2nd Battle of Nola, 215 BC ⚔️ Hannibal (Part 19) ⚔️ Second Punic War
Вставка
- Опубліковано 18 лют 2023
- 🚩 Thank you so much for watching. Consider supporting my work on Patreon and enjoy ad-free early access to my videos for as little as $1: / historymarche
👉 Hannibal Playlist: • Hannibal (PARTS 1 - 5)...
📢 Narrated by David McCallion
🎵 Music:
Peaks of Atlas - Omri Lahav
EpidemicSound
Filmstro
📜 Sources:
The Second Punic War: The battle of Hibera, 215 BC - David Feeney (2019)
www.academia.edu/40050728/Bat...
The Punic Wars, 264 - 146 BC - Nigel Bagnall (2002)
www.amazon.com/Punic-Wars-264...
Hannibal - G. P. Baker (1999)
www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00...
Hannibal's War - John Peddie (2005)
www.amazon.com/Hannibals-War-...
Hannibal: A History of the Art of War - Theodore Ayrault Dodge (2012)
www.amazon.com/Hannibal-Histo...
Fall of Carthage - Adrian Goldsworthy (2003)
www.amazon.com/Fall-Carthage-...
Cannae: Hannibal's Greatest Victory - Adrian Goldsworthy (2019)
www.amazon.com/Cannae-Hanniba...
The History of Rome, Livy (2006)
www.amazon.com/History-Rome-B...
Histories, Book 7 (from The Complete Histories) - Polybius (2009)
www.amazon.com/Complete-Histo...
The Rise of the Roman Empire - Polybius (translation by Ian Scott-Kilvert) (1980)
www.amazon.com/Rise-Roman-Emp...
A companion to the Punic Wars - Dexter Hoyos (2015)
www.amazon.com/Companion-Puni...
Problems of the Second Punic War: III. Rome and Her Italian Allies
www.jstor.org/stable/296292
Sicily and the Second Punic War: The (Re)Organisation of Rome’s First Province - John Serrati
#historymarche #hannibal #rome
🚩 Thank you so much for watching. Consider supporting my work on Patreon and enjoy ad-free early access to my videos for as little as $1: www.patreon.com/historymarche
👉 Hannibal Playlist: ua-cam.com/video/e3JPe75W-Eg/v-deo.html
When will you make second part to the Islam's first arrow video? You promised a series.
Thank you so much for a new hannibal video i just came back from a friends house and i am met by this! Keep up the work please
Thank you!! Great series! I've been watching it with my son!
Thank you very much for this video
Nice to see that you went back to making video's for this series.. Hope it's not too long before we see the next one.
please please please finish this series, its the best anyone has ever done on the carthaginian wars, i salute you guys for such a good job!
yes until Hannibal's death even when he was in Brythinia a foreign land he was accepted and commanded armies and won. it's crazy!
I concur!!!!
Yes. We need more.
Watched this whole series in one going.
I was so sad when I saw that there wasn't another part of Punic War. Please finish Hanibal's journey to the end.
Please finish the series.
It’s a miracle Carthage survived the 1st Punic war. How Hannibal managed to almost win the 2nd speaks volumes to his skill as a commander
Not skilled enough to finish the job though...
@@METALFREAK03 Tell me you know nothing about history without telling me you know nothing about history.
@@METALFREAK03 skill had nothing to do with it. He lacked the resources neccesary to fight a war on foreign soil. Same thing that happened to Pyrreahus
@@METALFREAK03it had nothing with skills you goof. he failed to convince and force Romes allies to abandon them, all the other cities were just under the control of Latin influence, and Rome had at least 800k people living inside it with high walls and ballistas all over the place. i would suggest to go actually learn about history before spewing shit. all of you.
A ever great miracle is historymarche has resumed the Hannibal series 😂😁..good work guys💯
I think Hannibal series is easily this channels niche... To my knowledge no other channel has covered Hannibal's battles and 2nd Punic War in such details... really hope you will keep uploading episodes on this series more frequently
i actually like they space them out. Feels like a wait before a great film from a series you love.
@@jonbaxter2254 Agreed, I like that too but last episode came out 1 years ago which is little too big of a gap lol, like once a month or every other month would be cool imo but considering that this channel has other vids to post it's probably impossible to do it that frequently. I just want to see conclusion of this war before 2030s lmao
Hannibal is the reason i notice this channel. And they are soooo f-ing slow with Hannibal....
spot on!
