Dead will always be my favorite. He always had something special about his voice. It can be very rich or very painful. He really dedicated himself to the craft of his music
Exactly, it's not a debate between the real black metal followers, his voice was uncomparable with anyone else who tried to fill his shoes he lived black metal breathed it ,not taking away from the other singer's the band has had but he's the best one🤘🏽 😈🤘🏽
Dead although I do think a lot of people think it's him singing on the Deathcrush EP so if that's you then listen to Live in Liepzig to hear his vocals
Atilla has the most evident vocal range. He can go from true black metal shrieks, to operatic singing, to wolfish barks, to these menacing mumbles. In terms of technique hes one of the best in the genre.
Maniac and Dead are angsty and dark, but Attila is just pure evil. It's like this upside down inverted Satano-Ugric mass of perversion where sometimes he will straight up go into religious chant.
I really felt sorry for Dead. So young and eaten up by fucking depression. His soul was lost, he was surrounded by pure darkness. But he was an icon and will never be forgotten. The best singer may have been Attila because of his immense range.
Dead has proper open screams. They’re not growls, they’re not shrieks, they’re open screams that have such a unique croak and grimness to them. Listen to the song carnage. Maniac, Dead, and Attila are all fantastic.
Dead is the epitome of a black metal vocalist. Yet Attila is one of the most unique. That being said, Dead. The raw aggression and pain in his voice I the true match to the music. Dawn of The Black Hearts is where Dead really shines. Musically. Lol.
*Overall Atilla first place... Because he have the most advanced vocal technics... With the best vocal range and the most sinister voice... He is the one credited for the vocal parts on the most popular black metal album ever made in history, "De Mysteriis Dom Sathanas"... He's also the one that have cumulated the most year of activity and the biggest quantity of credited stuff with the band... He remain the present vocalist and for see him performing live two month ago... The only think i can say is that for his age he remains at the top of the best active 90's black metal vocalist now... And obviously his outstanding vocal and theatrical talents continu to be realy impresive and unique to this day. *I will put Maniac on second place... Not necessary for is vocal performances that i think at some points are slightly equal to the one's delivred by "Dead"... But more because the fact he is the second vocalist of the band history and he is the second one with the most vocals contribution credited... Is personal attitude and is live performances are purely chaos and savagery... I think at some point he is the most fückəd up members that the band had ever have at an equal position with "Dead" but clearly for different reasons... Maniac erratical behaviors are the principal reason he got kicked out of the bands by Necrobutcher and Hellhammer... Because he drinking realy too much and acted like a Cahotic trouble maker during and outside live performance... Obviously he is the one credited for the vocal parts on the band second most popular album/ep "Deathcrush"... This masterpiece are the one that helped start and propulsed the band popularity... But also that the album that propulsed the entiere second wave of Norwegian black metal to what they are between 1987 and 1994... And by paving the way for all the next steps for propulsing and popularising the second wave of black metal... Not just at a national level but also at a worldwide one during that same era... Outside of the Deathcrush ep, "Maniac" best performances rest the one's he made on Wolf Lair's Abyss ep and Grand Declaration of War full-length. He's not outperform Atilla vocals so he got second place. *I put Dead the most legendary of this three vocalist... At the third place. Obviously Dead are maybe the most legendary member (beside band founder & guitarist Euronymous)... But sadly he is also the one with the less albums credited between Atilla, Maniac and himself... His vocals range sound pretty clear and at some points very very creepy... He got a vocal pitch that are unique and easy to identify from the others... He's also the only frontman that have not to invent or play a role during is lives performances... His short contribution with the band (early 88 to April 91) are legendary but also mark the most important period... For the band evolution and for the entire evolution and developing of the Norwegian second wave of black metal... Specificaly because of is live performances during the 1990 band tours and lives gigs... With the most popular and the most legendary gigs locations at (Jessheim, Sarpsborg, Zeitz & Liepzig)... Dead definitely shaped the dark imageries of MayheM during that specific period and era of time (88-89-90)... By his theatrical live performances and by his use of corpses paint (that he got credited for popularising all over the genre for the second wave)... But also definitely by his dark imageries and obsessions with death and his self mutilations behaviors during MayheM live performances... Like that one time at Jessheim (theirs first gig of 1990 band tour)... Where he cut himself so deep and badly thst he got to be taking to the hospital for important blood lost... Sadly his suicide and all the rumours and storys surrounding that tragical event... Definitely helped, shaped and cimented the band credibility and the overall credebility of the genre... Regarding dark, evil, satanic, and death related imageries... Linked to the entiere genre of Norwegian second wave of black metal. For a black metal vocalist his personal legacy are obviously the most important of all... But due to the small quantity of credited and released stuff... And due to the fact that he's not technicaly outperform the vocal quality and performances of Atilla or Maniac... He got the third place as a vocalist but will remain forever as the most legendary band member. 🔥🖤🤘🏻
Though Dead is my favourite (Live In Leipzig won me over), Maniac is such a good vocalist, dude. He definitely made Deathcrush HIS release. Bloody brilliant stage presence as well.
