I'm almost surprised it released in this playable of a state where it's weaknesses are contained instead of overarching game-ruining flaws. A trade-off instead of a gimmick.
Ran into a Unicom player in the Mecklenberg yesterday. It was like playing against a thunderer or conqueror minus a little alpha. 5 fires in 5 salvos. Wonderful experience. Developers at WG must have been pyromaniacs as children with their fascination with fires
Beyond annoyed this was a steel ship and not coal. I saw it way back when it was first announced and said “of course the German BB that looks fun is steel. Guess it’ll be another 5 years before I can save up enough to get it. GG.
@@willytheekid been playing 2 years this month and I've just got my 3rd steel ship. It's also a lot easier now to get steel than it was when I started.
My own verdict: I got one with the coupon and drive it as a survival build, long range ship primarily, then brawl later in the game. 10 points captain, so still some potential there. I usually do around 100k damage. I have a little bit of buyers regret chosing it over the the Bourgogne, which would probably pull in bigger numbers (I'm extrapolating my experience from Thunderer and Ohio here, based on the Bourgogne's stats). BUT the Mecklenburg guns are just so much fun! Insanely accurate over 25km even, every salvo is 8-10 hits, and if shooting HE, almost every salvo is a fire. However, the gun damage seems anemic. I often land several hits for 4-5k total. AP pens quite often, but citadels rarely. It's not very effective in damage numbers or alpha strikes, but hitting 10 shells or such consistently is good fun. Armor seems good. I didn't yet get citadelled even sailing broadside to BB, the speed lets one disengage quite well. Almost every match had 2-2.5M potential damage, I think 2.5M was close to my personal best even. The turret angles are extremely meh, but if you rarely ever get citadelled, that's partly mitigated.
100k for a T10 BB is not that much. 150+ should be possible in most games, otherwise that ship is not good. What i saw her back gunangles are bad, meaning you give alomst broadside to use them or only use the front. If you use front only a Bourgogne, Yammy or Shikishima is way more fun.
The 305 guns get easily incapacitated in any German ship not only the Mecklenburg but the Agïr and the Odin have the same fate, the turrets plating being just 305 do not get the armor like the other german fellows do. And they're so large they eat most of the shot while bowtanking. i remember 1 game that a couple of Kremlins focused me down and destroyed all main turrets on the Agïr.
One of those u go through a hell of ranked with a smile on your face.. getting steel, knowing what u get for all the pain 👍 Put Lutchens on it, keep your distance,use her range and shes so much fun with that amount of guns. Pretty accurate,but not the best brawler imoo. She's like a hughe Mainz,a great firestarter 😂
So looks like it is a Malburough only able to actually hit things and have a bare able reload time. It's German so I give it two or three months before WeeHee needs its accuracy into the ground hard.
I want to put Aux Mod in Slot 6 and let loose a billion flak with my DFAA so bad. Take it from a guy with an AA Montana, the AA values on Mecky feels impactful.
If you want to play more satisfying AA builds, try full AA spec Petropavlovsk, if you haven't already. Petro is still great even without any gun buffs, and its 6.9km range on the AA, its flak and continuous are really good
@@symenbrug1992 I have yet to grind a Petro, but from my AA build US CA/L and AA Hipper, I can’t wait. Too many potato CVs that rely on the fact that CVs are strong and not actually dodging flak exist atm.
This looks a bit ridiculous. And having a four barrel turret being more accurate than two barrel ones is hilarious, considering the reason the German navy went with two barrel turrets was for improved accuracy… but hey, it’s not as if this inconsistency hasn’t been there for years already…
No not at all accuracy had nothing to do with it It was rate of fire and through rate of fire correction of fire could be achieved. Their magazine hoists couldn’t also facilitate more than 2 barrels too. They had designs on 3 barreled turrets irl but they knew their hoists needed refinement to keep up with their preferred naval doctrine.
@@Momofukudoodoowindu In triple or quadruple barrelled turrets the barrels are closer to each other and more prone to interfere with each other making them less accurate. That’s irl of course, not in WoWs.
Does the lower HP balance the good points or will this be another Steel ship that will get nerfed later? Not a huge fan of grinding a resource like Steel, purchase a ship, then have WG (repeatedly) nerf it many months or even a year after release.
The lower HP along with the lack of ability to overmatch, well….anything, keeps her in check. She’s basically a giant Hindenburg. I’d like to think she won’t get nerfed, but WG is WG.
@@sealordmountbatten i love both ends . For example in one ranked battle with a Salem i ended the life of a flank contain Incomp and Hiki by myself alone . Incomp melted fast and i was exposed to both of them . And that gave me the impression that is incomp in a real bad ship
Low hit point pool, 305mm shells, and no hydro playing against super ships? No thanks. I have all of the German BBs, up until now. Great video though, +1
She's a good ship, but consider what Mecklenburg can do, Bourgogne can also do, some aspects even better, Bourgogne have bigger guns, better turret angles( Mecklenburg turret angle is even worse than Kufurst, has reload booster, a little bit better turning circle.
