t resist. You guys did a great job and to see how excited you are. C’mon January 2020. That seems soooooo far away.
When I first looked at the list I saw quite a few people who stated they would never play Survivor again or I assumed never would. It's crazy how easily minds change when it's an all-winners season. I just hope it lives up to the sky high expectations and some of the iconic and old school winners make it far.
PARVATI IS A CHALLENGE BEAST. Dont forget that!
She is the endurance Queen 💓
pretty she’s one of only a few three time players that one an individual immunity in each of her seasons
SO IS KIM SPRADLIN!
I just realized Ethan breaks Kelley Wigglesworth’s record for the longest gap between two seasons that a player has played
i guess he & Amber.
Ya except Ethan was eliminated like 10 months before Amber was because her game technically ended at the reunion
the segment where they talk about tony, is soooo satisfying to watch now
Bummed about the loss of Ashley from Survivor China. Just picked up the last merge buff from Amazon. China is one of my favorite seasons even though it started kinda slow. There weren’t any buffs from pre-merge China.
Survivor MUST get back to basics. Push off from Fiji. It costs waaaay more but the locations were a huge part of the show‼️
Rich, Vecepia, Brian, Chris, Tom, Todd, Bob, Natalie, Fabio were not contacted to what I’ve heard. I don’t think Cochran wanted to come back plus he works for cbs. Earl had to decline because he had a child born within the last month. The fact that we have Jeremy, Tyson, and Amber instead of Rich, Todd, and Tina is just shocking. Also I heard they cut Tina because she is too old plus has had a few opportunities to play. I sadly predict Amber and Denise going early until I see the tribes
Jeremy and Tyson, I see being okay for this cast. Amber not so much.
I’m shocked Rich isn’t back. Todd not so much, he’s still recovering from addiction and all and that should be his focus, and Tina is great for nostalgia but her in the game wouldn’t change all that much. Chris (S9) not being contacted is really crazy tome
What’s wrong with Tyson
@@liambacon7060 I just didn’t want too many winners who have played multiple times on this cast when we have one time winners I’d rather see. Plus I thought Tyson and Amber wouldn’t play again; Jeremy maybe
They should've brought back JT so he could do something stupid again.
He probably could've won if he was on this season
Aztec Goji
Game Changers says hello
He got played by Sandra once, she’d do it again
@@TheMurrmursonbottle JT was a bad move away from winning HvV, he was absolutely running that Heroes tribe and had he of been right about the Russell situation, he'd be the 2x Champ
@@aztecgoji His play was based on a lack of information. It's true if Russel flips they get down to six but I think the heroes would still blindside him at the end. But the problem was he trusted people well known for being villains.
JT is not allowed to come back over some drug related situation at The Ponderosa.... according to Russell Hantz.
My winner pick is Yul. He’s in a middle season compared to the other winners in the cast, and I think there are bigger threats than him because people will forget how good he is strategically. He’ll fly under the radar but be controlling the game just watch
Its his chance to prove that his win was not because the god idol
NeoKurow to be fair, he never had to play the idol. The way he used it and the leverage he had with it shows his strategic mind.
I think it will be
Yul / Ethan men wise have best chance
Yul is probably the smartest out of all of them and he's really nice too. I've watched some interviews and he was the nicest guy. I think he's got everything it takes to win,, he's strategic, physical and is someone you want to be friends with. At the same time he plays under the radar and is adaptable. My all time favourite winner.
Rooting for Yul!
So to disappoint Phil but even Michele is very unlikely to win All Winners and even if Michele does win All Winners , she's going to get a purple edit all the same. Too many big players in this season. She'll likely get the Nathalie White/Chris Underwood edit
Michel Ghorayeb you cant really compare chris’s edit when he only played like 13 days
I do think Michele will get far. I don’t see a scenario where she doesn’t at least make it to the final 9
Gets to the final 3 and gets 0 votes
biggest shock for me is not seeing cochran
Same
I like this, but I think the idea of winners vs “the best to never win” *name pending* would be better. Imagine a tribe with FairPlay, Rob C, Russel etc.