Maniac did a hell of a Job on declaration, and atilla's the most versatile and talented over all. But i just adore dead. Maybe I'm partial because I'm still sad that such a talented young man was taken from us so early. But he was so dedicated to his stage presence, and his voice was just... Just, R.I.P man 😢
Dead, because Live in Leipzig gives me chills galore. Atilla’s performance on DMDS is sinister as fuck and I love it. Maniac’s performance on Chimera is stellar too! No favorite based on vocals alone, but no doubt Dead is the most iconic. RIP
I choose Maniac and Dead, each voice is unique in its own way. Each of their characters, each of their voices, are very cool. Each album and song is unique, and so are their performances at the concert😟
I think the name speaks for me! But I also think there's a hell of alot of Mayhem and Other kick ass vocalists who were influenced by DEAD. And some whose vocals were even Better because of DEADs influence!
Each had or have their strengths. Dead literally sounded like a living corpse. Maniac had an absolute classic and iconic black metal rasp and Attila has such an extreme range he's kinda hard to beat. He's like the Mike Patton of extreme metal. It's a tough one but I'm going to have to go with Attila.
@@Deadpool-px2nm I do know what they meant. I just think it’s ridiculous to say it considering there is very little footage of him, so know one even knows what kind of person he was, and saying they miss him applies that they were keeping up with him while he was alive, and I’m guessing not
They’re all great in their own right. Dead was my favorite as you could hear the pain in his voice that I feel fit the atmosphere of the music. You could tell he was putting everything into it. Attila is amazing to see live, though. His stage presence may seem goofy from videos but it’s cool to see live with the music, and his voice sets a different mood entirely
I guess Messiah has no place here? For those unaware the vocal tracks on Deathcrush were done by both, Maniac and Messiah. I really liked Dead. He was that perfect fit for the band. But Maniac and Attila def put in their work! I still think De Mysteriis and Wolfs Lair is still their best work!
For me its Attila, he is really cool vocalist, and Dead... For me its just crazy metalhead, who killed himself, and Euronymous just use his death to promote his group
Dead had thorns in his throat.
Is that good or bad ?
@Nirvanalovertaylor911 It's incredible.
@@Tatvashastramu I have thorns up my ass
this is the moest black metlal thing iv heard in a while
Dead will always be my favorite. He always had something special about his voice. It can be very rich or very painful. He really dedicated himself to the craft of his music
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
He also lives up to his name which u should give him credit for
@@kuutamoxtf???
@@kuutamox "lives up"
@@carlospereyra9148lives down
Dead rules! He worked his ass off and died with his genre that will forever be in our hearts R.I.P!
Yea and the maker of the band got killed by that nazi guy who stabbed him
Poser.
He Is a fucking satanist... He Will never R.I.P
Dead. I didn't think this was even up for debate 😂
You will be surprised 😉
It shouldnt even be up for debate. And I am sursprised!
Exactly, it's not a debate between the real black metal followers, his voice was uncomparable with anyone else who tried to fill his shoes he lived black metal breathed it ,not taking away from the other singer's the band has had but he's the best one🤘🏽 😈🤘🏽
Attila is probably the most technically talented, but Dead and Maniac just fit the vibe of the band a thousand times better.
Pelle had unbelievable vocals, not too raspy or guttural but Attila brought something unique to Black Metal with his vocals
I feel like Attila uses to much nostrils in his vocals.