Check Mike Duncan, History of Rome. Over a hundred episode and he goes deep on Punic wars
Please make part 20 I’m begging you. I’ve been waiting years for this series to end. It’s so good and the information is so amazing. Your videos are top quality and leaving this series unfinished would be a crime with your skill and knowledge. Don’t let oversimplified overshadow you! Please please please make a part 20
The information after the battle of Cannae is complicated to handle, several Spanish and Italian channels have stayed in 215 BC. It is a pity.
@@fortnche has confirmed in a comment on another video that he’s working on part 20 right now
Rome - “we need to support an army on the other end of the continent fighting a secondary front that is not a pressing concern, let’s get into debt to ensure this happens”
Carthage - “Our best general is winning against our most bitter rival, relatively close to Carthage and this campaign will decide the fate of our empire…we see no reason to send him reinforcements or supplies”
Iberia was the primary front, because if Rome took over all of Iberia, Carthage's economy wouldn't last long. Not to mention Rome could then invade Africa from 2 directions.
Men fighting for political control while the fate of their empire hangs in the balance is honestly outlandish
The fact that hannibal was the only carthaginan general with any significant success in the second punic war just shows that carthage was really on its last leg as an empire. A Roman army that was sick and filled with inexperienced troops had nearly wiped out a carthaginan army (along with allies). I can only imagine the frustration he had during the winters waiting for help that would never come. While trying to protect newly found allies too. Very disappointing
On its last leg, indeed. The Carthaginian Senate denied Hannibal Barca reinforcements. No wonder they lost.
They denied reinforcements because of those losses in Sardinia, in Spain etc. democratic societies are ruled by wealthy people, and when war is no longer good for business, people start to pull there investments. Being the largest exporter of olives and Olive Oil, the war was likely terrible for business.
Carthage was also not a empire that had a true uniting definition of citizenship. Carthaginians were not compelled to serve in the army. Where in Rome it was a requirement.
Its a classic example that no empire can thrive on just wealth alone, and that society and culture are just as important.
@@largemouthbass355 Carthage was a marine time empire that performed mass child sacrifice, to their Phonciean god Baal, wore the skins of Barbary lion pelts in honour of Melqart, the Phonciean Hercules. An rode armoured war elephants to war.
@@lcplapiata5501 yup, Bad ideas don’t usually last long.
@@largemouthbass355 tht is the biggest argument against democracy and particularly top heavy democracy, periods of turmoil and fast growth. it's a miracle rome reigned that long as a republic an extremely corrupt republic but a republic nonetheless.
He might not be a Scipio or a Hannibal, but a salute to Titus Manilus for playing a poorly given hand really well, 2 times.
IKR
Interestingly he was the consul who conquered Sardínia in 237 bc and then he
Closed the doors of temple of Janus ( done only when Rome is at peace ) , the last closing of the doors until Augustus
Feels like it would have been better for Hasdrubal the bald to just wait out the Romans
I can't believe that I just today stumbled upon this channel, watched all the episodes from the Hannibal series, desperately searched for the 19th episode and saw that it's been 11 months since the last post, gave up, read the continuation from Wikipedia instead, and three hours later he uploads the episode.
Still going to watch this and enjoy as much as any of the earlier episodes. Thank you sir, I could binge on long sagas like this all day!
Thanks for watching. And welcome to the channel
Dude, this channel is theraputic
Welcome. Enjoy yourself. This channel is amazing
Me to. Discovered the channel and watched all the episodes back to back. Didn't get much work done that day.
@@HistoryMarche where is the part 20 please ?
You guys really need to finish this series 🙏
First foray in to your channel, 10/10 educational, easy to follow, utterly engrossing.
You're probably sick of researching the second punic war but this series is excellent. Every ep of Hannibal's machinations and maneuvering is a thrill ride.
