Ningning's control and lows are impeccable✨. Her ease within her range makes her sound soooo effortless. When it comes to chest voice and mid belts Karina and Ningning wins me with their tone and approach
Ningning and Karina's voice win me over with this song. I'm loving their performances recently and I think they're my favorite voices from aespa at the moment. Even though Giselle's lines were short, I'm seriously in love with her tone. I really need to hear more singing line from her in the future, especially ones in the E4 - G#4 range cuz she sounds greatttttt. And Winter AGAINNN showing us her extensive and flexible mix. She gets a bit piercing the higher she goes but this is a great showcase of her strong control and range.
Karina is truly an ACE. She can go from singing to rapping to slay the dance break in less than a second. I would love to see her singing above C5/C#5 cause she has so much ease👌
My favorite parts here are basically Ningning's parts, all her parts sounded like ease 😫❤✨ also Karina's cause I like her vocal tone so much ✨ I wish they would make karina go up to D5 - Eb5/E5 but not higher than that huhu, I'm actually scared and also not wanting to think like this but I'm really obsessed with her voice 😫💔✨
I watched that Re-Masterpiece video and was surprised that Ningning actually sings stronger and with more attitude than I’ve ever heard her sing. Her voice is not as smooth and sugary as what I usually hear in the finalised versions of Aespa songs. So now I think maybe a lot of the nuances in her live vocal were just “washed away” by sound effects in production. It smooths out her voice a bit too much. What a shame. It suits this particular song, but not Savage and most other Aespa songs. Hope we get to hear more of Ningning’s live singing in the future. She is a quite interesting and versatile singer. p.s. BoA also sounded really strong and raspy in that video I watched. I’ve been listening to her for years and years and didn’t know she could sound like that. SM vocal effects really need to chill down a bit😂
The fact that Giselle & Karina would be Main Vocalists if placed in almost any other 4th gen group is equally parts exciting as it is disappointing 😭😭😭
I arrived late I know but it's because I was very busy and I didn't even have free time, now that I have I came to watch this video. I loved Aespa's version of Dreams Come True, like it's really good and I'm particularly addicted to the alien/robot rapping haha. I was in love with Karina's vocals on Savage and now I'm in love with her A4's on Dreams Come True and I don't even talk about how much I think her vibrato is very beautiful and natural. It sure stood out a lot in this song.
@@andinho2204 I just notice, if you like the singer, you tends to defend them when people say they are too nasal or piercing. But if you dont like the singer, you keep on looking for the flaws and forgetting the good notes they do. Just saying.
@@camille4277 No, that's not true, i defend the singer when the singer is good and when they're being criticized for something as stupid as sounding too high when singing a note that's literally really high lmao.
Amazing how far Ningning has come from her early training videos. Talent is one thing, but you have to work at it hard to get this good (unless your name is Christina Aguilera...)
a karina e a 2ning são definitivamente minhas vocalistas favoritas do aespa e da 4° geração no geral. costumava ser a winter, mas quanto mais eu ouço a voz dela nas músicas, mais eu me canso, ela tem um tom muito estridente, ainda mais nos upper belts.
@@somalighosh461 Where are yall getting that information from? She's literally known for having a well placed round approach up to B4 and can even sound good up to D5 (placement wise). You just don't like her tone, she's not nasal
@@andinho2204 sorry if im mistaken but isnt her tone nasal? What i meant to say was she didnt sound nasal in black mamba but im sorry if im spreading misinformation I'll delete the comment
I've been thinking, i'm pretty sure although NingNing is the best vocalist they see Winter as the main vocal ( Ik they don't have positions, but in the line distribution they have to decide someone to get the high notes, and it's mostly winter, soo... )
Do you think that you will be able to do a analysis on different companies vocal training based off of idols video? I know that SM has the best vocalist, but where exactly are they strong at/ what does the company focus on… idk if I’m saying this right😅
There's no such thing as that id say, take those sm vocalists as exemples: Wendy: heady, masked placement, agile, good vibrato Seulgi: very nasal, chesty, decent agility, bad vibrato Sunny: nasal, heady, weak agility, bad vibrato Tiffany: chesty, throaty, decent agility, ok vibrato They don't have something in common between every single one of them, the same goes for vocalists at other companies
@@francescasolarino6843 Idk if that's actually a thing tbh, id say only Yerin baek and some sub vocalists use it, you don't see any of it in Jihyo, Jeongyeon, Yeji, Jimin and not even in Nayeon
I've been waiting for this! 💕 Thanks! Anyways, I have a question. I saw someone said that Purple Kiss' main vocalist is better than NingNing? Is that true? Can anyone confirm? Thanks!