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
maniac was the best but dead is the most iconic
So glad someone has recognised maniac as the best
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
fr bro
This
Totally you're right, 👍
Dead although I do think a lot of people think it's him singing on the Deathcrush EP so if that's you then listen to Live in Liepzig to hear his vocals
Deathcrush- maniac
DE mysteriis- Attila
Grand declaration- maniac
Chimera- maniac
Wolf's lair- maniac
Everything after is Attila
Yeah, a lot of people think dead was singing on Deathcrush
@@GoatHeadTeddeathcrush is maniac and messiah
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
I was one of those people for far too long
Atilla has the most evident vocal range. He can go from true black metal shrieks, to operatic singing, to wolfish barks, to these menacing mumbles. In terms of technique hes one of the best in the genre.
And I'll bet even He will admit to influence from DEAD!
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
Any vocalist can do those stupid sounds but they don’t want to
Many don't find them stupid. Me neither. Question of personal taste. I think they were all different and difficult to compare..@@naturalianoss
You can't and you're butt hurt about it@@naturalianoss
Maniac had those banshee-like screamy mumbles that made deathcrush the legendary blood red thrash-black-metal masterpiece of a production that it was
Maniac is the most sinister, but Dead was iconic.
Attila sounded more sinister.
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
Greta Thunberg
@@-d2775
Lmao
Attila is still their current vocalist. Just watched them live a few days ago
Maniac and Dead are angsty and dark, but Attila is just pure evil. It's like this upside down inverted Satano-Ugric mass of perversion where sometimes he will straight up go into religious chant.
Atilla his stage presence is beyond badass!
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
I really felt sorry for Dead. So young and eaten up by fucking depression. His soul was lost, he was surrounded by pure darkness. But he was an icon and will never be forgotten. The best singer may have been Attila because of his immense range.
dead all the way 🖤🤍 nobody could ever beat his vocals. R.I.P Pelle 🖤
dead ,the first, the legend
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
The first?
Maniac was before Dead
Freezing moon with deads vocals is my favorite music from them. That boy had something special
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
I like all 3 but there was something special about Dead. How did he have such a deep and scary voice at such a young age??
110% Attila... he made DMDS Special
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
Dead has proper open screams. They’re not growls, they’re not shrieks, they’re open screams that have such a unique croak and grimness to them. Listen to the song carnage. Maniac, Dead, and Attila are all fantastic.
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
Dead was probably my favourite, he just had that sound in his voice RIP
Pelle is undefeated. RIP PER.
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
They all have amazing vocals.
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
Dead is the epitome of a black metal vocalist. Yet Attila is one of the most unique. That being said, Dead. The raw aggression and pain in his voice I the true match to the music. Dawn of The Black Hearts is where Dead really shines. Musically. Lol.
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
*Overall Atilla first place...
Because he have the most advanced vocal technics... With the best vocal range and the most sinister voice... He is the one credited for the vocal parts on the most popular black metal album ever made in history, "De Mysteriis Dom Sathanas"... He's also the one that have cumulated the most year of activity and the biggest quantity of credited stuff with the band... He remain the present vocalist and for see him performing live two month ago... The only think i can say is that for his age he remains at the top of the best active 90's black metal vocalist now... And obviously his outstanding vocal and theatrical talents continu to be realy impresive and unique to this day.
*I will put Maniac on second place...
Not necessary for is vocal performances that i think at some points are slightly equal to the one's delivred by "Dead"... But more because the fact he is the second vocalist of the band history and he is the second one with the most vocals contribution credited... Is personal attitude and is live performances are purely chaos and savagery... I think at some point he is the most fückəd up members that the band had ever have at an equal position with "Dead" but clearly for different reasons... Maniac erratical behaviors are the principal reason he got kicked out of the bands by Necrobutcher and Hellhammer... Because he drinking realy too much and acted like a Cahotic trouble maker during and outside live performance... Obviously he is the one credited for the vocal parts on the band second most popular album/ep "Deathcrush"... This masterpiece are the one that helped start and propulsed the band popularity... But also that the album that propulsed the entiere second wave of Norwegian black metal to what they are between 1987 and 1994... And by paving the way for all the next steps for propulsing and popularising the second wave of black metal... Not just at a national level but also at a worldwide one during that same era... Outside of the Deathcrush ep, "Maniac" best performances rest the one's he made on Wolf Lair's Abyss ep and Grand Declaration of War full-length. He's not outperform Atilla vocals so he got second place.
*I put Dead the most legendary of this three vocalist... At the third place.