Fair Play isnt welcomed back. Its ridiculous to even say him. So point is moot.
Chris is gonna come in on day 39 in a helicopter and he’s gonna be able to vote out the other 2 people in the F3 with an idol and 2 idol nullifiers for the other 2 (who already have idols) at a surprise 2 extra tribals where Chris is the only one left and is the only one the jury can vote for
22:51-23:01
Boston Rob: Hold by beeuh bro. You’re wrong
My predictions:
1st off-Ethan-I love Ethan and hate to put him down as the first boot but he is literally a fish out of water. He hasn't played in about 30 seasons and is the only one of the cast not to really play with idols (Amber too but we'll get to her later.) I feel his social and strategic game will lack and he just won't really have the ties necessary for longetivity. In a season like this with so many huge players you're more inclined to go for the easy vote and I feel Ethan will just be blown back.
2nd off-Parvati-There's four people I think are "titans" in the game. Parvati, Rob, Sandra and Tyson and they're gonna be in a lot of trouble. Parvati I think will just stick to her flirtacious game as per usual but it'll have run dry especially by players like Adam who are super fans and can see through the facade. Unfortunately she's just got a huge target on her back and I think she'll be gone really early.
3rd off-Tony-God I love Tony but he's screwed. I think he outlives the first boot on his tribe but will just end up being too mouthy and leading to his demise. He'll always be perceived as the lier and backstabber from Cagayan and Gamechangers has done him no favours showing how easily he can be beaten. He may have an alliance in the early game with Wendell, Adam, Sarah or Natalie but they'll betray him and kick him off before he gets any further into the game before he potentially immunity idol trains his way far into the game.
4th boot-Ben-God, poor Ben, I don't think he'll be able to keep up with the calibur of play. I don't think he'll have that many people around or supporting him and he'll just be identified as someone just out of the group and will be picked off before the tribe swap. HHH was a fairly recent season and nobody wants him to go on his immunity train again.
*Tribe swap*
5th boot-Sandra-Just swapped into a new tribe and spat back out I reckon. By this stage I just can invision everyone going into must get Sandra out mode to prevent her making it to the merge. The Queen won't stay queen unfort, adios.
6th boot-Rob-He'll be a shield for the likes of Wendell and Jeremy but I think by this rate I think people would be satisfied by getting him out rather than keeping the protection around. I doubt he's on a tribe off the bat with Amber nor do I think he'll be luckily swapped onto the same tribe with her but people will acknowledge by this stage the couple threat looming around the corner on the merge horizion.
7th boot-Sophie-Again, with Ben, I don't think she'll make that strong of relations. I think the emotions will get the best of her like SP and she'll just mess up her game due to them unknowingly just before the merge.
8th boot-Tyson-Yep, the merge boot, the final titan. Despite probably playing a bit of a controlling dominant game like in Blood vs Water I think with the cast realising Sandra and Rob are gone he'll just be the next person to go. And it's Tyson Apostol, the guy that said he liked to see people cry, how do you not want him out before he destroys your game?
9th boot-Kim-I know a lot are fans of Kim but I just don't see her getting far into the merge. Her game was one of the most dominant but I think her experience of playing with the braindead One world cast (I mean literally Monica and Troyzan the only two of that season to finish top 3 in later seasons were complete goats, Colton quit again and Kat cried again.) I think upon playing a slow game during the pre-merge she'll go too agressive at the merge due to her lack of experience playing against others in such a long time, near 20 seasons. Might make some strong bonds with some young guys or women but not enough.
10th boot-Yul-I don't really have much to say on Yul I just think he's that early-ish boot that is sort've just agreed upon to get out. I can see him earlier on in the game idolling someone else out so perhaps that catches up to him and gets him.
11th boot-Adam-Idk, I feel like he's a winner pick for some but I just feel his MvGx game was overrated, he got away scott free with a lot of things and I think he just won't be able to do that this time. His game will be good, like previously, but he'll make some hiccups and eventually get caught out. With youth on his side too I can see him being fairly good at immunity challenges and seen as a threat that way. However, I think a Nick, Wendell and Adam "young boys" alliance has got to happen.
