I personally think, as a musician myself, that to hear a audiance of people you've never meet singing your lyrics with you word by word is nothing short of flattering......
addicted to this song right now, must of listened to it a good 30, 40 times since hearing it for the first time yesterday, reminds me of jimmy eat world just pure raw emotion, love it
Bruch is so freaking awesome. And I love how everyone was having a good time. I wish I could share it with them. And people whining and bitching about the audience, you're just jealous that you weren't there like I am right now. Just enjoy the fucking fact you can still hear the music. If I was there, I'd be singing along. Forget It is a very under appreciated song. I don't usually see people talk about the song.
I would like to think that Ben and the band would have been very humbled by the fact that the crowd was singing along with him. Gavin DeGraw has let the crowds sing entire songs for him live before. It's very humbling for many artists, The Ataris included. I even asked Kris once when I met him this past February... so you can't really argue on that one.
@DarkTragedyLife You don't expect the crowd to sing along to a song like this? Especially when they've never played it live before? Singing was a must, my friend. :D
but if you watch alot of his concerts...like their homecoming dvd...he likes to bring his crowds into it...what singer doesnt feel awesome knowing people knows their lyrics word for word....i know i would love it.
were you there? have you ever been to a concert? if you have youd understand singing along with the artist. by the way artists like it when you do that.
@luvR4babes6 The song has 4 different key changes in it. I'm not surprised he said that. As for him sounding good, he DID but you can't really tell as the audience was singing along pretty loud with him. :/
@gpburr I'm confused at what you are saying. This is my video and I sure as hell sang along. My above comment was to the other poster arguing with me. I was being sarcastic in the post I think you're referring to.
@lonnarific Never been to a show in my life where the audience didn't sing along. Shame on them, they should have been considerate for all those who would later watch a video of the show they paid for!
i cant even freaking hear ben! im tired of the audience singing to everything. you only sing when BEN says sing it, otherwise it is annoying and interruptive.
I would like to think that Ben and the band would have been very humbled by the fact that the crowd was singing along with him. Gavin DeGraw has let the crowds sing entire songs for him live before. It's very humbling for many artists, The Ataris included. I even asked Kris once when I met him this past February... so you can't really argue on that one.
I would like to think that Ben and the band would have been very humbled by the fact that the crowd was singing along with him. Gavin DeGraw has let the crowds sing entire songs for him live before. It's very humbling for many artists, The Ataris included. I even asked Kris once when I met him this past February... so you can't really argue on that one.
![Lp. Последняя Реальность #97 ЧЁРНАЯ МАТЕРИЯ [Анти Скинт] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/k4MjXCzKsYw/mqdefault.jpg)
I personally think, as a musician myself, that to hear a audiance of people you've never meet singing your lyrics with you word by word is nothing short of flattering......
Especially when it's not even close to your most known song.
Yeah.. Thier masterpiece but underrated song
I would cry or be happy tbh it would mean alot to me.
@@zaincager3121 ??
this audience are a good crowd
I love the way the audience sings along with him, shows how much they love Breaking Benjamin! Wish I could've been there.
addicted to this song right now, must of listened to it a good 30, 40 times since hearing it for the first time yesterday, reminds me of jimmy eat world just pure raw emotion, love it
Jimmy Eat World is one of my favorites! This'll always be my top BB song even though it strays from their norm.
I think the audience sung this beautifully, Along with ben
Bruch is so freaking awesome. And I love how everyone was having a good time. I wish I could share it with them. And people whining and bitching about the audience, you're just jealous that you weren't there like I am right now. Just enjoy the fucking fact you can still hear the music. If I was there, I'd be singing along. Forget It is a very under appreciated song. I don't usually see people talk about the song.
true
he's just so amazing 😂😂😂
he is really enjoying this beautiful music, its really from his heart.omfg
Who knew that some time later Aaron would become a central part of the new line up. And goddam this song just hits you differently.
SIng along with it, it'll make you feel as-if you were there with the concert.
How can I believe when this cloud hangs over me?
you were so damn close. Lucky to be you. thanks for the post it is my favorite song on heavy rotation.
Stop trash talking about the crowd because i'm pretty sure that if you were in a concert you would sing along too
NoobsGetGP I’m sure he loves hearing fans sing too
@@kaileynadine2811whip it
Amazing fucking song!!! Thanks for sharing
2500+ times played and most in my ipod
Mi vida...
I would like to think that Ben and the band would have been very humbled by the fact that the crowd was singing along with him. Gavin DeGraw has let the crowds sing entire songs for him live before. It's very humbling for many artists, The Ataris included. I even asked Kris once when I met him this past February... so you can't really argue on that one.
Love this song!!!! American pie 4!!! Love love love!!!!
❤❤❤❤❤❤
2 people liked the song sooo much, they flipped their monitor over to like it again,
Just my favourite BB song!!!!