Obviously Dead are maybe the most legendary member (beside band founder & guitarist Euronymous)... But sadly he is also the one with the less albums credited between Atilla, Maniac and himself... His vocals range sound pretty clear and at some points very very creepy... He got a vocal pitch that are unique and easy to identify from the others... He's also the only frontman that have not to invent or play a role during is lives performances... His short contribution with the band (early 88 to April 91) are legendary but also mark the most important period... For the band evolution and for the entire evolution and developing of the Norwegian second wave of black metal... Specificaly because of is live performances during the 1990 band tours and lives gigs... With the most popular and the most legendary gigs locations at (Jessheim, Sarpsborg, Zeitz & Liepzig)... Dead definitely shaped the dark imageries of MayheM during that specific period and era of time (88-89-90)... By his theatrical live performances and by his use of corpses paint (that he got credited for popularising all over the genre for the second wave)... But also definitely by his dark imageries and obsessions with death and his self mutilations behaviors during MayheM live performances... Like that one time at Jessheim (theirs first gig of 1990 band tour)... Where he cut himself so deep and badly thst he got to be taking to the hospital for important blood lost... Sadly his suicide and all the rumours and storys surrounding that tragical event... Definitely helped, shaped and cimented the band credibility and the overall credebility of the genre... Regarding dark, evil, satanic, and death related imageries... Linked to the entiere genre of Norwegian second wave of black metal. For a black metal vocalist his personal legacy are obviously the most important of all... But due to the small quantity of credited and released stuff... And due to the fact that he's not technicaly outperform the vocal quality and performances of Atilla or Maniac... He got the third place as a vocalist but will remain forever as the most legendary band member.
🔥🖤🤘🏻
100% agreed
Though Dead is my favourite (Live In Leipzig won me over), Maniac is such a good vocalist, dude. He definitely made Deathcrush HIS release. Bloody brilliant stage presence as well.
They're both incredibly good in their own way
I loved Dead, but Atilla is a genuinely cool dude, got to hang out with him
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
Its Dead for a few reasons but if they wouldve got him in the studio, i think there would have been no question. Atillia is number 2.
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
Maniac did a hell of a Job on declaration, and atilla's the most versatile and talented over all. But i just adore dead. Maybe I'm partial because I'm still sad that such a talented young man was taken from us so early. But he was so dedicated to his stage presence, and his voice was just...
Just, R.I.P man 😢
Maniac is the real deal. Too bad he had so much stage fright.
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
Dead, because Live in Leipzig gives me chills galore. Atilla’s performance on DMDS is sinister as fuck and I love it. Maniac’s performance on Chimera is stellar too! No favorite based on vocals alone, but no doubt Dead is the most iconic. RIP
I'm between dead and maniac. Deads live vocals are unmatched but the snarling grit on de mysterious by manic at so good
The dead is alive for eternity !!!
YES! I believe he is!
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
I choose Maniac and Dead, each voice is unique in its own way.
Each of their characters, each of their voices, are very cool.
Each album and song is unique, and so are their performances at the concert😟
Maniac …. But Dead is MAYHEM!
DEADS VOCALS SURPASSES EVERYONE BY A LONG SHOT.
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
Hard to pick. They all got it
I think the name speaks for me! But I also think there's a hell of alot of Mayhem and Other kick ass vocalists who were influenced by DEAD. And some whose vocals were even Better because of DEADs influence!
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
Dead is always gonna be the best vocalist for Mayhem hands down!!!
D E A D no contest. his voice was from another place.
Each had or have their strengths. Dead literally sounded like a living corpse. Maniac had an absolute classic and iconic black metal rasp and Attila has such an extreme range he's kinda hard to beat. He's like the Mike Patton of extreme metal. It's a tough one but I'm going to have to go with Attila.
Pelle without question, he had a great potential but died too soon. Attila made an awesome work in De Mysteriis.
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
They are all “the best” in their contributions. It’s what Mayhem was/is at that time.
Nicely put
Attila is beast🤘🏾🤘🏼🤘🏻🤘
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
Atilla's voice shakes me to my core.. but love all 3. i think Euronymous knew what he was doing
1: dead, 2: Maniac, 3: Atilla
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
@@massiveheadwoundrecords 🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
Maniac. But dead is so icon it’s mind blowing
Attila 🖤 the pure and extremely Darkness voice.