12th boot-Michelle-I have high hopes for Michelle, I think she'll genuinely be one of the most underrated winners going into this by the fans and other winners and therefore I think she can get away with a lot. She's smart, pretty fit and I think she'll use her looks and cute smiles to her advantage to ease through the start. But I fear she'll play a little like Aurora in EOE where she gets too friendly with the bigger players and not with other castaways and so eventually is picked off due to losing a substantial amount of alliance members.
13th boot-Danni-Despite being now in her 40s in comparision to 20s in her season she won I think Danni will go under the radar. I can see her aligning with Kim and Michelle and can play the role of the person that sows doubts in others minds and gets others to vote for others due to a few strategic words. She'll make it mid-merge and will sneak through the cracks.
14th boot-Amber-"Oh yeah, didn't Amber like win a season?" "Yeah but it's whatever." Essentially what I think will happen in this season in regards to her. She'll play the "I havent played in so long" Ethan might play but actually use it well. Moreover with Rob gone I don't think Amber goes for a while and I think she'll be unexpectedly good with idols considering she's never had idols in her season but would've obviously learned about them through Rob. She might idol some big names out and magically get away with it that's how much I think she'll be underestimated.
15th-Jeremy-I think Jeremy pulls a Joe and is just unkillable for half of the merge. I fully expect him to do well in immunity challenges and will probably supplement any loses and vunerability with idol plays to protect himself. He's smart and I don't think he'll be targetted plus he might be viewed as an asset and worsehorse to the tribes he's on and so he'll be kept around. But I think he'll lose some immunity challenge without an idol as a back up and he'll go out about here.
16th off-Sarah-I can see her being not as underestimated as some might imagine like I think, especially by beating Tony and Sandra she'll be a recognised threat. That being said, it'll be annoying to get her out. I can see Sarah being the person you can't get out pre-merge because there's so many other legends you need to remove early and then in the merge you can't cause she is super likeable and has a lot of people in her alliance so you have to chip away at her alliance then finally go for he-and she's won immunity. That's how I feel Sarah will play out, she's just impossibly hard to get out when you want her out.
17th off-Denise-Unfortunately against the 3 others I've pitted her against Denise just hasn't got the experience in survivor in so many years that she'll probably be worse at making fire in contrast to Nick fresh out of David Vs Goliath. I think she's at that perfect stage of winning where she's acknowledged but not to the point she's freshly acknowledged and people are screaming for her to go. Being at the tribe that constantly losing in the Philliphines I think will have her battle hardened to endure what a game can throw at her, expect a fire making challenge.
3rd place-Wendell-I think he'll be seriously underrated for co-conducting one of the most dominant alliances in suvivor history. He just lives and breathes survivor and i don't think he's ever stopped getting out of "How could I have improved my survivor GI game?" And does a lot of survivor events. He'll win maybe 2 immunity challenges and might cement his name in the game with a well played idol but I think at the end he'll receive a vote or two but probably won't be responsible for the large amount of moves in the game.
2nd-Nick-Ol' Kentucky boy I don't think is losing his charm. Sure, his season was probably the most reason the winners have watched and probably know all about him but I think that works well for him. Every alliance he's had he hasn't betrayed unless they betrayed him first and he is likeable and i think the winners will just struggle to get him out expecting him to be just a young dumb boy and not really utelising his brain. Still gets some votes, maybe does a good move or two, wins an immunity challenge, plays an idol but doesn't win.
1st-Natalie-I told myself if Natalie plays in another season she would be first again so there ya go. I just see her as a sweet girl but with a cutthroat instinct like in SJDS. I think she'll play a silent but deadly game being the "puppet master" and will always be kept in the loop of what will be going on.
Parvati was targeted heavily for being a flirt on FvF... And even worse on HvV.... The cast is going to work Damm hard to get rid of her... She can't win it, but she's devious and plays nonstop.
Just write a fanfic dude. I stopped reading when you called Tyson a "titan". Thats definitely fantasy.
