Freedom is inside you and eternal. IF you want it. People were poorer but a million times happier in the past because most people knew this. They depended and trusted in Jesus. They didn't put their full trust in politicians who are generally trustworthy and are always here today and gone tomorrow. John 8:31-36. Romans chapter 8.
@@leenieledejo6849 You are missing the point entirely, freedom is not inside you when you are brainwashed, when you are limited in action, etc. Scotland has to free itself from delusion, from dependency. That is how this so-called Union works. That is how Colonisation has always worked.
Correct, it was imprisoned by unelected bureaucrats in Brussels. Half of these bureaucrats couldn’t even point to Scotland on a map. Thankfully the English and Welsh voters have freed Scotland from the unelected bureaucrats of Brussels because the UK left the EU 🎉
I had to laugh at JC biting her tongue. Politicians pretty much blaming the people and not the incompetent politicians at her side. The politicians could've gave us our freedom with Brexit but under Sturgeon, they chose not to!
We have to move forward. We can't trust the politicians to bring us Independence, we have to educate one another about what this union actually means and what it was all about; the greed of the few, selling off the many into slavery to a foreign government. People have short memories, and this is not about grudge, simply one of dignity and knowing how much better off we'd all be under our own rule. Westminster is about limitation and exploitation, if anyone can show otherwise I'll consider what they present. A self ruling Scotland would mean our own currency and more importantly, our own control of such. That's what blew the chance of freedom out of the water, the lack of clarity concerning all issues surrounding money. We have to be complete autonomous. Just as our government must operate under a Scottish Constitution to protect us from their stupidity. An actual democracy is what we must have, not the present pretend nonsense. What we have to present is a full rounded argument, showing why we can't just sit back in our comfort but question that very delusion. All the talk of Westminster being a safety net for Scotland is simply baloney. We have to show the very real dangers of such thinking, such as interest rates, mortgage rates, such as every rising food prices, energy prices, etc. A Country without control over such basics is never safe. Scotland can feed itself, heat itself, have adequate housing, etc. That is not wishful thinking but based on simple facts, such as the way the farming market has been held back. In my lifetime, farmers have gone from growing dozens of varied crops to just a handful. I mean, it is ludicrous to import that which we can produce ourselves. That is the basis of a real Scottish economy. Same with electric and gas. We have abundance, and yet it is all siphoned off and then sold back to us at 10 times the price. Scotland having its own National Energy Provider would give us all cheap electric, and when we consider the effect of that for our businesses, well it gives us a great advantage over others; innovation and industry would certainly grow exponentially.
Especially these pathetic politicians who so lightlt skip over the unforgivable treachery of the the riddlesd SNP How dare they sit there mouthing such weak platitudes
Totally agree. We have to reframe the debate. List some of what it would be sensible for us to do, economically, infrastructure and lifestyle wise. Point out which laws-of-another-country prevent us doing that. And repeat the question: What sort of Country ALLOWS their hands to be tied like that?
Bernard Ponsonby is insightful, analytical, has an encyclopedic knowledge of politics - such an interesting and charismatic, humorous speaker. Fascinating.
Bollocks. He's boring as hell and even pressing x2 double speed I can't get through listening to him drone on. Warm up for the lightweight and offensive, nothing to do with us guv, trio later. This show was even worse than expected. Why are we now seemingly stuck with the Alex & Tasmina Show. WHY?
An independent Scotland would be even fairer. Free university benefits everyone, that's simply why all should have free adult education. England is about exploiting its people, and thus, Scottish people, Welsh, Irish, anyone it can. Just one reason to break free from that type of tyranny.
@@Bob-v3g4mIndy supporters are like men who make an advance on woman and that woman says NO, the Indy supporter continues regardless as they don’t understand the word NO
Scotland is in a special club. Its an imprisoned nation: an imprisoned people. Look at the comments here.
Yep, the old Stockholm Syndrome.
Freedom is inside you and eternal. IF you want it.
People were poorer but a million times happier in the past because most people knew this.
They depended and trusted in Jesus.
They didn't put their full trust in politicians who are generally trustworthy and are always here today and gone tomorrow.
John 8:31-36.
Romans chapter 8.
@@leenieledejo6849 You are missing the point entirely, freedom is not inside you when you are brainwashed, when you are limited in action, etc.
Scotland has to free itself from delusion, from dependency. That is how this so-called Union works. That is how Colonisation has always worked.
Correct, it was imprisoned by unelected bureaucrats in Brussels. Half of these bureaucrats couldn’t even point to Scotland on a map. Thankfully the English and Welsh voters have freed Scotland from the unelected bureaucrats of Brussels because the UK left the EU 🎉
I had to laugh at JC biting her tongue.
