That bike frame looked absolutely spot on Andy ! Very, very impressive, indeed...👌 I'm just so pleased that the efforts you put into removing the stubborn seat post paid off and I am looking forward to the next instalment of this bike's restoration.
While I love your restorations, would it be reasonable to conclude that the time and money you spent to remove the seat post and repair this frame is way beyond what it's worth? As a proof of concept I see the value but the cost of repairing the damage caused by removing the seat post seems unviable unless it has some heritage.
Yes completely agree, and yes these points are definitely valid. For me personally it’s a little different having the channel and creating content. Thanks for watching and your support.
Big thanks for such a helpful video, Andy! Your explanation of how to remove a seized seat post using caustic soda was incredibly clear and easy to follow, even for someone like me who isn't the most mechanically inclined. I especially appreciated you detailing the time and effort that it took. Your videos are very helpful. You saved me a lot of time and frustration, and I'm sure your video will help many others too. Keep up the great work! Regards Graham
A good idea that would make for easy work as long as you could isolate all of the fluid in the seat tube. What I could not overcome was how to stop all leaking into adjacent tubes and out of the frame itself. I used uninflated balloons stretched over either side of the BB shell which worked really well. It ran through the holes for the BB cable guide which I successfully plugged with chopsticks. Great. But then it found its way out the chain stays at the dropouts and out the headset, out the stem. Everything is open inside the frame to some degree. Then I flipped the frame, plugged the top of the seat tube and tried filling through the BB shell. Ultimately the same problem. It ended up getting so messy (and dangerous) that I had to stop. If it was just a matter of plugging the BB shell and fill the seat tube it would be a certain fix for all bikes. But you must have a bike with isolated tubing?
Great video Andy! can you give us some insight about the welding? isn´t it a crucial spot, which is constantly under tension due to the seatpost clamping therefore making it very prone to cracking again in the welded spot?
FULL EYE PROTECTION is paramount when using Caustic Soda; I cannot stress this enough. I worked for 46 years in the industrial chemical trade, and knew of two colleagues whose careers were ended by Caustic eye injuries. Please be very, very careful if using this method.
Brilliant mate! I had to leave a fantastic Peugeot 653 frame in England when I emigrated and left the disassembly too late. Yes, the aluminium seat post was welded into the frame and I’d already sold all my tools. I couldn’t get the frame with post attached into the shipping crate and the movers were waiting.
On the safety front I would just add that a full face visor would be better than safety glasses. NaOH will severely burn skin. I've used it to remove anodizing, but I use water at 50C before adding the NaOH slowly - also a 30% solution. I weigh out 300g of Solids to add to 700ml of water then once dissolved top up to 1 litre with cold water. Works much more quickly when hot. Good job and very clearly explained.
I've had same issue on my bike. Unfortunately it's an Aluminium frame and it was a carbon seatpost that was stucked. NaOH couldn't be used. Obviously. I've filed it away with hours of sandpapering. Worked Well but so hardly.
I'm exactly here, I have a lot more post out... At the cost of putting a screwdriver through the frame. Hopefully will weld up ok. I'm definitely going to have to try this or gallium
I'll add this, if I was going to do this again, aluminium post in steel frame, I would buy a long 26mm twist drill and drill the "meat" out of it. I'm confident it would stay fairly centered in the tube
Bob Jackson is no longer in business so that frame is worth a bit of extra tlc in my opinion. A few minutes of preventive work would have prevented the seat post from getting stuck in the first place. I've used caustic soda in the past and yes it's effective but it is volatile and gets very hot! Very informative video. Cheers.
Fantastic.Great to see that the caustic soda worked,definitely will use it in the future should I have the same problem.The Bob Jackson is a stunning frame,looking forward to the build
That bike frame looked absolutely spot on Andy ! Very, very impressive, indeed...👌
I'm just so pleased that the efforts you put into removing the stubborn seat post paid off and I am looking forward to the next instalment of this bike's restoration.
Glad you enjoyed it, yes it’s definitely getting brought back to life. Build coming up soon. 👍 Thanks buddy
Glad you taken the comments onboard and saved a great frame
Redemption Andy! As a Bob Jackson owner I was sad to see the frame in that state. Thanks for giving it another go. That paint scheme is classy!
Yes it should make a classic build. Watch this space 👍
Amazing paint Job 👍, very nice frameset❤, much fun with it!
Thank you! Glad you like it
While I love your restorations, would it be reasonable to conclude that the time and money you spent to remove the seat post and repair this frame is way beyond what it's worth? As a proof of concept I see the value but the cost of repairing the damage caused by removing the seat post seems unviable unless it has some heritage.
Yes completely agree, and yes these points are definitely valid. For me personally it’s a little different having the channel and creating content. Thanks for watching and your support.
Great video!
Beautiful paint on the frame.
Definitely looking forward to the build.
Thanks glad you liked it. Thanks for your feedback it’s appreciated
Big thanks for such a helpful video, Andy!
Your explanation of how to remove a seized seat post using caustic soda was incredibly clear and easy to follow, even for someone like me who isn't the most mechanically inclined. I especially appreciated you detailing the time and effort that it took. Your videos are very helpful. You saved me a lot of time and frustration, and I'm sure your video will help many others too. Keep up the great work!