@@rf5510 well a titan as in he's one of the OGs thats played more times than most of the winners.
@@rf5510 I had to pause when he said "Ben-God" lololol luckily I'm a fan of fan fiction so I finished it
@paula I meant OG in regards to HvV. But some of my beliefs in that post I previously had now have been updated due to more knowledge and knowing now how the tribe layout is.
Fabio would have been fantastic on this season! what a miss... Fabio has always been that WTF winner, and I think that would have been so interesting on an all winners season.
My prediction is Chris Underwood enters the game on day 35, and wins after 4 days... becoming the GOAT 2x winner with like 17 total days played.
Ugh. Thank God no Fabio.
@@rf5510 Why so? he's fun
@@12354rony Just a really weak game player. If you listen to, or read, any list of the worst surivor winners, Bob and Jud are constantly the 2 named as worst, and I have to agree with that assessment.
@@rf5510 I've read some, and you have to agree as much as they claim to be objective, they are always subjactive. Now Bob and Jud are definitely not the most strong social players, they certainly had their moments from entertainment pov, and therefore I would've liked to see them on all winners. I get why Bob can't, but I'm disappointed that Jud didn't make the cut. Tbh it's kinda rare for a reality show for me, but I genuinely like most of the survivor winners lol, disliking maybe only Brian as a person.
@@12354rony I agree its subjective but its literally universally agreed. haha. But yea, I generally have liked most of the winners, or at least thought they deserved it. I was never a big fan of Brian, V, Ben, Tony, or Tyson as PEOPLE, but they played a good game and deserved the win. Likewise I like Jud, Bob, and Natalie White as people, but their gameplay wasnt top notch.
Ben Is super underrated,Ben could fly under the radar like Russell did at the beginning of HvV and could possibly start finding numerous idols ultimately getting him deep in the game
No challenge beasts?!? Are we forgetting that Kim Spradlin won 12 challenges her season? (And she's still under 40.)
My winner pick for now is Michele Fitzgerald also, Sandra said there would never be another two time winner other than the queen. There is a 95% chance of that not happening
Maybe this time Michele will actually play a game that deserves the win
The person to win season 40 will tie for the crown of the queen SANDRA DIAZ TWINE lol
Not really. Sandra only competed against 3 other winners in order for her to get her 2x winner’s crown. Whereas it is default for someone to win in an all winners season against 19 other winners. See the difference?
Also please stop sleeping on Sophie! She performed really well individually on her season too. I think youre letting personal bias get in the way.
Would have loved to see Fabio, Todd, Rich and Tina again, instead of the more recent winners (ie, Wendell, nick and adam). I guess this season will still be good since they still have the likes of Parvati, Tony and Danni on the cast.
Jesse Chadder Todd forsure
Everybody: Season 40 is going to be the greatest season of Survivor ever. Nothing could go wrong.
Edge of Extinction: Hi
🤦🏻♂️
Chris Daughtry is so underrated, and it sucks that he had the misfortune of being really close friends with Julie and getting stuck in Jeff’s blacklist.
Phil's potential tribe division did a pretty good job of splitting up the previous connections, but the first tribe seemed much more dominiant challenge wise:
T1 - Rob Tony Ethan Nick Wendell Parvati Denise Danni Natalie Michele
T2 - Ben Tyson Jeremy Adam Yul Sophie Sarah Kim Amber Sandra
Possibly, but Rob, Tony, and Ethan are getting older, and Tyson, Jeremy, Sophie, Adam, and Kim were all good competitors
@@TheMurrmursonbottle I almost listed Kim as the one exception from Tribe 2
I guess these starting tribes will likely only be in play for 2 rounds so it wont matter too much. They swap almost right away
I wanted Chris Daugherty!!!! So glad this is finally happening though.
The fact that Tina has been wanting all winners since 2001 just leaves me heartbroken that she is not back. She shoulda been a lock over Amber or Sarah.
it's sad to think that if tina didn't play blood vs water she would be on this season.