Personally for me, I wouldn’t say Giselle has improved but rather finally showcase us more as to what she is capable of due to the limited material on her. She’s shown to support G4, and have shallow support toward A4’s. (Anyone please correct me if I’m wrong)
@@davidakbar4876 others have proven that she can produce shallow support of a4 in the dreams come true live recording, they have also said her approach to bb4 while it’s mostly likely relaxed and not supported is pretty decent.
@@davidakbar4876 she may strain there but its prolly well done, also, she has supported Bb4s in a fansign and the around the end of Yeppi Yeppi credits to @lemon zetter for the info
Yes Giselle is better than lia as Giselle’s quality of support despite it being shallow is better and lia’s approach lately has been inconsistent and very stylistic
Dana...that's a name I haven't heard in a while. Err they're not far from each other, with Dana's regression, not yet but I wouldn't be surprised because NN actually sounds much better live support wise and without studio affects. We still don't have the complete picture on Aespa.
1. Ningning (High Average to Above Average or Low Above Average) 2. Winter (Mid Average) 3. Karina (Low Average or High Weak to Average) 4. Giselle/Lia (Mid to High Weak) < Giselle is slightly better but the gap isn’t too big 5. The rest of Itzy (Undeveloped) Basically only Lia has a sense of support in Itzy and carries the group vocally but she just competes with Giselle due to her inconsistent approach Anybody please correct me but I believe this is the general ranking
@Arabic Treasure Nope, she have always been weak. Lia never really show strong moments of support,only in some like her price tags covers and the one in knowing bros(i forgot the title). She shows okay support in those perf but then suddenly in others perf she was just being fairly relaxed. Basically her sense of support is very inconsistent.
@@andinho2204 I disgaree. Sorry to say that. Winter really sound so piercing and nasally. She's actually becoming Eunha and Nayeon. Jihyo has really good technique considering the type of voice she has. And JYP, ruining her voice. Maybe Ningning is better than high notes, because of her natural high pitched voice, but still sound strain and pierced. Jihyo's high notes are chef kiss until JyP started ruining it. So I think, Jihyo is a lil better than these two. You better watch the MR removed of Aespa. They are overrated vocally. Wait for the JYPn new girl group, Lily is way way better than them.
@@ayeon5609 No, I'm just stating my insights. As a Filipino, Ningning and Winter's voice are just... Can't say it, you might be offended. But Jihyo's voice, too powerful and whole. But I'm not saying that she is a great great singer. I'm just saying that she's better than Winter and Ningning. The only ones who are way way better than Jihyo in 3rd gen kpop are Wendy, SolaR and Wendy. I'M not saying that Winter and Ningning are bad singers. What I'm saying is, they're slowly becoming Nayeon and Eunha. Singing a lot og high notes, result is, sounds very strained and pierced even auto tune included. When they sang in encore and heard the MR removed, really surprised how they become so overrated vocally.
@@camille4277 Yes, you are biased. Do you even know what the meaning of biased is ? Maybe google it, you think Jihyo is a better singer because her voice is your type, and Winter/Ningning are bad singer because you don't like their voice. Its very very very simple to understand. You Are Biased.
oi andinho! será que você poderia fazer algum vídeo curto de análise da giselle? eu sei que o foco dela não é o vocal, por isso existem poucos materiais de análise, mas eu particularmente acho o timbre dela muito bonito e, ainda que leiga, sinto que ela tem um potencial interessante com mais tempo e treinos, porém não acho um único vídeo que fale nem superficialmente sobre :/ ela tem alguns vídeos curtos pelo youtube cantando, tem os stages de forever, vídeo pre debut...talvez tenha como formular alguma coisa sobre 🤔 (caso seja cedo demais vou ficar na espera de um vídeo seu🙏🏻)
@@andinho2204 ah que bom!! eu aguento esperar. na verdade não sei muito bem o que perguntar, mas...onde vc encaixaria ela no ranking vocal (A, B, C, D...) com o que viu da giselle até agora? E qual aparentemente seria a classificação vocal dela?
@@andinho2204 parece bem bom pra uma main rapper! ela seria soprano, mezzo ou contralto? vejo pelo youtube afirmarem que ela é contralto mas não sei se é verídico
@@mariana-tn3qi soprano, eles confundem o fato dela pegar as partes de uma alto quando ela cantava em coros (n sei onde direito) com ela ser uma contralto. Alto é aquela q canta as partes mais graves em um coro, contralto é um tipo vocal.