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
Maniac's voice was crazy before it became shot.
I love all of them but maniac has always been my favorite
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
Gotta go with Dead not because he's the original but because he is the original...
Dead sounds like death (soa como a morte)
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
Dead was the best, by far. He was even rated pretty highly in the 100 Greatest Metal Vocalists.
They're all good vocalists, but the best for me is Dead. I miss his vocals so much. He sounded like a real corpse and was born into it.
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
You miss him? You’ve never met the dude and I’m assuming you weren’t even alive when he was
Bro... I mean I miss his voice
@@Reinmain12You know exactly what he meant...whyre you being so weird abt his comment?
@@Deadpool-px2nm I do know what they meant. I just think it’s ridiculous to say it considering there is very little footage of him, so know one even knows what kind of person he was, and saying they miss him applies that they were keeping up with him while he was alive, and I’m guessing not
Dead would breath death to sound like the man doesn't get darker than that R.I.P. dead
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
Attila for the range and unique style he adds to the band
Thanks for the comment
I love Maniac's vocals, even if Attila and Dead are awesome as well !
for me they are equal but Dead would have improved his style
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
Dead unique style can never be matched
Maniac❤
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
in my opinion, dead, because he was one of the people who made mayhem successful, and he's very iconic for black metal, and i like his vocals a lot
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
Maniac for me. He has an odd, otherworldly quality to his voice.
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
I obsessed by Dead's voice💀
Dead is the most darkest vocalist.
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
💯It's literally impossible to argue that.
DEAD ETERNALY THE ONE AND BEST VOCALIST AND SONG RITER FOR MAYHEM....🖤🤟🤘🤙
Dead is iconic and the best to me
Maniac!
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
maniac. underrated
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
Honestly maniac on death crush is insane it sounds like screams from hell but other than that ovously dead
Dead sera toujours et à jamais le meilleur🤘
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
Non maniac c'est le best
They’re all great in their own right. Dead was my favorite as you could hear the pain in his voice that I feel fit the atmosphere of the music. You could tell he was putting everything into it. Attila is amazing to see live, though. His stage presence may seem goofy from videos but it’s cool to see live with the music, and his voice sets a different mood entirely
I guess Messiah has no place here? For those unaware the vocal tracks on Deathcrush were done by both, Maniac and Messiah. I really liked Dead. He was that perfect fit for the band. But Maniac and Attila def put in their work! I still think De Mysteriis and Wolfs Lair is still their best work!
I didn't put Messiah as he wasn't that prominent as the others. But yeah, he could have been added.
dead was definitely the darkest, gonna have to go with him
Maniac for sure
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
Dead had a special voice
For me its Attila, he is really cool vocalist, and Dead... For me its just crazy metalhead, who killed himself, and Euronymous just use his death to promote his group
I'm going to have to go with Atilla. My second choice would be Maniac because I loved how expressive he was.
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
Dead is definitely my pick
Dead the one and only ❤
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
Always liked maniac vocally. But I think the band played best with Attila
Atilla
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
i got so much respect for dead that i cants say anyone else is my favourite, attila is undeniably a good vocalist though
100% Dead
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
Reason why he is best?
@@pt.mr.s Have a listen and you'll see.
@@galaxydragon6153 😂😂😂
@@pt.mr.s Hmm?
Atilla is the best. Sorry dead fans but Atilla has most orchestral and demonic voice.
Atilla, no question!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
Dead Eternal 🖤
Dead is mithic, maniac was incredible before alcohol destroyed his voice and atilla is the most talented one
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
I don’t even think this had to be asked😅😅dead’s shit is just so unique
Dead the only one 🤘🏻😭rip
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
of course it’s “dead” but sad that his dead body was used for a album.but it’s what he woulda wanted
The true Mayhem is Dead ,Necrobutcher ,Hellhammer and Euronymus
Dead is and always will be my favorite. His voice is iconic.
I like Maniac but I like Atilla on his other projects too
Deadline forever
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
Maniac was hands down their best. Dead is a close second. Attila is great as well
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
Its not even a competition, everyone knows the right answer
Was just checking! 😉
DEAD IS MY FAVOURITE MEMBER OF MAYHEM!!!!!
Dead the best
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘
Dead IS Mayhem...but Atilla's absolutely brutal tbph! 🤘😈
🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