Politicians pretty much blaming the people and not the incompetent politicians at her side.
The politicians could've gave us our freedom with Brexit but under Sturgeon, they chose not to!
How?
The SNP are too comfortable under Colonial rule, pretending to want self rule and regaining the sovereignty of our Country.
@@SI-vb7hd by completely failing to articulate an 'Independence Now' campaign, rather than a 'Stop Brexit' one.
I was never in support of Scottish independence, but he was real patriot and a decent man..Sorry he has gone...
So sad to have lost Alex Salmond so soon after this and so suddenly. RIP
The EU required the UK that Scotland should have the opportunity of voting for or against a devolved Scottish Government.
Independence is dead and buried no matter what the dirty old man and his sidekick crooked solicitor have to say
Show us the eu document or correspondence that shows this?? Or did you make it up whilst smoking your joint 😂
We have to move forward. We can't trust the politicians to bring us Independence, we have to educate one another about what this union actually means and what it was all about; the greed of the few, selling off the many into slavery to a foreign government. People have short memories, and this is not about grudge, simply one of dignity and knowing how much better off we'd all be under our own rule.
Westminster is about limitation and exploitation, if anyone can show otherwise I'll consider what they present. A self ruling Scotland would mean our own currency and more importantly, our own control of such. That's what blew the chance of freedom out of the water, the lack of clarity concerning all issues surrounding money.
We have to be complete autonomous. Just as our government must operate under a Scottish Constitution to protect us from their stupidity. An actual democracy is what we must have, not the present pretend nonsense.
What we have to present is a full rounded argument, showing why we can't just sit back in our comfort but question that very delusion. All the talk of Westminster being a safety net for Scotland is simply baloney. We have to show the very real dangers of such thinking, such as interest rates, mortgage rates, such as every rising food prices, energy prices, etc. A Country without control over such basics is never safe.
Scotland can feed itself, heat itself, have adequate housing, etc. That is not wishful thinking but based on simple facts, such as the way the farming market has been held back. In my lifetime, farmers have gone from growing dozens of varied crops to just a handful. I mean, it is ludicrous to import that which we can produce ourselves. That is the basis of a real Scottish economy. Same with electric and gas. We have abundance, and yet it is all siphoned off and then sold back to us at 10 times the price. Scotland having its own National Energy Provider would give us all cheap electric, and when we consider the effect of that for our businesses, well it gives us a great advantage over others; innovation and industry would certainly grow exponentially.
Especially these pathetic politicians who so lightlt skip over the unforgivable treachery of the the riddlesd SNP
How dare they sit there mouthing such weak platitudes
Totally agree. We have to reframe the debate.
List some of what it would be sensible for us to do, economically, infrastructure and lifestyle wise. Point out which laws-of-another-country prevent us doing that. And repeat the question: What sort of Country ALLOWS their hands to be tied like that?
@@louisehogg8472 the debate should be nationwide and grassroots. Time is ticking on 2026 and this show missed the mark
You can still take us to independence Alex.. Remember the Spider
Had his chance… Could not take us across the road
these programs are always interesting, thanks so much
💙
Bernard Ponsonby is insightful, analytical, has an encyclopedic knowledge of politics - such an interesting and charismatic, humorous speaker. Fascinating.
Bollocks. He's boring as hell and even pressing x2 double speed I can't get through listening to him drone on.
Warm up for the lightweight and offensive, nothing to do with us guv, trio later.
This show was even worse than expected. Why are we now seemingly stuck with the Alex & Tasmina Show.
WHY?
I live in England and went to uni in England, the system is rubbish but you don't need to pay £9000 upfront for uni fees
Did ye aye
An independent Scotland would be even fairer. Free university benefits everyone, that's simply why all should have free adult education. England is about exploiting its people, and thus, Scottish people, Welsh, Irish, anyone it can. Just one reason to break free from that type of tyranny.
Aye
The Rev👌😎😇
This SNP revival show was worse than expected
Horse .....a....dead.....flogging
well darling already done rip, plenty left on the black list
Scotland still says no 10 years on
Ha, so says you. Give me 10 rational reasons as to why Scotland is better off ruled by a foreign government, than by our own People.
Brainwashed.
We said no no means no stuff Scottish Independence
Why would any rational person not want his or her Country to have absolute self rule? Colonial brainwashing!
Do you still live with your mum & dad?
Grow a brain FFS.
@@Bob-v3g4mIndy supporters are like men who make an advance on woman and that woman says NO, the Indy supporter continues regardless as they don’t understand the word NO