![[STATION] aespa 에스파 'Dreams Come True' MV](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/H69tJmsgd9I/mqdefault.jpg)
![[STATION] aespa 에스파 'Dreams Come True' MV](/img/tr.png)
Ningning's control and lows are impeccable✨. Her ease within her range makes her sound soooo effortless. When it comes to chest voice and mid belts Karina and Ningning wins me with their tone and approach
Ningning and Karina's voice win me over with this song. I'm loving their performances recently and I think they're my favorite voices from aespa at the moment.
Even though Giselle's lines were short, I'm seriously in love with her tone. I really need to hear more singing line from her in the future, especially ones in the E4 - G#4 range cuz she sounds greatttttt.
And Winter AGAINNN showing us her extensive and flexible mix. She gets a bit piercing the higher she goes but this is a great showcase of her strong control and range.
Karina is truly an ACE. She can go from singing to rapping to slay the dance break in less than a second. I would love to see her singing above C5/C#5 cause she has so much ease👌
My favorite parts here are basically Ningning's parts, all her parts sounded like ease 😫❤✨
also Karina's cause I like her vocal tone so much ✨
I wish they would make karina go up to D5 - Eb5/E5 but not higher than that huhu, I'm actually scared and also not wanting to think like this but I'm really obsessed with her voice 😫💔✨
i would like to hear an F5 from her, I'm actually obsessed with F5's so..
karina’s voice is so beautiful, i love her voice. i want to see her do mid belts
your editing skills are top notch, I really enjoy your videos...keep the good work ^^
Thank u^^
Karina’s bridge😩
Her + Giselle are always the best bridge combo
Honestly I’m not really shock if one day NingNing belt an 6 or even 7 octaves note. Considering the fact her range from s already this wide
I watched that Re-Masterpiece video and was surprised that Ningning actually sings stronger and with more attitude than I’ve ever heard her sing. Her voice is not as smooth and sugary as what I usually hear in the finalised versions of Aespa songs.
So now I think maybe a lot of the nuances in her live vocal were just “washed away” by sound effects in production. It smooths out her voice a bit too much. What a shame. It suits this particular song, but not Savage and most other Aespa songs.
Hope we get to hear more of Ningning’s live singing in the future. She is a quite interesting and versatile singer.
p.s. BoA also sounded really strong and raspy in that video I watched. I’ve been listening to her for years and years and didn’t know she could sound like that. SM vocal effects really need to chill down a bit😂
The fact that Giselle & Karina would be Main Vocalists if placed in almost any other 4th gen group is equally parts exciting as it is disappointing 😭😭😭
It's kinda sad tbh
fr, but this also shows how low the standards are 😭.
Even in nct dream which is from SM too 🥲
More exciting - it's great to see a group of strong vocalists, like Mamamoo does...
lol I know about 11 4th gen vocalists who are average and higher this gen isn't THAT bad
I arrived late I know but it's because I was very busy and I didn't even have free time, now that I have I came to watch this video. I loved Aespa's version of Dreams Come True, like it's really good and I'm particularly addicted to the alien/robot rapping haha. I was in love with Karina's vocals on Savage and now I'm in love with her A4's on Dreams Come True and I don't even talk about how much I think her vibrato is very beautiful and natural. It sure stood out a lot in this song.
i totally obsessed with this song , def my fav along with black mamba
Giselle and Karina sounds very promising. If only they have more materials 😩
P.S:
Karina + Giselle Bridge >>>
They are the best bridge duoo. Both of them seem to support the same range (Bb3/B3-G#4/A4), but with a clear difference in quality
Absolutely in love with Ningning as usual
ningning's d3🛐🛐
I really don't understand SM trying to cram Winter into the high notes, even though she's talented, her high notes still sound shrill sometimes.
I think its producers preferrence. Even though I agree Win's voice is piercing, her vocals are the most identifiable out of all members.
Ningning's d5 seems promising
there's a reason why Ningning is their Main Vocalist
Wanted to hear Karina's voice more ever since savage I really love her tone
her bridge part 💕
D3? Pheww Ningning
2:25 Winter's E5 sounds piercing but somehow it fits the song tho so I'm not gonna complain 😌💁
Would you say ningning’s c5’s are consistently supported here other than what we got from the live recording
Yes, B4/C5 atleast
Still the same except for Giselle that now showed consistency with G#4/A4
karina's tone is just >>>>>>>
Ningning Chestier C5 🤤🤤🤤
love your vids, hoping for more contents💚
I'll try to post more often
Winter's high note at 2:36 sounds really piercing
Those notes are really high
@@andinho2204 I just notice, if you like the singer, you tends to defend them when people say they are too nasal or piercing. But if you dont like the singer, you keep on looking for the flaws and forgetting the good notes they do. Just saying.
