Desh Deshantar: पड़ोसी देशों के साथ विदेश नीति

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 14 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 82

  • @raju9377
    @raju9377 5 років тому +1

    SD Muni Sir ka clear.c concept.
    Man khush ho gaya unki batein sunkar.

  • @raju9377
    @raju9377 5 років тому

    SD Muni sir ka speech kamaal. Unka logic aur diplomatic thought bahut badiya hai sir.
    Muni sir ko often laya karo sir.

  • @ekramquadri8903
    @ekramquadri8903 6 років тому +1

    Great program

  • @umakantswain4978
    @umakantswain4978 7 років тому +28

    Sala ye discussion agar, Z news ka hota too isme 1 lakh view too kamse kam hota. Shame on us, we BHARATIYA, ham ek paid news channel Ko itna interest se dekh te he joo hum Ko sirf FOOL banata he !!!! Magar joo channel (RS TV, Loksabha TV, DD News ) hum Ko EDUCATE karta he use hum koi nehi dekhte !!!!

  • @bhabindrapoudel5437
    @bhabindrapoudel5437 6 років тому

    sd muni ji sahi kaha

  • @myhabesha7040
    @myhabesha7040 6 років тому +1

    First time I ever like Indian news talk in favor of Nepal!! Say NO to interference other countries internal matters 👍👍

  • @aaryagajjar507
    @aaryagajjar507 6 років тому

    Excellent debate...

  • @traveljourneyvedio9654
    @traveljourneyvedio9654 6 років тому

    it's very good.

  • @manshubhalawati922
    @manshubhalawati922 7 років тому

    good talk show I agree with all expert

  • @abhisheksaha5809
    @abhisheksaha5809 2 роки тому

    JNU wale Muni se main 100% agree karta hoon. Itihas, sanskriti yeh sab sunne mein achcha hain, lekin long run pe yeh kisi kaam ka nahi. Neighbouring nations (excluding pakistan and china) mein investment karna hi relation achcha rakhne ka ek matra tareeka hain, aur kuch nahi.

  • @ajeetkranti3556
    @ajeetkranti3556 7 років тому

    Prof. SD muni👌👍👏👏

  • @ashishkumar-sq7kl
    @ashishkumar-sq7kl 7 років тому +4

    thanks to rstv invite for grate scholar PR. S.D muni and many more

  • @suneelsingh4868
    @suneelsingh4868 7 років тому +1

    thank you sir

  • @ArunKharel
    @ArunKharel 7 років тому

    appreciated S D muni view 🙏

  • @dineshbasnet1020
    @dineshbasnet1020 7 років тому +1

    Suhashini seems to be a sensible person compared to the two other ignorant males,SD Muni and the other old man..she is saying the right thing!

  • @sanjeevpradhan2748
    @sanjeevpradhan2748 7 років тому +18

    Nepal is eager to address India's security concern. India's security is Nepal's' concern. Needless to point out that beside thousands of Nepalese working in many cities in India, there are six Gorkha Regiments in the Indian army. No Nepali mother would like to see her son get into harms way fighting against the other neighbor. That will be very unfortunate day for Nepal and Nepali people. Besides, there are many more reasons that Nepal would like and needs to address our neighbor India's concern. Indian economic and commercial partnership is the lifeline of Nepali economy.
    Himalayas used to be impenetrable but with the new technical developments, Himalayas will not stand as the barrier to the progress and development of trade and economy through the northern front of Nepal. These recent developments in the relations with Nepal China are the demands of the time and the Nepali people's aspiration for trade and economic development.
    Nepal would like to address our important neighbor India's security concerns as a good neighbor, a sovereign country and an equal partner. Nepal needs both neighbours cooperation and partnership in the development of Nepal. New developments in the relation with Nepal and China does not diminish Indian's importance. Chinese leadership and Nepali leadership understand the dependency and integration of Nepali economy with India. China can not and will not be a substitute for India in Nepal.
    P.S. We know India mean well when Nepal is called a "Chota Bhai" but no we are not! We are very good friends and equal partners. This is the prerequisite of any successful relation.