Don't be like Hanno II and leave us stranded 🥲🤣 PART XX!!! ⚔️⚔️
Thanks so much for the support! Very kind of you. Actually, I'm a Hannibal fanboy. Currently I'm on my 4th rewrite of the part 20 script. For the first time I'm happy with how it's looking, as I'm trying to pack 214, 213, and 212 BC into it, up to the First Battle of Capua. Tricky task, that. 4th version is up to Hannibal moving on Tarentum. From there I plan to pivot to Macedonian war briefly. Then back to Sicily, then Spain. Then back to simultaneously looking at Hannibal and Tarentum + Carthage's "civil war" stoked by Rome, which forced Hasdrubal to temporarily leave Spain to address this issue.
It's looking good. I was just not happy with my previous versions of the text, hence the delay. I went into animating version 2 and mid-way through animation I realized it's lacking. So I dropped it and started again.
Glad you're enjoying the series! I'm definitely working on it, don't worry :)
@@HistoryMarcheThanks for taking the time to explain where you're at! Godspeed 🙂
P.S. Why is Hasdrubal the Bald pictured with hair? 😂
I couldn't Google much about the name since there's about 74,000 Hasdrubals
@@Mr_Smyth ha, ha, ha Excellent contribution! We have to wait then.
@@HistoryMarche Wonderful! Looking forward to this!
@@HistoryMarche As we say here "good things need time", the series is worth waiting for. It truly is amazingly well done.
Probably your best series. Hats off to you sir.
heads off *
While this campaign had started to go into its autumn years, I still can't help but be impressed with my boy Hannibal. Occupying Italy and waging war so far from home, all the while fighting against his own senate who hated him. Still, Cannae was becoming a memory now, and the Romans were finding the will to fight even then.
The biggest strenght of Rome was the ability to master a professional army at lightning Speed. Not only that, the overall way of fighting, the training, the logistics they were masters in that
Only Rome could've survived a Hannibal level threat and that's high praise for both Hannibal and Rome
@@DrewPZack All my homies hate Hano
Hannibal may be the #1 best generals of all time, followed by Alexander at 2nd position. Hannibal's ability to predict the enemy's actions was simply above human. I can't cease to be impressed at his every prediction
#1 Alexander the Great
#2 Napoleon
#3 Caesar
#4 Genghis Khan
#5 Hannibal
Hannibal is astonishing! How he managed to put the wind up the Romans for so long speaks volumes about his military genius.
the dude deserves his own movie or TV show
@bastiat4855 You're clueless.
@@matt54321100 Second that. Bastiat is literally so clueless it's not even worth making a reply.
@bastiatrome literally threw over 250k men against Hannibal 's same 40k half of them gallic mercs and still lost every battle. Idk what you are smoking
@@antoniopimentel3546 that’s because the Roman’s were clueless on how to fight Hannibal, remember they were still a fairly young Republic while the Carthaginians have been established for a while now and Rome was hated by everyone because they were getting too big
My boy Fabian had the best strategy, staying back and finding an opening since all other generals failed to beat Hannibal on an open battle. It was the best he could do but of course the Senate hated the Fabian Strategy
At the current velocity ... it looks like this series will take longer to be made, than the Second Punic War itself. Most probably, this project is headed by Fabius Cunctator himself. And he's applying his favorite tactics.
😂😂😂😂
😂 maybe true.. but the next episode could appear sooner if you consider supporting such a great work ;)
Can't wait for part 20
Hopefully you'll complete the series before Oversimplified does
This video doesn't have any jokes but it's still somehow funnier than every Oversimplified vid
@@modernclassicalmusic8942 i hope he completes before them.. Oversimplified is good but I don't want a serious high quality content to be ruined by immature jokes.. I mean we've already seen what he did with 1st Punic war
@@modernclassicalmusic8942 Idk
The views and opinions refute your statement
@@raidangthey’re completely different channels lol. oversimplified is a good thing for pushing history to a large audience even if I prefer deep dive channels like historia civilis, historymarche, kings and generals. etc.
@bastiat this is why i said.. Serious and deep topic like 2nd Punic war shouldn't fall kids show.. The sheer fear among the Italian population and nervousness and anxiety after the battle of cannae cannot be Express through Childish jokes
Please finish the Hannibal series. It is the best and most thoroughly done I have ever seen. Congratulations, and thank you for such great work.
Pls historymarche this is by far the best series on Hannibal on UA-cam, hope you finish the series.
Please finish up Hannibal's story. This is some of the best content I've seen on UA-cam. Almost feels like a Netflix documentary.