@@camille4277 No, that's not true, i defend the singer when the singer is good and when they're being criticized for something as stupid as sounding too high when singing a note that's literally really high lmao.
@@camille4277 You should stop trying to shit on Winter's vocals under every comment, makes your hate agaianst her really obvious.
@@camille4277 you are right haha
I noticed that too.
I would like to know how to edit like u, good job andinho!
Thank you bestie
@@andinho2204 u're welcome!
I think NingNing only problem now is her confidence. Considering the fact that she’s always sing so lightly. Also was the D3 and D5 supported?
No, she never supported those notes, she supports G3-C5 with consistency and F#3-C#5 at her best
@@andinho2204 off topic but Monday is still better than her right?
@@haseulstolejamescharlsesfo9009 Possibly, but from what i heard, she's weaker cuz her support quality in the Bb4-C5 quality can be inconsistent
@@haseulstolejamescharlsesfo9009 monday is inconsistent with her approach even some of her b4s can be questionable so ningning is better
@@haseulstolejamescharlsesfo9009 Monday never was stronger than Ning Ning really.
Amazing how far Ningning has come from her early training videos. Talent is one thing, but you have to work at it hard to get this good (unless your name is Christina Aguilera...)
Christina isn't a very technical vocalist, I love her but she's a weak to average vocalist.
a karina e a 2ning são definitivamente minhas vocalistas favoritas do aespa e da 4° geração no geral. costumava ser a winter, mas quanto mais eu ouço a voz dela nas músicas, mais eu me canso, ela tem um tom muito estridente, ainda mais nos upper belts.
O timbre dela é agudo dmss
@@andinho2204 acho q as vezes ela força pra fazer os high notes, pq é muito agudo o timbre dela
@@somalighosh461 Where are yall getting that information from? She's literally known for having a well placed round approach up to B4 and can even sound good up to D5 (placement wise). You just don't like her tone, she's not nasal
@@andinho2204 sorry if im mistaken but isnt her tone nasal? What i meant to say was she didnt sound nasal in black mamba but im sorry if im spreading misinformation I'll delete the comment
i like winters voice but sometimes when she sings high notes it’s a bit piercing 😅.
I've been thinking, i'm pretty sure although NingNing is the best vocalist they see Winter as the main vocal ( Ik they don't have positions, but in the line distribution they have to decide someone to get the high notes, and it's mostly winter, soo... )
They do have positions. NingNing is main and Winter, lead
@@camilamartel5913 they said themselfs they don't have positions
Take Nayeon for example she’s not the main vocalist but starting from DTNA era she’s constantly getting high note
@@Dimyixx yup, but they have like 4 comebacks with high notes and in 3 of then winter got'em
@@dmyst1 NingNing have the same amount too. I guess it’s just a tone preference
Omg Karina sounds so good- her bridge part is everything
Frr
Giselle did a fine work
Giselle's G4s are definitely supported
She seems to be able to support up to G#4/A4 id say
@@andinho2204 I know but 2:08 sounds so good
@@camilamartel5913 It doess
Are they the best vocal group in 4th gen?
Yup
@@andinho2204 how about 12DAL lol?
@@wenreneisreal6668 12dal is more of a soloist now
@@andinho2204 is Yuri (ex izone) better than Winter?
@@cucazurrechnung8975 Nop, Winter is better
💕
Great editing skill I see here! Well done!
Also, is Ning Ning's D5 at 02:46 supported?
Thanks you. The one at 2:39 sounds better to me, but even this one is pretty questionable
Do you think that you will be able to do a analysis on different companies vocal training based off of idols video? I know that SM has the best vocalist, but where exactly are they strong at/ what does the company focus on… idk if I’m saying this right😅
There's no such thing as that id say, take those sm vocalists as exemples:
Wendy: heady, masked placement, agile, good vibrato
Seulgi: very nasal, chesty, decent agility, bad vibrato
Sunny: nasal, heady, weak agility, bad vibrato
Tiffany: chesty, throaty, decent agility, ok vibrato
They don't have something in common between every single one of them, the same goes for vocalists at other companies
@@andinho2204 how about Jyp vocalists?