She’s too old
tim it’s sad to think that Tina was so close to winning blood vs water and if so she’d definitely be on WAW
GO QUEEN DANNI!!!
In all stars amber did not beat rob, the jury beat him to the ground so the jury are the real bad winners. On russel hantz video he said that samoa had the saltiest jury. HAS HE SEEN ALL STARS AT LEAST IN THE PAST 10 YEARS!
The 4 people I think have the best chance to win are Yul, Sarah, Amber, and Boston Rob.
Sad Natalie White, Chris, Todd, and Brian aren’t on.
I wanted to see how Natalie would fit in with other winners
Brian is kinda a bad person and Todd’s an alcoholic
@Nathan Featherstone What is your problem? Him having different opinion that you doesn't mean he sucks. Grow up.
@@justtrent9519 Todd's sober now and agreed about Brian great player but wouldn't want to see him again.
12354rony that’s good about todd
It’s weird how close Phil was to guessing the correct tribe divisions
Bummed about them not having earl but should be fun
BB Banks Michelle and Sophie shouldn’t be on this season lol Earl would have been way better
He was highly considered by production to replace Wendell for WaW
seasons 43,44 or 45 needs to be second chance 2. we need to see players back like eddie from fans vs favorites, carter from philippines, micheal from ghost island, chrissy from HHH, hayden from blood vs water, dr mike from hhh, i’m forgetting her name but the girl who aubrey beat in fire, christian from DVG, seabass from ghost island, jay from MVGX, rick devens, and sprinkle in some older players as well. i haven’t seen many of the old seasons yet i’m still trying to get through them all. id love to see caleb from blood vs water but i don’t think he’ll play again, i’d also love to see john or baylor from BVW 2- but i also don’t think they’ll be asked back. my biggest want to see play again is keith’s son wes but i doubt they’ll ever ask him back. but yah i feel like another second chance season would be good to bring back some one time players who wouldn’t make other seasons now that there’s so many big players that they would rather cast for their third time.
Eric Wolff Caleb from BvW died in a train accident years ago :(
No Mike, Todd or Fabio is just sad :(
Maybe Season 40 is gonna be called End of an Era. Jeff retires and they have a new host in 41, who knows Jeff probably wanted his last season to be a winners season. Boston Rob becomes the new host
They're still having open calls, sometimes they don't have that casting speel right after the spring season
Anyone upset that this is pretty much the first time they used the a new person for head of casting that's Probst and made wrong Choices
Sarah is surprisingly awful at challenges she has never won an immunity challenge
Can't wait! I miss the OG's!
This is gonna be epic season. I can’t freaking wait
Survivor's hate boner for Brian Heidik is their loss.
I would have preferred Jenna M over Sophie. Sophie is so boring and there's not enough old school. But then again having Ethan and Jenna on together might have been awkward for them. Ethan and Jenna were a couple, even on The Amazing Race season 19 together in 2011, but split up a couple of years after that. Having exes compete would have been awkward maybe.
So apparently they’re including the edge of extinction twist as a part of season 40
wanna make it crazier tyson apostle is on the list and he usually tweets something once in a while everyday kind of thing i have not seen him tweet in a while.
Can’t wait for this season :)
Does anyone know when survivor 40 is being filmed?
I heard next week
How did you find the cast?
You got the link?
Ja La it’s all over the internet
After Season 39 you guys have to do a winners ranking from worst to best 39-1
Hey Phil there is a open cast auditions in Michigan this summer so it not ending at 40
Man Inside survivor could really dupe us all, I would believe anything Redmond said at this point. Great preview!
Boston Rob is about to play for his 5th time lol
First person
Would you play survivor if you had the chance
My early pick is Sarah Lacina. Off-the-radar for a season with all winners and great at playing the middle-ground game.
Ideal Team Split
Blue
Sandra Diaz-Twine
Amber Mariano
Sarah Lacina
Danni Boatwright
Denise Stapley
Ethan Zohn
Yul Kwon
Tyson Apostle
Jeremy Collins
Nick Wilson
Green
Rob Mariano
Tony Vlachos
Adam Klein
Ben Driebergen
Wendell Holland
Parvati Shallow
Natalie Anderson
Sophie Clarke
Kim Spradlin
Michelle Fitzgerald
What's a purple edit?