    • @rajanarai4748
      @rajanarai4748 7 років тому +2

      Sanjeev Pradhan तो क्या हुवा भिख तो नहिमाङरहे हैन! हामे ईसा धम्की मतदो। नेपाल ने भारत से रिस्ता नहितोरा,भारत ने तोरा है! गोर्खा नेपाली लोग भारत मे काम कर्ता है। हिम्मत हैतो लाेटादो सब गोर्खा आर्मी नेपाल के भुभाक, हाम दुख सुख जिलेङगे, तब भारत के नाम निसान रहेगा या नहि।

  • @prabhattiwari5603
    @prabhattiwari5603 6 років тому

    Good

  • @soninepali6253
    @soninepali6253 4 роки тому +1

    S.S.muni,you are saying that other countries aren't ideal countries but India itself is less than ideal country. Religious tension, castist society, mob lynching and rampant corruption far more than other countries combined.

  • @mahbubarTalukdar
    @mahbubarTalukdar 7 років тому +1

    Good discussion, but it missed the main issues, e.g. 1. 18th century style overt bossy tactic toward small neighbors, 2. haggling over small interest. 3. Lack of trust and certainty in policy etc. 4. Counterproductive obsession about Pakistan, cow etc. 5. Perception of weakness because of internal lawlessness, craving for foreign support. All these are averse to human nature that seeks protection, certainty etc.

  • @udit410
    @udit410 7 років тому

    nice discussion

  • @milanpuri7300
    @milanpuri7300 7 років тому +5

    nepal don't think about aids indians ...... we want you to respect our sovereignty.

    • @btwk1157
      @btwk1157 7 років тому

      milan puri We don't get as much aid as they say. all they give is old and wearing vehicles which increase our dependency on india.

  • @giribishal5738
    @giribishal5738 7 років тому +1

    Guys don't waste your time to talking about others.they have their own guts to solve theirs problems.solve your own problems first and try to decrease poverty.JAYA NEPAL.✊✊

  • @manaangrae9392
    @manaangrae9392 7 років тому +8

    why india is so tense with China, when Nepal n China are creating good friendly relationship?

  • @Self_self_self
    @Self_self_self 7 років тому +3

    Nice

  • @sirmouriprince2739
    @sirmouriprince2739 7 років тому

    great intellectuals

    • @sureshsapkota4787
      @sureshsapkota4787 7 років тому

      Muni is relatively true from Nepalese perspective.

  • @wahchili4847
    @wahchili4847 5 років тому

    मुनि जि नेपाल चीन से लोन लेगा - रेल बनाएगा - कनेक्टिभिटी बढाएगा।

  • @gopalbudhamagar2257
    @gopalbudhamagar2257 7 років тому +1

    हो ईन्डियान बोल्छ एउता गर्छ अर्को कम सताको थियो हामी नेपाली लाई नाका बन्द गरेर साएद दराउछ झुक्छ भनेर होला याद गर ईन्डियान धोती हरु अंग्रेज़ लाई झुकाउने नेपाली हौ हामी मोर्न तयार तर कसै सङ्ग कहिले नझुक्ने जात हो नेपाली जय नेपाल

  • @GyanSingh-bg3lf
    @GyanSingh-bg3lf 3 роки тому

    Padosi Desh kiyu door horahe hai kabhi apni Ander ki kami kamjori samajhna chahiye Sara dosh samne wale ko deke samasya ka Samadhan nahi hoga rahi baat Nepal ki to kitnni bar pidit Kiya Bharat Sarkar ne haa ye baat sahi hai Nepal ka sab kuchh Bharat par nirbhar hai ye bhi sachh hai aapke India me Pani kaha se aaya hai bada home ka matlab ye nahi hota chhote Desh ki dabana jai Nepal jai hind

  • @shekhardahal2863
    @shekhardahal2863 7 років тому +1

    And they always try to prove that the are always right and other are always wrong...