I would say that a netflix dcoumentary is a downgrade, this is way way better
@@user-wl1uz5sb9fnetflix documentary is the biggest insult I ever seen
@@user-wl1uz5sb9fyea there's no way they can replicate such quality content like this
Unless Hannibal and Fabius secretly engage in homosexual relations and decide to crush the patriarchy, it's not a Netflix series.
please finish the series, I would like the see what happens in the end and how scipio africanus beats hannibal
Worth the wait! You can't help but sympathize with Hannibal and his campaign in Italy. Even though both were imperial powers, The Carthaginian truly was a unique military figure on par with Alexander (given his meager resources). He came within a hair of destroying The Roman Empire at their genesis and changing the course of history. The Macedonian's assessed all too correctly that they would be fighting The Romans alone soon enough if Hannibal was defeated in Italy.
@bastiat Hey, buddy. Are you in a lot of severe pain and bed ridden? There's no need to lash out at people from behind your computer for silly reasons. If you are, I hope you get better soon and try to remember the wise words of Aurelius before you decide to be a keyboard warrior “If you are distressed by anything external, the pain is not due to the thing itself, but to your estimate of it; and this you have the power to revoke at any moment.”
― Marcus Aurelius, Meditations
@bastiat Apology accepted. To the degree Rome was an imperial power compared to Carthage at that point, geographically, you're right. Rome did not control the real estate Carthage controlled. Although, they were still an imperial power. I never made any mention of who had the greatest territory in terms of size. Rome was well into expansionist mode in the Italian peninsula, what we now call Switzerland and their foothold in Iberia. Breaking up the Italy was obviously Hannibal's mission and not particularly conquest. The Romans were the technical underdog true but not in manpower. Brainpower, maybe. They never produced a warlord with the guile that could rival Hannibal. Something The Romans were very astute at though, was their unwavering support for their armies. Until recently, I always wondered why Hannibal was always severely lacking for reinforcements. I never knew about the factionalism going on in Carthage. I enjoy learning about history from a military perspective but admittedly, I'm more so into personalities. Hope your legs feel better.
@bastiat Rome was a city state in the Italian Peninsula that eventually imposed a system of vassalage on it's immediate neighbors through military intervention and at times, outright conquest. These other city states and polities weren't Romans nor spoke Romantic languages. Sure, a few joined through alliances and became protectorates but the majority were coerced. That's enough to qualify them as imperial and this was what Hannibal was attempting to exploit in Southern Italy. They were an ambitious, aggressive and expansionist federation that just happened to be called a republic. Not that dissimilar from Carthage. The Aztecs were mostly confined in Central Mexico but they still had an empire by any definition.
This has been a legendary series ❤
Great work 👏
Cheers for the support! Very kind of you.
@@HistoryMarchewhen will part 20 come out?
Damn, can't imagine how painful it would be to be forced to fight in battle while having scurvy and other major health problems... fact that they were able to not only push back but also kill the commander on left flank is crazy, they were probably full of adrenaline lol, can't imagine the burnout after the battle...
but so far Hannibal's march through swamps still takes the cake for most suffering lol, that one before battle of lake Trasimene when they had to march for 4 whole day-night in swamps...
Can't imagine how painful it would be to wait months more for the next part in this series either.
I don't know, crossing the Alps was way harder on them, in my opinion.
The commander on the left was fighting on the frontline for some reason
Hannibal is crying 😢 waiting in Italie for this channel to release the next episode 😢😢
Hanibal himself lost an eye too
Yes, FINALLY. More Hannibal!🦅
This is so great series. Many times have hear of the battle of Cannae and about how Hannibal stood against Rome but never knew what happened after, until the Scipio Africanus. This visual representation of the whole epoch is so great!
@bastiat I never said they were victims or something like that. Just two powers fighting who is greater and the outcome, yeah everyone knows Rome.
Part 20.
Please i need some more history crack.
I am addicted.
The small but important victories of the Romans in the other theaters of operations, was what slowly began to put the balance on their part in the war. For Hannibal, it was not useful to be the best general of their times, if the other commanders of their nation weren't at the same level attacking the romans on the Mediterranean islands and in the Iberian peninsula (causing constant unnecessary loss of troops). Although in addition, Hannibal had to fight in the frontline with the difficult situation of dealing with the incompetent desicions of Carthage Senate (the real enemy of the war for him). I hope you upload this series more often, it's the best on the channel.