Baek yerin
Jimin
Sunye
Yeeun
Min
Lia.
Jihyo.
Jeongyeon
Nayeon
Lily
Haewon
Jinny
I already said "same goes for vocalists at other companies".
@@andinho2204 some JYPE vocalists use the half air technique though, so maybe that's something in common
@@francescasolarino6843 Idk if that's actually a thing tbh, id say only Yerin baek and some sub vocalists use it, you don't see any of it in Jihyo, Jeongyeon, Yeji, Jimin and not even in Nayeon
What is giselle support range
Bb3/B3 - G#4/A4
G#3/A3-A4 now
Can you do GOT - Step Back???
0:09 wait ningnings the one doing the low part :o ?
Yup
@@andinho2204 DAYUM
i keep coming back to that and GODDAMN.. she's so hot for that
do you think Giselle is better than Mina? or is it still too early to tell
Yeaa giselle is slightly better than mina cuz she had better quality on her support + more consisten than mina and even giselle is better than lia tho
Both of them have shallow support
@@haseulstolejamescharlsesfo9009 Mina barley support, Giselle have much better support although shallow.
Yes, Giselle's support is truly consistent and quite a bit fuller.
@@andinho2204 does Mina support?🤨
I've been waiting for this! 💕 Thanks!
Anyways, I have a question. I saw someone said that Purple Kiss' main vocalist is better than NingNing? Is that true? Can anyone confirm? Thanks!
It's wrong. Goeun, the main vocalist of Purple Kiss, is an average vocalist, but Ning's level is between average and above average.
@@lehuunhatkhoa4820 Thank you!
Even Winter is technically stronger than Goeun
I love PK's song library more, but vocally? Nah, Aespa is the best of this generation easily.
@@lehuunhatkhoa4820 i thought swan is the main vocalist?
Can you do IVE next?
Nop sorry
@@andinho2204 lmao why is this response so funny 😭 also thnx for the video 💕
@@patiencegord1161 You're welcome ❤️
Andinho, oq vc acha dos vocais da Luísa Sonza?
Ela é average, mais ou menos no nível da Jihyo ou da Olívia Rodrigo, ela tem apoio entre G#3-Bb4 se n me engano, mas ela já apoiou F#3 e C5 tbm.
@@andinho2204 obrigadoo
Qual seria teu rank vocal no aespa ??
Ningning>Winter>Karina>Giselle
Eu tava na piscina
Q inveja
@@andinho2204 Inveja nada, eu tava ali com medo dos ralos puxarem meu cabelo
Slsksd
Hello, does Giselle seem to have improved in any way?
Personally for me, I wouldn’t say Giselle has improved but rather finally showcase us more as to what she is capable of due to the limited material on her. She’s shown to support G4, and have shallow support toward A4’s. (Anyone please correct me if I’m wrong)
@@MrJay822 giselle is shallow throughout but she can show support up to Bb4 if I'm not wrong
@@eternal6257 i think giselle is already strain up to A4 only karina a sub vocal that can sup to Bb4
@@davidakbar4876 others have proven that she can produce shallow support of a4 in the dreams come true live recording, they have also said her approach to bb4 while it’s mostly likely relaxed and not supported is pretty decent.
@@davidakbar4876 she may strain there but its prolly well done, also, she has supported Bb4s in a fansign and the around the end of Yeppi Yeppi
credits to @lemon zetter for the info
was winters E5 supported ?
No, anything above c5 is not supported for winter
Her consistency ends at B4, but o think she was able to support one phrased C5
@@andinho2204 can u link me this one
Actually she wasn't able to support any C5
giselle rn might be better than lia or ???
some ppl said lia is still better bcs she has better lows and upper but yea idk
Yes Giselle is better than lia as Giselle’s quality of support despite it being shallow is better and lia’s approach lately has been inconsistent and very stylistic
They're close skill wise, both carry shallow support up A4, but Lia has A3, let's wait for more live materials.
is ningning better now than dana from the grace???
Dana...that's a name I haven't heard in a while. Err they're not far from each other, with Dana's regression, not yet but I wouldn't be surprised because NN actually sounds much better live support wise and without studio affects. We still don't have the complete picture on Aespa.
AESPA UPDATE VOCALS
• Ningning: G3 ~ C5/C♯5 ~ E♭5/E5
• Winter: A3 ~ B♭4/B4
• Karina: G♯3/A3 ~ A4/B♭4
• Giselle: G♯3/A3 ~ A4/B♭4
How would you tier aespa and itzy members?