Pretty much a player that never gets shown so when they do your like who's that... Pretty much players who contribute very little to the season... I think that's the idea
@@dayleigh6164 Oh, that must come from Purple Kelly then lol. Thanks!
So bummed if Hatch and Todd aren't there. But this is a pretty believable list, aside from Amber.
Spoiler: Sarah wins
I don’t think overlap is that important to them - they put Tyson and Coach on the same tribe, James, Amanda, and Cirie on the same tribe, etc in HvV. and I’m pretty sure there were overlaps in Cambodia too.
Plus, Parv was on the opposite side of Tyson, Rob and Sandra in their season, does that affect anything? Ethan and Amber dated, does that matter? There’s more to consider
I hope season 40 is not the last season I want plenty of years of you guys and plenty of years of making intros.
Also in my area of Massachusetts, Jeremy is the legend
Smart guys like tony Wendell and Jeremy will want to keep rob and that around till the merge for shields I’d say
And we were right
I 100% thought you meant Sandra when you said the queen
Natalie Tenerelli is baby sitting Rob and Amber's babies
Boston Rob would have done six seasons after season 40 in-which one is as a coach
Is this confirmed that its 20 people?
S Ch yes
Amber Mariano is winning Survivor 40. Don't @ me.
Either her or Boston Rob is going early. No way they let them both get to the merge
Danni will win
What does don’t @ me mean?
Stewart Palmer
On some social media websites, when you reply to someone, you have to put @ and then their usernames. Basically, it’s saying “don’t come after me for my opinion” in a less serious way
Brian Heidik gonna win again... Oh wait CBS hates him 😒
Tina didnt mad the cut because of age. In blood vs water it was qustion will she mad it MEDICAL
Hoping for minimal idols.
Im hoping for maximum idols
My winner pick is Sarah
Is Rob not a challenge beast just because of his age now? I wouldn't count him out of winning a few immunity challenges
SANRA has to play aggressive in Gc but this is all winners i bet she will back like how she plays on her original season
Rooting for Yul, Danni, Michelle, Ethan, Kim, or Tony
everyone from season 30 and on will make to jury but go early merge
Todd isn’t on because he is recovering from an alcohol addiction, it’s bad :(
My winner pick is Yul calling it now
Ethan, Nick, Sarah, and Adam for the win!!!!
TONY IS THE GOAT
Wow he predicted tony from a year ago
First boot has to be Sandra right just because she’s won twice
Natalie and Aras
Damn I wanted to see Heidik again. No him or Chris is disappointing to me.
Lance Matthews Heidik has had some legal problems over the years
No challenge beasts? When Parvati played Micronesia she made the record for most challenge immunity wins of any player.
46 minutes reaction? Lmao
Michele fan
Disappointed we aren’t getting Rich Todd, Earl, Fabio or Nat W.
Indifferent we aren’t getting Tina, honestly don’t really find her that interesting and we’ve seen enough of her.
Ethan’s the biggest shock for me and originally I wasn’t on board, but I think he could have an interesting story, I think an older Ethan will be more entertaining than the young Ethan we got twice before.
Didn’t want Amber or Rob, although I new the season wasn’t happening without him. Two seasons in a row of him will be exhausting, hope he’s gone early in winners.
I like Tyson, but honestly would have rather had Fabio in his place, another case of we’ve seen enough of him. I think he’ll probably do well this season.
Best odds to win.... I would put Adam #1 Nat #2 and maybe Ethan #3
Forgot about Danni, she’s #2 for me and the person I’m most excited to see return
Go Michele Fitzgerald. I'm with you man, i hope she wins again. She's a nice pretty genuine girl. What's not to like? Finally a nice pretty girl won. I was so happy
Danni will win pls
To be honest I wanted heroes vs villains 2 instead of all winners. Some of the winners just don't have a chance to win again also I'm tired Sandra and Rob already