I don’t know about being the best of his time as Fabius Maximus and Scipio Africanus are/will be there. Heck, there’s also Marcellus.
Please finish this series
Great to see a new vid on this series, does this mean we will be getting more soon?
Possibly. They are debating on how to cover 214.
@@seanmac1793 is it because it's difficult year to compile into a episode?
@@jozzieokes3422 ya most years are 365 days so its hard to shorten to 20 minutes 😃
@@jozzieokes3422 yeah they said if it was going to be a single episode it would most likely be 40 minutes long
@@nicknewell23 indeed mate
This series is the most detailed account of Hannibal Barca. Loved it.
More to come
Nooooo!!! Why is this series not concluded!? What an anti-climax.
Finally , I missed this serie so much
Why you guys don't continue this series to finish it. As you can see everyone is in love with it. Please continue this series.
I just watched Oversimplified, and it reminded me of this. I checked on this to see if there was another part out
We’ve been waiting for this one for too long.. at last!! 🙏🏻
Finally Hannibal 💙🔥
I started watching Hannibal series yesterday from part 1 up to 19. I was so hooked i cant believe that you have to wait a year or so for another episode 😢. This is actually intriguing than watching a movie. Thumbs up to everyone who made this possible i truly appreciate your work.
I have been waiting for this for a long time!Thank you for continuing this series!Amazing work as always!
Please finish the series I am eagerly waiting
I look forward to these Hannibal episodes more than my birthday
Finish this up before I finish the Carthaginians up
Behave yourself buddy
Just found your channel a bit ago, and getting another video continuing the Punic war is just grand.
When I see your videos, then I think I am right now in that battle. This channel is the most beautiful and outstanding channel I have ever seen. I see Hannibal series everyday.
I am waiting for Hannibal next move.
can't wait for the next part
Hannibal is like the guy who carries the group when everyone fails him
I absolutely love these romans episodes! The best I’ve ever seen and learnt so much from them!
This is the single best documentary of its type I have ever seen, the detail and clear way events are depicted is astonishing!
Waiting for part 20 is like waiting on Winds of Winter.
I just can’t wait for part 20. This series is a masterpiece
Thank you fo the thrilling series- long awaited continuation. Hope next chapters will not be much delayed.
Man you gotta make part 20
This playlist was the reason i subscribed you😭
This is the best series on your channel *period*
Thank you so much for updating and continuing to add to this story ! I’ve waited so long for this and really appreciate your work !
Hannibal was arguably the greatest commander of all time, fighting in alien territory against heavy odds. And always winning for 16 years .... until Zama in 203 BC
finally Hannibal wars!!!
dont interrupt this series! keep it going!
The second punic war series is my favourite series of this channel, it's awesome, please continue to update it!
I'm so excited to see you all continuing the Hannibal series. It's my favorite one on the channel!
I love how you tell this history. It almost makes you think Hannibal can win this time. So great.
Man this series is so good. This video was some of your best work because the quality was there without any collaborations. Thank you for listening to calls to continue this series. It must be rough given how length of this first proto-WW. You operate on Blazetime
Yeah, I used to work solo on all my videos. In more recent times I've hired a small team to increase the number of videos per month. I'm mostly busy managing the team, hence the numerous delays with Hannibal.
@@HistoryMarche Man, so you are like Hannibal, without many resources but managing to produce extraordinary content. No other channel has brought so much detail about the second Punic War and Hannibal as yours. You should have a whole team at your disposal to make more videos. Hopefully the senate will give you more resources, unlike Hannibal.
If I knew there were no end to this series, I would never started seeing it. So, to your loyal followers, please put the rest online. Thanks.
This is better than any movie, any series.. and you know that the next season is coming. Hopefully soon plz @historymarche
Please finish the series! By far the best coverage of the second Punic war I've come across.
Wow, perfect timing. I just finished watching all the rest yesterday.
great video as always HistoryMarche! love the content!
So glad you brought back this Series! Thank you!!
I just found this series and thank you for explaining Hannibal's entire military career against Rome. This is by far the best representation of events I have ever found on this site.