Can anyone pronounce our region worse than the rest of Germany? Sea Lord Mountbatten: Yes, I can! The first "e" has a longer pronouncing like an "e" in English. It's more like an "i". And the "g" at the end is pronounced like the "ch" in the word "French".
The sheer mass of this things volume of fire is enough metal to rebuild half a Bismarck.
I'm almost surprised it released in this playable of a state where it's weaknesses are contained instead of overarching game-ruining flaws. A trade-off instead of a gimmick.
Worth putting Lutjens on, with the # of guns and the reload time you can activate his main battery loader skill and make the reload even faster.
Ran into a Unicom player in the Mecklenberg yesterday. It was like playing against a thunderer or conqueror minus a little alpha. 5 fires in 5 salvos. Wonderful experience. Developers at WG must have been pyromaniacs as children with their fascination with fires
My experience too. I overwhelmed Thunderers with fires in this thing repeatedly.
That was me
Beyond annoyed this was a steel ship and not coal. I saw it way back when it was first announced and said “of course the German BB that looks fun is steel. Guess it’ll be another 5 years before I can save up enough to get it. GG.
do some ranked and you will soon get it, its not that hard
@@Dave_Allen So for the average player...it should only take about two years! 😂
@@willytheekid been playing 2 years this month and I've just got my 3rd steel ship. It's also a lot easier now to get steel than it was when I started.
@@willytheekid looking at the average player's winrate and statistics, _good._
Wg have clearly lost thier minds with the premium ships at this point
19 second reload on 16 305mm guns!!!
Which are accurate.
This is a German ship right?
Currently saving my steel for Ragnar, but maybe I’ll get this thing in the future
The mecklenburg's design does seem to be based off some of the h class design proposals, the turrets however are just WG being on drugs
nah, the Germans did designed some quad mounts
still, 16 guns is pretty nice
a German battleship with quad turrets and 16 main guns? COME TO PAPA MEIN PRECIOUS!
Why didn't they make Malborough guns more on line with these, can't wait to get her, just need 2k more steel
My own verdict: I got one with the coupon and drive it as a survival build, long range ship primarily, then brawl later in the game. 10 points captain, so still some potential there. I usually do around 100k damage.
I have a little bit of buyers regret chosing it over the the Bourgogne, which would probably pull in bigger numbers (I'm extrapolating my experience from Thunderer and Ohio here, based on the Bourgogne's stats).
BUT the Mecklenburg guns are just so much fun! Insanely accurate over 25km even, every salvo is 8-10 hits, and if shooting HE, almost every salvo is a fire. However, the gun damage seems anemic. I often land several hits for 4-5k total. AP pens quite often, but citadels rarely. It's not very effective in damage numbers or alpha strikes, but hitting 10 shells or such consistently is good fun.
Armor seems good. I didn't yet get citadelled even sailing broadside to BB, the speed lets one disengage quite well. Almost every match had 2-2.5M potential damage, I think 2.5M was close to my personal best even.
The turret angles are extremely meh, but if you rarely ever get citadelled, that's partly mitigated.
100k for a T10 BB is not that much.
150+ should be possible in most games, otherwise that ship is not good.
What i saw her back gunangles are bad, meaning you give alomst broadside to use them or only use the front. If you use front only a Bourgogne, Yammy or Shikishima is way more fun.
The 305 guns get easily incapacitated in any German ship not only the Mecklenburg but the Agïr and the Odin have the same fate, the turrets plating being just 305 do not get the armor like the other german fellows do. And they're so large they eat most of the shot while bowtanking. i remember 1 game that a couple of Kremlins focused me down and destroyed all main turrets on the Agïr.
One of those u go through a hell of ranked with a smile on your face.. getting steel, knowing what u get for all the pain 👍
Put Lutchens on it, keep your distance,use her range and shes so much fun with that amount of guns.
Pretty accurate,but not the best brawler imoo.
She's like a hughe Mainz,a great firestarter 😂
She's a Hindenburgh in Battleship form
16:53 is that a saw you're using to cut up your latest murder victim?
still torn between this and incomparable. I'd be running secondaries on this thing definitely.
Have both, I would go for this first, it’s VERY strong
That was helluva hello!
So looks like it is a Malburough only able to actually hit things and have a bare able reload time.
It's German so I give it two or three months before WeeHee needs its accuracy into the ground hard.
What have you done? Now the Marlborough masochist will come to your comment section.
Got chonked hard by one in my Cherbourg. Those HE shells fucking hurt jeez
Thank you SLM. picking up my Mecklenburg..
I built mine with a main battery/secondary build with Lutjins as my captain
Are you glad you bought Mecklen?
I want to put Aux Mod in Slot 6 and let loose a billion flak with my DFAA so bad.
Take it from a guy with an AA Montana, the AA values on Mecky feels impactful.
If you want to play more satisfying AA builds, try full AA spec Petropavlovsk, if you haven't already. Petro is still great even without any gun buffs, and its 6.9km range on the AA, its flak and continuous are really good
@@symenbrug1992 I have yet to grind a Petro, but from my AA build US CA/L and AA Hipper, I can’t wait.