Regards
Graham
Glad it helped! Thanks for your support and watching. Your support is appreciated 👍
A good idea that would make for easy work as long as you could isolate all of the fluid in the seat tube. What I could not overcome was how to stop all leaking into adjacent tubes and out of the frame itself. I used uninflated balloons stretched over either side of the BB shell which worked really well. It ran through the holes for the BB cable guide which I successfully plugged with chopsticks. Great. But then it found its way out the chain stays at the dropouts and out the headset, out the stem. Everything is open inside the frame to some degree. Then I flipped the frame, plugged the top of the seat tube and tried filling through the BB shell. Ultimately the same problem. It ended up getting so messy (and dangerous) that I had to stop. If it was just a matter of plugging the BB shell and fill the seat tube it would be a certain fix for all bikes. But you must have a bike with isolated tubing?
Great video Andy! can you give us some insight about the welding? isn´t it a crucial spot, which is constantly under tension due to the seatpost clamping therefore making it very prone to cracking again in the welded spot?
Stunning work considering no decals. Glad you included that part, was a nice bonus to the removal of the seat post.
Thanks buddy, yes it should make a nice build. Watch this space 👍
Bob Jackson classic well done and interesting way to save a frame we’ve all had the stuck quills and seat post
Thanks for your support and watching. Happy Cycling
Great video, crack on science man..
Thanks buddy thanks for the support
FULL EYE PROTECTION is paramount when using Caustic Soda; I cannot stress this enough. I worked for 46 years in the industrial chemical trade, and knew of two colleagues whose careers were ended by Caustic eye injuries. Please be very, very careful if using this method.
Thanks for sharing your personal experience and knowledge it's much appreciated
Bob Jackson bike frame is heavy , but so strong 😊. Will come long lasting 😘
Definitely out live us 😂👍 thanks for your support
@BikeItUK so joyfully😊! my elder brother had a Bob Jackson road bike with shimano groupset😎
Brilliant mate! I had to leave a fantastic Peugeot 653 frame in England when I emigrated and left the disassembly too late. Yes, the aluminium seat post was welded into the frame and I’d already sold all my tools. I couldn’t get the frame with post attached into the shipping crate and the movers were waiting.
Oh dear, shame. Thanks for sharing and watching it’s much appreciated
Thanks for the knowledge. I've been working with my aluminum seat post on my 1981 Schwinn Sidewinder. I'm going to try this. Have a great weekend Mate
Good luck! Glad it helped
On the safety front I would just add that a full face visor would be better than safety glasses. NaOH will severely burn skin. I've used it to remove anodizing, but I use water at 50C before adding the NaOH slowly - also a 30% solution. I weigh out 300g of Solids to add to 700ml of water then once dissolved top up to 1 litre with cold water. Works much more quickly when hot. Good job and very clearly explained.
Thanks for watching and sharing your experience and knowledge it’s much appreciated
Thank you very much sir!! I have one project stalled becouse of a stuck seatpost. I will try this method. Best regards
Hope it helps thanks for watching
I've had same issue on my bike. Unfortunately it's an Aluminium frame and it was a carbon seatpost that was stucked. NaOH couldn't be used. Obviously. I've filed it away with hours of sandpapering. Worked Well but so hardly.
Oh wow, never had that combination eek. All the fun hay. Glad you sorted it, thanks for your support and happy cycling buddy
Where there is a will, there is a way. Brilliant and beautiful. Congrats.
Much appreciated thanks for tuning in glad you liked it
wished I knew this 20yrs ago before the hammer split my thumb!
Thanks for watching hope the video was helpful
A last resort solution and a great reminder to use anti-sieze / grease with seat post and stem installations.
Definitely thanks for watching happy cycling
I'm exactly here, I have a lot more post out... At the cost of putting a screwdriver through the frame. Hopefully will weld up ok. I'm definitely going to have to try this or gallium
I'll add this, if I was going to do this again, aluminium post in steel frame, I would buy a long 26mm twist drill and drill the "meat" out of it. I'm confident it would stay fairly centered in the tube
Thanks for watching and your advice much appreciated
Mark to the rescue! Beautiful work as always.
Many thanks! Glad you like it
Well done! The frame has been transformed .
It certainly has, thanks for watching and your support
Was it an alumnium seatpost?
Yes
Fantastic to watch👍
Thank you! Glad you liked it
Bob Jackson is no longer in business so that frame is worth a bit of extra tlc in my opinion. A few minutes of preventive work would have prevented the seat post from getting stuck in the first place. I've used caustic soda in the past and yes it's effective but it is volatile and gets very hot! Very informative video. Cheers.
Thanks for sharing your knowledge, watching and your support it's much appreciated
Fantastic.Great to see that the caustic soda worked,definitely will use it in the future should I have the same problem.The Bob Jackson is a stunning frame,looking forward to the build
Glad you like it thanks for watching and your support it’s much appreciated. Happy Cycling buddy
Could you use this to remove a steel seatpost fromman aluminium frame?
If you only want to save the seatpost ! 😅
If it was the seat post you was after saving, and not the frame.
Looks really good now
Glad you like it 👍