Please concentrate your forces to Hannibal’s frontline and make part 20
don’t leave Hannibal stranded like them Carthaginians :/
This is an excellent narrative. The Punic Wars were a subject of interest to me, but the only book I had read on the subject was Harold Lamb's "Hannibal". I did not know that there were so many other operations taking place outside of Italy and Spain, such as the Sardinian revolt you covered. I will follow your lectures on this topic.
Been waiting for this story to pick back up! Beyond excellent series!🙌🏼
Yes, yes yes! I am so happy this series has continued! Thank you for another great video!
18:37
Imagine if we added one zero to those numbers .How history could have been changed
This is one of the best history series on any topic I have ever seen. It's not long enough. It needs to keep going!
Working on part 20
@@HistoryMarche YES!! You made my day! Thank you!
Woooo
@@HistoryMarche Letsgo!!! Love it!
What happened
Please don’t wait another year for the next part!
I'll do my best! Part 20 will likely be 35-40min video. Thanks so much for the support. Very kind of you.
@@HistoryMarche 🙏 thank you legend!
The very much anticipated episode is finally here
Good work Historymarche!!
Great video HM! well worth the wait!
Glad you enjoyed it! Thanks for joining the live premiere!
Desparately waiting for part 20. 😪
The logistics of this war are mind blowing. Fighting on so many fronts, yet food and manpower are sent. CRAZY
Love HistoryMarch, so happy i found this channel and i keep watch. Also, thanks for being impartial unlike most people right now.
This is my favorite series on youtube. I've been waiting on a new episode for almost a year 🤧
So glad this series is back!
Brilliant serie I love it since it started in pandemic! Go on please with next episodes. Thank you!!!
Im so happy this came out! Thanks for all your work!
This series on the 2nd Punic War is going to be become a mainstay on the history of the war for future generations.
Thank you for the support. Very kind of you!
is this the first Hannibal video you've done in ages?
We need this
The series is going on for 5 yrs 😂
Found the channel because of this particular series almost a year ago. I have been waiting for continuation since I binged all the previous episodes. At last! I hope we don't have to wait a year for the next part.
Yes, please do continue this superiorly series on Hannibal, you can’t just leave us on an amazing cliff hanger like that! Please continue the series, they’re always so well narrated and visually stunning!
Finally ! Part 19, waited so long for this.
Please carry on with this series
This is the only channel I have the bell button on you didn't even need to ask. Your videos are top quality, I have been waiting so long for this episode and it was worth the wait thank you
Awesome, absolutely awesome!!!! Waited so long for this and it hasn't disappointed. Cannot wait for part 20, hopefully soon!!!
Each epsiode i am surprised how did Romans manage to survive this war, its rly increadible.
And the animations are lovley, this storm was very nice, and the reading and the history itself conducted this way - i just could kept listening to it for ages!
Cant wait for another episode amd the Battle of Zama.
I, like others, has waited so long for this. Your channel is the best as having the most detailed videos on Hannibal. I hope you guys will continue this until the end. Looking forward to the part of triumphs and sinking into oblivion of the great Scipio Africanus also 🥳🥳🥳
Thank you very much for the support. Very kind of you
You (HistoryMarch) are amazing, your videos are excellents, in addition, I'm so happy for Hannibal's campaign, he was the greatest general. Thankyou to all researchers.
I had almost given up hope that you'll continue this series. Thank you so much for this !! and I hope you'll finish the second punic war. Much love 🙆♂️❤
Yes!!!! Hot damn I've been waiting for this video. Your Hannibal videos are 1st class. Bravo history marche! Still amazes me that rome's enemies didn't realize they are the weakest right now. Greeks could've jumped at any chance, imagine if all romes enemies could've rallied together at this point!
This series is worth watching over and over. Please please please, you have to finish it 🙏
Amazing. More Hannibal in the near future please. This is the most important series in your channel
Hannibal is crying 😢 waiting in Italie for this channel to release the next episode 😢😢
😂😂😂
i have been waiting tirelessly for another hannibal episode, now i can enjoy this.
Me too!
The most epic of campaigns.
Just started watching these series yesterday, I am already here, thank you
Have been waiting for this for a while. Thank you so much for bringing this out!