Too many potato CVs that rely on the fact that CVs are strong and not actually dodging flak exist atm.
Press 1 for SLM sounding like a drunken seal :D
After how long do you get a armory ship coupon? One yearly?
You get another resource coupon at christmas.
Every 6 months. They're on set timers I believe, you get 1 in June and another in December.
June 19th is the next one.
Looks like they put another gun on the Pommern and then uptiered it. I still want it though! :)
Pommern got 380s, this guy got 305s but better
It's closer to the Brandenburg. Same caliber guns, just one more per turret. No hydro, and fast.
This thing is basically a Thunderer
This looks a bit ridiculous. And having a four barrel turret being more accurate than two barrel ones is hilarious, considering the reason the German navy went with two barrel turrets was for improved accuracy… but hey, it’s not as if this inconsistency hasn’t been there for years already…
No not at all accuracy had nothing to do with it
It was rate of fire and through rate of fire correction of fire could be achieved. Their magazine hoists couldn’t also facilitate more than 2 barrels too. They had designs on 3 barreled turrets irl but they knew their hoists needed refinement to keep up with their preferred naval doctrine.
@@Momofukudoodoowindu
In triple or quadruple barrelled turrets the barrels are closer to each other and more prone to interfere with each other making them less accurate. That’s irl of course, not in WoWs.
Does the lower HP balance the good points or will this be another Steel ship that will get nerfed later? Not a huge fan of grinding a resource like Steel, purchase a ship, then have WG (repeatedly) nerf it many months or even a year after release.
The lower HP along with the lack of ability to overmatch, well….anything, keeps her in check. She’s basically a giant Hindenburg. I’d like to think she won’t get nerfed, but WG is WG.
If you had the choice between a FDR, SHIKASHIMA or the MECKLENBURG what would you chose?
FDR
i wish i had the strength of saving steel to buy steel ships :'D
but man iam too lazy to keep the steel
I still can't decide between this and the Bourgogne.
Bourg will always probably be the better comp choice, but honestly unless you’re going for super Meta CB play then get whatever looks fun to you.
Bourgogne is more fun. I have both.
Same..have both and Bourg is better ..
This thing is 2 Jean Barts with better armor.
A fixed Marlborough?
Would you chose this ship over Incom ?
Incomparable is a goofy fun ship, this one is a bit more competitive. So if it was for fun, Incom, for more serious play, Meck
@@sealordmountbatten i love both ends . For example in one ranked battle with a Salem i ended the life of a flank contain Incomp and Hiki by myself alone . Incomp melted fast and i was exposed to both of them . And that gave me the impression that is incomp in a real bad ship
its basically the german colombo
do you think pommern is better then macklenburg?
its the pommern hull
Low hit point pool, 305mm shells, and no hydro playing against super ships? No thanks. I have all of the German BBs, up until now. Great video though, +1
Nice match.
Every one of these I’ve run into just spams he from range.. maybe they are playing it wrong, but I have no desire to get it rn.
I play it with AP and it's just as good.
Guess we aren’t getting that Bourgone review for another year then, huh?
Gonna get it when the PR dockyard comes out
@@sealordmountbatten is realease date on puerto rico dockyard? and it is worth it I I have Alaska?
Why couldn't they give this sigma to Odin?
This or Bourgone?
Bourgogne.
Use rtx voice to take out the background noise :)
She's a good ship, but consider what Mecklenburg can do, Bourgogne can also do, some aspects even better, Bourgogne have bigger guns, better turret angles( Mecklenburg turret angle is even worse than Kufurst, has reload booster, a little bit better turning circle.
Yeah, it is less accurate tho
Bourgogne is more aggressive tho, ain’t have torps
Tier 10 brandonburg :-p
How you could called ship good for brawling but you use tank build?
The firing angles of the back turrets are real bad!
I bought the Incomparable instead
Brandenburg on steroids
So now would it besafe to say that german dispersion is a thing of the past ? Due to evolution of the game and power crept?
Torpedo range of six seconds? Hmmmmm. Sounds very short range,,,
topshit ship at the moment
I regret downloading the game again. I'm seriously considering uninstalling it again.
🤣
Can anyone pronounce our region worse than the rest of Germany?
Sea Lord Mountbatten: Yes, I can!
The first "e" has a longer pronouncing like an "e" in English. It's more like an "i". And the "g" at the end is pronounced like the "ch" in the word "French".
As a fellow Hessian, thanks for the clarification. In middle German we make the first "e" short and the "g" a "k". I'll keep it in mind.
A Ship or Tank that WG just made up? Get out of town!!!
And of course it's a stupid steel ship, imagine a good tech line BB
Good AA dont exist in wows
russian cvs dont care about aa anyways
I really hope your not a maths teacher lmao
Am not, for obvious reasons lol
I really hope YOU'RE not an English teacher 🙂
17 sec long rudder, horrible turret angles with low hp pool and for that reason am out
Go with rudder mod, then.