1. Ningning (High Average to Above Average or Low Above Average)
2. Winter (Mid Average)
3. Karina (Low Average or High Weak to Average)
4. Giselle/Lia (Mid to High Weak) < Giselle is slightly better but the gap isn’t too big
5. The rest of Itzy (Undeveloped)
Basically only Lia has a sense of support in Itzy and carries the group vocally but she just competes with Giselle due to her inconsistent approach
Anybody please correct me but I believe this is the general ranking
1.Ningning A-AA
2. Winter A
3. Karina W-A
4/5. Giselle & Lia W
5. The rest
@Arabic Treasure
Nope, she have always been weak. Lia never really show strong moments of support,only in some like her price tags covers and the one in knowing bros(i forgot the title). She shows okay support in those perf but then suddenly in others perf she was just being fairly relaxed. Basically her sense of support is very inconsistent.
@@andinho2204 isnt Karina Low Average?
Imo she's just a highe weak to average
how was ningning cover with onew?
She did good like she usually does, nothing different to highlight
What is Karina's supported range?
Bb3/B3-G#4/A4, possibly A4/Bb4
@@andinho2204 i thought karina can support A3 ☹☹
She can actually
@@andinho2204 at her best? Or she is more consistent with A3 now?
@@daffapahrezi2430 consistent
How about ningning vocal and Ji Hyo, who's better?
I want to know.
Ningning and Winter are better than Jihyo, Jihyo is close to Winter
@@andinho2204 I disgaree. Sorry to say that. Winter really sound so piercing and nasally. She's actually becoming Eunha and Nayeon. Jihyo has really good technique considering the type of voice she has. And JYP, ruining her voice. Maybe Ningning is better than high notes, because of her natural high pitched voice, but still sound strain and pierced. Jihyo's high notes are chef kiss until JyP started ruining it. So I think, Jihyo is a lil better than these two. You better watch the MR removed of Aespa. They are overrated vocally. Wait for the JYPn new girl group, Lily is way way better than them.
@@camille4277 You sound so biased. But you do you 👍
@@ayeon5609 No, I'm just stating my insights. As a Filipino, Ningning and Winter's voice are just... Can't say it, you might be offended. But Jihyo's voice, too powerful and whole. But I'm not saying that she is a great great singer. I'm just saying that she's better than Winter and Ningning. The only ones who are way way better than Jihyo in 3rd gen kpop are Wendy, SolaR and Wendy. I'M not saying that Winter and Ningning are bad singers. What I'm saying is, they're slowly becoming Nayeon and Eunha. Singing a lot og high notes, result is, sounds very strained and pierced even auto tune included. When they sang in encore and heard the MR removed, really surprised how they become so overrated vocally.
@@camille4277 Yes, you are biased. Do you even know what the meaning of biased is ? Maybe google it, you think Jihyo is a better singer because her voice is your type, and Winter/Ningning are bad singer because you don't like their voice. Its very very very simple to understand. You Are Biased.
oi andinho! será que você poderia fazer algum vídeo curto de análise da giselle? eu sei que o foco dela não é o vocal, por isso existem poucos materiais de análise, mas eu particularmente acho o timbre dela muito bonito e, ainda que leiga, sinto que ela tem um potencial interessante com mais tempo e treinos, porém não acho um único vídeo que fale nem superficialmente sobre :/ ela tem alguns vídeos curtos pelo youtube cantando, tem os stages de forever, vídeo pre debut...talvez tenha como formular alguma coisa sobre 🤔
(caso seja cedo demais vou ficar na espera de um vídeo seu🙏🏻)
Eu pretendo fazer um, após eu terminar os da Seulgi e da Sunny, mas vai levar um tempinho. Eu posso responder suas dúvidas por aqui msm se vc quiser
@@andinho2204 ah que bom!! eu aguento esperar. na verdade não sei muito bem o que perguntar, mas...onde vc encaixaria ela no ranking vocal (A, B, C, D...) com o que viu da giselle até agora? E qual aparentemente seria a classificação vocal dela?
@@mariana-tn3qi D-
@@andinho2204 parece bem bom pra uma main rapper! ela seria soprano, mezzo ou contralto? vejo pelo youtube afirmarem que ela é contralto mas não sei se é verídico
@@mariana-tn3qi soprano, eles confundem o fato dela pegar as partes de uma alto quando ela cantava em coros (n sei onde direito) com ela ser uma contralto. Alto é aquela q canta as partes mais graves em um coro, contralto é um tipo vocal.