I think the singing actually adds a lot to it. There's probably nothing like singing for people and have them all know every word.
Amo esta canción❤
this is my fav bb song from their we are not alone album.
Awesome! Nice Work Guys!
This song made American Pie Band Camp.
AP, 1,2,3 love forever, my best time in life!
Красавчики
ohhh ben i love you♥
Breaking benjamin sings awesome live sounds just like the iTunes Version
Hermoso 🤩🤩
I would love to hear billy corgan play this... he co wrote it and I wanna hear his take on it. Think it would be awesome
He actually thought this song was out of his range 2 sing live? 2 words: NAILED IT!!! Ben ur freakin' amazing!!
The hand gestures are fucking tremendous. 🤘
damn ben is playing with his iconic black guitar same he played on the phobia dvd
❤
❤️❤️❤️
@DarkTragedyLife
You don't expect the crowd to sing along to a song like this? Especially when they've never played it live before? Singing was a must, my friend. :D
FUCKING AMAZING, Thank you for sharing this! PrinceyP
@justinx1103
Thanks! It's just a little compact Sony Cybershot, but it captures great audio and video at shows.
hell yeah!!!! :)
♥♥♥
but if you watch alot of his concerts...like their homecoming dvd...he likes to bring his crowds into it...what singer doesnt feel awesome knowing people knows their lyrics word for word....i know i would love it.
nice
Nice
@bbfreak9
It's probably my favorite song from them overall.
breaking benjamin la rja!!!!!!!!!!!!
y cant they play this live! my fav song in the world and i missed it live! DAMNIT!!!! FUCK! SHITCAKES!
American Pie \o/
just forget it
@ShadowWolf9 actually, this was their second time singing it live!
@jaredwhorton41 Ha, well I'm sorry you couldn't make it. It was truly amazing. Hopefully they actually tour again.
My birthday
u've got a really good camera! XD
@bbfreak9 thanks
@cafeledavid My first concert was from these guys and it was amazing aha
How dare the crowd sing along and support Ben, they should hang their heads in shame.
@runningcow13 Why weren't they playing it live??? its a great song!
were you there? have you ever been to a concert? if you have youd understand singing along with the artist. by the way artists like it when you do that.
To who? The people watching the performance years later? I doubt Ben nor the people there enjoying it could really care.
@gntrihg Aaron Burch from OurAfter.
@luvR4babes6 The song has 4 different key changes in it. I'm not surprised he said that. As for him sounding good, he DID but you can't really tell as the audience was singing along pretty loud with him. :/
@gpburr I'm confused at what you are saying. This is my video and I sure as hell sang along. My above comment was to the other poster arguing with me. I was being sarcastic in the post I think you're referring to.
Get your ears flushed, you'll hear him great! :D
which brand of guitar he's using?
3 years late, but it's an Ovation Tangent T357 most likely, BB has almost always used Ovation guitars for their acoustic shows
You must be deaf sir, I hear him quite well :P
ah well. i just wanted to hear him live, but ill stick to my itunes version.
It's different not seeing him with the other guys
who's playing with him, please message or reply to me.
@lonnarific
I'm not. That's also why I don't expect anything different than the inevitability of the crowd singing.
who is the other guy?
@lonnarific
Never been to a show in my life where the audience didn't sing along. Shame on them, they should have been considerate for all those who would later watch a video of the show they paid for!
@ShadowWolf9
When it's an acoustic set, no-one should sing along and just listen, couse it overpowers the music... I agree, the crowd ruins it.
I am sad. You can jam harder than this.
Grr, I can't hear him!
The guy's mad right? He plays electric songs acoustic and this is an acoustic song which he's playing on an electric! What is this opposite land?! lol
thumbs up if you hate comments based on the number of dislikes
wish audience would shut the mouth so i can hear him...
@ShadowWolf9 he was prob the lone dislike haha
Why doesn't Ben just hire the other guy who's playing with him? And get a new bassist. There's a lot of hidden talent.
MrDead67 I know it's an old comment but I think he took your advice :)
was he mumbling sumting else?!
sry just accidently press the dislike button,,:(
sorry guys!
i cant even freaking hear ben! im tired of the audience singing to everything. you only sing when BEN says sing it, otherwise it is annoying and interruptive.
I would like to think that Ben and the band would have been very humbled by the fact that the crowd was singing along with him. Gavin DeGraw has let the crowds sing entire songs for him live before. It's very humbling for many artists, The Ataris included. I even asked Kris once when I met him this past February... so you can't really argue on that one.
I would like to think that Ben and the band would have been very humbled by the fact that the crowd was singing along with him. Gavin DeGraw has let the crowds sing entire songs for him live before. It's very humbling for many artists, The Ataris included. I even asked Kris once when I met him this past February... so you can't really argue on that one.