  • @udit410
    @udit410 7 років тому +1

    China has competitive advantage in infrastructure

  • @rajuthapa1823
    @rajuthapa1823 7 років тому

    Shame on Indian foreign policy

  • @gsnadiya8698
    @gsnadiya8698 7 років тому +1

    अभि पस्ता के कोई फाईदा नहि है,सब पडाेसि फासी के फन्दा से निकल के सुकुन के सासलेना चाहते है।जब मद्दत चाहिएथा तो नाकाबन्दी कर्के हामे तडपा तडपा के भारत खुशी के जसमा मना रहेथे।

    • @gsnadiya8698
      @gsnadiya8698 7 років тому +1

      भारत के कित्ना पत्रकार मिडिया बोल्ता है भुकम्प पीडित लिए भारत ने ईत्ना मद्दत किया,ये किया, ओ किया।अरे भाइ हामने तो कभी नहि बोला हमारे गोर्खाऔ के बजासे ताकत वर देश बनगये हो, 56 ईन्च के सिना तानके गुमरहे हो। फिर ढोकलाम के मुद्दा लेके आय सुस्मा सौराज, उस मुद्दा को हामने समर्थन नहि किया, उसमेभी चिल्लना सुरुहुवा, ये नेपाल ने धोका दिया गद्दार किया, हामने ईत्ना मद्दत कियथा अभि चाइना साथ देरहे है।

  • @keshowprasadbhattarai6407
    @keshowprasadbhattarai6407 7 років тому

    The most important thing is that Indian politician should realize the existence of neighbouring countries otherwise if they go on interfering in their internal affairs..it certainly be far and far in the days to come... These countries realize their limitations but they have no option than to call China in Nepal... Otherwise who the hell wishes to invite China...seeing its role in African countries and brazuk

  • @sudarshanpaudel6085
    @sudarshanpaudel6085 7 років тому +2

    aap itne badhe hokar bhi nepal ke issue ko samajhna na sake. there are these reasn below why nepal is going away from india otherwise we know indian culture and brotherhood would be the better one as compared to china but india always took negetive adventage of these cultural ethnological and historical resemblance.
    i wana take example of my neighbour
    i was a poor boy struggeled for existance and there was my uncle who could only help me. he was my relative but he didnt help but used me . a man who is not my relative helped me when my condition was critical and i am an engineer and my uncle says u dont care me but the another guy and i say why should i??? analogy( my uncle = india )
    1. india is trying to capture nepalese boarder land slowly that is not acceptable to nepalese people .
    2. india always wants to help the poor country nepal so it always want to help , it mean india always want nepal to be poor cause it always want to help
    .
    3. roadblock and unnecessary activity at the time of earthqake .
    4.always feeding and supporting the nepali saying leader who want to make fragemented nepal such as ck raut.
    5.not wanting any other developmental project by other countries in nepal and itself taking hydropower project and not working and lingering .
    6. india dont want nepal to be stable for indias national security but nepal will be developed by the help of china as well so if india doesnt touch nepals sovereignty then india will be closer to nepal when do u indian critic say that i am still waiting .cause these are the main issue why india is not good neighbour of nepal.
    so if india think better nepal then nepal wont have to be close to any country but india always want to make nepal like bhutan ( without sovereignty ). but that is not acceptable if india is good neighbour to nepal change policy .

  • @madhavthapaliya7604
    @madhavthapaliya7604 7 років тому

    PADOSI DESH KESE HOGAYA ESA
    Check in the history, go back to Veda, search for Nepal. Search for Gurkha, also look for china and Mongolia. Check about Bharat and Mahabharata.
    British left India free, Nepal was a sovereign nation and federal state from ancient time. India doesn't know how to conduct good governance to its proud citizen and they speak loud about Nepal. Be a good friend and learn to respect the dignity of Nepalese citizen.India could never remove British ruler without of sacrifice of Gurkhas or Nepalese support, check the history in detail check the treaties for who was wrong!
    India always trapped Nepal, kept it land locked, stopped using it resources, tried to create intolerance among the citizens, religion, race, language as India itself is facing so many problems, they never stop inferiority. The dominance of India in the world is just because of Gurkhas as 'The great Britain do...
    India is just a big country by luck. It should start respecting its strong neighbors. China Nepal bhutan,maldives,pakistan,bangladesh,myanmar,srilanka,Darjeleeing,sikkim,Deradun,nagaland,kasmir etc.
    British left India free ,Nepal was a sovereign nation and also a federal state from ancient time. India doesn't know how to do good governance to its proud citizen and they speak loud about Nepal. Be a good friend and learn to respect the dignity of Nepalese citizen. India could never remove the British ruler without of sacrifice of Gurkhas or Nepalese support. But India always trapped Nepal, kept it land locked, never let to reach ocean ,stopped from using it resources, tried to create intolerance among the citizens, religion, race as India itself is facing so many problems. They never stopped to d dominance of India in the world is just because of Gurkhas, as The great Britain...
    India is just a big country by luck. It should start respecting its strong neighbors like china, Nepal Bhutan, Maldives ,pakistan,bangladesh,myanmar,srilanka,Darjeleeing,sikkim,Deradun, Nagaland, Manipur Kasmir etc.
    Lets come out of imposed mind and be positive to bring Asia in rise again. Nepal has created its kingdom in the middle of our Asia for long from the Vedic time ,and the whole India has its influence of Hinduism-Buddhism and we also equally respect Muslims and Christians just to unite the Asia and the whole world_ The rise of new world is mission for long time. Take care every one

  • @malliksss
    @malliksss 7 років тому

    There seems to be a unevolving kind of world view of SD Muni and Suhasini. And am surprised the anchor neither understands nor lets Shivshankar to complete. Looks like these all have some ideological biases

  • @shekhardahal2863
    @shekhardahal2863 7 років тому

    India is moving towards the direction of US..Interfere in other country issue and they always says that other nation are treating bad with them..There will be a time when India will be alone and there relationship will be separated from Asia ...

  • @udit410
    @udit410 7 років тому +1

    China is encircling India

  • @aminulchoudhury8685
    @aminulchoudhury8685 7 років тому

    We should be concerned about Islamisation of Indian Ocean countries..
    See Indonesia, how radicals are rising...Indonesia was once a Secular country but nowadays it is transforming...
    Right wing Politics growing everywhere. .Start from India to our neighbours...Right wing Political should be strictly dealt with..

  • @tenzinsangpo321
    @tenzinsangpo321 7 років тому +4

    If Tibet was an independent nation today, which it was before the Chinese annexation of Tibet in 1959, India would certainly have a friend as dear as Bhutan.

  • @vikashkumar9090
    @vikashkumar9090 7 років тому +1

    We should revise our diplomatic with neouber

  • @risingwambule
    @risingwambule 7 років тому +2

    Kutta vuktale ser sikar kartahai bass

  • @bharatbhuria9097
    @bharatbhuria9097 7 років тому

    election mai jo sthati Congress ki ho rakhi vahi sthati Bharat ki China k sath ho rhi h...indian Ocean Mai Bharat backfoot pr aa rha h.

  • @shankerbhandari5427
    @shankerbhandari5427 6 років тому

    mune sai bat keya ya snkr glat bat kea

  • @yogeshverma5937
    @yogeshverma5937 7 років тому

    Mana ki neighbors ki apni samaiya h to china fir ku aaram se kaam kar rha h ye bhi dekhna chaiye

    • @rebchhetri4133
      @rebchhetri4133 7 років тому +1

      नेपाली लोग भारत के करिब है ये सच है लेकिन आज तक भारत ने नेपाल को छिमेकी नैसम्झी जब भि कोइ सहायता कि अप्ने फाइदे के किये कालापनि हद्प्के बैथा है । बहुत नदिया के contract लेके बर्शो से hold कर्के बैथा है ता कि नेपाल खुद अर दुस्ररी देश को नदे ओर बिकास नहो ।खुद चाइना से निवेश करके अप्ने देश को बिकास करराहे छिमेकी को रोक्ने कि कोशिश क्या ये सहि है? दादागिरी कि दम्भ से कुछ होगा नहि दोस्त बनो गोर्खाली न कभी झुका था न कभी झुकेगा। दोस्ती के भर मे हजारौं सैनिक खुन बहाते आये है ।

  • @psykidhimo2209
    @psykidhimo2209 7 років тому

    So called intellectual and victim of dominant mindset...

  • @phymaguru3210
    @phymaguru3210 7 років тому

    I think sd munni is ri8.......wada pura karo china border tak road le aya aap avi v lge ho

  • @rajakumarbhagat9961
    @rajakumarbhagat9961 7 років тому +5

    सीधा आदमी को कोई v कुछ v बोल देता हैं।
    इंडिया को कोई v कुछ v बोल देता है।दूसरे देश में इंटरफेयर करना सीखना चाहिए। हमे softpower से hardpower में कन्वर्ट होना होगा।
    Lone देने का कंडिशन बढ़ाये , फ्री में देने से कुछ नहीं होगा interast rate china ke brabr ya usse 0.5% कम रखना चाहिए।
    और इस type के देश को उसका औकाद बताते रहना चाहिए नहीं तो सर पर चढ़ कर बैठेगे ही।

    • @rahulthapa6985
      @rahulthapa6985 7 років тому

      rajakumar bhagat aaukat dekhayo vaai sav ko. Jis tarike se srilanka maldivs bangala desh sav ko dekhao. Akela powerfull bane raho.pata chal jayega fir apne aaukat vi.

    • @rajakumarbhagat9961
      @rajakumarbhagat9961 7 років тому

      Rahul Thapa अरे यार तुम तो गुस्सा गए।मेरा मतलब सब को मार कर अपना औकाद नहीं दिखाना है।
      मतलब उतना सर पर नहीं बैठा लो । आप देखे होगे v
      आप उसी का रिस्पेक्ट करते होंगे जो आपसे पावरफुल होगा।जो आपको दिल से मानता होगा और वह कमजोर होगा तो आप उसका मजाक कभी v उड़ा देते होंगे। जबकि वह आप से सच्चे दिल से मानता होगा। जब कि जो मजबूत है वह आपका कभी v मजाक बना देता होगा लेकिन आप कुछ नहीं बोलते होंगे। और तो और आप उसी का इज्जत v करते होंगे। for example USA , CHINA , UK ,FRANCE , ISRILE , जर्मनी

  • @kamaljaishi9056
    @kamaljaishi9056 6 років тому

    Mukharji is representing the attitude of most of the ruling parties of India. Until and unless you are not realizing the fact and resist to change your attitude . you will remain always looser . Please not to divide your neighbors by tagging them anti india, pro china by your poor mentality. every country has its sovereignty and respect the country sovereignty.

  • @dambarbasnet2441
    @dambarbasnet2441 7 років тому +1

    Why you guys are getting tension about our relation with china ? we just want good relation like india but you are crying here . Leave us alone we know what is good and what is bad.

  • @chandanmahara6477
    @chandanmahara6477 7 років тому

    बिनाश काले बीपीरित बुध्दि

  • @sailak7959
    @sailak7959 7 років тому

    Naka bandi kiya bhulgaya sale

  • @rupeshrimal9820
    @rupeshrimal9820 7 років тому

    Shankar very bad man

  • @Viralshortswithpk
    @Viralshortswithpk 7 років тому

    Nice